Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
W.P.(C) No.733 of 2024
Smt. Anita Saha
wife of Sri Satya Narayan Parial, C/O- Sri
Upendra Debnath, resident of Bardowali, Near
Manasha Mistanna Bhandar, P.O. & P.S. A.D.
Nagar, District- West Tripura
–Versus–
……… Petitioner(s)
1. The State of Tripura,
represented by the Secretary, Directorate of
Social
Welfare
&
Social
Education,
Government of Tripura, Civil Secretariat, New
Capital Complex, P.O. Kunjaban, P.S. New
Capital Complex, District- West Tripura
2. The Secretary,
Directorate of Social Welfare & Social
Education, Government of Tripura, Civil
Secretariat, New Capital Complex, P.O.
Kunjaban, P.S. New Capital Complex, DistrictWest Tripura
3. The Director of Social Welfare & Social Education,
Government of Tripura, Ujan Abhoynagar,
Agartala, District- West Tripura
4. The Additional Director of Social Welfare & Social Education,
Government of Tripura, Ujan Abhoynagar,
Agartala, District- West Tripura
5. Sri Pradip Bhattacharjee,
son of late Haripada Bhattacharjee, resident of
Jangalia, P.O. & P.S. Bishalgarh, DistrictSepahijala, PIN-799102
6. Sri Sanjoy Saha,
Social Education Organiser, Bishalgarh ICDS
Project, P.O. Bishalgarh, Sepahijala
…… Respondent(s)
For the petitioner (s)
:
Mr. K. Pandey, Adv.
For the Respondent (S)
:
Mr. M. Debbarma, Addl. G.A.
Date of hearing & delivery of
judgment and order
:
27.03.2026
Whether fit for reporting
:
Yes
✔
No
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. DATTA PURKAYASTHA
JUDGMENT & ORDER [ORAL]
Heard Mr. K. Pandey, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner and Mr. M. Debbarma, learned Addl. G.A. appearing for the
respondents.
[2]
The petitioner was appointed as Social Worker Organizer
(Female) on ad-hoc basis vide memorandum dated 30.09.1992 [Annexure-2
to the writ petition] against the sanctioned post. She is continuing her service
since then without any break. On 19.07.2001, the State Government issued
one memorandum [Annexure-3 to the writ petition] following the judgment of
the High Court mentioning that in exceptional circumstances where in the
exigency of public service, ad-hoc appointments/promotions are made, same
should be limited to one year only and on expiry of one year, the ad-hoc
appointment/promotion would automatically be ceased. It was also directed
that the departments should regularize all ad-hoc appointments/promotions,
in eligible cases, within a stipulated timeframe of 3 (three) months w.e.f.
30.09.2001 which would be the outer limit and if within the said period of
3[three] months in case, any Department was not able to regularize all adhoc appointments/promotions, the detailed report should be submitted to the
G.A. (P&T) Department within 15th October, 2001. But the present petitioner
was neither regularized in her service at that time nor her ad-hoc
appointment was cancelled.
[3]
She continues to serve the department and she has also been
receiving the regular pay scale against the said post. Again, on 24.12.2018
[Annexure-4 to the writ petition] another memorandum was issued by the
State Government mentioning that some
employees
under various
departments/offices were appointed on ad-hoc basis and were kept for a long
period without regularisation. Subsequently, the departments approached the
G.A(P&T) Department for regularisation of those ad-hoc appointments,
defying the earlier instructions and therefore, it was stated that no ad-hoc
appointment/promotion should be allowed and on an emergent necessity for
allowing ad-hoc appointment, same might be allowed with the prior
concurrence of the G.A. (P&T) Department and Finance Department.
[4]
As per the service records of the petitioner, it appears that the
department granted her higher pay scale on completion of 10 years of service
for not providing any promotion to her. By the memorandum dated
12.04.2010 [Annexure-6 to the writ petition], she was further granted second
ACP w.e.f 30.09.2009. The benefit of MACP-3 was also provided to her on
completion of 25 years of service vide memorandum dated 19.09.2018
[Annexure-7 to the writ petition]. Interestingly, in the said memorandum, the
followings were mentioned:
“As per the provision of the Rule 12 of the TSCS(R.P) Rules, 2017 vide
Finance Department, Government of Tripura, Notification No.F.7(2)FIN(PC)/2017 dated 11.07.2017 the proposal for granting the benefit of
MACP-3 in respect of Smt. Anita Saha, Social Education Organizer
(Female) under the disposal of CDPO, Mandwi ICDS Project, West
Tripura. Hence, Smt. Anita Saha, S.E.O (F) is entitled to get the benefit of
MACP-3 advancement with effect from 30th September, 2017 on
completion of 25 (Twenty Five) years satisfactory service from the
date of regular appointment.
[Emphasis underscore]
[5]
Thus, from the said memorandum, it appears that her service
was not formally regularised but she was treated as a regular employee.
[6]
A final seniority list was also published on 30.03.2021
[Annexure-8 to the writ petition] wherein she was placed against serial
No.219, whereas her two colleagues namely, Sri Pradip Bhattacharjee and
Sri Sanjoy Saha, according to the petitioner, who are juniors to her, were
placed before her name.
[7]
Being
aggrieved
thereof,
the
petitioner
submitted
one
representation to the department and finally, filed W.P.(C) No.394 of 2021 in
this Court. At Paragraph No.15 of the counter affidavit submitted in the said
writ petition, it was mentioned by the respondents that seniority was revised
giving effect to the date of regularisation in pursuance of the verdict of the
High Court in W.P.(C) No.1497-1514 of 2017 and following the same
procedure and process of those regularized as on 02.06.2017, the
department would also regularise the present petitioner and two others.
[Emphasis underscore]
[8]
Ultimately, the said writ petition bearing W.P.(C) No.394 of 2021
was disposed of by a Coordinate Bench of this Court on 13.07.2023 without
expressing any opinion on the merit of the case and giving the liberty to the
petitioner to make necessary communication with all relevant documents to
the respondents in this regard and the respondent were also directed to
consider such representation of the petitioner in accordance with law within a
period of 3[three] months. She thereafter, submitted a representation on
24.07.2023 [Annexure-13 to the writ petition] to the present respondent Nos.2
& 3 for consideration of the modification of the seniority list. Said
representation was rejected by the respondent No.3 vide communication
dated 20.01.2024 [Annexure-14 to the writ petition] stating that her service
was not regularised till date and therefore, her claim of seniority could only be
settled on regularization of her service in observance of due procedure,
which was still to be finalised.
[9]
Being aggrieved thereby, the present writ petition has been filed
by the petitioner with the following reliefs:
[i] Issue Rule upon the respondents to show cause as to why the the
respondents should not transmit all the records relating to the case of
the petitioner.
[ii] As to why a writ in the nature of Mandamus should not be issued
directing the State Respondents to regularize the service of the
petitioner to the post of Social Education Organiser under the
Directorate of Social Welfare & Social Education, Government of
Tripura w.e.f. the date of her initial appointment i.e. 30.09.1992 along
with all service benefits including seniority and promotion.
[iii] As to why such order/orders should not be passed so as to give full
relief to the petitioner, and, upon causes shown, to make the Rule
absolute.
[10]
Mr. K. Pandey, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner
submits that only after the counter affidavit was submitted in the previous writ
petition, the petitioner for the first time came to know that her service was not
formally regularised, though she was being treated like other regular
employees and she was given the benefit of regular pay scale with
upgradation and even all 3[three] ACPs were also granted to her and her
name was also entered in the seniority list. Therefore, now the respondents
cannot contend that she was an ad-hoc employee. Learned counsel further
refers to paragraph No.9 of the counter affidavit submitted by the State in this
writ petition wherein it is contended by the respondents that the department
earlier took initiative to regularise the service of some Supervisors, Rural
Functional Literacy Programme [RFLP], Social Education Organiser [SEO],
Superintendent of Homes and Supervisor [ICDS] who were appointed on Adhoc basis and they regularized them vide memo dated 02.06.2017 and
among them, names of Sri Pradip Bhattaharjee and Sri Sanjoy Saha were
also included but the name of the petitioner was not included inadvertently at
that time for regularisation.
[11]
Mr. Pandey, learned counsel also refers to one additional
affidavit submitted by the State-respondents wherein at paragraph No.4.7, it
is stated that so far the matter of regularisation of ad-hoc service of the
petitioner is concerned, an instruction was issued by a memo dated
19.07.2001 that all ad-hoc appointments under the State Government should
be regularized within a period of 30th September, 2001 and accordingly, adhoc employees under the administrative department submitted prayers but on
scrutiny, it is found that only one prayer was received from said Sri Pradip
Bhattacharjee who hold the post of SEO during the period of 1991-92 on adhoc basis along with other prayers but no representation was received from
the petitioner before placing the matter for approval of the Council of
Ministers held in 2017 and thereby, the proposal for regularisation of the
petitioner was not placed before the Council of Ministers in absence of her
representation. It is also stated in paragraph No.4.8 that as per record of the
memorandum of the Council of Ministers dated 11th May, 2017, total 19
persons appointed on ad-hoc basis out of which 2(two) posts for SEOs who
were also appointed in the year 1991-92 were proposed for regularisation
and accordingly, approval was also accorded by the Council of Ministers.
[12]
Mr. Pandey, learned counsel submits that according to the
respondents by their above assertions made in the additional affidavit itself,
only Pradip Bhattacharjee submitted his representation for regularisation of
the service and none other else, but
while regularising said Pradip
Bhattacharjee, service of another person, namely Sanjoy Saha was also
regularized. Therefore, according to learned counsel, if the petitioner was not
provided with the benefit of regularisation for submission of representation,
then on what basis, service of said Sanjay Saha was regularized, treating the
petitioner with discrimination.
[13]
Learned counsel also relies on a decision of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in the case of Jaggo vs. Union of India & Ors., AIR 2025
SC 296; Vinod Kumar and others vs. Union of India and others, (2024) 9
SCC 327 and Dharam Singh and others vs. State of U.P. and Another,
2025 SCC OnLine SC 1735.
[14]
Mr. M. Debbarma, learned Addl. G.A. appearing for the State
submits that as the petitioner like her other colleagues did not submit any
representation, her case for regularisation was not considered and moreover,
her name was wrongly entered in the seniority list.
[15]
This Court has considered the submissions of the learned
counsel appearing for both sides and has gone through the documents relied
on by the parties.
[16]
As already discussed above, since 1992, the petitioner is still
serving the department and she was appointed against regular sanctioned
post. She has been provided with regular pay scale and other career
progression benefits. Her name was also reflected in the seniority list in the
year 2021 but the plea of wrong mention of the name of the petitioner in the
seniority list was not agitated in the counter affidavit of the State-respondents
in her previous writ petition bearing W.P.(C) No.394 of 2021 and therefore,
such a plea regarding the wrong entry of her name in the seniority list cannot
be accepted at this belated stage in the present writ petition. For her long
standing service in the department and discharging her duties itself
evaporates the essence of ad-hocism and it appears that her duty was
perennial in nature and that is why the department allowed her to continue in
the service for more than three decades and has derived the benefit of her
hard labour.
[17]
Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Dharam Singh (supra)
observes that “ad-hocism” thrives where administration is opaque. The State
Departments must keep and produce accurate establishment registers,
muster rolls and outsourcing arrangements, and they must explain, with
evidence, why they prefer precarious engagement over sanctioned posts
where the work is perennial. It is also observed that if “constraint” is invoked,
the record should show what alternatives were considered, why similarly
placed workers were treated differently, and how the chosen course aligns
with Articles 14, 16 and 21 of the Constitution of India.
[18]
In the case of Jaggo (supra), Hon’ble Supreme Court also
observed that that the appellants of that case were engaged as part-time
worker on ad-hoc basis in Central Water Commission during the period from
1993 to 1999 as Safaiwali who were primarily responsible for cleaning and
maintaining the office premises and one of the appellants was appointed as a
Khallasi/Mali. They sought regularization of their services and being refused
thereby ultimately they approached the Hon’ble Supreme Court. While dealing
with their such claim, the Hon’ble Supreme Court found despite being labelled
as "part-time workers," the appellants were performing essential tasks on a
daily and continuous basis over extensive periods, ranging from over a decade
to nearly two decades. Regarding the law laid down in Secretary, State of
Karnataka and Ors. vs. Umadevi (3) & Ors., (2006) 4 SCC 1, the Apex Court
at paragraph-20 of said judgment observes that the decision in Umadevi (3)
(supra) did not intend to penalize employees who have rendered long years of
service fulfilling ongoing and necessary functions of the State or its
instrumentalities. Rather, said judgment sought to prevent backdoor entries
and illegal appointments but where the appointments were not illegal but
possibly "irregular," and where employees had served continuously against the
backdrop of sanctioned functions for a considerable period, the need for a fair
and humane resolution became paramount. Prolonged, continuous, and
unblemished service performing tasks inherently required on a regular basis
can, over the time, transform what was initially ad-hoc or temporary into a
scenario demanding fair regularization. Finally, the Apex Court directed in that
case that the services of said appellants be regularized.
[19]
In the case of Vinod Kumar (supra), the appellants were initially
appointed to ex-cadre posts of Accounts Clerks after a selection process
involving written tests and viva voce interviews and after the rejection of their
representation for regularization to the Divisional Railway Manager in 1999,
the appellants approached the Central Administrative Tribunal but their
applications were dismissed. Then, they approached the High Court and the
High Court upheld the order of the Tribunal. Finally, Hon’ble Supreme Court
observed that the service conditions of the appellants, as evolved over time,
warrant a reclassification from temporary to regular status and the failure to
recognize the substantive nature of their roles and their continuous service
akin to permanent employees runs counter to the principles of equity,
fairness, and the intent behind employment regulations. Accordingly, the
respondents were directed to regularize the appellants in that case.
[20]
In view of the above position of law, this Court is of the view that
this is a fit case to order for regularization of the petitioner when her other
colleagues who are similarly situated, have already been regularized long
ago and even they have been put to the higher position in the seniority list
than the petitioner. Like them, she is also rendered her service for similar
period and the source of selection of all of them was same. Therefore, merely
on the pretext that she did not file a representation for regularization, she
cannot be subjected to discriminatory treatment. When the State Government
issued notification on 19.07.2001 [Annexure-3 of the writ petition] as stated
above,
directing
the
departments
for
regularization
of
all
ad-hoc
appointment/promotions in eligible cases within the stipulated period of
3[three] months, it was the duty of the respondents to take necessary step for
regularization of the petitioner, and now for inaction or default on their part in
compliance with the said direction, they cannot blame the petitioner and
deprive her legitimate claim of regularization.
[21]
In view of above, this writ petition is allowed. The respondents
are directed to regularize the service of the petitioner in the post of Social
Education Organizer (Female) with effect from the date of her initial
appointment like her other colleagues as mentioned in the memorandum
dated 02.06.2017 [Annexure-R/4 to the additional counter affidavit filed by the
respondents No.1 to 4] within 3[three] months from the date of receipt of the
copy of the judgment and order. Necessary consequential benefit, if any,
should be provided to her accordingly.
With this observation and direction, this writ petition is disposed
of.
Pending application(s), if any, also stand disposed of.
JUDGE
signed by SUJAY GHOSH
SUJAY GHOSH Digitally
Date: 2026.04.02 10:24:28 +05'30'
Sujay
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review