Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Mat.A No.77 of 2024
2025:KER:16939
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE DEVAN RAMACHANDRAN
&
THE HONOURABLE MRS. JUSTICE M.B. SNEHALATHA
THURSDAY, THE 27TH DAY OF FEBRUARY 2025 / 8TH PHALGUNA, 1946
MAT.APPEAL NO. 77 OF 2024
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT DATED 28.10.2023 IN OP(DIV)NO.195 OF
2021 OF FAMILY COURT, THODUPUZHA
APPELLANT/PETITIONER:
SINI BHASKARAN
AGED 34 YEARS
D/O.KANNAN BHASKARAN, PARAYIRIKKUMPURAYIDA,
KUMBANAD.P.O., THRIVUVALLA,
PATHANAMTHITTA, PIN - 689547
BY ADV M.R.JAYALATHA
RESPONDENT/RESPONDENT:
SIJU PAUL,
AGED 42 YEARS
S/O THOMAS PAULOSE, THYPPARAMBIL HOUSE,
MULAPPURAM.P.O, MULAPPURAM,
NEYYASSERI VILLAGE, IDUKKI, PIN - 685581
THIS
MATRIMONIAL
APPEAL
HAVING
COME
UP
FOR
HEARING
24.02.2025, THE COURT ON 27.2.2025 DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
ON
Mat.A No.77 of 2024
2025:KER:16939
DEVAN RAMACHANDRAN & M.B.SNEHALATHA, JJ.
------------------------------------------Mat.Appeal No.77 of 2024
------------------------------------------Dated, this the 27th February 2025
JUDGMENT
M.B.Snehalatha.J
Challenge in this appeal is by the wife against the judgment
and decree of the Family Court, Thodupuzha which declined the relief
of divorce sought by her under Section 10(1)(x) of the Divorce Act
and the claim for permanent alimony.
2. Appellant filed the Original Petition stating that her
marriage with the respondent was solemnized on 5.11.2018; that the
respondent married her by misrepresenting his age and salary. After
the marriage, appellant had to resign her job as insisted by the
respondent. In March 2019, respondent took her to Dubai, wherein
he was employed. While residing there, though she became pregnant,
due to the stress and strain in the marital life, she had to suffer
miscarriage.
Thereafter, she returned to Kerala.
Respondent
completely ignored her and did not provide any financial support to
her.
Respondent subjected the appellant to mental cruelty and due
to the harassment and ill-treatment, appellant is residing in her
Mat.A No.77 of 2024
2025:KER:16939
parental home since September 2019.
contacted her thereafter.
Respondent has never
There is no chance of reunion and it is
impossible for the appellant to continue marital life with the
respondent. Therefore, she sought divorce on the ground of cruelty
and also claimed permanent
alimony of ₹10 lakhs
from the
respondent.
3. In the objection filed by the respondent he denied the
allegations levelled against him and contended that there was no
cruelty; that he has not suppressed his age and the details of his job
at the time of marriage proposal, as alleged by the appellant.
Respondent took the appellant to Dubai and they were residing in a
rented apartment. Respondent provided all support and care to the
appellant while she was residing there. The miscarriage was occurred
due to the health issues of the appellant and not due to any mental
strain allegedly caused by the respondent. Appellant stayed in UAE
along with the respondent till October 2020.
avoided the appellant as alleged.
He never ignored or
He used to send money to her
bank account maintained at Federal Bank, Karimannoor Branch and
the allegation that he did not provide any financial aid to the
appellant, is incorrect. He sought for dismissal of the petition.
4. After trial, the learned Family Court dismissed the petition
on the ground that the appellant failed to establish the mental cruelty
Mat.A No.77 of 2024
2025:KER:16939
alleged by her.
5. The point for consideration in this appeal is whether the
judgment and decree of the Family Court dismissing the petition for
divorce and permanent alimony need any interference by this Court.
6. Despite notice by paper publication, respondent failed to
enter appearance in this appeal and defend his case and therefore the
court proceeded to hear the appeal exparte.
7. Heard the learned counsel for the appellant.
8. Parties are Christians and admittedly, the marriage
was
solemnized on 5.11.2018. Appellant seeks divorce on the ground of
cruelty. One of the allegation raised by the appellant/wife is that at
the time of the marriage proposal, respondent suppressed his actual
age and also misrepresented his job and salary. But no evidence was
let in by the appellant to show that the respondent misrepresented
his age and job and thus played fraud on her as alleged.
9.
The definite case of the appellant is that though
after marriage respondent/husband took her to his workplace in
Dubai, he failed to take care of her and totally neglected her; that he
could not arrange a comfortable accommodation for her; that since
the respondent was reluctant to pay the rent of the accommodation,
the couple had to shift their accommodation frequently. According to
the appellant, there was no bed, water and electricity in the room
Mat.A No.77 of 2024
2025:KER:16939
wherein they resided. It is her case that due to the stress and strain
undergone by her, she had to suffer miscarriage. Her version is that
after the marriage, respondent behaved indifferently and strangely to
her parents and relatives, which caused great mental agony to her.
She has also testified that respondent did not spend any amount for
her treatment at Kolenchery MOSC Medical College, consequent to
her miscarriage.
10. Cruelty can be either physical, emotional, psychological
or verbal.
Different people may experience and pursue cruelty in
different ways based on their personality and emotional resilience. A
behavior that may be seen as trivial in one marriage might be deeply
hurtful in another. The courts do not rely on a definition of cruelty
but has to evaluate each case based on its facts.
11. In Litty Mary John v. Manoj K.Varghese (2024 KHC OnLine
693) the Division Bench of this Court (One of us was in the said
Bench) held as follows:
“11. A single, overarching definition of "cruelty" is
impractical and ineffective, as it can manifest in various forms
and shapes - it may be perceived differently in different
situations. What constitutes cruelty often differs from person
to person, situation to situation, as it is subjective and
depends on the perception of the individual experiencing it.
12. The concept of cruelty indubitably is inherently
subjective - it being inevitable - since what one person
considers cruel, may not be perceived the same way by
another. This subjectivity arises from individual differences in
values, experiences, and sensitivity. For instance, an action
that causes emotional distress to one person, might be
perceived as trivial or inconsequential by someone else. These
varying perceptions make it difficult to establish a universal
Mat.A No.77 of 2024
2025:KER:16939
definition of "cruelty", as it relies heavily on the individual's
personal interpretation and emotional response to the
behaviour in question.
13.
Though "Matrimonial cruelty" unfortunately has
sometimes been perceived "part and parcel" of marriage, it
has - more than often - evaded precise connotation. A spouse
who has endured it for years - whether due to being silenced
by the other spouse or their family, gas lighted, or unaware
that it constitutes "cruelty" - may lack the courage to speak
out about the horrific experiences she / he has faced within
the four walls of their shared household. When they finally do
muster the courage, the complaining spouse frequently finds
themselves under intense scrutiny, facing questions about
their background, the frequency of such incidents, and
whether the other spouse is otherwise ideal in other aspects of
the marriage and so on. This is applicable more pointedly in
the case of a woman in a matrimonial relationship.”
12. A more flexible and comprehensive approach is needed
when evaluating a case where there is a wife seeking divorce on the
ground of cruelty.
13. In Roopa Soni v. Kamalnarayan Soni [AIR 2023 SC 4186] ,
The Hon’ble Supreme Court observed as follows:
“(7). Historically, the law of divorce was predominantly built
on a conservative canvas based on the fault theory.
Preservation of marital sanctity from a societal perspective was
considered a prevailing factor.
With the adoption of a
libertarian attitude, the grounds for separation or dissolution of
marriage have been construed with latitudinarianism. ”
14. The Apex Court also observed as follows:
“…... element of subjectivity has to be applied albeit, what
constitutes cruelty is objective. Therefore, what is cruelty for a
woman in a given case may not be cruelty for a man, and a
relatively more elastic and broad approach is required when we
examine a case in which a wife seeks divorce.” (emphasis
supplied by us)
15. In the case at hand, the appellant is categoric in her
Mat.A No.77 of 2024
2025:KER:16939
version that respondent treated her with cruelty. Unlike physical
abuse, which is easier to prove, mental cruelty varies from case to
case. When she says that respondent behaved in a manner so as to
create an impression in her that she was totally neglected by the
respondent, there is no reason for this Court to disbelieve the said
version. It is her definite case that it was due to the stress and strain
experienced by her in her family life with the respondent, she had to
suffer miscarriage.
It is in evidence that after miscarriage, she
returned to Kerala and she is residing with her parents and thereafter
respondent has not looked after her affairs.
16. In Anilkumar V.K. v. Sunila.P (2025 (2)KHC 33) this Court
held as follows:
“15. A behaviour that may be seen as trivial in
one marriage might be deeply hurtful in another. Therefore,
cruelty is to be assessed on a case - by - case basis. What
constitutes cruelty in a matrimonial relationship depends on
the unique circumstances, behaviour and experience of the
parties involved. Courts do not rely on a rigid definition of
cruelty but has to evaluate each case based on its facts.
Courts have to analyse whether the conduct makes out
unreasonable for the one spouse to live with the other.”
17. The conduct of the respondent in not defending the
appeal points to the fact that he is not interested in saving the
matrimony with the respondent.
couples. Courts have
leaned
There is no love lost between the
towards
granting
relief of divorce
when the wife faces neglect, indifference and emotional distress even if
Mat.A No.77 of 2024
there is no
outright
violence.
If
2025:KER:16939
neglect, humiliation or lack of
affection makes cohabitation unbearable, courts can grant divorce.
This flexible approach ensures that justice is served based on the
realities of marriage rather than rigid definitions. Forcing incompatible
partners to stay together would cause more harm to both parties.
The marriage between the spouses is no longer viable and the
relationship had essentially ended as the same has irretrievably
broken and therefore there is no need to continue the agony of a
mere status of husband and wife. Accordingly, this appeal is allowed;
the impugned judgment and decree stand set aside and divorce is
granted under Section 10(1)(x) of the Divorce Act.
18. Now let us see whether the appellant is entitled to get
permanent alimony.
19. Appellant has sought ₹10 lakhs as permanent alimony
from the respondent.
20. Appellant’s case is that she has no job or income of her
own and the respondent has not provided any maintenance to her.
According to her subsequent to the marriage, she had to resign her
job as insisted by the respondent.
21. Respondent has no case that he has given any
maintenance to the appellant from 2020 onwards and he is looking
after any of her affairs.
Mat.A No.77 of 2024
2025:KER:16939
22. Taking into account the facts and attending circumstances,
we are of the view that a sum of ₹5 lakhs can be awarded as
permanent alimony to the appellant.
23. In the result appeal allowed as follows:
a) The judgment and decree in O.P.No195/2021 of
Family Court, Thodupuzha stands set aside and divorce
is granted under Section 10(1)(x) of the Divorce Act. The
marriage between the appellant and the respondent
solemnized
on
5.11.2018
is
hereby
declared
as
dissolved, with effect from the date of this judgment.
b) The respondent shall pay an amount of ₹5
lakhs as permanent alimony to the appellant.
The
amount shall carry interest at 6% per annum from this
date till the date of realisation.
Sd/DEVAN RAMACHANDRAN
JUDGE
Sd/M.B.SNEHALATHA
JUDGE
ab
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review