Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) 675/2021
Smt. Babli Rani Das,
Wife of Sri Dipak Datta, resident of
Sreerampur, Kailashaher, PO-Sreerampur,
P.S-Kailashaher, Sub-Division-Kailashaher, District-Unokoti Tripura.
…..Petitioner
-VERSUS1.
The State of Tripura, represented by the Commissioner &
Secretary, Education Department, Government of Tripura, having his
office at Secretariat Building, P.O-Kunjaban, P.S-New Capital
Complex, District-West Tripura, Pin-799006.
2.
The Commissioner & Secretary, Education Department,
Government of Tripura, having his office at Secretariat Building, P.OKunjaban, P.S-New Capital Complex, District-West Tripura, Pin799006.
3.
The Commissioner & Secretary, Finance Department,
Government of Tripura, having his office at Secretariat Building, P.OKunjaban, P.S-New Capital Complex, District-West Tripura, Pin799006.
4.
The Director of School Education, Education Department,
Government of Tripura, having his office at Shiksha Bhawan, Office
Lane, P.O-West Agartala, District-West Tripura.
…..Respondents
For Petitioner(s)
:
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Somik Deb, Sr. Advocate
Mrs. R. Chakraborty, Advocate
Mr. D. Bhattacharya, GA
Date of hearing & delivery
of judgment & order
:
22.08.2023
Whether fit for reporting
:
No
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
Heard Mr. Somik Deb, learned senior counsel assisted by Mrs. R.
Chakraborty, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner. Also heard Mr. D.
Bhattacharya, learned GA appearing for the respondents-State.
2.
Brief facts of the case are that the petitioner was appointed as a
Graduate Teacher in the year 2010, under the Education Department(School
Education), Tripura on fixed pay basis with monthly salary of Rs.7,060/-. After
completion of 5(five) years of service on fixed pay basis, regular pay scale was
allowed in favour of the petitioner vide Memorandum dated 31.07.2015.
Subsequently, the petitioner appeared in the TET Examination, Paper(I) &
Paper(II) and after successfully acing the Teachers Eligibility Test,(TTET)2017, Paper(I), the petitioner was appointed to the post of Under-Graduate
Teacher temporarily on fixed pay basis with monthly salary of Rs.14,078/-. The
petitioner again appeared in Tripura Teacher’s Eligibility Test/Verification of
certificates for (T-TET) Paper(I) & Paper(II) 2019 and successfully obtained the
certificate of T-TET, Paper(II). Vide memorandum dated 28.04.2021, the
petitioner was issued with offer of appointment to the post of Graduate
Teacher(VI-VIII) purely on temporary basis at fixed monthly pay of
Rs.20,475/-(revised). Based on these facts, the petitioner prayed for granting her
relief to regularize her from the date of her initial joining till the date of
subsequent joining to the post of Graduate Teacher.
3.
Mr. Bhattacharya, learned GA has submitted that a Division Bench
of this Court vide common judgment and order dated 07.05.2014, passed in
WP(C) No.51/2014 [Tanmoy Nath & Ors. vs. State of Tripura & Ors.] had
interfered the selection process of the petitioner which was initiated vide
Memorandum dated 30.08.2003, holding that the selection made to the posts of
Under-Graduate, Graduate & Post-Graduate Teachers under the Education
Department, Government of Tripura suffers from arbitrariness and illegalities
and as a sequel set aside and quashed the entire selection process. Assailing the
correctness of the observations and directions, contained in the judgment &
order dated 07.05.2014, Special Leave Petitions were presented before the
Hon’ble Supreme Court of India and by a judgment and order dated 23.03.2017,
the said Special Leave Petitions were disposed of inter alia affirming the
conclusions and directions recorded by the Hon’ble Division Bench of this
Court in Tanmay Nath(supra) with some modifications.
4.
Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel has urged that the respondents be
directed to act in compliance with the specific direction made by this Court in
Para-125 of the judgment dated 07.05.2014 delivered in Tanmay Nath(supra).
The relevant portion of para 125 reads as under:
“125……. It is further made clear that if the persons who
are selected in the previous selection are again selected then the
service rendered by them earlier shall be counted for the purpose
of seniority, pension and all other purposes.”
5.
Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel has submitted that the present writ
petition is squarely covered by a common judgment and order dated 20.05.2022
passed by a learned Single Judge (Talapatra, J.) of this Court in WP(C)
901/2021 titled as Sri Uttam Kumar Das & Ors. vs. The State of Tripura &
Ors. along with other connected writ petitions. Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel
has further submitted that another batch of writ petitions, lead case of which
being numbered as WP(C) 10/2022 titled as Sri Dipak Das & Ors. vs. The
State of Tripura & Ors., was disposed of by a learned Single Judge(Lodh, J.)
of this Court vide judgment and order dated 20.09.2022 in terms of the
judgment passed in Uttam Kumar Das(supra). The relevant portion of the
judgment passed in Uttam Kumar Das(supra) may be reproduced here-inbelow:
6 “…..Based on the perspective facts, the reliefs those have been
urged in these writ petitions are paraphrased and reproduced as
under:to treat the period rendered by the petitioners as Post
Graduate Teachers w.e.f. 28.06.2010 or any date as relevant in
case of each of the writ petitioners to 31.10.2020 or before the
joining of the petitioners in the post of Post Graduate
Teacher/Graduate Teacher being selected and recommended by
Teachers Recruitment Board of Tripura [TRBT] for appointment
for purpose of seniority, pension and for any other purpose
including pay protection.
It has been further urged that the respondents be directed to act in
compliance with the specific direction made by this court in Para125 of the judgment dated 07.05.2014 delivered in W.P.(C)
No.51/2014 [Tanmoy Nath & Ors. vs. State of Tripura & Ors.]. It
has been further urged that the respondents be directed to extend the
benefits of the judgment and order dated 21.01.2019 delivered in
W.P.(C) No.435/2018 [Babul Debnath & others vs. State of Tripura
& Ors.], the common judgment and order dated 29.01.2020
delivered in W.P.(C) No.295 of 2019 [Sangita Reang & Ors. vs.
State of Tripura & Ors.] along with analogous writ petitions and the
judgment and order dated 06.07.2020 delivered in W.P.(C) No.381
of 2020 [Prasanta Pal vs. State of Tripura & Ors.]. Further, it has
been urged that the petitioners be treated to have been appointed as
Graduate Teacher on recommendation of the TRBT in the regular
scale pertaining to the post of Graduate Teacher and on such
premises, their GPF account be activated. Finally, the petitioners
have urged that the common termination letter dated 31.03.2020
may not be applicable to the petitioners and as such, the non-
working period w.e.f 01.04.2020 till their joining in the post of
Graduate Teacher, having been recommended by TRBT to be
regularised by granting non-paid leave.
[2] For purpose of reference and to appreciate the challenge raised
in these writ petitions, Para-125 of Tanmoy Nath (supra) is
reproduced hereunder:
“125. We would also like to make it clear that other than the
benefits
indicated
by
us
above
there
can
be
no
reservation/preference on the basis of age. There shall be no
preference to dependent government servants or retired government
employee or retrenched employees etc. There can be no reservation
for linguistic or religious minorities or on area wise basis. It is
further made clear that if the persons who are selected in the
previous selection are again selected then the service rendered by
them earlier shall be counted for the purpose of seniority, pension
and all other purposes.”
[Emphasis added]
[3] In Babul Debnath (supra) while this court was noticing noncompliance of Para-125 of Tanmoy Nath (supra) had occasion to
observe that the exercise undertaking by the Government is not in
the spirit rather in utter disregard to the direction issued by this
court. Past service rendered by a candidate who was selected has to
be counted for the purpose of seniority, pension and all other
benefits. Candidates stood selected to the very same post. Thus, a
direction was issued to the State to treat the past service of each one
of the petitioners who rendered service being appointed by the
earlier selection process for the purpose of seniority, pension and
all other benefits.
[4] In a different matrix of facts, in Sangita Reang (supra), this
court having noted the divergence that emerged for the reasons that
some of the terminated teachers vide Tanmoy Nath (supra) got fresh
appointments following the substantive selection process, meaning
being recommended by TRBT not in the same post, but in the higher
post and also in the post lower than the post where they were earlier
appointed and render their service, but all the petitioners were
appointed as the teachers. It has been observed in Sangita Reang
(supra) that there are 3 distincts and different situations and thus, 3
[three]broad categories can be formed.
Category-I would be those cases where the teachers who was
previously selected and appointed in a particular post and selection
and appointment thereof was set aside by this court in Tanmoy Nath
(supra) is now through a fresh selection process is selected and
appointed on the same post.
Category-II would be cases where the teachers who were previously
holding post but now are selected and appointed on a particular
post by a fresh selection process. Their selection and appointments
had been, like in all the cases, set aside by this court in the case of
Tanmoy Nath (supra). They have been selected and appointed
through fresh selection process to posts higher than whereby they
previously held.
Category-III would be those cases where a teacher who was
previously selected and appointed on a particular post and his
selection and appointment had been set aside by this court in case of
Tanmoy Nath (supra) is, pursuant to fresh selection process,
selected and appointed to a post lower than which he previously
held.
Thereafter, in Sangita Reang (supra) the following
observation has been made:
26. In cases falling in Category-I therefore, there shall be full
protection of their past service as envisaged in para-125 of the judgment
in case of Tanmoy Nath (supra).
27. Coming to the cases falling in Category-II where the teachers have
been selected and appointed on the higher posts, their cases must be
considered in light of the observations made in para-125 of the
judgment in case of Tanmoy Nath (supra). The said paragraph is
pivotal to the entire discussion. Nevertheless, certain developments have
taken place after rendering of the said judgment and suitable
modifications shall have to be made to suit the purpose. In other words
this discussion must revolve around the directions contained in para
125 of the decision in case of Tanmoy Nath (supra) but cannot be
confined to it completely. Right of the petitioners flow from the said
judgment but the directions contained therein will have to be applied
with suitable modifications as per the requirements of the case.
Significant developments are that the proceedings remained pending
before the Supreme Court and thereafter lingered before the
Government. In the meantime, limited selections were made and
appointments offered. The foundational purpose of issuing the
clarification direction in para-125 of the judgment was to ensure that
those teachers, who offer themselves for fresh selection which would be
undertaken on the basis of sound employment policy which may be
framed and after competitive examination are selected and appointed,
in their cases there must be a protection of past service already
rendered. The Division Bench while striking down the entire selection
process was of course actuated by certain irregularities committed in
such selection process and in particular, offended by the fact that the
selection policy was totally un-guided. However, that would not per say
imply that every selected and appointed candidate was undeserving or
incompetent. Therefore for such candidate who gets selected and
appointed in the fresh selection process, the desire of the Court was to
protect his past service for all purposes.
28. While doing so, the Court obviously would not be in a position to
foresee all eventualities which may arise in future and provide for all
possible combinations which may develop. Category-II is of cases where
the teachers, who were previously holding particular post have proved
their merit by securing selection on the higher posts. The philosophy
and logic for protection past service contained in the judgment in case
of Tanmoy Nath (supra) would therefore apply in their cases also,
however, with a rider, namely, that their service for the purpose of
seniority upon their fresh appointments cannot be protected. Any such
direction would be wholly unjust to those teachers, who may be holding
the post on regular basis long before these teachers were appointed on
regular basis pursuant to fresh selection process. Surely, by no judicial
dictum these teachers can jump in seniority over those who are already
existing in the cadre since long. Subject to this restriction, the
petitioners in Category II must get the protection of their past service.
This would also be in consonance with the clarification contained in
para-125 of the judgment in case of Tanmoy Nath (supra).
29. Coming to Category-III, the teachers who were previously holding a
post but are now selected and appointed on the lower post, for obvious
the reasons cannot claim seniority benefit or any other benefit of past
service except for the limited purpose of leave to their credit, provident
fund, pension and gratuity which the Government has already
recognized and granted as also for being posted in the regular scale.
These teachers had rendered more than 5 years of service since the year
2010 and therefore, had been brought on the regular pay scale in the
year 2015 and thereabouts. They now cannot be placed back on fixed
salary basis. Firstly, this would be going against the philosophy of
counting past service of those teachers, who eventually get regular
selection and appointment. Secondly, it would also be incongruent with
the decision of the Government to count their past service for the
purpose of pension and gratuity. If their past service is counted towards
pensionery benefits, it would defy logic that the same should not be
counted as a qualifying service for the purpose of being brought over to
regular pay scale.
30. Under the circumstances, petitions are disposed of with following
directions:
(i) In case of Category-I cases, the petitioners shall receive full benefit
of the past service for the purpose of seniority, pension and all other
purposes.
(ii) In Category-II cases, past service rendered by the petitioners will be
counted for the purpose of pension, pay fixation and all other purposes
except for seniority. In other words, it is provided that the pay of these
petitioners would be fixed in their respective posts pursuant to fresh
appointments taking into account entire past service rendered by them
and bearing in mind the principles contained in F.R.22 of the
Fundamental Rules. However, their past service shall not count towards
seniority. They would be placed at the bottom of seniority as on the date
of their fresh appointments. It is clarified that these directions shall not
enable any other teachers in the same cadre or any other cadre to claim
upgradation of his/her pay by seeking removal of anomaly or in any
other manner.
(iii) In Category-III cases, the petitioners’ past service would be
counted for the limited purpose of retaining their leave credit, provident
fund, pension and gratuity and further that they will be placed in the
regular scale of pay from the date of their fresh appointment and the
pay will be fixed at the minimum of the scale. They would receive all
admissible allowances.
[5] In order to comply, the judgments as referred before, in
Prasanta Pal(supra), the Director of Elementary Education,
Government of Tripura issued the memorandum No.F.1(163-1)DEE/Estt:(LA)/2020)(L-2)/6046 dated 17.12. 2020. Considering its
relevance, the entire text of the said memorandum dated 17.12.2020
is reproduced hereunder:
No.F.1(163-1)-DEE/Estt: LA)/2020)(L-2)/6046
Government of Tripura Directorate of Elementary Education
Establishment Section
Dated, Agartala, the 17.12.2020
Subject : Extension of benefit of past service/Pay, Seniority, Pension
benefits etc. in respect of Sri Prasanta Pal, UGT appointed by selection
through Teachers’ Recruitment Board, Tripura
Whereas, Sri Prasanta Pal, S/O- Srirish Chandra Pal was appointed to
the post of Graduate Teacher or fixed pay basis under the Directorate of
School Education, Tripura in the year 2010 and subsequently after
completion of 5(five) yeas of his service were allowed regular pay meant
for Graduate Teachers.
AND
Whereas the Hon’ble High Court of Tripura in its judgment and order
dated 07.05.2014 in W.P.(C) No.51 of 2014 and other Writ Petitions had
set aside the Revised Employment Policy of the State Government and the
entire selection process of Teacher appointed/recruited in the year 2010;
AND
Whereas, the Hon’ble High Court of Tripura in Para-125 in its above
judgment dated 07.05.2014 ordered as under: “It is further made clear
that if the persons who are selected in the previous selection are again
selected then the service rendered by them earlier shall be counted for the
purpose of seniority, pension and all other purposes.”
AND
Whereas the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in its Judgment and order
dated 29.03.2017 in SLP No(s) 18993-19049 of 2014 has also affirmed
the above judgment and order of the Hon’ble High Court of Tripura with
some modifications.
AND
Whereas Sri. Prasanta Pal was appointed to the post of Graduate
Teachers in the year 2010 and subsequently terminated on 31.12.2017
and again appointed on Ad-Hoc basis w.e.f 01.01.2018 and thereafter
joined/appointed as UGT on fixed pay basis afresh on 06.04.2020, being
selected through Teachers’ Recruitment Board, Tripura filed writ
petitions before the Hon’ble High Court of Tripura for issuing the
necessary directions to the State Respondents for consideration of his
matters as ordered by the Hon’ble High Court of Tripura in Para 125 in
the judgment and order dated 07.05.2014. AND Whereas the petitioner
Sri Prasanta Pal was offered for appointment to the post of Under
Graduate Teacher during his Ad-Hoc service and accordingly the offer of
appointment was accepted before his termination from the Ad-hoc Service
but due to some administrative reasons he has to join on 06.04.2020.
AND
Whereas the others similarly situated Ad-hoc teachers, who were selected
by the same selection process for appointment to the post of UGT, joined
the post of UGT prior to their termination from their Ad-hoc service was
allowed the benefit of past service rendered by them in the light of the
judgment and order of the Hon’ble High Court of Tripura dated
29.01.2020 passed in the Writ petition W.P.(C) No.295/2019.
AND
Whereas in the light of the principle judgment and order of the Hon’ble
High Court of Tripura dated 29.01.2020 on the writ petition W.P(C)
No.295 of 2019 and other similar writ petitions the concerned persons
have been categorised as Category-III who were previously holding a
post but are now selected and appointed on the lower post and it has been
ordered that the petitioners past service would be counted for the limited
purpose of retaining his leave credit, provident fund, pension and gratuity
and further that he will be placed in the regular scale of pay from the
date of his fresh appointment and the pay will be fixed at the minimum of
the scale.
AND
Whereas the Hon’ble High Court of Tripura in the judgment and order
dated 06.07.2020 passed in W.P.(C) No.381 of 2020, has comprehended
that the case is covered by the judgment and order dated 29.01.2020
delivered in W.P.(C) No.295 of 2019 and directed for the similar relief
under the Category-III and whereas the concerned person who was
appointed to the post of Graduate Teacher in the year 2010 and enjoyed
regular pay scale meant for graduate Teachers and thereafter again
joined and appointed in the post of UGT on fixed pay basis being selected
by the teachers recruitment board, Tripura from their previous post of
Graduate Teacher also comes under Category-III.
AND
Whereas the Finance Department vide U.O. No.526/FIN(Estt-22)/20
dated 07.12.2020 and the Law Department, Tripura has opined to comply
with the order of Hon’ble High Court of Tripura dated 06.07.2020.
AND
Now the undersigned ordered that:
1. The common termination letter, dated, 31.03.2020 will not be
applicable to the petitioner & he will be deemed to be in-service & the
non working period w.e.f 01.04.2020 to 05.04.2020 is be regularized by
granting admissible non paid leave (EOL).
2. The petitioner who was earlier a Graduate Teacher & now holding the
post of UGT on fixed pay basis will get the benefits regular pay scale
meant for UGTs from the date of their fresh appointment as UGT, i.e.
08.04.2020, & his pay would be fixed at the minimum of the pay scale/pay
matrix.
3. He will also get the benefits of past service, rendered as Graduate
Teacher (w.e.f. 21.05.2010) in respect of leave at credit, GPF Account (if
opened) & counting of past service for pension & gratuity purposes.
4. He will be placed at the bottom of the seniority list of UGTs as on the
date of his fresh appointment as UGTs. The inter-se seniority of such
teachers themselves shall be according to their position in the select list
(TET-I) conducted by the Teachers Recruitment Board, Tripura.
The Head of Offices & DDOs of the concerned teacher shall take all
necessary action for releasing monetary benefits admissible to Sri
Prasanta Pal, UGT, immediately.
(Saju Vahdood A, IAS)
Director of Elementary Education)
Tripura
[6] The counsel for the petitioners have submitted that the
petitioners are not straightway covered by the judgments of Babul
Debnath (supra), Sangita Reang (supra) and Prasanta Pal (supra)
because there is a gap in the continuity. The petitioners were
terminated from their ad-hoc appointment w.e.f. 31.0.30.2020 and
they have been appointed after a gap of a period. The said gap
commencing from 01.04.2020 has provided the respondents the
basis in denying the benefits of Para-125 of Tanmoy Nath (supra).
[7] Mr. Somik Deb, learned senior counsel and Mr. P. Roy Barman,
learned senior counsel have appeared for the petitioners and stated
that the period that the petitioners have served from their date of
appointment for example, in W.P.(C) 901 of 2021 the said period is
from 21.05.2010 to 31.03.2020, be added to their service on
regularising the period from 01.04.2020 to the date of joining of
each of the petitioners on their fresh appointment by admissible
non-paid leave [POL].
[8] Mr. D. Bhattacharjee, learned GA appearing for the
respondents has quite categorically stated that the benefit of service
has been given to those terminated teachers who have joined their
fresh appointment after technical resignation from their ad-hoc
appointment. But the petitioners herein did not get the fresh
appointments during the tenure of ad-hoc appointment, meaning till
31.03.2020. As such, they are not entitled to any benefit of their past
service. Mr. Bhattacharjee, learned GA has submitted that the
petitioners are like any other unemployed candidate who joined the
fresh government service, while benefit of past service is only
allowed in case of the government’s servant who applied through
proper channel for a post in the same or some other departments
and is, on selection, required to resign technically from the previous
post on administrative reason. The petitioners do not fall in this
category Mr. Bhattacharjee,, learned has submitted that even the
petitioners case cannot be compared with Prasanta Pal (supra)
because his offer of appointment was issued before 31.03.2020 but
in these cases all the petitioners have been appointed after a long
gap. For example, the petitioners in W.P.(C) No.901 of 2001 [Uttam
Kr. Das & 25 Ors. vs. State of Tripura & Ors.] they have joined the
post of Graduate Teacher after 16 months from 31.03.2020. Mr.
Bhattacharjee, learned GA therefore, has contended that no benefit
should be extended in view of Para-125 of Tanmoy Nath (supra)
where it has been directed that if the persons who are selected in the
previous selection process are again selected, then the service
rendered by them earlier shall be counted for purpose of seniority,
pension and all other purposes.
[9] Having appreciated the submission of the learned counsel
appearing for the parties, there cannot be any amount doubt that
there is a gap between the day of the appointment of the petitioners
from the day of termination of ad-hoc appointment i.e. 31.03.2020.
But it is also not in dispute that all the petitioners have been
appointed afresh in the post of Graduate or Post Graduate Teacher,
but admittedly there is a gap. Under the normal rules there is
difficulty in granting the benefit of the past service. This Court in
Prasanta Pal (supra) waiving the gap directed the respondents to
count the petitioner’s past service for the limited purpose of
retaining his leave credit, provident fund and also for purpose of
pension and gratuity. It was further directed that the petitioner
would be placed in his regular scale of pay from the date of fresh
appointment and accordingly, their pay shall be refixed but in the
minimum of the scale of pay. The respondents were directed to make
payment of arrears within a period of 3 months from the day when a
copy of the order be placed before them. From the memorandum
dated 17.12.2020, as reproduced above, it would be apparent that
the said directions have been complied by the respondents. One
observation of the apex court in Ajoy Debbarma vs. State of Tripura
and others [judgment dated 05.08.2020 delivered in Civil Appeal
No.286 of 2020, Annexure-11 to the writ petition] is noteworthy. In
Ajoy Debbarma (supra) the apex court has projected the
constitutional empathy towards the terminated teachers vide
Tanmoy Nath (supra). For purpose of reference, the relevant
passage from Ajoy Debbarma (supra) is reproduced below:
18. In our view, considering the fact that the very selection and
appointments were found to be illegal and invalid, no other
advantage can be conferred upon the concerned candidates. It
must be noted that the attempt on part of the State in offering
certain alternate employment is not to degrade the teachers but
some solace is being offered even in cases where the candidates do
not succeed in the selections to the posts of teachers. The
candidates, if they are otherwise competent and eligible, will
certainly have every opportunity till 31.03.2023 to get selected for
the posts of teachers in the State and by way of additional benefit
those who are unsuccessful in such attempts may retain the
alternate employment. In our view, it does not amount to
degradation.
[10] If that observation of the apex court in Ajoy Debbarma (supra)
is read with Para-125 of Tanmoy Nath (supra) it becomes clear that
if the persons who were selected in the previous selection are again
selected, then the service rendered by them earlier shall be counted
for the purpose of seniority, pension and all other purposes. It is an
unambiguous direction, not factored by any other considerations. It
is apparent that the persons who are appointed during the period of
age relaxation should be given the benefit of the past service. In
Sangita Reang (supra) this court had occasion to direct that the
candidates who fall broadly in the three categories as identified,
would be extended the benefit in the manner as reiterated below:
(i) In case of Category-I cases, the petitioners shall receive full
benefit of the past service for the purpose of seniority, pension
and all other purposes.
(ii) In Category-II cases, past service rendered by the petitioners
will be counted for the purpose of pension, pay fixation and all
other purposes except for seniority. In other words, it is
provided that the pay of these petitioners would be fixed in their
respective posts pursuant to fresh appointments taking into
account entire past service rendered by them and bearing in
mind the principles contained in F.R.22 of the Fundamental
Rules. However, their past service shall not count towards
seniority. They would be placed at the bottom of seniority as on
the date of their fresh appointments. It is clarified that these
directions shall not enable any other teachers in the same cadre
or any other cadre to claim upgradation of his/her pay by
seeking removal of anomaly or in any other manner.
(iii) In Category-III cases, the petitioners‟ past service would be
counted for the limited purpose of retaining their leave credit,
provident fund, pension and gratuity and further that they will be
placed in the regular scale of pay from the date of their fresh
appointment and the pay will be fixed at the minimum of the
scale. They would receive all admissible allowances.
[11] In the circumstances, this court is persuaded to direct the
respondents to regularise the gap commencing from 01.04.2020 till
the date of joining of each of the writ petitioners by deeming them to
be in service and the non-working period meaning the gap period be
regularised by granting admissible non-paid leave [EOL]. So far the
other benefits are concerned, that shall be released in favour of the
petitioners in terms of the directions in Sangita Reang (supra), as
reproduced above, finding out their relevant categories.
[12] Having observed thus, the writ petitions are allowed partly.
There shall be no order as to costs.”
6.
Since the factual aspects of the present writ petition is similar and
identical to the subject matter of the case of Uttam Kumar Das(supra), the
present writ petition is also, therefore, allowed and disposed of in the same
terms.
7.
Accordingly, the respondents are directed to regularize the gap
period of the petitioner of this writ petition from the date of her initial
appointment under the earlier selection process till the date of her subsequent
joining in service. The non-working period that is, the gap period, be
regularised by way of granting admissible non-paid leave (EOL). Needless to
say, all other service and consequential benefits shall be decided in favour of
the petitioner in terms of the directions in Sangita Reang (supra), as quoted and
extracted here-in-above as per her relevant category.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands dismissed.
JUDGE
Snigdha
SANJAY
GHOSH
SANJAY GHOSH
Date: 2023.08.24 13:59:00
+05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review