Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
signed by
SHAMURAILATPAM Digitally
SHAMURAILATPAM SUSHIL SHARMA
Date: 2023.01.10 15:58:51 +05'30'
SUSHIL SHARMA
Page |1
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WP(C) No.243 of 2020
J S Chauhan, CRPF (IRLA-6189) age 56 years S/O
Sh. Satya Pal Singh, resident of Flat No. 102, B-1/67,
Sai Sadan – II Swak Park, Uttam Nagar, New Delhi,
presently posted as 2-IC 32 Bn CRPF, NHPC Project
Zero Colony Kaomkieru Loktak, PO & PS – Loktak,
Churachandpur District, Manipur PIN 795124.
...Petitioner
-Versus-
1. The Union of India, through the Secretary,
Ministry of Home Affairs, Government of India,
North Block, New Delhi-110 001.
2. The Director General of Police, CRPF, Head
Quarters
CGO Complex, New Delhi- 110 003.
3. The Director (Accts), Pay & Accounts Office,
CRPF,
Plot No. 14, PSP-2, Rohini Sector-23,
New Delhi-110086
4. Inspector General of Police, Manipur & Nagaland
Sector, CRPF GC Campus, Langjing, Imphal,
Manipur-795 113
WP(C) No. 243 of 2020 and WP(C) No. 508 of 2020
Page |2
5. DIG (Adm) CRPF, GO’s Entitlement Cell,
Directorate CGO Complex, Lodhi Road, New
Delhi – 110003
...Respondents
WP(C) No.508 of 2020
Shri Vinod Sawant, CRPF (IRLA-7070) age 37 years
S/o Sh. Lal Singh, presently posted as Deputy
Commandant, 109 Bn. Mongsangei, PO Chanchipur,
Imphal West, Manipur – 795 003.
...Petitioner
-Versus-
1. The Union of India, through the Secretary, Ministry of
Home Affairs, Government of India, North Block, New
Delhi-110 001
2. The Director General of Police, CRPF, Head
Quarters, CGO Complex, Lodhi Road , New Delhi110 003
3. The Director (Accts), Pay & Accounts Office, CRPF,
Plot No. 14, PSP-2, Rohini Sector-23, New Delhi110086
4. Inspector General of Police, ADM DTE CRPF, CGO
Complex, Lodhi Road, New Delhi- 110 003
5. Asst. Director (Adm/Accts), ADM DTE CRPF, CGO
Complex, Lodhi Road, New Delhi- 110 003
WP(C) No. 243 of 2020 and WP(C) No. 508 of 2020
Page |3
6. The AC, GO’s Entitlement Section, East Block No. 9,
Level-2, Sector-1, RK Puram, New Delhi – 110 006
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE M.V. MURALIDARAN
For the Petitioners
::
Mr. K. Roshan, Advocate in
WP(C) No. 243 of 2020;
Mr. A. Mohendro, Advocate in
WP(C) No. 508 of 2020
For the Respondents
::
Mr. S. Vijayanand Sharma,
Sr.PCCG
Date of Hearing and
reserving Judgment & Order ::
20.12.2022
Date of Judgment & Order ::
10.01.2023
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
(CAV)
The prayer in W.P.(C) No.243 of 2020 is as
follows:
“Admit the Writ petition and issue Rule Nisi
calling upon the respondents to show cause
as to why a Writ/order/directive(s) should not
be issued for quashing and setting aside the
stoppage of HRA given to the Petitioner with
effect from 16.2.2019, as it was done without
due process of law and without issuing any
order and violation of Principle of Natural
Justice and stoppage is against the OM issued
WP(C) No. 243 of 2020 and WP(C) No. 508 of 2020
Page |4
by the Ministry of Finance, in the facts and
circumstances;
To show cause as to why a Writ in the nature
of Mandamus or any other appropriate
writ/order/directive(s) should not be issued
directing the Respondents to pay the HRA in
terms of the Sanction order dated 21.2.2019
issued by the Commandant – 32 Bn CRPF,
Loktak,
Manipur
and
also
directed
the
respondents to pay the illegal recovery
amount of Rs.27,827/ to the petitioner;
Make the Rule absolute;
To pass any appropriate order or direction(s)
which may be appropriate to be passed under
such facts and circumstance of the instant
case, for the ends of justice.”
2.
The prayer in W.P.(C) No.508 of 2020 is as
follows:
“To admit the Writ Petition, call for the records
of the case and issue rule nisi calling upon the
Respondents to show cause as to why the
prayer prayed for by the Petitioner should not
be granted.
And, after hearing them your
Lordships may make the rule absolute;
WP(C) No. 243 of 2020 and WP(C) No. 508 of 2020
Page |5
To
issue
a
writ
in
the
nature
of
mandamus/certiorari or any other appropriate
writ
thereby
quashing
the
letter
dated
27.2.2020 and to direct the concerned
respondents to release the HRA entitled to the
petitioner with effect from 13.8.2019 in terms
of the Sanction order dated 3.9.2019 issued by
the
Commandant
Bn.,
CRPF,
Mongsangai, Imphal West, Manipur;
To direct the concerned respondents to
release the HRA entitled to the petitioner w.e.f.
13.8.2019 along with 6% interest per annum;
To direct the concerned respondents to refund
the amounts deducted from the salary of the
petitioner
without
giving
any
reason/clarification;
To direct the concerned respondents to
consider the letter dated 6.3.2020 submitted
by the petitioner to the IGP(ADM) DTE, CRPF
(through proper channel) within a stipulated
timeframe by issuing necessary speaking
order;
To pass any other appropriate order(s) or
direction(s) that this Hon’ble Court deem fit
and proper; and
To award cost of the Petition to the Petitioner.”
WP(C) No. 243 of 2020 and WP(C) No. 508 of 2020
Page |6
3.
Since the grounds raised and relief sought in the
writ petitions are similar, both the writ petitions were heard
together and are being disposed of by this common order.
4.
The case of the petitioner in W.P.(C) No.243 of
2020 is that he was remained posted in 103 Bn RAF/CRPF,
New Delhi by drawing HRA with his pay and after completing
his tenure period of posting at 103 Bn, the petitioner was
transferred to 32 Bn CRPF, Loktak, Churchandpur District,
Manipur. Pursuant to the transfer order dated 29.1.2019, he
reported duty at 32 Bn and the Commandant, 32 Bn had also
taken him in the strength of the unit with effect from 15.2.2019.
Vide order of the Commandant, 32 Bn, a sanction was accorded
for his entitlement of HRA and was also drawing his HRA with
his pay regularly with effect from 15.2.2019 without any
interruption till March, 2020. However, in the month of April,
2020, the respondent authority without giving any opportunity of
hearing and without issuing any recovery order, recovered a
sum of Rs.27,827/- from the petitioner’s pay and also stopped
the HRA of Rs.22,584/-. After knowing the stoppage of HRA
and recovery of Rs.27,827/-, the petitioner has submitted a
representation on 25.4.2020 to the competent authority.
WP(C) No. 243 of 2020 and WP(C) No. 508 of 2020
Page |7
Despite the receipt of the said representation, the same has not
been considered till date. Hence, the writ petition.
5.
Resisting the writ petition, the respondents filed
affidavit-in-opposition stating that on checking of dues being
drawn by officers, it was found that many officers whose
Notional HQ (i.e. Group Centre) is not situated in North Eastern
region (for short, “NE region”) are also drawing HRA at the rates
applicable to their previous headquarters. Accordingly, all HRA
drawal cases were reviewed and all those officers, whose
detachment headquarter is in NE region but their notional
headquarter is away from NE region, were stopped and
recovery of irregular HRA was scheduled in equal instalments.
It is stated that the HRA case of the petitioner Chauhan was of
similar nature as his notional headquarter is GC CRPF
Kathgodam (Uttrakhand) and detachment headquarter is in NE
region and, therefore, his HRA was found irregular and stopped
from month of April 2020 and recovery of irregular HRA already
drawn for period from 16.2.2019 to 31.3.2020 amounting to
Rs.2,78,263/- was booked in 10 equal instalments for recovery
@ Rs.27,827/- per month from the pay of April 2020. It is stated
that the representation of the petitioner has been examined by
the DIG (Adm) Dte. General vide their signal dated 12.5.2020
WP(C) No. 243 of 2020 and WP(C) No. 508 of 2020
Page |8
and passed an order to recover the HRA amount in 20 equal
instalments instead of 10 instalments and the same has been
conveyed to the petitioner through Commandant 32 Bn.
6.
The case of the petitioner in W.P.(C) No.508 of
2020 is that after completing his tenure period of posting at DG,
CGO, Lodhi Road, New Delhi, the petitioner was transferred on
25.7.2019 to 109 Bn. located at Imphal and upon report, the
petitioner has been taken into 109 Bn. with effect from
13.8.2019. According to the petitioner, while posted at DG,
Headquarters, Delhi as Deputy Commandant (CR&VIG) from
January, 2014 to August 2019, he was allotted Government
quarters from 16.10.2014 to 12.6.2019. The petitioner vacated
the Government accommodation and shifted his family
members to a rented accommodation at Delhi-85. Vide order
dated 3.7.2019, the DIG (Adm) Dte issued sanction order
according for drawing HRA with effect from 13.6.2019.
Although the sanction order was issued, the petitioner has failed
to receive the HRA since September 2019 and he was informed
deduction of Rs.26,807/- from the salary of September, 2019
without disclosing any reason. The stoppage of HRA with effect
from September 2019 is against the Office Memorandum and
WP(C) No. 243 of 2020 and WP(C) No. 508 of 2020
Page |9
the same is illegal, arbitrary and unreasonable. Hence, the writ
petition.
7.
The respondents 1 to 6 filed affidavit-in-opposition
stating that on his reporting, the petitioner has been sanctioned
HRA at 24% with effect from 13.8.2019 vide 109 Bn. sanction
order dated 3.9.2019 for residing his family at House No.60-61,
Third Floor, BLK, a-Pkt-3 Sector-16, Rohini City, Delhi-85. It is
stated that the officer/personnel who are posted to NE region
from outside of NE region but kept their family at the last place
of posting are entitled to HRA of the old duty station. However,
officer/personnel posted in a unit deployed in NE region, the
notional Headquarter i.e. GC of which is situated outside of NE
region are not entitled for grant of HRA at the last place of
posting. It is stated that no such order exists to grant HRA to
those personnel who is posted in a unit deployed in NE region
but kept their family at the last place of posting without linking
his notional Headquarter i.e. GC. Therefore, on receipt of 109
Bn. sanction order dated 3.9.2019, the office of DIG (Amn) has
not drawn the sanctioned HRA to the petitioner in the light of
clarification/direction and the same has been intimated to 109
Bn. on 27.2.2020 which has further been communicated to the
petitioner through Commandant, 109 Bn. vide endorsement
WP(C) No. 243 of 2020 and WP(C) No. 508 of 2020
P a g e | 10
dated 20.03.2020. It is stated that the personnel posted in those
Units which are deployed in NE region but their notional
Headquarter i.e. GC are situated outside of NE region, are not
entitled for grant of HRA at the last place of posting. No order
has so far been received from the Government of India to grant
of HRA to the personnel posted in unit deployed in NE region
and kept their family at last place posting without linking his
notional Headquarter. Further, the petitioner prior to his posting
as Deputy Commandant (Legal) M&N Sector Headquarter,
Imphal was posted in 109 Bn. as Deputy Commandant.
8.
Assailing the impugned stoppage of HRA and
recovery of Rs.27,827/-, Mr. A. Mohendro, the learned counsel
for the petitioner in W.P.(C) No.243 of 2020 submitted that the
petitioner was drawing HRA as per the sanction order dated
21.2.2019 till March 2020 without any interruption, as the
petitioner has been posted at NE region. He would submit that
HRA was being drawn to the officer as per the admissibility by
PAO of Government of India, but after taken over of entitlement
section by CRPF, point of notional HQ (GC) raised at their own
which is nowhere mentioned in the order of the Government of
India.
WP(C) No. 243 of 2020 and WP(C) No. 508 of 2020
P a g e | 11
9.
The learned counsel further submitted that the
petitioner came to know from his pay slip for the month of April
2020 that his HRA was stopped and recovery of total amount of
Rs.2,78,263/- was made and recovery instalment of a sum of
Rs.27,827/- per month for 10 instalments started without any
recovery order to the petitioner or did not cancel the sanction
order dated 21.2.2019 issued by the Commandant, 32 Bn. The
said act is illegal and malafide and violation of Office
Memorandum of the Ministry of Finance, Department of
Expenditure for granting benefit to the Central Government
employees employed in the NE region, whereas the petitioner
is now posted at 32 Bn., which is under the NE region and
therefore, the petitioner is entitled for the benefit of HRA.
10.
The learned counsel for the petitioner urged that
the petitioner has been transferred from 103 Bn. to 32 Bn. and
is still keeping his family at the last place of posting i.e. Delhi.
Hence, the stoppage of HRA and recovery ordered to be made
is illegal.
11.
The learned counsel for the petitioner then
submitted that the respondents are twisting the issue and
misinterpreting the rules/orders of the Government at their
WP(C) No. 243 of 2020 and WP(C) No. 508 of 2020
P a g e | 12
whims and do not try to understand the spirit of granting NE
concession extended under the Government policy.
The
learned counsel added that most of the CRPF battalions whose
Group Centres are located in NE region are deployed outside
the region.
But these battalions are not allowed NE
concessions though its affiliated GC are located in NE region
and that it is clear that presence in the NE region of an
employee is mandatory for granting NE region benefits.
12.
The learned counsel appearing for the petitioner in
W.P.(C) No.508 of 2020 submitted that as per the Office
Memorandum dated 22.1.2019, HRA is entitled to the CRPF
personnel on their transfer to non-family location viz., North
Eastern
Region,
Sikkim,
Andaman
&
Nicobar
Island,
Lakshadeep island, J&K and left wing extremist area and there
cannot be a classification whether the headquarters are within
the NE region or not. The petitioner who is posted at non-family
location at NE region is very much entitled to HRA in terms of
Office Memorandum dated 22.1.2019.
13.
The learned counsel further submitted that the
petitioner Vinod Sawant has been again transferred vide signal
dated 13.7.2021 from 109 Bn. to M&N Sector Headquarters with
WP(C) No. 243 of 2020 and WP(C) No. 508 of 2020
P a g e | 13
effect from 13.9.2021 and the petitioner has been taken on the
strength of Manipur and Nagaland Sector Headquarters vide
signal dated 20.9.2021. He would submit that on 27.9.2021, the
petitioner submitted an application to the office of M&N Sector
Headquarters for sanction of HRA for his last place of posting
i.e. Delhi mentioning that headquarter of the petitioner is now
situated in North East only and hence, he is entitled for HRA of
last place of posting. However, vide letter dated 21.10.2021,
the petitioner has been informed that he was not drawing HRA
at old station.
14.
Mr. S. Vijayanand Sharma, the learned Sr.PCCG
for the respondents submitted that HRA is a headquarter based
allowance and that the petitioners are posted at the duty Bn.
whose notional headquarters are situated outside the present
place of posting. As such, the petitioners are not entitled for
HRA.
Further, the HRA is given to an employee in case
Government Provided Residential Accommodation is not
available to him. Since the petitioners are given GPRA, they
are not entitled to claim HRA in the present place of posting.
The petitioners could only avail the allowance under additional
HRA scheme and not regular HRA.
WP(C) No. 243 of 2020 and WP(C) No. 508 of 2020
P a g e | 14
15.
The learned counsel for the respondents further
submitted that the petitioner in W.P.(C) No.508 of 2020 vacated
his GPRA on his own on 12.6.2019 whereas vide signal dated
6.5.2029, he has been transferred from Dte. General to 109 Bn.
Since the petitioner in W.P.(C) N.508 of 2020 vacated his GPRA
within the retention period of three years, he is not eligible to
claim for the benefit of additional HRA. Similarly, the petitioner
in W.P.(C) No.243 of 2020 was transferred from 103 Bn. to 32
Bn. vide signal dated 25.7.2018 and that the petitioner applied
for HRA while being posted in 32 Bn. for his previous place of
posting and sanction order was passed vide order dated
21.2.2019. Since the said sanction order is not in consonance
with the rules, it was stopped by the respondent authority.
Further, the petitioner in W.P.(C) No.243 of 2020 has applied
for the additional HRA before completion of the retention period
of three years as stipulated in the rules.
16.
The learned counsel for the respondent urged that
since both the petitioners are posted at duty battalion whose
notional headquarters are situated outside the State of Manipur
and HRA being a headquarter based allowance, the petitioners
are not entitled to claim for HRA.
WP(C) No. 243 of 2020 and WP(C) No. 508 of 2020
P a g e | 15
17.
This Court considered the rival submissions and
also perused the materials available on record.
18.
The grievance of the petitioner in W.P.(C) No.243
of 2020 is that he is a second in command and after completion
of his tenure period he was transferred from 102 Bn. New Delhi
to 32 Bn at Loktak, Manipur and after relieving from 103 Bn.,
the petitioner joined his new posting at 32 Bn. on 15.2.2019 and
at 32 Bn., he was sanctioned HRA vide order dated 21.2.2019
and was enjoying till March, 2020. However, the respondent
authorities without giving any opportunity to the petitioner,
stopped payment of HRA and also started recovery in 10
instalments with effect from 16.2.2019 to March, 2020 at the
rate of Rs.27,827/-. However, pursuant to the interim order of
this Court, the recovery was not effected. Thus, a prayer has
been made to direct the respondents to pay the HRA with effect
from April, 2020 and also to refund the recovery amount, if any,
to the petitioner.
19.
Similar is the grievance made by the petitioner in
W.P.(C) No.508 of 2020, who contended that he was posted at
the
Directorate
General,
CGO
Complex
as
Deputy
Commandant (CR & VIG) from January, 2014 to August, 2019
WP(C) No. 243 of 2020 and WP(C) No. 508 of 2020
P a g e | 16
and after completing his tenure period of posting at DG, CGO,
New Delhi, vide transfer order dated 25.7.2019, he was
transferred to 109 Bn. at Mongsangai, Manipur. According to
the petitioner, while he was at DG, New Delhi, the GPRA
quarters allotted to him was vacated and shifted his family to a
rented accommodation at Delhi and also the DIG (Adm) Dte.
had issued sanction order dated 3.7.2019 for drawing HRA with
effect from 13.6.2019. According to the petitioner, on reporting
at the new station, the petitioner requested the authority for
sanction of HRA of his last place of posting and the
Commandant, 109 Bn. had also issued sanction order dated
3.9.2019 for drawing HRA. When the order copy was forwarded
to the Director Accounts, PAO, CRPF, New Delhi for needful
action for drawal of HRA, his claim was returned stating that no
such order received from the Government of India to grant HRA
to the personnel posted in unit deployed in NE region and kept
their family at last place of posting without linking his notional
headquarter i.e. Group Centre. Thus, a prayer has been made
to quash the letter dated 27.2.2020 and to release the HRA
entitled to the petitioner with effect from 13.8.2019 in terms of
the sanction order dated 3.9.2019 and to refund the amount, if
any, deducted from the salary of the petitioner.
WP(C) No. 243 of 2020 and WP(C) No. 508 of 2020
P a g e | 17
20.
On the other hand, it is the say of the respondents
that in the case of the petitioner in W.P.(C) No.243 of 2020, he
was transferred from 103 Bn. to 32 Bn., Manipur. While the
petitioner was posted at 32 Bn., he had applied for HRA for his
previous place of posting and sanction order was issued on
21.2.2019. After finding that the said sanction order was not in
consonance with the rules, it was stopped by the respondent
authorities. As far as the petitioner in W.P.(C) No.508 of 2020
is concerned, it is the say of the respondents that the petitioner
had vacated his GPRA on his own on 12.6.2019, whereas vide
signal dated 6.5.2019, he has been transferred from Dte. CG to
109 Bn. Since the petitioner had vacated his GPRA within the
retention period of three years, he is not eligible to claim HRA.
21.
The respondents urged that since the petitioners
are posted at duty battalion whose notional headquarters are
situated outside the State of Manipur and HRA being
headquarter based allowance, the petitioners are not entitled to
claim for HRA. Even if the argument of the petitioners qua claim
of HRA is considered on the ground of being posted at nonfamily station i.e. Manipur, since both the petitioners are
provided with GPRA, they are not entitled to claim HRA at the
present place of posting. Further, even if the petitioners are
WP(C) No. 243 of 2020 and WP(C) No. 508 of 2020
P a g e | 18
entitled to claim for HRA or additional HRA for their previous
place of posting, they ought to have claimed the HRA or
additional HRA within the retention period of three years and,
as such, violated the eligibility criteria to claim HRA or additional
HRA.
22.
As could be seen from the records, in the case of
the petitioner in W.P.(C) No.508 of 2020, a sanction order was
issued by the DIG (Adm) Dte according sanction to the
petitioner for drawal of HRA at the rate applicable in X Class
cities i.e. 24% of basic pay with effect from 13.6.2019. On a
perusal of the pleadings, it is clear that pending writ petition, the
petitioner was again transferred to M&N Sector headquarters
from 109 Bn. vide order dated 13.7.2021 with effect from
13.9.2021 and he has been taken on the strength of Manipur
and Nagaland Sector headquarters. On 27.9.2021, the
petitioner in W.P.(C) No.508 of 2020 had also submitted his
application for sanction of HRA for his last place of posting i.e.
Delhi mentioning that the headquarter is now situated in NE only
and, therefore, he is entitled for HRA of last place of posting.
This has not been refuted by the respondents. In fact, as could
be seen from the records, vide letter dated 21.10.2021, the
petitioner in W.P.(C) No.508 of 20202 has been informed that
WP(C) No. 243 of 2020 and WP(C) No. 508 of 2020
P a g e | 19
he was not drawing HRA at old station. Hence, the last station
HRA amount is not known and, therefore, the fixed amount of
HRA of last station under NE provisions could not be sanctioned
to him. It was also informed that when his HRA at last place of
posting i.e. 109 Bn. is drawn, he may submit his claim for
drawing old station headquarter HRA in this headquarter for
sanction.
23.
At this juncture, it is pertinent to note that the
respondent authorities adopted two yardsticks for drawing the
entitled HRA in the case of the petitioner in W.P.(C) No.508 of
2020. Earlier, the department had refused the HRA of the
petitioner on the ground that the headquarter of him is situated
outside NE. Now the petitioner has been posted to M&N Sector
headquarter which is located in NE, the M&N Sector has raised
an objection that only on drawal of HRA at 109 Bn., his
subsequent drawal will be considered. The aforesaid objection
raised by the respondent authorities is arbitrary in nature for the
simple reason that the respondent authorities without applying
their mind have come to such conclusion.
24.
As far as the claim of the petitioner in W.P.(C)
No.508 of 2020 for sanction and drawal of HRA at 109 Bn. is
WP(C) No. 243 of 2020 and WP(C) No. 508 of 2020
P a g e | 20
concerned, while the petitioner was posted at DG, CGO, New
Delhi, a Government quarters was allotted to him where he
resided from 16.10.2014 to 12.6.2019 and had vacated the said
quarters on transfer to 109 Bn. and shifted his family to a rented
accommodation at Delhi.
Accordingly, he was issued with
sanction order vide order dated 3.7.2019 for drawing HRA with
effect from 13.6.2019.
On reporting at 109 Bn., when the
petitioner requested for sanction of HRA of his last place of
posting, the Commandant, 109 Bn. had also issued sanction
order on 3.9.2019 for drawing HRA and a copy of the sanction
order forwarded to DG, CGO for drawal of arrear HRA.
However, vide impugned letter dated 27.2.2020, the DG, CRPF,
New Delhi returned the claim by stating as under:
“A clarification on the subject was sought
from DIG (Adm) Dte., in reply, DIG (Adm)
Dte, vide their ION No.H.III.1/2019-20/DAIV dated 12/1/2020 has intimated that no
such orders so far received from GoI/MHA
to grant of HRA to the personnel posted in
unit deployed in NE region and kept their
family at last place of posting without linking
his notional headquarter i.e. Group Centre.
As and when it has been received from
GoI/MHA, the same will be provided. Copy
WP(C) No. 243 of 2020 and WP(C) No. 508 of 2020
P a g e | 21
of this letter is enclosed herewith for your
further needful.
Hence, HRA sanction
order in respect of Shri Vinod Sawant, D/C
(IRLA-7171) of your unit is returned
herewith.
Officer
may
be
informed
accordingly.”
25.
The Office Memorandum dated 22.1.2019 issued
by the Ministry of Home Affairs, Government of India, provides
as under:
“The undersigned is directed to say that a
proposal
for
grant
of
HRA
of
Old
Station/Selected Place of Residence, in
addition to the HRA admissible at the new
place of posting, to CAPF personnel on their
transfer to non-family locations, viz., North
Eastern
Region,
Sikkim,
Andaman
&
Nicobar Islands, Lakshadweep Islands,
State of Jammu & Kashmir and Left Wing
Extremist (LWE) areas, in the event of their
vacation of Government accommodation
retained by them after three years, as per
Ministry of Housing & Urban Affairs OM
No.12035/4/2015-Pol.II dated 14.11.2017
and 01.08.2018, till they remain posted in
such non-family stations, was examined in
this Ministry in consultation with Ministry of
WP(C) No. 243 of 2020 and WP(C) No. 508 of 2020
P a g e | 22
Finance (Department of Expenditure), and
it has agreed to:(i) allow HRA, on vacation of the
Government
accommodation
by
families of CAPF personnel after 3
years retention period, who are posted
in non-family stations/locations (as
defined by M/o Housing & Urban
Affairs in their OM dated 01/08/2018),
in addition to the HRA admissible at the
new place of posting.
(ii) relax the mandatory provision of
keeping families of CAPF personnel at
last place of posting for allowing HRA
at the rate of Selected Place of
Residence.
2. This issues with the approval of Ministry
of Finance (Department of Expenditure),
vide their ID No.28/2/2018-E.II(B) dated
18.01.2019 and as vetted by integrated
Finance Division of this Ministry vide their
Dy No.3437419 dated 22.01.2019.”
26.
The petitioner
in W.P.(C) No.508 of 2020
contended that the Government quarters was allotted to him
while he was at DG, CGO and he and his family members
WP(C) No. 243 of 2020 and WP(C) No. 508 of 2020
P a g e | 23
resided in the said quarters from 16.10.2014 to 12.06.2019 and
thereafter, vacated the said quarters and shifted his family to a
rented house at Delhi. Thus, as per the Office Memorandum
dated 22.1.2019, the petitioner in W.P.(C) No.508 of 2020 is
entitled to receive HRA along with additional HRA, as he has
been transferred to North Eastern region from DG, CGO, New
Delhi to 109 Bn., Manipur and also he had vacated the
Government quarters after three years retention in compliance
to the Office Memorandum dated 22.1.2019.
27.
Coming to the case of the petitioner in W.P.(C)
No.243 of 2020, the only contention of the respondents is that
the petitioner being posted in battalion in NE region is treated
as on tour and not eligible for NE concession as headquarter of
the battalion is Group Centre, Kathgodam which is located
outside NE region. The aforesaid contention of the respondents
cannot be appreciated for the reason that while granting the
concession the only criteria laid down by the Government is
posting of a person in NE region. The purpose to attract and
retain services of the person in NE region and the issue of
headquarter of a person is nowhere mentioned in the Office
Memorandum/Government Order.
WP(C) No. 243 of 2020 and WP(C) No. 508 of 2020
P a g e | 24
28.
Admittedly, the petitioner in W.P.(C) No.243 of
2020 is not on tour as he was posted to 32 Bn., Lokatak,
Manipur on transfer from 103 Bn., New Delhi. The CRPF
personnel are posted in a battalion for years and minimum
tenure has been laid down in the transfer policy. Therefore,
there is no question of treating such long tenure as on tour.
29.
The Commandant, 32 Bn. issued a sanction order
dated 21.2.2019 for the entitlement of the petitioner for drawal
of HRA and as per the sanction order dated 21.2.2019 and the
petitioner was drawing his HRA with his pay regularly with effect
from 15.2.2019 without any interruption till the month of March,
2020. However, in the month of April, 2020, the respondent
authorities without giving any prior notice or opportunity of
hearing cancelled the sanction order dated 21.2.2019 and
directed to recover a sum of Rs.27,827/- from the petitioner’s
pay and also ordered to stop HRA amount of Rs.22,584/-. After
knowing the stoppage of HRA and recovery, on 25.4.2020, the
petitioner has submitted a representation to the respondent
authorities and, admittedly, the said representation has not
been considered till date.
WP(C) No. 243 of 2020 and WP(C) No. 508 of 2020
P a g e | 25
30.
It is apposite to mention that the Ministry of
Finance, Department of Expenditure, issued an Office
Memorandum dated 14.8.2018 for grant of additional HRA to
the civilian employees of the Central Government serving in the
States of NE region, Andaman & Nicobar Island, Lakshadweep
Islands and Ladakh, which provides as under:
“(i) In case of civilian employees of Central
Government transferred to and posted from
a date prior to 01.07.2017 who leave their
families behind at the old duty station, the
HRA of the old duty station will be
calculated on the revised pay drawn on
01.07.2017 with percentage rates of HRA
effective on 01.07.2017 as per O.M.
No.2/5/2017-E.II(B) dated 07.07.2017.
(ii) In case of civilian employees of Central
Government transferred to an posted from
a date on or after 01.07.2017 who leave
their families behind at the old duty station,
the HRA of the old duty station will be
calculated on the revised pay drawn on the
date of transfer with the percentage rates of
HRA effective on the date of transfer.”
31.
Thus, as per the aforesaid Office Memorandum,
the petitioner in W.P.(C) No.243 of 2020 is entitled to receive
WP(C) No. 243 of 2020 and WP(C) No. 508 of 2020
P a g e | 26
the HRA along with additional HRA, as he has been transferred
to NE region from 103 Bn. Therefore, the stoppage of HRA to
the petitioner and recovery of HRA being paid to him from
16.2.2019 to March, 2020 is not appreciable and without
opportunity of hearing to the petitioner.
32.
Drawal of two HRAs by a Central Government
employee would be admissible even if the employee keeps their
family in the previous station on the own or rented house after
vacating the Government quarters due to transfer to NE region.
33.
It is not the case of the respondents that the
petitioners herein are still occupying the Government quarters
at the previous place of posting. The essential requirement for
applicability of the benefit of HRA to the employee is that the
family members of the employee must be residing with the
employee at the previous place of transfer before being sent to
NE region. It is not the case of the respondent authorities that
the family members of the petitioners have not resided with the
petitioners at the previous place of transfer before they have
been transferred to NE region.
The specific case of the
petitioners is that before the transfer, they resided with their
family members at the previous place.
WP(C) No. 243 of 2020 and WP(C) No. 508 of 2020
P a g e | 27
34.
The rationale behind grant of double HRA to
employees, who are posted to NE region or at Andaman and
Nicobar Islands is that on their posting to those difficult stations,
they are not expected to take their families along with them.
That is the reason why posting to these places is called difficult
posting, as it is not normally feasible to keep the families along
while working at such stations. In order to ensure that such
employees join these difficult stations, the benefit of HRA is
extended to their families as well, who are allowed to remain at
the last station of posting.
35.
It is not in dispute that the petitioners otherwise
fulfilled the conditions for grant of HRA. As stated supra and
also the circumstances in which the petitioners’ families could
not be expected to be at 32 Bn., Loktak, Manipur and 109 Bn.,
Imphal respectively, the petitioners are entitled to the benefit of
HRA.
36.
There is no dispute that most of the CRPF
battalions whose Group Centres are located in NE region are
deployed outside region. However, they are not allowed to NE
concessions though its affiliated Group Centres are located in
NE region.
As rightly argued by learned counsel for the
WP(C) No. 243 of 2020 and WP(C) No. 508 of 2020
P a g e | 28
petitioners, hundreds of thousands of CRPF personnel serving
in difficult areas leaving their family behind are deprived of the
concession granted by the Government only because of the
whimsical attitude and misinterpreting of the rules/orders of the
Government.
37.
It is settled law that grant of HRA under special
concession to NE region should also be treated on the same
line without restriction of the location of the headquarter.
38.
In W.P.(C) No.11083 of 2019 (Praveen Yadav and
others v. Union of India and others) with W.P.(C) No.3370 of
2020 (Gaurav Singh and others v. Union of India and others),
decided on 16.12.2022, a Division Bench of the Delhi High
Court held as under:
“16. The afore-noted commendation of the
Seventh Pay Commission acknowledging
the
services
of
uniformed
services
regarding HRA is highly appreciated. We
are also in consent with the view that they
are required to stay in the fields, far off from
all necessary amenities while leaving their
families behind. We, while holding the Chair
as the Judges of this Court as well as
normal civilians, respect their will power to
WP(C) No. 243 of 2020 and WP(C) No. 508 of 2020
P a g e | 29
stay away from their families. Interestingly
though the competent authority of Seventh
Pay Commission also recognized the lack
of proper compensation and need of paying
HRA to these employees, we fail to
understand why the Commission only
thought of giving parity to the PBORs of
CAPF at par with PBORs of Defence
Forces; while leaving behind the proposal of
extending the same benefit to the Coy
Commanders (officers of the level of
Assistant
Commandants/
Deputy
Commandants) under examination. It is a
strange anomaly which is sought to be
corrected in this petition.
17. Even in the counter affidavit filed on
behalf of respondents and during the
course of arguments, no such submission
was made by learned CGSC appearing on
behalf of respondents that the proposal of
extending the same benefit to the Coy
Commanders/ Officers of Group A was
under consideration. To the contrary, the
stand of respondents is that the impugned
Signal has been passed in compliance of
the recommendations of the Seventh Pay
Commission. We are unable to find any
reason as to why officers belonging to the
rank of Officers / Coy Commanders or
WP(C) No. 243 of 2020 and WP(C) No. 508 of 2020
P a g e | 30
PBROs, should not be granted similar
benefit more so as the factum of their
serving at far off locations has been
recognized and it cannot be differentiated
on cadre basis. We fail to understand why
such policy decisions discriminating within
the force should be permitted to continue,
especially to the officers of the force who
spend their lives serving the nation.
18. We have gone through the decision in
Supreme Court in Prem Chand (Supra)
relied upon by the petitioners and find that
the said case relates to benefits of
flexibilities in imports given to Export
Houses and though the facts of the case are
distinguishable and not applicable to the
present case, however, there is no dispute
qua the settled position that the right to
equality
guaranteed
under
Article
ensures equality amongst equals and its
aim is to protect persons- similarly placed
against discriminatory treatment. We have
also gone through the decision of this Court
in Govind Kumar Srivastava (Supra) relied
upon by the petitioners, which pertains to
grant of pro-rata pension only to the
Commissioned Officers of the Defence
Services and not to non-Commissioned
Officers/ PBORs and this Court held that
WP(C) No. 243 of 2020 and WP(C) No. 508 of 2020
P a g e | 31
such denial of pro-rata pension to them is
violative of Article 14 of the Constitution. In
Dev Sharma (Supra) this Court while
dealing with the case of retirement age of
members of the Central and Allied Forces
held that element of discrimination of
retirement age must be done away with.
19. Applying the ratio of law settled in
various decisions to these petitions, we find
that respondents cannot be permitted to
take discriminatory view for personnel of
different forces deployed in common areas
for grant of HRA. Accordingly, the Signal
dated 15.03.2018 and letter 22.03.2018,
rejecting petitioners’ request for grant of
HRA, are hereby set aside. The impugned
Office Memorandum No. II-270 12/35/CF3396486/20
17-PF-I dated
31.07.2017
issued by the Government of India, Ministry
of Home Affair, Police-II Division (PF-I
Desk) and the Signal No. P.I-1I2017 dated
08.09.2017 in respect of Seventh Pay
Commission issued by the DIG (Adm) Dte.
CRPF, are hereby partly set aside with
direction to the respondents that the benefit
of HRA shall not be confined to only PBORs
but shall be extended to all the personnel of
the Forces irrespective of their rank, as per
their entitlement. Further, respondents are
WP(C) No. 243 of 2020 and WP(C) No. 508 of 2020
P a g e | 32
directed to take necessary steps within six
weeks of this judgment, in consultation with
the Ministry of Home Affairs as well as
Ministry of Finance, to grant benefit of HRA
to the petitioners and similarly situate
personnel w.e.f. passing of this judgment.
20. In view of the above, these petitions are
accordingly disposed of.”
39.
The ratio propounded by the Division Bench of the
Delhi High Court squarely applies to the case on hand. The
benefit of HRA is for the welfare of the families of the employees
who are posted in the difficult stations like NE region etc. Those
Central Government employees, particularly the civilians, who
on their transfer to the notified region keep their families at the
previous place of posting in a rented or own accommodation
after vacating the Government quarters which they were
occupying and had to vacate after transfer shall be entitled to
the benefit of the HRA/additional HRA.
40.
The purpose and object of granting the benefit of
HRA is to reward the persons who are posted in the NE region.
When the basis for granting HRA to the employees posted in
NE region is provided, this Court fails to understand why the
WP(C) No. 243 of 2020 and WP(C) No. 508 of 2020
P a g e | 33
respondents are denying the benefit of HRA to the petitioners,
who were posted in NE region.
41.
In Director General, CRPF and others v.
Janardan Singh and others, (2018) 7 SCC 656, the Hon’ble
Supreme Court held:
“23. The classification as made in the
Government Order dated 31.3.21987 does
not pass the twin test as noted above. The
Government having itself realised the error
has corrected the same by the Government
Order dated 3.8.2005 permitted the special
(duty) allowance to all who are posted and
serving in North-East region irrespective of
the facts as whether their headquarters are
within the North-Eastern Region or outside
the North-Eastern region.”
42.
Thus, it is clear from the above decision of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court that there is no intelligible differentia
between two classes of employees posted and serving in the
NE region. The policy of law as is clear from the Government
notification is that the Government came with a scheme of
special (duty) allowance with the object and purpose of
encouraging, attracting and retaining the services of the officers
WP(C) No. 243 of 2020 and WP(C) No. 508 of 2020
P a g e | 34
in the NE region.
The two categories, namely (i) whose
headquarters are within NE region and (ii) whose headquarters
are outside the NE region clearly indicate that classification is
not founded on any intelligible differentia.
43.
Nowhere in Chapter-XV of FR-SR Part-IV it is
mentioned that HRA is a headquarter based allowance. While
issuing the impugned order, the respondent authorities have not
stated anything about the specific rule that HRA is a
headquarter based allowance.
Further, there is no such
detachment of headquarter or notional headquarter in any rules
or Government Orders granting HRA to Government servants
posted in NE region.
44.
For the foregoing discussions, this Court is of the
considered view that the petitioners have established their case
and also the petitioners are still keeping their families at the last
places of posting and since they were posted in NE region, the
petitioners are entitled to HRA of last place of posting.
However, without applying the mind and affording any
opportunity of hearing before stopping the payment of HRA, the
respondent authorities have issued the impugned orders, which
are arbitrary and, therefore, the same are liable to be set aside.
WP(C) No. 243 of 2020 and WP(C) No. 508 of 2020
P a g e | 35
45.
In the result,
(i)
W.P.(C) No.243 of 2020 and W.P.(C)
No.508 of 2020 are allowed.
(ii)
The order dated 27.2.2020 issued by the
respondent authorities in W.P.(C) No.508
of 2020 and the stoppage of HRA granted
to the petitioner in W.P.(C) No.243 of 2020
are set aside.
(iii)
The respondent authorities are directed to
release the entitled HRA to the petitioner in
W.P.(C) No.508 of 2020 with effect from
13.8.2019 in terms of sanction order dated
3.9.2019 issued by the Commandant, 109
Bn., CRPF, Mongsangai, Imphal West,
Manipur.
(iv)
Similarly, the respondent authorities are
directed to release the HRA to the
petitioner in W.P.(C) No.243 of 2020 in
terms
of
the
sanction
order
dated
21.2.2019 issued by the Commandant, 32
Bn., CRPF, Loktak, Manipur with effect
from April, 2020.
WP(C) No. 243 of 2020 and WP(C) No. 508 of 2020
P a g e | 36
(v)
The respondent authorities are directed to
refund the recovery of HRA, if any made,
to the petitioners within a period of four
weeks from the date of receipt of a copy of
this order.
(vi)
There will be no order as to costs.
JUDGE
FR/NFR
Sushil
WP(C) No. 243 of 2020 and WP(C) No. 508 of 2020
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review