Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) 923 OF 2021
Sri Sunil Chandra Das, son of Amarendranath Das, aged about-64 years,
Resident of Kalikapur, PO-Ramnagar, PS-West Agartala,
Sub-Division-Agartala, District-West Tripura, Pin-799002.
……Petitioner.
Vrs.
1. Tripura Gramin Bank, having its Head Office at Abhaynagar,
Agartala, District-West Tripura, Pin-799005, represented by its Chairman.
2. The Disciplinary Authority (Chairman),
Tripura Gramin Bank, having its Head Office at Abhaynagar, Agartala,
District-West Tripura, Pin-799005.
3. Inquiry Officer (Chief Managar) (SPF-123),
Tripura Gramin Bank, Head Office (C & R Department), Abhaynagar,
Agartala, District-West Tripura, Pin-799005.
…. Respondents.
Present:
For the petitioner (s)
: Mr. Sankar Lodh, Advocate.
For the respondent (s)
: Mr. A. Roy Barman, Advocate.
Date of hearing and
date of delivery of
judgment and order
: 13.03.2023
Whether fit for
reporting
: Yes
HON’BLE MR.JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
Judgment & Order(Oral)
By means of filing the present writ petition, the petitioner has
challenged the impugned order of penalty, dated 27.10.2021 (Annexure-8
to the writ petition), directing recovery of one third of monthly pension
admissible to the petitioner until recovery of pecuniary loss to the bank in
terms of the Regulations 40 and 46 of Tripura Gramin Bank (Employees’)
Pension Regulations, 2018 [for short, the TGB Pension Regulations, 2018].
2.
Facts:
2.1
Shortly stated, the petitioner was an officer of Tripura Gramin
Bank, the respondents herein. He retired from service on 28.02.2018 on
superannuation as Senior Manager. After 2(two) years of retirement, the
Bank through respondent no.2 issued a notice dated 04.03.2020 asking him
to show cause for violation of the lending norms of the Bank. He
sanctioned and disbursed loans to 11(eleven) persons. The petitioner was
asked to submit his reply within a period of 10 days from the date of receipt
of the said show cause notice [Annexure-1 to the writ petition].
2.2
On receipt of the show cause notice dated 04.03.2020, the
petitioner submitted his reply on 27.03.2020, stating inter alia that he had
retired from service on 28.02.2018 and since 2 (two) years had elapsed
over, it was not possible for him to respond to the notice adequately. That
apart, the petitioner in his reply further contended that at the time of
retirement he handed over the charge to the concerned authority and he was
allowed to go on retirement by the authority as it was found that he had no
liability towards the bank, and he had discharged his duties and
responsibility sincerely and honestly to the satisfaction of the bank. It was
further stated in his reply that he never acted in any manner which was
detrimental to the interest of the bank and never violated any norms or
regulations prescribed by the bank time to time.
2.3
Further, the respondents-bank framed Articles of Charges and
proceeded with the inquiry. The petitioner did not participate in the
proceeding and it continued ex parte. Final order was passed on 27.10.2021
wherein it was stated that the petitioner was given reasonable opportunities
to participate in the inquiry and for cross-examination of the prosecution
witnesses on behalf of the managements of the bank. The petitioner was
given all reasonable opportunities to defend himself and to adduce
evidence.
2.4
Considering all aspects, it was held in the impugned
punishment order dated 27.10.2021 that the petitioner had violated
Regulations 18 and 20 of Tripura Gramin Bank (Officers and Employees)
Service Regulations,2010 [for short, the TGB Service Regulations,2010]
during his service period and for not taking care of the interest of the bank
in an effective manner as well as the customers. In consultation with the
Board and considering the gravity of misconduct resulting pecuniary loss to
the bank, the respondents inflicted penalty of recovery of 1/3 rd of monthly
pension admissible until recovery of pecuniary loss to the bank following
the Regulations 40 and 46 of the TGB Pension Regulations, 2018.
2.5
In view of the aforesaid impugned order of penalty, the
respondents-bank at present has been deducting different amount at
different times from the pension of the petitioner as would be evident from
the statements reflected in the bank’s passbook [Annexure-9 to the writ
petition] of the petitioner.
3.
Submissions of the Counsel:
3.1
In the light of aforesaid background, I have heard Mr. Sankar
Lodh, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner and Mr. A. Roy Barman,
learned counsel appearing on behalf of the respondents-bank.
3.2
Mr. Lodh, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the
petitioner has submitted that the impugned order of penalty for recovery of
the alleged loans of the bank is illegal, arbitrary and is liable to be quashed.
Mr. Lodh, learned counsel has made the following arguments:
(i) The TGB Pension Regulations, 2018 is not applicable to
the case of the petitioner since it came into force w.e.f. 01.04.2018 and
admittedly, the petitioner retired from service on 28.02.2018.
(ii) The TGB Pension Regulations, 2018 was not given
retrospective effect.
(iii) The TGB Pension Regulation 46 of the TGB Pension
Regulations, 2018 is not applicable to the petitioner and no punishment can
be imposed on the petitioner in terms of Regulation 46.
(iv) Regulation 46 will only be applicable if a pensioner is
found to be guilty of committing grave misconduct or negligence or
criminal breach of trust or forgery or acts done fraudulently during the
period of service and the conduct of the petitioner does not come within the
purview of the parameter mentioned in Regulation 46 to pass an order of
recovery to the extent of pecuniary loss caused to the bank. On the date of
retirement of the petitioner, there was ‘O’ (zero) pension of the petitioner
as per the schematic pattern of the bank.
(v) During service life of the petitioner, there was not a single
instance where the authority concerned had criticized the role of the
petitioner in rendering service to the bank and to protect the interest of the
bank. The petitioner was given time to time promotion and the respondentbank had allowed the petitioner to go on retirement without any stigma.
(vi) Actual loss suffered by the bank during the inquiry
proceeding as well as in the impugned order of penalty dated 27.10.2021,
has not been mentioned and the bank authority is deducting a substantial
amount from his pension at their own whims. The petitioner does not know
what is the quantum of loss to the bank and the amount to be recovered
from his pension and lastly,
(vii) Mr. Lodh, learned counsel has placed reliance upon a
decision of the Delhi High Court in WP(C) 10968/2009 titled as Amarjit
Singh Vrs. Punjab and Sind Bank, decided on November 21, 2013.
3.3
On the other hand, Mr. Roy Barman, learned counsel for the
respondents-bank has argued that—
(i) The TGB Pension Regulations, 2018 is well applicable to
the case of the petitioner.
(ii) The proceeding has been initiated after 2(two) years of the
retirement of the petitioner which is within the limit of 4(four) years of
drawing disciplinary proceeding against any employee of the bank after his
retirement from service.
(iii) Regulation 46 clearly stipulates that even after the date of
retirement, if the bank finds any of its employees committed gross
misconduct or criminal breach of trust as embodied in the said provision,
the bank may initiate disciplinary proceeding against such an employee.
(iv) Pension scheme was introduced in the bank on 13 th
December, 2018 (i.e. date of gazette notification) giving its effect from
01.04.2018 and the petitioner came within the purview of the pension
scheme and from the date of retirement, he has enjoyed the benefit of
pension. However, the petitioner was brought under the ‘National Pension
System’ as per Regulation 3(c) the Pension Regulations, 2018 since the
petitioner had exercised option.
(v) The disciplinary or the punishing authority is not under any
mandatory obligation to mention the amount of actual loss incurred by the
bank in the order of penalty since Inquiring Authority after going through
the records produced by the management of the bank had determined the
loss to the tune of Rs.1,01,05,124/- (Rupees one Crore One Lakh Five
Thousand One Hundred and Twenty Four) only.
4.
Analysis:
4.1
I have given my thoughtful consideration to the submissions
advanced by learned counsel appearing for the parties to the lis.
4.2
From the impugned order of penalty dated 27.10.2021
[Annexure-8 to the writ petition], it comes to fore that the petitioner has
been punished for committing breach of the Regulations 40 and 46 of the
Pension Regulations, 2018, which need to be reproduced here-in-below, for
convenience:
“40. Pension subject to future good conduct.—
Future good conduct shall be an implied condition of
every grant of pension and its continuance under these regulations.
“46.“Recovery of pecuniary loss caused to the Bank.(1) The competent authority may withhold or withdraw a
pension or a part there of, whether permanently or for a
specified period, and order recovery from pension of the whole
or part of any pecuniary loss caused to the Bank if in any
departmental or judicial proceedings the pensioner is found
guilty of grave misconduct or negligence or criminal breach of
trust or forgery or acts done fraudulently during the period of
his service:
Provided that before passing any final orders under this
sub-regulation, the Board shall be consulted:
Provided further that where a part of pension is withheld
or withdrawn the amount of pension drawn by a pensioner shall
not be less than the minimum pension payable under these
regulations:
Provided also that departmental proceedings, if instituted
while the employee was in service, shall, after the retirement of
the employee, be deemed to be the proceedings under these
regulations and shall be continued and concluded by the
authority by which they were commenced in the same manner as
if the employee had continued service.
(2) No departmental proceedings shall be initiated in respect of
an event if more than four years time lapsed after the event:
Provided that the disciplinary proceedings initiated under
this sub-regulation shall be in accordance with the procedure
applicable to disciplinary proceedings in relation to the
employee during the period of his service.
(3) Where the competent authority orders recovery of pecuniary
loss from the pension, the recovery shall not ordinarily be made
at a rate exceeding one third of the pension admissible on the
date of retirement of the employee.”
4.3
From the Articles of Charges, I find that the main allegation
against the petitioner is that the petitioner had sanctioned loan of a certain
amount at a certain interest. For example, Rs.14:00 lakh @ Rs.11.50%
interest. During the continuous repayment period, the interest rate was
reduced, for example @ 9.25%. According to the bank, the petitioner had
sanctioned further loan to the same borrower before its liquidation, for
example, Rs. 14:00 lakh. While granting such loan, outstanding balance of
earlier Rs.14:00 lakh was first adjusted with the former loan giving benefit
to the borrower to repay the loan amount at lesser rate of interest.
According to the bank, the bank was supposed to receive repayment of the
entire loan amount @ Rs.11.50% interest, but, after closing the former
loan and sanctioning the fresh loan again the bank had incurred loss to the
extent of the difference of the interests rate between the former loan and the
later fresh loan. It is the contention of the bank that the said conduct of the
petitioner is contrary to the lending policy of the bank. One of such cases,
relating to different customers may be reproduced here-in-below, for
convenience:
“Shilpi Biswas: Smt. Shilpi Biswas was sanctioned new
HBL (804330212565 @ Rs.9.25% interest) for new house
construction without valid documents for Rs.14 lakh. However,
existing HBL (8043302113362 @ Rs. 11.50 % interest) was
adjusted to give her reduced interest benefit where outstanding
balance was Rs.12,25,947/- out of Rs.14 lakh. Why extra
Rs.1,74,053/- was given not understood. It was against lending
policy of the bank. The bank has to loss interest margin of 2.25%
over the loan. The processing of the loan was not properly done.
Total deduction exceeded 60% of her gross salary. The landed
property as security offered owned by Shri Bikash Cnahdra Sarkar
(Husband) was found neither as co-loanee nor guarantor against
the loan. No record found for extension of Equitable mortgage
either with re-valuation of the property. It appeared as unsecured
loan. The whole process was illegal, detrimental for the interest of
the bank.”
The TGB Pension Regulations, 2018 came into force w.e.f.
01.04.2018. Admittedly, under Sub-Regulation 1(c) of Regulation 3, the
petitioner had opted for pension on the basis of which he was granted
pension w.e.f. date of his retirement i.e. from 28.02.2018.
4.4
Considering the submissions of Mr.Lodh, learned counsel
appearing for the petitioner as regards the retrospective effect of Pension
Regulations 2018, in my opinion, Regulation 46 in expressed terms has
dealt with various facts of initiating departmental proceeding against the
retired employee of the bank. Regulation 46 clearly speaks of certain
contingencies
of initiation of departmental proceeding
qua the
requirements of imposition of penalty. It clearly stipulates that if an
employee is found to be guilty of committing grave misconduct, negligence
or criminal breach of trust or fails to protect the interest of the bank, in
that case, a departmental proceeding can be initiated irrespective of the
fact that he has retired and such proceeding would be deemed to be the
proceedings under the TGB Pension Regulations, 2018 which would be
continued and concluded by the authority, as if, such employee is in service
under the bank. Here, the petitioner retired from service on 28.02.2018.
The departmental proceeding was initiated on 22.09.2020 as submitted by
learned counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioner in presence of an
officer of the bank in the court. As such, in view of clear expressions
embodied under Regulation 46 of TGB Pension Regulations, 2018, the
framers of the said Regulations have given its retrospective effect in the
matter of drawing up of disciplinary proceeding subject to the
contingencies as embodied in Regulation 46 quoted here-in-above. In the
instant case, all the events had occurred within four years,
4.5
At this juncture, I have given look to the imputation of
misconduct as revealed from Annexure-II of Articles of Charges, which is
as under:
“IMPUTATION OF MISCONDUCT
AGAINT SRI SUNIL CHANDREA DAS (SPF-403),
(Retired Senior Manager)
You have violated Regulation 18 & 20 of Tripura Gramin
Bank (Officers and Employees) Service Regulations, 2018 by not
complying Rules and Regulations of the Bank and by not taking
care of interest of the Bank rather you have undertaken some
irregular activities and failed to serve the bank honestly and
faithfully, which amounts to major misconducts attracting
invocation of Sub-Regulation (2) under Regulation 46 of Tripura
Gramin Bank (Officers and Employees) Pension Regulations, 2018
in respect of article of charge under item No.1 to 18 as mentioned
in Annexure-I.
DISCIPLINARY AUTHORITY
CHAIRMAN
TRIPURA GRAMIN BANK”
4.6
Here, learned counsel appearing for the respondents-bank has
clarified that the year of the Regulations under which imputation of
misconduct was made by the authority concerned is a typographical
mistake. It should be made as “Regulations 18 and 20 of the “Tripura
Gramin Bank (Officers and Employees) Service Regulations,2010”
instead of “Regulations 18 & 20 of the Tripura Gramin Bank (Officers
and Employees) Service Regulations, 2018”
4.7
Regulations 18 and 20 of the TGB Service Regulations,2010
is reproduced here-in-below for convenience:
“18. Liability to abide by the regulations and orders.—
Every officer or employee shall conform to and abide by these
regulations and shall also observe, comply with and obey all
orders and directions which may, from time to time be given to him
by any person or persons under whose jurisdiction,
superintendence or control he may for the time being he posted.”
“20. Obligation to Promote the Bank’s interest.—Every
officer or employee shall serve the Bank honestly and faithfully,
and shall use his utmost endeavour to promote the interests of the
Bank and shall show courtesy and attention in all transactions and
dealings with officers of Government, the Bank’s constituents and
customers.”
4.8
A plain reading of Regulation 18 of the TGB Service
Regulations,2010 makes it clear that all officers and employees have to
strictly adhere to the Regulations made thereunder and shall also act in
accordance with the orders and directions they receive from time to time
from his/her higher authorities.
Regulation 20 clearly speaks of the responsibilities of the
officers and the employees who shall serve the bank honestly and faithfully
and shall make their maximum endeavour to promote the interests of the
bank.
4.9
From the imputation of misconduct as quoted here-in-above, it
is alleged that the petitioner failed to act honestly and faithfully, which
amounts to a major misconduct attracting invocation of Sub-Regulation (2)
under Regulation 46 of the TGB Pension Regulations, 2018. On careful
reading of Sub-Regulation (2) under the Regulation 46 along with its
proviso, it comes to fore that it provides the procedure which was
prevailing during the service of the pensioner, that is, before the date of his
retirement, will be applicable to disciplinary proceeding in relation to such
employee. It does not in any way relate to nature of commission of any
misconduct.
4.10
Mr. Roy Barman, learned counsel for the bank has tried to
emphasize upon Regulations 18 and 20 of the TGB Service
Regulations,2010 to invoke Regulation 46 of TGB Pension Regulations,
2018, as an aid to pass order of penalty of recovery of pecuniary loss
caused to the bank. Mr. Roy Barman, learned counsel appearing for the
bank in response to a query made by this court has submitted that there is
no disagreement to the effect that for violation of Regulations 18 and 20 of
the TGB Service Regulations, 2010, disciplinary proceeding can be
initiated in terms of the prevailing Regulations applicable to such retired
employee during his service period.
4.11
In the context of the present case, Sub-regulation (2) of
Regulation 46 of the TGB Pension Regulations,2018, according to this
court, will play a vital role to adjudicate the questions raised in this writ
petition as regards concluding of disciplinary proceeding in relation to the
petitioner in accordance with TGB Pension Regulations,2018. Subregulation (2) of Regulation 46 starts with a non obstante clause when it is
categorically stipulated that- “no departmental proceedings shall be
initiated in respect of an event if more than four years time lapsed after the
event.” The said Sub-regulation (2) has to be read in conjunction with its
proviso where it is clearly stated that the disciplinary proceedings initiated
under Sub-regulation (2) would proceed in accordance with the procedure
applicable to disciplinary proceedings in relation to the employee during
the period of his service. Admittedly, the petitioner is a pensioner and
disciplinary proceedings has been initiated after his retirement when TGB
Service Regulations, 2010 was in vogue. Thus, the procedure to be adopted
to conduct and conclude the disciplinary proceedings would have to be
regulated in relation to the petitioner under TGB Service Regulations, 2010
and not under TGB Pension Regulations,2018.
4.12
In the opinion of this court, the words, “procedure applicable
to disciplinary proceedings” means and includes not only the procedure to
be followed in the disciplinary proceedings, but also it includes procedure
of imposing penalty.
4.13
[emphasis supplied]
In the case in hand, the Disciplinary Authority inflicted
penalty of withdrawal of 1/3rd of monthly pension admissible under
recovery of pecuniary loss to the bank following Regulations 40 and 46 of
the TGB Pension Regulations, 2018 for committing misconduct as
provided under Regulations 18 and 20 of the TGB Service Regulations,
2010. In my considered view, in view of the procedure embodied in Subregulation (2) of Regulation 46 of the TGB Pension Regulations, 2018, the
penalty imposed upon the petitioner in terms of Sub-regulations (1) and (3)
of Regulation 46 of the TGB Pension Regulations, 2018 is utterly illegal
and arbitrary.
4.14
In my opinion, the Disciplinary Authority ought to have
imposed penalty upon the petitioner in terms of the relevant provisions as
contemplated under the TGB Service Regulation, 2010 instead of the TGB
Pension Regulation,2018.
4.15
Here, it will be worthy to have a look to the schematic pattern
of imposing penalty upon a retired employee of the bank affecting his
pension. Chapter IV of the TGB Pension Regulations, 2018 absolutely
deals with the grant of pension and pensioner where the drafters have
imbibed some contingencies to institute disciplinary proceeding against a
petitioner. Regulation 40 of the TGB Pension Regulations, 2018 lays down
that future good conduct shall be an implied condition of every grant of
pension and its continuance under these regulations. From the impugned
order passed by the Disciplinary Authority, it comes to fore that
punishment of 1/3rd of monthly pension was imposed following the
Regulation 40. There is no material and even no charge has been framed
that the petitioner has committed any misconduct after his retirement so
that the bank authority can interfere with the grant of pension and its
continuance. Regulation 41 clearly says that- the competent authority may,
by order in writing, withhold or withdraw a pension or a part thereof,
whether permanently or for a specified period, if the pensioner is convicted
of serious crime or criminal breach of trust or forgery or acting
fraudulently or is found guilty of grave misconduct. It is not the case here
that after his retirement, the petitioner was found to be convicted of being
involved in a serious crime or in criminal breach of trust or forgery or
acting fraudulently or is found guilty of grave misconduct.
4.16
Regulation 42 speaks of a situation where a pensioner is
convicted of a serious crime by a court, action shall be taken in the light of
the judgment of the court relating to such conviction.
Regulation 43
envisages that in a case not falling under regulation 42, if the competent
authority considers that the pensioner is prima facie guilty of grave
misconduct, it shall, before passing an order, follow the procedure
specified in the Service Regulations i.e. TGB Service Regulations,2010.
4.17
Now, under the “explanation” of Regulation 44, the nature of
crime is explained. Explanation (a) defines “serious crime”, which includes
a crime involving an offence under the Official Secrets Act,1923;
Explanation (b) defines “grave misconduct” which includes
the communication or disclosure of any secret official code or password or
any sketch, plan, model, article, note, documents or information, such as is
mentioned in section 5 of the Official Secrets Act, 1923 which was obtained
while holding office in the Bank so as to prejudicially affect the interests of
the general public or the security of the State;
Explanation (c) defines “fraud”, which shall have the meaning
assigned to it under section 25 of the Indian Penal Code,1860;
Explanation (d) defines “criminal breach of trust” which shall
have the meaning assigned to it under section 405 of the Indian Penal
Code,1860 and
Explanation (e) defines “forgery” which shall have the
meaning assigned to it under section 463 of the Indian Penal Code,1860.
4.18
So, recourse to Regulation 46 of the TGB Pension
Regulations,2018 can only be taken when a pensioner is found to be
involved in committing serious crime or grave misconduct or fraud or
criminal breach of trust or forgery as quoted here-in-above and in terms of
Regulations 40, 41, 43 of the TGB Pension Regulations,2018.
4.19
Noticeable feature, is that, Chapter IX of the TGB Pension
Regulations, 2018 primarily centres round with various aspects related to
the pensioners and deals with the circumstances or events including
initiation of disciplinary proceeding and penalty thereof. It is noted that
Regulation 46 of the TGB Pension Regulations, 2018 in unambiguous
terms prescribes the situations, rather, to say, certain contingencies, under
which penalty for recovery of pecuniary loss be imposed if a pensioner is
found to be guilty of grave misconduct or negligence or criminal breach of
trust or forgery or acts done fraudulently during the period of his service.
The imputation of charges made against the petitioner under Regulations
18 and 20 of the TGB Service Regulations, 2010. On plain reading of the
definition of ‘grave misconduct’ as quoted here-in-above, it can easily be
said that it is not the case here that the petitioner had made any
communication or disclosed any secret official code or password as
mentioned in Section 5 of the Official Secrets Act,1923. The charge
framed against the petitioner is for committing ‘grave misconduct’. As
such, in my considered view, no punishment or penalty can be imposed
upon the petitioner for recovery of pecuniary loss to the bank from the
pension of the petitioner as provided under Sub-regulation (3) of
Regulation 46 of the TGB Pension Regulations, 2018.
4.20
Yet another aspect, which falls for consideration is that the
Disciplinary Authority has not mentioned the actual pecuniary loss caused
to the bank in the impugned order of penalty dated 27.10.2021.
4.21
The report of the inquiring authority is the foundation of the
formation of the opinion of the disciplinary authority. It is the statutory
obligation of the Disciplinary Authority to mention in his show cause
notice or order as regards the penalty/punishment he proposes to inflict
upon the petitioner. In the instant case, the Disciplinary Authority has not
mentioned the actual pecuniary loss suffered by the bank, and quantum to
be recovered from the petitioner.
4.22
In addition, Sub-regulation (3) of Regulation 46 clearly speaks
that recovery shall not ordinarily be made at a rate exceeding one third of
the pension admissible on the date of retirement of the employee. From the
bank statement dated 01.10.2021, it is found that the pension amount of the
petitioner as on September, 2021 was Rs.42,495/-. Now from the statement
dated 01.11.2021, it is found that the pension amount against the petitioner
was credited to his account to the tune of Rs.14,165/- and from the
statement dated 1.12.2021, it is found that the pension amount was credited
to the account of the petitioner for an amount of Rs.25,796/-. So, it is
apparent from the statement of the bank that different amounts are being
deducted by the bank at different times and there is no fixed amount which
were deducted from the pension amount of the petitioner, which fact is
neither disputed by the bank officer present in the court nor by leaned
counsel for the bank.
5.
Conclusion:
5.1
In the light of above discussions, by way of imposing penalty
of withdrawal of one third of monthly pension admissible until recovery of
pecuniary loss to the bank, following the Regulations 40 and 46 of the
TGB Pension Regulations, 2018, in my considered view, the respondentsbank has committed a serious error in law and as such, the impugned order
of recovery dated 27.10.2021 [Annexure-8 to the writ petition] is illegal,
arbitrary and contrary to established principle of law and liable to be set
aside and quashed.
5.2
Accordingly, the impugned
order of recovery dated
27.10.2021, passed by the respondents-bank stands set aside and quashed.
5.3
The money already recovered by the respondents-bank shall
be refunded/credited to the relevant bank account of the petitioner within a
period of two months from the date of receipt of a copy of this
judgment/order.
5.4
The writ petition, accordingly, stands allowed and disposed of
in the above terms.
JUDGE
sanjay
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review