Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1NC: 2026:KHC-D:786
RSA No. 265 of 2006
C/W RSA.CROB No. 100002 of 2024
HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA,AT DHARWAD
DATED THIS THE 22ND DAY OF JANUARY, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE C M JOSHI
REGULAR SECOND APPEAL NO. 265 OF 2006 (DEC/INJ)
C/W
RSA CROSS OBJ NO. 100002 OF 2024
IN RSA NO. 265/2006:
BETWEEN:
SHRI VEERABHADRA PARAGOUDA PATIL,
SINCE DECEASED BY HIS LRS.
1(a) SMT. NIRMALA W/O. VEERABHADRA PATIL,
AGED ABOUT 66 YEARS,
OCC. HOUSEHOLD WORK,
R/O. IIIRD CROSS, GANDHI NAGAR,
GHATAPRABHA, TQ. GOKAK,
DIST. BELGAUM.
Digitally signed
by NAGARATHNA
TEKAL
SUBBARAO
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
1(b) HALASIDDA S/O. VEERABHADRA PATIL,
AGED ABOUT 47 YEARS, OCC. DOCTOR,
R/O. IIIRD CROSS, GANDHI NAGAR,
GHATAPRABHA, TQ. GOKAK,
DIST. BELGAUM.
1(c)
SIDAGOUDA S/O. VEERABHADRA PATIL,
AGED ABOUT 45 YEARS,
OCC. DOCTOR,
R/O. IIIRD CROSS, GANDHI NAGAR,
GHATAPRABHA, TQ. GOKAK,
DIST. BELGAUM.
...APPELLANTS
-2NC: 2026:KHC-D:786
RSA No. 265 of 2006
C/W RSA.CROB No. 100002 of 2024
HC-KAR
(BY SRI B S KAMATE, ADVOCATE)
AND:
1.
SIDRAM DUNDAPPA DANDIN,
SINCE DECEASED BY HIS LRS.
1(a).
SMT. SHIVALEELA,
W/O. LAKKAPPA VANTAMURI,
AGED ABOUT 45 YEARS,
OCC. HOUSEHOLD WORK,
R/O. BASTWAD, TQ. HUKERI,
DIST. BELAGAVI.
1(b).
SRI DUNU SIDRAM DANDIN,
AGED ABOUT 41 YEARS,
OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O. HOLI ONI, GHODGARI,
TQ. HUKERI, DIST. BELAGAVI.
2.
THE MANAGING DIRECTOR,
HIRANYAKESHI SAHAKARI SAKKARE
KARKHANE NIYAMIT,
SANKESHWAR-591 313,
TQ; HUKKERI,DIST;BELGAUM.
3.
SMT. BHAGIRATI,
W/O PARAGOUDA PATIL,
SINCE DECEASED BY HER LRS.
APPELLANTS AND RESP.NO. 4 TO 9.
4.
SMT SHRINGAREWWA W/O IRAPPA GULL,
SINCE DECEASED BY LRS.
4(a).
UMESH I. GULL,
SINCE DECEASED BY LRS.
1(a)(i). MALATI W/O. UMESH GULL,
AGE NOT KNOWN,
OCC. HOUSEHOLD,
-3NC: 2026:KHC-D:786
RSA No. 265 of 2006
C/W RSA.CROB No. 100002 of 2024
HC-KAR
R/O. 2454, MARKET ROAD,
ATHANI-591 304, DIST. BELGAUM.
1(a)(ii). HARISHA S/O. UMESH GULL,
AGE NOT KNOWN, OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O. 2454, MARKET ROAD,
ATHANI-591 304, DIST. BELGAUM.
4(b).
4(c).
RAMESH I. GULL,
AGED ABOUT 42 YEARS,
OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O. 2454, MARKET ROAD,
ATHANI-591304, DIST. BELGAUM.
NIRMALA W/O. VEERABHADRA PATIL,
AGED MAJOR,
OCC. HOUSEHOLD,
R/O. J.G. HOSPITAL, GHATAPRABHA-591 321.
TQ. GOKAK, DIST. BELGAUM.
4(d).
SHASHIKALA,
W/O. SHIVALING TORLI,
AGED ABOUT 48 YEARS,
R/O. C/O. I.C. NAGATHANA,
PANCHASEELA, GURU KRUPA ROAD,
BIJAPUR.
4(e).
SMT. VANITA MOHAN TADAKASE,
AGED ABOUT 46 YEARS,
R/O. C/O. MOHAN C. TADAKASE,
58/B, SAMRAT HOUSING SOCIETY,
SOLHAPUR-413 002.
4(f).
RAJESHWARI MAHESH VIJAPURE,
AGED ABOUT 40 YEARS,
SHOP NO.386, EAST MANGALAWAR PETH,
SOLHAPUR-413 002.
5.
SMT. SHANTA BHIMARAO SHIVANNAVAR,
AGED ABOUT 64 YEARS,
OCC:HOUSEHOLD WORK,
R/O C/O DR RAJENDRA SHIVANNAVAR,
-4NC: 2026:KHC-D:786
RSA No. 265 of 2006
C/W RSA.CROB No. 100002 of 2024
HC-KAR
SHIVANNAVAR'S UROLOGY HOSPITAL,
OPP: AMBEDKAR GARDEN, AMBEDKAR ROAD,
MIRAJ 416 410, DIST:SANGLI.
6.
SMT. PREMA W/O SHIVAKANT GOUDAPPAGOL,
AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS,
OCC:HOUSEHOLD WORK,
R/O NEAR BASAVA TEMPLE,
M.MALLAPUR-591 307, TQ:GOKAK,
DIST:BELGAUM.
7.
SMT. LALITA W/O KASHIRAO PARVATRAO,
AGED ABOUT 56 YEARS,
OCC:HOUSEHOLD WORK,
R/O BASAV COLONY, BEHIND KLE HOSPITAL,
BAUXITE ROAD, BELGAUM-590 001.
8.
SMT. GOURADEVI,
W/O LAXMAN HALLUR,
AGED ABOUT 53 YEARS,
OCC:HOUSEHOLD WORK,
R/AT KAMAT BUILDING, YOGIKOL ROAD,
GOKAK-591 307, DIST:BELGAUM.
9.
SMT. UMA, W/O BALCHANDRA GULL,
AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS,
OCC:HOUSEHOLD WORK,
R/AT SHANKAR NAGAR, NEAR BUS STAND,
ATHANI 591 304, DIST:BELGAUM.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI SHIVARAJ P MUDHOL, ADVOCATE FOR R1 (a) AND
R1(b);
SRI JAGADISH PATIL, ADVOCATE FOR R2(NOC);
SRI RAVI S. BALIKAI, ADVOCATE FOR R4(b to f);
SRI MAHANTESH R. PATIL, ADVOCATE FOR R6 TO R9;
R5- SERVED;
R4(a) (i)-HELD SUFFICIENT;
R4(a) (ii)-HELD SUFFICIENT)
-5NC: 2026:KHC-D:786
RSA No. 265 of 2006
C/W RSA.CROB No. 100002 of 2024
HC-KAR
THIS RSA IS FILED UNDER SECTION 100 OF CPC, AGAINST
THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED 16.11.2005 PASSED IN
R.A.NO.4/2003 ON THE FILE OF THE I ADDL. DISTRICT JUDGE,
BELGAUM, PARTLY ALLOWING THE APPEAL AND MODIFYING THE
JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED 25.10.2002 PASSED IN
O.S.NO.85/1997 ON THE FILE OF THE CIVIL JUDGE (SR.DN.)
HUKKERI.
IN RSA CROB. NO.100002/2024:
BETWEEN:
SRI. SIDRAM S/O. DUNDAPPA DANDIN
SINCE DECEASED BY HIS LRS
SHIVALEELA @ LAXMI
W/O LAKKAPPA VANTAMURI,
AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS,
OCC: HOUSEHOLD WORK,
R/O. BASTWAD, TALUK: HUKKERI,
DIST: BELAGAVI, PIN: 591 309.
SRI DUNDANAGOUDA,
S/O. SIDRAM DANDIN @ PATIL,
AGED ABOUT 45 YEARS,
OCC: AGRICULTURE,
R/O. HOLI ONI, GHODAGERI,
TQ. HUKKERI, DIST: BELAGAVI,
PIN: 591107.
…CROSS OBJECTORS
(BY SRI SHIVARAJ P MUDHOL, ADVOCATE)
AND:
VEERABHADRA S/O PARAGOUDA PATIL,
SINCE DIED REP. BY HIS LRS.
1.
NIRMALA W/O VEERABHADRA PATIL,
-6NC: 2026:KHC-D:786
RSA No. 265 of 2006
C/W RSA.CROB No. 100002 of 2024
HC-KAR
AGED ABOUT 66 YEARS,
OCC: HOUSEHOLD WORK,
R/O. III RD CROSS, GANDHI NAGAR,
GHATAPRABHA, TALUK: GOKAK,
DIST: BELAGAVI, PIN-591 306.
2.
HALASIDDA S/O. VEERABHADRA PATIL
AGED ABOUT 47 YEARS, OCC: DOCTOR,
R/O. IIIRD CROSS, GANDHI NAGAR
GHATAPRABHA, TQ. GOKAK,
DIST. BELAGAVI, PIN-591 306.
3.
SIDAGOUDA S/O. VEERABHADRA PATIL,
AGED ABOUT 45 YEARS,
OCC. DOCTOR,
R/O. IIIRD CROSS, GANDHI NAGAR,
GHATAPRABHA, TQ. GOKAK,
DIST. BELAGAVI, PIN-591 306.
4.
THE MANAGING DIRECTOR,
HIRANYAKESHI SAHAKARI SAKKARE
KARKHANE NIYAMIT SANKESHWAR,
TQ. HUKKERI, DIST: BELAGAVI,
PIN:591 313.
SMT. BHAGIRATI W/O. PARAGOUDA PATIL,
(SINCE DIED THE LRS ALREADY ON RECORD
RESPONDENT NO.1 AND 2 AND 4 TO 9)
SMT. SHRINGAREWWA W/O. IRAPPA GULL
SINCE DECEASED BY LRS
5.
UMESH S/O. IRAPPA GULL,
AGED ABOUT 44 YEARS,
OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O. 2454 MARKET ROAD, ATHANI
TQ. ATHANI, DIST., BELAGAVI-591 304.
(SINCE DIED REP. BY HIS LRS)
5(a). MALATI W/O. UMESH GULL,
AGED MAJOR,
-7NC: 2026:KHC-D:786
RSA No. 265 of 2006
C/W RSA.CROB No. 100002 of 2024
HC-KAR
OCC. HOUSEHOLD WORK,
R/O. 2454, MARKET ROAD, ATHANI,
TQ. ATHANI, DIST. BELAGAVI-591 304.
5(b). HARISH S/O. UMESH GULL,
AGED MAJOR, OCC: ARICULTURE,
R/O: 2454, MARKET ROAD, ATHANI,
TALUK: ATHANI, DIST: BELAGAVI-591 304.
6.
RAMESH S/O. IRAPPA GULL,
AGED MAJOR, OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O. 2454, MARKET ROAD, ATHANI
TQ. ATHANI, DIST. BELAGAVI-591 304.
7.
NIRMALA W/O. VEERABHADRA PATIL,
AGED MAJOR, OCC. HOUSEHOLD WORK,
R/O. J.G. HOSPITAL GHATAPRABHA,
TQ. GOKAK, DIST. BELAGAVI-591 321.
8.
SHASHIKALA W/O. SHIVALING TORLI,
AGED ABOUT 48 YEARS,
OCC: HOUSEHOLD WORK,
R/O. C/O: I.C. NAGATHANA,
PANCHASEELA, GURU KRUPA ROAD,
VIJAYAPUR, TQ: VIJAYAPUR,
DIST.: VIJAYAPUR.
9.
VANITA W/O. MOHAN TADAKASE,
AGED ABOUT 46 YEARS,
OCC. HOUSEHOLD WORK,
R/O. C/O. SAMRAT HOUSING SOCIETY,
SOLAPUR- 413 002.
10.
RAJESHWARI W/O: MAHESH VIJAPURE,
AGED ABOUT 40 YEARS,
OCC: HOUSEHOLD WORK,
R/O. SHOP NO. 386 EAST,
MANGALWAR PETH, SOLAPUR- 413 002.
11.
SMT. SHANTA W/O. BHIMARAO SHIVANNAVAR,
AGED ABOUT 64 YEARS,
-8NC: 2026:KHC-D:786
RSA No. 265 of 2006
C/W RSA.CROB No. 100002 of 2024
HC-KAR
OCC. HOUSEHOLD WORK,
R/O. C/O: RAJENDRA SHIVANNAVAR,
SHIVANNAVAR UROLOGY HOSPITAL,
OPP. AMBEDKAR GARDEN,
AMBEDKAR ROAD, MIRAJ-416 410.
12.
SMT. PREMA W/O. SHIVAKANT GOUDAPPAGOL,
AGED ABOUT 67 YEARS,
OCC. HOUSEHOLD WORK,
R/O. NEAR BASAVA TEMPLE M. MALLAPUR,
TQ. GOKAK, DIST. BELAGAVI.
13.
SMT. LALITA W/O. KASHIRAO PARVATRAO,
AGED ABOUT 56 YEARS,
OCC. HOUSEHOLD WORK,
R/O. BASAV COLONY BEHIND KLE HOSPITAL
BAUXITE ROAD, BELAGAVI-590 001.
14.
SMT. GOURADEVI W/O. LAXMAN HULLER,
AGED ABOUT 63 YEARS,
OCC. HOUSEHOLD WORK,
R/O. KAMAT BUILDING,
YOGIKOLLA ROAD, GOKAK, TQ. GOKAK,
DIST. BELAGAVI-591 307.
15.
SMT. UMA W/O. BALACHANDRA GULL,
AGED ABOUT 60 YEARS,
OCC. HOUSEHOLD WORK,
R/O. SHANKAR NAGAR,
NEAR BUS STAND, ATHANI,
TQ. ATHANI, DIST. BELAGAVI-591 304.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI B S KAMATE, ADVOCATE FOR R-1 TO R-3;
SRI GANGADHAR J.M., ADVOCATE AND
SRI SHARANABASAVARAJ C, ADVOCATE FOR R4;
SRI MAHANTESH R. PATIL, ADVOCATE FOR R12 TO R15;
SRI RAVI S. BALIKAI, ADVOCATE FOR R9;
R6, R7, R8, R10, R11-SERVED;
R5(a), R5(b)-HELD SUFFICIENT)
-9NC: 2026:KHC-D:786
RSA No. 265 of 2006
C/W RSA.CROB No. 100002 of 2024
HC-KAR
THIS RSA CROB IS FILED UNDER ORDER 41 RULE 22 OF
CPC, PRAYING TO CALL FOR RECORDS AND TO SET ASIDE
/MODIFIED THE IMPUGNED JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED
16.11.2005 IN REGULAR APPEAL NO.04/2003 PASSED BY THE I
ADDITIONAL DISTRICT JUDGE BELAGAVI IN RESPECT OF ITEM
NO.1 AND 2 IN THE SUIT SCHEDULE PROPERTY I.E LAND
BEARING SY.NO.21/1 MEASURING 1 ACRE 14 GUNTAS AND
LAND BEARING SY.NO.21/2 MEASURING 2 ACRE 14 GUNTAS,
AND SET ASIDE THE JUDGMENTS AND DECREE DATED
25.10.2002 PASSED BY THE CIVIL JUDGE (SR. DN.) HUKKERI IN
O.S.NO.85/1997 BY ALLOWING THIS CROSS OBJECTION IN THE
INTEREST OF JUSTICE AND EQUITY.
THIS RSA AND RSA CROSS OBJECTION HAVING BEEN
HEARD AND RESERVED ON 30.10.2025, COMING ON FOR
PRONOUNCEMENT OF JUDGMENT THIS DAY AT BENGALURU
BENCH, COURT DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
CAV JUDGMENT
(PER: THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE C M JOSHI)
1.
The plaintiff in OS No. 85/1997 before the Civil
Judge (Sr. Dvn.), Hukkeri, is before this Court in RSA
No.265/2006 assailing
the judgment in RA No.4/2003
dated 16.11.2005 by learned I Additional District
Judge,
Belgaum, which partly allowed the appeal and decreed the
suit in respect of two of the suit schedule properties only
- 10 NC: 2026:KHC-D:786
RSA No. 265 of 2006
C/W RSA.CROB No. 100002 of 2024
HC-KAR
and Legal Representatives of defendant No.1 are before
this Court in RSA Cross Objection No.100002/2024.
2.
The factual matrix of the case as may be found
from the pleadings, may be summarized as below:
A. The plaintiff, Veerabhadra Paragouda Patil, filed
suit before the Senior Civil Judge of Hukkeri,
seeking
declaration of title and consequential relief of injunction
against the defendants. The suit schedule properties are as
below:
Description of the Suit Property:
Agricultural
lands
situated
within
the
limits
of
Ghodageri village in Hukkeri taluka, bearing:SL.No. R.S.No.
1.
2.
21/1
21/2
3.
4.
Extent AGs
1-14
2-14
-0-02
PK
2-12
2-37
-0-01 PK
2-36
2-27
-0-14 PK
2-13
Total
Assessment
Rs. Ps.
06=76
11=90
Market
Value Rs.
10,000/20,000/-
11=92
25,000/-
Half
Share
13=66
44=24
25,000/-
80,000/-
- 11 NC: 2026:KHC-D:786
RSA No. 265 of 2006
C/W RSA.CROB No. 100002 of 2024
HC-KAR
B.
It is the case of the plaintiff that he is the son of
one Paragouda, who died on 29.07.1974 at Ghodageri
village in Hukkeri Taluka. Paragouda had two sons and six
daughters, who are the plaintiff and defendant Nos. 1, 3 to
9. Said Paragouda had two wives i. e., Shivavva and
Bhagirathi. He had married Bhagirathi after the death of
Shivavva. Defendant No.1 had gone in adoption to one
Dundappa Dandin of Ghodageri long back. Since the date of
adoption, defendant No.1 had severed all his ties with the
genital family and he was considered as adopted son of the
said Dundappa Dandin. He was managing the family affairs
of his family and the suit schedule properties were owned
by the adopted father of the defendant No. 1. The suit
schedule properties mentioned at Sl.Nos. 1, 2 and 4 were
owned by defendant No.1 and he had gifted the properties
at Sl.Nos. 1 and 2 completely and half share in the property
at Sl. No. 4 i. e., R.S. No. 518 in favour of the plaintiff
under a registered Gift Deed. As per the Gift Deed, the
name of the plaintiff came to be entered in the record of
- 12 NC: 2026:KHC-D:786
RSA No. 265 of 2006
C/W RSA.CROB No. 100002 of 2024
HC-KAR
rights of the properties at Sl.Nos. 1, 2 and to the extent of
half share in the property at Sl.No. 4. Since then he is
using, cultivating and enjoying the said property.
C.
So far as the property at Sl.No. 3 i.e., R.S. No.
653 of Ghodageri, is concerned,
it was owned by the
adopted father of defendant No. 1 Dundappa Dandin and he
had gifted half portion of the same to the elder sister of the
present plaintiff i. e., Shringarewwa. Accordingly, her name
came to be entered in the revenue records in respect of the
said half share. After coming into force of the Land Reforms
Act, the father of the plaintiff, Paragouda had filed Form
No.7 for grant of occupancy rights in respect of the said
property.
The
Land
Tribunal,
Hukkeri,
granted
the
occupancy rights in favour of the father of the plaintiff. The
plaintiff has succeeded to the said property and therefore, it
is the case of the plaintiff that he is the absolute owner in
respect of the suit schedule properties.
- 13 NC: 2026:KHC-D:786
RSA No. 265 of 2006
C/W RSA.CROB No. 100002 of 2024
HC-KAR
D.
While the plaintiff was in peaceful possession and
enjoyment of the suit schedule
properties, he had grown
sugar cane crop and had invested huge amount for the
same.
Defendant
No.
taking
undue
advantage
of
appearance of his name in the property extract of Sl.Nos.3
and 4 properties i.e., R.S. Nos. 653 and 518 to the extent
of half share, he illegally and unauthorisedly
tried to get
the amount from the sugar factory in respect of those
properties as well as the R.S. No. 21/1 and 21/2
i.e.,
Sl.Nos.1 and 2 of schedule properties. After coming to know
this fact, plaintiff had made several representations to the
defendant No.2 Sugar Factory, requesting it not to make
any payment to anybody other than the plaintiff and
therefore, the correspondence made by the plaintiff though
were acknowledged by
defendant No. 2, it didn't answer
the same. It is contended that the plaintiff was permitted to
cut the sugar cane crop in the properties and he was also
issued the necessary authorization by defendant No.2sugar factory. Therefore, it is contended that there was
- 14 NC: 2026:KHC-D:786
RSA No. 265 of 2006
C/W RSA.CROB No. 100002 of 2024
HC-KAR
obstruction
and
interference
by
defendant
No.1
and
defendant Nos. 3 to 9 for the possession and enjoyment of
the schedule property and as such, there was a necessity
for filing the present suit for declaration of his title and
consequential relief of injunction.
3.
On being served with the summons, defendant
No. 1 appeared and filed his written statement. Defendant
No.1 in the written statement
contended the following
aspects:
A.
Defendant No.1 admitted that the plaintiff and
defendant No. 1 were born to Paragouda and the said
Paragouda had died on 29.07.1974. He also admitted that
Paragouda had two sons and six daughters and that
defendant No. 1 had gone in adoption to one Dundappa
Dundin.
B. He contends that the deceased Paragouda acted as
guardian of the defendant as he was a natural father. He
denied that all ties of defendant No.1 were severed with the
- 15 NC: 2026:KHC-D:786
RSA No. 265 of 2006
C/W RSA.CROB No. 100002 of 2024
HC-KAR
original family. Defendant No.1 specifically denied that he
had gifted the suit schedule properties
i.e.,
the property
Nos. 1, 2 and 4 in favour of the plaintiff under a registered
Gift Deed. He contented that he never executed any Gift
Deed in favour of the plaintiff and has not conveyed any
right, title or interest to the plaintiff. He asserted his
possession and enjoyment over the schedule property.
C.
The other contentions of the plaintiff were denied
by defendant No.1. He contended that when the adoptive
father of defendant No.1 died, defendant No.1 was left in
the care and custody of his natural father Paragouda.
Defendant No.1 had never executed any documents in
favour of anybody and Paragouda died leaving behind him,
his second wife Bhagirathi and the plaintiff and the 6
daughters. Therefore, he contended that all of them have
inherited the properties left by deceased Paragouda and this
suit being for declaration they are also necessary parties to
the suit. Hence, he sought for dismissal of the suit.
- 16 NC: 2026:KHC-D:786
RSA No. 265 of 2006
C/W RSA.CROB No. 100002 of 2024
HC-KAR
4.
Defendant No.2 -Sugar Factory in its written
statement denied the plaint averments and stated that the
plaintiff be put to strict proof of the same. It was contended
that defendant No.2 is not a necessary party to the suit and
therefore, the suit be dismissed with compensatory costs.
5.
The contention of defendant No.1 that the suit is
bad for non-joinder of necessary parties was considered by
the trial Court as a preliminary issue and it held that the
daughters of Paragouda are also necessary parties. Hence,
they came to be impleaded as defendant Nos.3 to 9. The
defendant No.4 and defendant No.5 filed the written
statement supporting the contention of the plaintiff and
stated that they have relinquished their share in favour of
the plaintiff.
6.
On the basis of the above contentions, following
issues and additional issues were framed by the trial Court:
ISSUES
"1. Whether the Plaintiff proves that he is the
exclusive owner of the suit properties?
- 17 NC: 2026:KHC-D:786
RSA No. 265 of 2006
C/W RSA.CROB No. 100002 of 2024
HC-KAR
2. Whether the Plaintiff further proves that the
suit properties were in his lawful possession on
the date of suit and he has grown the crops
therein?
3. Whether the Plaintiff further proves that the
obstruction by the Defendant No.1?
4. Whether the Plaintiff further proves the cause
of action against the defendant No.2?
5. What decree or order?"
ADDITIONAL ISSUES:
Whether the Defendant No.1 proves that the
parties shown at para No.7 of the W.S. of D-1 are
necessary parties to the present suit?
7.
In support of the case of the plaintiff, plaintiff
was examined as PW1 and one witness was examined as
PW2. Exhibit P1 to Exhibit P45 were marked in evidence.
The defendants have not adduced any evidence before the
trial Court.
8.
After hearing the parties, the trial Court has
decreed the suit of the plaintiff declaring that the plaintiff is
- 18 NC: 2026:KHC-D:786
RSA No. 265 of 2006
C/W RSA.CROB No. 100002 of 2024
HC-KAR
the absolute owner of the suit schedule
properties and
defendant No.1 is liable to be restrained by an injunction.
Aggrieved by the same, defendant No.1 approached the
First Appellate Court in RA No.4/ 2003 and
after hearing
both the sides, the First Appellate Court framed following
points for consideration:
"1. Whether the finding of the trial court that the
Plaintiff is the exclusive owner of the suit properties is
sustainable?
2. Whether the finding of the trial court that the Plaintiff
is in lawful possession of the suit properties and has
grown crops therein is sustainable?
3. Whether the order of the trial court granting
declaration and permanent injunction as prayed by the
Plaintiff and direction to Defendant Nos.1 and 2 to pay
Rs.73,543/- to the Plaintiff is sustainable?
4. Whether the appeal deserves to be allowed?
5. If so what order?"
9.
After consideration, point Nos. 1 to 4 were partly
answered in the affirmative and allowed the appeal in part.
The First Appellate Court held that the properties at Sl.No.1
- 19 NC: 2026:KHC-D:786
RSA No. 265 of 2006
C/W RSA.CROB No. 100002 of 2024
HC-KAR
and 2 i.e., Sy.No.21/1 and 21/2 are of the ownership of the
plaintiff and restrained the defendants
from interfering in
respect of the enjoyment of those properties. However, it
dismissed the claim of the plaintiff in respect of R.S.Nos.653
and 518 which are at Item Nos. 3 and 4 of the suit
schedule.
10.
Aggrieved by the same, the plaintiff is before this
Court in RSA No.265/2006 and
legal representatives of
defendant No.1 is in RSA Cross Objection No.100002/2024.
11.
On issuance of notice, defendant No.1 has
appeared before this Court in the year 2009. During the
pendency of this appeal, respondent No.3 and respondent
No. 4 have died and their LRs are brought on record.
12.
Respondent No.1 has appeared on 17.11.2009.
The respondent No.1 also died during the pendency of this
appeal and his LRs are brought on record. The LRs of
defendant No.1/respondent No.1 herein have filed the cross
objection in the year 2024 in RSA Crob.No.100002/2024
- 20 NC: 2026:KHC-D:786
RSA No. 265 of 2006
C/W RSA.CROB No. 100002 of 2024
HC-KAR
along with an application for condonation of delay of 702
days. The said application for condonation of delay has been
opposed by the plaintiff.
13. Further, during pendency of this appeal, the
appellant has also filed an application under Order XLI Rule
No. 27 of CPC, seeking to produce the copy of the order of
the Land Tribunal which had granted the occupancy rights
in favour of Paragouda.
14.
After
hearing
the
learned
counsel
for
the
appellant on 08.06.2010, this Court admitted the appeal
and framed following substantial questions of law:
"1) Whether the lower Appellate Court is justified in
reversing the judgment and decree of the Trial
Court in respect of the properties bearing No. 653
and 518?
2) Whether the lower Appellate Court is justified in
dismissing the suit of the plaintiff in respect of
recovery of Rs.73,543/-?
- 21 NC: 2026:KHC-D:786
RSA No. 265 of 2006
C/W RSA.CROB No. 100002 of 2024
HC-KAR
3) Whether the lower Appellate Court is justified in
dismissing the suit insofar as the property at
Sl.No.3 is concerned?"
15.
In view of the above, this Court needs to
consider the application seeking production of the additional
evidence under Order XLI Rule 27 of CPC filed by the
appellant, the application for condonation of delay in filing
the cross objections by the LRs of the respondent No.1
along with the substantial questions of law framed as
above.
16.
The arguments by learned counsel appearing for
the appellant and the learned counsel for the respondents
were heard.
Re.IA for production of additional document:
Plaintiff has filed an application under Order XLI Rule
27 of CPC on 23.01.2006. The affidavit filed in support of
the application contends that the plea taken in the suit that
the Land Tribunal, Hukkeri had granted the occupancy
- 22 NC: 2026:KHC-D:786
RSA No. 265 of 2006
C/W RSA.CROB No. 100002 of 2024
HC-KAR
rights in favour of father of the plaintiff in respect of the suit
property at Sl.No.3 i.e. R.S. No. 653 was not disputed or
denied by
defendant No.1 in the written statement and
therefore, there was no question of producing the order of
the Land Tribunal before the trial Court. However, when the
appeal was filed by
defendant No.1, the First
Appellate
Court had recorded the findings that plaintiff has not placed
any piece of paper regarding the grant of occupancy rights
by the Land Tribunal. Therefore, in view of the said findings
of the First Appellate Court, it is necessary for him to
produce the additional evidence in this case and as such, he
may be permitted to produce the additional evidence.
17. The learned counsel appearing for the appellant
submits
that
when
there
was
no
specific
denial
by
defendant No. 1 in the written statement about the grant of
the occupancy rights by the Land Tribunal, there was no
question of producing the said document. However, the
First Appellate Court gave a finding that there is no material
produced to show the title of the plaintiff over the schedule
- 23 NC: 2026:KHC-D:786
RSA No. 265 of 2006
C/W RSA.CROB No. 100002 of 2024
HC-KAR
property, particularly, R.S. No.653 and therefore, it was
necessary for the plaintiff to produce it before this Court.
18.
It is pertinent to note that the plaintiff had
approached the Court seeking relief of title over the suit
schedule properties, of which, R.S. No. 653 was one among
them. The burden of proving title over Survey No. 653 was
on the plaintiff. Plaintiff had claimed half share in the said
property on the basis of the occupancy rights. It is his case
that R.S. No. 653 was owned by the father of defendant No.
1 Dundappa and he had gifted half of it in favour of
Shringarewwa and in turn, when it was in the hands of
Shringarewwa, the father of the plaintiff- who was also
none else than the father of Shringarewwa- filed Form No. 7
before the Land Tribunal and the Land Tribunal had granted
the occupancy rights in favour of Paragouda. Therefore, in
order to establish his title over the suit schedule property, it
was incumbent upon the plaintiff to produce the said
document at the time of the trial. It is not the case of the
plaintiff that he was not in possession of the said document.
- 24 NC: 2026:KHC-D:786
RSA No. 265 of 2006
C/W RSA.CROB No. 100002 of 2024
HC-KAR
It is pertinent to note that the said document is not a piece
of evidence which has come into existence after the appeal
is filed. The fact that defendant is claiming title over the suit
schedule property was known to him and it was incumbent
upon him to produce those documents. Even then the
plaintiff did not produce it. The written statement of
defendant No.1 clearly indicates that he has denied all the
plaint averments which assert title of the plaintiff over the
suit schedule properties. Therefore, the grounds contended
by the plaintiff in affidavit do not fall within the purview of
the requirements mentioned in Rule 27 of Order XLI of CPC.
19.
Here it is necessary to reproduce Order XLI Rule
27 of CPC which reads as below:
"27. Production of additional evidence in Appellate
Court.- (1) The parties to an appeal shall not be
entitled to produce additional evidence, whether oral
or documentary, in the Appellate Court. But if—
(a) the court from whose decree the appeal is
preferred has refused to admit evidence which ought
to have been admitted, or
- 25 NC: 2026:KHC-D:786
RSA No. 265 of 2006
C/W RSA.CROB No. 100002 of 2024
HC-KAR
(aa) the party seeking to produce additional
evidence, establishes that notwithstanding the
exercise of due diligence, such evidence was not
within his knowledge or could not, after the exercise
of due diligence, be produced by him at the time
when the decree appealed against was passed, or
(b) the Appellate Court requires any document to
be produced or any witness to be examined to enable
it to pronounce judgment, or for any other
substantial cause, the Appellate Court may allow
such evidence or document to be produced, or
witness to be examined.”
(2) Wherever additional evidence is allowed to be
produced by an Appellate Court, the Court shall record
the reason for its admission.”
20. Thus, from the bare perusal of the provisions of
Rule 27, it is clear that the grounds stated by the plaintiff in
the affidavit do not fall under any of the above clauses and
therefore, the application is unmerited. When the plaintiff
has approached the Court, it was his duty to produce all
material on record to show his title over the schedule
property. It is also relevant to note that though the plaintiff
claims half share in R.S. No. 653, which was allegedly gifted
to Shringarewwa by Dundappa Dandin, such Gift Deed is
not produced by the plaintiff. The document now sought to
- 26 NC: 2026:KHC-D:786
RSA No. 265 of 2006
C/W RSA.CROB No. 100002 of 2024
HC-KAR
be produced, which
is the order passed by the Land
Tribunal show that occupancy rights of entire Survey No.
653 has been granted to Paragouda. Therefore, the said
document do not fit in the pleadings of the plaintiff. Under
these circumstances, the application filed under Order LXI
Rule 27 of CPC is unmerited and as such, the same is liable
to be dismissed.
Re.IA
for
condonation
of
delay
in
filing
cross
objection
21.
Regarding the delay in filing the Cross objection
by cross objectors is concerned, the affidavit filed by the
cross objectors shows that his father Sidram Dandin had
appeared before the Court through his counsel. Sidram died
on 18.07.2015. Thereafter, the appellant had not taken any
steps within time to bring these cross objectors on record as
LRs of Sidram and the present appeal came to be abated.
When the LRs were brought on record, notice was issued to
the cross objectors and then they came to know about the
- 27 NC: 2026:KHC-D:786
RSA No. 265 of 2006
C/W RSA.CROB No. 100002 of 2024
HC-KAR
present appeal proceedings and then they engaged their
advocate in the year 2022, who advised them to file a cross
objections. It is contented that their cross objection is in
respect of the proof concerning the gift of R.S. No. 21/1 and
21/2, i.e., Item Nos.1 and 2 of the schedule properties. It
is their case that certified copy of the Gift Deed produced
by the plaintiff as per Exhibit P15 has not been proved and
therefore, they were advised to file the present cross
objection to canvass their contention. They contend that if
the application is dismissed, they will be put to irreparable
loss and injury.
22.
The
delay
application
is
opposed
appellant, Veerabhadra Paragouda Patil,
by
the
contending that
the notice of the RSA was served upon defendant No.1 in
the year 2006, but no cross-objection was filed by him. It is
contended that the present cross-objectors step into the
shoes of respondent No.1 and therefore, they cannot claim
any fresh right to file a cross-objection when they were
brought on record. It is contended that there is a lapse of
- 28 NC: 2026:KHC-D:786
RSA No. 265 of 2006
C/W RSA.CROB No. 100002 of 2024
HC-KAR
more than 18 years after filing of the second appeal and
therefore, the filing of the cross- objection at this juncture
is not sustainable in law. The fact remains that respondent
No.1/defendant No.1 had appeared before this Court in the
year 2009 as may be found from the records. He was
represented by the same counsel, who is now representing
the cross objectors. Obviously, defendant No.1 had not filed
any cross-objection concerning the Gift Deed. When the
present cross objectors have come on record in the year
2022 or 2024, obviously, they have stepped into the shoes
of
defendant No. 1. The limitation starts to run from the
date when the notice of the appeal was served upon
defendant No.1, but not on the cross objectors. The cross
objection/appeal
being
the
carrying
forward
of
the
contentions of defendant No.1 before the trial Court, it had
to be filed within limitation from the date of service of
notice of this appeal to defendant No.1. The present cross
objectors cannot claim any independent right and as such,
- 29 NC: 2026:KHC-D:786
RSA No. 265 of 2006
C/W RSA.CROB No. 100002 of 2024
HC-KAR
the application which seeks condonation of delay of 702
days is also incorrect.
23.
This Court does not find any discernible reason
which would entitle the cross objectors to maintain the
cross appeal/objection. It is significant to note that even in
the absence of the cross objection, these respondents are at
liberty to raise all such disputes and all such contentions in
the appeal. The issues which have gone against them can
be agitated by them in the appeal also. The provisions of
Order XLI of CPC make it very clear that if they are
aggrieved by finding on any of the issues, they are at liberty
to file the cross appeal and even in the absence of the cross
appeal, they can agitate their rights since an appeal is a
continuation of the suit. In that view of the matter, the
cross objection is hopelessly barred by time and as such,
the application is refused
and consequently, the cross
objection is also liable to be dismissed.
- 30 NC: 2026:KHC-D:786
RSA No. 265 of 2006
C/W RSA.CROB No. 100002 of 2024
HC-KAR
Re.Substantial questions of law 1 to 3:
24.
The substantial questions of law which have been
framed by this Court, really overlap on each other. The first
substantial question of law concerns to R.S. Nos. 653 and
518. The third substantial question of law is also in respect
of the same. The second substantial question of law is in
respect of recovery of Rs.73,543/- regarding which there is
no prayer in the plaint but it was on the ground that such a
relief was given by the trial Court and set aside by the First
Appellate Court. Therefore, all these three substantial
questions of law framed are taken up together.
25. The learned counsel appearing for the appellant
Sri
B. S. Kamate, submits that Item Nos.1 and 2 of the
schedule properties are the properties which were gifted by
defendant No. 1 in favour of the plaintiff and the said gift
was never challenged by
defendant No.1 at any point of
time. He submits that R.S. No. 653, which is Item No.3 of
the property was a subject matter of an order of the Land
Tribunal and therefore, when Paragouda became the owner
- 31 NC: 2026:KHC-D:786
RSA No. 265 of 2006
C/W RSA.CROB No. 100002 of 2024
HC-KAR
of the property by virtue of the occupancy rights granted to
him, it has devolved upon the plaintiff and therefore, he is
the absolute owner. He further submits that ME.No.2426 at
Ex.P16 shows that a varadi was given by none else than
defendant No.1 and he had consented to enter the name of
the plaintiff to the extent of half share as it is in joint
possession. Therefore, he contends that the suit schedule
properties are the absolute properties owned by the
plaintiff. It is submitted that Exhibit P16 is of 12.06.1960
and since then it was not challenged by defendant No.1 at
any point of time. Similarly, the other records which are in
favour of the plaintiff were never challenged by defendant
No.1 or anybody else and as such they have attained
finality and therefore, the First Appellate Court should have
dismissed the appeal, confirming the judgment passed by
the trial Court. He points out that the defendant No.1 only
filed
his
written
statement
and
to
substantiate
his
contention he had not adduced any evidence in the matter.
Therefore, it is submitted that when the Gift Deed at Exhibit
- 32 NC: 2026:KHC-D:786
RSA No. 265 of 2006
C/W RSA.CROB No. 100002 of 2024
HC-KAR
P15 is acted upon and the mutation entry has not been
challenged at any point of time and also there being an
order of Land Tribunal in favour of father of plaintiff, the
First Appellant Court erred in partly allowing the appeal.
26.
Per contra, learned counsel appearing for the
respondent submit that the Gift deed at Ex.P15 has not
been proved as required under law. He contends that the
original Gift Deed has not been produced by the plaintiff
and it is only the certified copy which has been produced by
him. He submits that the gift having not been proved as
required under law, the contention of the plaintiff should
have been rejected.
27.
Insofar as Item Nos. 3 and 4
of the schedule
properties are concerned, he submits that Item No. 3 was
owned by one Shringarewwa and father of the said
Shringarewwa acted as a minor guardian as well as tenant.
This dual role played by Paragouda
cannot be accepted.
Therefore, he submits that the
alleged grant of the
- 33 NC: 2026:KHC-D:786
RSA No. 265 of 2006
C/W RSA.CROB No. 100002 of 2024
HC-KAR
occupancy rights in favour of Paragouda as against his own
daughter is shrouded with suspicious circumstances. He
points out that the order of the Land Tribunal has not been
produced. Therefore, insofar as R.S.No.518 is concerned, he
submits that though the plaintiff contends that it was also
part of the gift, the Gift Deed nowhere mention about Site
No. 518. Hence, a mere mutation entry as per Exhibit P16 is
insufficient and no title would pass on the basis of a
revenue record. The alleged transfer of Survey No. 518 to
the extent of half share is unknown to law and therefore, he
seeks the total dismissal of the suit.
28.
In support of his contention, he has placed
reliance on the judgment reported in the case of
N.
Ramaswamy Padayachi Vs. C. Ramaswami Padayachi
and others1, wherein it was held that, a Gift Deed has to
be proved as required under Section 68 of the Evidence Act.
AIR 1975 Madras 88
- 34 NC: 2026:KHC-D:786
RSA No. 265 of 2006
C/W RSA.CROB No. 100002 of 2024
HC-KAR
29.
He also relied on the judgment in the case of
P.Kishore Kumar Vs. Vittal K. Patkar2 rendered by Apex
Court, wherein it was held that, having instituted the suit
for declaration, the burden of proof rested on the shoulders
of the plaintiff to reasonably establish the probability of the
better title. He also contends that the interference in the
second appeal under Section 100 of CPC ought not to be
made unless the appeal involves substantial questions of
law, as distinguished from a mere question of law.
In this case, it was also held that it is trite law that
revenue records are not documents of title and they neither
create nor extinguish title or does it have any presumptive
value on title.
Analysis and conclusions:
30.
A bare perusal of the plaint shows that insofar as
R.S. No. 21/1 and 21/2 are concerned, the plaintiff pleads
that they were owned by
2024(3) SCC 553
defendant No.1 and he has
- 35 NC: 2026:KHC-D:786
RSA No. 265 of 2006
C/W RSA.CROB No. 100002 of 2024
HC-KAR
executed a Gift Deed in favour of the plaintiff. It is also
stated in the plaint that half share in serial No. 4 property
i.e., R.S. No. 518 was also subject matter of the gift. A
certified copy of the Gift Deed is produced at Exhibit P15. A
perusal of this document would show that
nowhere, R.S.
No. 518 is the subject matter. This Gift Deed dated
21.05.1960 shows that defendant No. 1 has executed the
Gift Deed in favour of the plaintiff in respect of R.S. Nos.
21/1 and 21/2. As may be found from this document,
defendant No.1 was aged about 20 years. Therefore, it is
evident that Paragouda was not the minor guardian of
defendant No. 1 in any way. The Gift Deed avers that the
genitive mother of the defendant, Shringarewwa, was the
original owner of the property and therefore, he wants to
gift the same to the plaintiff. It is also mentioned that it was
as per the wish of the said Shringarewwa. A perusal of this
document shows that it was a registered Gift Deed and
there is no reason not to believe the said document. It is
pertinent to note that this Exhibit P15 pertains to only R.S.
- 36 NC: 2026:KHC-D:786
RSA No. 265 of 2006
C/W RSA.CROB No. 100002 of 2024
HC-KAR
No. 21/1 and 21/2 and it is not concerned with R.S. No. 518
as pleaded in the plaint.
31.
Exhibit
P16
is
the
mutation
entry
dated
12.06.1960, which is about a month later to Exhibit P15. In
this, it is mentioned that defendant No.1 admitting the joint
share of the plaintiff to the extent of half, wanted to mutate
his name and accordingly, the mutation entry was effected.
It may be noted that R.S. No.518 is the property which was
owned by defendant No.1. The plaintiff had no right, title or
interest in the same in whatsoever manner. Plaintiff was not
a
co-parcener
of
1st
defendant's
family.
Admittedly,
defendant No.1 had gone in adoption. Therefore, any
conveyance has to be by way of registered deed. If the
value of the property is more than Rs.100/-, it has to be
necessarily to be registered. Therefore, a mutation transfer
in the form of Exhibit P16 is unknown to law. This aspect
has been clearly dealt by the Apex Court in the judgment
relied by the learned counsel for defendant No. 1 in the
case of P. Kishore Kumar referred supra. It was held that
- 37 NC: 2026:KHC-D:786
RSA No. 265 of 2006
C/W RSA.CROB No. 100002 of 2024
HC-KAR
it is trite law that revenue records are not documents of
title and they do not convey any property. In paragraph
Nos.22 to 26, it was held as below:
"22. It is trite law that revenue records are not
documents of title.
23. This
Court
in Sawarni v. Inder
Kaur [Sawarni v. Inder Kaur, (1996) 6 SCC 223] held
that mutation in revenue records neither creates nor
extinguishes title, nor does it have any presumptive
value on title. All it does is entitle the person in whose
favour mutation is done to pay the land revenue in
question.
24. This was further affirmed in Balwant Singh v. Daulat
Singh [Balwant Singh v. Daulat Singh, (1997) 7 SCC
137] wherein this Court held that mere mutation of
records would not divest the owners of a land of their
right, title and interest in the land.
25. In Jitendra
Singh v. State
of
M.P. [Jitendra
Singh v. State of M.P., 2021 SCC OnLine SC 802] , this
Court after considering a catena of judgments,
reiterated the principle of law as follows: (SCC OnLine
SC para 6)
“6. … mutation entry does not confer any right, title
or interest in favour of the person and the mutation
entry in the revenue record is only for the fiscal
purpose.”
- 38 NC: 2026:KHC-D:786
RSA No. 265 of 2006
C/W RSA.CROB No. 100002 of 2024
HC-KAR
26. We may also profitably refer to the decision of this
Court in Sita Ram Bhau Patil v. Ramchandra Nago
Patil [Sita Ram Bhau Patil v. Ramchandra Nago Patil,
(1977) 2 SCC 49] wherein it was held that there exists
no universal principle that whatever will appear in the
record of rights will be presumed to be correct, when
there exists evidence to the contrary."
32.
Therefore, so far as R.S. No. 518 is concerned,
there being absolutely no transfer of title as required under
law, it cannot be said that the plaintiff has acquired any
right, title or interest in the same.
33.
In so far as R.S. No. 653 is concerned, it is the
case of the plaintiff that it was the property which was
gifted to Shringarewwa. The alleged Gift Deed executed by
Dundappa Dandin, the adoptive father of defendant No.1 in
favour of Shringarewwa has not been produced. What is
available on record is the record of rights, Exhibit P3, which
show that half of the property stands in the name of
Paragouda and the remaining half stands in the name of
defendant No.1. The name of the said Shringarewwa
- 39 NC: 2026:KHC-D:786
RSA No. 265 of 2006
C/W RSA.CROB No. 100002 of 2024
HC-KAR
doesn't find any place in it. Exhibit P4 is also the record of
rights for the year 1995–96.
34.
The next document that is available in respect of
R.S. No. 653 is Exhibit P36. It is a mutation entry dated
17.07.1991. It is mentioned that Paragouda had given a
vardi to the revenue authorities stating that he has become
old and he is unable to manage the property and therefore,
the name of his son Sidram Jundappa Patil i. e., defendant
No.1 be entered in the records. Accordingly, the name of
Paragouda came to be retained in respect of half share in
R.S. No. 653 and the remaining half was entered in the
name of defendant No.1. Apart from Survey No. 653, R.S.
No. 541 and 652 were also entered in the name of
defendant No.1. The said mutation entry was confirmed by
the order of the Tahsildar. It may be noted that the entry
was in the year 1991 and by that time defendant No.1 had
gone in adoption. The mutation entry does not mention
anything about the adoption of defendant No.1. Therefore,
this document concerning R.S. No. 653 do not confer any
- 40 NC: 2026:KHC-D:786
RSA No. 265 of 2006
C/W RSA.CROB No. 100002 of 2024
HC-KAR
right, title or interest over the plaintiff to claim any share.
Exhibit P41 is the record of rights of R.S. No. 653 and it
shows that half share is standing in the name of Paragouda
and the remaining half in the name of the defendant No. 1 –
Sidrama. In other words, it only shows what has been
effected in the mutation entry at Exhibit P36. These
documents nowhere mention as to how R.S. No. 653 came
in the hands of the plaintiff. The learned counsel for
defendant No.1 has contended that the R.S. Nos. 21/1 and
21/2 are not at all the subject matter of the Gift Deed and
the Gift Deed exhibited as P15 has not been proved as
required under law. This aspect has been considered by the
First Appellate Court. In its judgment, it notices that during
course of trial, Exhibit P15 has been let in without any
objections.
35.
It is relevant to note that R.S. No. 21/1 and 21/2
are subject matter of the Gift Deed at Exhibit P15 and no
objections were raised for marking the said document at the
time of the trial. The defendants did not object for Exhibit
- 41 NC: 2026:KHC-D:786
RSA No. 265 of 2006
C/W RSA.CROB No. 100002 of 2024
HC-KAR
D15 and they have not let in any rebuttal evidence
regarding the same. It is to be noted that the said property
was standing in the name of defendant No.1 and he has
executed a Gift Deed. The Gift Deed being registered one, it
can be relied and it is not necessary that all the witnesses
have to be examined in order to prove it. Obviously, the
judgment relied by the learned counsel for the respondent
cannot be accepted since the provisions of Section 68 of the
Evidence Act are applicable only in respect of the Will. If a
registered document is produced or in this case a certified
copy is produced, there is no reason as to why it should not
be believed. Under these circumstances, the finding of the
First Appellate Court in respect of the Gift Deed has to be
accepted. Hence, There is no infirmity in the judgment of
the First Appellate Court. It may be noted that there was no
such relief which was claimed by the plaintiff for recovery of
money from the defendant. The trial Court by invoking the
Provisions of Order VII Rule 7 of CPC has moulded the relief
and had granted the price of the sugar cane supplied by
- 42 NC: 2026:KHC-D:786
RSA No. 265 of 2006
C/W RSA.CROB No. 100002 of 2024
HC-KAR
defendant No.1 to
defendant No. 2. In fact, the First
Appellate Court while discussing point Nos. 2 and 3 holds
that the possession of the plaintiff in respect of Survey No.
653 and 518 cannot be approved since he had no right, title
or interest over the same. In para 16, it observes that when
no relief is asked by the plaintiff, such a relief could not
have been granted by the trial Court. Obviously, there was
no such issue which was framed concerning the payment of
Rs.73,543/- and therefore, there is no evidence that was let
in by the parties in respect of the same. Such relief was
granted only on the basis of the oral evidence. Hence, the
finding of the First Appellate Court in respect of the
schedule
Court
properties do not need any interference by this
and
cannot
be
interdicted.
In
the
result,
the
substantial questions of law are answered in the affirmative.
The First Appellate Court has also discussed about from
which property the sugar cane was sent and the said sum is
in respect of the sugarcane sent from such property.
Therefore, the said finding has to be justified. The finding is
- 43 NC: 2026:KHC-D:786
RSA No. 265 of 2006
C/W RSA.CROB No. 100002 of 2024
HC-KAR
proper and correct. For aforesaid reasons, the appeal is
bereft of any merits. Hence, the following:
ORDER
(i)
IA No.2/2006 in RSA.No.265/2006 is dismissed.
(ii)
IA No.1/2024 in RSA CROB No.100002/2024
dismissed
and
consequently,
RSA
is
CROB
No.100002/2024 is also dismissed.
(iii) RSA.No.265/2006 is dismissed.
(iv) The judgment of the First Appellate Court in RA
No.4/2003 dated 16.11.2005 is hereby confirmed.
Sd/(C M JOSHI)
JUDGE
tsn*
List No.: 19 Sl No.: 1
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review