Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/12
GAHC010282592025
undefined
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : Crl.Pet./1620/2025
SHUMAR ALI
S/O FALU SHEIKH
VILL- TIAMARI PART-II
P.O.TIAMARIP
P.S. GAURIPUR
DIST. DHUBRI, ASSAM
VERSUS
THE STATE OF ASSAM AND ANR
REP BY THE PP, ASSAM
2:MABIA KHATUN (INFORMANT)
D/O ABDUS SAMAD
P.O. AM CO. ROAD
P.S. AND DIST. DHUBRI
ASSAM
PIN- 78332
Advocate for the Petitioner
DEKA
: MR H R A CHOUDHURY, MR. SAYED SALIM AHMED,MS R
Advocate for the Respondent : PP, ASSAM, MS. B SARMA (LEGAL AID COUNSEL FOR
RESPONDENT NO. 2)
Page No.# 2/12
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE MRIDUL KUMAR KALITA
ORDER
Date - 05.06.2026
1.
Heard Mr. H. R. A. Choudhury, the learned senior counsel assisted by
Mr. S. A. Ahmed, the learned counsel for the petitioner. Also heard Mr.
K. Baishya, the learned Additional Public Prosecutor for the State
respondent as well as Ms. B. Sarma, the learned Legal Aid Counsel for
the respondent No. 2.
2.
This Criminal Petition under Section 528 of the BNSS, 2023 has been
filed by the petitioner, namely, Shumar Ali, praying for quashing of the
proceedings of PR Case No. 1071/2025 under Section 82(2)/83 of the
BNS, 2023.
3.
The facts relevant for consideration of the instant criminal petition, in
brief, are that the respondent No.2, namely, Mabia Khatun, had lodged
an FIR before the Officer-in-Charge of Gauripur Police Station on
04.08.2025, inter-alia, alleging that the petitioner, who is her husband,
used to torture her after her marriage, and in this regard, she had
earlier lodged an FIR against him under Section 498A of the Indian
Penal Code and on the basis of the said FIR, Gauripur P. S. Case
No.346/2025 was registered.
4.
It is also alleged that during the subsistence of the marriage of
respondent No.2 with the present petitioner, he married another lady
on 04.08.2025. On receipt of the said FIR, Gauripur P. S. Case
No.346/2025 was registered under Sections 85/318(4)/82(2)/83/49 of
Page No.# 3/12
the BNS, 2023, and investigation was initiated. After completion of
investigation, charge-sheet was laid against the present petitioner
under Section 82(2)/83 of BNS, 2023. On the basis of the said charge
sheet, PR Case No. 1071/2025 was registered and said case is pending
before the Court of the learned Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate,
Dhubri.
5.
It is pertinent to mention herein that the further proceeding of the
aforesaid PR Case was stayed by this Court by its order dated
07.01.2026.
6.
Mr. H. R. A. Choudhury, the learned senior counsel for the petitioner
submits that the Section 82 of the BNS, 2023, which is in pari-materia
with Section 494 of the Indian Penal Code, provides that in the event
of conducting a second marriage, a husband or wife shall be punished
with imprisonment. In the event, “such marriage is void by reason of
its taking place during the lifetime of such husband/wife”. He submits
that the personal law applicable to Muslims does contemplate four
marriages by a Muslim man. He submits that one of the essential
ingredients for applicability of Section 82 of the BNS, 2023 is that the
second marriage should be void. However, in the case of a Muslim
man, such second marriage is not void and consequently, Section 82
of the BNS, 2023 is not attracted even if a Muslim man marries a
second woman. In support of his submission, he has cited ruling of
the High Court of Bombay in the case of Kalim Shaikh Munaf and
Others Vs. The State of Maharashtra and others reported in 2022 SCC
online, BOM 12036.
Page No.# 4/12
7.
He submits that since a second marriage by Muslim man is permissible
under his personal law, the provision of Section 82(1) of the BNS,
2023 is not applicable and since such an act of marrying for the second
time is not an offence under Section 82(1) of the BNS, 2023, even the
provisions of Section 82(2) of the BNS, 2023 is not applicable and
consequently, in the instant case, the provision of Section 83 of the
BNS, 2023
is also not applicable. He, therefore, submits that
continuation of the proceedings of PR Case No.1071/2025 would be
an abuse of process of law and, therefore, he prays for quashing the
said proceeding.
8.
On the other hand, Ms. B. Sarma, the learned counsel for respondent
No. 2 has submitted that the petitioner used to torture respondent No.
2 after her marriage with him and in this regard, a case under Section
498 A of Indian Penal Code has also been filed by the respondent No.
2. The said case is still pending. However, she fairly submits that the
personal law applicable to the petitioner allows a Muslim man to have
four wives at a time. She, however, submits that even if the Muslim
man can marry more than one wife at a time, he is under obligation
to intimate the second wife regarding existence of her first marriage
and on failure to do so, he may be regarded as having committed
offence under Section 82 (2) of the BNS, 2023.
9.
She also submits that though, the petitioner had filed an application
for restitution of conjugal rights with the respondent No. 2 before the
Principal Judge, Family Court, Dhubri, however, after filing the said
case, he had not pursued the same and the said case was dismissed
due to non-prosecution by him.
Page No.# 5/12
10. The learned counsel for the respondent No.2 submits that the fact as
to whether the petitioner had informed his second wife regarding the
subsistence of his first marriage with the respondent No. 2 can only
be revealed during the trial and, therefore, she submits that this is not
a fit case to invoke the inherent jurisdiction of this Court to quash the
proceeding of PR Case No.1071/2025.
11. On the other hand, Mr. K. Baishya, the learned Additional Public
Prosecutor submits that the Assam Compulsory Registration of Muslim
Marriages and Divorces Act, 2024, which was in force, when the
second marriage of the petitioner was held, requires compulsory
registration by Muslim persons. He submits that the there is no
material to indicate that the second marriage of the petitioner was
registered under the said Act. He, however, fairly submits that nonregistration of such marriage would not make the second marriage
void in itself.
12. I have considered the submissions made by the learned counsel for
both sides and have gone through the materials available on record.
I have also gone through the rulings cited by the learned counsel.
13. The allegation against the present petitioner in the FIR lodged by the
respondent No.2 is that he had performed second marriage during the
subsistence of his earlier marriage with the respondent No.2. The
accusation against him is of commission of offence under Section
82(2) and 83 of the BNS, 2023. For the sake of convenience, Section
82 and 83 of the BNS, 2023 are quoted hereinbelow as below:
“82. Marrying again during lifetime of husband or
wife.—
Page No.# 6/12
(1) Whoever, having a husband or wife living,
marries in any case in which such marriage is void
by reason of its taking place during the life of such
husband or wife, shall be punished with
imprisonment of either description for a term
which may extend to seven years, and shall also
be liable to fine.
Exception.—This sub-section does not extend to
any person whose marriage with such husband or
wife has been declared void by a Court of
competent jurisdiction, nor to any person who
contracts a marriage during the life of a former
husband or wife, if such husband or wife, at the
time of the subsequent marriage, shall have been
continually absent from such person for the space
of seven years, and shall not have been heard of
by such person as being alive within that time
provided the person contracting such subsequent
marriage shall, before such marriage takes place,
inform the person with whom such marriage is
contracted of the real state of facts so far as the
same are within his or her knowledge.
(2) Whoever commits the offence under subsection (1) having concealed from the person
with whom the subsequent marriage is
contracted, the fact of the former marriage, shall
be punished with imprisonment of either
description for a term which may extend to ten
years, and shall also be liable to fine.
83. Marriage ceremony fraudulently gone through
without lawful marriage.—Whoever, dishonestly
or with a fraudulent intention, goes through the
ceremony of being married, knowing that he is
not thereby lawfully married, shall be punished
with imprisonment of either description for a term
which may extend to seven years, and shall also
be liable to fine.”
Page No.# 7/12
14. On bare perusal of the aforesaid provisions, it appears that the
requirement of second marriage being void due to the reason of its
taking place during the subsistence of the first marriage is mandatory
for commission of an offence under Section 82(1) of the BNS, 2023.
Similarly, commission of offence under Section 82(1) of the BNS, 2023
is a pre-requisite for fulfilling the ingredients of offence under Section
82(2) of the BNS, 2023. For commission of offence under Section 83
knowingly performing the ceremony of an illegal marriage is a prerequisite, which also indicates that the marriage in question has to be
illegal marriage for whatsoever reason. In the instant case, the
accusation against the petitioner is that he married during existence
of his marriage with respondent No.2.
15. In this regard, the observations made by the High Court of Bombay in
the case of Kalim Shaikh Munaf and Others Vs. The State of
Maharashtra and others (Supra) are relevant in this case and as such,
the same are reproduced hereinbelow:
“17. In a case of A.S. Nazar v. Jissa, 2017 SCC OnLine
Ker 17001, the Kerala High Court by referring the case
of Dr. Surajmani Stella (supra), in paragraph nos. 9 and
10 has made following observations:—
“9. The Apex Court in Dr. Surajmani Stella
Kujur v. Durga Charan Hansdah, [(2001) 3 SCC
13 : 2001 KHC 1043 : AIR 2001 SC 938] held that
the fact of the second marriage being void is sine
qua non for the applicability of Section 494 of IPC.
Page No.# 8/12
The Muslim male can have four wives at a time.
However, if the Muslim male marries a fifth wife,
he can very well be prosecuted under
section 494 of IPC since the fifth marriage is void
as the present law permits only four wives to be
taken together.
10. One of the most ingredients to attract the
offence under section 494 IPC is that the second
marriage should be void. So far as Muslim males
are concerned, since they can have four wives
living at a time, the second marriage is not void.
Since the second marriage is not void, the offence
under section 494 IPC is not attracted, even if the
Muslim male marries a second woman. In this
case, there is no allegation that the first petitioner
had married more than once before the marriage
with the second petitioner. Therefore, no offence
under section 494 IPC is attracted in this case.
Consequently, the abetment of the said offence is
also not attracted. For the said reason, there
cannot be any successful prosecution against the
petitioners for the above said offences and
consequently, no purpose will be served even if the
prosecution against the petitioners is permitted to
be continued. For the said reason, I am inclined to
quash annexure A-1 complaint and further
proceedings against the petitioners in CC No. 1232
of 2015 on the files of the Court below, in exercise
of the inherent power under section 482 of Cr.
P.C. to meet the ends of justice and accordingly, I
order so.”
18. In a case of Venugopal K. v. Union of India, 2015
SCC OnLine Ker 798 relied upon by the learned counsel
for the applicants, in paragraph nos. 10 and 11 of the
Page No.# 9/12
judgment, Kerala High Court has made the following
observations:—
“10. There may be cases where a Muslim male or
female can be prosecuted for offence under
Section 494 IPC also. In a case where a Muslim
male marries a fifth wife, he can very well be
prosecuted under Section 494 IPC since the
5th marriage will be void, personal law being
having permitted only four wives to be taken
together. Similarly a Muslim female contracting a
second marriage can be proceeded with for
offence under Section 494 IPC. Thus submission of
the learned counsel for the petitioner that offence
under Section 494 IPC is discriminatory between
Hindu/Muslim/Christian is not acceptable. The sina
qua non for giving rise to an offence under Section
494 is whether the second marriage performed by
a husband or wife when the spouse is living is void
or not. In this context judgment of the Apex Court
in Dr. Srajmani Stella Kujur v. Durga Charan
Hansdah, ((2001) 3 SCC 13) is relevant to be
mentioned. In the above case wife had filed a
complaint that her marriage was performed at
Delhi in accordance with the Hindu rites and
customs and the husband solemnized another
marriage with accused No. 2. Parties belonged to
Scheduled Tribe. The Apex Court held that in the
absence of specific pleadings, evidence and proof
of alleged custom making the second marriage
void, no offence under section 494 of IPC can
possibly be made out against the respondent. It
was held by the Apex Court that the fact of second
marriage being void is sin qua non for the
applicability of section 494 of IPC. The following
was laid down in paragraph 14:
Page No.# 10/12
“14. Nowhere in the complaint the appellant has
referred to any alleged custom having the force of
law which prohibits the solemnisation of second
marriage by the respondent and the consequences
thereof. It may be emphasised that mere pleading
of a custom stressing for monogamy by itself was
not sufficient unless it was further pleaded that
second marriage was void by reason of its taking
place during the life of such husband or wife. In
order to prove the second marriage being void, the
appellant was under an obligation to show the
existence of a custom which made such marriage
null, ineffectual, having no force of law or binding
effect, incapable of being enforced in law or non
est. The fact of second marriage being void is a
sine qua non for the applicability of S. 494 IPC. It
is settled position of law that for fastening the
criminal liability, the prosecution or the
complainant is obliged to prove the (SIC) appellant
herself appears to be not clear in her stand
inasmuch as in her statement in the court recorded
on 24th October, 1992 she has stated that “I am a
Hindu by religion”. The complaint was dismissed by
the Trial Court holding, “there is no mention of any
such custom in the complaint nor there is evidence
of such custom. In the absence of pleadings and
evidence reference to Book alone is not sufficient”,
the High Court vide the judgment impugned in this
appeal held that in the absence of notification in
terms of sub-section (2) of S. 2 of the Act no case
for prosecution for the offence of bigamy was
made out against the respondent because the
alleged second marriage cannot be termed to be
void either under the Act or any alleged custom
having the force of law.”
Page No.# 11/12
11. To the same effect there is another judgment
of the Supreme Court in Lilly Thomas v. Union of
India, ((2000) 6 SCC 224) wherein the following
was observed in paragraph 23:
“23. We have already seen above that under the
Hindu Marriage Act, one of the essential
ingredients of a valid Hindu marriage is that
neither party should have a spouse living at the
time of marriage. If the marriage takes place in
spite of the fact that a party to that marriage had
a spouse living, such marriage would be void under
S. 11 of the Hindu Marriage Act. Such a marriage
is also described as void under S. 17 of the Hindu
Marriage Act under which an offence of bigamy has
been created. This offence has been created by
reference. By providing in S. 17 that provisions of
S. 494 and 495 would be applicable to such a
marriage, the legislature has bodily lifted the
provisions of S. 494 and 495 IPC and placed them
in S. 17 of the Hindu Marriage Act. This is a well
known legislative device. The important words
used in S. 494 are “MARRIES IN ANY CASE IN
WHICH SUCH MARRIAGE IS VOID BY REASON OF
ITS TAKING PLACE DURING THE LIFE OF SUCH
HUSBAND OR WIFE”. These words indicate that
before an offence under S. 494 can be said to have
been constituted, the second marriage should be
shown to be void in a case where such a marriage
would be void by reason of its taking place in the
lifetime of such husband or wife. The words
“husband or wife” are also important in the sense
that they indicate the personal law applicable to
them which would continue to be applicable to
them so long as the marriage subsists and they
remain “husband and wife”.”
Page No.# 12/12
16.
The provisions contained in Section 82 of the BNS, 2023 are in pari-
materia with the provisions of Section 494 of the Indian Penal Code.
This Court is in agreement with the observations made by the High
Court of Bombay and High Court of Kerala in the above referred
judgment that the fact of second marriage being void is sine qua non
for applicability of Section 494 of the Indian Penal Code and by the
same analogy for applicability of Section 82 of the BNS, 2023. As
according to the personal law of the petitioner, who is a Muslim male,
he can have four wives at a time. Hence, he can be prosecuted under
Section 82 of the BNS, 2023 only if he marries a fifth wife, during the
life time of earlier four wives, without divorcing any of them as such
a marriage would be void marriage. For the same reasons, the
provisions of Section 83 of BNS, 2023 will also be not applicable as
his second marriage is not an illegal marriage under the personal law
applicable to a Muslim male.
17.
For the aforesaid reasons continuation of the criminal proceedings of
PR Case No. 1071/2025 would be a futile exercise and an abuse of
process of law, as such, the same is liable to be quashed.
18.
The proceedings of PR Case No. 1071/2025 is, accordingly, quashed.
19.
This Criminal Petition is, accordingly, allowed.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review