Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Appellate Jurisdiction)
DATED : 3rd July, 2018
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
S.B. :THE HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I.A. No. 01 of 2018
in
MAC APP. No.02 of 2018
Shriram General Insurance Co. Ltd.,
Registered Office :
E-8, EPIP, RIICO Industrial Area,
Sitapura, Jaipur, Rajasthan – 302022,
Regional Office :
53A Rafi Ahamed Kidwai Road, 3rd Floor,
Kolkata – 700 016,
Branch Office :
142/14, Sevoke Road, 1st Floor,
Opposite PAN Card Office,
Beside Raymond Showroom,
Siliguri, Darjeeling – 734 001.
… APPELLANT/INSURER
-VERSUS1.
Mr. Kezang Kazi,
Son of late Pem Singh Kazi,
Resident of House No.45,
Aritar, Near Simick Sangngak,
Duddulling Monastary,
17 Khamdong, Singtam,
P.O. Simik Lingzey,
P.S. Singtam, East Sikkim.
… RESPONDENT/CLAIMANT
2.
Shri Karma Chezing Bhutia,
Son of Late Phuchung Bhutia,
Resident of Khamdong,
P.O. Simik Lingzey,
P.S. Singtam, East Sikkim.
(Owner of the Vehicle SK-01T/5531 (Wagon R LXI)
… RESPONDENT/OWNER
Application under Section 173(1) of the Motor Vehicle Act, 1988
IA No.01 of 2018
in
MAC APP. No.02 of 2018
Shriram General Insurance Co. Ltd. -Vs- Mr. Kezang Kazi & Anr.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Mr. Yadev Sharma and Mr. Dilip Kumar Tamang, Advocates for the
Appellant.
Ms. Vidya Lama, Advocate for the Respondent No.1.
Mr. Sushant Subba, Advocate for the Respondent No. 2.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ORDER
Meenakshi Madan Rai, ACJ
1.
The instant Application is filed under Section 173(1) of
the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (for short, the M.V. Act), seeking
condonation of 115 days’ delay in filing the Appeal.
2.
The grounds, put forth for the delay, are that the
impugned award of the Learned Member, Motor Accident Claims
Tribunal, East Sikkim at Gangtok in M.A.C.T. Case No. 11 of 2016,
was pronounced on 26.04.2017. Pursuant thereto, it was received
by the Branch Office at Siliguri and forwarded to the Kolkata
Regional Office.
The Regional Office sought reasons from the
conducting Counsel as to why the Judgment passed was ex-parte.
Thereafter, copy of the Judgment was forwarded to the Jaipur Head
Office for opinion and instructions. The Head Office asked for copies
of the deposition, exhibits and other relevant documents which had
been forwarded to the Petitioner, in which circumstance, it was not
possible for the Petitioner to make a decision about preferring the
Appeal. As per internal procedure of the Company, the Jaipur Head
Office sent back the file to the Kolkata Regional Office for required
IA No.01 of 2018
in
MAC APP. No.02 of 2018
Shriram General Insurance Co. Ltd. -Vs- Mr. Kezang Kazi & Anr.
documents, which the Learned Counsel for the Appellant had applied
for on 25.05.2017.
The copy was made available on 31.05.2017.
After procuring the required documents, the Regional Office sent the
file once again to the Jaipur Head Office for further instructions,
which, in turn, sent back the file to Kolkata Regional office for
appointing an Advocate to prefer the Appeal. On such appointment,
the Counsel completed all official formalities following which the
Memorandum of Appeal was sent by the Counsel to the Jaipur Head
Office for verification and signature, which took a few days. That, in
the meanwhile, the Respondent-Claimant had already preferred an
Appeal before this Court and before the Appellant could enter an
appearance, the Appeal came to be withdrawn. In the meanwhile,
the validity of the statutory deposit made by the applicant expired
and had to be sent to the Kolkata Regional Office for re-validation
and thereafter, to the Jaipur Head Office. Hence, the delay. That, it
is a settled position of law that Government and Government
undertakings have been permitted some flexibility in case of
condonation of delay due to time required for process of the file.
Hence, the delay be condoned as it is neither intentional nor wilful
but due to sufficient reasons as laid down in the averments.
3.
Learned Counsel for the Respondent, while objecting to
the petition for delay, sought to remind this Court that the M. V. Act
is benevolent legislation where compensation/award is granted to
the next of kin of the deceased, who succumbed to injuries in an
accident. The purpose is to ensure that the family is not reduced to
vagrancy on account of death of the deceased. That apart, it was
IA No.01 of 2018
in
MAC APP. No.02 of 2018
Shriram General Insurance Co. Ltd. -Vs- Mr. Kezang Kazi & Anr.
also brought to the notice of this Court that the conduct of the
Respondent is of callousness towards the loss of family member of
the Respondent as well as to the provisions of law.
In the first
instance, the Appellant failed to enter an appearance before the
Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, East Sikkim at Gangtok, despite
service of notice, on account of which the matter was proceeded exparte and Judgment pronounced. Besides, the grounds put forth for
condonation of delay deserve no consideration as it lacks details of
sufficient cause.
No dates of movement of the file have been
furnished for the perusal of this Court and although Judgment was
pronounced
on
26.04.2017,
copy
was
sought
for
only
on
25.05.2017, a month after the pronouncement of the Judgment.
Merely because the file was sent from one office to the next is no
ground for considering the petition and allowing it.
Moreover, the
averments are devoid of dates. That, in fact, in view of the grounds
put forth, the petition be ordered to be dismissed.
4.
I have heard learned Counsel for the parties and
considered their submissions.
5.
The provisions of Section 173 of the Act of 1988, inter
alia, provide that the High Court may entertain the appeal after the
expiry of the period of ninety days, if it is satisfied that the appellant
was prevented by sufficient cause from preferring the appeal in
time.
Thus, what requires consideration is whether the applicant
was circumspect while taking steps in filing the appeal, the delay
was bona fide and has been sufficiently explained.
IA No.01 of 2018
in
MAC APP. No.02 of 2018
Shriram General Insurance Co. Ltd. -Vs- Mr. Kezang Kazi & Anr.
6.
In Postmaster General and Others vs. Living Media
India Limited and Others1, Hon’ble Supreme Court would hold as
follows:“29.
In our view, it is the right time to inform all the government
bodies, their agencies and instrumentalities that unless they have
reasonable and acceptable explanation for the delay and there
was bona fide effort, there is no need to accept the usual
explanation that the file was kept pending for several months/years
due to considerable degree of procedural red tape in the process.
The government departments are under a special obligation to
ensure that they perform their duties with diligence and
commitment. Condonation of delay is an exception and should not
be used as an anticipated benefit for the government departments.
The law shelters everyone under the same light and should not be
swirled for the benefit of a few.
30.
Considering the fact that there was no proper explanation
offered by the Department for the delay except mentioning of
various dates, according to us, the Department has miserably
failed to give any acceptable and cogent reasons sufficient to
condone such a huge delay. Accordingly, the appeals are liable to
be dismissed on the ground of delay.”
7.
In Maniben Devraj Shah vs. Municipal Corporation
of Brihan Mumbai2, the Supreme Court observed as under:“25.
In cases involving the State and its agencies/
instrumentalities, the court can take note of the fact that sufficient
time is taken in the decision-making process but no premium can
be given for total lethargy or utter negligence on the part of the
officers of the State and/or its agencies/instrumentalities and the
applications filed by them for condonation of delay cannot be
allowed as a matter of course by accepting the plea that dismissal
of the matter on the ground of bar of limitation will cause injury to
the public interest.”
8.
On the bed rock of the above decisions, I now proceed
to examine the grounds put forth by the Petitioner.
It would be
apposite to state here that the M.V. Act is social welfare legislation,
a benevolent provision, which seeks to compensate the victim for
the loss of not only a family member but the breadwinner therein,
within a short span of time sans the procedural technicalities which
(2012) 3 SCC 563
(2012) 5 SCC 157
IA No.01 of 2018
in
MAC APP. No.02 of 2018
Shriram General Insurance Co. Ltd. -Vs- Mr. Kezang Kazi & Anr.
ought not to defeat the benevolent purpose of the M. V. Act. That,
having been said when the grounds, as extracted hereinabove for
the delay, are carefully perused and considered, it is evident that
the conduct of the applicant cannot be said to be beyond reproach.
In the first instance, they failed to enter an appearance before the
Motor Accident Claims Tribunal during the entire trial, consequently
the impugned Judgment came to be pronounced ex-parte. Added to
this is the fact that they applied for a certified copy of the Judgment
a month after its pronouncement.
Following this, the file, while
seeking opinion of the various officers of the Company, was sent
from one table to the next. Curiously, no date is furnished by the
Applicant to enable this Court to gauge as to whether there was
unnecessary delay at any stage. The Applicant has chosen to keep
the various dates on which the file made its journey from one official
to the next under wraps. In any event, the grounds have not been
sufficiently explained.
This Court is conscious of the fact that a
plethora of the Judgments of the Supreme Court have laid down
that a liberal approach should be adopted in matters of condonation
of delay, but at the same time, it may also be mentioned here that
the Supreme Court has also observed that there ought to be a
justice oriented approach.
In my considered opinion, justice does
not mean justice only to the Applicant but it means justice to the
Respondent as well. Here, we have a Respondent, who has lost a
family member and is awaiting compensation on account of his
death, which, although being granted to him in material terms,
cannot compensate for the void created by the loss of the person.
It is only an effort made by legislation to comfort the victim and to
IA No.01 of 2018
in
MAC APP. No.02 of 2018
Shriram General Insurance Co. Ltd. -Vs- Mr. Kezang Kazi & Anr.
ensure that they are not reduced to vagrancy due to the loss of a
breadwinner.
9.
In Basawaraj and Another vs. Land Acquisition
Officer3, the Supreme Court would observe as under:
“11.
The expression “sufficient cause” should be given a liberal
interpretation to ensure that substantial justice is done, but only so long as
negligence, inaction or lack of bona fides cannot be imputed to the party
concerned, whether or not sufficient cause has been furnished, can be
decided on the facts of a particular case and no straitjacket formula is
possible. (Vide Madanlal v. Shyamlal [(2002) 1 SCC 535 : AIR 2002 SC
100] and Ram Nath Sao v. Gobardhan Sao [(2002) 3 SCC 195 : AIR 2002
SC 1201] .)
12.
It is a settled legal proposition that law of limitation may harshly
affect a particular party but it has to be applied with all its rigour when the
statute so prescribes. The court has no power to extend the period of
limitation on equitable grounds. “A result flowing from a statutory provision
is never an evil. A court has no power to ignore that provision to relieve
what it considers a distress resulting from its operation.” The statutory
provision may cause hardship or inconvenience to a particular party but the
court has no choice but to enforce it giving full effect to the same. The legal
maxim dura lex sed lex which means “the law is hard but it is the law”,
stands attracted in such a situation. It has consistently been held that,
“inconvenience is not” a decisive factor to be considered while interpreting
a statute.
13. The statute of limitation is founded on public policy, its aim being to
secure peace in the community, to suppress fraud and perjury, to quicken
diligence and to prevent oppression. It seeks to bury all acts of the past
which have not been agitated unexplainably and have from lapse of time
become stale.”
10.
In view of the grounds put forth and the discussions
which have ensued hereinabove, it is clear that the conduct of the
Appellant has been lackadaisical, firstly none appeared before the
Tribunal for the Appellant and thereafter the appeal is being filed
belatedly.
Considering the purpose of the Act as already detailed
hereinabove, there appears to be no reason for this Court to even
consider condoning the delay, bereft as the application is of
sufficient cause.
(2013) 14 SCC 81
IA No.01 of 2018
in
MAC APP. No.02 of 2018
Shriram General Insurance Co. Ltd. -Vs- Mr. Kezang Kazi & Anr.
11.
In such circumstances, the Application is rejected.
12.
Consequently, the Appeal stands dismissed.
( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Acting Chief Justice
03-07-2018
Approved for reporting : No
Internet : Yes
pm
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review