Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C)No.709 of 2021
Shri Suman Nag,
son of Sri Madhusudhan Nag,
Owner, Editor, Publisher and Printer of Kalamer Shakti,
resident of Sukanta Nagar, P.O. S.B.C. Nagar,
P.S. & Sub-Division-Belonia, District–South Tripura
………… Petitioner(s)
–Versus–
1. The State of Tripura,
represented by the Secretary,
Revenue Department, Government of Tripura,
New Capital Complex, P.O. Kunjaban,
P.S. New Capital Complex,
Agartala, District-West Tripura
2. The District Magistrate,
South Tripura District, Belonia
3. The Union of India,
represented by the Secretary,
Ministry of Information and Broadcasting,
Room No.655, A wing, Shastri Bhawan,
New Delhi-110001
4. Registrar of Newspapers for India,
represented by the Press Registrar & Head of the Department,
Ministry of Information and Broadcasting, West Block VIII,
Wing-2, R.K. Puram, New Delhi-110066
………… Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
For Respondent(s)
:
:
Date of Hearing
Date of Judgment & Order
:
:
Mr. S. Lodh, Adv.
Mr. Biswanath Majumder, CGC
Mr. D. Bhattacharya, G.A.
Mr. P. Saha, Adv.
02.03.2022
27.05.2022
Whether fit for reporting
:
NO
HON‟BLE MR. JUSTICE S. TALAPATRA
JUDGMENT & ORDER
By means of this writ petition, the petitioner has challenged the
order No.F.6(298)/DM/S/JDL/PRB Act/P-I/2021/280 dated 18.09.2021 issued by the
District Magistrate, South Tripura Belonia [Annexure-9 to the writ petition]. In
addition thereto, the petitioner has urged for a writ of prohibition against the
respondents restraining them from acting in furtherance of the said order dated
18.09.2021.
2.
The petitioner started publishing a vernacular newspaper namely
Kalamer Shakti (Bengali daily) since 23.11.2017. The petitioner decided to change
the language of the newspaper and accordingly, the declaration under Section
5(2D) of Press and Registration of Books Act, 1867, PRB Act, in short was made.
The said declaration was authenticated on 17.06.2021 by the respondent No.2 [the
District Magistrate, South Tripura] under Section 6 of the PRB Act. After three
months of filing the said declaration, the respondent No.2 issued a show cause
notice to the petitioner [Annexure-3 to the writ petition]. By the said show cause
notice, the petitioner has been asked to explain how the said newspaper
commenced its publication as an English daily without any certificate of registration
as required under Section 19(C) of the said Act. For publication of the English daily
how the petitioner has used the same RNI number being TRIBEN10404 which was
earlier used for the Bengali daily under the same title which has however ceased its
publication. It has been also revealed in the said notice that the discrepancy letter
was issued to the petitioner by the section officer/Registration Supervisor, for the
Registrar of Newspaper in India by the letter No.23.10.2017-R3 dated 25.10.2017,
the reply of which has not been received from the petitioner. Finally, the petitioner
was asked to give his reply within three days from the date of the receipt of the
reply to the respondent No.2 why the appropriate action would not be taken
against him.
3.
The petitioner filed his reply [Annexure-4 to the writ petition] but
there is no date in the copy that has been enclosed with the writ petition. In the
reply, the petitioner has stated as follows :
“I would like to inform you that, after receiving the letter vide
file no.23.10.2017-R3 dated 25.10.17 which was issued by RNI
(Annexure-A);
I went to DM West for due authentication of Declaration
(FORM-1) which was required by RNI because publisher and
printing press were from different district. The DM West
denied to do so. I rushed to the Hon‟ble High Court of Tripura.
On writ petition, the High Court instructed DM West to
immediately authenticate FORM 1 so that I could start printing
at West Tripura. FORM 1 authenticated by the then DM West
on 17th November 2017, is attached as (Annexure B) and
document related to High court‟s judgment attached as
(Annexure C).
Finally as required by the RNI, New Delhi I sent them the
latest edition of newspaper and declaration (FORM 1) duly
authenticated by DM West and South Tripura DM on 23 rd
November 2017. The receive copy of the reply to this letter of
RNI is attached herewith as (Annexure D). In the reply to the
letter we cleared all requirements of RNI and was able to
submit FORM 1 authenticated by DM West, finally requesting
RNI to issue Kalamer Shakti a revised registration certificate.”
A copy of the declaration dated 17.11.2017 which was enclosed to the
reply is available also with the writ petition.
4.
After the reply was furnished the date of hearing was fixed by the
respondent No.2 on several occasion at the instance of the petitioner. Finally, the
impugned order dated 18.09.2021 has been passed by the respondent No.2. Since
the said order is the pivot of the controversy, the full text is reproduced hereunder:
“No.F.6(298)/DM/S/JDL/PRB Act/P-I/2021/280
GOVERNMENT OF TRIPURA
OFFICE OF THE DISTRTICT MAGISTRATE & COLLECTOR
SOUTH TRIPURA, BELONIA
Dated, Belonia, the 18th September, 2021
PROCEEDING
Whereas a Show Cause Notice was issued to Sri Suman Nag, S/O- Sri
Madhusudhan Nag, Vill-Sukanta Nagar, P.O.-SBC Nagar, under Belonia P.S. Belonia,
South Tripura vide No.F.6(298)/DM/S/JDL/2016/265 dated, 1/9/2021 in connection
with printing & publication of the English newspaper „Kalamer Shakti‟ and a reply is
received from Sri Nag on 04/09/2021 and on scrutiny of the reply it is found that Sri
Nag has sought 30 days time for submitting the latest revised Registration
Certificate, which was not found to be satisfactory.
AND
Whereas, under section 5(2D) of the Press and Registration of Books Act,
1867; in case the language of the newspaper is changed, then the declaration shall
cease to have effect a new declaration shall be necessary before the publication of
the newspaper can be continued and subsequently under section 19C of the said Act,
on receiving from the Magistrate u/s 6 a copy of the declaration in respect of a
Newspaper and on the publication of such Newspaper, the Press Registrar shall as
soon as practicable thereafter, issue a certificate of registration in respect of that
Newspaper to the Publisher thereof. That certificate of Registration in favour of
“Kalamer Shakti” in English edition is yet to be received by the undersigned but the
newspaper „Kalamer Shakti‟ is being printed & published in English without
Certificate of Registration.
AND
The title code “TRIBEN10404” which is appearing in the English edition of
“Kalamer Shakti” Newspaper and previously the same title code used to appeared in
the Bengali edition of “Kalamer Shakti”. But the title code TRIBEN10404 was issued
by the RNI for “Kalamer Shakti” in Bengali version which is found from the RNI title
verification letter, vide file No.1317942, dated, 29-08-2017. But u/s 5(2D) of the
said Act since the language of the Newspaper is changed from Bengali to English, a
new declaration shall be necessary which the publisher Sri Suman Nag made on 1 st
June 2021 in Form-I. Subsequently, the declaration was sent to the RNI by post as
Registration on 29-06-2021, but till date no title verification letter for the English
edition of “Kalamer Shakti” by RNI is received to this end. Yet Sri Suman Nag is using
the old title code (TRIBEN10404) of the Bengali edition of “Kalamer Shakti”
Newspaper for the new English edition of “Kalamer Shakti” which is in contravention
of the Act u/s 5(2D).
AND
An enquiry team had been formed u/s 8(B) of the said Act and subsequently
the team has submitted the report vide No.F.37(1)/ADM(PP)/S/Misc/VolII/2020/221, dated, 9th September, 2021, wherein the enquiry team has clearly
recommended for cancellation of the declaration in Form-I made by Sri Suman Nag,
dated, 17-06-2021.
AND
Sri Suman Nag had been asked to appear before the undersigned on
15/09/2021 at 11 AM for hearing u/s 8(B) of the said Act, vide this Office letter
No.F.6(298)/DM/S/JDL/PRB ACT/P-I/2021/269, dated, 13th September, 2021 which
is duly served to him and he did not appear. Instead he submitted a letter asking for
more time to appear. Based on his request letter, he was asked to appear on 18-092021 at 11 AM before the undersigned vide letter No.F.6(298)/DM/S/JDL/PRB
ACT/P-I/2021/275, dated, 15th September 2021, which was duly served to him. But
neither he turned up nor he represented himself by any of his representative, which
indicates that he wants to avoid the hearing. Instead he submitted a reply for
rescheduling the hearing date within 10 days along with a xerox copy of old
prescription dated 02-04-2021, which is found not justified and not satisfactory.
Now, therefore, u/s 8(B) of the Press and Registration of Books Act, 1867, the
declaration in Form-I submitted by Sri Suman Nag in favour of “Kalamer Shakti” in
English language which was authenticated on 17-06-2021 is hereby cancelled.
To
Suman Nag, S/O-Sri Madhusudhan Nag,
Of Sukanta Nagar, P.O.-SBC Nagar,
P.S. Belonia, South Tripura,
For information and necessary action.
Illegible
(Saju Vaheed A. IAS)
District Magistrate & Collector,
South Tripura, Belonia”
5.
Immediately, after receipt of the said order dated 18.09.2021, the
petitioner submitted an application to the respondent No.2 on 20.09.2021 urging
reconsideration as according to him, he started printing the newspaper in English
newspaper only after the authentication was done on 17.06.2021. The said
declaration was also sent to the Press Registrar by the respondent No.2 along with
his communication dated 24.06.2021. It is to be pointed out that by the said
declaration, three changes which are as follows were sought to be made :
1) Change of the Printing Press
2) Change of Newspapers price and
3) Change of the language of the Newspaper-from
Bengali to English.
6.
Mr. S. Lodh, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner has stated that
for changing the language of the newspaper or the name of the printer etc., the
publisher shall furnish a declaration under Section 5(2D) of the PRB Act and that
should be authenticated by the District Magistrate and after such authentication,
the newspaper may commenced its publication. In terms of the declaration under
Section 5(2D) of the PRB Act, the respondent No.4, the Registrar of Newspapers for
India will follow the provisions of Section 19(C) of the said Act. Ignoring those
provisions of law, the respondent No.2 has passed the impugned order invoking the
jurisdiction as provided under Section 8(B) of the PRB Act. From a bare reading of
Section 5(2D) of the said Act, it would be apparent that the petitioner had followed
all the required procedure, despite that, the said order dated 18.09.2021 has been
passed most illegally. Hence, interference of this court has been sought in order to
protect the Constitutional right of expression of the petitioner.
7.
The respondents No.1 and 2 filed the reply whereas the
respondents No.3 and 4 filed a separate reply. The respondents No.1 and 2
represented by Mr. D. Bhattacharya, learned G.A. has in their reply stated that the
petitioner commenced the publication of the newspaper titled as Kalamer Shakti in
English language without the Certificate of Registration from the Press Registrar
under Section 19(C) of the PRB Act. According to Mr. Bhattacharya, learned G.A.,
the Press Registrar is supposed to issue a Certificate of Registration under Section
19(C) of the PRB Act on receiving the declaration authenticated by the authorised
Magistrate. But such certificate has not been issued as yet. Defying the provisions
of law, the petitioner commenced the publication. It has been stated in their reply
that under Section 5(2D) of the Act where the language of the newspaper is
changed, the declaration shall ceased to have effect and a new declaration is
necessary to be made before the publication of the newspaper commences. But
without fresh Certificate of Registration from the Press Registrar, the petitioner
commenced publication of newspaper in English using the title code of the
newspaper which was granted for publishing the newspaper in Bengali. Thus, the
petitioner violated the provisions of Section 5(2D) and Section 19(C) of the Act.
8.
That apart, it has been contended that the petitioner was given
enough opportunity of hearing, but he did not avail those opportunities to place the
materials in support of his contentions. No one can be allowed to take the
proceeding at ransom.
9.
In para 12 of the reply filed by the respondents No.1 and 2, it has
been specifically stated by those respondents that the respondent No.2 forwarded
the declaration of the petitioner in Form-I to the Press Registrar by the
communication dated 24.06.2021. Even after lapse of two months, no certificate of
registration has been received. It has been also stated that an inquiry team was
constituted vide order dated 07.09.2021. The inquiry team has submitted a report
by the communication dated 09.09.2021. The inquiry team has opined that the
declaration in Form-I submitted by the petitioner on 17.06.2021 and authenticated
by the respondent No.2 may be cancelled as per provisions of Section 8(B) read
with Section 14 of the PRB Act, if the authority is satisfied.
10.
There had been no infraction of the procedure in passing the
impugned order dated 18.09.2021 and hence, the challenge against the order
dated 18.09.2021 is bound to fail. Moreover, maintainability of the writ petition has
been challenged in view of the provisions made for preferring appeal to the Press
and Registration Appellate Board. It has been urged that the writ petition has been
dismissed at the threshold.
11.
The respondents No.3 and 4 represented by Mr. Biswanath
Majumder, learned CGC have also filed a separate reply. Those respondents have
at the outset stated that the Registrar of Newspaper for India is a statutory
authority under Section 19 of the PRB Act, 1867 for purpose of verifying and
registering a title of newspaper on the recommendation of the District Magistrate
within whose local jurisdiction such newspaper shall be printed or published.
According to them, no fundamental or statutory right of the petitioner has been
infringed and hence, the writ petition is not maintainable. In para 6.B it has been
stated that as per record the title Kalamer Shakti was verified by the answering
respondent on 29.08.2017 as Bengali daily under the title code “TRIBEN10404” in
favour of the petitioner. It is further submitted that as per record, application for
registration was received by RNI on 26.09.2017. However, on scrutiny of the
documents, certain discrepancies in the records were noticed and the same was
intimated to the publisher vide RNI letter dated 25.10.2017 and the complete
documents are yet to be received in RNI as on date [Annexure-R/1 to the reply
filed by the respondent No.3 and 4].
12.
It has also been admitted by them that the District Magistrate,
South Tripura, Belonia had forwarded the declaration dated 17.06.2021. But in that
declaration, the seal and signature of the authenticating authority was missing.
According to them, it was the reason that no action could be taken. No dispute has
been raised by the respondent No.3 and 4 as they had received the letter dated
24.06.2021 of the District Magistrate, South Tripura, Belonia.
13.
In para 12, the respondents No.3 and 4 have categorically asserted
as under :
“While copy of declaration dated 17.06.2021 is attested by
District Magistrate, South Tripura, Belonia, portion of
declaration containing the seal and signature of authenticating
authority is missing. Further, it is pertinent to mention here
that change of language of a verified/registered title at the
time of filing declaration is not permissible. The
owner/publisher is required to apply afresh for verification of
title in the desired language(s) through the District Magistrate
concerned, which shall be verified by RNI based on
availability, as per the PRB Act, 1867 and the title verification
guidelines. The same was communicated by RNI to Shri Saju
Vaheed A., IAS, District Magistrate & Collector, South Triprua,
Belonia vide letter dated 02.12.2021 (Annexure-R-4). A copy
of RNI letter dated 02.12.2021 was also endorsed to the
Publisher of Kalamer Shakti.”
[Emphasis added]
14.
They have further asserted that a change of language of a
verified/registered title cannot be brought about by filing declaration of the nature
as filed by the petitioner. The owner/publisher is required to apply afresh for
verification of title in the desired language(s) through the District Magistrate
concerned. The title shall be verified based on availability, as per the PRB Act, 1867
and the title in accordance with the verification guidelines, be verified and be
allotted on availability. The said procedure was communicated to the respondent
No.2 by the letter dated 02.12.2021 [Annexure-R/4 to the reply filed by the
respondents No.3 and 4]. A copy of the RNI letter dated 02.12.2021 was endorsed
to the Publisher of Kalamer Shakti, the petitioner herein. The text of the said
communication dated 02.12.2021 [Annexure-R/4 to the reply filed by the
respondents No.3 and 4] having considered pertinent is fully extracted hereunder :
No.23/10/2017-R3(Part)
GOVERNMENT OF TRIPRUA
OFFICE OF REGISTRAR OF NEWSPAPERS FOR INDIA
(Ministry of Information & Broadcasting)
9th Floor, Soochna Bhawan, CGO Complex,
Lodhi Road, New Delhi-110003
2nd December, 2021
To
Shri Saju Vaheed A., IAS
District Magistrate & Collector,
South Tripura, Belonia, Tripura
Subject : Registration of „Kalamer Shakti‟, Bengali Daily published from Agartala.
Sir,
This is in reference to your letter No.F.6(398)/DM/S/JDL/2016/213 dated
24.06.2021 on the above subject.
2. In this connection, it informed that the title „Kalamer Shakti‟, was verified
by RNI on 29.08.2017 as Bengali Daily under Title Code “TRIBEN10404” in favour of
Shri Suman Nag from South Tripura District, Tripura.
3. The publisher applied for registration of „Kalamer Shakti‟ vide letter dated
26.09.2017. However, on scrutiny of the documents, certain discrepancies were
noticed and the same was intimated to the Publisher vide RNI letter dated
25.10.2017 (copy enclosed). Complete documents are yet to be received.
4. Now we have received a declaration sent under your seal and signature for
change of language of the Daily to English vide the said letter dated 24.06.2021. It is
informed that change of language of a verified/registered title at the time of filing
declaration is not permissible. The owner can apply afresh for verification of title in
the desire language(s) through the District Magistrate concerned, which shall be
verified based on availability, as per the PRB Act, 1867 and the title verification
guidelines.
Yours faithfully,
Illegible
(Ashutosh Mohle)
Assistant Press Registrar
15.
On appreciation of the averments and the records as produced by
the petitioner and the respondents, two pertinent questions fall for consideration of
this court. Those are –
(1) Whether the writ petition is maintainable in view of
Section 8C of the PRB Act which provides that any person
aggrieved by an order by a Magistrate to refuse to
authenticate a declaration under section 6 or cancelling a
declaration under section 8B may, within sixty days from the
date on which such order is communicated to him, prefer an
appeal to the Appellate Board to be called the Press and
Registration Appellate Board [consisting of a Chairman and
another member to be nominated by the Press Council of
India, established under section 4 of the Press Council Act,
1978 (37 of 1978), from among its members, provided that the
Appellate Board may entertain an appeal after the expiry of
the said period, if it is satisfied that the appellant was
prevented by sufficient cause from preferring the appeal in
time ?
(2) Whether for change of language of a newspaper whose
titled is already verified and registered it requires to be
registered afresh with the Press Registrar on furnishing copy
of the declaration under Section 6 of the said Act ?
16.
The petitioner’s contention is that no fresh registration is required.
Only a declaration under Section 5(2D) of the PRB Act would suffice, as on the
basis of the said declaration, the Press Registrar shall issue a fresh certificate by
changing the language of the newspaper. Section 5(2D) of the Act provides that
when the title of any newspaper or its language or the periodicity of its publication
is changed, the existing declaration ceases to have any effect. A new declaration
becomes necessary before the publication of the newspaper. The other changes
are not very material for our purpose.
17.
The respondents have in unison contended that the word
declaration as appearing in Section 5(2D) shall mean the declaration as referred in
Section 19C of the PRB Act. In the event, unless the certificate of registration under
Section 19C of the PRB Act is issued, no newspaper shall commence its publication.
The certificate of Registration is preceded by verification of the declaration and
approval of the title of the newspaper depends on availability of the title.
18.
In the considered view of this court, a conjoint reading of Section
5(2D) and Section 19C of the PRB Act would lead to an inference that for change of
language, a fresh verification is to be carried out by the Registrar of Newspapers
for India or the Press Registrar. On availability of the said title in English, the Press
Registrar shall issue the fresh Certificate of Registration. But the petitioner did not
follow the said procedure and as such, the contention of the petitioner cannot be
accepted by this court.
19.
So far the maintainability of the writ petition is concerned, this
court is of the view that by Section 8C of the PRB Act, the jurisdiction under Article
226 is not made absolutely barred. In this writ petition, the petitioner has
contended that a declaration under Section 5(2D) is sufficient for change of
language. Therefore, the issue precisely in the case in hand is whether such
declaration would suffice the purpose or not. This is a question of interpretation
and hence, this writ petition is maintainable and is not hit by the provisions of
Section 8C of the PRB Act. Section 19C of the PRB Act provides that on receiving
from the Magistrate the declaration under Section 6 of the PRB Act in respect of a
newspaper and on the publication of such newspaper, the Press Registrar shall, as
soon as practicable, thereafter issue that certificate of registration in respect of that
newspaper to the publisher thereof.
20.
By the communication dated 02.12.2021, the petitioner was
apprised by the Office of the Registrar of Newspapers for India that the change in
the language of a verified/registered title by filing a mere declaration is not
permissible. The owner or the publisher can apply for verification of title in the
desired language through the District Magistrate concerned. That shall be verified
based on availability of title as per the PRB Act, 1867 and the title verification
guidelines.
21.
It appears that the petitioner did not take any step as suggested
by the said letter dated 02.12.2021. Even no rejoinder has been filed against the
reply filed by the respondents No.3 and 4.
22.
Having appreciated the submission of the counsel appearing for the
parties and the records so produced with the writ petition and the replies, this court
is of the view that the petitioner has misconstrued the provisions of Section 5(2D)
of the PRB Act inasmuch as Section 5 of the PRB Act prescribes the rules for
publication of newspapers. Section 5(2A) provides specifically that every declaration
under Rule 2 shall specify the title of the newspaper, the language in which is to be
published and periodicity of its publication and such other particulars as may be
prescribed. It has been clearly stated under Section 5(2C) that a declaration under
Rule (2) and authenticated under Section 6 shall be necessary before the
newspaper can be published. In the prospective of those prescriptions, Section
5(2D) has provided that where the title of any newspaper or its language or its
periodicity of publication is changed, the declaration is ceased to be effective and a
new declaration is necessary before the publication of the newspaper can be
continued. Such declaration is required to be made conforming to the requirement
of Section 6 of the PRB Act, in respect of a newspaper, as soon as practicable, and
that be submitted to the Press Registrar. The Press Registrar shall as soon as
practicable issue a certificate of Registration in respect of that newspaper to the
publisher thereof. But the order of cancellation has been made under Section 8B of
the PRB Act, as according to the considered opinion of the District Magistrate, the
newspaper was being published in contravention of the provision of the PRB Act,
inasmuch as the petitioner did not get any Certificate of Registration under Section
19C of the PRB Act.
This court does not find any infirmity in the order dated
18.09.2021 [Annexure-9 to the writ petition] and hence, the writ petition stands
dismissed.
23.
Before parting with the records it is observed that the petitioner
may file the appropriate declaration conforming to the provisions of Section 6 of
the PRB Act and upon authentication, the District Magistrate, South Tripura, Belonia
shall forthwith forward the same to the Press Registrar, if the petitioner filed any
such declaration. It is further observed that the Press Registrar shall forthwith
consider the said declaration for purpose of issuing Certificate of Registration in
terms of Section 19C of the PRB Act, on verification of title vis-à-vis its availability.
This order will not create any embargo in the said process.
No order as to costs.
JUDGE
Sabyasachi B
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review