Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
W.P.(C) No.24 of 2025
1. Smt. Ajita Tripura (Debbarma)
W/o- Lt. Rabindra Debbarma,
D/o- Lt. Shyama Charan Tripura,
Of Ward No- 14, B.K. Road, Ganesh Thakur Lane,
Near Bijoy Kumar School, Krishnanagar,
P.S.-West Agartala, District- West Tripura,
Tripura-799001.
………Petitioner(s)
VERSUS
1. The State of Tripura,
To be represented by Secretary, Department of Home,
Government of Tripura, New Secretariat Building,
New Capital Complex, Kunjaban, Agartala, West Tripura,
Pin- 799010.
2. The Director,
Director of Secondary Education,
Government of Tripura, Office Lane, Agartala, West Tripura
Pin- 799001.
3. The District Education Officer,
West District Zonal Office, Agartala, Tripura,
Pin- 799006
…….Respondent(s).
For Petitioner(s)
: Mr. Elembrok Debbarma, Adv,
Mr. Akbar Debbarma, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
: Mr. Kohinoor N. Bhattacharyya, G.A.
Date of Hearing
Date of delivery of
Judgment and Order
Whether fit for
: 19.01.2026
Reporting
: YES
: 28.01.2026
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
Heard Learned Counsel, Mr. E. Debbarma appearing
on behalf of the petitioner and also heard Learned G.A., Mr. K.
N. Bhattacharyya appearing on behalf of the respondents.
02.
This writ petition is filed by the petitioner praying
for directing the respondents to allow the petitioner to
reimburse the medical expenses amounting to Rs.14,60,400/and the travel allowances of Rs.34,347/- incurred by the
petitioner for the purpose of treatment of her dependent-son at
Apollo Hospital, Kolkata.
03.
According to Learned Counsel for the petitioner, the
petitioner is a Group-B, Government Employee serving as
Headmistress at R.K. Ganj High School, Dukli, West Tripura,
under the department of Secondary Education, Government of
Tripura. The petitioner is the mother of her dependent-son,
Shri Salka Debbarma aged 28 years, who has been suffering
from
chronic
liver
disease
with
upper
Gastro
Intestinal
complications. According to Learned Counsel, on 21.03.2024
the petitioner‟s dependent-son was admitted to AGMC & GBP
Hospital due to critical nature of his health condition and
thereafter, on 24.03.2024 upon the recommendation of the
State Medical Board, AGMC & GBP Hospital, Agartala, he was
referred to Apollo Hospital, Kolkata for advanced treatment.
Accordingly, the dependent-son of the petitioner was admitted
at Apollo Hospital, Kolkata on 24.03.2024. In support of his
contention, Learned Counsel relied upon Annexure-4, i.e. the
certificate of the State Referral Board. At Kolkata Hospital the
son of the petitioner was admitted w.e.f. 24.03.2024 to
16.04.2024
wherein
he
undergone
surgery
and
medical
treatment and for the purpose of treatment the total medical
expenditure incurred was Rs.14,60,400/- and at the time of
shifting the son of the petitioner, the petitioner had to arrange
an escort of doctor, oxygen cylinder with complete medical
system as advised by the State Medical Board. After that as
the treatment at Kolkata Hospital did not yield satisfactory
result, so, the petitioner had to approach in institute of liver
and Biliary Sciences, New Delhi and consulted doctors therein.
On 29.07.2024 the petitioner submitted an application for
medical reimbursement amounting to Rs.14,60,400/- which
was received by the authority. As the physical condition of the
son of the petitioner was not improved, so, the petitioner had
to arrange for his treatment at Delhi for liver transplantation
for which cost of Rs.18,45,000/- was incurred and the
petitioner had to manage the entire amount by borrowing
money from his relatives. After that the petitioner submitted
written application to the District Education Officer, West
District requesting for imbursement of Rs.14,60,400/- and on
07.10.2024, she submitted another application to the authority
for reimbursement of travelling allowances amounting to
Rs.34,347/-. But the Joint Director, Directorate of Secondary
Education by a memo dated 14.11.2024 (Annexure-10)
rejected the claim of the petitioner on the ground that the son
of the petitioner was aged about 28 years and as per rule he is
not entitled to get the same. Thus, the petitioner was
compelled to file this writ petition before this Court seeking the
relief.
Learned Counsel at the time of hearing further
drawn the attention of the Court the memorandum dated
22.12.2022
issued
by
the
Health
and
Family
Welfare
Department, (Annexure-9) Government of Tripura wherein in
sub-clause-a it is provided as under:
GOVERNMENT OF TRIPURA
HEALTH & FAMILY WELFARE DEPARTMENT
No. F. 2(10-43A)-DHS/ESTT/MR/2022
Dated, 22. 12. 2022
MEMORANDUM
Subject : - Re-imbursement facility to the State Government
employees of medical expenditure incurred by the employees for
treatment inside/outside the State.
With a view to simplify and streamline the operational guidelines
of medical re-imbursement facility for the eligible State government
employees, the Council of Minister's has examined the existing
provision and in supersession/partial modification of all existing
guidelines as follows:
[ G.O. No.236, G.O. No.237, dated 25-10-2013, G.O. No.267, G.O.
No.100, dated 04-01-2012, G.O. No. 469, dated 15-12-2015, File
No.F.5(10)-FIN(G)/75-1, dated 09-08-2005 and 01-08-2007, 18-092013. File No. F.8(3)-FIN(G)/2000, dated 29-04-2010, F.2(10-43A)MS/Estt/MR/07
(part-I),
dated
20-08-2009,
F.2(10-43A)MS/Estt/MR/08(sub),
dated
25-03-2011,
F.2(10-43A)MS/Estt/MR/2016, dated 05-10-2016 , F.2(10-43A)-MS/Estt/MR/2016
, dated 10-01-2019 and 18-06-2019, F.2(10-43A)-MS/Estt/MR/2012, .
F.2(10-43A)-, 10-06-2019, F.2(10-43A)-MS/Estt/MR/2019, dated 0609-2019 and 27-03-2020.]
The Governor, Tripura is pleased to lay down following guidelines
with regards to admissibility of medical expenses to State
Government Officials inside/outside the State.
a) Group-A and Group-B officials of the State Government employees
and their dependent family members when referred by the Standing
Medical Board to a particular listed referral institution/hospital as
Annexed (A) for medical treatment but undertakes the treatment at
some other Institution/Hospital of his/her own choice/volition,
he/she shall be entitled to get reimbursement for
treatment/investigation(s) undertaken at the rates of their referred
institution including journey expenses for the purpose as existing T.A.
Rules.
It was also submitted that since the Apollo Hospital
was approved by the State Referral Board as referral hospital,
so, the petitioner is entitled to get the reimbursement of the
said expenses. Learned Counsel also submitted that in this
regard,
a
certificate
has
been
issued
by
SDM,
Sadar
(Annexure-11) dated 15.05.2025 from which it appears that
the son of the petitioner was dependent upon her and
according to Learned Counsel, since Annexure-11, i.e. the
certificate of dependent supports the memo dated 22.12.2022
and as such there was no justification on the part of the
respondents to deny the claim of the petitioner. It was further
submitted
by
Learned
Counsel
that
in
the
said
policy
(Annexure-9) dated 22.12.2022 there was no indication of
any age limit regarding dependency and even the term
„dependent‟ is not defined in the said policy. It was further
submitted that though the respondents have relied upon the
Central
Services
Medical
Attendance
Rule
and
Government of India memorandum dated 25.02.2009, but the
same is applicable only in respect of Central Government
Employees. But here in the case in hand, the petitioner is a
State Government Employee, so, without adoption of the same
there is no scope to apply the Central Rules until and unless it
is
adopted.
memorandum
Learned
Counsel
further
dated
16.11.1982
relied
submitted
that
upon
the
by
respondents does not impose any age limit, rather the said
memorandum deals with authorized doctors, fee structures and
procedure of treatment, nor it indicates „family‟ and no age
limit is mentioned therein and since the State referral board
granted expost-facto referral on 22.05.2024 which has not
been objected by the respondents, so, there was no ground to
deny the same. So, the action of the respondents is arbitrary
and violative of Article 14 and 21. Further, Learned Counsel
submitted that the cited case of the CAT as referred by the
respondents is distinguishable, so, the same cannot be applied
in this case. The State-respondents have contested the case by
filing counter-affidavit denying the assertions of the petitioner.
In the counter-affidavit it was specifically stated that the State
of Tripura by memorandum dated 16.11.1982 has adopted the
Central Services Medical Attendance Rule, 1944 and as per the
Central Services Medical Attendance Rule the petitioner is not
entitled to get the benefit of medical reimbursement for her
son, since he has attained the age of 28 years and the
definition of „family‟ clearly excludes the entitlement of the son
beyond 25 years. In addition to that the State-respondents
along with the counter-affidavit relied upon one memorandum
dated 25.02.2009 issued by the Deputy Secretary to the
Government of India, Ministry of Health and Family Welfare
(Annexure-2) which excludes the entitlement of son above 25
years and also relied upon one judgment of the Central
Administrative
Tribunal,
in
case
No.TR
07/2012
dated
27.03.2014 (Annexure-3).
04.
At the time of hearing, Learned G.A. appearing on
behalf of the State-respondents submitted that since the State
of Tripura has adopted the Central Services Medical Attendance
Rule 1944 by memorandum dated 16.11.1982 which excludes
the entitlement of the son of the present petitioner being aged
about 28 years at the time of filing the writ petition. So, clause
(a) of memo dated 22.12.2022 would not attract the case of
the present petitioner.
05.
Heard both the sides. Since there is no dispute on
record that the State of Tripura has adopted the Central
Services Medical Attendance Rule, 1944 by a memorandum
dated 16.11.1982. So, here in this writ petition, we are to
decide whether the petitioner of the instant writ petition is
entitled to reimburse the medical expenses incurred for the
treatment of her son who is aged about 28 years. From the
documents referred by the parties, it appears that in none of
the documents the definition of „family‟ is mentioned. In this
regard, Swamy‟s compilation of Medical Attendance Rules in
the caption “Concession for families”, the term „family‟ has
been defined, which reads as under:
I. Definition of Family
1. General conditions. --The term 'family' for the purpose of the
Centr Services (Medical Attendance) Rules, 1944, shall mean a
Government servant's wife or husband, as the case may be,
and parents, sisters, widowed sisters, widowed daughters,
minor brothers, children, stepchildren divorced/separated
daughters and stepmother wholly dependent upon the
Government servant and are normally residing with the
Government servant.
NOTE 1.-- A member of the family is treated as dependant only
if hishe income from all sources including pension and pension
equivalent of DCRG benefit and exclusive of Dearness Relief on
pension sanctioned after December, 1995 and Dearness
Pension sanctioned from 1-4-2004 is less than 1,500 p.m. The
condition of dependency both in the case of the husband or the
wife of the Government servant has been dispensed with.
NOTE 2.-- The residential condition for members of families of
a Govern-dance and treatment even if they do not stay with
the Government servant. servant having been waived, family
members may have medical Recanting Parents, please see
Para. 2 (b).- AUTHORS.
(a) Age-limits of dependent son/daughter.(i)Son
Till he starts earning or attains the
age of 25 years or gets married,
whichever is earlier.
(ii) Daughter
Till she starts earning or gets
married, irrespective of the agelimit, whichever is earlier.
(iii)Son suffering from any permanent
disability of any kind (physical or mental).
Irrespective of age-limit
(iv)Dependent divorced/abandoned or
separated from their husband/
widowed daughters and dependent
unmarried /divorced/abandoned
or separated from their husband
/widowed sisters.
Irrespective of age-limit
(v) Minor brother(s).
Up to the age of becoming a major.
This order will take effect from the date of issue of the Office
Memorandum.
This order would also be applicable to Central Government
employees vered under Central Services (Medical Attendance) Rules,
1944.
This issues with the concurrence of IFD vide their Dy. No. 2552/2007,
dated the 15th May, 2007.
From the aforesaid definition of the „family‟, it
appears that the entitlement of the son is mentioned as under:
(a) Age-limits of dependent son/daughter.(i)Son
Till he starts earning or attains the
age of 25 years or gets married,
whichever is earlier.
From the aforesaid definition, it appears that by the
said rules, it is specifically mentioned that the said order of
definition of „family‟ would apply to Central Government
Employees covered under Central Services (Medical Attendance
Rules, 1944). Now, since the State of Tripura has adopted the
said Central Services Medical Attendance Rules by notification
dated 16.11.1982 which is still followed. So, in view of the said
rule it is found that the dependent-son of the petitioner aged
more than 25 years is not entitled to medical coverage by the
Government
servant.
Furthermore,
the
memo
dated
25.02.2009 issued by the Deputy Secretary to the Government
of India, Ministry of Health & Family Welfare, Department of
Health & Family Welfare (Annexure R-2) relied upon by the
respondents, it also excludes the son aged about more than 25
years from the coverage of medical facilities. So, in pursuance
of memo dated 22.12.2022 (Annexure-9) relied upon by the
petitioner, the present petitioner is not entitled to get benefit
of medical reimbursement of her son as prayed for, who
according to her is depending upon her income.
Hon‟ble the Apex Court in a judgment in State of
Punjab and Others vs. Ram Lubhaya Bagga and Others
dated 26.02.1998 reported in (1998) 4 SCC 117, wherein in
para No.25 observed as under:
“25. Now we revert to the last submission,
whether the new State policy is justified in not
reimbursing an employee, his full medical
expenses incurred on such treatment, if incurred in
any hospital in India not being a government
hospital in Punjab. Question is whether the new
policy which is restricted by the financial
constraints of the State to the rates in AIIMS
would be in violation of Article 21 of the
Constitution of India. So far as questioning the
validity of governmental policy is concerned in our
view it is not normally within the domain of any
court, to weigh the pros and cons of the policy or
to scrutinize it and test the degree of its beneficial
or equitable disposition for the purpose of varying,
modifying or annulling it, based on howsoever
sound and good reasoning, except where it is
arbitrary or violative of any constitutional,
statutory or any other provision of law. When
Government forms its policy, it is based on a
number of circumstances on facts, law including
constraints based on its resources. It is also based
on expert opinion. It would be dangerous if court is
asked to test the utility, beneficial effect of the
policy or its appraisal based on facts set out on
affidavits. The court would dissuade itself from
entering into this realm which belongs to the
executive. It is within this matrix that it is to be
seen whether the new policy violates Article 21
when it restricts reimbursement on account of its
financial constraints.”
From the above observation, it appears that it is not
within the domain of the Court to weigh the pros and cons of
the policy or to scrutinize it and test the degree of its beneficial
or equitable disposition for the purpose of varying, modifying
or annulling it, based on howsoever sound and good reasoning,
except where it is arbitrary or violative of constitutional,
statutory or other provision of law.
06.
Since, the petitioner has failed to satisfy the Court
by showing any extent rule of the State that the son of the
petitioner aged about 28 years would be entitled to medical
coverage. As such this Court does not find any scope to grant
any relief in favour of the petitioner in absence of any statutory
rule.
07.
In the result, the writ petition filed by the petitioner
stands dismissed being devoid of merit. The petitioner is not
entitled to get any relief in this petition. No order is passed as
to costs.
With this observation, this writ petition stands
disposed of.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed
of.
JUDGE
PURNITA DEB
Purnita
Date: 2026.01.29 18:14:22 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review