The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
10. The Learned Trial court came to the observation that since there is ‘Will’ regarding the suit property so the suit was barred by law and dismissed the suit. But Learned Trial court did not specify anything under what provisions of law and also under which act the suit was barred. Similarly, the Learned First Appellate court also dismissed the appeal of the plaintiff on the same grounds. Because on perusal of the ‘Will’ which was not marked as exhibit by the Learned Trial court it appears that by the said ‘Will’ the testator had distributed the share of building amongst his legal heirs but regarding the quantum of land the ‘Will’ was totally remained silent. But the Learned Trial court below came to the observation that since the building is standing on the suit property so no partition was required and without proper application of mind dismissed the suit which in my considered view Learned Trial court below and as well as the Learned First Appellate court committed serious error in dismissing the suit and the appeal. Moreso, by the said ‘Will’ the testator bequeathed his property to his wife not to the present parties. But the Learned Trial court below did not consider the said fact in discussing the preliminary issue. Even the said ‘Will’ was not taken into consideration and proved as per law. Moreso, the petition filed under Order 7 Rule 11 of CPC was also not appropriate fo…
11. In the result, the appeal filed by the appellant- plaintiff is hereby allowed with costs against the respondent-defendant. The judgment and decree dated
06. 08.2022 delivered by the Learned First Appellate court in Title Appeal No.08 of 2022 is hereby set aside. The suit be remanded back to the Learned Trial court i.e. the Learned Civil Judge (Senior Division), Court No.1, West Tripura, Agartala for framing the proper issues and to deliver the judgment and decree in accordance with law after taking evidence and hearing arguments of both the sides within a period of 4(four) months from the date of receipt of the copy of the judgment. The parties shall appear before the Learned Trial court on 26.03.2024. Send down the LCRs along with a copy of this judgment. Prepare decree accordingly. Pending application(s) if any, stands disposed of. 2024.03.15 01:17:39 BHATTACHARJEE Date: -07'00' Moumita
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
RSA No.42 of 2022
Smt. Anindita Roy (Chowdhury),
Wife of Late Anjan Chowdhury,
Daughter of Late Soroj Kumar Roy,
A resident of Parbati Villa,
Palace Compound, Jagannath Bari Road,
P.O. Agartala, P.S. West Agartala,
District: West Tripura, Age: 54
----Plaintiff-Appellant (s)
Versus
Smt. Alakananda Roy (Basu),
Wife of Shri Biswajit Basu,
Daughter of Late Soroj Kumar Roy,
A resident of Parbati Villa,
Palace Compound, Jagannath Bari Road,
P.O. Agartala, P.S. West Agartala,
District: West Tripura
---- Defendant-Respondent (s)
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. S. M. Chakraborty, Sr. Adv.
Ms. P. Chakraborty, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. D. C. Saha, Adv.
Date of Hearing
:
06.03.2024
Date of delivery of
Judgment and Order :
13.03.2024
Whether fit for
Reporting
YES
:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
This
appeal
under
Section
of
CPC
is
filed
challenging the judgment and decree dated 06.08.2022
delivered by Learned Addl. District Judge, Court No.5, West
Tripura, Agartala in Title Appeal No.08 of 2022 dismissing
the appeal and upholding the order of Learned Civil Judge
(Senior Division), Agartala, West Tripura, Court No.1 dated
21.01.2022 delivered in connection with T.S.(P)37 of 2020.
02.
Heard Mr. S. M. Chakraborty, Learned Senior
counsel assisted by Ms. P. Chakraborty, Learned counsel
appearing for the appellant and Mr. D. C. Saha, Learned
counsel appearing for the respondent. Before entering into
the merit let us revisit the subject matter of the dispute
amongst the rival parties. The appellant as the plaintiff filed
a suit before the court of Learned Civil Judge (Senior
Division) Court No.1, West Tripura, Agartala which was
numbered as TS(P)37 of 2020, seeking a decree of partition
of the parental property inherited by the parties in equal
share. According the appellant-plaintiff the father of the
plaintiff and the respondent-defendant was the owner of the
suit land including two storeyed building and three shop
premises by purchase and during his lifetime he executed
one
‘Will’
bearing
No.III-239
dated
22.05.2006
and
distributed his property in favour of plaintiff and defendant.
After the death of the father, the plaintiff-appellant found a
photocopy of ‘Will’ and in the said ‘Will’ it was mentioned
that land measuring 2 ganda 2 kara but practically there
was only land measuring 2 ganda 1 kara. So according to
the plaintiff-appellant the ‘Will’ was defective and not
binding upon them. It was also pleaded by the appellantplaintiff that she requested the defendant for partition of the
suit
land.
But
the
respondent-defendant
avoided
the
request. Lastly on 20.04.2020 the plaintiff-appellant again
requested
for
partition
and
initially
the
respondent-
defendant though agreed but later on she refused to agree
with the proposal. On 14.05.2020, the plaintiff informed the
matter to the local people and the local people also asked
the defendant, but they failed. It was further submitted that
the building over the suit land was constructed in the year
1978 and condition was deteriorated and required to be
demolished and new building is required to be constructed
and after the death of father of the parties the defendant
has been taking all the rent of shop premises and has taken
all the security money of rent and premises and on being
requested for equal distribution of money by the appellantplaintiff
the
husband
of
the
respondent-defendant
threatened the plaintiff and her son. Hence, the appellantplaintiff filed the suit.
03.
The respondent-plaintiff contested the suit by
filing written statement denying the plea of the plaintiff and
pleaded that the father of the plaintiff and defendant during
his lifetime executed a registered ‘Will’ vide No.III-239
dated 22.05.2006 and father of the defendant and plaintiff
declared the possession of plaintiff and defendant and
therefore, the partition of the suit was liable to be
dismissed. It was further asserted that by the said ‘Will’ 2
and half ganda land having double storied building was
distributed and the building is in good condition and not
required to be demolished. It was further submitted that
both the parties are in possession of the building as per
possession declared in the ‘Will’. Therefore, no question of
partition arise and the right, title, interest and possession is
already acquired by the party through the ‘Will’ and the
contesting respondent-defendant by the written statement
prayed for dismissal of the suit. Thereafter, the respondentdefendant filed one application before the Learned Trial
court under Order 7 Rule 11 of CPC for rejection of the
plaint on the ground that the partition suit was barred by
law as there is one ‘Will’ bequeathing and distributing the
suit land and partition suit does not arise at all. So the
Learned Trial Court on the petition filed heard both the sides
framed one preliminary issue on 01.10.2021 and after that
by order dated 21.01.2022 dismissed the suit of the
appellant-plaintiff. For the sake of convenience, I would like
to reproduce herein below the relevant portion of the order
dated 21.01.2022 passed by Learned Trial court which is as
follows:
“*
*
*
*
*
Be it observed that on the above said ground the
injunction application was also dismissed.
The plaintiff in para No.2 of her plaint categorically
mentioned that the predecessor of the parties executed
one Will regarding the suit property.
Considering all facts and circumstances, this court
of the opinion that this instant suit for partition is barred
by law.
Accordingly, this suit is hereby dismissed and
disposed of on merit.”
*
*
*
*
*
04.
Challenging
that
order
the
appellant-plaintiff
preferred an appeal before the court of the Learned District
Judge, West Tripura, Agartala and in due course of time the
case was assigned to the Learned Addl. District Judge, West
Tripura, Agartala, Court No.5 and the case was numbered
as Title Appeal No.8 of 2022. The Learned First Appellate
court after hearing both the sides by judgment and order
dated 06.08.2022 dismissed the appeal upholding the order
of the Learned Trial court. For the sake of convenience, the
relevant portion of the judgment and order of the Learned
First Appellate Court runs as follows:
“In the result, I find the appeal is liable to be dismissed
and stands dismissed.
This appeal is disposed of on contest.
Prepare appellate decree accordingly and place before
me for signature within 15 days.
Send down the Trial Court Record along with a copy of
this Judgment and decree.
Make entry in Trial register and upload in CIS.”
05.
At the time of admission of this appeal by order
dated 04.11.2022, the following substantial questions of law
were framed:
(i) Whether both the Courts below committed serious
perversity while dismissing the partition suit and first
Appeal thereof because of existence of Will without at
all going through and appreciating the contents of the
said Will correctly and properly?
(ii) Whether the dismissal of the suit by the Ld. Courts
below by passing a simple order without framing any
issue and taking the Will in question in evidences as
Exhibit rendered the impugned order totally bad and
perverse in the eye of law?
06.
At the time of hearing of arguments Learned
Senior counsel Mr. S. M. Chakraborty fairly submitted that
the Learned Trial Court below without application of mind
has dismissed the suit on the ground that since there was
‘Will’ so the partition suit was not maintainable. Learned
senior counsel further submitted that the appellant-plaintiff
filed the suit for partition of the paternal property and it was
specifically admitted the fact of execution of one ‘Will’ by
their deceased father. In the said ‘Will’ there was no
whisper regarding distribution of lands for which the appeal
was required to be held. But the Learned Trial court below
without understanding the legal provisions in respect of
partition dismissed the suit of the appellant-plaintiff without
any grounds and the Learned First Appellate court also did
the same wrong. Learned Senior counsel further submitted
that the partition is affected in view of the provisions of the
Partition Act and there is no bar as per the Partition Act for
partition of the suit property when there is existence of any
‘Will’. But the Learned Trial court and the First Appellate
court did not consider these aspects. Learned Senior
counsel further drawn the attention of the court referring
Section-59 of the Indian Succession Act and submitted that
every person of sound mind not being a minor may dispose
of his property by will. So by the ‘Will’ the testator
expressed his last desire as to how the building standing on
the earth would be distributed but there is no recital in the
‘Will’ regarding distribution of land amongst the parties for
which the order has become infructuous and furthermore
the testator executed the ‘Will’ in favour of his wife not in
favour of the parties of this appeal. But the Learned court
below did not consider the same. Learned Senior counsel
further submitted that by this time the wife of the original
testator expired. Learned Senior counsel further submitted
that even the purported ‘Will’ was not admitted in to
evidence by the Learned Trial court, then how the Learned
Trial court without admitting the documents came to the
observation that suit was not maintainable. Learned Senior
counsel further submitted that in view of Section-107 of
CPC Learned First Appellate court also could remand back
the matter to the Learned Trial court for framing proper
issues and to dispose of the case as per law. But the
Learned First Appellate court also did not follow the
procedure and committed the same wrong for which the
judgments are not maintainable and further submitted that
if for argument sake at one point of time if the building is
demolished or damaged in that case in absence of land how
the party would proceed for further construction over the
land in question. So finally Learned Senior counsel for the
appellant-plaintiff
submitted
that
the
matter
may
be
remanded back to the Learned Trial court for partition of the
suit property after making proper issues as per law.
07.
Per contra, Learned counsel Mr. D. C. Saha,
appearing for the respondent-defendant submitted that both
the courts below rightly and reasonably delivered the
judgment dismissing the suit and the appeal filed by the
appellant-plaintiff.
Learned
counsel
further
drawn
the
attention of this court that as per Order 7 Rule 11 of CPC
the Learned Trial court passed the order which was affirmed
by Learned First Appellate court and there is no infirmity in
the judgment of the Learned First Appellate court as well as
the Trial court. So Learned counsel for the respondentdefendant urged for dismissal of this appeal with costs.
08.
I have heard submissions of both the sides and
also gone through the records of the Learned courts below.
Admittedly in this case there is no dispute on record in
respect of execution of one ‘Will’ by the predecessor father
of the parties. The said ‘Will’ was not marked as exhibit by
the Trial court nor it was taken into consideration by the
Learned First Appellate court. However, at the time of
hearing Learned Senior counsel drawn the attention of the
court that although the ‘Will’ could not be marked as exhibit
as per law but for perusal of this court the appellant along
with the memo of appeal has annexed the same which is
now available with the record and on perusal of the same it
appears that the testator of the said ‘Will’ bequeathed both
his moveable and immovable properties to his wife who is
also by this time has expired and on perusal of the Will it
appears that in the said ‘Will’ the testator only has
distributed the building standing on his land amongst his
two daughters in the event of death of his wife, but
regarding distribution of land the ‘Will’ is totally silent.
09.
The Learned Trial court below just on the basis of
one application filed by the respondent-defendant under
Order 7 Rule 11 of CPC framed one preliminary issue and
ultimately
dismissed
the
suit.
Now
for
the
sake
of
convenience, I would like to mention herein below the
provision of Section-59 of Succession Act, Order 13 Rule 4
of the CPC and Order 7 Rule 11 of the CPC:
Section-59 of Succession Act:
59. Person capable of making wills.- Every person of
sound mind not being a minor may dispose of his
property by will.
Order 13 Rule 4 of CPC:
4. Endorsements on documents admitted in evidence.(1) Subject to the provisions of the next following subrule, there shall be endorsed on every document which
has been admitted in evidence in the Suit the following
particulars, namely:—
(a) the number and title of the suit,
(b) the name of the person producing the document,
(c) the date on which it was produced, and
(d) a statement of its having been so admitted;
and the endorsement shall be signed or Initialed by the
Judge.
(2) Where a document so admitted is an entry in a book,
account or record, and a copy thereof has been
substituted for the original under the next following rule,
the particulars aforesaid shall be endorsed on the copy
and the endorsement thereon shall be signed or initialed
by the Judge.
Order 7 Rule 11 of CPC:
11. Rejection of plaint.-The plaint shall be rejected in the
following cases.(a) where it does not disclose a cause of action;
(b) where the relief claimed is undervalued, and the
plaintiff, on being required by the Court to correct the
valuation within a time to be fixed by the Court, fails to
do so;
(c) where the relief claimed is properly valued, but the
plaint is returned upon paper insufficiently stamped, and
the plaintiff, on being required by the Court to supply the
requisite stamp-paper within a time to be fixed by the
Court, to do so
(d) where the suit appears from the statement in the
plaint to be barred by any law;
(e) where it is not filed in duplicate;
(f) where the plaintiff fails to comply with the provisions
of Rule 9;
Provided that the time fixed by the Court for the
correction of the valuation or supplying of the requisite
stamp-paper shall not be extended unless the Court, for
reasons to be recorded, is satisfied that the plaintiff was
prevented by any cause of an exceptional nature form
correcting the valuation or supplying the requisite stamppaper, as the case may be, within the time fixed by the
Court and that refusal to extend such time would cause
grave injustice to the plaintiff.
10.
The Learned Trial court came to the observation
that since there is ‘Will’ regarding the suit property so the
suit was barred by law and dismissed the suit. But Learned
Trial court did not specify anything under what provisions of
law and also under which act the suit was barred. Similarly,
the Learned First Appellate court also dismissed the appeal
of the plaintiff on the same grounds. Because on perusal of
the ‘Will’ which was not marked as exhibit by the Learned
Trial court it appears that by the said ‘Will’ the testator had
distributed the share of building amongst his legal heirs but
regarding the quantum of land the ‘Will’ was totally
remained silent. But the Learned Trial court below came to
the observation that since the building is standing on the
suit property so no partition was required and without
proper application of mind dismissed the suit which in my
considered view Learned Trial court below and as well as the
Learned First Appellate court committed serious error in
dismissing the suit and the appeal. Moreso, by the said ‘Will’
the testator bequeathed his property to his wife not to the
present parties. But the Learned Trial court below did not
consider the said fact in discussing the preliminary issue.
Even the said ‘Will’ was not taken into consideration and
proved as per law. Moreso, the petition filed under Order 7
Rule 11 of CPC was also not appropriate for dismissal of the
suit as filed by the respondent-defendant because the
provision relied upon speaks for ‘rejection of plaint’ not for
‘dismissal of suit’, but the Learned Trial court dismissed the
suit. Thus in my considered view both the courts have
committed serious perversity in delivering the order and
judgment for which in my considered view the matter be
remanded back to the Learned Trial court for framing of
proper issues and to pass appropriate judgment and decree
in accordance with law as prayed for by the appellantplaintiff within a period of 4(four) months from the date of
receipt of the copy of judgment.
11.
In the result, the appeal filed by the appellant-
plaintiff
is
hereby
allowed
with
costs
against
the
respondent-defendant. The judgment and decree dated
06.08.2022 delivered by the Learned First Appellate court in
Title Appeal No.08 of 2022 is hereby set aside. The suit be
remanded back to the Learned Trial court i.e. the Learned
Civil Judge (Senior Division), Court No.1, West Tripura,
Agartala for framing the proper issues and to deliver the
judgment and decree in accordance with law after taking
evidence and hearing arguments of both the sides within a
period of 4(four) months from the date of receipt of the
copy of the judgment. The parties shall appear before the
Learned Trial court on 26.03.2024.
Send down the LCRs along with a copy of this
judgment.
Prepare decree accordingly.
Pending application(s) if any, stands disposed of.
JUDGE
SABYASACHI
SABYASACHI BHATTACHARJEE
2024.03.15 01:17:39
BHATTACHARJEE Date:
-07'00'
Moumita
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review