Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN
THE
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT GWALIOR
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE ROOPESH CHANDRA VARSHNEY
ON THE 8th OF JANUARY, 2024
MISC. APPEAL No. 337 of 2013
BETWEEN:1.
SMT. ANITA TOMAR W/O LATE SHRI RAM
KUMAR SINGH TOMAR, AGED ABOUT 40 YEARS,
OCCUPATION: HOUSEWIFE
2.
ABHISHEK TOMAR S/O LATE RAM KUMAR SINGH
TOMAR, AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS, OCCUPATION:
STUDENT
3.
ABHIJEET TOMAR S/O LATE RAM KUMAR SINGH
TOMAR, AGED ABOUT 19 YEARS, OCCUPATION:
STUDENT
4.
KU.RUCHI TOMAR D/O LATE RAM KUMAR SINGH
TOMAR, AGED ABOUT 18 YEARS,
5.
KU.HEMLATA TOMAR D/O LATE RAM KUMAR
SINGH TOMAR, AGED ABOUT 17 YEARS,
6.
HARIOM SINGH S/O HUKUM SINGH , AGED
ABOUT 64 YEARS,
APPELLANT NO. 5 SINCE MINOR UNDER THE
GUARDIANSHIP OF MOTHER SMT. ANITA TOMAR
ALL R/O ADARSHPURAM, POLICE STATION
MAHARAJPURA, DISTRICT GWALIOR (MADHYA
PRADESH).
.....APPELLANTS
(BY SMT. MEENA SINGHAL - ADVOCATE)
AND
1.
HARI SINGH S/O VIJAY SINGH R/O GIRENDRA
NAGAR BHIND OCCUPATION (DRIVER OF BUS
NO. MP 06 A 7077) DECEASED THROUGH LRS WIFE
SMT SHAKUNTALA W/O LATE SHRI HARI SINGH
OCCUPATION: DRIVER R/O VILLAGE KHEDA
RATHOER, MALONI KHERA RATHORE, BAAH,
AGRA (UTTAR PRADESH)
2.
SURENDRA SINGH S/O RAMBABU SINGH
KUSHWAH R/O CHATURVEDI NAGAR BHIND,
DISTRICT BHIND (MADHYA PRADESH) (OWNER
OF BUS NO. MP06A7077)
3.
UNITED INDIA INSURANCE COMPANY LTD TH:
DIVISIONAL
MANAGER
CENTRE
POINT
COMPLEX
PHOOLBAGH
ROAD,GWALIOR
(MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(RESPONDENT NO. 3 BY SHRI RAJESH GUPTA - ADVOCATE )
T h is appeal coming on for
orders this day, t h e court passed the
following:
ORDER
Present miscellaneous appeal under Section 173 (1) of the Motor Vehicle
Act is filed against the award dated 17/12/2012 passed by Ninth Additional
Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Gwalior in Claim Case No. 166/2011 by
which the Insurance Company has been exonerated from the liability of
compensation.
2. The necessary facts for the disposal of the present appeal in short are
that on 16/2/2010 when deceased Ramkumar was going in Bus No.
MP06A7077 from village Sahaspura to village Rudrapura, District Jalon, due to
rash and negligent driving of driver of bus, near Police Station Madhavtah, bus
turn turtled due to which he died on spot. Therefore, His Lrs.
appellants/claimants filed a claim petition before the Claims Tribunal claiming
total compensation of Rs.56,22,000/- from the respondents in different heads.
3. Respondent No. 3 / Insurance Company appeared before the learned
Tribunal and filed its written statement and denied each and every content made
in the claim petition. Insurance company has also taken the defence that at the
time of accident, the offending vehicle was being run in violation of terms and
conditions of the insurance policy without route permit, hence, insurance
company is not liable to pay the compensation amount.
4. Learned Claims Tribunal framed issues and recorded the evidence
produced by the parties and after hearing both the parties partly allowed the
claim application and awarded the sum of Rs.18,82,406/- and while exonerating
the Insurance Company from liability of payment of compensation amount,
fixed the liability of payment of compensation amount on driver and owner of
the offending vehicle with interest @ 7% per annum from the date of
application. .
5. Learned counsel for the appellants / claimants submitted that while
passing the impugned award learned Claims Tribunal failed to award future
prospects to the Claimants for death of deceased and the amount of
compensation awarded under other heads is also on lower side and in light of
catena of decisions of Apex Court, the insurance company is liable to pay the
compensation, which can be recovered from respondents No. 1 and 2 as if any
breach of terms and conditions of insurance policy has been committed, then it
is a matter between the owner, driver and the insurance company. The claimants
being third party should not be punished, therefore, burden lies on respondent
No. 3 / insurance company to pay the compensation amount. Hence, the finding
with respect to the exoneration of the insurance company from its liability is
liable to be set aside.
6. Per contra, the appeal is vehemently opposed by the counsel for
respondent No. 3 / Insurance company. Learned counsel for respondent
No.3/Insurance Company did not opposed the quantum of compensation
awarded by learned Tribunal and supported the award submitting that
respondent No.3 / Insurance Company has rightly been exonerated and prayed
for dismissal of appeal.
7. Heard the learned counsel for the parties and perused the material
available on record.
8. As regards prayer of appellants/claimants regarding grant of future
prospects, as the deceased was a Govt. Employee, in the opinion of this Court
in the light of decision of Apex Court in the matter of National Insurance
Company Limited Vs. Pranay Sethi and Ors., (2017) 16 SCC 680;
wherein, it is held that "while determining the income, an additional of 50% of
actual salary to the income of the deceased towards future prospects, where the
deceased had a permanent job and was below the age of 40 years, should be
made. The additional should be 30%, if the age of the deceased was between 40
t0 50 years. In case the deceased was between the age of 50 to 60 years, the
additional should be 15%. Actual salary should be read as actual salary less
tax.:
9. Therefore, while assessing the income of deceased at Rs. 14,781/- as
assessed by Claims Tribunal and adding 30% towards future prospects and
deducting 1/4th towards self expenditure and applying the multiplier of 14 the
compensation amount comes to Rs. 14,781 + 4434(14781 x 30/100) = 19,215
and deducting 1/4, same comes to Rs. 14411/- monthly and annually Rs. 14411
x 12 = 1,72,932/- and after applying multiplier of 14, 1,72,932 x 14 =
24,21,048/-. The claimants shall also be entitled for Rs. 70,000/- towards
pecuniary heads like loss of estate, funeral expenses and loss of consortium.
Thus, the total compensation amount comes to Rs. 24,21,048 + 70,000 =
24,91,048/-. The Claims Tribunal has already awarded a compensation of RS.
18,82,406/- therefore, the appellants/claimants shall be entitled to receive an
enhanced compensation of Rs. 24,91,048 - 18,82,406 = 6,08, 642/-. Rest of the
conditions as imposed by claims Tribunal shall remain intact.
10. As regards appellants second prayer to get compensation from
Insurance Company with liberty to recover the same from respondents No.1 &
2, the Supreme Court in the case of Shivaraj Vs. Rajendra [(2018) 10 SCC
432], Manuara Khatun Vs. Rajesh Kumar Singh [2017 ACJ 1031] &
Shamanna and another Vs. Divisional Manager, the Oriental Insurance
Co. Ltd. and others,[(2018) 9 SCC 650] observed that in the case of breach
of policy directions against the Insurance Company to pay the awarded sum to
the claimants and then to recover the said sum from the insured be given by
applying the principle of "pay and recover". The Insurance Policy is a contract
between the insured and the insurer and the insurer agrees to indemnify the
insured against all the claims arising out of use of vehicle, however, such
contract is subject to the conditions that the vehicle shall not be plied or driven
contrary to the provisions of law as well as Insurance Policy. Thus, it is clear
that the insurer / Insurance Company can get away from its liability of
indemnifying the insured by proving that the vehicle was being used contrary to
the Insurance Policy. However, the claimants are completely stranger to the
contract between the insured and the insurer. Once, the Insurance Company
had agreed to indemnify the insured than it would be a dispute between the
insured and the insurer as to whether the vehicle was being used contrary to the
conditions of Insurance Policy or not? But the claimants cannot be made to
suffer because of inter se dispute between the insured and the insurer. Once, the
vehicle is insured, then the Insurance Company must satisfy the award and if it
is found by the Claims Tribunal that the vehicle was being used contrary to the
conditions of Insurance Policy, then the right to recover the amount has been
given to the Insurance Company without filing a separate suit against the
insured.
11. Thus, while allowing this appeal in part the appellants are held entitled
to received enhanced compensation of Rs. 6,08,642/- with interest at the rate of
6% per annum from July, 2017, when the decision of Pranay Sethi (supra)
came into force. However, they shall not be entitled to receive any interest for
the period from 16/6/2014 to 9/9/2015 and 26/8/2016 to 2/8/2021, the period
during which this appeal remained dismissed in default and on enhanced. This
order shall be executable upon payment of proportionate Court fees on the
enhanced amount. The Court fees be paid within 3 months from the date of this
order. Registry to prepare memo of costs. The appellants' counsel shall provide
certified copy of memo of costs to the counsel for Insurance Company. The
Insurance Company thereafter shall deposit the enhanced amount with costs
with the Tribunal within one month from the date of receipt of memo of Cost.
Failure to comply with the aforesaid direction no interest would be payable on
the enhanced amount from the date of order till the Court fees is actually paid
and memo of costs is supplied to counsel for Insurance Company.
12. As regards the findings of Tribunal to exonerate the respondent No.3
/ Insurance Company from its liability to pay is hereby affirmed, however, in the
light of principles laid down by Apex Court as above, it is directed that the
Insurance Company shall pay the compensation to the appellant which may be
recovered from the respondent No.1 / driver and respondent No.2 / owner.
13. Resultantly, the Award dated 17/12/2012 passed by Ninth Additional
Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Gwalior (M.P.) in Claim Case No. 166/2011
is modified to the extent mentioned above.
14. This Misc. Appeal is disposed of accordingly.
(ROOPESH CHANDRA VARSHNEY)
JUDGE
JPS/-
JAI
PRAKASH
SOLANKI
DN: c=IN, o=HIGH COURT OF MADHYA
PRADESH BENCH GWALIOR, ou=HIGH
COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH BENCH
GWALIOR,
2.5.4.20=287738d30aabaeda9b10cecdf179c
ec865c7633f4cfb9e38ce14fcbb05b9522a,
postalCode=474001, st=Madhya Pradesh,
serialNumber=8D6BC1C9FCE36623D0BD6B
8072A2D8C01433EBD48AE4F609F108CA8F
8DE6B522, cn=JAI PRAKASH SOLANKI
Date: 2024.01.10 12:04:42 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review