The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
11. In view of the above order passed by the learned Judge, it appears to this Court the relief which the petitioner could not get directly is attempting before this court to obtain relief by indirect method. In the above order the court has appointed a person to look after the affairs of the committee and also appointed persons to conduct the elections. It appears from the record that they have not challenged the said order and the present writ petition is filed seeking an order for continuance of their elected body without going for election. It cannot be accepted that the petitioner before WP(C) No.471 of 2023, [Mr. Partha Sarathi Gupta and Anr. Versus The State of Tripura and 20 Ors], wherein the petitioner Mr. Partha Sarathi Gupta a Life Member of Tripura Cricket Association and the petitioner in the present writ petition is holding the post of Treasurer. And any order i.e., passed against the Office Bearers affecting the continuance of their term would equally have a force on all Office Bearers of this committee. Each individual cannot approach this court contending that he is not a party to the earlier writ proceeding and the principle of res-judicata would not apply to him and he can file a fresh writ. This court has no hesitation to say that principle of res-judicata would definitely apply in this matter. Moreover, the petitioner has also not made out a case to say that hi…
12. In view of the above disputed question of facts and in view of the orders passed in WP(C) No.471 of 2023 & WP (C) No 473 of 2023, dated 16.01.2024, this court is not inclined to grant any relief to the petitioner. Accordingly, the writ petition stands dismissed.
13. Accordingly, the present writ petition stands dismissed. As a sequel, miscellaneous application(s), pending if any, shall stand closed. Paritosh 11:42:30 +05'30'
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No. 25 of 2024
1. Shri Tapash Ghosh,
Son of Late Sailendra Ghosh
Aged about 48 years, resident of Ramnagar Road No.8 PO- Ramnagar, PSWest Agartala, Agartala, District-West Tripura, Honorary Secretary of TCA;
2. Shri Timir Chanda,
Son of Late Kajal Chanda
Aged about 48 years, resident of 56, HGB Road, PO-Agartala, PS-West
Agartala, District-West Tripura, Honorary Vide President of TCA;
3. Sri Joylal Das,
Son of Late Lal Bihari Das,
Aged about 36 years, resident of Chechuria, PS- Sidhai, PO & Sub-DivisionMohanpur, District- West Tripura, Treasurer, Tripura Cricket Association
-----Petitioners.
Versus
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
The State of Tripura,
Represented by the Secretary, Sport Department, Government of Tripura,
Agartala, West Tripura
Tripura Cricket Association,
Post Office Chowmuhani, PS- West Agartala, PO & Sub-Division- Agartala
District- West Tripura, Represented by its Secretary.
The Honorary
President,
Tripura Cricket Association, Post Office
Chowmuhani, PS- West Agartala, PO & Sub-Division- Agartala, District- West
Tripura.
The Joint Secretary, Tripura Cricket Association, Post Office Chowmuhani,
PS- West Agartala, PO & Sub-Division- Agartala, District- West Tripura.
Sri Bimal Kanti Roy, IPS (Retired),
Commissioner of Tripura Cricket Association, Post Office Chowmuhani, PSWest Agartala, PO & Sub-Division- Agartala, District –West Tripura.
----- Respondents.
For the Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. S. Lodh, Advocate.
Mr. Subham Majumder, Advocate
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. S. S. Dey, Advocate General.
Mr. D. Sarma, Addl. GA
Mr. S. Debnath, Advocate
Ms. A. Chakraborty, Advocate
18.01.2024.
Date of hearing
:
Date of delivery of
Judgment & Order
:
Whether fit for reporting :
22/01/2024
YES
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
JUDGMENT & ORDER
This present writ petition is filed by the 3(three) writ
petitioners. The petitioner no.3 Mr.Joylal Das is the deponent
and the prayer as sought for in the writ petition are as under:“i. Issue Rule, calling upon the respondents and each one of them, to
show cause as to why a writ of certiorari and/or in the nature
thereof, shall not be issued, calling for the records, lying with them
and a writ petition under article 226 of the Constitution of India, for
issuance of a writ of certiorari and/or in the nature thereof, for calling
for the records, lying with the official respondents, for rendering
substantial and conscionably justice to the petitioner and to
quash/set aside the resolution of the Annual General Meeting 202223 of TCA held on 04.12.2023 at 12.00 noon at Club House, MBB
stadium, Agartala with regard to dissolution of the existing Apex
Council and Office bearers and for conducting fresh election for a
afresh next tenure of three years as per amended Constitution on
18.09.2023.
ii. Issue Rule, calling upon the respondents and each one of them,
to show cause as to why a writ of mandamus and/or in the nature
thereof, shall not be issued for mandating/directing the respondents,
to revoke/resend the impugned resolution of the Annual General
Meeting 2022-23 of TCA held on 04.12.2023 at 12.noon at Club
House, MBB Stadium, Agartala with regard to dissolution of the
existing Apex Council and Office Bearers and for conducting fresh
election for a fresh next tenure of three years as per amended
constitution on 18. 09.2023 forthwith;
iii. Issue Rule, calling upon the respondents and each one of them, to
show cause as to why a writ f prohibition and in the nature thereof,
shall not be issued prohibiting the respondents to act in furtherance
of the resolution of the Annual General Meeting 2022-23 of TCA held
on 04.12.2024 at 12.noon at Club House, MBB Stadium, Agartala
with regard to dissolution of the existing Apex Council and Office
bearers and for conducting fresh election for a fresh next tenure of
three years as per amended constitution on 18.09.2023.
iv. Pass an interim order staying the operation / execution of
impugned resolution of the Annual General Meeting 2022-23 of TCA
held on 04.12.2023 at 12.noon at Club House, MBB Stadium,
Agartala with regard to dissolution of the existing Apex Council and
Office Bearers and for conducting fresh election for a fresh next
tenure of three years as per amended constitution on 18.09.2023
and to allow the petitioner-applicants to do all the works as
secretary, Vice President and Treasurer of TCA as per Memorandum
of Association & Rules and Regulations of Tripura Cricket Association.
v. After hearing the parties, be pleased to make the Rules absolute
interms of prayer i,ii, & iii, above.
vi. Call for records, appertaining to this petition.
vii. Costs of and incidental to this proceeding
viii. Any other relief(s) as to this Hon’ble High Court may deed fit and
proper.”
2.
The petitioner has sought the aforestated reliefs as
prayed for only on the ground that he was absent in the Annual
General meeting held on 4th December, 2023 and in the said
meeting, the impugned resolution was passed. To his surprise,
in the minutes of the meeting, it is recorded as if he is present
and thus prayed to set aside the said resolution and allow the
writ petition.
3.
On the other hand, Mr. S.S Dey, learned Advocate
General appearing for the State-respondents contended before
this court that the writ petition is not maintainable and the same
is liable to be dismissed. To forward his argument, learned
Advocate General relied on judgment dated 18.01.2022 passed
in CRP No.95 of 2021 and another Judgment dated 16.01.2024
in WP(C) No. 471 of 2023 & WP(C) No.473 of 2023 passed by
this Court.
4.
Mr. S. Debnath, learned counsel appearing for the
respondent-TCA contended that the petitioner though he was
not present, but very much participated in the proceedings and
upon
his
instructions,
his
version
was
recorded
through
WhatsApp communication and he prayed to dismiss the writ
petition since the disputed question of facts cannot be gone into
in writ jurisdiction. Learned Counsel further placed before this
court the order dated 16.01.2024 in WP(C) 471 of 2023 and
WP(C) 473 of 2023 passed by the learned Single Judge wherein
the learned Judge has categorically directed the respondents to
proceed with the elections and nominating a Committee for
conducting the elections and also to manage the affairs, person
in-charge has been appointed.
5.
Mr. S. Lodh, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner on the point of maintainability relied on Judgment of
Hon‟ble Apex Court in Board of Control for Cricket in India
v. Cricket Association
of
Bihar
and
others,
dated
22.1.2015 reported in AIR 2015 SC 3194 the relevant portion
of the said judgment as referred by the learned counsel is
quoted below:“2. Allegations of sporting frauds like match fixing and
betting have for the past few years cast a cloud over the
working of the Board of Control for Cricket in India (BCCI).
Cricket being more than just a sport for millions in this part
of the world, accusations of malpractices and conflict of
interests against those who not only hold positions of
influence in the BCCI but also own franchises and teams
competing in the IPL format have left many a cricketing
enthusiasts and followers of the game worried and deeply
suspicious about what goes on in the name of the game.
There is no denying the fact that lower the threshold of
tolerance for any wrong doing higher is the expectation of
the people, from the system. And cricket being not only a
passion but a great unifying force in this country, a zero
tolerance approach towards any wrong doing alone can
satisfy the cry for cleansing.
3. These appeals arise out of two successive writ petitions filed
in public interest by the appellant-Cricket Association of
Bihar before the High Court of Bombay for several reliefs
including a writ in the nature of mandamus directing BCCI
to recall its order constituting a probe panel comprising two
retired Judges of Madras High Court to enquire into the
allegations of betting and spot fixing in the Indian Premier
League (IPL) made among others against one Gurunath
Meiyappan. The High Court has by its order dated 30th July,
2013 passed in PIL No.55 of 2013 (reported in 2013 (5) AIR
Bom R 598) granted that relief but declined a possible
reconstitution of the panel. Aggrieved, BCCI has assailed
the order passed by the High Court in Civil Appeal No.4235
of 2014. In the connected Civil Appeal No.4236 of 2014,
Cricket Association of Bihar has prayed for further and
consequential orders which according to the appellant could
and indeed ought to have been passed by the High Court,
inter alia, for removal of respondent No.2 from the post of
President
of
BCCI
and
cancellation
of
the
franchise
favouring Chennai Super Kings and Rajasthan Royals for
the IPL matches to be conducted in future. In Civil appeal
arising out of SLP (C) No.34228 of 2014 the association
challenges the validity of Regulation 6.2.4 of the BCCI
Regulations for Players, Team Officials, Managers, Umpires
& Administrators (for short „BCCI Regulations‟) and the
order passed by the High Court dismissing PIL No.107 of
2013.”
Learned counsel further contended that the parties
are amenable to writ jurisdiction and prayed to allow the writ
petition.
6.
Heard both sides.
7.
It is seen from the record that the petitioner is
represented at serial No. 22 as Treasurer, Tripura Cricket
Association is shown absent. But whereas in the resolution
dated 4th December, 2023 recording the petitioner Joylal Das as
under :“………One Sri Joylal Das, Treasurer expressed his
consent to the decision of the house, of course along with his
recorded report and submission as the Treasurer, TCA...........”
8.
To the said argument made by the respondent-
Tripura Cricket Association, the petitioner has not denied that he
has
not
instructed
the above
quoted submission to
the
respondents through WhatsApp.
9.
Therefore, the learned counsel appearing for the
respondents-TCA submits before the Court that the petitioners
are not entitled for any relief to say that by way of no
confidence motion the petitioners have been removed and
bodies dissolved.
10.
In view of the above argument, made by counsel for
Tripura Cricket Association, the order of the learned Single
Judge dated 16.01.2024 in WP(C)
No.471 of 2023 & WP (C)
No 473 of 2023 is extracted hereunder:
“23.
In view of the aforesaid facts and circumstances
and keeping in mind the present and future of the cricket in
the State of Tripura, this Court deems it fit to appoint a
Committee of Administrators to look after the affairs of the
Tripura Cricket Association.
24. Since, it is a peak season of Cricket, in my opinion, any
person alien to the administration of TCA may face difficulties
to achieve the object and purposes of the Association.
In view of this, I would like to appoint Sri Tapan
Lodh, a former Chief Engineer of PWD, Government of Tripura,
Sri Basudeb Chakraborty, a member of Blood Mouth Club
associated
with
cricketing
affairs
and
former
honorary
Secretary of TCA and Dr. Pallab Das Gupta, Level-B Coach of
BCCI and senior cricket coach of SAI, Kolkata as threemembers Committee of Administrators. At the same time, Sri
B. K. Ray, IPS (Retd.) will continue as Commissioner to
supervise the affairs of the Association. The Committee of the
Administrators, as constituted here-in-above, shall take over
the charge with immediate effect.
25.
Simultaneously, I deem it fit to appoint an
Electoral Officer to conduct the election of TCA. Accordingly, I
request Mr. Kishore Ambuly, IAS(Retd.) as an Electoral Officer
to conduct and hold election of the Tripura Cricket Association.
I have considered his name for the reason that in the earlier
occasion, in the similar situation Mr. Kishore Ambuly had
conducted the election of the TCA as he had experience to
conduct the election of the TCA. Mr. Ambuly is requested to
complete the entire process of election within a period of
1(one) month from the date a copy of this order is furnished to
him.
26.
The Registry is directed to forward a copy of this
order to Mr. Ambuly (Electoral Officer appointed by this court)
and the members of the above-mentioned Committee of
Administrators as well as in favour of Sri B. K. Ray, the Court
appointed Commissioner within 2(two) days from today.”
11.
In view of the above order passed by the learned
Judge, it appears to this Court the relief which the petitioner
could not get directly is attempting before this court to obtain
relief by indirect method.
In the above order the court has
appointed a person to look after the affairs of the committee
and also appointed persons to conduct the elections. It appears
from the record that they have not challenged the said order
and the present writ petition is filed seeking an order for
continuance of their elected body without going for election. It
cannot be accepted that the petitioner before WP(C) No.471 of
2023, [Mr. Partha Sarathi Gupta and Anr. Versus The State of
Tripura and 20 Ors], wherein the petitioner Mr. Partha Sarathi
Gupta a Life Member of Tripura Cricket Association and the
petitioner in the present writ petition is holding the post of
Treasurer. And any order i.e., passed against the Office Bearers
affecting the continuance of their term would equally have a
force on all Office Bearers of this committee. Each individual
cannot approach this court contending that he is not a party to
the earlier writ proceeding and the principle of res-judicata
would not apply to him and he can file a fresh writ. This court
has no hesitation to say that principle of res-judicata
would
definitely apply in this matter. Moreover, the petitioner has also
not made out a case to say that his legally enforceable rights for
filing this writ petition has been infringed, when the entire body
is dissolved and when there is a direction of this court to
proceed to the elections as seen from the above order the
petitioner do not deserve any relief in this writ petition. Further,
the writ petition no WP(C) No.471 of 2023, is still pending
before this Hon‟ble Court.
12.
In view of the above disputed question of facts and in
view of the orders passed in WP(C) No.471 of 2023 & WP (C) No
473 of 2023, dated 16.01.2024, this court
is not inclined to
grant any relief to the petitioner. Accordingly, the writ petition
stands dismissed.
13.
Accordingly,
the
present
writ
petition
stands
dismissed. As a sequel, miscellaneous application(s), pending if
any, shall stand closed.
JUDGE
Paritosh
SABYASAC
HI GHOSH
SABYASACHI GHOSH
Date: 2024.01.22
11:42:30 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review