Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Jurisdiction)
DATED : 28th July, 2022
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DIVISION BENCH : THE HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BHASKAR RAJ PRADHAN, JUDGE
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Review Pet.(C) No.01 of 2022
:
Petitioners
Sikkim Power Development Corporation and Another
versus
Respondents :
M/s. Amalgamated Transpower (India) Ltd.
Application under Order XLVII Rule 1
of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Mr. Tarun Johri, Advocate with Ms. Tamannna Chettri and Mr.
Tenzing Thinlay Lepcha, Advocates for the Petitioners.
Mr. Prateek K. Chadha, Advocate with Ms. Rachana Rai, Advocate
for the Respondent.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ORDER
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
1.
The Petitioners/Appellants have filed an application
under Order XLVII Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (for
short, the “CPC”), dated 01-02-2022, seeking a review of the Order
dated 07-10-2021 passed in I.A. No.1 of 2020 in Arb.A. No.1 of
2020, on grounds that the Order suffers from an error apparent on
the face of it.
2(i).
For clarity in the matter, it is essential to recapitulate
that the Petitioners/Appellants under Section 34 of the Arbitration
and Conciliation Act, 1996 (for short, the “Arbitration Act”) had
challenged the Award dated 30-09-2017 of the sole Arbitrator
before the Learned Commercial Court, East Sikkim, at Gangtok, in
Arbitration Case No.05 of 2017 [Sikkim Power Development
Review Pet.(C) No.01 of 2022
Sikkim Power Development Corporation and Another vs. M/s. Amalgamated Transpower (India) Ltd.
Corporation
Ltd.
(SPDCL)
and
Transpower (India) Ltd. (ATPIL)].
Another
vs.
Amalgamated
The Arbitral Tribunal had
allowed the claim filed by the Respondent and dismissed the
counter-claims filed by the Petitioners/Appellants. A decree of
specific performance of the Agreement dated 21-12-2002 was
passed in favour of the Respondent with damages against the
Appellants. The Learned Commercial Court, East Sikkim, at
Gangtok, partly upheld the Arbitral Award dated 30-09-2017 vide
its impugned Order dated 26-12-2019. An Appeal being Arb.A.
No.01 of 2020 against the finding of the Learned Commercial Court
was filed by the Petitioners herein.
(ii)
Notice was issued on 22-06-2020 to the Respondent on
I.A. No.01 of 2020 supra the application filed by the Appellants
seeking a Stay of the impugned Judgment of the Learned
Commercial Court. In the interregnum, the Learned Single Judge
of this Court granted ex parte ad interim stay of the impugned
Judgment until further orders.
(iii)
After hearing the rival submissions of Learned Counsel
for the parties, the ex parte ad interim order of stay was confirmed
vide Order dated 07-10-2021. The directions of this Court in the
said Order were inter alia as follows;
“8.(i)
In view of the rival contentions put forth,
we are of the considered opinion that Learned
Counsel for the Appellants has made out a case for
grant of Stay of the operation of the Arbitral Award till
further orders of this Court.
(ii)
Consequently, the ex parte ad interim
Order of Stay granted by this Court vide Order, dated
22.06.2020, stands confirmed until further orders.
(iii)
However, considering the submissions of
Learned Counsel for the Respondent as reflected
supra, whereby his specific prayer is for deposit of the
amounts as granted in Prayer “G‟ and Prayer „I‟, the
Appellants are directed to deposit two Bank Drafts,
Review Pet.(C) No.01 of 2022
Sikkim Power Development Corporation and Another vs. M/s. Amalgamated Transpower (India) Ltd.
one for a sum of Rs.85,43,11,904/- (Rupees eighty
five crores, forty three lakhs, eleven thousand, nine
hundred and four) only, (i.e. Rs.47,13,53,405/- +
Rs.38,29,58,499/-) and another for a sum of
Rs.265,10,00,000/- (Rupees two hundred and sixty
five crores and ten lakhs) only, within sixteen weeks
from today.
…………………………………………………………………..”
3.
The Appellants filed the instant Review Petition on 01-
02-2022 as stated supra seeking a review of the Order dated 0710-2021, along with I.A. No.01 of 2022 an application under
Section 5 of the Limitation Act, 1963, seeking condonation of 76
days delay in filing the Review Petition, while placing reliance on
the Order of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court dated 10-01-2022 in In Re
: Cognizance for Extension of Limitation [Miscellaneous Application No.21
of 2022 in Miscellaneous Application No.665 of 2021 in Suo Motu
Writ Petition (C) No.03 of 2020].
Contesting the aforementioned
delay, the Respondent on 21-02-2022 filed I.A. No.05 of 2022 in
Arb.A. No.01 of 2020 and averred inter alia as follows therein;
“18. That, in addition to the Review Petition, the
Appellants have also filed an Application of
Condonation of delay of 76 days (i.e. from
06.11.2021 to 20.01.2020) sighting (sic)
Hon‟ble Supreme Court of India‟s suo-motu
cognizance of situation arising from COVID.
But, as per the records of this Hon‟ble Court,
the Appellants had submitted their detail
arguments in Virtual Court on 25.10.2021,
26.10.2021; have done physical filing of
Documents in Ist/2nd week of Nov.2021;
appeared through V.C on 10.11.2021 and
appeared physically before this Hon‟ble Court
during court proceeding on 24.11.2021.”
Learned Counsel for the parties were heard on the delay
petition (supra) and in consideration of the Order of the Hon‟ble
Supreme Court, the delay was condoned and the Review Petition
taken up for hearing.
A reply dated 01-06-2022 was filed on
behalf of the Respondent to the Review Petition dated 01-02-2022.
Review Pet.(C) No.01 of 2022
Sikkim Power Development Corporation and Another vs. M/s. Amalgamated Transpower (India) Ltd.
4.
Prior in time, on 21-02-2022, an application being I.A.
No.5 of 2022 came to be filed by the Respondent under Section
151 of the CPC along with an affidavit inter alia submitting that the
non-depositing of the amount by the Appellants despite the Order
of this Court dated 07-10-2021, under the guise of a frivolous
Review Petition along with a frivolous petition for condonation of
delay is also an epitome of dodging payment of the amount
ordered. Reply was filed by the Appellants to this application supra
on 20-04-2022.
5.
Learned Counsel for the Petitioners contended that an
error apparent on the face of the Order dated 07-10-2021 passed
in I.A. No.01 of 2020 in Arb.A. No.01 of 2020 existed for the
reasons enumerated hereinbelow; that, the Petitioners/Appellants
under Section 151 of the CPC had filed an application for Stay,
being I.A. No.01 of 2020 in Arb.A. No.01 of 2020 on 06-03-2020.
Reply to which was filed by the Respondent on 22-03-2021 and a
rejoinder thereof by the Appellants on 23-04-2021.
That, the
Respondent in its reply dated 22-03-2021 to the application for
Stay had inter alia stated as under;
“19. The amount which is due to be deposited by
the Appellants in view of the operation of the
2015, Act and the settled law, an amount of
Rs.131,56,40,332/- (Due as on 30.09.2020)
has already become final and binding in terms
of Section 36 of the Arbitration and Conciliation
Act with respect to Prayer G and Prayer K of
the Award. For this the Respondent has already
filed an Execution Petition before the Hon‟ble
District Judge, East Sikkim, registered as Civil
Execution Case No.15 of 2020. Therefore the
remaining amount which is further liable to be
deposited the Appellants are mentioned in the
TABLE below.
Findings in
the
Arbitral
Award
Whether
interfered
by
the Commercial
Court U/s 34?
Amount payable to
the Respondent/
Applicant
Review Pet.(C) No.01 of 2022
Sikkim Power Development Corporation and Another vs. M/s. Amalgamated Transpower (India) Ltd.
The
Tribunal
awarded
Rs.265.10
Crores
towards
Prayer 1
(Loss
toward
Cost
Escalation)
(Para 803
@ Pg. 419)
Total
20.
No
Rs.265.10
Crores
with post award
interest
of
18%
(Refer Para 813 @
Page 425 of the
Award)
approximating
to
Rs.431,00,17,589/(Upto 23.3.2021)
Rs.431,00,17,589/-
The Respondent having filed a separate Appeal
under Section 37, before this Hon‟ble Court as
Arb. A/80/2020, seeking for an alternate claim
of damage as granted by the Arbitral Tribunal
the above mentioned amount in the table has
not been pressed for execution.”
[emphasis supplied]
6.
That, in view of the reply supra, the Respondent had
thus admitted that as far as the amount of Rs.265,10,00,000/(Rupees two hundred and sixty five crores and ten lakhs) only, was
concerned the Respondent was not pressing for its execution as
they had preferred a separate Appeal before this Court seeking an
alternate claim for damages.
It was further submitted that,
contrary to the aforestated averments, the Respondent during the
course of arguments on the Stay application prayed for the deposit
of the amount of Rs.265,10,00,000/- (Rupees two hundred and
sixty five crores and ten lakhs) only.
That, despite the above
averments in the reply of the Respondent to the Stay application at
Paragraphs 19 and 20, extracted supra, while confirming the
interim Order dated 22-06-2020, this Court in its Order dated 0710-2021 directed the Appellants to deposit two Bank Drafts in the
Registry of this High Court for an amount of Rs.85,43,11,904/(Rupees eighty five crores, forty three lakhs, eleven thousand, nine
hundred and four) only, [i.e. Rs.47,13,53,405/- (Rupees forty
seven crores, thirteen lakhs, fifty three thousand, four hundred and
Review Pet.(C) No.01 of 2022
Sikkim Power Development Corporation and Another vs. M/s. Amalgamated Transpower (India) Ltd.
five) + Rs.38,29,58,499/- (Rupees thirty eight crores, twenty nine
lakhs, fifty eight thousand, four hundred and ninety nine] and
another Bank Draft of an amount of Rs.265,10,00,000/- (Rupees
two hundred and sixty five crores and ten lakhs) only, within 16
(sixteen) weeks from 07-10-2021.
That, the Order consequently
suffers from an error apparent on the face of it as it failed to take
into consideration the submissions of the Respondent that they
were not pressing for execution of the awarded amount of
Rs.265,10,00,000/- (Rupees two hundred and sixty five crores and
ten lakhs) only.
That, this Court had also failed to take into
consideration that the Respondent had consciously not pressed for
execution of the said amount. That, in the light of the stand of the
Respondent the direction for deposit of the said amount of
Rs.265,10,00,000/- (Rupees two hundred and sixty five crores and
ten lakhs) only, is erroneous.
It was also stated that the Court
erred in directing the Appellants to deposit the balance Bond
amount in Court and failed to take into consideration that when the
Respondent had itself breached its obligation to submit the Bank
Guarantee to the Petitioners, then the Petitioners could not have
been legally called upon to deposit the amount of the balance Bond
amount. Hence, the grounds submitted are sufficient for this Court
to review its Order dated 07-10-2021 thereby deleting/modifying
the direction to the Appellants to deposit the Bank Draft of
Rs.85,43,11,904/- (Rupees eighty five crores, forty three lakhs,
eleven
thousand,
nine
hundred
and
four)
only
and
Rs.265,10,00,000/- (Rupees two hundred and sixty five crores and
ten lakhs) only.
Review Pet.(C) No.01 of 2022
Sikkim Power Development Corporation and Another vs. M/s. Amalgamated Transpower (India) Ltd.
7(i).
Per contra, it was contended by Learned Counsel for
the Respondent that firstly the Arbitration Act, as amended, is a
complete Code in which there is no provision for a Review and
hence, the Appellants could not file a Review Petition under Order
XLVII Rule 1 of the CPC seeking a review of its Order. That, in the
absence of any such provision, any Order in review, if passed
would be ultra vires, illegal and without jurisdiction.
That, this
Court in its Order dated 07-10-2021 has directed deposit of the
amount in terms of the provisions of Section 36 of the Arbitration
Act, as amended in 2015, and under binding precedents of the
Hon‟ble Supreme Court which the Petitioners are seeking an
alteration by claiming a review, which is wholly impermissible.
That, in fact the Petitioners have under the guise of a Review
Petition filed an Appeal assailing the Order of this Court, which can
only be filed through an appropriate appeal before the higher Court
and not through a Review Petition.
It was next urged that in
prescribing the amount to be deposited under Section 36 of the
Arbitration Act, as amended in 2015, the Court does not consider
whether any Execution Petition towards any particular claim is filed
or not. The Court is only to consider the awarded amount or what
is the amount concurrently upheld by the Court under Section 34
of the Arbitration Act as in the instant case. That, the claim of the
Petitioners that the Order to deposit Rs.265,10,00,000/- (Rupees
two hundred and sixty five crores and ten lakhs) only, is erroneous
in light of Paragraphs 19 and 20 of the reply of the Respondent
dated 22-03-2021, to the Stay application, is totally false.
That,
the directions of this Court to the Appellants to deposit the two
Bank Drafts within 16 (sixteen) weeks‟ period ended on 27-01-
Review Pet.(C) No.01 of 2022
Sikkim Power Development Corporation and Another vs. M/s. Amalgamated Transpower (India) Ltd.
2022 despite which the Appellants failed to make the deposits and
instead filed the Review Petition. That, whether Execution Petition
is to be filed or not is the discretion of the Respondent.
That,
Section 36 of the Arbitration Act, as amended in 2015, expressly
provides for deposit of the awarded amount for grant of stay, it
does not state the relevance of filing or non-filing of Execution
Petition by the award holder.
(ii).
That,
the
Petitioners‟
interpretation
that
as
the
Respondent had not pressed for execution meant that they would
not press for execution of the claim is bizarre. That, as soon as the
Respondent noticed that the Petitioners had not deposited the two
Bank Drafts as per the Order of this Court dated 07-10-2021, the
Respondent
filed
an
Execution
Petition
for
Prayer
for
Rs.265,10,00,000/- (Rupees two hundred and sixty five crores and
ten lakhs) only, before the Commercial Court on 19-02-2022 which
is registered as Execution Petition (C) No.05 of 2022. That, in fact,
the Petitioners have not even deposited a separate Bank Draft of
Rs.85,43,11,904/- (Rupees eighty five crores, forty three lakhs,
eleven thousand, nine hundred and four) only, for which they have
not sought any extension, establishing a deliberate defiance of the
Order of this Court.
Hence, in light of the above mentioned facts
and circumstances, this Court be pleased to dismiss the Review
Petition with exemplary costs.
8.
Learned
Counsel
for
the
Appellants
in
rebuttal
contended that the Appellants had legally and validly invoked the
grounds permissible under Law for review of the Order and also on
the basis of facts as applicable to the case in question.
It was
reiterated that the Respondent itself had stated that it was not
Review Pet.(C) No.01 of 2022
Sikkim Power Development Corporation and Another vs. M/s. Amalgamated Transpower (India) Ltd.
pressing for execution of Order relating to the award of the amount
of Rs.265,10,00,000/- (Rupees two hundred and sixty five crores
and ten lakhs) only.
This being a material fact it had a legal
bearing on the exercise of discretion by this Court while deciding
the application of Stay of the arbitral award preferred by the
Appellants. It is denied that Sections 34 and 37 of the Arbitration
Act mandates that the hearing of objection petition/appeal on
merits can be taken up only on the amount which was directed by
the Court being deposited by the Appellants/Objectors, hence the
Petition filed by the Respondent under Section 151 of the CPC be
dismissed.
9.
The rival contentions were heard at length and given
due consideration.
While addressing the arguments of Learned
Counsel for the Respondent that the Arbitration Act is a selfcontained Act which provides for no review, in ITI Ltd. vs. Siemens
Public Communications Network Ltd.
the Supreme Court held as
hereunder;
“19. Revisional jurisdiction of a superior court
cannot be taken as excluded simply because
subordinate courts exercise a special jurisdiction
under a special Act. The reason is that when a special
Act on matters governed by that Act confers a
jurisdiction on an established court, as distinguished
from a persona designata, without any words of
limitation, then the ordinary incident of procedure of
that court including right of appeal or revision against
its decision is attracted. The right of second appeal to
the High Court has been expressly taken away by
sub-section (3) of Section 37 of the Act, but for that
reason it cannot be held that the right of revision has
also been taken away. ……………………..”
The Supreme Court in Mahanagar Telephone Nigam Limited vs.
Applied Electronics Limited
(2002) 5 SCC 510
(2017) 2 SCC 37
held that;
Review Pet.(C) No.01 of 2022
Sikkim Power Development Corporation and Another vs. M/s. Amalgamated Transpower (India) Ltd.
“27. Section 5 which commences with a non
obstante clause clearly stipulates that no judicial
authority shall interfere except where so provided in
Part I of the 1996 Act. As we perceive, the 1996 Act
is a complete code and Section 5 in categorical terms
along with other provisions, lead to a definite
conclusion that no other provision can be attracted.
Thus, the application of CPC is not conceived of and,
therefore, as a natural corollary, the cross-objection
cannot be entertained. Though we express our view in
the present manner, the judgment rendered in ITI
Ltd. [ITI Ltd. v. Siemens Public Communications Network Ltd., (2002) 5
SCC 510] is a binding precedent. The three-Judge Bench
decision in International Security & Intelligence
Agency Ltd. [MCD v. International Security & Intelligence Agency
Ltd., (2004) 3 SCC 250] can be distinguished as that is
under the 1940 Act which has Section 41 which
clearly states that the procedure of CPC would be
applicable to appeals. The analysis made in ITI
Ltd. [ITI Ltd. v. Siemens Public Communications Network Ltd., (2002) 5
SCC 510] to the effect that merely because the 1996 Act
does not provide CPC to be applicable, it should not
be inferred that the Code is inapplicable seems to be
incorrect, for the scheme of the 1996 Act clearly
envisages otherwise and the legislative intendment
also so postulates.
28. As we are unable to follow the view
expressed in ITI Ltd. [ITI Ltd. v. Siemens Public Communications
Network Ltd., (2002) 5 SCC 510] and we are of the considered
opinion that the said decision deserves to be
reconsidered by a larger Bench. Let the papers be
placed before the Hon'ble the Chief Justice of India
for constitution of an appropriate larger Bench.”
[emphasis supplied]
However, later in time in Municipal Corporation of Greater
Mumbai and Another vs. Pratibha Industries Limited and Others
a two
Judge Bench of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court expounded as follows;
“10. Insofar as the High Courts' jurisdiction to
recall its own order is concerned, the High Courts are
courts of record, set up under Article 215 of the
Constitution of India. Article 215 of the Constitution of
India reads as under:
“215. High Courts to be courts of
record.—Every High Court shall be a court of
record and shall have all the powers of such a
court including the power to punish for
contempt of itself.”
It is clear that these constitutional courts,
being courts of record, the jurisdiction to recall
their own orders is inherent by virtue of the
fact that they are superior courts of record.
This has been recognised in several of our
judgments.”
[emphasis supplied]
(2019) 3 SCC 203
Review Pet.(C) No.01 of 2022
Sikkim Power Development Corporation and Another vs. M/s. Amalgamated Transpower (India) Ltd.
The extract in Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai (supra)
being self-explanatory with regard to the powers of review no
further elucidation is necessitated on this point.
10.
Now to consider what an error apparent on the face of
the record is, the Hon‟ble Supreme Court has observed in a
plethora of Judgments as to what such an error consists of. In
Satyanarayan
Laxminarayan
Hegde
vs.
Mallikarjun
Bhavanappa
Tirumale , it was held as follows;
“17. …………. An error which has to be established
by a long drawn process of reasoning on points where
there may conceivably be two opinions can hardly be said
to be an error apparent on the face of the record. As the
above discussions of the rival contentions show the
alleged error in the present case is far from selfevident and if it can be established, it has to be
established, by lengthy and complicated arguments.
We do not think such an error can be cured by a writ
of certiorari according to the rule governing the
powers of the superior court to issue such a writ. In
our opinion the High Court was wrong in thinking that
the alleged error in the judgment of the Bombay
Revenue Tribunal viz., that an order for possession
should not be made unless a previous notice had been
given was an error apparent on the face of the record
so as to be capable of being corrected by a writ of
certiorari.”
[emphasis supplied]
11.
It is relevant to note that Learned Counsel for the
Appellants in his arguments on the Stay application, which were
recorded by this Court and reflected in the Order dated 07-10-2021
nowhere put forth the plea that under Paragraphs 19 and 20 of the
reply dated 22-03-2021 of the Respondent to the application for
Stay, the Respondent had not pressed for deposit of the amount of
Rs.265,10,00,000/- (Rupees two hundred and sixty five crores and
ten lakhs) only. In fact, it was the specific argument of Learned
Counsel for the Appellants that the amount awarded is a large
amount sans a submission seeking exemption from payment of
AIR 1960 SC 137
Review Pet.(C) No.01 of 2022
Sikkim Power Development Corporation and Another vs. M/s. Amalgamated Transpower (India) Ltd.
Rs.265,10,00,000/- (Rupees two hundred and sixty five crores and
ten
lakhs)
only,
on
the
ground
that
the
amount
of
Rs.265,10,00,000/- (Rupees two hundred and sixty five crores and
ten lakhs) only, has not been pressed in execution. This Court in
Paragraph 5(i) to Paragraph 7 of the Order dated 07-10-2021
observed as follows;
5.(i)
The rival submissions having been heard
in extenso, it may appropriately be mentioned that
the Stay granted vide Order, dated 22.06.2020, was
an ex parte ad interim relief and hence the matter
was taken up for hearing on 28.09.2021. While
considering the requirements of the provisions of
Section 36 of the Arbitration Act and Order XLI Rules
5 and 6 of the CPC, it is apposite to notice that in
Manish vs. Godawari Marathwada Irrigation Development
Corporation (supra), the Hon‟ble Supreme Court, while
disagreeing with the decision of the Bombay High
Court which had ordered 60% deposit, pending the
Section 37 Appeal, observed inter alia as follows;
“…… since these are money decrees
there should be 100% deposit, with the
respondent being entitled to withdraw the
amount deposited and furnish solvent
security to the satisfaction of the High
Court.”
The impugned Order of the High Court was set aside.
(ii)
In Pam Developments Private Limited (supra), the
grant of unconditional Stay to Government with
respect to proceedings under Section 34 of the
Arbitration Act, 1996, by invoking the provisions of
Order XXVII Rule 8-A of the CPC were being
considered. The Hon‟ble Supreme Court observed
that the invocation of Order XXVII Rule 8-A of the
CPC by the High Court for the grant of the
unconditional Stay to Government with respect to
Arbitral Award passed against it was not proper. It
was held inter alia thus;
“28. Section 36 of the Arbitration Act
also does not provide for any special
treatment to the Government while dealing
with grant of stay in an application under
proceedings of Section 34 of the Arbitration
Act. Keeping the aforesaid in consideration
and also the provisions of Section 18
providing for equal treatment of parties, it
would, in our view, make it clear that there is
no exceptional treatment to be given to the
Government while considering the application
for stay under Section 36 filed by the
Government in proceedings under Section 34
of the Arbitration Act.
29. Although we are of the firm view
that the archaic Rule 8-A of Order 27 CPC
Review Pet.(C) No.01 of 2022
Sikkim Power Development Corporation and Another vs. M/s. Amalgamated Transpower (India) Ltd.
has no application or reference in the present
times, we may only add that even if it is
assumed that the provisions of Order 27 Rule
8-A CPC are to be applied, the same would
only exempt the Government from furnishing
security, whereas under Order 41 Rule 5
CPC, the Court has the power to direct for
full or part deposit and/or to furnish security
of the decretal amount. Rule 8-A only
provides exemption from furnishing security,
which would not restrict the Court from
directing deposit of the awarded amount and
part thereof.
30. For the foregoing reasons, we are
of the opinion that the impugned order
passed by the Calcutta High Court granting
unconditional stay of the arbitration award
dated 21-1-2010, cannot be sustained in the
eye of the law. ………………………………”
(iii)
In Board of Control for Cricket in India
(supra), Section 34 Applications under the Arbitration
and Conciliation Act, 1996, were all filed prior to the
coming into force of the Amendment Act w.e.f.
23.10.2015. In the four Appeals, the Section 34
Applications were filed after the Amendment Act came
into force. The Court went into a detailed discussion
about the pre-amended Section 36 and amended
Section 36 of the Arbitration Act. The 246th Law
Commission Report which led to the Amendment Act
was also discussed in the ratio, wherein the reason
for proposing to replace Section 36 of the Arbitration
Act of 1996 was considered and it was observed
therein that the unamended Section 36 of the Act
made it clear that an Arbitral Award became
enforceable as a Decree only after the time for filing a
Petition under Section 34 had expired, or after the
Section 34 Petition was dismissed. In other words, the
pendency of a Section 34 Petition rendered an Arbitral
Award unenforceable, hence the admission of a
Section 34 Petition virtually paralysed the process for
the Winning Party/Award Creditor. The Report also
observed that the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in National
Aluminium Co. Ltd. v. Pressteel & Fabrications (P) Ltd.
[(2004) 1 SCC 540] had criticized the said situation in the
following words;
“44. ……………………..
‘11. However, we do notice that this
automatic suspension of the execution of the
award,
the
moment
an
application
challenging the said award is filed under
Section 34 of the Act leaving no discretion in
the court to put the parties on terms, in our
opinion, defeats the very objective of the
alternate dispute resolution system to which
arbitration belongs. We do find that there is
a recommendation made by the Ministry
concerned to Parliament to amend Section
34 with a proposal to empower the civil court
to pass suitable interim orders in such cases.
In view of the urgency of such amendment,
we sincerely hope that necessary steps
would be taken by the authorities concerned
Review Pet.(C) No.01 of 2022
Sikkim Power Development Corporation and Another vs. M/s. Amalgamated Transpower (India) Ltd.
at the earliest to bring about the required
change in law.‟ ”
[Emphasis supplied]
That, the Amendment in Section 36 was to ensure
that mere filing of an Application under Section 34
does not operate as an automatic Stay on the
enforcement of the Award. It was held inter alia as
follows;
“60. This brings us to the manner of
enforcement of a decree under CPC. A decree
is enforced under CPC only through the
execution process (see Order 21 of the Code
of Civil Procedure). Also, Section 36(3), as
amended, refers to the provisions of the
Code of Civil Procedure for grant of stay of a
money decree. This, in turn, has reference to
Order 41 Rule 5 of the Code of Civil
Procedure, which appears under the Chapter
heading, “Stay of Proceedings and of
Execution”. This being so, it is clear that
Section 36 refers to the execution of an
award as if it were a decree, attracting the
provisions of Order 21 and Order 41 Rule 5
of the Code of Civil Procedure and would,
therefore, be a provision dealing with the
execution of arbitral awards. …………”
6.
In light of the ratiocinations referred to
hereinabove, it is evident that in terms of Section
36(2) and (3) of the Arbitration Act, which came into
effect from 23.10.2015, in order to obtain a Stay of
operation of the Arbitral Award, the party assailing
the Award may file an application seeking such relief
from the Court. The Court, in turn, has the discretion
to consider the prayer and grant Stay of operation of
the Arbitral Award, subject to conditions that it may
impose as deemed fit. As per Section 36(3) of the
Arbitration Act, however, when the party seeks Stay
of the operation of the Arbitral Award for payment of
money, the Court is to consider the provisions for
grant of Stay of a Money Decree under the provisions
of Order XLI of the CPC. The argument of Learned
Counsel for the Appellants that the Court is only to be
guided by the provisions of the CPC and there is no
mandate that the Code is to be complied with cannot
be countenanced, in view of the specific direction of
the Hon‟ble Supreme Court as laid down in Manish vs.
Godawari Marathwada Irrigation Development Corporation
supra and the discussions that have emanated in
Board of Control for Cricket in India supra. Thus, while
considering the prayer of the Appellants for grant of
Stay of the operation of the Arbitral Award made
against them for payment of money, this Court is
required to follow the provisions of Order XLI Rule 5
of the CPC.
7.
In consideration of the discussions that
have emanated supra and the law laid down by the
Hon‟ble Supreme Court, it is not necessary to delve
into a prolix discussion of the provisions of Section 36
of the Arbitration Act and Order XLI Rules 5 and 6 of
the CPC. Suffice it to state that when Stay is to be
Review Pet.(C) No.01 of 2022
Sikkim Power Development Corporation and Another vs. M/s. Amalgamated Transpower (India) Ltd.
granted, a deposit is to be made by the party seeking
Stay of the operation of the Arbitral Award.”
12.
In view of the Order extracted hereinabove, we are of
the considered opinion that the Petitioners have indeed failed to
demonstrate any error manifest on the face of the Order, which is
in fact in due compliance of the statutory provisions and the law
laid down by the Hon‟ble Supreme Court on this facet.
The
intention of the Appellants is evidently to stall executing the Order
of this Court by filing this facetious Petition which is more in the
nature of an Appeal than a Review Petition. The Petitioners ought
to be mindful that the Order which is sought to be reviewed is an
order granting a stay and not an order for execution of a Decree.
13.
Hence, the Review Petition deserves to be and is
accordingly dismissed. The amount directed to be deposited vide
Order of this Court dated 07-10-2021 be made good within four
weeks from today failing which necessary steps as per law will
follow.
14.
Costs of Rs.20,000/- (Rupees twenty thousand) only,
are imposed on the Petitioners who are to deposit the amount in
the Sikkim State Legal Services Authority within a week from the
date of this Order, to be utilized for the senior citizens in “Lee Al
Old Age Home”, Tintek, East Sikkim.
15.
Consequently, the Review Pet.(C) No.01 of 2022 and
I.A. No.05 of 2022 in Arb.A. No.01 of 2020, both stand disposed of.
( Bhaskar Raj Pradhan )
Judge
28-07-2022
Approved for reporting : Yes
ds/sdl
( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
28-07-2022
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review