Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE DEVAN RAMACHANDRAN
&
THE HONOURABLE MRS. JUSTICE M.B. SNEHALATHA
FRIDAY, THE 4TH DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 14TH CHAITHRA, 1947
MAT.APPEAL NO. 474 OF 2021
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED 30.04.2024 IN OP NO.302
OF 2015 OF FAMILY COURT,ERNAKULAM
APPELLANT/RESPONDENT:
SIMI @ ANNAMMA, AGED 41 YEARS
D/O. THOMAS, UNNUKAKALLUTHOTTIYIL HOUSE, KATTACHIRA,
KOTTAYAM, PIN CODE 686 572
SIBY CHENAPPADY
AIBEL MATHEW SIBY(K/1376/2020)
ANU GEORGE(K/1793/1995)
ELANA ROSE SIBY(K/3081/2022)
RESPONDENT/PETITIONER:
NISHANTH THOMAS @ JOSEPH,AGED 41 YEARS
S/O. K.J THOMAS, KEERAMPANAL HOUSE, KOODARANJI P.O,
KOZHIKODE 673 604
VARGHESE C.KURIAKOSE
JISA P.JOSE
THIS
MATRIMONIAL
APPEAL
HAVING
COME
UP
FOR
HEARING
04.04.2025, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
ON
2025:KER:29562
MAT.APPEAL NO. 474 OF 2021
JUDGMENT
Devan Ramachandran, J.
When this matter was called today, the learned counsel
for both sides were ad idem that all disputes between their
clients have been settled under the aegis of the Ernakulam
Mediation Centre, High Court of Kerala.
2. We notice that a report has been placed before us by
the Nodal Officer of the Mediation Centre, containing the
original of the Memorandum of Settlement between the parties.
3. We have examined the afore Memorandum of
Settlement and notice that it has been subscribed to by the
parties and signed by their learned counsel. We, therefore, see
no reason not to accept the same.
4. Consequently,
we dispose of this appeal in terms of
the agreement between the parties, as reflected in the
Memorandum of Settlement, a copy of which shall stand
appended as part of this judgment.
5. As a corollary and with the consent of both sides, we
clarify that if the respondent is to pay the amount of Rs.1 crore
as agreed by him, to the appellant and his minor daughter
2025:KER:29562
MAT.APPEAL NO. 474 OF 2021
within the time frame fixed, this appeal will stand dismissed and
the impugned judgment and decree will stand confirmed.
6. If, on the contrary, the respondent is to make any
default in payment as agreed by him within the time frame
agreed, this appeal will stand allowed and the impugned
judgment and decree will stand set aside.
7. We, resultantly, direct the parties to act expressly in
terms of their agreement.
We also leave liberty to the parties to approach this
Court for any clarification or further directions for the working
out of the compromise as recorded above; in which event, such
application/s shall be placed before us for appropriate orders by
the Registry.
Sd/- DEVAN RAMACHANDRAN
JUDGE
Sd/- M.B. SNEHALATHA
JUDGE
stu
BEFORE THE HON'BLE HIGH COURT OF KEfIALA AT
ERNAl(ULAM
Mat Appeal No. 474 of 2021
Simi@ Annamma
Appel]ant
Nishanth Thomas
Respondent
MEMORANDUM OF AGREEMENT UNDEF` SECTION 89 0F THE CODE
OF CfvTL PROCEDURE READ WITH RULES 24 & Z5 0F THE KERALA
CIVIL PROCEDURE (ALTERNATIVE DISPUTE RESOLUTION) RULES
The above case relates to the disputes between the Petitioner and
the Respondent arising out of their marriage and regarding the custody
and welfare of the minor daughter by name Saaya Anna Njshanth now
aged 15 years (DOB-20/8/2009)
The disputes and claims between the parties in the above matter
was resolved in mediation in the following terms and conditions:
1,
The. respondent agrees to pay an amount of Rs.1,00,00,000/-
(Rupees one crore) towards full and final settlement of the claims put
forward by the appellant Simi @ Annamma for herself and for the minor
daughter saaya Anna Nishanth.
2.
The respondentagrees to pay an amount of Rs.10 lakhs (Rupees ten
lakh only) to be paid out of the amount of 1 Crore mentioned in clause 1.
The said amount of 10 Iakhs, being the arrears of maintenance due to the
minor daughter Saaya Anna Nishanth will be remitted by the respondent
Nishanth Thomas in the SB Account of the appellant Simi @ Annamma.
The appellant on receipt
of the said amount agrees that
64/202-4 pending before the Fami'[y Court,
claim satisfied
Appellant
Simi @ Annamma
Respo
.
will be
ndent-
Njshanth Thomas
:I.,~``.``
xecution
3.
The respondent agrees that he will continue the payment of the
monthly maintenance of Rs.10,000/-for the minor daughter without any
default, which has fallen due from the month of November. He also agrees
that the payment of the maintenance of Rs.10,000/-will be made by the
respondent father on him on monthly basis without fail, on or before the
loth every calender month. In case of default, the appellant mother Simi
@ Annamma as the natural guardian of the minor daughter is at liberty to
initiate appropriate proceedings before the suitable Forum for recovery of
the maintenance amount.
4.
The respondent father agrees to pay an amount of Rs.40 lakhs
which is part of the amount One crore as stipulated in clause 1 of the
agreement. The said amount will be remitted, within a period of 6 months
from the date of this agreement, by way of fixed deposit, in the name of
minor daughter Saaya Anna Nishanth, in a Nationalized Bank, with the
appellant mother as the guardian with liberty to the appellant mother, to
withdraw the interest from the said fixed deposit in case of necessity as
required or decided by the appellant mother.
5.
The respondent father further agrees to pay the balance amount of
Rs.50,00,000/-(Rupees fifty lakh only) in addition to the amount of to the
appellant
Simi @ Annamma,
remaining out of the total amount Rs.1
crore as stipulated in clause 1 of the agreement. The said amount is paid
by the respondents
towards the full and final settlement of the claims
raised by the appellant
for
herself in the petition O.P.No.881/2020 for
r.ecovery of money and properties
pending before the Family Court,
Ernakulam
2022,
and
M.C.No.102
of
pending
before
Ettumannoor.
Appellant
-..1.`,i,;.
Simi @ Annamma
Eiii
Respondent
Nishanth Thomas
6.
The respondent father further agrees to deposit the principal
amount of Rs.50 lakhs( in addition to the 1 Crore as stipulated in clause 1
to be utilised by the daughter for her marriage or for any major event
other than the marriage in the life of the daughter Saaya Anna Nishanth,
which is to be decided between the father and the daughter, The proposal
for marriage or any other major event in the life of the daughter shall be
decided upon after due consulation with the father. The respondent
agrees that the deposit of the said amount will be made on or before
20/8/2030. The amount with accru,ed interest thereon will be disbursed by
the respondent's father to the daughter for the above mentioned
purposes.
On receipt of the amounts from the respondent as stipulated in clause 1
to 4,
the
petitions
appellant Simi
OP
@ Annamma
No.881/.2022
pending
agrees to withdraw the
before
the
Family
Court,
Ernakulam and MC No.102/2024, of jFMC, Ettumannor.
7.
Both the parties agrees that the above said
terms of agreement
entered into by the parties can be executed as a Decree/Order
proceedings
in the
in MC N.a.10`2/2`0.2`4, pending before the Judicial First Class
Magistrate Court, Ettumanoor. after the stipulated period is over in case
the amounts are not paid as agreed by the parties to the agreement. If
any part of the amount is paid by the respondent execution proceedings
can be initiated for the recovery of the balance amount that is remaining
unpaid'
8.
Both the parties agree that since the son is now age,d 18 years,
there need not be any agreement regarding the custody of the son. Since
the son Rahul Nishanth is residing with the respondent father, in England,
the respondent agrees that he will make necessary arrangements, taking
into account, the situations and the timing of both the countries for a
Nishanth Thomas
:::itp:::A:ln:nnrata:tlmoanasnth:;:if:andtheapp::s:h:a:nn::::nh::rn
9`,
Both the parties ag.ree that the permanent custody of the minor
daughter Saya Anna Nishanth
shall remain with the appellant Simi @
Annamma who is the mother.
10,
The appeJlant agrees that she will make all necessary arrangements
for cordial interaction between the father and the minor daugh,tor taking
into
account the timing
and
academic
exigency
of the daughter.
Accordingly, the respondent father agrees to contact the daughter and
interact with her during a convenient time preferably between 7:00 p.in.
and 08:00 p.in. (lsT)
11.
Both the parents agree that the communication/interaction with the
children by the respective parents will be without any interference from
either of the parents at the time of interaction of the children.
12.
Both the p.arties agree th'at since the dispute as on the date of
signing the agreement has been resolved, they will not jnjtjate or
prosecute any further petitions or complaints against the other or their
assets, in any legal forums in future with respect to the dispute involved
herein after the payment of the above said amount .
13.
The parties to the agreement agreement undertake that they shall
duly perform and abide by all the` te.rms and condi.-tions as contained i-n the
settlement agreement and compliance of the terms regarding the
payment of the amount of Rs.1 Crore as stipulated in clause 1 in total,
which
is
payable
in
a
period
of 6
months
in
total,
the
petition
O.P.No.881#022 filed by the appellant for recovery of `the money and
property including gold as well as M.C.No.1,02 of 2022 will be closed as
withdrawn, after the payment of the amount of Rs.1 Crore as
of the agreement
Respondent
Appe„ant
Simi @ Annamma
•.,:ir}.:i-?
Nishanth Thomas
clause 1
14.
In the light of the above terms of settlement, after the receipt of
the amount of Rs.1 Crore as
ipulted in clause No.1 this Hon'ble Court
in-ay be pleased 'to dismiss Of
#ie 'above appe`al after recording the terms
of settlement.
.--,.i
-
Dated this 24th the day of March, 2025
-i------:
Respondent
Appella-nt
Nishanth
Simi @ Annamma
Counselfor=+`
Counsel for
ou.S;bJGCh4€T:qpq?
-twneffi
This settlement agreement is authenticated by me
Adv.Sally Thomas Chacko(Medi
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review