Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1NC: 2026:KHC-D:258-DB
RFA No. 100091 of 2016
C/W RFA No. 100055 of 2016
RFA No. 100071 of 2018
RSA No. 5392 of 2010
HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA, DHARWAD BENCH
DATED THIS THE 12TH DAY OF JANUARY 2026
PRESENT
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MOHAMMAD NAWAZ
AND
THE HON'BLE MRS JUSTICE GEETHA K.B.
REGULAR FIRST APPEAL NO.100091 OF 2016 (PAR/POS)
C/W REGULAR FIRST APPEAL NO.100055 OF 2016
REGULAR FIRST APPEAL NO.100071 OF 2018 AND
REGULAR SECOND APPEAL NO.5392 OF 2010
IN RFA NO. 100091/2016
BETWEEN:
1.
VEERANNA
S/O. SHANTAVEERAPPA RITTIGANIGER,
AGE: 45 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O. SHIRAMAPUR VILLAGE,
TQ. AND DIST. HAVERI.
2.
ANIL KUMAR
S/O. SHANTVEERAPPA RITTIGANGER,
AGE: 41 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O. SHIRAMPUR VILLAGE,
TQ. AND DIST. HAVERI.
SAROJA
HANGARAKI
...APPELLANTS
SAROJA HANGARAKI
Location: HIGHCOURT
OF KARNATAKA
DHARWAD BENCH
DHARWAD
(BY SRI. R.G. KODLI, ADVOCATE)
AND:
1.
SMT. ANASUYA @ AKKAMAHADEVI
W/O. ULAVAPPA TALAGERI,
AGE: 51 YEARS, OCC. HOUSE WORK,
R/O. KAMALAPUR, NARAYANPUR, DHARWAD.
2.
SMT. CHANNABASAVVA
W/O. BASAPPA HONNALLI,
AGE: 56 YEARS, OCC. HOUSE WORK,
R/O. HALAGERI ONI, UNAKAL,
TQ. AND DIST. HUBBALLI.
R
-2NC: 2026:KHC-D:258-DB
HC-KAR
RFA No. 100091 of 2016
C/W RFA No. 100055 of 2016
RFA No. 100071 of 2018
RSA No. 5392 of 2010
3.
UMESH S/O. BASAPPA HONNALLI,
AGE: 38 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURIST,
R/O. HALAGERI ONI, UNAKAL,
TQ. AND DIST. HUBBALLI.
4.
PARAMESH S/O. BASAPPA HONNALLI,
AGE: 34 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURIST,
R/O. HALAGERI ONI, UNAKAL,
TQ. AND DIST. HUBBALLI.
5.
MANJU S/O. BASAPPA HONNALLI,
AGE: 31 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURIST,
R/O. HALAGERI ONI, UNAKAL,
TQ. AND DIST. HUBBALLI.
6.
SIDDAPPA S/O. VEERABHADRAPPA HONNALLI,
AGE: 66 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURIST,
R/O. HALAGERI ONI, UNAKAL,
TQ. AND DIST. HUBBALLI.
7.
VIRUPAKSHAPPA
S/O. VEERABHADRAPPA HONNALLI,
AGE: 56 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O. ADARGUNCHI, TQ. HUBBALLI.
8.
IRANNA S/O. BASAPPA HEBBALLI,
AGE: 29 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O. TEACHERS COLONY, UNKAL, TQ. HUBBALLI.
9.
JAGADISH S/O. BASAPPA HEBBALLI,
AGE: 31 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O. TEACHERS COLONY, UNKAL, TQ. HUBBALLI.
10. SHIVABASAYYA S/O. SIDDRAMAYYA HIREMATH,
AGE: 78 YEARS, OCC. DOCTOR,
R/O. KALYAN NAGAR, HUBBALLI.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. V.P. VADAVI, ADVOCATE FOR R1;
SRI. MALLIKARJUNSWAMY B. HIREMATH, ADVOCATE FOR R2-R6;
R7 TO R9-NOTICE SERVED;
SRI. SHIVASHANKAR R. AMBLI, ADVOCATE AND
SRI. S.S. NIRJAN, ADVOCATE FOR R10 )
THIS RFA IS FILED UNDER SECTION 96 OF CPC, PRAYING TO
SET ASIDE THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE IN O.S.NO.20/2010 DATED
-3NC: 2026:KHC-D:258-DB
HC-KAR
RFA No. 100091 of 2016
C/W RFA No. 100055 of 2016
RFA No. 100071 of 2018
RSA No. 5392 of 2010
29.01.2016 ON THE FILE OF THE PRINCIPAL SENIOR CIVIL JUDGE
AND JMFC, HUBBALLI, BY ALLOWING THIS APPEAL IN THE INTEREST
OF JUSTICE AND EQUITY.
IN RFA NO. 100055/2016
BETWEEN:
1.
SMT. CHANNABASAVVA
W/O. BASAPPA HONNALLI,
AGE: 58 YEARS, OCC. HOUSE WORK,
R/O. HALAGERI ONI, UNAKAL,
TQ. HUBBALLI-580030.
2.
UMESH S/O. BASAPPA HONNALLI,
AGE: 38 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURIST,
R/O. HALAGERI ONI, UNAKAL,
TQ. HUBBALLI-580030.
3.
PARAMESH S/O. BASAPPA HONNALLI,
AGE: 34 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURIST,
R/O. HALAGERI ONI, UNAKAL,
TQ. HUBBALLI-580030.
4.
MANJU S/O. BASAPPA HONNALLI,
AGE: 31 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURIST,
R/O. HALAGERI ONI, UNAKAL,
TQ. HUBBALLI-580030.
5.
SIDDAPPA S/O. VEERABHADRAPPA HONNALLI,
AGE: 66 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURIST,
R/O. HALAGERI ONI, UNAKAL,
TQ. HUBBALLI-580030.
...APPELLANTS
(BY SRI. MALLIKARJUNSWAMY B. HIREMATH AND
SRI. R.G. KODLI, ADVOCATES)
AND:
1.
SMT. ANASUYA @ AKKAMAHADEVI
W/O. ULAVAPPA TALAGERI,
AGE: 51 YEARS, OCC. HOUSE WORK,
R/O. KAMALAPUR, NARAYANPUR,
DHARWAD-580030.
-4NC: 2026:KHC-D:258-DB
HC-KAR
RFA No. 100091 of 2016
C/W RFA No. 100055 of 2016
RFA No. 100071 of 2018
RSA No. 5392 of 2010
2.
VIRUPAKSHAPPA
S/O. VEERABHADRAPPA HONNALLI,
AGE: 56 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O. ADARGUNCHI, TQ. HUBBALLI-580030.
3.
IRANNA S/O. BASAPPA HEBBALLI,
AGE: 29 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O. TEACHERS COLONY, UNKAL,
TQ. HUBBALLI-580030.
4.
JAGADISH S/O. BASAPPA HEBBALLI,
AGE: 31 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O. TEACHERS COLONY, UNKAL,
TQ. HUBBALLI-580030.
5.
SHIVABASAYYA
S/O. SIDDRAMAYYA HIREMATH,
AGE: 78 YEARS, OCC. DOCTOR,
R/O. KALYAN NAGAR, HUBBALLI-580030.
6.
VEERANNA
S/O. SHANTAVEERAPPA RITTIGANIGER,
AGE: 45 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O. SHIRAMAPUR VILLAGE,
TQ. AND DIST. HAVERI-580030.
7.
ANIL KUMAR
S/O. SHANTVEERAPPA RITTIGANGER,
AGE: 41 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O. SHIRAMPUR VILLAGE,
TQ. AND DIST. HAVERI-580030.
...RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. V.P. VADAVI, ADVOCATE FOR R1;
R2 TO R3-NOTICE SERVED;
SRI. RAKESH BILKI, ADVOCATE FOR R4;
SRI. SHIVASHANKAR R. AMBLI, ADVOCATE AND
SRI. S.S. NIRANJAN, ADVOCATE FOR R5;
SRI. S.B. PATIL, ADVOCATE FOR R6, R7)
THIS RFA IS FILED UNDER SECTION 96 OF CPC, PRAYING TO SET
ASIDE THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE IN O.S.NO.20/2010 DATED
29.01.2016 ON THE FILE OF THE PRINCIPAL SENIOR CIVIL JUDGE
AND JMFC, HUBBALLI, BY ALLOWING THIS APPEAL IN THE INTEREST
-5NC: 2026:KHC-D:258-DB
HC-KAR
RFA No. 100091 of 2016
C/W RFA No. 100055 of 2016
RFA No. 100071 of 2018
RSA No. 5392 of 2010
OF JUSTICE AND EQUITY.
IN RFA NO. 100071/2018
BETWEEN:
SHIVABASAYYA S/O. SIDDRAMAYYA HIREMATH,
AGE: 80 YEARS, OCC. DOCTOR,
R/O. KALYAN NAGAR, HUBBALLI-580001.
...APPELLANT
(BY SRI. S.S. NIRANJAN, ADVOCATE)
AND:
1.
SMT. ANASUYA @ AKKAMAHADEVI
W/O. ULAVAPPA TALAGERI,
AGE: 53 YEARS, OCC. HOUSE WORK,
R/O. KAMALAPUR, NARAYANPUR,
DHARWAD-580001.
2.
SMT. CHANNABASAVVA
W/O. BASAPPA HONNALLI,
AGE: 52 YEARS, OCC. HOUSE WORK,
R/O. HALAGERI ONI, UNAKAL,
TQ. AND DIST. HUBBALLI-580001.
3.
UMESH S/O. BASAPPA HONNALLI,
AGE: 34 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURIST,
R/O. HALAGERI ONI, UNAKAL,
TQ. AND DIST. HUBBALLI-580001.
4.
PARAMESH S/O. BASAPPA HONNALLI,
AGE: 30 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURIST,
R/O. HALAGERI ONI, UNAKAL,
TQ. AND DIST. HUBBALLI-580001.
5.
MANJU S/O. BASAPPA HONNALLI,
AGE: 27 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURIST,
R/O. HALAGERI ONI, UNAKAL,
TQ. AND DIST. HUBBALLI-580001.
6.
SIDDAPPA S/O. VEERABHADRAPPA HONNALLI,
AGE: 62 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURIST,
R/O. HALAGERI ONI, UNAKAL,
TQ. AND DIST. HUBBALLI-580001.
-6NC: 2026:KHC-D:258-DB
HC-KAR
RFA No. 100091 of 2016
C/W RFA No. 100055 of 2016
RFA No. 100071 of 2018
RSA No. 5392 of 2010
7.
VIRUPAKSHAPPA
S/O. VEERABHADRAPPA HONNALLI,
AGE: 52 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O. TEACHERS COLONY, UNKAL,
TQ. HUBBALLI-580001.
8.
IRANNA S/O. BASAPPA HEBBALLI,
AGE: 25 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O. TEACHERS COLONY, UNKAL,
TQ. HUBBALLI-580001.
9.
JAGADISH S/O. BASAPPA HEBBALLI,
AGE: 27 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O. TEACHERS COLONY, UNKAL,
TQ. HUBBALLI-580001.
10. VEERANNA
S/O. SHANTAVEERAPPA RITTIGANIGER,
AGE: 41 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O. SHIRAMAPUR VILLAGE,
TQ. AND DIST. HAVERI-581110.
11. ANIL KUMAR
S/O. SHANTVEERAPPA RITTIGANGER,
AGE: 37 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O. SHIRAMPUR VILLAGE,
TQ. AND DIST. HAVERI-581110.
...RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. V.P. VADAVI, ADVOCATE FOR R1;
SRI. MALLIKARJUNSWAMY B. HIREMATH, ADVOCATE FOR R2-R6;
R7 TO R10-NOTICE SERVED;
SRI. S.B. PATIL, ADVOCATE FOR R11)
THIS RFA IS FILED UNDER SECTION 96 OF CPC, PRAYING TO
SET ASIDE THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE IN O.S.NO.20/2010 DATED
29.01.2016 ON THE FILE OF THE PRINCIPAL SENIOR CIVIL JUDGE
AND JMFC, HUBBALLI, BY ALLOWING THIS APPEAL IN THE INTEREST
OF JUSTICE AND EQUITY.
-7NC: 2026:KHC-D:258-DB
HC-KAR
RFA No. 100091 of 2016
C/W RFA No. 100055 of 2016
RFA No. 100071 of 2018
RSA No. 5392 of 2010
IN RSA NO. 5392/2010
BETWEEN:
1.
SIDDAPPA S/O. VEERABHADRAPPA HONNALLI,
AGE: MAJOR, OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O. UNKAL, HUBBALLI-580031.
2.
CHANNABASAVVA S/O. BASAPPA HONALLI,
AGE: MAJOR, OCC. HOUSEHOLD WORK,
R/O. UNKAL, HUBBALLI-580031.
3.
UMESH S/O. BASAPPA HONALLI,
AGE: 39 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O. UNKAL, HUBBALLI-580031.
4.
PARAMESH S/O. BASAPPA HONNALLI,
AGE: 39 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O. UNKAL, HUBBALLI-580031.
5.
MANJU S/O. BASAPPA HONNALLI,
AGE: 26 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O. UNKAL, HUBBALLI-580031.
...APPELLANTS
(BY SRI. MALLIKARJUN B. HIREMATH, ADVOCATE)
AND:
1.
SMT. RUDRAVVA
W/O. VEERABHADRAPPA HONNALLI,
AGE: MAJOR, OCC. HOUSEHOLD,
R/O. C/O. SMT. A.U. TALAGERI,
KAMALAPUR, NARAYANAPUR,
DHARWAD-580001.
2.
SMT. ANASUYA @ AKKAMAHADEVI
W/O. ULAVAPPA TALAGERI,
AGE: MAJOR, OCC. HOUSEHOLD,
R/O. KAMALAPUR, NARAYANPUR,
DHARWAD-580001.
3.
SRI. IRAPPA VEERABHADRAPPA HONNALLI
AGE: MAJOR, OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O. UNKAL, HALAGERI ONI,
HUBBALLI-580031.
-8NC: 2026:KHC-D:258-DB
RFA No. 100091 of 2016
C/W RFA No. 100055 of 2016
RFA No. 100071 of 2018
RSA No. 5392 of 2010
HC-KAR
4.
PARVATEVVA W/O. YALLAPPA YALIWAL,
AGE: MAJOR, OCC. HOUSEHOLD WORK,
R/O. INGALGAI, TQ. KUNDAGOL,
DIST. DHARWAD-580001.
5.
SIDDAWWA
W/O. PARAMESHWARAPPA HOTAGI,
AGE: MAJOR, OCC. HOUSEHOLD WORK,
R/O. UNKAL, HALAGERI ONI,
HUBBALLI-580031.
6.
VEERUPAXAPPA S/O. VEERABHADRAPPA HONNALLI,
AGE: MAJOR, OCC. COOLIE,
R/O. ADARGUNCHI, HUBBALLI-580031.
...RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. V.P. VADAVI, ADVOCATE FOR R2;
R1 AND R3-NOTICE SERVED; R4-ABATED;
R5 AND R6-DISPENSED WITH)
THIS RSA IS FILED UNDER SECTION 100 OF CPC, PRAYING TO
SET ASIDE THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED 19.08.2009 PASSED
BY THE FAST TRACK COURT-II, DHARWAD SITTING AT HUBBALLI IN
R.A.NO.163/2003
AND
CONSEQUENTLY
DECREE
THE
SUIT
IN
O.S.NO.213/2000 BY CONFIRMING THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE
DATED 21.01.2003 PASSED BY ADDITIONAL CIVIL JUDGE (SR.DN.)
AT HUBBALLI AND ETC.
THESE APPEALS, COMING ON FOR FINAL HEARING, THIS DAY,
JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MOHAMMAD NAWAZ
AND
HON'BLE MRS JUSTICE GEETHA K.B.
-9NC: 2026:KHC-D:258-DB
RFA No. 100091 of 2016
C/W RFA No. 100055 of 2016
RFA No. 100071 of 2018
RSA No. 5392 of 2010
HC-KAR
ORAL JUDGMENT
(PER: HON'BLE MRS JUSTICE GEETHA K.B.)
1.
Regular First Appeal Nos.100091/2016 is filed
by defendant Nos.10 and 11, 100055/2016 is filed by
defendant Nos.1 to 5 and 100071/2018 is filed by
defendant No.9 challenging the judgment and decree
dated 29.01.2016 passed in O.S.No.20/2010 on the file of
the learned Principal Senior Civil Judge and J.M.F.C.,
Hubballi.
2.
Regular Second appeal No.5392/2010 is filed
challenging the judgment and decree dated 19.08.2009
passed in R.A. No.163/2003 on the file of the learned Fast
Track Court-II, Dharwad sitting at Hubballi.
3.
This
second
appeal
is
clubbed
with
the
aforesaid regular first appeals, as the parties to both the
suits are one and the same and they relate to the partition
dated 23.09.1984 between the parties.
- 10 NC: 2026:KHC-D:258-DB
RFA No. 100091 of 2016
C/W RFA No. 100055 of 2016
RFA No. 100071 of 2018
RSA No. 5392 of 2010
HC-KAR
4.
O.S.No.20/2010 is filed by Anasuya-daughter of
Veerabhadrappa seeking partition and separate possession
of her 1/4th share in the suit properties against her two
brothers and legal representatives of another brother and
also against purchasers in respect of ‘A’ to ‘G’ schedule
properties. Said suit was decreed.
5.
Two brothers of plaintiff in O.S.No.20/2010
have filed O.S.No.567/1987 against their father and
another brother praying for declaration and injunction that
they are the absolute owners of suit schedule property
bearing
No.887-888
23.09.1984.
Said
based
on
suit
was
the
partition
dated
renumbered
as
O.S.No.213/2000. The said suit was decreed. Against
which R.A.No.163/2003 was filed. It was dismissed.
Against
said
dismissal,
Regular
Second
appeal
No.5392/2010 is filed. Hence, both the regular first
appeals and the regular second appeal are clubbed
together and the arguments are heard commonly.
- 11 NC: 2026:KHC-D:258-DB
RFA No. 100091 of 2016
C/W RFA No. 100055 of 2016
RFA No. 100071 of 2018
RSA No. 5392 of 2010
HC-KAR
6.
The parties would be referred with their names
for sake of convenience and clarity.
7.
The admitted genealogy of parties is as follows:
Veerabhadrappa
Rudravva
Shiddappa
(deft.5)
Basappa
deceased
Virupakshappa
deft.6
Channabasavva
(deft.1)
Umesh
(dft.2)
Paramesh
(deft.3)
8.
Anasuya
Plf
Manju
(deft.4)
There are series of litigations pending between
parties since 1987 onwards. The first suit was filed in the
year 1987 i.e., O.S.No.567/1987, which is re-numbered as
O.S.No.213/2000,
for
the
relief
of
declaration
that
plaintiffs-Siddappa and Basappa are owners of the suit
schedule properties which were fallen to their respective
shares under partition deed dated 23.09.1984.
9.
The second suit is O.S.No.690/1989 filed by
father Veerabhadrappa challenging the partition dated
- 12 NC: 2026:KHC-D:258-DB
RFA No. 100091 of 2016
C/W RFA No. 100055 of 2016
RFA No. 100071 of 2018
RSA No. 5392 of 2010
HC-KAR
23.09.1984 alleging that it came into existence by fraud
and
misrepresentation.
It
was
dismissed
for
non-
prosecution on 18.06.1991 and it became final and nobody
has filed miscellaneous petition to restore the said suit.
10.
The
third
suit
is
filed
by
Siddappa
for
declaration in O.S.No.380/1990 in respect of property
fallen to his share in the earlier partition and later he sold
the said property to one Prabhavati Dambal and thus, he
withdrew the said suit.
11.
The fourth suit in O.S.No.28/1991 was filed by
present plaintiff-Anasuya against her father for the relief
of specific performance of contract in respect of three
schedule properties and it was compromised within 17
days.
12.
Afterwards fifth suit in O.S.No.130/1991 was
filed by Siddappa and Basappa praying for the relief of
declaration that the decree passed in O.S.No.28/1991 is
not binding on them and to restrain Anasuya from
- 13 NC: 2026:KHC-D:258-DB
RFA No. 100091 of 2016
C/W RFA No. 100055 of 2016
RFA No. 100071 of 2018
RSA No. 5392 of 2010
HC-KAR
alienating those properties, alleging impersonation and
fraud against Anasuya.
13.
Sixth
suit
in
O.S.No.106/2012
is
filed
by
Prabhavati Dambal against plaintiff-Anasuya and others.
14.
O.S.No.130/1991
and
O.S.213/2000
were
clubbed together and common judgment was passed
decreeing
both
judgment
suits.
and
Challenging
decree,
R.A.No.163/2003
are
challenging
judgment
the
filed.
the
said
common
R.A.No.162/2003
R.A.No.162/2003
and
decree
and
is
filed
passed
in
O.S.No.130/1991 and R.A.No.163/2003 is filed challenging
the judgment and decree passed in O.S.No.213/2000.
Ultimately, O.S.No.130/1991 is decreed by setting aside
the compromise decree in O.S.No.28/1991. It became
final because
Anasuya
has not challenged
the said
judgment and decree passed in R.A.No.162/2003.
15.
The judgment and decree in R.A.No.163/2003
was passed on 19.08.2009. Only after passing said
- 14 NC: 2026:KHC-D:258-DB
RFA No. 100091 of 2016
C/W RFA No. 100055 of 2016
RFA No. 100071 of 2018
RSA No. 5392 of 2010
HC-KAR
judgment and decree in R.A.No.162/2003, the plaintiffAnasuya has filed seventh suit in O.S.No.20/2010 praying
for partition in respect of all the joint family properties.
16.
During pendency of these matters, the second
son Basappa died and his legal representatives i.e., his
wife and children are brought on record in all proceedings.
17.
Against the judgment and decree passed in
R.A.No.163/2003, the present RSA No.5392/2010 is filed
by the Siddappa-son of the original propositus and the
legal
representatives
of
second
son
of
the
original
propositus.
18.
It
is
the
contention
of
plaintiffs
in
O.S.No.567/1987 that there was an earlier partition in
20.08.1984 and the said partition was challenged by one
of the sons of Veerabhadrappa through another wife of
Veerabhadrappa-Erappa before the Revenue Authorities
and ultimately, the revenue entries based on the said
20.08.1984 partition was set aside.
- 15 NC: 2026:KHC-D:258-DB
RFA No. 100091 of 2016
C/W RFA No. 100055 of 2016
RFA No. 100071 of 2018
RSA No. 5392 of 2010
HC-KAR
19.
The learned Appellate Judge has dismissed the
suit filed by Siddappa and the legal representatives of
deceased Basappa on some grounds. The first ground is
that no share is allotted to father in immovable properties
and no share is allotted to mother. The said partition deed
dated 23.09.1984 is marked as Ex.P-14 in that suit. On
perusal of Ex.P-14-partition deed, specifically a house
property bearing No.863/864A and northern portion of
agricultural property bearing block No.132 measuring 2
acres 17 guntas were allotted to the share of both parents
and after their demise, they shall be equally divided
amongst
three
brothers
and
even
some
movable
properties were also allotted to their share. Hence, this
reasoning of learned Appellate Judge is incorrect.
20.
The second ground is that the second partition
dated 23.09.1984 is a partition deed under which, the
parties have partitioned the properties and thus, as per
Section 17 of the Indian Registration Act, 1908 (for short,
hereinafter referred to as ‘the Registration Act’) it is
- 16 NC: 2026:KHC-D:258-DB
RFA No. 100091 of 2016
C/W RFA No. 100055 of 2016
RFA No. 100071 of 2018
RSA No. 5392 of 2010
HC-KAR
compulsorily registerable document and there was no such
registration.
21.
The third reason assigned by the Appellate
Judge for dismissal is that, by filing O.S.No.690/1989,
father
himself
challenged
the
second
partition
deed
23.09.1984. For these reasons, the suit of Siddappa and
the legal representative of Basappa was dismissed.
22.
This Court while admitting Regular Second
Appeal No.5392/2010 on 26.03.2014, framed the following
substantial questions of law:
“i)
Whether
the
first
appellate
Court
has
committed a serious error in not accepting
the partition deed dated 23.09.1984 marked
as Ex.P14 in spite of the same being not set
aside till date?
ii) Whether the judgment and decree of the first
appellate Court is perverse and illegal for
misinterpreting Ex.P14 and other material
evidence placed on record?”
- 17 NC: 2026:KHC-D:258-DB
RFA No. 100091 of 2016
C/W RFA No. 100055 of 2016
RFA No. 100071 of 2018
RSA No. 5392 of 2010
HC-KAR
23.
Always, nomenclature of a document is not to
be considered, but the recitals of the document are to be
considered to say whether the document is memo of
partition or partition deed. If the document is a memo of
partition, then it requires no registration. If the document
under which, parties have partitioned the properties, then
it is partition deed and it requires compulsory registration
under Section 17 of the Registration Act.
24.
In
this
regard,
the
learned
counsel
for
appellants places reliance on the judgment of the Hon’ble
Apex Court in the case of Roshan Singh and others vs.
Zile Singh and others1 at paragraph No.9, as follows:
“9. It is well settled that while an instrument
of partition which operates or is intended to
operate as a declared volition constituting or
severing ownership and causes a change of legal
relation to the property divided amongst the
parties to it, requires registration under Section
17(1)(b) of the Act, a writing which merely recites
(2018) 14 SCC 814
- 18 NC: 2026:KHC-D:258-DB
RFA No. 100091 of 2016
C/W RFA No. 100055 of 2016
RFA No. 100071 of 2018
RSA No. 5392 of 2010
HC-KAR
that there has in time past been a partition, is not
a declaration of will, but a mere statement of fact,
and it does not require registration. The essence of
the matter is whether the deed is a part of the
partition
transaction
or
contains
incidental
recital
a
previously
of
merely
an
completed
transaction. The use of the past tense does not
necessarily indicate that it is merely a recital of a
past transaction. It is equally well settled that a
mere list of properties allotted at a partition is not
an instrument of partition and does not require
registration. Section 17(1)(b) lays down that a
document for which registration is compulsory
should, by its own force, operate or purport to
operate
to
create
or
declare
some
right
in
immovable property. Therefore, a mere recital of
what has already taken place cannot be held to
declare any right and there would be no necessity
of registering such a document. Two propositions
must therefore flow: (1) A partition may be
effected orally; but if it is subsequently reduced
into a form of a document and that document
purports by itself to effect a division and embodies
all the terms of bargain, it will be necessary to
register it. If it be not registered, Section 49 of the
Act will prevent its being admitted in evidence.
Secondary evidence of the factum of partition will
- 19 NC: 2026:KHC-D:258-DB
RFA No. 100091 of 2016
C/W RFA No. 100055 of 2016
RFA No. 100071 of 2018
RSA No. 5392 of 2010
HC-KAR
not be admissible by reason of Section 91 of the
Evidence Act, 1872. (2) Partition lists which are
mere records of a previously completed partition
between the parties, will be admitted in evidence
even though they are unregistered, to prove the
fact of partition:”
25.
In the aforesaid judgment, the Hon’ble Apex
Court held that mere recitals of what has already taken
place cannot be held to declare any right and there would
be no necessity of registering such a document. A partition
may be effected orally, but if it is subsequently reduced
into a form of document and that document purports by
itself to effect a division and embodies all the terms of
partition, it will be necessary to register it. If it be not
registered, Section 49 of the Act will prevent its being
admitted in evidence.
26.
With this background, the relevant recitals of
Ex.P-14 are to be looked into.
- 20 NC: 2026:KHC-D:258-DB
RFA No. 100091 of 2016
C/W RFA No. 100055 of 2016
RFA No. 100071 of 2018
RSA No. 5392 of 2010
HC-KAR
Ex-P-14:£ÁªÀÅ CAzÉæ (1) ¹zÀÝ¥Àà
(2) §¸À¥Àà (3) «gÀÄ¥ÁPÀë¥Áà vÀAzÉ
«ÃgÀ¨sÀzÀæ¥Àà ºÉÆ£Àß½î ¸Á. GtPÀ®è vÁ®ÄÌ ºÀħâ½î. £ÁªÀÅ ªÀÄÆªÀgÆ
À SÁ¸Á
CtÚ vÀªÀÄäAzÀjzÀÄÝ, F »AzÉ ¢.18.8.84 gÀAzÀÄ £ÀªÄÀ äzÉà ªÀiÁ°Ì ªÀ
ªÀ»ªÁn£À D¹ÛUÀ¼À£ÀÄß C¥À¸Áw £À°è ªÁnß ªÀiÁrPÉÆArzÀÄÝ EzÀÄÝ. DzÀgÉ,
»¸Éì-j¸ÉìAiÀİè PÉ®ªÉÇAzÀÄ vÁgÀvÀªÀÄåªÁVzÀÝ ªÀÄÆ®PÀ CzÀ£ÄÀ ß gÀzÄÀ Ý ªÀiÁr
EAzÀÄ ¢£ÁAPÀ 23.9.1984 gÀAzÀÄ NtÂAiÀÄ ¥ÀAZÀgÀ ªÀ »jAiÀÄgÀ ¸ÀªÄÀ PÀëªÄÀ
F PɼÀPÀAqÀAvÉ £ÁªÉ¯Áè ªÀÄÆªÀgÀÄ CtÚvÀªÀÄäA¢gÀÄ D¹ÛUÀ¼À£ÄÀ ß ªÁnß
ªÀiÁrPÉÆArgÀÄvÉÛêÉ.
I) MAzÀ£ÉÃ
»¸ÉìÃzÁgÀ ¹zÀÝ¥Àà vÀA¢ «ÃgÀ¨sÀzàÀ¥àÀ ºÉÆ£Àß½î FvÀ£À
»¸ÉìÃUÉ §AzÀ D¹ÛAiÀÄ «ªÀgÀUÀ¼ÀÄ
1)…..
2)…..
3)…..
2)
JgÀqÀ£Éà »¸ÉìÃzÁgÀ §¸À¥Àà vÀA¢ «ÃgÀ¨sÀzæÀ¥àÀ ºÉÆ£Àß½î FvÀ£À
»¸ÉìÃUÉ §AzÀ D¹ÛAiÀÄ «ªÀgÀUÀ¼ÀÄ
1)…..
2)…..
3)…..
3) ªÀÄÆgÀ£Éà »¸ÉìÃzÁgÀ «gÀÄ¥ÁPÀë¥Àà vÀA¢ «ÃgÀ¨sÀzæÀ¥àÀ ºÉÆ£Àß½î
FvÀ£À »¸ÉìÃUÉ §AzÀ D¹ÛAiÀÄ «ªÀgÀ
1)…..
- 21 NC: 2026:KHC-D:258-DB
RFA No. 100091 of 2016
C/W RFA No. 100055 of 2016
RFA No. 100071 of 2018
RSA No. 5392 of 2010
HC-KAR
2)…..
3)…..
I) ¸ÀzÀgÀ GtPÀ®è UÁæªÀÄzÀ°ègÀĪÀ ªÀiÁzÀgÀ NtÂAiÀİègÄÀ ªÀ ªÀÄ£É ªÀ
»vÀÛ¯Á¬ÄªÀÅUÀ¼À H.D.M.C. £ÀA. 863-864 A £ÉÃzÀÄÝ EzÀÄÝ EªÀÅ vÀAzÉ
vÁ¬ÄUÀ¼ÀÄ EgÀĪÀ vÀ£ÀPÀ CªÀgÀ »¸ÉìÃUÉ EgÀÄvÀÛªÉ. £ÀAvÀgÀ CªÀgÄÀ
¥ÉÆÃwAiÀiÁzÀ ªÉÄïÉ, ¸ÀzÀjà D¹ÛAiÀÄÆ, ¸ÀºÀ ªÀÄÆgÀÄ ªÀÄA¢UÉ, ¸ÀªÄÀ ªÁV
¨sÁUÀªÁUÀĪÀªÀÅ.
II)
ªÀÄvÀÄÛ ¸ÀzÀgÀ ºÀħâ½î vÁ®ÄÌ ¨sÉÊjzÉêÀgÀPÉÆ¥Àà UÁæªÄÀ zÀ ¨ÁèPï
£ÀA. 132 4-29 JPÀgÉ 13-57 DPÁgÀ ¬ÄzÀgÀ ¥ÉÊQ GvÀÛgÀ ¨sÁUÀzÀ d«ÄãÀÄ
2=17 JPÀgÉ EzÀgÀ ZÀPÀ§A¢ ¥ÀƪÀðPÉÌ ¹zÀÝ¥Àà PÀ½îªÀĤ¬ÄªÀgÀ d«ÄãÀÄ,
¥À²ÑªÀÄPÉÌ ªÀ zÀQëtPÉÌ w¥Àà£ÀUËqÀ ±ÉnÖ£ÀUËqÀgÀ EªÀgÀ d«ÄãÀÄ, GvÀÛgÀPÌÉ
¸ÀgÀPÁj ºÀ¼Áî, F ¥ÀæPÁgÀ ZÀPÀ§A¢ ªÀÄzÀåzÀ°ègÀĪÀ d«ÄãÀÄ, vÀAzÉvÁ¬ÄAiÀĪÀgÀÄ EgÀĪÀ vÀ£ÀPÀ CªÀgÀUÉà EzÀÄÝ, CªÀgÀÄ E®èzÀ PÁ®PÉÌ ¸ÀzÀjÃ
PÁt¹zÀ d«ÄãÀÄ 2=17 JPÀgÉ EzÀÄ CªÀgÀÄ E®èzÀ PÁ®PÉÌ ªÀÄÆgÀÆ
ªÀÄA¢ CtÚ vÀªÀÄäA¢jUÉ ¨sÁUÀªÁUÀ¨ÉÃPÀÄ.
III)
vÀAzÉ-vÁ¬ÄAiÀĪÀgÀÄ, G½vÁAiÀÄ ªÀ UÀ½¹lÖ ºÀtzÀ°è
CªÀgÀÄ EgÀĪÀ vÀ£ÀPÀ §jà §rØAiÀÄ£ÀßµÉÖà ¥ÀqÉzÀÄPÉÆ¼ÀîvÀPÌÀzÄÀ Ý. CªÀgÄÀ , E®èzÀ
PÁ®PÉÌ, ¸ÀzÀjà ªÉÆÃvÀÛªÀ£ÀÄß ªÀÄÆgÀÆ d£ÀgÀÆ, CtÚvÀªÄÀ äA¢gÀÄ ¸ÀªÄÀ ªÁV
ºÀAaPÉÆ¼ÀîvÀPÀÌzÀÄÝ.
IV)
vÀAzÉ,
vÁ¬ÄAiÀĪÀgÀ
ºÀwÛgÀ«gÀĪÀ
20(E¥ÀàvÄÀ Û)
vÉÆ¯É,
§AUÁgÀzÀ D¨sÀgÀtUÀ¼À°è CªÀgÀÄ ¥ÉÆÃwAiÀiÁzÀ £ÀAvÀgÀ, 1) ¹zÀÝ¥àÀ 2) §¸À¥àÀ
- 22 NC: 2026:KHC-D:258-DB
RFA No. 100091 of 2016
C/W RFA No. 100055 of 2016
RFA No. 100071 of 2018
RSA No. 5392 of 2010
HC-KAR
3) «gÀÄ¥ÁPÀë¥Àà vÀ¯Á 6 (DgÀÄ) vÉÆ¯ÉAiÀÄAvÉ ºÀAaPÉÆ¼ÀîvÀPÌÀ zÄÀ Ý. «ÄPÀÌ JgÀqÄÀ
vÉÆ¯ÉAiÀÄ §AUÁgÀªÀ£ÀÄß vÀAV, CPÀ̪ÀÄä¤UÉ PÉÆqÀvÀPÀÌzÀÄÝ.
V) ªÀÄvÀÄÛ
JvÀÄÛ, ZÀPÀÌr, JªÉÄä ºÁUÀÆ ¨sÀÆ ¸ÁUÀĪÀ½PÉAiÀÄ, J¯Áè
ªÀ¸ÀÄÛUÀ¼ÀÄ J®è CtÚ-vÀªÀÄäA¢jUÉ, ¸ÁªÀÄÆ»PÀ G¥ÀAiÉÆÃUÀPÌÉ EgÀÄvÀÛªÉ.
F jÃw £ÁªÀÅ ªÀÄÆgÀÄ CtÚvÀªÀÄäA¢gÀÄ ¥ÀAZÀgÀ ªÀ »jAiÀÄgÀ
¸ÀªÀÄPÀëªÀÄ, F »AzÉ ªÀiÁrPÉÆAqÀ C¥À¸Ávï ªÁnßAiÀÄ£ÀÄß gÀzÄÀ Ý ªÀiÁr F
ªÁnßAiÀÄ£ÀÄß £ÀªÀÄä DvÀä-¸ÀAvÉÆÃµÀ¢AzÀ, AiÀiÁªÀÅzÉà vÀPÀgÁgÀÄ-vÀAmÉUÀ½®èzÉÃ
ªÀiÁrPÉÆAqÀ ªÁnß PÀgÁgÀÄ ¥ÀvÀæ ¸À». vÁ. 23.9.84.”
27.
This document is signed by the father and three
sons and two witnesses. It is not signed by any Panchas or
elders under whom the partition has taken place. Further,
the names of those elders are not mentioned in this
document.
28.
As stated above “D¹ÛUÀ¼À£ÀÄß ªÁnß ªÀiÁrPÉÆArgÀÄvÉÛêÉ.”
reflects the past events that is already partition had taken
place amongst the parties and it was being reduced into
writing. Thus, this is only a memo of partition and not a
partition deed under which, the parties have partitioned
the properties.
- 23 NC: 2026:KHC-D:258-DB
RFA No. 100091 of 2016
C/W RFA No. 100055 of 2016
RFA No. 100071 of 2018
RSA No. 5392 of 2010
HC-KAR
29.
Learned
counsel
for
respondent
No.1
Sri.V.P.Vadavi would vehemently contend that father
himself has not accepted this document and challenged it
and hence, this is not a partition amongst parties to the
suit.
30.
In this regard, he places reliance on the order
sheet and plaint of O.S.No.690/1989 Exs.D.13 to D.17
filed by Veerabhadrappa contending that Siddappa and
Basappa had created bogus, false Vatni Patra dated
23.09.1984 and it is a false and concocted one with mala
fide intention to cause wrongful loss to him and Siddappa
and Basappa have filed suit in O.S.No.567/1987, which is
still pending for consideration. Hence, prayed for passing
decree that Vatni Patra is illegally and high handedly
created, and it is a false and bogus document dated
23.09.1984.
31.
written
In that O.S.No.690/1989, Siddappa has filed
statement
denying
the
contention
of
- 24 NC: 2026:KHC-D:258-DB
RFA No. 100091 of 2016
C/W RFA No. 100055 of 2016
RFA No. 100071 of 2018
RSA No. 5392 of 2010
HC-KAR
Veerabhadrappa and said written statement is adopted by
the other legal representatives of second son-Basappa.
32.
When said suit was pending, this plaintiff-
Veerabhadrappa has not appeared in that suit and thus,
finally said suit got dismissed for non-prosecution on
18.06.1991.
33.
After
such
dismissal
of
the
suit,
Veerabhadrappa-plaintiff has not filed any miscellaneous
petition under Order IX Rule 9 of CPC for its restoration.
He died on 18.07.1991.
34.
Under Order IX Rule 8 CPC, where only the
defendant appears and plaintiff does not appear, when the
suit is called on for hearing, then the Court shall make an
order that suit be dismissed unless the defendant admits
the claim wholly or in part thereof.
35.
The dismissal of suit on 18.06.1991 is in
accordance with Order IX Rule 8 CPC. After such dismissal,
the only option available for plaintiff under Order IX Rule 9
- 25 NC: 2026:KHC-D:258-DB
RFA No. 100091 of 2016
C/W RFA No. 100055 of 2016
RFA No. 100071 of 2018
RSA No. 5392 of 2010
HC-KAR
of CPC is to file a miscellaneous petition for restoration of
the suit. If he did not do so, then such dismissal of suit
shall preclude him from bringing a fresh suit in respect of
the same cause of action.
36.
As
discussed
O.S.No.690/1989,
the
above,
plaintiff
after
has
dismissal
not
filed
of
any
miscellaneous petition. As per Article 122 of the Limitation
Act, 1963, the limitation to file such a miscellaneous
petition is 30 days from the date of dismissal. Within said
days,
the
miscellaneous
original
petition.
plaintiff
After
its
has
not
filed
any
dismissal,
his
legal
representatives i.e., his another son Virupakshappa and
his daughter-Anasuya @ Akkamahadevi could have filed a
petition for its restoration claiming that they are the legal
heirs of said plaintiff. But they also did not do so. Hence,
the dismissal of suit in O.S.No.690/1989 became final and
it precludes original plaintiff-Veerabhadrappa and after his
death, his legal representatives to file a suit challenging
- 26 NC: 2026:KHC-D:258-DB
RFA No. 100091 of 2016
C/W RFA No. 100055 of 2016
RFA No. 100071 of 2018
RSA No. 5392 of 2010
HC-KAR
the partition of 23.09.1984 on the ground that it is false,
concocted and created by Siddappa and Basappa.
37.
By filing a suit in the year 1987, both Siddappa
and Basappa have claimed that suit schedule properties in
those suits are their absolute properties because of
partition
amongst
them,
their
another
brother
and
parents. Veerabhadrappa was fully aware about filing of
said suit in the year 1987 because in his suit of 1989; he
made a reference of O.S.No.567/1987. Even then, he has
not made any effort to file any written statement in the
said suit.
38.
Even though for a period of four years, this
Veerabhadrappa was alive, he has not filed his written
statement in the said suit. Only after his death, his legal
representatives i.e., his daughter and his wife have filed
written statement. During his lifetime, he has not taken
any defence and thus, his legal representatives are
- 27 NC: 2026:KHC-D:258-DB
RFA No. 100091 of 2016
C/W RFA No. 100055 of 2016
RFA No. 100071 of 2018
RSA No. 5392 of 2010
HC-KAR
precluded from taking any defence which was not taken by
the original defendant.
39.
Under
those
circumstances,
the
finding
of
Appellate Court that the father himself challenged the
partition deed and it ought to have been compulsorily
registerable
document
are
erroneous
findings
and
improper appreciation of evidence and thus, the First
Appellate Court has committed serious error in not
accepting the partition deed dated 23.09.1984, in spite of
the same being not set aside till date and thus, the
judgment and decree of First Appellate Court is perverse
and illegal for wrong appreciation of Ex.P-14 and other
material evidence placed on record.
40.
After allowing R.A.No.162/2003 by decreeing
O.S.No.130/1991 and holding that the compromise decree
in
O.S.No.28/1991
as
null
and
void;
only
as
an
afterthought, plaintiff-Anasuya has filed O.S.No.20/2010
- 28 NC: 2026:KHC-D:258-DB
RFA No. 100091 of 2016
C/W RFA No. 100055 of 2016
RFA No. 100071 of 2018
RSA No. 5392 of 2010
HC-KAR
praying for partition in respect of all the joint family
properties.
41.
It is to be noted here that, as on the date of
partition of 1984, the plaintiff being a married daughter
was not having any right over ancestral properties during
lifetime of her father. Only after death of her father, under
Section 8 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 she would
have claimed a right in the share of her father. However,
after
commencement
of
the
Hindu
Succession
(Amendment) Act, 2005 (for short, hereinafter referred to
as ‘the Act, 2005’) the daughter will be considered as
coparcener since from her birth. However, Proviso to
Section 6 of the Act, 2005 bars the daughter to challenge
any alienation made earlier to 20.12.2004 and as per
Section 6(5) of the Act, 2005 bars the daughter to
challenge any registered partition that had taken place
earlier to said 20.12.2004.
- 29 NC: 2026:KHC-D:258-DB
RFA No. 100091 of 2016
C/W RFA No. 100055 of 2016
RFA No. 100071 of 2018
RSA No. 5392 of 2010
HC-KAR
42.
In this regard, the Hon'ble Apex Court, in the
case of Vineeta Sharma vs. Rakesh Sharma and
others2, has clearly held in paragraph Nos.117, 127 and
129 as follows:
“117. How family settlement is effected was
considered
in Kale
v.
Deputy
Director
of
Consolidation, (1976) 3 SCC 119, thus:
“10. In other words to put the binding effect
and the essentials of a family settlement in a
concretised form, the matter may be reduced into
the form of the following propositions:
“(1) The family settlement must be a
bona fide one so as to resolve family
disputes and rival claims by a fair and
equitable
division
or
allotment
of
properties between the various members
of the family;
(2) The said settlement must be
voluntary and should not be induced by
fraud, coercion or undue influence;
AIR 2020 SC 3717
- 30 NC: 2026:KHC-D:258-DB
RFA No. 100091 of 2016
C/W RFA No. 100055 of 2016
RFA No. 100071 of 2018
RSA No. 5392 of 2010
HC-KAR
(3) The family arrangement may be
even oral in which case no registration is
necessary;
(4) It is well settled that registration
would be necessary only if the terms of
the family arrangement are reduced into
writing. Here also, a distinction should be
made between a document containing the
terms
and
recitals
of
a
family
arrangement made under the document
and a mere memorandum prepared after
the family arrangement had already been
made either for the purpose of the record
or for information of the Court for making
necessary mutation. In such a case the
memorandum itself does not create or
extinguish
any
rights
in
immovable
properties and therefore does not fall
within the mischief of Section 17(2) of
the Registration Act and is, therefore, not
compulsorily registrable;
(5)
The
members
who
may
be
parties to the family arrangement must
have some antecedent title, claim or
interest even a possible claim in the
- 31 NC: 2026:KHC-D:258-DB
RFA No. 100091 of 2016
C/W RFA No. 100055 of 2016
RFA No. 100071 of 2018
RSA No. 5392 of 2010
HC-KAR
property which is acknowledged by the
parties to the settlement. Even if one of
the parties to the settlement has no title
but under the arrangement the other
party relinquishes all its claims or titles in
favour
of
such
a
person
and
acknowledges him to be the sole owner,
then
the
antecedent
title
must
be
assumed and the family arrangement will
be upheld and the courts will find no
difficulty in giving assent to the same;
(6)
present
Even
or
if
bona
possible,
fide
which
disputes,
may
not
involve legal claims are settled by a bona
fide family arrangement which is fair and
equitable the family arrangement is final
and
binding
on
the
parties
to
the
settlement.”
15. In Tek Bahadur Bhujil v. Debi Singh Bhujil, AIR
1966 SC 292, 295, it was pointed out by this Court
that a family arrangement could be arrived at even
orally and registration would be required only if it
was reduced into writing. It was also held that a
document which was no more than a memorandum
- 32 NC: 2026:KHC-D:258-DB
RFA No. 100091 of 2016
C/W RFA No. 100055 of 2016
RFA No. 100071 of 2018
RSA No. 5392 of 2010
HC-KAR
of what had been agreed to did not require
registration. This Court had observed thus:
“Family arrangement as such can be
arrived
at orally. Its terms may
be
recorded in writing as a memorandum of
what had been agreed upon between the
parties. The memorandum need not be
prepared for the purpose of being used as
a document on which future title of the
parties be founded. It is usually prepared
as a record of what had been agreed
upon so that there be no hazy notions
about it in future. It is only when the
parties reduce the family arrangement in
writing with the purpose of using that
writing
as
proof
of
what
they
had
arranged and, where the arrangement is
brought about by the document as such,
that
the
document
would
require
registration as it is then that it would be a
document of title declaring for future
what rights in what properties the parties
possess.””
(emphasis supplied)
It is settled law that family arrangements can
be entered into to keep harmony in the family.
- 33 NC: 2026:KHC-D:258-DB
RFA No. 100091 of 2016
C/W RFA No. 100055 of 2016
RFA No. 100071 of 2018
RSA No. 5392 of 2010
HC-KAR
127. A special definition of partition has been
carved out in the explanation. The intendment of
the provisions is not to jeopardise the interest of
the daughter and to take care of sham or frivolous
transaction set up in defence unjustly to deprive
the daughter of her right as coparcener and
prevent nullifying the benefit flowing from the
provisions as substituted. The statutory provisions
made in section 6(5) change the entire complexion
as to partition. However, under the law that
prevailed earlier, an oral partition was recognised.
In view of change of provisions of section 6, the
intendment of legislature is clear and such a plea of
oral partition is not to be readily accepted. The
provisions
of section
6(5) are
required
to
be
interpreted to cast a heavy burden of proof upon
proponent of oral partition before it is accepted
such
as
separate
occupation
of
portions,
appropriation of the income, and consequent entry
in the
revenue records and invariably
supported
by
documents
admissible
accepted
most
other
contemporaneous
in
reluctantly
evidence,
while
to
be
public
may
be
exercising
all
safeguards. The intendment of Section 6 of the Act
is only to accept the genuine partitions that might
have taken place under the prevailing law, and are
not set up as a false defence and only oral ipse
- 34 NC: 2026:KHC-D:258-DB
RFA No. 100091 of 2016
C/W RFA No. 100055 of 2016
RFA No. 100071 of 2018
RSA No. 5392 of 2010
HC-KAR
dixit is to be rejected outrightly. The object of
preventing, setting up of false or frivolous defence
to set at naught the benefit emanating from
amended provisions, has to be given full effect.
Otherwise, it would become very easy to deprive
the daughter of her rights as a coparcener. When
such a defence is taken, the Court has to be very
extremely careful in accepting the same, and only if
very cogent, impeccable, and contemporaneous
documentary
evidence
in
shape
of
public
documents in support are available, such a plea
may be entertained, not otherwise. We reiterate
that the plea of an oral partition or memorandum
of partition, unregistered one can be manufactured
at any point in time, without any contemporaneous
public document needs rejection at all costs. We
say so for exceptionally good cases where partition
is proved conclusively and we caution the courts
that the finding is not to be based on the
preponderance of probabilities in view of provisions
of gender justice and the rigor of very heavy
burden
of
Explanation
proof
which
to Section
meet
6(5).
intendment
It
has
to
of
be
remembered that courts cannot defeat the object of
the beneficial provisions made by the Amendment
Act. The exception is carved out by us as earlier
execution of a registered document for partition
- 35 NC: 2026:KHC-D:258-DB
RFA No. 100091 of 2016
C/W RFA No. 100055 of 2016
RFA No. 100071 of 2018
RSA No. 5392 of 2010
HC-KAR
was not necessary, and the Court was rarely
approached for the sake of family prestige. It was
approached as a last resort when parties were not
able to settle their family dispute amicably. We
take note of the fact that even before 1956,
partition
in
other
modes
than
envisaged
under Section 6(5) had taken place.
129. Resultantly, we answer the reference as
under section:
(i) The provisions contained in substituted Section
6 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 confer status
of coparcener on the daughter born before or after
amendment in the same manner as son with same
rights and liabilities.
(ii) The rights can be claimed by the daughter born
earlier with effect from 9.9.2005 with savings as
provided in Section 6(1) as to the disposition or
alienation, partition or testamentary disposition
which
had
taken
place
before
20th
day
of
December, 2004.
(iii) Since the right in coparcenary is by birth, it is
not necessary that father coparcener should be
living as on 9.9.2005.
- 36 NC: 2026:KHC-D:258-DB
RFA No. 100091 of 2016
C/W RFA No. 100055 of 2016
RFA No. 100071 of 2018
RSA No. 5392 of 2010
HC-KAR
(iv) The statutory fiction of partition created by
proviso to Section 6 of the Hindu Succession Act,
1956 as originally enacted did not bring about the
actual partition or disruption of coparcenary. The
fiction was only for the purpose of ascertaining
share
of
deceased
coparcener
when
he
was
survived by a female heir, of ClassI as specified in
the Schedule to the Act of 1956 or male relative of
such
female.
The
provisions
of
the
substituted Section 6 are required to be given full
effect. Notwithstanding that a preliminary decree
has been passed the daughters are to be given
share in coparcenary equal to that of a son in
pending proceedings for final decree or in an
appeal.
(v) In view of the rigor of provisions of Explanation
to Section 6(5) of the Act of 1956, a plea of oral
partition cannot be accepted as the statutory
recognised mode of partition effected by a deed of
partition duly registered under the provisions of
the Registration Act, 1908 or effected by a decree
of a court. However, in exceptional cases where
plea
of
oral
partition
is
supported
by
public
documents and partition is finally evinced in the
same manner as if it had been affected by a decree
of a court, it may be accepted. A plea of partition
- 37 NC: 2026:KHC-D:258-DB
RFA No. 100091 of 2016
C/W RFA No. 100055 of 2016
RFA No. 100071 of 2018
RSA No. 5392 of 2010
HC-KAR
based on oral evidence alone cannot be accepted
and to be rejected outrightly.”
43.
Thus,
heavy
burden
is
on
Siddappa
and
Basappa to establish the earlier partition. In this case,
parties have produced some revenue records. Exs.P-1, 2
and 8 to 11 are extracts from the property register card.
They reveal that property bearing Nos.3522/B/32 and
3522/B/33 were mutated into the names of Basappa
based on partition dated 20.08.1984 and continued to
stand in his name till his death. After his death, these
properties are mutated into the names of his wife and
children.
44.
Ex.P-19 is property extract of house No.186
stands in the name of Veerabhadrappa. As per Ex.P-14
also, the said property has fallen to the share of
Veerabhadrappa. Based on the partition of 23.09.1984,
the revenue entries are not mutated into the names of
respective sharers, this is because since from the date of
partition, there are disputes.
- 38 NC: 2026:KHC-D:258-DB
RFA No. 100091 of 2016
C/W RFA No. 100055 of 2016
RFA No. 100071 of 2018
RSA No. 5392 of 2010
HC-KAR
45.
According to recitals of Ex.P-14, there was
earlier partition on 20.08.1984 and it was set aside by
entering into fresh partition on 23.09.1984. Based on the
earlier partition of 20.08.1984, as discussed above some
revenue entries were mutated. One of the sons of
Veerabhadrappa through another wife of Erappa has raised
revenue dispute in respect of those revenue entries and
then,
finally
Anyway,
those
said
revenue
Erappa
is
entries
not
were
brought
as
set
aside.
party
in
O.S.No.20/2010 filed by Anasuya even though she was
fully aware that he is one of the legal representatives of
her father. Hence, said suit is definitely bad for nonjoinder of necessary parties. However, he was brought as
one
of
legal
representatives
in
O.S.No.213/2000
[defendant No.1(c)]. He has not contested the said suit or
appeal or this second appeal.
46.
In the aforesaid Vineeta Sharma’s case cited
supra, the Hon’ble Apex Court held that the intendment of
Section 6 of the Act is only to accept the genuine partition
- 39 NC: 2026:KHC-D:258-DB
RFA No. 100091 of 2016
C/W RFA No. 100055 of 2016
RFA No. 100071 of 2018
RSA No. 5392 of 2010
HC-KAR
that might have taken place under the prevailing law. The
object of preventing, setting up false or frivolous defence
to set at naught the benefit emanating from amended
provisions, has to be given full affect. Otherwise, it would
become very easy to deprive the daughter of her rights as
a coparcener. When such defence is taken, the Court
should be extremely careful in accepting it.
47.
With this background, the facts of the present
case are to be analysed.
48.
As discussed above, from 1984 onwards, the
sons of Veerabhadrappa are contending that there was
partition. This plea is not taken after commencement of
the Act, 2005. Furthermore, at that time, Anasuya being
a
married
daughter
had
no
right
whatsoever
over
ancestral properties of her parental house. Such right was
conferred upon a daughter only after commencement of
the Act, 2005. Thus, as on 23.09.1984 itself there was
- 40 NC: 2026:KHC-D:258-DB
RFA No. 100091 of 2016
C/W RFA No. 100055 of 2016
RFA No. 100071 of 2018
RSA No. 5392 of 2010
HC-KAR
partition amongst father and sons which cannot be
challenged by the daughter subsequently in the year 2010.
49.
It is to be noted here that as on 20.08.1984
itself, there was partition amongst father and his three
sons and based on it, revenue entries were mutated.
Those mutations of revenue entries were challenged by
one of the sons of Veerabhadrappa-Erappa, through his
another wife and those revenue entries were set aside, but
that is challenged only in the year 1985-1986. But much
earlier to it, in the year 1984 itself, during September
1984, again another partition was taken place between
parties as per Ex.P-14 and said partition brings absolute
right to parties.
50.
This partition deed was acted upon between
parties and it could be gathered from some of the sale
deeds executed by respective sharers. As per Ex.D-20 of
O.S.No.20/2010, the sale deed dated 16.10.1995 was
executed by legal representatives of Basappa to defendant
- 41 NC: 2026:KHC-D:258-DB
RFA No. 100091 of 2016
C/W RFA No. 100055 of 2016
RFA No. 100071 of 2018
RSA No. 5392 of 2010
HC-KAR
Nos.10 and 11 of O.S.No.20/2010 in respect of ‘E’
schedule property. The next sale deed was executed on
01.04.2004
in
respect
of
‘F’
schedule
property
of
O.S.No.20/2010 by defendant No.5 i.e., Siddappa in
favour of defendant No.9. The third sale deed was
executed by said Siddappa on 28.02.2004 in respect of ‘G’
schedule property to defendant No.9. All these three sale
deeds came into existence much prior to commencement
of the Act, 2005. Furthermore, same Siddappa i.e.,
defendant No.5 in O.S.No.28/1991 has sold another Item
No.B of schedule in O.S.No.20/2010 to defendant Nos.7
and 8 through registered sale deed dated 06.05.2005.
51.
All the above four sale deeds clearly and
categorically establish that parties have accepted the
partition effected on 23.09.1984 and they have exercised
their absolute rights over those properties and have sold
some of the portions of properties which were allotted to
their respective shares. These facts establish that partition
deed was acted upon. Hence, even though a registered
- 42 NC: 2026:KHC-D:258-DB
RFA No. 100091 of 2016
C/W RFA No. 100055 of 2016
RFA No. 100071 of 2018
RSA No. 5392 of 2010
HC-KAR
partition
deed
is
not
available
in
the
exceptional
circumstances noted above, in view of the principles laid
down in Vineeta Sharma (supra), Siddappa and Basappa
have successfully established the earlier partition of 1984.
The plaintiff-Anasuya in the year 2010 cannot challenge
the said partition. She was not having any iota of right
over the ancestral properties during lifetime of her father.
Hence, the partition that had taken place in 1984 and sale
deeds that have came into existence from 1995 to 2005
categorically establish the rights of parties exercised by
them and they are the absolute owners of their respective
portion of properties.
52.
The attitude and conduct of plaintiff in O.S.
No.20/2010 is also to be looked into. During lifetime of her
father i.e., at the fag end of his life, she got created
agreement of sale in respect of some properties of joint
family (‘E’ to ‘G’ schedule) and filed suit for specific
performance of agreement and got it compromised by
impersonating
her
father
and
it
was
set
aside
in
- 43 NC: 2026:KHC-D:258-DB
RFA No. 100091 of 2016
C/W RFA No. 100055 of 2016
RFA No. 100071 of 2018
RSA No. 5392 of 2010
HC-KAR
O.S.No.130/1991
and
confirmed
in
R.A.No.162/2003.
These facts clearly and categorically establish the conduct
of the plaintiff of O.S.No.20/2010.
53.
The above discussion reveals that plaintiffs in
O.S.No.567/1987 re-numbered as O.S.No.213/2000 have
established the partition dated 23.09.1984 and thus, they
have to be declared as owners of the properties fallen to
them as mentioned in the said schedule. Thus, the
property No.887-888 situated at Ward No.3 of Halageri
Oni at Unkal village, Hubballi is the absolute property of
plaintiff Nos.1 and 2 i.e., suit schedule property of
O.S.No.213/2000 (old No.567/87). However, the learned
Trial Judge has not examined these points of law that the
suit filed by Veerabhadrappa was dismissed for default and
it precluded him from filing a similar suit based on the
same cause of action that means he was precluded from
contending that partition deed dated 23.09.1984 is based
on fraud and misrepresentation and thus, the plaintiff-
- 44 NC: 2026:KHC-D:258-DB
RFA No. 100091 of 2016
C/W RFA No. 100055 of 2016
RFA No. 100071 of 2018
RSA No. 5392 of 2010
HC-KAR
Anasuya cannot claim any right over the property allotted
to her brothers under said partition deed.
54.
O.S.No.20/2010 is filed by plaintiff-Anasuya
claiming partition alleging existence of joint family and suit
‘A’
to
‘G’
properties.
schedule
are
joint
family
and
ancestral
Out of these properties already ‘B’, ‘E’ to ‘G’
schedule properties were sold under different sale deeds
as discussed above. Out of them, ‘E’ to ‘G’ schedule
properties were sold prior to 20.12.2004 and ‘B’ schedule
was sold during May-2005.
55.
While considering RSA No.5392/2010, it is
already held that the plaintiffs in O.S.No.213/2000 have
established the partition dated 23.09.1984 and it was
acted upon. When said partition was acted upon, the
plaintiff-Anasuya was not having any right over the joint
family properties in question at that time. Hence, she
cannot reopen the partition as per the principles noted in
Vineeta Sharma's case by the Hon’ble Apex Court.
- 45 NC: 2026:KHC-D:258-DB
HC-KAR
RFA No. 100091 of 2016
C/W RFA No. 100055 of 2016
RFA No. 100071 of 2018
RSA No. 5392 of 2010
Respectfully relying upon the principles laid down in
Vineeta Sharma's case stated supra, we hold that the
plaintiff-Anasuya is not entitled for any share in the joint
family properties. This is more so, because in partition
deed dated 23.09.1984, it is clearly stated that after death
of both parents, the property which were allotted to the
share of father will be equally divided by his sons. Under
these circumstances, the suit of plaintiff-Anasuya in
O.S.No.20/2010 cannot be decreed and is liable to be
dismissed. However, the Trial Court has come to the
wrong conclusion only by wrongly appreciating the oral
and documentary evidence that there was no partition of
23.09.1984 and this partition was challenged by father
himself. Learned Trial Judge without verifying proper
provisions of law i.e., Order IX Rule 8 and Rule 9 of Code
of Civil Procedure, came to the wrong conclusion and thus,
it needs interference. Accordingly, all the Regular First
Appeals are to be allowed.
- 46 NC: 2026:KHC-D:258-DB
RFA No. 100091 of 2016
C/W RFA No. 100055 of 2016
RFA No. 100071 of 2018
RSA No. 5392 of 2010
HC-KAR
56.
Accordingly substantial questions of law are
answered in affirmative and we proceed to pass the
following:
ORDER
i)
RSA No.5392/2010 is allowed by setting
aside the judgment and decree dated
19.08.2009 passed in R.A.No.163/2003
on the file of the learned Fast Track
Court-II, Dharwad sitting at Hubli and
confirming
dated
the
judgment
21.01.2003
O.S.No.213/2000
on
and
decree
passed
the
file
in
of
the
learned Additional Civil Judge (Sr.Dn.),
Hubballi.
ii)
RFA
No.100091/2016,
No.100055/2016
and
RFA
RFA
No.100071/2018 are allowed by setting
aside
judgment
and
decree
dated
- 47 NC: 2026:KHC-D:258-DB
RFA No. 100091 of 2016
C/W RFA No. 100055 of 2016
RFA No. 100071 of 2018
RSA No. 5392 of 2010
HC-KAR
29.01.2016 passed in O.S.No.20/2010 on
the file of the learned Principal Senior Civil
Judge and J.M.F.C., Hubballi.
iii)
Under facts and circumstances of the
case, parties are directed to bear their
own costs.
iv)
Draw decree accordingly.
SD/(MOHAMMAD NAWAZ)
JUDGE
SD/(GEETHA K.B.)
JUDGE
KMV: Para 1 to 10
SSP: Para 11 to 36
RKM: Para 37 to end
CT:PA LIST NO.: 1 SL NO.: 8
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review