Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
17.09.2026
Item No. 02 to 04 (DL)
Court No. 07
(Samar)
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CIVIL REVISIONAL JURISDICTION
C.O. 4253 of 2025
CAN 1 of 2026
CAN 2 of 2026
Sri Prakash Kumar Maity
-VsSri Pabitra Kumar Maity & Ors.
With
C.O. 3064 of 2024
CAN 2 of 2025
Smt. Shyamali Manna
-VsPabitra Kumar Maity & Ors.
with
C.O. 4118 of 2023
CAN 2 of 2026
Smt. Shyamali Manna
-VsSri Pabitra Kumar Maity & Ors.
<
Mr. Sounak Bhattacharya,
Mr. Samaresh Chandra Dhara.
…for the petitioner.
Mr. Shuvasish Sengupta,
Mrs. Subhra Das,
Mr. Sourath Nath Dutt,
Mr. Sasosiji Dasgupta,
…..for the opposite party No. 1.
1. As these three revisional applications assail
different orders passed by the learned Civil Judge
(Senior Division), 2nd Court at Tamluk, Purba
Medinipur in Title Suit 89 of 2015 and Title
Execution Case No. 6 of 2024 between the same
parties therefore a common order is being passed
in respect thereof.
2. CO 4118 of 2023 has been filed by the
defendant
no.
assailing
the
order
dated
September 16, 2023 passed in Title Suit No. 89 of
2015.
3.
CO 3064 of 2024 has also been filed by the
defendant no. 1 in Title Suit No. 89 of 2015
thereby challenging orders dated October 16, 2023,
November 24, 2023, December 11, 2023, February
16, 2024 and April 09, 2024.
4. CO 4253 of 2025 has been filed by the
defendant no. 2 in the said suit assailing all the
aforesaid orders which have been challenged by
the defendant no. 1 by filing CO 4118 of 2023 and
CO 3064 of 2024 as already indicated above.
5. Briefly put, the facts of the case are that the
opposite party no. 1 (hereafter “plaintiff) had
instituted Title Suit No. 89 of 2015 before the
learned Civil Judge (Senior Division), 2nd Court at
Tamluk, Purba Medinipur praying inter alia for
decrees of:i) declaration that the plaintiff had right, title and
interest in respect of the property mentioned in
‘Ka’ schedule of the plaint by way of inheritance;
ii) declaration that the plaintiff had preferential
right to acquire the property mentioned in ‘Ka/1’
schedule of the plaint in terms of Section 22 of
the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 and also for
ii) mandatory injunction directing the defendant
nos. 1 and 2 to execute and register conveyance
in favour of the plaintiff upon payment of market
value
of
the
property
schedule of the plaint.
mentioned
in
‘Ka/1’
6. The said suit was decreed in part on October
24, 2017 thereby declaring the right, title and
interest of the plaintiff in the ‘Ka’ schedule
property and granting permanent injunction in
respect thereof but holding that the plaintiff had
no preferential right to acquire the property
described ‘Ka/1’ schedule of the plaint.
7. The plaintiff carried the decree in appeal being
FAT 661 of 2017 before the Hon’ble Division Bench
of this Court. The said appeal was ultimately
disposed on April 03, 2021 thereby modifying the
impugned decree by holding that the plaintiff has
preferential right in respect of Ka/1 schedule
property.
8. The Hon’ble Division Bench remanded the
matter to the learned Trial Court for determining
the market price of the share in respect of the
immovable property acquired by the defendant no.
1 by way of gift after affording an opportunity of
hearing to the respective parties.
9. The appellate order dated April 03, 2021 was
assailed by the defendant no. 1 before the Hon’ble
Supreme Court by way of a Special Leave Petition
bearing SLP No. 11609 of 2021. The same was
dismissed by an order dated August 16, 2021.
10. In the mean time, the plaintiff filed an
application under Section 151 of the Code of Civil
Procedure, 1908 praying for determination of the
fair market price of the immovable property in
question. The defendant no. 1 filed a written
objection to the said application asserting that
valuation can be determined only by a Court
appointed valuation commissioner and not on the
on the basis of the valuation rendered by the
registry office.
11. On January 20, 2023 the learned Trial Court
passed an order recording that the Registrar,
Purba
Medinipur
Government
had
empanel
reported
land
and
that
“no
property
valuars/existence in this office”. By the said order
the plaintiff was directed to take steps.
12. Ultimately, on September 16, 2023 an order
was passed recording that the defendant had never
been directed by the Court to submit any query
report obtained from the land/immovable property
registry office and it was only the plaintiff who had
been directed to take steps for valuation of the suit
property through the local registry office. The said
order has been challenged by filing CO 4118 of
2023.
13. Subsequently, by an order dated December
11, 2023 the learned Trial Court accepted the
valuation report obtained by the plaintiff through
E-assessment slip from the office of the ADSR
Tamluk and the plaintiff was directed to deposit
the consideration amount mentioned in the Eassessment slip according to the direction of this
Court passed in FAT 661 of 2017. The plaintiff was
also directed to file the draft copy of the deed.
14. The plaintiff filed the draft copy of the deed
and challan evincing deposit in terms of the order
dated December 11, 2023 on February 16, 2024.
The matter was thereafter fixed on April 09, 2024.
15. Ultimately on July 03, 2024 the learned Trial
Court directed the defendant no. 2 to execute and
register a deed of sale in favour of the plaintiff in
respect of the Ka/1 schedule suit property within
two months from the date of the order. The plaintiff
was, thereby, also, granted liberty to put the decree
in the execution in accordance with law. A further
direction was passed on the office/department to
modify the decree accordingly. All the orders
starting from October 16, 2023 (being the one
which
recorded
the
filing
E-assessment
slip
obtained by the plaintiff from the office of the
ADSR Tamluk) to July 03, 2024 have been
challenged in CO 3064 of 2024 by the defendant
no. 1.
16. Both CO 4118 of 2023 and CO 3064 of 2024
were heard by a Co-ordinate Bench of this Court
on March 10, 2025 when an order of stay of all
further proceedings of Title Suit No. 89 of 2015
pending before the learned Civil Judge (Senior
Division), 2nd Court at Tamluk was passed till the
end of month of March, 2025 or until further order
whichever is earlier. The said order was extended
on July 01, 2025.
17. However, on November 11, 2025 the interim
order granted earlier was not extended in view of
the submission made on behalf of the plaintiff
/opposite party no. 1 that the said party would not
take any step before the Executing Court on the
next date.
18. It may be recorded that at the time when the
undertaking as aforesaid was recorded by this
Court, November 14, 2025 was the next date for
the matter to be returnable before the learned
Executing Court.
19. The order of stay that had been granted
earlier but which was not extended later in view of
the aforesaid undertaking was thereafter never
extended.
20. The Learned Executing Court thus proceeded
with the execution and ultimately, on January 20,
an
order
was
passed
by
the
learned
Executing Court directing the decree holder to
make payment of the registration fees as indicated
by the ADSR Chandipur/ESR Purba Medinipur
and
complete
the
process
of
registration
by
February 07, 2024. The Additional clerk of the said
learned Court was authorized to complete the
formalities regarding registration of the proposed
sale deed on behalf of the learned Court in his
official capacity.
21. Subsequently CO 4253 of 2025 that had been
filed by the defendant no. 2 was moved before this
Court on February 06, 2026 when an order of stay
of Title Execution Case No. 06 of 2025 as also of
the order directing registration of the deed for a
period of six weeks from the date of order or until
further orders was passed.
22. In the wake of such fact, the plaintiff took out
an application being CAN 2 of 2026 in connection
with CO 4253 of 2025 thereby bringing on record
the orders passed subsequent to the filing of CO
4253 of 2025 as well a copy of the registered sale
deed. By the said application the plaintiff sought
recall of the order dated February 06, 2026 passed
in CO 4253 of 2025, while asserting that that the
conveyance deed had been executed before the CO
4253 of 2025 could even be moved.
23. All the three revisional applications were
thereafter heard by this Bench and judgment was
reserved.
While
preparing
the
judgment
the
decision taken by the learned Trial Court on July
03, 2024 struck the mind of Court as the same
clearly appeared to be one that disposed of the suit
finally and hence assumed the character of a
decree within the meaning of Section 2(2) of the
Code. Such being the position, the same could not
have been interfered with in revision under Article
227 of the Constitution of India.
24. However, since the said point was never urged
before this Court and the matter had been
entertained by the earlier Coordinate Benches as
well, the matter has been brought back on board
and the parties have been heard on such point.
25. Mr.
Bhattacharyya,
learned
advocate
appearing for the petitioners in his usual fairness
submits that indeed, the said decision is in the
nature of the decree.
26. Mr. Sengupta, learned advocate appearing for
the opposite party no. 1 relies on a judgment of the
Hon’ble Division Bench of this Court in the case of
Smt. Arati Das Vs. Bharati Sarkar & Ors.
reported at AIR 2009 Cal 8 and agrees that the
said decision is in the nature of the decree
inasmuch as the same has the effect of disposing
of the suit.
27. There is no dispute as regards the fact that
the decision dated July 03, 2024 whereby the
decree passed earlier was directed to be modified is
in the real sense a decree which is appealble under
Section 96 of the Code in terms of the decision of
the Hon’ble Division Bench in the case of Smt.
Arati Das (supra).
28. Although the plenary constitutional power of
this Court under Article 227 of the Constitution of
India still remains untrammeled by any legislation
— the Hon’ble Supreme Court has reiterated time
and again that such jurisdiction should not be
exercised when an alternative appellate remedy is
available before the Civil Courts. To be precise, in
the case of
Dharma
Virudhunagar
Paribalana
Hindu
Sabai
vs.
Nadargal
Tuticorin
Educational Society & Others reported at (2019)
9 SCC 538, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held as
follows :-
“12. But courts should always bear in mind a distinction
between (i) cases where such alternative remedy is available
before civil courts in terms of the provisions of Code of Civil
Procedure, and (ii) cases where such alternative remedy is
available under special enactments and/or statutory rules
and the fora provided therein happen to be quasi-judicial
authorities and tribunals. In respect of cases falling under
the first category, which may involve suits and other
proceedings before civil courts, the availability of an
appellate remedy in terms of the provisions of CPC, may have
to be construed as a near total bar. Otherwise, there is a
danger that someone may challenge in a revision under
Article 227, even a decree passed in a suit, on the same
grounds on which Respondents 1 and 2 invoked the
jurisdiction of the High Court. This is why, a 3-member Bench
of this Court, while overruling the decision in Surya Dev
Rai v. Ram Chander Rai [Surya Dev Rai v. Ram Chander Rai,
(2003) 6 SCC 675] , pointed out in Radhey Shyam v. Chhabi
Nath [Radhey Shyam v. Chhabi Nath, (2015) 5 SCC 423 :
(2015) 3 SCC (Civ) 67] that “orders of civil court stand on
different footing from the orders of authorities or tribunals or
courts other than judicial/civil courts”.
29.
In such view of the matter, it would not be
proper for this Court to proceed with these matters
any
further.
However,
since
the
revisional
applications filed by the petitioners have been
entertained by this Court, it would also not be
proper for this Court to leave the petitioners’ in the
lurch. This case therefore warrants exercise of
inherent powers of this Court in the interest of
justice in terms of the decision of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in the case of Nawab Shaqafath
Ali Khan & Ors. vs Nawab Imdad Jah Bahadur
& Ors. reported at (2009) 5 SCC 162 where the
Hon’ble Court had observed as follows:
“If the High Court had the jurisdiction to entertain either an
appeal or a revision application or a writ petition under Articles
226 and 227 of the Constitution of India, in a given case it,
subject to fulfillment of other conditions, could even convert a
revision application or a writ petition into an appeal or viceversa in exercise of its inherent power. Indisputably, however,
for the said purpose, an appropriate case for exercise of such
jurisdiction must be made out.”
30.
Accordingly this Court passes directions for
conversion of CO 3064 of 2024 and CO 4253 of
2025 into appeals. Insofar as CO 4118 of 2023 is
concerned, the orders challenged therein, being
passed prior in point of time than the ultimate
decree dated July 03, 2024 all such orders would
ultimately stand merged with the ultimate decree
and would be assailable before the appellate Court
in terms of Section 105(2) of the Code. The
department is directed to provide appropriate two
separate FAT numbers in respect of CO 3064 of
2024 and CO 4253 of 2025.
31.
Mr. Sengupta, learned advocate appearing for
the opposite party no. 1 has fairly submitted that
the opposite party no. 1 would not proceed with
the execution case before the learned Trial Court
and would take adjournment on the next day
awaiting conversion of the aforesaid two revisional
applications in this first appeal in terms of this
order. It is also recorded that both the parties have
fairly submitted that the revisional applications
may be converted to appeals.
32.
CO 4118 of 2023 will be treated as disposed of
upon having become infructuous. However, for the
purpose
of
convenience
and
getting
all
the
documents handy, the same would be tagged along
with the papers of the converted appeals. The
petitioners well cooperate with the department for
the purpose of aforesaid conversion.
(Om Narayan Rai, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review