Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
Present:The Hon’ble Justice Supratim Bhattacharya
SA 111 of 2022
Sk. Abdul Alim.
Vs.
Sri Tarak Das & Ors.
For the Appellant
: Mr. Buddhadeb Ghosal
Md. Younush Mondal
For the Respondents : Mr. Saptangshu Basu
Mr. Shayak Chakraborty
Mr. Md. Siraj Munir
Mr. Abdul Zahid
Delivered On
: 15.10.2026
Supratim Bhattacharya, J.:
1. Factual Matrix
Before the Trial Court
The
factual matrix of the lis is that a Title Suit bearing No. 20 of 2017
seeking recovery of khas possession
has been filed
on behalf of the
appellant namely Sk. Abdul Alim.
Through the plaint the appellant plaintiff has submitted that at the
premises number 5/2 Rifle Range Road Police station Karaya
cottahs of land with structure
there is 3
which is mentioned in schedule A of the
plaint. In the schedule B of the plaint there is mention of one tile shed room
having brick wall on the roof of the ground floor.
The appellant plaintiff through the plaint has sought for eviction of the
respondents defendants on the ground of trespass and has also prayed for
permanent injunction.
The
respondents defendants No. 1, 2 and 3 namely Tarak Das, Kumari
Mampi Das ad Smt. Bulbuli Das entered appearance and filed their written
statement while
the defendant No 4 before the Trial Court has not
contested the case. Through the written statement the defendants
respondents have controverted the pleadings mentioned in the plaint.
The Ld. Civil Judge (Sr. Divn.) 2nd Court, Alipore decreed the said suit on
contest in part against the defendants No. 1 to 3 and ex parte against the
defendant no. 4.
Before the Ld. First Appellate Court
Being aggrieved by and dissatisfied with the said judgment, the defendants/
respondents preferred Title Appeal before the Ld. District Judge at Alipore
bearing Title Appeal No. 5 of 2020. The First Appellate court after hearing
the parties has been pleased to pass the following order:
“Hence it is
ORDERED
That the Appeal be and the same is allowed on contest
against the Respondents. The Judgment and Decree of
Title Suit No. 20 of 2017 of Civil Judge (Senior Division)
2ndCourt
ofAlipore
made in suit property from the
defendant as passed by the Ld. Trial Judge is hereby
reversed and set aside. The suit filed by the RespondentsPlaintiffs are dismissed. No. Cost
Let a copy of judgment be sent to the Ld. Trial Judge”
Being aggrieved by and dissatisfied with the aforementioned impugned
order the appellant has preferred the present appeal.
2. During the admission of the present second appeal
the following
substantial questions of law have been framed :
“1) Whether the Court of Appeal below was justified in reversing
the judgment and Decree of the trial Court solely on the ground of
res judicata without ascertaining whether in an earlier suit filed
by the defendant/respondent for injunction, there was any
service of or summons upon the appellant or they contested the
said proceeding and suffered the Decree?
2) Whether the Court of appeal below was justified in applying
the principle of res judicata solely on the ground that the
proceeding as proforma defendant and, therefore, such judgment
and decree is binding upon him.
3) Whether the principle of res judicata can be extended to a
party against whom no relief was claimed in earlier suit?”
3. Ld. Senior counsel namely Mr. Buddhadeb Ghosal being assisted by Md.
Younush Mondal, the learned Counsel
representing the
appellant
during his exhaustive argument has submitted the following;
i)
That the appellant is an absolute owner of the suit land
including premises being 5/2 Rifle Rage Road PS Karaya Kolkata
measuring about 2 cottahs 13 chitaks 40 sq. ft.
ii)
He has further submitted that the name of the appellant is
recorded in the Kolkata Municipal Corporation after the same
being purchased on 07.01.2005 vide deed No. 05654/2017
iii)
The Ld. Counsel has also submitted that one Anwar Jahan was
the erstwhile owner who sold the property in favour of Fulbasia
and Jogmaya in the year 1939 and after their demise
Anandomohan got the property and thereafter
the present
appellant became the owner of the said land.
iv)
It is therefore submitted that the respondents defendants have
no right title and interest over the suit property as because they
are the legal heirs of the caretaker namely Sagar Das. He has
further submitted that Sagar Das was the caretaker in respect
of the suit property and
had no document regarding right,
title and interest.
v)
The Ld. Counsel has also submitted that earlier a suit has been
disposed of ex parte against one Debasis Ghosh a promoter
without deciding the matter on merit and no issue was framed in
the said former suit.
vi)
The Ld. Counsel has further submitted that the Ld. Trial Judge
was correct
in passing the decree in favour of the appellant
while the Ld. First Appellate Court has erroneously allowed the
first appeal (title appeal) on the ground of res judicata as
because the caretaker had no document to substantiate any
right, title and interest in respect of the suit land and Ananda
Mohan
from whom the present appellant purchased the
property had nothing against him to defend.
vii)
Ld. Counsel has again submitted that there was no prayer
against the said Ananda Mohan.
viii)
He has then submitted that the said Ananda Mohan was a
proforma defendant in the said suit (Title Suit 24 of 1997).
ix)
Ld. Counsel has submitted that the respondents No. 1,2 and 3
re the main contesting parties and particularly the Respondent
No. 3 is the daughter in law of Sagar Das and mother of the
respondent No. 2.
x)
He has further submitted that Sagar Das never demanded the
said land during his lifetime and even his son, daughter and the
wife of said Sagar Das never claimed themselves to be the owner
of the property, it is the third generation of Sagar Das who are
claiming themselves to be owners of the said property on the
basis of possession. They do not have any document to
substantiate their right, title and interest except ration card
voter card, Aadhar card and tax receipts and electricity bill.
xi)
The Ld. Senior Counsel has also submitted that respondent nos.
1 2 and 3 had filed an earlier title suit being Title Suit No. 24 of
1997 before the Ld. Civil Judge (Jr. Divn.) 2nd Court Alipore
praying for
a) A decree for permanent injunction restraining the
defendant No.1 from having forceful possession of the
suit property and from disturbing
the peaceful
possession of the plaintiffs in respect of the suit
property
b) A decree for cost of the suit
c) A decree for any other relief/reliefs.
xii)
He has submitted that in the aforementioned title suit
the
vendor of the appellant was made a proforma defendant and
service was not effected upon him
and there was no prayer
against the said proforma defendant
xiii) He has then submitted that the respondents have admitted that
Ananda Mohan the vendor of the appellant had 3/4th share over
the suit property and in the record of the corporation
the name
of Ananda Mohan was recorded as absolute owner and presently
the appellants are the absolute owner of the suit land.
xiv)
Ld. Counsel has again submitted that the said suit being No. 24
of 1997
was disposed of ex parte
by restraining the said
promoter Debasis Ghosh
xv)
He has further submitted that no issue was framed in the said
earlier suit and
the said suit was disposed of without going
into the merit of the case.
xvi)
Ld. Counsel stressed upon the point that the respondents
fraudulently filed another title suit being title suit No.8 of 2005
(Tarak Das and Ors. Vs. Ananda Mohan and Ors.) seeking
declaration, partition and permanent injunction before the Ld.
Civil Judge (Sr. Divn.) 2nd Court at Alipore and in the said title
suit Tarak Das Kumari Mampi Das, Smt. Bulbuli Dasi, Smt.
Bishnu Dasi
and Sonarani Dasi were plaintiffs
Mohan Das, Sk. Abdul Alim, Gopal Das ,
and Ananda
Smt. Sobha Das,
Ghanashyam Das, Smt. Bina Das and Smt. Rama were made
defendants. In the said suit the defendants No. 1 and 2 filed a
counter claim
seeking
eviction of the plaintiff No.5 Sonarani
Dasi who was the widow of Sagar Das, who was in possession of
the room mentioned in schedule B..
xvii) He has further submitted that during the pendency of the said
suit Sonarani Dasi expired and the said suit has been ultimately
dismissed on 23.02.2016 on the ground
that the plaintiffs
therein /respondents herein had failed to establish the said suit
in their favour and at the same time counter claim was also
rejected.
xviii) Ld. Counsel then submitted that Ananda Mohan the vendor of
the appellant and
Sk. Abdul Alim
the appellant
had filed
another suit being title suit No. 17 of 2009 seeking declaration
of title and permanent injunction before the Ld. Civil Judge (Sr.
Divn) 4th Court at Alipore which has also been dismissed without
any declaration.
xix)
He has further submitted that Fulbasia and Jogmaya were the
owners of the suit property in equal share by way of purchase.
He has further submitted that after the death of Fulbasia and
Jogmaya
the vendor of the appellant namely Ananda Mohan
became the absolute owner of the suit property and the said
Ananda Mohan having sold the entire property in favour of the
present appellant the appellant herein has become the absolute
owner in respect of the suit property
xx)
The Ld. Counsel representing the appellant
has relied upon
the following authorities which are published at
i) AIR 1968 Calcutta 550
ii) AIR 1975 Calcutta 200
iii) (2012) 6 SCC 430
Banking upon the aforementioned facts and circumstances and
relying upon the authorities the Ld. Senior Counsel has prayed
for setting aside the impugned judgment passed by the Ld. First
Appellate court in Title Appeal No. 5 of 2020 and has further
submitted that declaration in respect of the suit property has
not been decided by any court of law
prior to the present
litigation as such the principle of res judicata will not apply. He
has further submitted that the LD. First Appellate Court has
erred in law in allowing the first appeal and setting aside the
decree passed by the trial court on the basis of res judicata.
4. Per contra, Ld. Senior Counsel Mr. Saptangshu Basu being assisted by
Mr.
Shayak
Chakraborty
and
Mr.
Abdul
Zahid,
Ld.
Counsels
representing the respondents has submitted the following:
i)
He has submitted that the First Appellate Court in Title Appeal
No. 5 of 2020 has reversed the judgment and decree
dated
11.12.2019 passed by the Ld. Trial Judge in Title suit No. 20 of
2017 on the ground that the issue raised in the present lis that
is title suit No. 20 of 2017 cannot be re-agitated in the present
suit as
the issue of title has been decided
order of eviction
which
while passing an
has been decided in
the previously
instituted titile suit No. 24 of 1997 filed by the
respondents
defendants herein wherein the predecessor of the plaintiff was a
party. Thus, applying the principle of res judicata the Ld. First
Appellate Court has allowed the title appeal.
ii)
He has further submitted that through the title suit No. 24 of
1997 which was filed by the defendants there were prayers for
a) decree of permanent injunction restraining the defendant No.
1 from taking forcible possession of the suit property and from
disturbing the peaceful possession of the plaintiffs.
b) decree for all costs of the suits.
c) decree for any other relief /reliefs.
He has further submitted that while deciding such a suit
a
court is required to decide the question of title.
iii)
He has also submitted that through the judgment passed in title
suit No 24 of 1997 the Ld. Court had expressly decided the title
in respect of the suit property in favour of the plaintiffs therein
who are the defendants respondents herein.
iv)
He has then submitted that in view of the above findings in title
suit no. 24 of 1997 the Ld. First Appellate Court has rightly
held that the issues raised in the present suit are directly and
substantially the issues which have been decided in the earlier
suit being title suit No. 24 of 1997 as such
the Ld. First
appellate
suit
court
has
held
that
the
present
is
not
maintainable in the eye of law in view of the provisions of
Section 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
v)
The Ld. Senior Counsel has submitted that the Ld. First
Appellate Court has rightly reached the conclusion which has
given rise to the present second appeal.
vi)
He has further submitted that the principle of res judicata laid
down under Section 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 has
been rightly taken into consideration and the impugned
judgment is correct in the eye of law and does not require
interference.
vii)
The Ld. Counsel has relied upon the following decision which
have been published at
i) (2000) 3 SCC 350
ii) (2008) 4 SCC 594
Banking upon the aforestated facts and
circumstances and
relying upon the aforementioned authorities
the Ld. Senior
counsel has prayed for dismissal of the present second appeal.
5. From the aforementioned substantial questions of law framed it
transpires that the moot point in issue is as to whether the principle of
res judicata will apply or not in this round of lis, as because there has
been several suits involving the suit property between
the erstwhile
owners, predecessors and even between these contending parties.
6.
Sl
Name
of
No.1
Suit
Title Suit No. Minor
24 of 1997
the Parties
to Prayers
the Suit
the suit
in Reliefs granted
The
Decree
Tarak Das , plaintiff
Minor
prayed
of
injunction
for passed
was
against
Mampi Das permanent
the
defendant
and Bulbuli injunction.
No.
Das.
Ananda Mohan
Debasis
Vs.
but
was one of the
Ghosh,
pro-defendant
Ananda
in that suit and
Mohan,
that
Bishnu Das
decided in his
and
presence.
suit
was
Sonarani
Das.
Title Suit No. 8 Tarak Das , This
of 2005
is
a The
plaintiffs
Kumari
suit
Mampi
declaration, establish
Das,
for failed
Smt. partition
Bullbuli
and
suit
to
the
in
favour
their
as such
Das , Smt. permanent
the suit was not
Bishnu Das injunction.
disposed of in
and
favour
Smt.
of
Sonarani
plaintiffs.
Das
Counter
Vs.
Ananda
of
Mohan
defendants
Das,
the
claim
the
Sk.
seeking eviction
Abdul Alim,
of plaintiff No.5
Gopal Das,
(Sonarani
Das)
Smt.
Sova
Das,
Sri
was
not
granted.
Ghanasyam
Das,
Smt.
Bina
Das,
Smt.
Kamala Lal,
Bhola
Lal,
Munna Lal,
Baby
Das,
Ruby Lal.
Title Suit No. Ananda
17 of 2009
This
Mohan and suit
Sk.
is
a The
Vs. and
Bulbuli
has
for been dismissed
Abdul declaration
Alim
suit
permanent
on
contest
against
the
defendants
No.
Das, Minor injunction.
1 to 3 and ex
Tarak Das,
parte
Minor
the
Mampi
No. 4,5 and 6
Das,
Bishnu
Smt.
against
defendants
without cost
Das, Sonali
Das
and
Debasis
Ghosh
From the chart/table above, the judgment of this Hon’ble Court can
proceed to deduce which earlier suit /proceeding on the self-same issue
by and between the same party or parties claiming under them will apply
on the point of res judicata or even, constructive res judicata, i.e. the
party could have taken the same point in the earlier /previous suit but
did not and hence it is barred from taking the point now.
7. In respect of this suit property there has been several litigations those
are laid down as follows:
i) First suit was Title Suit No. 24 of 1997. This suit was for permanent
injunction wherein Tarak Das , Mampi Das and Bulbuli Das had filed the
suit against one Debasis Ghosh, Ananda Mohan Das, Bishnu Das and
Sonarani Das. Debasis Ghosh is said to be a promoter/developer and
Anandamohan Das is the person from whom the present appellant
namely Sk. Abdul Alim is said to have purchased the property. In the
said suit issues had not been framed and an ex parte order of permanent
restraint was passed dated 25.04.2001.
ii) The second suit being Title Suit No. 8 of 2005 had been filed seeking
declaration, partition and permanent injunction. This suit was filed by
Tarak Das , Kumari Mampi Das, Bulbuli Das, Smt. Bishnu Das and Smt.
Sonarani Das against Ananda Mohan Das, Sk Abdul Alim, Gopal Das,
Sova Das, Ghanashyam Das, Bina Das , Kamala Lal, Bhola Lal, Munna
Lal, Baby Das and Ruby Lal.
The defendants in the said suit filed a counter claim for eviction. The
said suit was dismissed on contest without cost and the counter claim
was also dismissed. The Ld. Court had opined that the plaintiffs have
failed to establish the suit in their favour and the defendants are also
not entitled to get any relief.
iii) Thereafter another suit being Title Suit No. 17 of 2009 was filed
seeking declaration
and permanent injunction. The said suit was
initially filed by Ananda Mohan against Bulbuli Das , minor Tarak Das,
minor Mampi Das, Smt. Bishnu Das, Sonali Das , Debasis Ghosh being
principal defendants and Sk. Abdul Alim being proforma defendant.
Subsequently the proforma defendant namely Sk. Abdul Alim got
transposed to plaintiff No.2. This suit has also been dismissed.
Thus from the aforementioned details furnished as regards to the suits
involving the parties it transpires
that several suits have been filed
between the parties and among those suits the title suit No. 17 of 2009
was a suit for declaration and permanent injunction` and the said title
suit has been dismissed.
Thus, from the above it transpires that Ananda Mohan and Sk. Abdul
Alim,
that is the person from whom the present appellant is said to
have purchased the property and the present appellant, had preferred
the title suit seeking declaration which has been dismissed on contest.
8. Now this Court intends to deal with the issue of res judicata.
Section 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, deals with the issue of
res judicata. The said Section is laid down :
“11. Res judicata .No Court shall try any suit or issue in which the matter directly
and substantially in issue has been directly and substantially in
issue in a former suit between the same parties, or between
parties under whom they or any of them claim, litigating under the
same title, in a Court competent to try such subsequent suit or the
suit in which such issue has been subsequently raised, and has
been heard and finally decided by such Court.”
9. From the aforementioned Section it transpires that no court shall try
any suit or issue in which the matter directly and substantially in issue
has been directly and substantially in issue in a former suit between the
same parties , or between parties under whom they or any of them claim,
litigating under the same title, in a court competent to try such
subsequent suit or the suit in which such issue has been subsequently
raised and has been heard and finally decided by such court.
From the Title Suit 17 of 2009 it is evident that the issue of declaration
in respect of the suit property has been in issue in the said suit, which is
also the issue in the present lis being title Suit No 20 of 2017 wherein
the suit has been filed for recovery of khas possession. Once declaration
in respect of the suit property has been dealt with and finally decided
that cannot be reagitated through a subsequent suit and a subsequent
suit through which recovery of khas possession has been sought for also
involves the issue of title. If one has right, title and interest in respect of
the property then and only then he can seek recovery of khas possession.
The title suit No. 17 of 2009 was filed by the self-same appellant
plaintiff who along with another plaintiff is said to be the person from
whom the present appellant plaintiff has purchased the property. The
present appellant plaintiff is now seeking recovery of possession and
through the earlier suit being Title Suit 17 of 2009 this appellant plaintiff
along with
the person from whom he is said to have purchased the
property had sought for declaration and the said declaration been not
granted on the contrary has been dismissed cannot seek recovery of
possession by instituting a separate suit thereafter. The issue of title has
already been decided in the Title suit No. 17 of 2009 and that having
been not challenged has attained finality. It should have been agitated
before the higher forum and that not being done or preferred, by a
subsequent suit
the appellant plaintiff cannot seek recovery of
possession as such the principle of res judicata applies in the present
suit.
10.
Section 34 of the Specific Relief Act and Order II Rule 2 of the code
of Civil Procedure also comes into play.
In this context Order II Rule 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure is laid down
as follows:
“II. Suit to include the whole claim.
(1) Every suit shall include the whole of the claim which the
plaintiff is entitled to make in respect of the cause of action; but a
plaintiff may relinquish any portion of his claim in order to bring
the suit within the jurisdiction of any Court.
(2) Relinquishment of part of claim – Where a plaintiff omits to
sue in respect of, or intentionally relinquishes, any portion of his
claim, he shall not afterwards sue in respect of the portion so
omitted or relinquished.
(3) Omission to sue for one of several reliefs – A person entitled to
more than one relief in respect of the same cause of action may
sue for all or any of such reliefs; but if he omits, except with the
leave of the Court, to sue for all such reliefs, he shall not
afterwards sue for any relief so omitted.”
Section 34 of the Specific Relief Act is also laid down which staters that :
“34. Discretion of court as to declaration of status or right.—
Any person entitled to any legal character, or to any right as to
any property, may institute a suit against any person denying, or
interested to deny, his title to such character or right, and the
court may in its discretion make therein a declaration that he is
so entitled, and the plaintiff need not in such suit ask for any
further relief:Provided that no court shall make any such
declaration where the plaintiff, being able to seek further relief
than a mere declaration of title, omits to do so.”
Thus from Order II Rule 2 of the Civil Procedure Code and Section 34 of
the Specific Relief Act it is evident that a suit is to include the whole
claim where further relief is to be sought for then in that case a mere
declaration of title cannot be granted. Thus, in addition to
the
applicability of the principle of res judicata that is Section 11 of the CPC
the Order II rule 2 of the said Code and Section 34 of the Specific Relief
Act also comes into play. The present appellant/plaintiff is not entitled to
prefer/institute the present lis seeking recovery of possession once the
issue of title in respect of the self-same suit property been decided
against him.
11.
As regards to the substantial questions of law
those are being
dealt herein.
As regards to substantial question of law No.1
As no issue was framed in Title Suit No 24 of 1997 so issues have not
been dealt with. Through the said Title Suit No. 24 of 1997 only
permanent injunction was sought for
and there was no prayer for
declaration as such there being no issues framed and not dealt with
and there being no declaration sought for
and only permanent
injunction been prayed for, the principle of res judicata will not apply.
As regards to substantial questions of law No.2 and 3
The Title Suit No. 17 of 2009 being an earlier suit and through the said
suit declaration along with permanent injunction been sought for
by
Sk. Abdul Alim, appellant/plaintiff in the present suit and in the earlier
suit being transposed to plaintiff No.2 from proforma defendant No.7,
having been filed against the self-same defendants and
the issue
of
declaration been dealt with and dismissed on contest, so the principle of
res judicata will apply in the present suit.
12.
The appellant relied upon by the following authorities which are as
follows:
i)
AIR 1975 Cal 200, in the said case both declaration of title and
recovery of possession was sought for so the issue of res judicata did not
arise in the said suit as such the said authority is not applicable in the
present case.
ii) AIR 1968 Cal 550, in this case there had been admission in previous
suit which has binding effect on subsequent suit. This is not the issue
herein as such this authority is of no help to the appellant.
iii) (2012) 6 SCC 430, in the said case it was the caretaker whose status
had been decided earlier, who had preferred the suit whereas in the lis
in hand it is the other way round. The appellant has instituted the suit
against the alleged caretaker and herein the status of the appellant
/plaintiff has not been decided as the owner, so this judgment is also not
applicable in the present case.
On the contrary, the judgment passed by the Hon’ble Apex court
in the case between Sajjadanashin Saiyed MD. B.E. EDR (D) by LRs
Vs. Musa Dadavai Ummer and Ors is applicable Paragraph 12, 13, 14 ,
18 and 19 of the said judgment states as follows:
“ ... 12. It will be noticed that the words used in
Section 11 CPC are “directly and substantially in issue”.
If the matter was in issue directly and substantially in a
prior litigation and decided against a party then the
decision would be res judicata in a subsequent
proceeding. Judicial decisions have however held that if a
matter was only “collaterally or incidentally” in issue and
decided in an earlier proceeding, the finding therein
would not ordinarily be res judicata in a latter proceeding
where the matter is directly and substantially in issue.
13. As pointed out in Halsbury's Laws of England
(Vol. 16, para 1538, 4th Edn.), the fundamental rule is
that a judgment is not conclusive if any matter came
collaterally in question.
14. A collateral or incidental issue is one that is
ancillary to a direct and substantive issue; the former is
an auxiliary issue and the latter the principal issue. The
expression “collaterally or incidentally” in issue implies
that there is another matter which is “directly and
substantially” in issue.
... 18. In India, Mulla has referred to similar tests
(Mulla, 15th Edn., p. 104). The learned author says: a
matter in respect of which relief is claimed in an earlier
suit can be said to be generally a matter “directly and
substantially” in issue but it does not mean that if the
matter is one in respect of which no relief is sought it is
not directly or substantially in issue. It may or may not
be. It is possible that it was “directly and substantially”
in issue and it may also be possible that it was only
collaterally or incidentally in issue, depending upon the
facts of the case. The question arises as to what is the
test for deciding into which category a case falls? One
test is that if the issue was “necessary” to be decided for
adjudicating on the principal issue and was decided, it
would have to be treated as “directly and substantially”
in issue and if it is clear that the judgment was in fact
based upon that decision, then it would be res judicata in
a latter case (Mulla, p. 104). One has to examine the
plaint, the written statement, the issues and the
judgment to find out if the matter was directly and
substantially in issue (Ishwer Singh v. Sarwan Singh [AIR
1965 SC 948] and Syed Mohd. Salie Labbai v. Mohd.
Hanifa [(1976) 4 SCC 780 : AIR 1976 SC 1569] ). We are
of the view that the above summary in Mulla is a correct
statement of the law..
19. We have here to advert to another principle of
caution referred to by Mulla (p. 105):
“It is not to be assumed that matters in respect of
which issues have been framed are all of them directly
and substantially in issue. Nor is there any special
significance to be attached to the fact that a particular
issue is the first in the list of issues. Which of the matters
are directly in issue and which collaterally or
incidentally, must be determined on the facts of each
case. A material test to be applied is whether the court
considers the adjudication of the issue material and
essential for its decision.”.........
13.
From the aforementioned discussion this Court is of the view that
the judgment of the First Appellate Court is not required to be interfered
with as such the present second appeal being No. SA 111 of 2022 is
dismissed.
14.
Parties shall be entitled to act on the basis of the server copy of the
judgment and order placed on the official website of the Court.
15.
Urgent Xerox certified photo copies of this judgment, if applied for,
be given to the parties upon compliance of the requisite formalities.
(Supratim Bhattacharya, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review