Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN
THE
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT INDORE
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE HIRDESH
ON THE 23rd OF JANUARY, 2024
MISC. APPEAL No. 4658 of 2022
BETWEEN:-
Signed by: HARIKUMAR
NAIR
Signing time: 1/24/2024
6:04:47 PM
1.
SMT. HAKKU W/O ANSINGH KATARA, AGED
ABOUT 38 YEARS, OCCUPATION: AGRICULTURIST
R/O VILLAGE BHOYRA TEHSIL JHABUA (MADHYA
PRADESH)
2.
DINESH S/O ANSINGH KATARA, AGED ABOUT 23
YEARS, OCCUPATION: AGRICULTURIST VILLAGE
BHOYRA TEH. JHABUA (MADHYA PRADESH)
3.
MUKESH S/O ANSINGH KATARA, AGED ABOUT 20
YEARS, OCCUPATION: AGRICULTURIST VILLAGE
BHOYRA TEH. JHABUA (MADHYA PRADESH)
4.
SANJAY MINOR THROUGH NATURAL GUARDIAN
MOTHER SMT. HAKU W/O ANSINGH KATARA,
AGED
ABOUT
YEARS, OCCUPATION:
AGRICULTURIST VILLAGE BHOYRA TEH. JHABUA
(MADHYA PRADESH)
5.
KANU MINOR THROUGH NATURAL GUARDIAN
MOTHER SMT. HAKU W/O ANSINGH KATARA,
AGED
ABOUT
YEARS, OCCUPATION:
AGRICULTURIST VILLAGE BHOYRA TEH. JHABUA
(MADHYA PRADESH)
6.
AJAY MINOR THROUGH NATURAL GUARDIAN
MOTHER SMT. HAKU W/O ANSINGH KATARA,
AGED
ABOUT
YEARS, OCCUPATION:
AGRICULTURIST VILALGE BHOYRA TEH. JHABUA
(MADHYA PRADESH)
7.
LEELA MINOR THROUGH NATURAL GUARDIAN
MOTHER SMT. HAKU W/O ANSINGH KATARA,
AGED
ABOUT
YEARS, OCCUPATION:
AGRICULTURIST VILLAGEBHOYRA TEH. JHABUA
(MADHYA PRADESH)
8.
KAMLI MINOR THROUGH NATURAL GUARDIAN
MOTHER SMT. HAKU W/O ANSINGH KATARA,
AGED
ABOUT
YEARS, OCCUPATION:
AGRICULTURIST VILLAGE BHOYRA TEH. JHABUA
(MADHYA PRADESH)
9.
HAMJU S/O RANJEE KATARA, AGED ABOUT 70
YEARS, OCCUPATION: AGRICULTURIST VILLAGE
BHOYRA TEH. JHABUA (MADHYA PRADESH)
10.SMT.HUMA W/O HAMJU KATARA AGE 68
YEARS OCCUPATION AGRICULTURE ADDRESS OF
ALL VILLAGE BHOYRA TEHSIL JHABUA DISTRICT
JHABUA
.....APPELLANTS
(SHRI YASH PAL RATHORE, LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE
APPELLANTS).
AND
1.
GARVAR SINGH S/O MANJLA BILWAL, AGED
ABOUT 30 YEARS, OCCUPATION: DRIVER R/O
VILLAGE GHATTIYA TEHSIL JHABUA (MADHYA
PRADESH)
2.
LOKENDRA S/O SHANTILAL GURJAR, AGED
ABOUT 45 YEARS, OCCUPATION: BUSINESS 16,
CHETANYA MARG JHABUA (MADHYA PRADESH)
3.
THE NEW INDIA INSURANCE CO. LTD. CHETANYA
MARG, JHABUA (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(SHRI VINDHYAVASHINI PRASAD KHARE, LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE
RESPONDENT [R-3].
T h is appeal coming on for orders this day, t h e cou rt passed the
following:
ORDER
This miscellaneous appeal has been preferred by the appellants under
section 173(1) of the Motor Vehicles Act against the award dated 02.07.2022
passed in Claim Case No.57/2020 by MACT, Jhabua whereby application filed
under section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act for compensation has been
allowed and an award of Rs.10,78,000/- has passed in favour of the appellants
Signed by: HARIKUMAR
NAIR
Signing time: 1/24/2024
6:04:47 PM
and directed the driver and owner of the offending vehicle to pay the
compensation while exonerating the respondent No.3/Insurance Company.
2. Brief facts of the case is that on 13.01.2020 deceased Ansingh was
going to his village Bhoyra on his motorcycle no.MP-45-MJ-8997 after
purchasing vegetables from Jhabua. When he reached near culvert situated
between village Naldi and Bhoyra he was dashed by vehicle no.MP 41 P 0467
coming from the direction of Pitol and was driven by non applicant no.1 rashly
and negligently. Ansingh sustained grievous injuries and he was taken to district
hospital Jhabua from where he was carried to Dahod after primary treatment. In
Dahod he was first taken to Saifi hospital but for better treatment he was taken
to Avdhut hospital Baroda. During treatment he succumbed to injuries and
expired on 14.01.2020.
3.
Claimants filed this claim petition for compensation against the
respondents for a sum of Rs.55 lakhs 86 thousnad with interest.
4. Respondents No.1 & 2 were ex-parte before the Tribunal and did not
file written statement.
5. On the other hand, respondent No.3 filed written statement and denied
all the averments pleaded in the pleadings and submitted that owner and driver
of the offending vehicle breached terms and conditions of the insurance policy
and vehicle was driven without permit in contravention of the insurance policy
so insurance company is not liable to pay compensation.
6. The Tribunal framed issues and taking evidence passed the impugned
award in favour of the claimants and exonerated the insurance company
because owner and driver drove the vehicle without permit.
7. Being aggrieved by the inadequate compensation, present appeal has
been preferred by the appellant and submitted that quantum of compensation
Signed by: HARIKUMAR
NAIR
Signing time: 1/24/2024
6:04:47 PM
awarded by the Tribunal is on the lower side, hence deserves enhancement.
8.
Learned counsel for the appellants submitted that Tribunal has
committed error in exonerating insurance company on the ground that offending
vehicle was not having valid permit. It is submitted that the aforesaid finding
recorded by the Tribunal is contrary to the decision rendered by the Apex
Court in the case of National Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. Challa Bharathamma
and others reported in AIR 2004 SC 4882 wherein the apex Court has held
that in a case where the vehicle is plied without valid permit, the insurance
company can be exonerated.
However, the principal liability to pay the
compensation shall be of the insurance company which can be recovered by the
same from the owner and driver of the vehicle. Thus, it is submitted that
aforesaid finding be set aside.
9. On the other hand, counsel for the insurance company submitted that
Tribunal has rightly exonerated the insurance company and prayed for rejection
of the appeal.
10. Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record of the
Tribunal.
11. Learned counsel for the respondents has filed a citation in the case
o f Shravankumar and others vs. Deepakkumar & others
in MA
No.1097/2008 decided on 11.04.2023 passed by coordinate bench of this
Court in which it was held that when insurance company has proved that driver
of the offending vehicle has no driving license, Tribunal has rightly exonerated
the insurance company from the liability to pay compensation. He has further
cited Beli Ram vs. Rajinder Kumar and another - AIR 2020 SC 4453 and
Ram Sujan Tiwar vs. Sita Gupta and others - 2009 ACJ 437 of this Court
Signed by: HARIKUMAR
NAIR
Signing time: 1/24/2024
6:04:47 PM
and submitted that Tribunal has rightly exonerated insurance company
considering the submissions made by both the parties.
12. In the case of Challa Bharathamma (supra) the apex Court has held
that in the case where vehicle is plied without permit the insurance company can
be exonerated but principal liability to pay compensation shall be on the
insurance company, which can be recovered by the same from the owner and
driver of the vehicle. In the case of Gudiya and ors. vs. Govind Sharma and
ors. - 2020 ACJ 1569 this court has held that the insurance company is liable
to satisfy the award and thereafter seek recovery from the owner of the vehicle
if the offending vehicle was not having permit and fitness certificate on the date
of accident.
13. From the perusal of the record it cannot be said that there was any
error on the part of the claims tribunal in exonerating the insurance company
because offending vehicle was being driven without permit but this Court finds
that Tribunal has not applied ratio of the decision rendered in the case of Challa
Bharathamma (supra) to hold that even if the vehicle was not having any valid
permit the primary liability to pay compensation is on the insurance company
which can be recovered from the owner and driver of the vehicle.
14. In such circumstances it is directed that findings recorded by the
Claims Tribunal that insurance company is exonerated and is not liable to pay
compensation is modified to the extent that insurance company is liable to pay
the compensation but it shall be at liberty to recover the same from the owner
and driver of the offending vehicle.
15. So far as the compensation is concerned, on due consideration this
court finds that so far as enhancement of the award is concerned tribunal has
clearly erred
Signed by: HARIKUMAR
NAIR
Signing time: 1/24/2024
6:04:47 PM
to hold income of the deceased as Rs.6000/- per month.
According to the guidelines of the Labour Department the minimum wages of
an unskilled labour at the time of the accident was Rs.7950/- per month.
Therefore, the monthly income of the deceased in this case is fixed at Rs.7950/per month.
16. Learned counsel for the appellant submitted that tribunal has not
given consortium in this case as per the verdict in the case of United India
Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. Satinder kaur @ Satwuinder Kaur and others (2021) 11 Supreme Court Cases 780.
On the other hand, counsel for the
insurance company has submitted that only Rs.40,000/- should be given under
the head of consortium as per the verdict of the Supreme Court in the case of
Shriram General Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. Bhagat Singh Rawat and others
- 2023 ACJ 2330.
17. After hearing both counsel for the parties, in the considered opinion
of this court, appellants are entitled to get compensation under the head of
consortium in all heads i.e. spousal consortium, parental consortium and filial
consortium. Appellant No.1 is wife of the deceased, appellants No.2 to 8 are
his children and appellants No.9 & 10 are his parents, so each appellant is
entitled to get consortium @ Rs.44,000/-.
18. In view of the foregoing discussion, the compensation awarded by
the Tribunal is modified as under:
HEAD
AMOUNT
Loss of dependency
-Rs.13,35,600/-
(i.e. Rs.7950 x 12=95400 +25% FP i.e. Rs.23,850=119250 - 1/5 personal
expenses=95400 x 14 (multiplier)=13,35,600/-)
Loss of estate
Signed by: HARIKUMAR
NAIR
Signing time: 1/24/2024
6:04:47 PM
-Rs.16,500/-
Loss of consortium
-Rs.4,40,000/- (Rs.44000 x 10)
Funeral expenses
-Rs.16,500/-------------------TOTAL Rs.18,08,600/-
19.
Thus, the just and proper amount of compensation in the instant
case is Rs.18,08,600/- as against the award of the Tribunal of Rs.10,78,000/-.
Accordingly, the appellants are entitled to an additional sum of Rs.7,30,600/over and above the amount which has been awarded by the Tribunal. The
principal liability to pay the said compensation amount shall be on the insurance
company, however, the insurance company is at liberty to recover the same
from the owner and driver of the offending vehicle.
20.
In the result, the appeal is allowed to the extent indicated herein above by
enhancing the compensation amount by a sum of Rs.7,30,600/-. The enhanced
amount shall bear interest at the same rate as awarded by the Tribunal. The
other findings recorded by the Tribunal shall remain intact.
21.
The appellant has valued the appeal only to the extent of Rs.2 lakhs and
paid the Court fee accordingly, however, for the remaining amount, the Court
fee shall be paid by the appellants within a period of one month and thereafter
the amount shall be released by the Insurance Company on receiving the
certificate.
In case the certificate has not been filed before the Insurance
Company up to a period of three months, the claimant shall not be entitled to
receive the interest on the enhanced amount of compensation.
22.
In the result, the appeal is allowed to the extent indicated herein above.
(HIRDESH)
Signed by: HARIKUMAR
NAIR
Signing time: 1/24/2024
6:04:47 PM
JUDGE
hk/
Signed by: HARIKUMAR
NAIR
Signing time: 1/24/2024
6:04:47 PM
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review