Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT I N D O R E
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE SUSHRUT ARVIND
DHARMADHIKARI
&
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE DEVNARAYAN MISHRA
ON THE 8th OF JANUARY, 2024
FIRST APPEAL No. 381 of 2021
BETWEEN:SMT. ANU @ ANUSUIYA W/O SHRI MANISH
DHABHAI, AGED ABOUT 42 YEARS, OCCUPATION:
HOUSEWIFE 97/4, DILIP MARG, GRAM SELANA
(MADHYA PRADESH)
.....APPELLANT
(BY SHRI A.K.CHITALE - SENIOR ADVOCATE WITH SHRI ABHIMANYU
SANAP - ADVOCATE)
AND
SHRI
MANISH
DHABHAI
S/O
LATE
SHRI
CHANDRAMOHAN DHABHAI, AGED ABOUT 46
YEARS, OCCUPATION: AGRICULTURE 97/4, DILIP
MARG, GRAM SELANA (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENT
(BY SHRI AJAY BAGADIA – SENIOR ADVOCATE WITH SHRI RITU RAJ
BHATNAGAR - ADVOCATE)
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
This appeal coming on for hearing this day, Justice Devnarayan
Mishra passed the following:
ORDER
This first appeal under Section 19(1) of the Family Courts Act,
Signed by: VARSHA SINGH
Signing time: 18/01/2024
4:54:27 PM
-2-
1984 has been preferred being aggrieved by the judgment and decree
passed by Principal Judge, Family Court, Ratlam, District – Ratlam (M.P.)
in RCS HM/171/2017 dated 13.03.2021 by which the petition of the
respondent for dissolution of marriage has been allowed and the marriage
solemnized between the parties on 25.02.2003 has been dissolved.
With the consent of learned counsel for both the parties, the
appeal is heard finally at motion stage.
02.
Brief facts of the case are that the marriage between appellant and
the respondent was solemnized on 25.02.2003 as per Hindu Rites and
Customs. The applicant/respondents' mother was living with him and her
sister was residing at America. After sometime of the marriage, the
behavior of the wife became cruel towards him. She was not properly
behaving with his mother and ill-treating her. She was alleging that the
applicant/respondent has illicit relations with other women. Due to her
cruel behavior, the mother of the respondent has left the joint family
residence and started living with her daughter in America.
The non-
applicant/wife lodged the false report as Crime No.236/2016 under Section
498-A of IPC against the husband and his mother. Regarding the cruel
treatment of wife, the husband has filed the written complaints on
13.05.2017 to Station House Officer, Police Station Sailana, on 16.05.2017
to Superintend of Police, Ratlam, on 22.05.2017 to Police Station Sailana
and on 23.05.2017 before Mahila Thana, Ratlam. The applicant/husband'
friend has also filed the various reports against the wife.
The non-
applicant/wife has also made false and obscene comments regarding his
friends, she has also made a complaint in CM Helpline against him and on
an
enquiry
the
complaint
was
found
false.
The
non-
applicant/appellant/wife pressurized the applicant/respondent/husband to
Signed by: VARSHA SINGH
Signing time: 18/01/2024
4:54:27 PM
-3-
transfer the house and agricultural land in her name and when he was made
to understand the situation, she used to scream loudly going out of the
house and created a scene in front of everyone. She has also implanted spy
device in his car to trace his activities. On 21.05.2017, the nonapplicant/appellant by consuming poison attempted to suicide.
Since,
May, 2015 the wife has withdrawn from his company, so the marriage
solemnized between the parties be dissolved.
03.
The non-applicant/appellant/wife in her reply has denied the
allegations and stated that the applicant/respondent/husband and her
mother were treating her with cruelty and were demanding dowry, so he
has lodged the FIR. The matter is pending in the Criminal Court. The
applicant/husband was assaulting her and levelling false allegations against
her
and
he
was
calling
her
sterile
(Banjh).
The
applicant/respondent/husband was regularly consuming liquor and coming
late night home, was abusing and beating her and making pressure for his
second marriage. The non-applicant/appellant/wife was pursuing him not
to consume liquor and womanize and when the husband has not stopped
doing the same, she has filed a complaint before the police officers and
also filed a complaint in CM Helpline. The husband and his friends have
made false report against her. On 21.05.2017, the respondent/husband has
beaten her and thrown out her from matrimonial home and thus he was
constantly
presurrizing
her
to
commit
suicide.
The
applicant/respondent/husband himself has deprived her from the
matrimonial relations to make the ground for divorce.
The non-
applicant/appellant/wife is ready and willing to live with her husband.
04.
In additional reply, she has further pleaded that after marriage no
issue was born to her and when she requested for treatment, the husband
Signed by: VARSHA SINGH
Signing time: 18/01/2024
4:54:27 PM
-4-
has not provided her the treatment and constantly tortured her after
consuming liquor. He was also doubting on her character.
He was
constantly saying that he shall marry with another woman and for that
purpose he has filed his petition so that he can get married with another
woman.
He
has
also
lodged
false
report
agaisnt
her.
The
applicant/respondent/husband is not entitled for the decree of divorce,
hence, the petition be dismissed.
05.
On the above pleadings, the trial Court has framed the issue
regarding the cruelty, dissertation and after recording the evidence of the
parties has passed the impugned judgment.
06.
I.A.No.1361/2022, an application under section 25-(B) of Hindu
Marriage Act is dismissed as matter is being finally decided.
07.
Heard on I.A.No.8515/2023, an application filed under Order 41
Rule 27 of the CPC by the appellant/wife.
By the aforesaid application, the appellant has submitted certain
photographs of respondent's mother with her daughter's child.
Heard on the application.
08.
The appellant has not produced these documents during the
evidence without any reason. She has not disclosed why the documents
were not filed during the trial, without fulfilling the conditions enumerated
in Order 41 Rule 27 of the CPC the application was filed. Therefore, in
view of the above and the grounds necessary, application cannot be
allowed. Hence,
I.A.No.8515/2023 being devoid of merit hereby
dismissed.
09.
The respondent/husband/Manish has also filed an application
under Order 41 Rule 27 of the CPC as I.A.No.9980/2023 on the ground
that the judgment in the instant case has been passed on 13.03.2021 on the
Signed by: VARSHA SINGH
Signing time: 18/01/2024
4:54:27 PM
-5-
FIR lodged by the non-applicant/appellant/wife under Section 498-A of
IPC in Police Station, Sailana, Ratlam, not fulfilling the conditions
enumerated in Order 41 Rule 27 of the charge-sheet was filed and case
was registered as RCT No.186/2017. During the pendency of the appeal,
the Criminal Court have passed the judgment in RCT No.186/2017 and by
that the respondent – Manish has been acquitted for the offence under
Section 498-A of the IPC by the judgment, so the judgment of the Criminal
Court be taken on record.
Heard the parties and perused the record.
10.
This document is relevant and it is admitted that the appellant/wife
has lodged the FIR under Section 498-A of the IPC as Crime No.236/2016
and the judgment has been passed after passing of the decree i.e. on
26/07.2022 thus document came into existence after passing of the decree
and is relevant, hence, the I.A.No.9980/2023 is allowed and the additional
document is taken on record.
11.
Shri A.K. Chitale, learned senior counsel for the appellant has
argued that the matrimonial life was peaceful and happy and the appellant
has never make any quarrel or treated with cruelty to the respondent or his
mother or sister that is the reason the grandfather of the respondent has
made a will in favour of the non-applicant/appellant/wife. The relationship
between the appellant and respondent soured after the death of the
grandfather and father of Manish. As Manish came in contact with his
friends and in the evil company of his friends, respondent -Manish started
drinking liquor and spending out late night and when the appellant – Anu
objected, Manish started beating and maltreating his wife. Appellant Anu
could not conceive despite treatment. So he was also being treated with
cruelty. All the complaints filed by the Manish were after 02.08.2016. The
Signed by: VARSHA SINGH
Signing time: 18/01/2024
4:54:27 PM
-6-
applicant/respondent/husband himself started living separately with his
wife Anu and abundant her wife.
12.
Shri Chitale has further argued that being harassed by the conduct
of the respondent/husband, she has lodged the FIR and made complaints to
police authorities.
She has not levelled any allegations against her
husband. Manish himself want to remarry with other woman and to made
the grounds of divorce has filed the complaints to Police Officials and by
the help of his friends lodged false report against her wife.
13.
There is no case of cruelty as applicant/respondent's mother went
to USA to take case of her daughter's children because her daughter and
her husband were working and false grounds have been created.
14.
In support of his contention learned counsel for the appellant has
relied on the judgments in the case of Ravinder Kaur Vs. Manjeet Singh
(2019) 8 SCC 308, Vinod Kumar Subbaih Vs. Saraswathi Palaniappan
(2015) 8 SCC 336, K. Srinivas Rao Vs. D.A Deepa (2013) 5 SCC 226,
Vishwanath Agrawal Vs. Sarla Vishwananth Agrawal (2012) 7 SCC 288,
Pankaj Mahajan Vs. Dimple @ Kajal (2011) 12 SCC 1, Gurbux Singh
Vs. Harminder Kaur (2010) 14 SCC 301, Neelam Kumar Vs. Dayarani
(2010) 13 SCC 298, Suman Kapur Vs. Sudhir Kapur (2009) 1 SCC 422,
Mayadevi Vs. Jagdish (2007) 3 SCC 136, Naveen Kohli Vs. Neelu Kohli
(2006) 4 SCC 558, Lavanya Vs. Chiranjeevi (2005) 11 SCC 194, A.
Jayachandra Vs. Aneel Kaur (2005) 2 SCC 22, V. Bhagat Vs. D. Bhagat
(1994) 1 SCC 337 and Shobha Rani Vs. Madhukar Reddi (1988) 1 SCC
105 and filed the written synopsis.
15.
Learned counsel for the respondent has submitted that he is not
pursuing the ground of alleged post on facebook as a certificate under
Section 65-B of Evidence Act has not been filed, so he has conceded the
Signed by: VARSHA SINGH
Signing time: 18/01/2024
4:54:27 PM
-7-
ground of attack on the basis of post of facebook, transcript and recording
submitted before the trial Court exhibited as Annexure P/6 & P/7.
16.
Thus, this Court shall not consider the facebook post and
recording submitted by the respondent before the trial Court and the
transcript thereof.
17.
Learned counsel for the respondent has argued that the
respondent's wife was ill-treating the applicant/husband and her mother-inlaw. She has lodged the false report against her husband and mother-inlaw. At that time the mother-in-law of the appellant was residing in USA
with her daughter and in that case, the police has not filed Challan against
the mother-in-law of the appellant and the respondent has been acquitted
by the trial Court by the judgment dated 26.07.2022 passed in RCT
No.186/2017. The appellant/wife was levelling false allegation of illicit
relation of husband with other women. She was levelling the charges of
womanizing and constantly consuming liquor. She has tried to commit
suicide by consuming poison.
18.
It is further argued that the appellant/wife was quarreling with the
respondent's friends and their family members and has made complaint on
CM Helpline that was found false. All the acts of the respondent's wife
constitute the cruelty.
19.
The appellant/wife has deserted from the society of her husband
and residing separately for more than two years before filing of the
petition. The trial Court after due appreciation of the evidence passed the
judgment in which she has been awarded alimony of 10 Lakhs. The
judgment and decree are as per law. No interference is called for, hence,
the appeal be dismissed.
20.
Signed by: VARSHA SINGH
Signing time: 18/01/2024
4:54:27 PM
Learned counsel for the respondent has relied on the judgment of
-8-
Apex Court passed in the case of Rani Narasimha Sastry Vs. Rani
Suneela Rani passed in C.A. No.8871 of 2019 (S.L.P. (C ) No.1981 of
2019) decided on 19.11.2019.
21.
First of all, in this case as per the respondent Manish (PW-1) in
paragraph no.31 of statement has stated that he is not residing in
matrimonial home until appellant/wife left the matrimonial home he was
residing at Sailana and was doing farming. At present he is doing farming
on Adhbatai and he has stated that he cannot disclose where he is presently
residing. From his statement it does not appear that the appellant/wife has
left the matrimonial house or she is residing separately as she is residing in
Sailana and the husband himself has left the matrimonial home. So, the
ground of dissertation is not proved.
22.
Regarding the cruelty, the applicant/husband has pleaded that the
appellant was making quarrel with the mother of the respondent and due to
her ill-treatment, she left the Sailana and is residing at USA with
respondent's sister. On this point if we appreciate the evidence of the
parties it is clear that the respondent's sister since marriage was residing
with her husband in USA. Both of them were working there and they have
two issues and in that scenario if the mother is residing at USA it cannot be
said that she is residing due to ill-treatment of appellant/wife.
23.
On the other grounds, the respondent/husband has pleaded that the
wife was having doubt that he is having illicit relations with other women.
On this point, the respondent/husband has corroborated this fact in his
examination-in-chief and in paragraph no.23 of cross-examination certain
questions have been put through the appellant/wife and name of certain
women have been mentioned and in paragraph 24 of the cross this have
been asked that if husband is roaming with other women, the wife shall
Signed by: VARSHA SINGH
Signing time: 18/01/2024
4:54:27 PM
-9-
take objection. It has also been asked that he was consuming liquor
regularly.
24.
The respondent's wife (NAW-1) in her examination-in-chief has
stated that the appellant's husband was regularly consuming liquor and illtreating her and in her cross-examination he has stated that her husband is
having illicit relations with other women and in para no.30 when she was
asked regarding illicit relations, she has replied that she personally knew
the woman, with whom her husband is having relation and she has
disclosed the names of 2 ladies and when she was told in that one is
relative and other is wife of her cousin brother, he has not explained
properly.
25.
Thus, it is clear that the wife was having doubt on fidelity of the
husband and she was alleging that her husband is having illicit relations
with other women and was regularly consuming liquor and by her
suggestion in evidence it had not been recognized but not proved.
26.
It is admitted fact that the appellant has lodged the FIR regarding
cruelty (Ex.D-2) on 4.8.2016 alleging that her mother in law and husband
are assaulting her and trying to drive him out from the matrimonial home
and want Talaq and on 01.08.2016 at around 04:00 pm mother-in-law and
husband has beaten her.
27.
On this point when she was asked she has admitted that she has
lodged the FIR on 04.08.2016 and Police has not filed charge-sheet against
the mother-in-law and as per the judgment of the trial Court in RCT
No.186/2016,
the
Judicial
Magistrate,
Sailana
has
acquitted
respondent/husband.
28.
Thus, the conclusion be drawn that the alleged report (Ex.D/2)
was false and baseless that is why police has not filed charge-sheet against
Signed by: VARSHA SINGH
Signing time: 18/01/2024
4:54:27 PM
-10-
his mother and the trial Court has acquitted the respondent/husband.
29.
Regarding the attempt to suicide, the respondent/husband in his
examination-in-chief has clearly stated that on 21.05.2017, the
appellant/wife tried to commit suicide by consuming poison and when he
came to know, he called the police by dialing 100 and the Police carried
the appellant/wife to hospital and admitted there. He also went with the
police. On this point after paragraph no.34 of the cross-examination, the
question was asked by the respondent's wife, due to the ill-treatment of
husband she done so. In this reply, the husband has further stated that he
did not remember the date but in the night, the appellant/wife has stated
that she is consuming poison and on that he called the police by dialing
108 and police took his wife to sailana hospital and for 3 hours she was
kept in observation. Dr. told that she has not consumed the poison.
30.
On this point, when the appellant Anu was cross-examined she has
stated that the husband himself administered the poison forcefully. She has
also not filed any complaint to the police regarding that and further stated
that the appellant/husband himself called the police by dialing 100 and
police came and took her to hospital and left her in hospital. She was
admitted in hospital at 08:00 pm till 03:00 am and after that she went her
home.
31.
The respondent's wife has alleged that the husband has not make
treated her regarding infertility and the husband has stated that he made
treated her wife in Ratlam, Fertility Center Udaipur and Baroda but she did
not conceive and when this fact was asked to the appellant/wife she has
admitted that her husband make treated her at Ratlam after that in Baroda
Hospital and after that in Udipur Hospital and after the treatment she did
not conceive. She has further stated that she conceived but at that time the
Signed by: VARSHA SINGH
Signing time: 18/01/2024
4:54:27 PM
-11-
respondent's mother and sister treated her with cruelty, so the pregnancy
was aborted.
32.
Thus, on material point regarding the ill-treatment, she has falsely
stated that she was not cared.
33.
The respondent/husband has exhibited the documents Ex.-P/1 to
Ex.-P/5 regarding the conduct of his wife in the various police stations and
witness Rajesh (AW-2) has stated that the appellant/wife came to his home
and ill-treated with him, abused him and threatened him that she will kill
him and he made complaint to the Police as Ex.8 & 9. The witness
Ranjana Bakwal (AW-3) has also stated the same fact that on 20.12.2016
by calling through phone, the appellant has abused him and uttered
obscene words and threatened him and she has also lodged report (Ex.-P/7)
to Police Station Sailana.
34.
From Exhibit-P/2 to P/5 excluding the document Ex.P/6 and
Ex.P/7 that has not been admitted as it is not being supported by Section
65-B of the Evidence Act from the Ex.P/1 it is clear that on 13.05.2017,
appellant/wife went to the shop of Rajesh Rathore (AW-2) and abused to
the friends of the respondent/husband. As per Ex.P/2, on 16.05.2017 Police
Ratlam tried to solve the matter through conciliation but failed to do the
same. The husband as Ex.P/3 has filed the application regarding his wife in
Jansunwai to S.P. Ratlam and he has complained regarding the conduct of
wife as per Ex.P/4 to SHO, Police Station Sailana and SHO, Mahila Thana.
35.
The applicant/respondent's wife has also filed the complaint
against her husband in CM Helpline. When she was asked the
appellant/non-applicant Anu (DW-1) in para no.18 of her statement was
specifically asked that she herself have stated that sex racket is being
operated from the shop where the husband is sitting and specifically by
Signed by: VARSHA SINGH
Signing time: 18/01/2024
4:54:27 PM
-12-
saying the name of Rajesh Rathore (AW-2) she has stated that sex racket
was being operating by the shop of Rajesh Rathore and she has made the
police complaint regarding5 this. From her statement, it is clear that she
went to the shop of Rajesh Rathore and made quarrel there. She has also
admitted that she has filed the complaint in CM Helpline and she has filed
the application (Ex.D/3) in Jansunwai. The complaint of the CM Helpline
is Exhibited as Ex.D/4 and she has also lodged the Police report on
12.08.2016.
36.
Thus, from the above discussion it is clear that the appellant/wife
made false complaint against husband and her mother-in-law. She made
false allegations against the husband that he is having illicit relation with
other women and he is regularly consuming liquor and after that illtreating with her. She has also levelled the allegations that he was harassed
for the demand of dowry.
She was not being properly treated and
attempted to suicide.
37.
As per the judgment of the Apex Court in the case of
Rani
Narasimha Sastry (supra) it is held that :It is true that it is open for anyone to file complaint
or lodge prosecution for redressal for his or her
grievances and lodge a first information report for
an offence also and mere lodging of complaint or
FIR cannot ipso facto be treated as cruelty. But
when a person undergoes a trial in which he is
acquitted of the allegation of offence under Section
498-A of IPC, levelled by the wife against the
husband, it cannot be accepted that no cruelty has
meted on the husband.
38.
The act of the wife lodging false report and acquittal of the
respondent/applicant under Section 498-A of the IPC, levelled false
allegations against her husband and making her reputation bad to attempt
Signed by: VARSHA SINGH
Signing time: 18/01/2024
4:54:27 PM
-13-
suicide itself constitute the cruelty.
39.
On the point of cruelty, learned counsel for the appellant relied on
the various judgments passed by the Apex Court, which are as under:(a) In the case of Ravinder Kaur (supra), in short it is held that
the the wife filing a complaint as a defence to aggression by the husband is
not cruelty by wife.
(b) In the case of Vishwanath Agrawal (supra), it is held that it
has to be seen whether the conduct is such that no reasonable person would
tolerate it.
(c) In case of Gurbux Singh (supra) it is held that the aggrieved
party has to make a specific case that the conduct of which exception is
taken amounts to cruelty. The married life should be assessed as a whole
and a few isolated instances over certain period will not amount to cruelty.
The ill-conduct must be precedent for a fairly lengthy period where the
relationship has deteriorated to an extent that because of the acts and
behaviour of a spouse, one party finds it extremely difficult to live with the
other party no longer may amount to mental cruelty.
(d) In Suman Kapur (supra) the cruelty is of such a character as
to cause in the mind of the petitioner a reasonable apprehension that it will
be harmful or injurious for him to live with the respondent. In another case
Mayadevi (supra) it is held that Cruelty which is a ground for dissolution
of marriage may be defined as wilful and unjustifiable conduct of such
character as to cause danger to life, limb or health, bodily or mental, or as
to give rise to a reasonable apprehension of such a danger.
(e) In Naveen Kohli (supra) it is held that merely because there
are allegations and counter allegations, a decree of divorce cannot follow.
There must be really some extra-ordinary features to warrant grant of
Signed by: VARSHA SINGH
Signing time: 18/01/2024
4:54:27 PM
-14-
divorce on the basis of pleading (and other admitted material). The Courts
do not have to deal with ideal husbands and ideal wives. It has to deal
with particular man and woman before it. The ideal couple or mere ideal
one will probably have no occasion to go to Matrimonial Court.
(f) In the case of A. Jayachandra (supra) it is held that If
inference can be legitimately drawn that the treatment of the spouse is such
that it causes an apprehension in the mind of the other spouse, about his or
her mental welfare then this conduct amounts to cruelty.
(g) In case of V. Bhagat (supra) it is held that merely because
there are allegations and counter-allegations, a decree of divorce cannot
follow.
(h) On the point of breakdown of marriage, learned counsel for
the appellant further relied in the case of Neelam Kumar (supra) in which
it has been held that if a party to a marriage, by his own conduct brings the
relationship to a point of irretrievable breakdown, he/she cannot be
allowed to seek the divorce on the ground irretrievable breakdown of the
marriage on the principal that no one can take the benefit of his own
misdeeds.
(i) Further, on the point of prove of ground of divorce, learned
counsel for the appellant further relied in the case of Pankaj Mahajan
(supra) in which it is held that the appellant is bound to prove the conduct
of the appellant/wife independent and cogent evidence and on the hearsay
evidence no decree can be granted.
40.
I have perused the above principles laid down by the different
courts. On this point, as cited by the appellant herself, the Hon'ble Apex
Court in the case of K. Srinivas Rao vs D.A. Deepa (2013) 5 SCC 226 in
paragraphs no.10 to 16 has discussed and summarized all the
Signed by: VARSHA SINGH
Signing time: 18/01/2024
4:54:27 PM
-15-
circumstances in which the act of the parties can be treated as cruelty.
“10. Under Section 13(1)(i-a) of the Hindu Marriage
Act, 1955, a marriage can be dissolved by a decree of
divorce on a petition presented either by the husband or
the wife on the ground that the other party has, after
solemnization of the marriage, treated the petitioner with
cruelty. In a series of judgments this Court has repeatedly
stated the meaning and outlined the scope of the term
‘cruelty’. Cruelty is evident where one spouse has so
treated the other and manifested such feelings towards
her or him as to cause in her or his mind reasonable
apprehension that it will be harmful or injurious to live
with the other spouse. Cruelty may be physical or mental.
11. In Samar Ghosh vs. Jaya Ghosh, [(2007) 4 SCC
511], this Court set out illustrative cases where inference
of ‘mental cruelty’ can be drawn. This list is obviously not
exhaustive because each case presents it’s own peculiar
factual matrix and existence or otherwise of mental
cruelty will have to be judged after applying mind to it.
We must quote the relevant paragraph of Samar Ghosh.
We have reproduced only the instances which are relevant
to the present case. (SCC pp.546-547, para 101)
“101. No uniform standard can ever be laid down
for guidance, yet we deem it appropriate to
enumerate some instances of human behaviour
which may be relevant in dealing with the cases of
“mental cruelty”. The instances indicated in the
succeeding paragraphs are only illustrative and
not exhaustive:
(i)
On consideration of complete matrimonial
life of the parties, acute mental pain, agony and
suffering as would not make possible for the
parties to live with each other could come within
the broad parameters of mental cruelty.
(ii) On comprehensive appraisal of the entire
matrimonial life of the parties, it becomes
abundantly clear that situation is such that the
wronged party cannot reasonably be asked to put
up with such conduct and continue to live with
other party.
Signed by: VARSHA SINGH
Signing time: 18/01/2024
4:54:27 PM
-16-
(iii) xxx xxx xxx
(iv) Mental cruelty is a state of mind. The
feeling of deep anguish, disappointment,
frustration in one spouse caused by the conduct
of other for a long time may lead to mental
cruelty.
(v) A sustained course of abusive and humiliating
treatment calculated to torture, discommode or
render miserable life of the spouse.
(vi) Sustained unjustifiable conduct and
behaviour of one spouse actually affecting
physical and mental health of the other spouse.
The treatment complained of and the resultant
danger or apprehension must be very grave,
substantial and weighty.
(vii)
(viii)
(ix)
xxx xxx xxx
xxx xxx xxx
xxx xxx xxx
(x) The married life should be reviewed as a
whole and a few isolated instances over a period
of years will not amount to cruelty. The ill
conduct must be persistent for a fairly lengthy
period, where the relationship has deteriorated to
an extent that because of the acts and behaviour
of a spouse, the wronged party finds it extremely
difficult to live with the other party any longer,
may amount to mental cruelty.
(xi) xxx xxx xxx
(xii)xxx xxx xxx
(xiii) xxx xxx xxx
(xiv) Where there has been a long period of
continuous separation, it may fairly be concluded
that the matrimonial bond is beyond repair. The
marriage becomes a fiction though supported by
a legal tie. By refusing to sever that tie, the law in
such cases, does not serve the sanctity of
marriage; on the contrary, it shows scant regard
for the feelings and emotions of the parties. In
such like situations, it may lead to mental
cruelty.”
Signed by: VARSHA SINGH
Signing time: 18/01/2024
4:54:27 PM
-17-
12. It is pertinent to note that in Samar Ghosh case the
husband and wife had lived separately for more than
sixteen and a half years. This fact was taken into
consideration along with other facts as leading to the
conclusion that matrimonial bond had been ruptured
beyond repair because of the mental cruelty caused by the
wife. Similar view was taken in the case of Naveen Kohli
Vs. Neelu Kohli [(2006) 4 SCC 558].
13. In V. Bhagat vs. D. Bhagat [(1994) 1 SCC 337] in
the divorce petition filed by the husband the wife filed
written statement stating that the husband was suffering
from mental hallucination, that his was a morbid mind for
which he needs expert psychiatric treatment and that he
was suffering from ‘paranoid disorder’. In crossexamination her counsel put several questions to the
husband suggesting that several members of his family
including his grandfather were lunatics. This court held
that these assertions cannot but constitute mental cruelty
of such a nature that the husband cannot be asked to live
with the wife thereafter. Such pleadings and questions it
was held, are bound to cause immense mental pain and
anguish to the husband.
14. In Vijaykumar Bhate [Vijay Kumar Ramchandra
Bhate vs. Neela Vijay Kumar Bhate, (2003) 6 SCC 334]
disgusting accusations of unchastity and indecent
familiarity with a neighbour were made in the written
statement. This Court held that the allegations are of such
quality, magnitude and consequence as to cause mental
pain, agony and suffering amounting to the reformulated
concept of cruelty in matrimonial law causing profound
and lasting disruption and driving the wife to feel deeply
hurt and reasonably apprehend that it would be dangerous
to live with her husband.
15. In Naveen Kohli case, the respondent-wife got an
advertisement issued in a national newspaper that her
husband was her employee. She got another news item
issued cautioning his business associates to avoid dealing
with him. This was treated as causing mental cruelty to
the husband. In Naveen Kohli case, the wife had filed
several complaints and cases against the husband. This
Court viewed her conduct as a conduct causing mental
cruelty and observed that (SCC p.582, para 82)
Signed by: VARSHA SINGH
Signing time: 18/01/2024
4:54:27 PM
-18-
“82....the findings of the High Court that these
proceedings could not be taken to be such
which may warrant annulment of marriage is
wholly unsustainable.”
16. Thus, to the instances illustrative of mental cruelty
noted in Samar Ghosh case, we could add a few more.
Making unfounded indecent defamatory allegations
against the spouse or his or her relatives in the pleadings,
filing of complaints or issuing notices or news items which
may have adverse impact on the business prospect or the
job of the spouse and filing repeated false complaints and
cases in the court against the spouse would, in the facts of
a case, amount to causing mental cruelty to the other
spouse.”
41.
In view of the As above discussion, the facts and circumstance and
the material available on the record, it is a clear case of cruelty by wife.
The trial Court after due appreciation of the evidence has passed the decree
of divorce. The trial Court has also taken care of the appellant/wife and
granted her permanent alimony of Rs.10,00,000/-. Hence, no interference
is required and the
judgment and decree passed by Principal Judge,
Family Court is affirmed. The appeal being devoid of merit be dismissed.
42.
The appellant shall bear the cost of the respondent/husband.
43.
Advocate fee as per rules. Decree be drawn accordingly.
44.
With the copy of the judgment and decree, the record of the
Family Court be returned back.
(S.A. DHARMADHIKARI)
JUDGE
vs
Signed by: VARSHA SINGH
Signing time: 18/01/2024
4:54:27 PM
(DEVNARAYAN MISHRA)
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review