Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
JOHN
JOHN TELEN KOM
2023.10.13
TELEN KOM Date:
09:35:49 +05'30'
Item No.19
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WP(C)No.791 of 2022
1. Smt. Ayekpam Dolly Devi, aged about 32 years, W/o Late Yengkhopam
Surjit Singh of Athokpam Makha Leikai, PO & PS Thoubal, DistrictThoubal, Manipur-795138 presently residing at her parental residence at
Sagolband Tera Khamnam Leirak, PO & PS Lamphel, Imphal West
District, Manipur.
2. Shri Sorokhaibam Romesh Singh, aged about 39 years, S/o Shri
Sorokhaibam Jilla Singh of Charangpat Mayai Leikai, PO & PS Thoubal,
District-Thoubal, Manipur-795138.
…Petitioners
- Versus -
1. The Punjab National Bank, Imphal Branch represented by its Chief
Manager having its registered office at Thangal Bazar, PO Imphal, PS
City, District-Imphal West, Manipur-795001.
2. The Branch Manager, Punjab National Bank, Thangal Bazar Branch
having its registered office at Thangal Bazar, PO Imphal, PS City, DistrictImphal West, Manipur-795001.
3. PNB Metlife India Insurance Company Limited(formerly known as
Metlife India Insurance Company Limited) represented by its Managing
Director having its registered office: unit No.701, 702,703, 7th floor, West
Wing, Raheja Towers, 26/27 MG Road, Bangalore-560001.
4. Metlife Insurance and Loan Liability of Punjab National Bank(eUBI),
Imphal Branch, having its office at MG Avenue, PO & PS City, Imphal
West District, Manipur-795001.
…Respondents
BEFORE
HON’BLE THE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE MR. M.V.MURALIDARAN
ORDER
06.10.2023
[1]
Heard Mr. HS. Paonam, learned senior counsel for the
petitioners; Mr.L.Gunindro Singh, learned counsel for the respondents 1
and 2 and Mr.I. Somorjit, learned junior counsel to Mr. S.Samarjeet,
learned senior panel counsel for the respondents 3 and 4.
[2]
This writ petition has been filed by the petitioners for
issuance of a writ of mandamus directing the respondents 1 and 2 for
repayment of the loan being from PNH Metlife Loan and Life Suraksha
(Level Cover) with Group Policy Holder as Punjab National Bank, Group
Policy No.00000654 by insurance policy.
[3]
Mr. H. S Paonam, the learned senior counsel for the
petitioners submitted that the first petitioner’s husband, who was a State
Government employee, availed a personal loan from the respondent bank
for Rs.5.78 lakhs on 24.4.2021 and the second petitioner stood as
guarantor for the said loan.
At the time of sanction of the loan, an
insurance coverage was taken for the loan amount by the husband of the
first petitioner to be effective from 29.5.2021 and the first premium of
Rs.5056/- has already been paid along with other charges. The husband
of the first petitioner died on 9.6.2021 due to cardiac arrest and after the
demise, the first petitioner is facing financial problems, coupled with the
fact that she is living in a very pathetic condition having two children.
[4]
The learned senior counsel further submitted that the
husband of the first petitioner joined the insurance policy under PNB
Metlife Loan and Life Suraksha (Level Cover) with Group Policy Holder as
PNB, Group Policy No.00000654, thereby linking to the loan account and
having covered with effect from 29.5.2021. The respondent bank was also
aware about the insurance, as it is the group policy.
[5]
The learned senior counsel urged that the respondent bank
is pressuring the first petitioner for repayment of the loan dues of her
deceased husband by whatsoever means.
Since the first petitioner is
unable to repay the loan out of her source of income, she made a
representation on 8.9.2021 to the second respondent requesting to adjust
the loan dues of her deceased husband out of the insurance policy under
the group policy. Instead of adjusting the loan dues of the deceased
husband of the first petitioner, a letter dated 19.9.2021 was addressed by
the first respondent to the Commandant 5th IRB, Thenguchingjin, Imphal
East requesting to arrange to credit the terminal benefits in the salary
account of the deceased maintained by the first respondent to facilitate
loan adjustment.
[6]
The learned senior counsel further submitted that on
18.9.2021 the second respondent sent a letter to the first respondent
requesting to contact Metlife people for further steps for settlement.
According to the learned senior counsel, the first petitioner approached
the representative of the third respondent several times for repayment of
the loan by settling the insurance policy. However, the third respondent
was reluctant to settle the insurance policy for reason best known to them.
[7]
The learned senior counsel for the petitioners submitted that
since the representation dated 8.9.2021 submitted by the first petitioner
has not been considered, she sent a legal notice on 16.10.2021 requesting
to settle the loan dues of her husband by adjusting with the proceeds of
the insurance policy.
[8]
According to the learned senior counsel, the respondents are
also harassing the second petitioner and that his salary account has been
blocked for the last more than four months so as to adjust the loan amount
from his monthly salary. On 7.6.2022, the second petitioner submitted an
application to the second respondent requesting to release his salary
without any further delay for ensuring his livelihood.
[9]
The learned senior counsel submitted that despite the
existence of the alternative means to cover up the loan dues of the
deceased husband of the first petitioner by claiming the insurance policy,
the respondent bank resorted to a means which is depriving the right to
live and livelihood of the second petitioner by blocking his salary account
which is the only means of the livelihood of the second petitioner and his
family. On 8.8.2022, the second petitioner sent a reminder to the second
respondent requesting for harnessing other alternative than blocking his
bank account for repayment of the personal loan of late Y. Surjit Singh. In
the said letter, the second petitioner requested to recover the said loan
from the insurance policy subscribed by the deceased after due
procedure. Despite the receipt of the reminder, the respondent bank is
harassing the petitioners for repayment of loan amount, which is an
arbitrary act and the same is to be interfered with by this Court exercising
jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.
[10]
On the other hand, Mr. L. Gunindro, the learned counsel for
the respondents 1 and 2 submitted that as per the terms of the agreement,
the second petitioner being guarantor is bound to repay the personal loan
availed by the husband of the first petitioner. As per the records available,
the husband of the first petitioner died on 9.6.2021 and not on 9.6.2022.
As per the terms and conditions of the insurance policy, in case of nonemployer-employee groups schemes, the Company shall not be liable to
make any payment under the group policy on the occurrence of the
insured even during the warning period of 30 days.
[11]
The learned counsel submitted that as per free look
provision, insured member has a period of 15 days from the date of receipt
of the certificate of insurance to review the terms and conditions of the
insurance coverage. If the member has any objections to any of the terms
and conditions, then he/she has the option to return the certificate of
insurance stating the reasons for the objections and shall be entitled to a
refund of the premium paid subject to only a deduction of proportionate
risk premium for the period of cover, stamp duty charges and expenses
towards medical examination. All rights of the member under this policy
shall immediately stand extinguished at the cancellation of the certificate
of insurance. According to the learned counsel, the petitioner has not
approached this Court with clean hands and had misled the Court by
stating that the husband of the first petitioner expired on 9.6.2021 which
is beyond the waiting period of 30 days.
[12]
The learned counsel further submitted that as per the terms
and conditions of the insurance policy, the participation of the Punjab
National Bank and the Punjab National Bank customers are purely on a
voluntary basis and at the request of the borrower, a sum ofRs.5057/- has
been deducted from the saving account of the borrower on 28.5.2021 for
issuance of PNB MetLife Loan & Life Suraksha (Level Cover) insurance
policy from PNB MetLife India Insurance Company Limited. As such, the
PNB MetLife India Insurance Company Limited has issued a PNB Met Life
& Life Suraksha in the name of the borrower Yengkokpam Surjit Singh
with effective date of coverage from 29.5.2021 to 29.5.2026 for a sum
assured amount of R.5.76 lakhs vide certificate No.23815789. The said
certificate is issued based on the contract of insurance between PNB Met
Life India Insurance Company Limited and the Punjab National Bank and
not between the Punjab National Bank and the insured member.
[13]
The learned counsel urged that the respondent bank cannot
force the PNB MetLife Insurance Company Limited to settle the claim
against their terms and conditions. The respondents are to cover the loan
dues only when the PNB MetLife Insurance release fund, if the claim is
eligible for claim and settlement under the terms and conditions of the said
PNB MetLife Insurance. The respondent bank is also contacting the
respondents 3 and 4, but there is no response from them. In the mean
time, due to non-payment, the account was downgraded as NPA on
1.12.2021 and the outstanding balance of the loan account is
Rs.6,39,143/- as on 31.12.2022 plus upto date interest and other charges.
There is no illegality in pursuing to recover the bank’s loan, as bank’s
money is the public money and all actions are done within the ambit of law
and as per the terms and conditions of the sanction letter dated 20.4.2021.
The petitioners are duty bound to repay the outstanding loan amount. The
liability of the principal borrower and the guarantor stands in the same
footing and the guarantor cannot be discharged of his liability till the final
repayment of the loan.
The relation between the respondents 1 and 2
with the third respondent is under a corporate tie-up and the respondents
1 and 2 have no role to play in the decision making process of a claim.
[14]
Mr.I. Somorjit, learned junior counsel to Mr. S. Samarjeet,
learned senior panel counsel for the respondents 3 and 4 submitted that
the husband of the first petitioner opted for a loan from the first respondent
which was secured by the Deceased Life Assured by voluntarily opting for
the policy.
The contract of insurance is a contract based on
“uberrimaefidei” i.e. utmost good faith and any claim against the contract
of insurance is payable as per the terms and conditions of the policy. The
first petitioner has not intimated any claim against the policy to the
respondents 3 and 4 and due to which the same could not be evaluated
or processed as per the terms and conditions of the policy. The learned
counsel further submitted that till date no claim has been made by the
petitioners to the respondents 3 and 4 for processing the claim against the
policy. The present writ petition is pre-mature and the same is liable to be
dismissed.
[15]
This Court considered the rival submissions and also
perused the material available on record.
[16]
There is no dispute that at the time of availing bank loan with
the respondents 1 and 2, the husband of the first petitioner joined the
insurance policy under PNB Metlife Loan and Life Suraksha (Level Cover)
thereby linking the loan account covered with effect form 29.5.2021.
According to the petitioners, the said loan due is covered by the insurance
policy. After the demise of the husband of the first petitioner, instead of
adjusting the policy amount to the loan dues, the respondent bank is
harassing the petitioners and, in fact, the respondent bank blocked the
salary account of the second petitioner.
[17]
The respondents 3 and 4 admit the availing of loan by the
husband of the first petitioner from the respondent bank, which was
secured by the Deceased Life Assured by opting for policy bearing
certificate No.23815789. The details whereof have been stated by the
respondents 3 and 4 in their affidavit-in-opposition. On a reading of the
details furnished by the respondents 3 and 4, it is clear that the husband
of the first petitioner has taken the product Met Loan & Life Suraksha –
LCS. The date of proposal is 29.5.2021 and the risk commencement date
is 29.5.2021. The date of insurance is mentioned as 29.5.2021. The
premium amount is Rs.5,056.30 and the sum assured is Rs.5,76,000/-.
The policy term is 5 years. In the said details, it has been stated that “the
policy is in force”.
[18]
In
paragraph
(7)
of
the
affidavit-in-opposition,
the
respondents 3 and 4 have stated as under:
“7. That, with regard to para No.5 of the Writ Petition, the deponent
begs to submit that the contents of the para are admitted to the
extent that the husband of the Petitioner No.1 herein had opted for
a loan from Respondent No.1 which was secured by the Deceased
Life Assured (DLA) by voluntarily opting for the policy bearing
certificate No.’23815789’. It is pertinent to the claim against the
instant policy has to be processed by the Respondent No.3 and 4 in
accordance with the terms and conditions of the policy agreed by
the DLA at the proposal stage. However, till date no claim has been
made to the company (i.e. Respondents No.3 and 4) for processing
the claim against the policy.”
[19]
In India, if a personal loan borrower passes away, the
treatment of the personal loan and its repayment can vary based on
several factors, including the terms of the loan agreement, the lender’s
policies and the presence of any insurance coverage. Some personal
loans come with loan insurance or credit insurance, which may provide
coverage in the event of the borrower’s death. If the borrower had taken
out such insurance, the outstanding loan amount might be covered, either
partially or fully by the insurance company. The insurance payout would
go towards repaying the outstanding loan balance. As stated supra, the
respondents 3 and 4 have admitted the insurance policy towards the loan
taken by the husband of the first petitioner and, according to them, the
same was in force.
[20]
In the light of the statement made by the respondents 3 and
4 in the affidavit-in-opposition and since the respondents 3 and 4 have
now come forward and stated that if the petitioners submit a claim, they
are ready to process the same in accordance with the terms and
conditions of the policy agreed by the DLA, in the interest of justice, it
would be appropriate to direct the petitioners, particularly the first
petitioner, to make a claim to the respondents 3 and 4 so as to process
the claim by the respondents 3 and 4 against the policy in accordance with
law.
[21]
It is pertinent to note that by illegal means the bank cannot
pressurize and/or harass the deceased family members for repayment of
the loan, when they lost the bread winner.
It is stated that the first
petitioner being a widow is living with her two children in a pathetic
situation without having any source of income.
[22]
Considering the facts and circumstances of the case and
taking note of the averments set out in paragraph (7) of the affidavit-inopposition of the respondents 3 and 4, this Court is inclined to pass the
following order:
(i)
The first petitioner is directed to make claim to the
competent authority of the respondents 3 and 4 within
a period of two weeks from the date of receipt of a
copy of this order.
(ii)
Upon receipt of the claim, the competent authority of
the respondents 3 and 4 is directed to consider the
claim in accordance with law as expeditiously as
possible, preferably within a period of four weeks
thereafter.
(iii)
Till such time, the respondents 1 and 2 are directed
not to take any coercive action against the petitioners
for non-payment of the personal loan availed by the
deceased Yengkhokpam Surjit Singh.
[23]
With these observations and directions, the writ petition
stands disposed of. There will be no order as to costs.
ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE
NFR/FR
[[
John Kom
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review