The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
26. 06.2024 Yes. HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD Judgment & Order (Oral) Heard Mr. Ratan Datta, learned counsel for the petitioner also heard Ms. Riya Chakraborty, learned counsel for the respondents. [2] This is a petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India for seeking the following relief(s): i. Issue notice upon the respondents ii. Call for the records iii. Issue notice calling upon the respondents to show cause as to show cause as to why the compensation amounting to Rs.29,06,400/- (Rupees Twenty Nine Lakhs Six Thousand and four Hundred only) along with statutory interest shall not be disbursed infavour of the petitioner. And And after hearing the parties be pleased to make the rule absolute. And/Or Pass any other order/orders as deemed fit and proper. [3] The case of the petitioner is that the State and the High Court of Tripura had decided to set up court building and residential quarters for the District & Sessions Judge Court at Sepahijala District and accordingly government khas land of measuring 4.32 acres pertaining to plot no. 799/p and 800 under Khatian No 1/117 & 1/118 of Mouja Bastali TK Amtali along with other lands were acquired. The said land was khas land in the occupation of the petitioner for long period. They were allotted in the name of the Law Department by evicting the petitioner without there being any acquisition proceeding and without ma…
133. Definitions.-In this part,(a) “estate” means lands included under one entry in any of the general registers of revenue-paying and revenue-free lands and includes(i) revenue-free lands not entered in any register, and (ii) a part of, or a share in, an estate; (b) “homestead” means a dwelling house together with any courtyard, compound, garden, or outhouse and includes any out-buildings used for purposes connected with agriculture and any family graveyard, library, office, guesthouse, grain store, latrines, boundary walls, tanks, wells or places of worship appertaining to such dwelling house; (c) “intermediary” means a person who holds in an estate the right, title or interest of a talukdar and includes – (i) a person who holds land either revenue-free or at a concessional rate, and (ii) a tenure holder: (d) “tenant” means a person who cultivates or holds the land of an intermediary under an agreement, express or implied, on condition of paying therefor rent in cash or in kind or delivering a share of the procedure and includes a person who cultivates or holds land of an intermediary under the system generally known as “bhag”, “adhi” or “barga”, and the term “sub-tenant” shall be construed accordingly; (e) “tenure holder” means a person who has acquired from an intermediary the right to hold lands for the purpose of collecting rents or bringing them under cultivation by establish…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) 398 of 2024
Smt. Bimala Debbarma
W/o- Sri Binod Debbarma,
R/o- Pushkarbari,
PO + PS – Bishramganj, District- Sepahijala Tripura
Aged about – 49 years, PIN Code- 799103
---Petitioner(s)
Versus
1. The Law Secretary, Government of Tripura,
New Secretariat Building, Kunjaban,
PS – New Capital Complex, Agartala, West Tripura, PIN – 799010
2. The Secretary, Revenue Department, Government of Tripura, New Secretariat Building,
Kunjaban, PS- New Capital Complex, Agartala, West Tripura, PIN – 799010.
3. The District Magistrate & Collector, Sepahijala District,
O/o The DM & Collector, Sepahijala District, Bishramgang, Tripura
4. The Land Acquisition Collector (Addl. District Magistrate & Collector),
Sepahijala District, O/o The DM & Collector, Sepahijala District, Bishramganj, Tripura.
---Respondent(s)
For Appellant(s)
:
For Respondent(s)
Date of hearing and date of
judgment and order
Whether fit for reporting
:
Mr. Ratan Datta, Advocate.
Mr. A.T. Pal, Advocate.
Ms. Riya Chakraborty, Advocate.
:
:
26.06.2024
Yes.
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
Judgment & Order (Oral)
Heard Mr. Ratan Datta, learned counsel for the petitioner also heard Ms.
Riya Chakraborty, learned counsel for the respondents.
[2]
This is a petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India for seeking
the following relief(s):
i. Issue notice upon the respondents
ii. Call for the records
iii. Issue notice calling upon the respondents to show cause as to show cause as
to why the compensation amounting to Rs.29,06,400/- (Rupees Twenty Nine
Lakhs Six Thousand and four Hundred only) along with statutory interest
shall not be disbursed infavour of the petitioner.
And
And after hearing the parties be pleased to make the rule absolute.
And/Or
Pass any other order/orders as deemed fit and proper.
[3]
The case of the petitioner is that the State and the High Court of Tripura had
decided to set up court building and residential quarters for the District & Sessions Judge
Court at Sepahijala District and accordingly government khas land of measuring 4.32
acres pertaining to plot no. 799/p and 800 under Khatian No 1/117 & 1/118 of Mouja
Bastali TK Amtali along with other lands were acquired. The said land was khas land in
the occupation of the petitioner for long period. They were allotted in the name of the
Law Department by evicting the petitioner without there being any acquisition proceeding
and without making any payment of compensation for 800 numbers of matured rubber
trees raised by the petitioner and also portion of constructed structures were affected to
which the petitioner is entitled for compensation.
[4]
Further, it is pointed out from the record that there is proceeding of the
District Collector dated 19.10.2020 recommending for Rs.29,06,400/- to be paid as
compensation for the rubber trees. Since the said compensation was not paid, the present
writ petition said to be filed.
[5]
The counsel for the petitioner, Mr. Ratan Datta while reiterating the
contention made in the writ affidavit has relied upon Sections 11 and 140 of the Tripura
Land Revenue And Land Reforms Act, 1960 (in short TLR & LR, Act 1960) and Section
80 of the Right to Fair compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition,
Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013. He further relied upon the judgment of the
apex court in Rame Gowda (D) by Lrs vs. M V varadappa Naidu (D) by Lrs & Anr
reported in AIR 2004 SC 4609 wherein the apex court has observed as follows.
“iv) that one of the usual tests to determine the quality of settled possession, in
the case of culturable land, would be whether or not the trespasser, after having
taken possession, had grown any crop. If the crop had been grown by trespasser,
then even the true owner has no right to destroy the crop grown by the trespasser
and take forcible possession.”
[6]
Thus, the petitioner prayed to allow the writ petition by awarding the
compensation of Rs.2906400/- with interest.
[7]
The counsel for the respondents contended that the petitioner is not entitled
for claiming any compensation and he is an unauthorized occupant. Therefore, the writ
petition be dismissed.
[8]
Heard both sides.
[9]
Admittedly, as seen from the correspondence made by the respondent, it is
presumed that the petitioner who is an occupant and there were
trees which were
damaged and on the strength of the inquiry report dated 02.07.2020 addressed by SDM,
Bishalgarh, Sepahijala District to the Senior Deputy Collector, Office of the District
Magistrate and Collector, Sepahijala District, Bishalgarh and also Amtali Tehsildar
report dated 09.09.2020 addressed to the SDM, Bishalgarh Subdivision, Sepahijala and
the letter dated 19.10.2020 by the District Magistrate Collector, Sepahijala District,
Bishramganj addressed to the Deputy Secretary, Law Department, Government of Tripura
for making payment of Rs.32,76,966/- in favour of the petitioner-Bimala Debbarma wife
of Binod Debbarma Rs.29,06,400/- for damage of rubber trees of 800 nos and in favour of
the Abdul Ouahed son of Chand Miah for damage of rubber tress of 102 nos.
Rs.3,70,566/[10]
Thereafter, by letter dated 11.08.2021 the Land Acquisition Collector,
Additional District Magistrate Sepahijala addressed to the Under Secretary, Revenue
Department, Government of Tripura seeking clarification as to the claim of Bimala
Debbarma being an unauthorized occupant of government land is only asking
compensation for the trees but not land. A further reminder was also made on 13.05.2022.
The petitioner also got issued a legal notice dated 12.02.2024 addressing the Law
Secretary, Land Acquisition Collector, Secretary Revenue Department and District
Magistrate and Collector, Sepahijala seeking to disburse the compensation amount of
29,06,400/- with 15% interest as per Section 80 of the Right to Fair compensation and
Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013.
[11]
On 15.02.2024, the DLR & Deputy Secretary, Law, Government of Tripura
issued a reply to the above legal notice dated 12.02.2024 and categorically answered that
as opined by the Revenue Department that there is no provision in the Allotment rules to
provide any compensation to the unauthorized occupier of government land and also that
Finance Department has not given any concurrence to the proposal of the compensation to
the unauthorized occupier of the government land.
[12]
While replying to the said legal notice, a copy of the reply has also been
sent to (i) District and Sessions Judge Sepahijala, (ii) Principal Secretary, Revenue
Department and (iii) District Magistrate and Collector, Sepahijala.
[13]
As the matter proceeds, on 07.03.2024, the District Magistrate and
Collector, Sepahijala addressed a letter to the Joint Secretary, Law that the claim of
Bimala Debbarma for Rs.29,06,400/- and Abdul Ouahed for Rs.3,70,566/- totaling
32,76,966/- is pending and the response from the Government is still awaited and the
copy of the same is marked to the Advocate Ratan Datta, and also to the Deputy Secretary
Revenue.
[14]
On perusal of the record, this court notices at running page 25 filed along
with the writ petition an office note of the respondent has been filed. The said note
contains no heading, no signature. When this court has inquired as to how this said office
note has been brought to the file along with the writ paper since the affidavit did not
contain the source of the collecting the same, to which the counsel for the petitioner has
no answer. This is not for the first time. This court has experienced such office note or
confidential correspondences which are not marked to the party are filed before this court
in the writ petition. And on several occasions, as pointed out, how a common man can
have access to the government departmental file and to procure confidential document.
[15]
The District Magistrate and Collector, Sepahijala District on 19.10.2020 as
stated (supra) has recommended for granting of payment of compensation for
Rs.29,06,400/- in favour of Bimala Debbarma, the petitioner herein. In pursuance of the
said recommendation, the legal notice dated 15.02.2024 has been addressed. The request
of the petitioner has been rejected & accordingly reply has been sent on 15.02.2024 to
legal notice. But surprisingly without considering the said rejection, once again the
District Magistrate and Collector, Sepahijala on 07.03.2024 addressed to the Joint
Secretary, Law seeking to do the needful and the response is still awaited.
[16]
The letter dated 19.10.2020 and 07.03.2024 appear to this court as
erroneous. As the letter dated 15.02.2024 has already been communicated the opinion of
the government and a copy has been already marked to the District Magistrate and
Collector, Sepahijala there is no reason as to why again the District Magistrate &
Collector issued the letter dated 07.03.2024. This observation is pointed out by this court
since huge amount are involved in payment of compensation.
[17]
Now coming to the appreciation of the case by deciding it on the legal
acumen the relevant Sections 11 and 140 of the TLR & LR Act, 1960 as stated as under:
Section 11. Title of Government to lands, etc.-(1) All lands, public roads, lanes
and paths and bridges, ditches, dikes, and fences on or beside the same, the beds
of rivers, streams, nallas, lakes and tanks, and all canals and water courses, and
all standing and flowing water, and all rights in or over the same or appertaining
thereto, which are not the property of any person, are and are hereby declared to
be the property of the Government.
(2) Unless it is otherwise expressly provided in the terms of a grant made by the
Government, the right to mines, quarries, minerals and mineral products
including mineral oil, natural gas and petroleum shall vest in the Government,
and it shall have all the powers necessary for the proper enjoyment of such rights.
(3) Where any property or any right in or over any property is claimed by or on
behalf of the Government, or by any person as against the Government and the
claim is disputed, such dispute shall be decided by the Collector whose order
shall, subject to the provisions of this Act, be final:
(4) Any person aggrieved by an order made under sub- section (3) or in appeal
or revision therefrom may institute a civil suit to contest the order within a period
of six months from the date of such order and the decision of the civil court shall
be binding on the parties.
[18]
During the course of argument, counsel for the petitioner pointed out that
Section 11(3) the TLR & LR Act, 1960 is relevant. This court has no hesitation to say that
in the present context that the said sub-section 3 of Section 11 is not applicable and thus
the argument advanced that the claim of the petitioner should be considered under Section
11(3) as he is having the right upon the trees and he is the occupant of the land has no
weightage. And thus the said argument is rejected as the same is irrelevant.
[19]
Now coming to the Section 140 which deals with the intermediary entitled
to receive compensation in any estate:
Section 140: Intermediaries entitled to receive compensation:
Every intermediary, whose right, title and interest in any estate vest in the
Government under Chapter XI shall be entitled to receive and be paid therefor
compensation as hereinafter provided.
[20]
The definition of Estate, intermediary and rights are dealt in Part-IV
Chapter XI- Acquisition of Estates and OF Rights of Intermediaries therein
133. Definitions.-In this part,(a) “estate” means lands included under one entry in any of the general registers
of revenue-paying and revenue-free lands and includes(i) revenue-free lands not entered in any register, and
(ii) a part of, or a share in, an estate;
(b) “homestead” means a dwelling house together with any courtyard,
compound, garden, or outhouse and includes any out-buildings used for purposes
connected with agriculture and any family graveyard, library, office, guesthouse,
grain store, latrines, boundary walls, tanks, wells or places of worship
appertaining to such dwelling house;
(c) “intermediary” means a person who holds in an estate the right, title or
interest of a talukdar and includes –
(i) a person who holds land either revenue-free or at a concessional rate,
and
(ii) a tenure holder:
(d) “tenant” means a person who cultivates or holds the land of an intermediary
under an agreement, express or implied, on condition of paying therefor rent in
cash or in kind or delivering a share of the procedure and includes a person who
cultivates or holds land of an intermediary under the system generally known as
“bhag”, “adhi” or “barga”, and the term “sub-tenant” shall be construed
accordingly;
(e) “tenure holder” means a person who has acquired from an intermediary the
right to hold lands for the purpose of collecting rents or bringing them under
cultivation by establishing tenants thereon.
[21]
Since the petitioner does not fall under the definition of intermediary and
the estate is not the subject matter involved in the present litigation. The issue of
considering the petitioner entitlement for the said compensation is decided against the
petitioner and this court has no hesitation to say that he is an unauthorized occupant,
trespasser. Further, in so far as judgment of the Hon’ble apex court is concerned in Rame
Gowda (supra) , the principle laid down in the said judgment in the light of the Act dealt
therein about the standing crop is concerned, it pertains to granting of injunction on the
issues of balance of convenience and the same cannot be made applicable for awarding
compensation towards final settlement. The case in hand has no application to the above
judgment and it appears to this court the said judgment is not relevant.
[22]
Now coming to the Section 80 of the Right to Fair Compensation and
Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013 which
deals with payment on interest as stated below:
“80. Payment of Interest- When the amount of such compensation is not paid or
deposited on or before taking possession of the land, the Collector shall pay the
amount awarded with interest thereon at the rate of nine percent per annum from
the time of so taking possession until it shall have been so paid or deposited;
Provided that is such compensation or any part thereof is not paid or deposited
within a period of one year from the date on which possession is taken interest at
the rate of fifteen per cent per annum shall be payable from the date or expiry of
the said period of one year on the amount of compensation or part thereof which
has not been paid or deposited before the date of such expiry.”
[23]
Since this court has opined that the petitioner is not entitled for any
compensation, the question of payment of interest under Section 80 the said Act, does not
arise.
[24]
In view of the above discussion, this court is of the consider view that the
petitioner being an unauthorized occupant and a trespasser cannot claim any
compensation. Thus, he has no authority to enter into the land. He has no right to make
any plantation and also construction over the government land without obtaining any
permission. The petitioner has no locus standi to claim any compensation for the trees and
for the unauthorized construction as contended. The petitioner has also not placed before
this court any provision of law in support of his claim.
[25]
In case of genuine owner/claimant losing his land, he is certainly entitled for
fair compensation. But the compensation cannot be bonanza for a person having no locus.
Thus, this writ petition being devoid of merit, is liable to be dismissed.
[26]
Accordingly, the writ petition is dismissed. As a sequel miscellaneous
applications pending, if any, shall stand closed.
[27]
A copy of this order be sent to the Chief Secretary, Government of Tripura
for his perusal and to look into said claims.
JUDGE
Dipak
DIPAK
DAS
DIPAK DAS
Date: 2024.07.05
14:49:01 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review