Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.106 of 2024
Smt. Aparna Datta (Patari)
W/o Shri Ajit Patari, resident of village Ramendra Nagar, Madhya Para, P.O.
Chalitachari, Sabroom, South Tripura, Tripura-799145.
….Petitioner(s)
Versus
1. The State of Tripura
Represented by the Secretary, Social Welfare and Social Education,
Government of Tripura, Secretariat Building, New Capital Complex,
Agartala, West Tripura- 799010.
2. The Director
Social Welfare and Social Education Department, Government of Tripura,
Ujjan Abhoynagar, P.O. Abhoynagar, Agartala, West Tripura-799005.
3. The District Programme Officer (South)
SW & SE Department, Belonia, South Tripura, PIN-799155.
4. The Child Development Project Officer,
Satchand ICDS Project, P.O.- Satchand, South Tripura, Pin-799143.
….Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. D. Bhattacharya, Sr. Advocate
Mr. Samar Das, Advocate
Mr. S. Saha, Advocate
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. P. Gautam, Sr. G.A
Date of hearing &
Delivery of Judgment & Order :
16/12/2024
Whether fit for reporting
:
Yes
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
Heard Mr. D. Bhattacharya, learned senior counsel assisted by
Mr. S. Saha, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner. Also heard Mr. P.
Gautam, learned senior G.A appearing for the State-respondents.
2.
It is the case of the petitioner that under communication dated
16.01.2020 issued by the Child Development Project Officer, Satchand
ICDS Project, South Tripura, she was given engagement on temporary basis.
On the basis of said letter of engagement, she joined as Anganwadi
Worker/Helper at Purba Para AWC under Child Development Project
Officer, Satchand ICDS Project, South Tripura on 01.02.2020. Thereafter,
vide letter dated 16.03.2020 issued by the Child Development Project
Officer, the engagement of the petitioner was terminated on the ground that
she had misled or deceived the office by misrepresenting the fact in respect
of place of her residence.
3.
Challenging the termination order dated 16.03.2020, the
petitioner has filed the instant writ petition praying for setting aside the
same. For convenience, the termination order dated 16.03.2020 is
reproduced here-in-below, in extenso:“GOVERNMENT OF TRIPURA
OFFICE OF THE CHILD DEVELOPMENT PROJECT OFFICER
SATCHAND ICDS PROJECT, SOUTH TRIPURA
No. F.3(8)-ICDS/SAT/2018/1151(3)
Dated, Satchand 16/03/2020
To
Smt Aparna Datta (Patari)
W/O Ajit Patari
According to the report of the enquiry team constituted vide
Memo No No. F.3(8)-ICDS/SAT/2018/949(7) dated 11/02/2020, it has
been established that you have misrepresented facts regarding your
residence in your application for recruitment to the post of Anganwadi
Worker during the Interview of AWW/AWH undertaken by the office of
the undersigned vide advertisement memo No F.3(8)-ICDS/STC/201314/1184(25) dated 12/02/2019 by submitting documentation aimed to
mislead or deceive the office, and that you were not a resident of
'Indiranagar GP at the time of the interview.
The engagement letter explicitly mentions that 'any kind of
misrepresentation as to the applicant's age, marital status, place of
residence, qualification etc' shall be grounds for termination without any
explanation.
So, in view of the above findings and no evidence to prove the
contrary, your candidature for the post of Anganwadi Worker has been
deemed as invalid & accordingly your prayer for joining is hereby not
accepted by this office and your engagement as Anganwadi Worker vide
Memo No F.3(8)/ICDS/SAT/2017/742 dated 16/01/2020 is hereby
terminated as per the terms of your engagement.
Sd/Shyam SOUHARDYA CHAKRABORTY
CHILD DEVELOPMENT PROJECT OFFICER
SATCHAND ICDS PROJECT”
4.
On bare perusal of the said termination order dated 16.03.2020,
prima facie, it appears that the Child Development Project Officer having
gone through the report of the enquiry team, came to the conclusion that the
petitioner had misrepresented the place of her residence in her application,
submitted at the time of interview.
5.
Learned counsel for the petitioner has submitted that the
respondents without giving the petitioner any opportunity, most arbitrarily
and unilaterally cancelled the engagement of the petitioner on the ground of
misrepresenting/misleading the status of her residence.
6.
On the other hand, Mr. Gautam, learned senior G.A appearing
for the State-respondents has submitted that the petitioner is a resident of
Sabroom and not a resident of Indiranagar and further the eligibility criteria
prescribed in the revised guideline for engagement of Anganwadi
Worker/Helper does not permit her to be engaged as Anganwadi
Worker/Helper.
7.
I have gone through the records and also considered the
submissions of learned counsel appearing for the parties.
8.
Taking into account the factual background and the context of
the case at hand, following points fall for determination:
(i)
Whether Anganwadi Workers hold civil post?
(ii)
If a person does not hold civil post can claim the protection of
Article 31(2) of the Constitution of India?
8.1.
It appears that the Central Government has introduced a scheme
known as Integrated Child Development Scheme (ICDS Programme). The
said programme/scheme is funded by the Central Government. Its
applicability and implementation, however, has been shouldered upon the
respective States. The Anganwadi Workers (for short, „AWWs‟) and
Anganwadi Helpers (for short, „AWHs‟) are appointed from amongst the
local inhabitants, i.e. the place where the Anganwadi center is situated. The
Anganwadies were established at village or ward level. Thus, these are to be
run by AWWs or AWHs, and as per the scheme their engagements are made
to run various services at village or ward level. The selection of such
Anganwadi Workers or Helpers is to be made by a committee of officials
and non-officials at the project level. AWWs and AWHs do not hold any
statutory post under the State Government. Such workers are not engaged in
line of any recruitment rules framed under Article 309 of Constitution of
India. No selection process for appointment of AWWs and AWHs exists
within the Constitution scheme. They are engaged under the scheme, and
provision for honorarium was made for AWWs and AWHs. All the posts are
created in terms of the scheme on year to year basis. The objectives of the
said scheme are as under:
“(i) To improve the nutritional and health status of children in the age
group 0-6 years:
(ii). To lay the foundation for proper psychological, physical and
social development of the child;
(iii). To reduce the incidence of mortality, morbidity, malnutrition and
school drop out.
(iv). To enhance the capability of the mother to look after the normal
health and nutritional needs of the child through proper nutrition and
health education.”
9.
Furthermore, having gone through the definition of workmen as
defined under Section 2(s) of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, in my
opinion, the AWWs/AWHs do not come within the meaning of the
definition of Section 2(s) of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947. Similarly,
wages paid to such Anganwadi Workers/Helpers do not come within the
purview of Section 2 of Payment of Gratuity Act and the remuneration paid
to
the
Anganwadi
Workers/Helpers
can
be
said
to
merely
honorarium/stipend. Added to it, Anganwadi Workers/Helpers working
under the ICDS Programme/Scheme cannot be said to be “employee” as per
Section 2(e) of the Payment of Gratuity Act since ICDS scheme/project
cannot be said to be industry. The post „Anganwadi Workers‟ are not a
statutory post having created in terms of the scheme. It is one thing to say
that there exists a relation between an employer and employee by and
between the State and Anganwadi Workers, but, it is another thing to say
that they are holders of the civil post. While observed thus, the Supreme
Court categorically held that there cannot be any slightest doubt that
Anwanwadi Workers/Helpers play an extremely important role in their
respective villages. Here, I may profitably re-produce some of the
observations made by the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in State of Karnataka
and Ors. vs. Ameerbi and Ors. reported in (2007) 11 SCC 681 at para
Nos.28, 29, 31, 32, 33, 34, 35, 36, 38 and 39:“28. However, rules framed under proviso to Article 309 of the
Constitution of India are not attracted in the case of the respondents.
They are appointed under a scheme which is not of a permanent
nature, although might have continued for a long time.
29. Appointments made under a scheme and recruitment process
being carried out through a committee, in our opinion, would not
render the incumbents thereof holders of civil post. Our attention has
not been drawn to any rule or regulation governing the mode of their
recruitment. Some statements in this behalf have been made by the
interveners but for the reasons stated hereinbefore, we cannot enter
thereinto. A distinction must be made about a post created by the
Central Government or the State Governments in exercise of their
power under Articles 77 or 162 of the Constitution of India or under a
statute vis-à-vis cases of this nature which are sui generis. Terms and
conditions of services of an employee may be referable to Acts of
appropriate legislature. The matter may also come within the purview
of Article 309 of the Constitution of India as proviso appended thereto
confers power upon the President or the Governor of a State or other
authority, who may be delegated with such power, to make rules
during the interregnum.
31. One of the questions which was raised before us was in regard to
the right of an anganwadi worker to contest an election. They are
indisputably free to do so. A holder of a civil post may not be entitled
thereto.
32. In Satrucharla Chandrasekhar Raju v. Vyricherla Pradeep Kumar
Dev [(1992) 4 SCC 404] this Court while considering the provisions
of Article 191(1)(a) of the Constitution of India in relation to the posts
held by the employees of an Integrated Tribal Development Agency
opined that their employees would not be holder of an office of profit
although the State exercises control thereover holding: (SCC pp. 42728, para 28)
“28. It is also necessary to bear in mind that the Government
is undertaking several projects and activities including
commercial activities through the corporations and local
bodies exercising some control over such corporations or
bodies. In that view of the matter they may come within the
meaning of the „State‟ envisaged in Article 12 but that may not
be a decisive factor in deciding the issue. As a matter of fact,
Section 10 of the Representation of the People Act as well as
Article 58(2) of the Constitution of India do indicate that all
persons employed in such undertakings, corporations or local
bodies cannot be deemed to suffer disqualification for
contesting the elections except to the extent indicated therein.
This aspect also has been considered in some of the
abovementioned decisions. If a strict and narrow construction
is to be applied that amounts to shutting off many prominent
and other eligible persons to contest the elections which forms
the fundamental basis for the democratic set-up. Therefore
several factors as indicated above depending upon the facts of
each case have to be taken into consideration in deciding
whether a particular person is disqualified by virtue of his
holding an office of profit before concluding that such an office
is under the Government.”
33. The decision, therefore, is an authority for the proposition that
those employees who come within the meaning of Article 12 of the
Constitution of India are not necessarily government servants. A
fortiori the State in terms of a scheme may exercise control over a
section of the persons working but thereby only, they do not become
entitled to protection under Article 311 of the Constitution of India.
34. Reference to the provisions of the Minimum Wages Act, in our
opinion, is also not apposite. The said Act is applicable to the
workmen working in the industries specified therein. It is not the case
of the respondents that the icds Programme would constitute an
“industry” or anganwadi workers are industrial workmen. There
cannot be any doubt whatsoever that it is one thing to say that the
State would be liable to pay minimum wages irrespective of its
financial constraints but it is another thing to say that as to whether
such a claim can be raised in respect of those who are working under
a project. It is not a case where the concept of minimum wage, living
wage or fair wage can be brought in service.
35. Different tests applied even for determining the relationship of
employer and employee have recently been noticed by this Court in
District Rehabilitation Officer v. Jay Kishore Maity [(2006) 12 SCC
380 : (2007) 1 SCC (L&S) 953 : (2006) 11 Scale 545] . In that case,
in almost similar project, the employees appointed by the District
Rehabilitation Centre claimed themselves to be the Central
Government employees. Each case, therefore, has to be considered on
its own merits.
36. This Court cannot determine a lis only on sympathy.
38. It is also not a case where the doctrine of parity of employment
can be invoked. It is true that nomenclature of a term of payment is
not decisive but the substance is as was held in Jaya Bachchan v.
Union of India [(2006) 5 SCC 266] but the question has to be
determined having regard to the issue involved. We are concerned
herein with only one question viz. whether the respondents are
holders of any civil post. We are, having regard to the materials on
record, of the view that they are not.
39. Keeping in view the facts and circumstances of this case, we are of
the opinion that the Tribunal has no jurisdiction to entertain the
application. The appeals are allowed accordingly. No costs.”
9.1.
On bare perusal of the analysis made by the Supreme Court in
Ameerbi (supra), it is crystal clear that Anganwadi Workers do not hold any
statutory post under the statute, though a relationship of an employer and
employee exists. In the context, an example given is of the entitlement of the
Anganwadi Workers to contest an election which an employee/holder of
civil post may not be entitled to[Ref: Para 31]. Placing reliance being placed
upon the case of Satrucharla Chandrasekhar Raju vs. Vyricherla Pradeep
Kumar Dev [(1992) 4 SCC 404] Hon‟ble Supreme Court observed that the
employees who come within the meaning of Article 12 of the Constitution of
India are not necessarily Government Servants. Even the reference to the
provisions of Minimum Wages Act, 1948 has been held to be not apposite as
the same applies to workmen working in the industries. The ICDS scheme
would not constitute an industry nor the Anganwadi Workers as industrial
workmen, as I said earlier. Thus, the case of Ameerbi (supra) is squarely
covered to the facts and the question raised while deciding the present writ
petition.
9.2.
The question as regards the status of AWWs and AWHs was
posed before the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in Ameerbi (supra). In the said
case also, Anganwadi workers were appointed under the same ICDS
Scheme/project/programme who had filed an application under Section 15 of
the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985. While dealing with the question of
maintainability, the Supreme Court held that the post of Anganwadi Workers
was not a statutory post and their selection/recruitment process was not
governed by the Constitution or any statute and thus the application was not
maintainable. Hon‟ble Apex Court specifically held that ICDS programme
would neither constitute an “industry” nor Anganwadi Workers are
“industrial workmen”.
10.
This Court while dealing with a similar question and concept of
civil post in the case of Sri Biswajit Nandi vs. Sri Ratan Das and 4 Ors.
[WA No.174 of 2022] held as under:“12.
In a similar matter, one of the learned Single
Judge of this Bench (A. Lodh, J), while disposing the case of Sri
Shyamapada Pal(supra) observed that “It is settled proposition
of law that a person having not held civil post cannot seek
mandamus or the court cannot exercise its discretionary and
extra-ordinary jurisdiction, as enshrined under Article 226 of
the Constitution of India. The petitioner may claim
compensation in an appropriate forum, if he feels that
illegalities have been committed towards him by the
respondents.”
13.
It is no longer res integra that in the context of
Articles 309, 310 and 311, a post denotes an office. A person
who holds a civil post under a State holds “office” during the
pleasure of the Governor of the State, except as expressly
provided by the Constitution. A post under the State is an office
or a position to which duties in connection with the affairs of
the State are attached, an office or a position to which a person
is appointed and which may exist apart from and independently
of the holder of the post. Again, a post is an employment, but
every employment is not a post. A casual labourer is not the
holder of a post. A post under the State means a post under the
administrative control of the State.[Ref: The State of Assam
and Ors. vs. Kanak Chandra Dutta, AIR 1967 SC 884(FiveJudge Bench)]”
11.
The status of such Anganwadi Workers who are appointed
under the ICDS Programme/project has been considered by the Hon'ble
Supreme Court in the case of Ameerbi (supra). Considering the object and
purpose of scheme/project and staff pattern for ICDS Project the Hon‟ble
Supreme Court held that the Anganwadi Workers do not hold civil post.
12.
I have also seriously considered the expressions and views of a
Division Bench of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court [comprising of Mr. Justice
Ajay Rastogi, J. (Retd.) and Abhay S. Oka, J.] in the case of Maniben
Maganbhai Bhariya v. District Development Officer Dahod and Ors.,
reported in 2022 SCC OnLine SC 507. I am trying to reconcile the issues
raised in the cases of Ameerbi (supra) and Maniben Maganbhai Bhariya
(supra).
13.
The case of Maniben Maganbhai Bhariya (supra), which is a
later decision of the Supreme Court, deals with the entitlement of the benefit
of gratuity of Anganwadi workers/Helpers (for short, „AWWs/AWHs‟)
under the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1772 vis-à-vis, the Government of the
State of Gujarat resolution dated 25.11.2019 dealing with the issue of
extending the benefit of gratuity to the AWWs/AWHs. The Supreme Court
in the case of Maniben Maganbhai Bhariya (supra) held that to achieve the
object of Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972, hereinafter referred to as („Act,
1972) and the Gujarat Government resolution dated 25.11.2019, the
AWWs/AWHs are entitled to gratuity since it comes within the definition of
„establishment‟ as emphasized under sub-Section(2) of Section 4 of the Act,
1972. To resolve the issue raised in Maniben Maganbhai Bhariya (supra),
the Supreme court held that Gujarat Government in its resolution dated
25.11.2019 categorically lays down exhaustive provisions regarding
selection criteria, duties, disciplinary action, rules, etc. in respect of AWWs
and AWHs and in fact, under the resolution, the Gujarat Government has
framed the „Anganwadi worker/helper [Selection Criteria, Honorary Service,
Review and Discipline (rules)]‟. To say it otherwise, the Supreme Court in
the case of Maniben Maganbhai Bhariya (supra) held that the Gujarat
Government has come up with a statutory rule to govern the recruitment and
service conduct of the AWWs/AWHs. The relevant paragraph of the
judgment of Maniben Maganbhai Bhariya (supra) may be reproduced
hereunder, for convenience, in extenso:
“67. Now, coming to the State of Gujarat, the
Government Resolution dated 25th November, 2019 (Annexure
A-1 of IA no.161608 of 2021) lays down exhaustive provisions
regarding selection criteria, duties, disciplinary action, rules,
etc. in respect of AWWs and AWHs. In fact, by the said
Resolution, the State Government has framed the Anganwadi
Worker/Helper (Selection Criteria, Honorary Service, Review
and Discipline) Rules (for short “the said Rules”). Duties of
AWWs and AWHs have been laid down in Appendix-1 to the
Government Resolution. ...…………”
14.
Having taken note of the case of Ameerbi (supra), the Supreme
Court in Maniben Maganbhai Bhariya (supra) has observed that in the case
of Ameerbi (supra), the court dealt with the issues whether AWWs and
AWHs hold civil post and whether the original applications filed by AWWs
before the State Tribunal establishment under the Administrative Tribunals
Act, 1985 were maintainable, where it was held that the post of AWWs was
not statutory post and the same has been created in terms of ICDS.
Therefore, there was no relationship of employer and employee between the
State Government and the AWWs. In the case of Maniben Maganbhai
Bhariya (supra), the Supreme Court did not disturb the legal principle laid
down in the case of Ameerbi (supra) that the AWWs/AWHs do not hold
civil post and as such, their services are not protected by Article 311 of the
Constitution of India.
15.
Further, the Supreme Court in the case of Maniben Maganbhai
Bhariya (supra) declared the Anganwadi centres as “establishment”
considering the fact that Anganwadi centres are performing the statutory
duty of implementing provisions of Sections 4, 5 and 6 of the National Food
Security Act, 2013 (for short, „the Act of 2013‟). The Division Bench of the
Supreme Court ultimately held that since the issues raised in both the cases
are different, the legal principle and the decision of the Supreme Court in
Ameerbi (supra) have no bearing in the issue involved in Maniben
Maganbhai Bhariya (supra). Having held so, the Division Bench of the
Supreme Court in Maniben Maganbhai Bhariya (supra) held that
considering that Anganwadi centres come under the purview of the
definition of „establishment‟ under the Payment of Gratuity Act,
AWWs/AWHs are entitled to payment of gratuity.
16.
On reconciliation of the issues raised in the cases of Maniben
Maganbhai Bhariya (supra) and Ameerbi (supra), I find that Government
of Tripura has not framed any rules governing the recruitment and service
conduct of the AWWs/AWHs. In the case at hand, the issue raised does not
relate to extending the benefit of gratuity to the AWWs/AWHs. Here, the
engagement of the petitioner as an Anganwadi was terminated on the ground
that she had misled or deceived the office by way of misrepresenting the
fact. By means of filing the instant writ petition, the petitioner sought for a
protection under Article 311 of the Constitution, which is available to a
person employed to any civil service of the State or to holders of any civil
post under the State. Having found that AWWs/AWHs do not hold civil
post, the learned Central Administrative Tribunal (for short, „CAT‟) held
that the writ petition filed by Ameerbi (supra) was not maintainable, which
was affirmed ultimately by Supreme Court. In the instant case also, the
petitioner being an Anganwadi worker has approached this court under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India claiming protection under Article
311 of the Constitution. I have already held that since AWWs/AWHs do not
hold civil post and there is no direct relation between the petitioner and the
State, the instant writ petition is not maintainable.
17.
According to me, it would not be wise to lose sight of the
nature of employment of Anganwadi Workers/Helpers as their employment
is made in terms of the ICDS scheme/project/programme. The
conditionalities of their employments are to be governed by the said ICDS
scheme. No regular pay scale is prescribed for AWWs/AWHs since the
Government of India while framing the scheme was very clear that they are
required to provide part-time assistance. Working hours also are different
from a daily wager. As a matter of re-iteration, no educational qualification
is also required to get employed as either Anganwadi Worker or Helper.
Thus, the modes of providing honorarium/stipend to the Anganwadi
Workers/Helpers cannot be faulted. To conclude, I, in no manner, want to
disregard the valuable service/assistance extended by such Anganwadi
Workers/Helpers to the system. Thus, the question that was formulated for
determination in the present writ petition is answered that the Anganwadi
Workers/Helpers are not holders of any civil post.
18.
Another important feature in the instant writ petition is that the
engagement of the writ petitioner does not prescribe any definite rate of pay,
which is one of the essential components for a post in any service as also
held by the Hon‟ble Apex Court. There is no exhaustive recruitment rule
framed by the Government of Tripura to recruit the AWWs/AWHs.
Recruitment rules ordinarily applicable to the employees of the State are not
applicable in the case of Anganwadi workers. The State is not required to
comply with the constitutional scheme of equality as adumbrated under
Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India. No process of selection for
the purpose of their appointment within the constitutional scheme exists
alike the case of Maniben Maganbhai Bhariya (supra) as narrated here-inabove.
19.
Coming to the prayers made in the present writ petition, the
petitioner has been terminated for suppression of her actual place of
residence. However, according to the petitioner she was not given a
reasonable opportunity to represent her case. In the opinion of this Court,
suppression of material information and/or giving false information will not
entail a person to take the plea of violation of principles of natural justice. It
is also settled proposition that if an appointment/engagement is procured by
fraudulent means, the incumbent may be terminated without holding any
enquiry, however, it is also equally true that in case an employee is
confirmed, holding a civil post and has protection under Article 311(2) of
the Constitution of India, due enquiry has to be held before terminating the
service of such employee. In the instant case, it is already held that
AWWs/AWHs being not the holders of civil post, their services are not
protected under Article 311(2) of the Constitution of India. Applying the
aforesaid principle, challenge of the petitioner that her engagement was
terminated without a full-fledged enquiry is not tenable in law, though in the
instant case, her engagement was terminated after an enquiry made by an
enquiry team. From the termination order itself, it appears that before
issuance of the order of termination dated 16.03.2023, the Child
Development Project Officer(CDPO) had made a thorough enquiry through
an enquiry team and then came to the conclusion that the petitioner had
misrepresented the status of her residence in her application submitted at the
time of interview. In this circumstance, in my opinion, the State is not
required to comply with the Constitutional scheme of equality as
adumbrated under Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution [Ref: Ameerbi
(supra), pp. 688, 689, para 20] since the petitioner does not hold any civil
post.
20.
As it is already held, in the instant case, the petitioner, having
not held civil post, cannot seek mandamus or, in other words, cannot ask the
court to exercise its discretionary and extra-ordinary jurisdiction as
embodied in Article 226 of the Constitution of India.
21.
By now it is well established that principles of natural justice
cannot be put into a straight jacket formula. Its application will depend upon
the fact and circumstances of each case. In the case of Sohan Lal Gupta &
Ors. vs. Asha Devi Gupta & Ors., (2003) 7 SCC 492, the Hon‟ble Supreme
Court upon noticing a large number of decisions held thus: (SCC p.506, para
29).
“29. The principles of natural justice, it is trite, cannot be put in a straitjacket
formula. In a given case the party should not only be required to show that he
did not have a proper notice resulting in violation of principles of natural
justice but also to show that he was seriously prejudiced thereby. In Chairman,
Board of Mining Examination and Chief Inspector of Mines v. Ramjee [(1977) 2
SCC 256 : 1977 SCC (L&S) 226] this Court held: (SCC p. 262, para 13)
“Natural justice is no unruly horse, no lurking land mine, nor a judicial
cure-all. If fairness is shown by the decision-maker to the man proceeded
against, the form, features and the fundamentals of such essential
processual propriety being conditioned by the facts and circumstances of
each situation, no breach of natural justice can be complained of.
Unnatural expansion of natural justice, without reference to the
administrative realities and other factors of a given case, can be
exasperating. We can neither be finical nor fanatical but should be flexible
yet firm in this jurisdiction. No man shall be hit below the belt — that is
the conscience of the matter.”
(See also Union of India v. Anand Kumar Pandey [(1994) 5 SCC 663 : 1994 SCC
(L&S) 1235 : (1994) 28 ATC 165] and R.S. Dass v. Union of India [1986 Supp
SCC 617 : (1987) 2 ATC 628] .)”
22.
In the case at hand, the Officer concerned had constituted an
enquiry team to enquire about the actual place of residence of the petitioner
which she disclosed at the time of interview. The enquiry team after making
thorough enquiry furnished the report to the said concerned officer. Only
thereafter, the competent authority came to a conclusion that the petitioner
suppressed material information about the actual place of her residence. As
per the ICDS Scheme, an Anganwadi worker must be a resident of the place
where she is to work. In this circumstance, in my opinion, issuance of formal
notice would have been an empty formality. The petitioner failed to
demonstrate or explain how the non-issuance of formal notice resulted in
any prejudice to her.
23.
In view of the aforesaid well-weigh principles, I find no merit
in the instant writ petition to exercise the Court‟s discretionary and
extraordinary jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.
However, the petitioner may file appropriate suit claiming compensation if
she is aggrieved of any action/order of the respondents.
24.
For the reasons stated and discussed here-in-above, the instant
writ petition stands dismissed. However, there shall be no order as to costs.
JUDGE
Rohit
Digitally signed
SANJAY
SANJAY by
GHOSH
2025.03.18
GHOSH Date:
17:27:46 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review