Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Form No. J(2)
In the High Court at Calcutta
Civil Appellate Jurisdiction
Appellate Side
The Hon’ble Justice Sabyasachi Bhattacharyya
And
The Hon’ble Justice Supratim Bhattacharya
Present:
FA 336 of 2025
IA No: CAN 4 of 2025
Sri Siddhartha Mukherjee @ Siddhartha Mukhopadhyay
Vs.
Smt Jyotikona Banerjee
For the appellant
:
Mr. Subhabrata Bandyopadhyay
For the respondent
:
Mr. Arif Ali,
Mr. S. Bhattacharjee,
Mr. Bikash Kumar Roy
Heard on
:
27.01.2026
Judgment on
:
27.01.2026
Sabyasachi Bhattacharyya, J.:1.
The present appeal has been preferred against the grant of probate in
respect of a Will in favour of the respondent.
2.
Learned counsel for the appellant assails the impugned judgment
granting probate primarily on the ground that the issues in the
testamentary suit were framed subsequent to the evidence being led
by
both
the
parties,
whereafter
an
application
filed
by
the
propounder/respondent for adoption of the propounder’s witnesses’
evidence was allowed. Even thereafter, when the present appellant,
who disputed the grant of probate, made an application for crossexamination of P.W. 1 and P.W. 2 on recall, on the ground that the
adoption of evidence of P.W. 1 and P.W. 2 tantamounted to adduction
of fresh evidence, entitling the present appellant to further crossexamine such witnesses, the learned Trial Judge refused to grant the
same.
3.
It is contended by learned counsel for the appellant that in the event a
party is permitted to adopt its witnesses’ evidence, it tantamounts to
adduction of fresh evidence. The effect of such fresh evidence would
be that the earlier evidence adduced by the self-same witnesses gets
nullified, thereby reopening an opportunity to the other side to crossexamine the witnesses on the freshly adduced evidence.
4.
In support of such contention, learned counsel cites K.K. Velusamy
vs. N. Palanisamy, reported at (2011) 11 SCC 275, Ayaaubkhan
Noorkhan Pathan vs. The State of Maharashtra & Ors. reported at AIR
2013 SC 58, and an unreported judgment in the matter of M/s
Andaman Timber Industries vs. Commissioner of Central Excise,
Kolkata-II, passed in Civil Appeal No. 4228 of 2006.
5.
Learned counsel also argues that it was recorded by the testamentary
court in Order No.104 dated April 17, 2019 that time was sought by
the propounder/present respondent for filing a death certificate. It is
sought to be contended that the said order itself indicates that there
was no death certificate of the testator on record on the relevant date
and, as such, such death certificate must have been permitted to be
adduced in evidence subsequently. It is contended that such further
evidence also entitled the appellant to cross-examine the propounder’s
witnesses.
6.
Learned counsel appearing for the propounder/respondent opposes
the contentions of the appellant and argues that even without the
adoption of the evidence already led by P.W.1 and P.W.2, the effect
would be that the learned testamentary court would be at liberty to
look into the evidence adduced earlier. As such, it is submitted that
no fresh evidence could be said to have been led merely by adoption of
the earlier evidence which was already on record. Thus, no fresh right
could have been said to be created in favour of the present appellant
to further cross-examine the propounder’s witnesses.
7.
Learned counsel next points out that an earlier prayer of similar
nature, seeking to recall P.W. 1 and P.W. 2 for the purpose of crossexamining them afresh, had already been refused by the learned Trial
Judge and, as such, the learned testamentary court was justified in
refusing the second similar prayer in any event.
8.
Upon a careful consideration of the materials on record, we find that
nothing turned on the order dated April 17, 2019, in which the
testamentary court had merely recorded that the propounder had
sought for time to file a death certificate. There is nothing on record
to show whether the death certificate was filed or proved later.
9.
In any event, learned counsel for the appellant does not pursue this
line of argument further.
10. Insofar as the supposed right of the appellant to further crossexamine the propounder’s witnesses, we do not find substance in the
contention of the appellant.
11. Before the testamentary court, the pleadings of both the parties were
already on record and the parties went to trial knowing fully well the
issues which would have to be addressed by them in their evidence.
12. Moreover, the propounder adduced two witnesses, being P.W. 1 and
P.W. 2, who were cross-examined at length by the present appellant.
13. Not stopping there, the objector/present appellant also adduced as
many as three witnesses, being OPWs 1, 2 and 3 respectively, who
were also cross-examined by the propounder/respondent. After the
evidence was complete, it was pointed out to the testamentary court
that issues had not been formally formulated, upon which, the
learned testamentary court formally framed issues in the suit.
14. After framing of such issues, the first application was filed by the
present appellant for recall of P.W. 1 and P.W. 2 for further crossexamination. A perusal of the said application dated December 13,
2019 shows that no reason whatsoever was assigned for seeking such
recall. The only ground mentioned in the application was <for proper
adjudication=, which does not mean anything.
15. Such
application
was
followed
by
an
application
by
the
propounder/present respondent dated December 19, 2019 praying for
<necessary orders=. In the body of the application, it was pleaded that
the propounder had already adduced two witnesses, P.W. 1 and P.W.
2, by filing examination-in-chief and hence, the propounder was
thereby accepting and adopting the same chief of both the witnesses
and no further modification or addition or deletion of any facts or
circumstances were required to be made at that stage.
16. Vide Order No. 112 dated January 15, 2020, the court dealt with both
the applications and allowed the application of the propounder dated
December 19, 2019 for adopting the evidence taken earlier.
17. However, in the self-same order, the learned testamentary Judge
elaborately recorded that the P.W. 1, P.W. 2 and OPWs 1, 2 and 3 had
adduced evidence and were cross-examined and the evidence was
completely recorded and the witnesses discharged.
18. It was further recorded that after the said transferee court, being the
Additional District Judge, Second Court at Durgapur, receiving the
case records, the evidence of OPW 4 was also recorded partly on July
11, 2017 and August 03, 2017 by the transferee court but deferred on
the prayer of learned counsel for the opposite party (present
appellant).
19. Subsequently, the testamentary court went on recording, after taking
several adjournments, the opposite party filed a petition praying for
closing the OPWs and on the prayer of the opposite party only the
evidence of the OPWs stood closed and the case was fixed for
arguments.
20. Thereafter, at the time of arguments on January 07, 2019, learned
counsel for the petitioner drew the attention of the court, by filing a
petition, to the fact that no issue was framed by the previous
Presiding Officer, upon which on April 17, 2019, the court formally
framed the issues-in-question.
21. The learned Trial Judge further observed that power under Order
XVIII Rule 17 of the Code of Civil Procedure, which was sought to be
invoked by the present appellant at the first instance, can only be
invoked as per convenience of the court, to enable the court to clarify
any issue or doubt.
However, such power was not intended to be
used to fill omission in evidence of a witness who has already been
examined in full and discharged.
22. The learned testamentary court also observed that on a careful
reading of the petition dated December 13, 2019 filed by the
objector/OP, it was revealed that it had not been specifically
mentioned in the petition as to in what respect further crossexamination of P.W. 1 and 2 was essential and what are the essential
questions which could not be put to them earlier. Both the parties, it
was held, after understanding the crux of the case as well as keeping
in view the statute, that is, the Indian Succession Act, conducted the
case knowing the facts in issue in the case and therefore, absence of
issue did not lead to mistrial, though issues had been framed
afterwards.
23. We completely agree with such proposition of law as relied on by the
learned testamentary court. Mere adoption of evidence by the selfsame party, which led the evidence in the first place, does not make
any difference insofar as the effect of the evidence is concerned. In
fact, this Court is of the opinion that the order allowing the
propounder/present respondent to adopt her earlier evidence was a
surplusage and superfluity.
Nothing hinges on such so-called
adoption, since the evidence of both the parties, including the
propounder, was already on record irrespective of the formal framing
of the issues or not. There was no necessity at all for the propounder
to adopt evidence already led by the propounder herself as P.W.1 as
well as another witness, being P.W.2.
24. Therefore, in any event, we deem such adoption to be a surplusage
and the learned testamentary court rightly relied on the evidence of
the parties already on record.
25. There are two other aspects of the matter which we must deal with.
First, the earlier application for recall of P.W.1 and P.W.2 made by the
objector/present appellant was at a time when neither the application
for adoption of evidence was filed by the propounder/respondent nor
was the same allowed.
26. Thus, the primary ground for seeking such recall was evidently to fill
up the lacunae in the evidence already adduced by the opposite
party/appellant.
27. The said application having been dismissed categorically on merits
vide Order No. 112 dated January 15, 2020 and having not been
challenged successfully, such dismissal attained finality.
28. Hence, the second application dated February 06, 2020 with the selfsame prayer, that is, for cross-examination of P.W.1 and P.W.2, by
mere change of the caption to Order XVIII Rule 4 of the Code of Civil
Procedure, was ex facie barred by the principle of res judicata and
was rightly dismissed on such ground vide Order No. 114 dated
February 17, 2020 passed by the testamentary court.
29. The other aspect of the matter is that evidence was initially led by
both the parties at length.
The witnesses of the parties were also
cross-examined by each other. Thereafter, only at the behest of the
opposite party was the further evidence of the OPWs closed. Hence, it
cannot be said that the opposite party could have any grievance
regarding not getting adequate opportunity to adduce independent
evidence as well as cross-examine the propounder’s witnesses.
30. As held by the testamentary court, both the parties went to trial and
adduced evidence at length on the relevant issues, knowing fully well
the issues required to be addressed by them.
31. Thus, nothing turned on the subsequent formal formulation of issues,
which was a mere formality and did not change the material
circumstances of the case.
32. Hence, such formal framing of issues did not give rise to any further
cause of action for either of the parties to lead fresh evidence at all.
33. Insofar as the arguments of the appellant that due to adoption of the
propounder of her earlier evidence, the same should be treated to be
fresh evidence and a right ought to have been given to the appellant to
cross-examine the witnesses of the propounder, we cannot accept the
same, in view of our above observation that such permission to adopt
earlier evidence was a mere surplusage.
34. We accordingly hold that even without such adoption, independently
the testamentary court was entitled to and did examine the evidence
already on record on behalf of the propounder.
35. In such view of the matter, since the self-same evidence was relied on
by the propounder at all stages of the testamentary suit, there was no
occasion
for
the
court
to
grant
fresh
opportunity
to
the
objector/appellant to reopen the entire gamut of the case, after having
himself prayed for closure of the evidence, and/or to cross-examine
the P.W.1 and P.W.2 afresh in order to cover up the objector’s own
lacunae.
36. Hence, we do not find any merit in the contentions of the appellant.
37. Insofar as the judgments cited by learned counsel for the appellant
are concerned, those are not germane for the present adjudication.
38. In K.K. Velusamy (supra), the Hon’ble Supreme Court observed that
although there is no specific provision in the Code of Civil Procedure
enabling the parties to reopen the evidence for the purpose of further
examination-in-chief or cross-examination, Section 151 of the Code
can be resorted to in such circumstances in the absence of any
provision.
39. It was further held that in the absence of any such provision, for the
purposes other than securing clarification required by the court, the
inherent power under Section 151 could be invoked in appropriate
cases to reopen the evidence and/or recall the witnesses.
40. In the present case, there is no quarrel with such proposition. We
are, however, not satisfied on the facts of the instant lis, as discussed
above, that this is an appropriate case where such power of recall
ought to be exercised.
41. In Ayaaubkhan Noorkhan Pathan (supra), the Hon’ble Supreme Court
reiterated the well-settled proposition that affidavits within the
meaning of Order XIX of the Code of Civil Procedure per se could not
tantamount to evidence, unless directed by the court to be so
construed.
42. However, under Order XVIII Rules 4 and 5, the contemplation of the
amended Code of Civil Procedure is specifically to treat such evidence
in chief to be in lieu of oral evidence of the parties.
43. In such view of the matter, the ratio laid down in Ayaaubkhan
Noorkhan Pathan (supra) is not germane at all, as we are not dealing
at all with a situation under Order XIX of the Code of Civil Procedure
but regular affidavits in chief filed by the parties under Order XVIII
Rule 4 of the Code.
44. Thus, the said judgment cannot be of any aid to the appellant in the
present case.
45. Lastly, in M/s Andaman Timber Industries (supra), it was observed by
the Hon’ble Supreme Court that not allowing the assessee to crossexamine the witnesses by the Adjudicating Authority in the said case,
though the statements of those witnesses were made the basis of the
impugned order, was a serious flaw which rendered the order a
nullity.
46. The said proposition is not attracted to the present case in any
manner whatsoever, since, in the case at hand, both parties led
evidence at length and also cross-examined each other’s witnesses. It
was only at the behest of the objector/present appellant that the
evidence was ultimately closed.
47. Moreover, the other distinguishing circumstance here is that a
previous application for recall of P.W. 1 and P.W.2 at the behest of the
appellant himself had already been dismissed, which order had
attained finality and operated on the principle of res judicata to debar
the subsequent application on the self-same prayer.
48. Hence, the ratio laid down in M/s Andaman Timber Industries (supra)
is also not relevant in the present context.
49. Accordingly, FA 336 of 2025 is dismissed on contest, thereby
affirming the judgment and deemed decree dated March 16, 2020
passed by the learned Additional District Judge, Second Court at
Durgapur, District: Paschim Bardhaman in O.S. (Will) Case No. 01 of
2017.
50. The connected application, bearing CAN 4 of 2025, stands disposed of
accordingly as well.
51. There will be no order as to costs.
52. Urgent photostat certified copies of this judgment, if applied for, be
made available to the parties upon compliance with the requisite
formalities.
(Sabyasachi Bhattacharyya, J.)
I agree.
(Supratim Bhattacharya, J.)
AD-37
TN
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review