Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
JOHN
JOHN TELEN KOM
2026.06.01
TELEN KOM Date:
19:18:36 +05'30'
ca
Sl. Nos. 1 & 2 (suppl.)
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WP(C)No.395 of 2026
1. Smt. Smita Ngairangbam, aged about 39 years old, D/o Ngairangbam
Iboyaima Singh, resident of Nagamapal Kangjabi Leirak Machin, PO
Imphal & PS Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur-795004.
2. Smt. Arambam Kalpana Devi, aged about 40 years old D/o (Late) A.,
Mani Singh, resident of Thangmeiband Hijam Leikai, PO Imphal & P.S.
Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur-795004.
3. Shri Moirangthem Goroba Singh, aged about 35 years old S.o M.
Tamphajao Singh, resident of Langathel Mamang Leikai, P.O.
Wangjing & PS Khongjom Thoubal District, Manipur-795148.
4. Shri Kadamba Leitanthem, aged about 31 years old, S/o Rajen
Leitanthem, resident of Langmeidong Bazar, Burmah Sugnu Road, PO
Kakching & PS Waikhong, Kakching District, Manipur-795103.
5. Km. Konsam Sony Devi, aged about 26 years old D/o Konsam Gokul
Singh, resident of Khurai Konsam Leikai PO Lamlong & PS Imphal East
Imphal East District, Manipur-795010.
6. Shri Leishangthem Nongthang Singh, aged about 39 years old, S/o L.
Sovachandra Singh, resident of Mongshangei School Leirak, PO
Canchipur & P. S. Singjamei, Imphal West District, Manipur-795003.
7. Km. Sanathoibi Chongtham, aged about 30 years old, D/o Ch.
Priyokumar Meitei, resident of Nagamapal Chungkham Leirak, PO
Imphal & PS Singjamei, Imphal West District, Manipur-795001.
8. Km. Monika Saikhom, aged about 31 years old, D/o S. Priyokumar
Singh, resident of Sagolband Sayang Kuraomakhong, PO Imphal &
P.S. Lamphel, Imphal West District, Manipur-795001.
9. Km. Laishram Onida Devi, aged about 25 years old, D/o L. Basanta
Meitei, resident of Sayang Konthoujam Leikai, PO Imphal & P.S.
Lamphel, Imphal West District, Manipur-795001.
10. Smt. Leishichon Tallanao, aged about 43 years old, W/o Tharmingam
Khangrah, resident of Sihai Khullen Village, Sihai, PO Ukhrul & P.S.
Ukhrul, Ukhrul District, Manipur-795142.
11. Shri Simba Aheibam, aged about 30 years old, S/A. Romeo Singh,
resident of Heirangoithong Aheibam Leirak, Ahongshangbam Leikai,
PO Singjamei & PS Singjamei, Imphal West District, Manipur-795008.
12. Km. Laishram Jumila Devi, aged about 27 years old, D/o L. Joy Singh,
resident Thanga Ithing, PO Moirang & P.S. Keibul, Bishnupur District,
Manipur-795005.
13. Smt. Wangkhem Geeta Devi, aged about 41 years old, W/o
Konjengbam Bankim Singh, resident of Wangkhei Khunou, PO
Porompat & PS. Porompat, Imphal East District, Manipur-795005.
14. A Loha, aged about 41 years old, D/o L. Adani, resident of Bazar
Colony, Makhrelui, PO Senapati & P.S. Senapati, Senapati District,
Manipur-795106.
15. H Theirila Thangal D/o H. Hopeson, resident of Tumnoupokpi, PO
Kalapahar, P.S., Kangpokpi, Kangpokpi District, Manipur-795122.
Petitioners
Vs.
1. Manipur Public Service Commission, represented by the Secretary
MPSC, North AOC, Imphal East, Pin-795001.
2. The State of Manipur, represented by the Chief Secretary, Secretariat
South Block, Babupara, Imphal West, Manipur, Pin No: 795001.
3. Directorate of Handlooms & Textiles through the Director,
Government of Manipur, Lamphelpat, PO & PS Lamphel, Imphal West
District, Manipur-795001.
Respondents
With
MC(WP(C)) No.413 of 2026
BEFORE
HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. M. SUNDAR
HON’BLE MR JUSTICE AHANTHEM BIMOL SINGH
(ORDER)
(Order of the Court was made by Mr. M. Sundar, CJ)
01.06.2026
[1]
The following abbreviations/short forms have been used in this
order:
Sl.
No.
Abbreviation/Short
Form/other references
for
the
sake
of
brevity/convenience
and/or clarity
1.
MPSC
Manipur
Commission
said Rules
Manipur
Public
Service
Commission
(Procedure
&
Conduct of business), Rules 2011.
3.
WP
Writ Petition
4.
MC
Miscellaneous Case
[2]
Full Form/Expansion
Public
Service
Captioned WP and captioned MC thereat are in the Admission
Board. Mr. Keisham Kishan Singh, learned counsel on record for 15(fifteen)
writ petitioners is before this Court.
[3]
Factual matrix in a nutshell i.e., short facts shorn of
details/elaboration not imperative for appreciating instant order are that
MPSC issued a notification qua direct recruitment to 24(twenty) vacancies in
10(ten) different posts vide advertisement/notification dated 10.10.2024
bearing
Advt.No.08/2022;
that
pursuant
to
the
recruitment
notification/advertisement, the writ petitioners before this Court applied; that
the writ petitioners sat for recruitment examinations on 15.03.2026 (wrongly
mentioning as 13.03.2026 in paragraph 3 of the writ affidavit and learned
counsel for writ petitioners submits that this is a typographical error); that
thereafter the results of the written examinations were published; that MPSC
issued a notification dated 13.05.2026 bearing reference No.7/2/2022-
MPSC(DR)(Vol-II) notifying that interviews will be held on 26.05.2026; that
thereafter MPSC issued another notification dated 20.05.2026 bearing
reference No.7/02/2022-MPSC(DR) postponing the interview until further
orders; that MPSC issued a further notification dated 27.05.2026 bearing
reference No. 7/2/2022-MPSC(DR) fixing the interview on 06.06.2026 (this
weekend i.e., Saturday); that at this juncture, the writ petitioners have filed
captioned WP in this Court on 30.05.2026 inter-alia with a prayer to quash/set
aside the written examinations conducted on 15.03.2026 pursuant to
advertisement/notification dated 10.10.2024 besides assailing said Rules
insofar as it does not prescribe procedures (according to writ petitioners)
regarding safeguarding of question papers/booklets and also assailing certain
specific provisions of said Rules pertaining to question paper setting; that it
is to be noted that there is also one limb of prayer seeking appointment of
an independent ‘Facts Finding Committee’ qua alleged procedural lapses in
conduct of written examination (to be noted, procedural lapses according to
writ petitioners); that captioned WP and captioned MC are in the Admission
Board today as already alluded to in the earlier part of this factual matrix
narration.
[4]
Mr. Keisham Kishan Singh, learned counsel for writ petitioners
submits that on 15.03.2026 when the written examination was held and when
the writ petitioners admittedly took the written examination, they found that
question booklets distributed to candidates were already unsealed/opened.
Learned counsel for writ petitioners draws our attention to paragraph 8 of
the writ affidavit which read as follows:
‘8. That during the conduct of the examination on 15.03.2026, the
petitioners and many other candidates found that the Question
Booklets distributed to the candidates were already unsealed/opened
despite the clear printed instruction on the first page of the Question
Booklet stating: “Do not open this Question Booklet seal until
you are told to do so” ‘
Learned counsel for writ petitioners further draws our attention
to said Rules, more particularly Rule 26 (A) I and sub-rule (v) thereat.
Learned counsel, predicating on this Rule his campaign qua prayers in the
captioned WP, adverting to this sub-rule (v) of Rules 26 (A) I of said Rules
submitted that the outer envelop has to be sealed with wax and the
Chairman/Member has to put his signature at the opening edges of the
envelop but this according to writ petitioners was not done and it was also
submitted that signatures of the Supervisors were not affixed in the answer
sheets. To be noted, this Court finds that invigilators have signed but learned
counsel submitted that invigilators are different from Supervisors.
[5]
This Court carefully considered the case of the writ petitioners
predicated inter-alia on afore-referred submissions. This Court finds that
entire captioned WP is based on alleged irregularities in conduct of written
examination on 15.03.2026. This means that the writ petitioners were fully
aware of the alleged irregularities in conduct of written examinations on
15.03.2026 itself but the writ petitioners have chosen to wait for publication
of the results of the written examinations, found themselves unsuccessful but
further waited for notification of MPSC (to be noted, multiple notifications
fixing, adjourning and re-scheduling) viva-voice/interview on 06.06.2026 and
have filed the captioned
WP in this Court day before yesterday i.e., on
30.05.2026 (Saturday). This in the considered opinion of this Court is clearly
an eleventh hour nay 59th minute of eleventh attempt to assail, may be derail
the recruitment proceedings after having participated in the written
examinations and not having raised any issue regarding alleged irregularities
qua written examinations on 15.03.2026.
[6]
This Court finds that the said Rules are Rules of the year 2011,
the same has been amended multiple times i.e., on 22.5.2017, 04.05.2020,
14.08.2020
and
07.09.2020.
Said
Rules
which
governed
the
notification/advertisement made on 10.10.2024 continue to operate. Writ
petitioners responded to the notification and applied. Thereafter, there has
been no amendment to said Rules. In this scenario, the writ petitioners
without even assailing said Rules participated in the written examinations on
15.03.2026. The writ petitioners further waited for the results of the written
examinations to be published. Post publication of written examination results,
interview was notified, adjourned, re-notified and when it is scheduled to be
held on 06.06.2026 for the successful candidates, writ petitioners have
rushed to this Court, more particularly when there has been no further
amendment
to
said
Rules
which
is
operating
from
date
of
advertisement/notification in October of 2024 and continues to operate.
[7]
In the above regard, this Court respectfully reminds itself of the
principle laid down by Hon’ble Supreme Court in a long line of authorities
including of Madan Lal & Others Vs. State of J & K & Others reported
in (1995) 3 SCC 486. On facts, Madan Lal is a matter pertaining to
recruitment of Munsifs in Jammu & Kashmir and candidates after taking
written examination and after participating in viva-voice, finding themselves
unsuccessful and when they found that their cumulative scores in the written
examination and viva-voice were not good enough to get recruited rushed to
the Court assailing the entire process. In this factual backdrop, Hon’ble
Supreme Court made it clear that candidates who find themselves to have
not emerged successful and only because the results are not palatable cannot
turn around and subsequently contend that the recruitment process was not
properly done. This Court finds that on facts Madan Lal is a matter where
the aspirants/candidates participated in written examination as well as vivavoice,
thereafter found their cumulative scores not good enough to be
recruited and rushed to the Court. In the case at hand, the candidates have
come to Court after participating in the written examinations when the
interview for the successful candidates is in the anvil (06.06.2026) though
they had all the time in the world to approach this Court. In this case, this
Court deems it appropriate to write that as already alluded to supra, the
entire captioned WP is predicated on alleged irregularities in conduct of
written examinations on 15.03.2026 and what according to writ petitioners
are certain lapses and lacunae in said Rules which have been operating from
2011 which was last amended in 2020 (07.09.2020 to be precise) and
obviously remains unchanged from date of notification (10.10.2024) to date.
[8]
This Court also finds that the writ petitioners have not chosen
to array the successful candidates (in the written examinations) as corespondents.
[9]
Ergo, the sequitur of the narration, discussion and dispositive
reasoning thus far is that this Court finds that the captioned WP does not
pass muster in the Admission Board. The further sequitur is, captioned WP
fails to pass muster in the Admission Board and the same is dismissed.
Consequently, captioned MC thereat also perishes with captioned WP. This
Court restrains itself and refrains from imposing costs.
JUDGE
CHIEF JUSTICE
FR/NFR
John Kom
P.S. I : Upload forthwith.
P.S. II : All concerned to act on web copy of this proceedings/order uploaded in
official website of High Court.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review