Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/11
GAHC010251612023
2026:GAU-AS:14886
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : Crl.A./409/2023
SIKHAMONI DUTTA
W/O SRI NIRANJAN DUTTA,
R/O 2ND GOPAL PAR,
P.O.- SHANTIPUR, P.S.- SIVASAGAR,
DIST.- SIVASAGAR, ASSAM.
VERSUS
THE STATE OF ASSAM
REP. BY THE P.P., ASSAM.
Advocate for the Petitioner
: MR. D BARUAH, MR W TERON,MS S K GUPTA
Advocate for the Respondent : PP, ASSAM,
:::BEFORE:::
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE MICHAEL ZOTHANKHUMA
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJESH MAZUMDAR
Date on which judgment is reserved
Date of pronouncement of judgment
Whether the pronouncement is of the
operative part of the judgment ?
Whether the full judgment has been
pronounced?
: 30.09.2026
: 06.10.2026
: No.
: Yes
JUDGMENT & ORDER (CAV)
(M. Zothankhuma, J)
1.
Heard Mr. D. Baruah, learned counsel for the appellant and Mr. R. R.
Kaushik, learned Addl. PP, Assam.
Page No.# 2/11
2.
This criminal appeal under Section 374(2) Cr.PC is directed against the
impugned Judgment and Order dated 12.09.2023 passed by the learned
Sessions Judge, Sivasagar in Session Case no. 73(S-S)/2017. By the Judgment
and Order dated 12.09.2023, the accused-appellant has been convicted for the
offences under Section 302 and Section 201 IPC. For the offence under Section
302 IPC, the accused-appellant has been sentenced to undergo rigorous
imprisonment for life and to pay a fine of Rs. 10,000/-, in default of payment of
fine, to undergo simple imprisonment for another 3 (three) months. For the
offence under Section 201 IPC, the accused appellant has been sentenced to
undergo rigorous imprisonment for 3 (three) years and to pay a fine of Rs.
5,000/-, in default of payment of fine, to undergo simple imprisonment for
another 2 (two) months. The sentences were ordered to run concurrently.
3.
The brief facts of the case is that Prosecution Witness-1 submitted an FIR
dated 15.10.2016 to the Officer-in-Charge at Disangmukh Police Station
(actually Police Outpost), stating that on the morning of 15.10.2016, he had
made a report to the Police Station that his daughter, who was 1 month 8 days
old, had gone missing since the night before. Upon interrogation by the police,
his wife (appellant) had confessed, in the presence of local witnesses, that on
the night of 14.10.2016 at approximately 8 p.m., she had murdered their
daughter and disposed her body at Dikhow River. Pursuant to the FIR, Sivasagar
P.S. Case No. 923/2016 under Sections 302/201 IPC was registered on
15.10.2016. PW-10 started the investigation and as he was transferred during
the investigation period, he handed over the case diary to the O.C. of the
Sivasagar P.S., who thereafter handed over the case to S.I. Anil Kumar Baruah.
After the investigation being completed, charge sheet under Sections 302/201
IPC was filed against the appellant.
Page No.# 3/11
4.
The learned Trial Court thereafter framed charges under Sections 302/201
IPC, to which the appellant pleaded not guilty and claimed to be tried.
5.
The learned Trial Court thereafter examined 11 Prosecution Witnesses and
after examining the appellant under Section 313 Cr.PC, the learned Trial Court
came to a finding that the appellant was guilty of having committed an offence
punishable under Sections 302/201 IPC, on the basis of her confessional
statement made under Section 164 Cr.PC.
6.
The evidence of pw-1 (informant), who is the husband of the appellant, is
to the effect that his daughter was found missing and on inquiring with his wife
(appellant), she stated that she did not know the whereabouts of their child.
Thereafter, pw-1 was declared hostile by the prosecution and was examined by
the prosecution. In the cross-examination, PW-1 denied giving a statement to
PW-10 (I.O.) that the appellant had confessed to the villagers that she had
thrown the child in the Dikhow river. PW-1 stated that the appellant was
arrested on the suspicion that she had killed their child.
7.
The evidence of pw-2, who is the father-in-law of the appellant and the
evidence of PW-3, who is the brother-in-law of the appellant, are to the effect
that the police told them that on the appellant being interrogated by the police,
the appellant confessed that she had killed the child, by throwing the child into
the Dikhow River.
8.
The evidence of pw Nos. 4, 6 and 7 is to the effect that the police
informed them and the other villagers that the appellant had killed the child, by
throwing her into the Dikhow River.
Page No.# 4/11
9.
The evidence of pw-5 is to the effect that he had gone to the house of the
appellant and came to know that the child was missing.
10.
The evidence of PW-8 is to the effect that on 18.10.2016, while being
posted at Sivasagar as Judicial Magistrate First Class, the appellant had been
produced before her for giving her statement under Section 164 Cr.PC. Vide
order dated 18.10.2016, PW-8 sent the appellant to judicial custody, giving her
reflection time of 24 hours. On 19.10.2016, the appellant was produced before
her escorted by the woman constable Gulnahar Begum. The appellant seemed
to be very sad and not in a proper frame of mind. Accordingly, another 24 hours
reflection time was given to the appellant on 20.10.2016. The appellant was
again produced before PW-8 at 3 p.m. on 20.10.2016, where she appeared to
be normal and in a fit state of mind. On being asked, the appellant stated that
she was willing and voluntarily going to confess. Thereafter, her confessional
statement was recorded. PW-8 further stated that at the end of recording of the
confessional statement, a memorandum was given by PW-8 in her own
handwriting.
In her cross examination, PW-8 stated that as per the order dated
19.10.2016, she did not send the appellant or direct the district jail authority for
medical treatment of the appellant, as she was only emotionally not in a fit state
of mind to give her confession. However, in her order, though she had not
specifically used the word “emotion”, it was obviously implied from the language
used that the appellant was not in a proper state of mind.
11.
The evidence of PW-9 is to the effect that he saw the police interrogating
the appellant, but did not hear anything.
Page No.# 5/11
12.
The evidence of PW-10, who is the Investigating Officer, is to the effect
that on interrogating the appellant, the appellant had confessed to killing her
daughter, by throwing her body in the Dikhow River. Though they had searched
for the body, they did not find the body.
13.
The examination of the appellate under Section 313 Cr.PC shows that she
had stated “I don't know anything sir” and “I don't know sir” with regard to all
the questions that had been put to her.
14.
At the time of hearing the appellant, on the question of the sentence to
be imposed upon her under Sections 302/201 IPC, the appellant had stated as
follows:“Question: Trial of the case has been proceeded against you U/S
302/201 of the IPC and after conclusion of trial, you are held guilty and
convicted for the offence punishable under section 302/201 of Indian
Penal Code (IPC). Section 302 of IPC provides for punishment with death,
or imprisonment for life, and shall also be liable to fine and Section 201 of
the Indian Penal Code provides for punishment with rigorous
imprisonment for a term which may extend to 3 (three) years, and shall
also be liable to fine. What is your say about the quantum of sentence?
Answer: As the accused, I submit before this Hon'ble court that I
engaged in the commission of the offense under the influence of severe
emotional distress. I am a mother, responsible for the care of one child,
and I presently reside with my husband. I wish to bring to the court's
attention the potential hardship that may arise if I were to be
incarcerated, as my husband may not possess the capacity to provide
suitable care for our child under such circumstances. In light of these
circumstances, prayed before the court for a lenient sentencing
disposition.”
15.
From a consideration of the evidence adduced by the Prosecution
Page No.# 6/11
Witnesses and the examination of the appellant under Section 313 Cr.PC, it is
quite apparent that the appellant has been found guilty, only on account of her
confessional statement made under Section 164 Cr.PC, where she has admitted
to killing her daughter, by throwing the 38 day old baby in the river. The reason
for doing the same being that she was not feeling mentally well and did not like
to take her in her arms. The confessional statement is reproduced hereinbelow
as follows:“I was married 4 years ago. After wedding, I started living at my
husband's house with my husband, father-in-law Akonman Dutta and
brother-in-law Niranjan Dutta. My family life was good and there was
cordial relationship among all of us. At first, I gave birth to a boy. He is
two years old now. On 06.09.16, I gave birth to a girl child. I named her
Baby Dutta. At the time of birth, her weight was only 1.5 kg. I did not like
my daughter from the day she was born. Because, when I was pregnant,
initially I was not aware of it for about 4 months. When I got to know
about it, I went for abortion but time was already up and I could not
undergo abortion. As my male child was young, I did not want another
child right now. After my daughter was born, I started to feel mentally
unwell. I didn't feel like taking her in my arms. Since the morning of
14/10/16, I had been feeling mentally unwell. I kept on doing my daily
chores. I did not feel like having meal at mid-day and I did not feel like
going into my room. I was feeling sad for my son. Around 6:30-7:00 p.m.
in the evening, I finished cooking. My husband went out to attend 'Diha
Naam' in the village at that time. I had dinner at about 7:00 p.m. and only
my brother-in-law was at home at that time. Then, I went to bed to sleep
taking my son and daughter along. At about 7:30 p.m., my brother-in-law
had dinner and went to bed and at about 8:00 p.m., my father-in-law
returned. After a while I fell asleep. Suddenly, I woke up at around 8:309:00 p.m. I was heartbroken. I got up taking my daughter in my lap and
went out from the house. My father-in-law and brother-in-law were asleep
at that time and they were not aware of me going out. Walking in the
darkness of the night, I reached the bank of Dikhow river. Then, without
thinking anything, I threw away my little daughter into the river. She
drowned and was swept away. I did not feel bad at all and returning
home, I slept with my son in the bed. At about 10:30 p.m., my husband
Page No.# 7/11
returned home and woke me up from sleep. He asked me about our
daughter and I replied that I did not know. My husband raised a hue and
cry and the rest of the people at house woke up. We searched for the girl
together. Later, people from the village arrived and helped in searching. I
did not tell anything to anyone at that time. I was afraid and I could
realize my mistake. I started feeling like a criminal. The villagers asked me
whether I had done something to the girl. But I remained quiet. The next
morning the police were informed and they came. The villagers had
suspicion on me and after interrogation, the police also suspected me.
Then I was compelled to admit my crime and in front of everyone, I said
that I had thrown away my little daughter into the river. Now, I have
realized my guilt and I confess my crime.”
16.
The 164 Cr.PC confessional statement made by the appellant was then
signed by the appellant, the woman head constable Gulnahar Begum and PW-8.
The signing of the appellant’s confessional statement by the police-woman
implies that the policewoman was also present at the time of recording the
confessional statement. The same makes the said confessional statement
inadmissible as evidence, as the accused cannot be said to be completely free
from police pressure or influence at the time of making her confession.
17.
In the case of Jiten Engti & Ors v. State of Assam & Anr , reported in
2026 Live Law, (GAU) 75, the Division Bench of this Court has held that the
presence of a Police Officer during recording of a confession under Section 164
Cr.PC renders it inadmissible in evidence, as the said confession cannot be said
to be voluntary, being made in the presence of a Police Officer.
18.
The answer given by the appellant to question No. 12, while being
examined under Section 313 Cr.PC, appears to show that the appellant did not
know that her confessional statement was recorded. It can also be considered
to be a retraction of the confessional statement made under Section 164 Cr.PC.
Page No.# 8/11
Question No. 12 and the appellant's answer to the same during her examination
under Section 313 Cr.PC is reproduced herein below as follows:“Q. No.12: PW 8 Smti Manashreeporna Khound, in her evidence deposed
that while she was posted as JMFC at Sivasagar, on 20.10.2016, she
recorded your confessional statement u/s 164 Cr.P.C. in the prescribed
format. Ext. 8 is the prescribed format, Ext. 8(1), 8(2) & 8(3) are the
three relevant pages with relevant questions and answers. On looking at
Ext.8, it depicts that you have confessed your guilt stating that you had
thrown your baby daughter on the water of river. What is your say about
it ?
Ans: I don't know Sir.”
19.
Leaving aside the question as to whether there was a retraction of the
confessional statement by the appellant, due to the presence of the woman
head constable at the time of recording her confessional statement, the
conviction of the appellant cannot be sustained under Sections 302/201 IPC only
on the basis of the said confessional statement, which is inadmissible in
evidence.
20.
The above being said, the appellant had, at the time of sentence hearing
under Section 235(2) Cr.PC, admitted to having committed the offence under
severe emotional distress. The question that arises is whether an admission to a
crime made by an accused, at the time of hearing on the question of sentence,
can be admissible as evidence, for convicting an accused. In this respect, it
would be profitable to refer to the case of Muniappan vs. State of Tamil
Nadu, reported in (1981) 3 SCC 11, where the Supreme Court held that
questions which the Judge can put to the accused under Section 235 (2) Cr.PC
and the answers which the accused makes to those questions, are beyond the
Page No.# 9/11
narrow constraints of the Evidence Act. The Court, while on the question of
sentence, is in an altogether different domain, in which facts and factors which
operate are of an entirely different order than those which come into play on
the question of conviction.
21.
A reading of Section 235(2) Cr.PC shows that it is only when the Court has
come to a conclusion/finding that an accused is guilty of the offence, after
sifting through the recorded evidence, which has been made under oath, that a
hearing on the sentence is required to be held. On the other hand, the
admission of a crime during sentence hearing is not made under oath. Thus, the
conviction of an accused having already been made, on the basis of recorded
evidence on oath, an admission of a crime by an accused during sentence
hearing cannot be considered to be additional evidence against the accused.
22.
In the present case, the evidence that had been the basis for convicting
the appellant was her confessional statement made under Section 164 Cr.P.C.
However, as indicated earlier, her confessional statement under Section 164
Cr.P.C is inadmissible in evidence, inasmuch as, it could not be said to be
voluntary, due to the presence of the woman Head Constable, who had given
her signature in the said confessional statement. Further, an admission to a
crime made by an accused, at the time of sentence hearing under Section
235(2) Cr.PC, is not admissible as evidence for the purpose of convicting an
accused.
23.
Due to the above reasons, we find that the conviction of the appellant
under Section 302/201 IPC is not sustainable and accordingly, the conviction
and sentence of the appellant has to be set aside.
Page No.# 10/11
24.
The above being said, even if we have to assume that the confessional
statement of the appellant which has been recorded by PW-8 could be relied
upon, we are perplexed as to why the appellant would have killed her child. Her
confessional statement is to the effect that she was mentally unwell and that
she did not like her daughter from the day she was born. On trying to
understand the case where a mother does not like her newborn child, we have
come across rare cases of infanticide due to Postpartum Psychosis (P.P.P.).
25.
Postpartum Psychosis is a severe mental illness which develops acutely in
the early postnatal period. It is a psychiatric emergency where woman with
P.P.P. can lose touch with reality. Some symptoms of P.P.P. can come and go, be
fleeting and changeable. It has been estimated that some risk occurs to babies,
in around 35% P.P.P. cases, due to the mothers acting upon false beliefs,
incorrectly handling their babies, being severely confused or behaving in very
unusual ways. This behavior is temporary and is caused by the P.P.P. effect on
the brain.
26.
The National Library of Medicine in the National Centre for Biotechnology
Information states that P.P.P. is rare, affecting one and two per one thousand
women. However, P.P.P. can develop rapidly and place the life of the mother and
infant in danger. It’s symptoms may include delusions, hallucinations, severe
mood symptoms and cognitive symptoms. It also noted that childbirth is a
potent trigger for severe mood disorder.
27.
In the present case, though we are not required to go into the issue of
whether the appellant suffered from P.P.P., the same should have been
considered by the learned Trial Court, prior to convicting the appellant under
Page No.# 11/11
Section 302/201 IPC. As we have already held that the conviction of the
appellant only on the basis of the confessional statement is not sustainable, as
the confessional statement is inadmissible in evidence, the appeal succeeds. As
the Prosecution has failed to prove the guilt of the appellant beyond reasonable
doubt, the appellant is acquitted of the charges framed against her under
Section 302 IPC and Section 201 IPC. Consequently, the impugned judgment
dated 12.09.2023 passed by the Court of Sessions Judge, Sivasagar, in Case No.
Session 73(S-S)/2017 is set aside. The appellant should be released immediately
from judicial custody, if not wanted in any other case.
28.
Send back the TCR.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
Kalpan
a Devi
JUDGE
Digitally signed
by Kalpana Devi
Date:
2026.10.05
23:59:58 -07'00'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review