Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1NC: 2026:KHC-D:1350-DB
RFA No. 100337 of 2019
HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA, AT DHARWAD
DATED THIS THE 30TH DAY OF JANUARY, 2026
PRESENT
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE R.DEVDAS
AND
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE B. MURALIDHARA PAI
REGULAR FIRST APPEAL NO. 100337 OF 2019 (PAR)
BETWEEN:
VN
BADIGER
1.
SHRI SUDHAKAR S/O. PUTTA GOWDA,
(SUDHAKAR MOTA GOWDA),
SINCE DECEASED BY HIS LRS.
1A.
SMT. GOPI KOM. SUDHAKAR GOWDA,
AGE: 57 YEARS, OCC: HOUSE HOLD.
1B.
SRI. BAALA S/O. SUDHAKAR GOWDA,
AGE: 42 YEARS, OCC: AGRICULTURIST.
1C.
SMT. TARA D/O. SUDHAKAR GOWDA,
W/O. UDAY GOWDA,
AGE: 40 YEARS, OCC: HOUSEHOLD.
1D.
SMT. SULOCHANA
D/O. SUDHAKAR GOWDA,
W/O. PURUSHOTTAM GOWDA,
AGE: 36 YEARS, OCC: HOUSEHOLD.
1E.
SMT. URVASHI
D/O. SUDHAKAR GOWDA,
W/O. SANTOSH GOWDA,
AGE: 36 YEARS, OCC: HOUSEHOLD.
1F.
SRI MOHAN S/O. SUDHAKAR GOWDA,
AGE: 32 YEARS, OCC: AGRICULTURIST,
ALL ARE R/O. SEA BIRD COLONY,
BAAD VILLAGE, TODUR, TQ. KARWAR,
DIST. UTTARA KANNADA-581301.
Digitally signed
by V N
BADIGER
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
DHARWAD
BENCH
Date:
2026.02.04
14:52:51
+0530
-2NC: 2026:KHC-D:1350-DB
RFA No. 100337 of 2019
HC-KAR
2.
SHRI LAXMAN MOTA GOWDA,
SINCE DECEASED BY HIS LRS.
2A.
SMT. KAMALA KOM. LAXMAN GOUDA,
AGE: 45 YEARS, OCC: HOUSEHOLD.
2B.
SRI. SAISHWAR S/O. LAXMAN GOUDA,
AGE: 22 YEARS, OCC: STUDENT.
2C.
KUMARI SAHANA D/O. LAXMAN GOUDA,
MINOR, REP. BY MINOR GUARDIAN MOTHER,
SMT. KAMALA KOM. LAXMAN GOUDA,
ALL ARE R/AT: L.I.G.NO.179, 10TH CROSS,
NOW R/AT: NAVANAGAR, HUBLI TALUK,
DHARWAD DIST. 560001.
3.
SMT. GANGA KOM. KRISHNA GOWDA,
(SMT. GANGA D/O. MOTA GOWDA),
AGE: 56 YEARS, OCC: HOUSEHOLD,
R/O. HARWADA, TQ: KARWAR,
DIST: UTTARA KANNADA-581301.
4.
SMT. SHANTI KOM. RAMA GOWDA,
AGE: 54 YEARS, OCC: HOUSEHOLD,
R/O. POST CHENDIA, TQ: KARWAR,
DIST: UTTARA KANNADA-581301.
5.
SMT. VIMALA KOM. BOMMA GOWDA,
(SMT. VIMALA D/O. MOTA GOWDA),
AGE: 52 YEARS, OCC: HOUSEHOLD,
R/O. MADANGERI, TQ: KUMTA,
DIST: UTTARA KANNADA-581301.
6.
SMT. SHYAMALA KOM. NAGENDRA GOWDA,
AGE: 71 YEARS, OCC: HOUSEHOLD,
R/O. TODUR SEA BIRD, REHABILITATION
COLONY, TODUR, TQ: KARWAR,
DIST: UTTARA KANNADA-581301.
…APPELLANTS
(BY SRI. SABEEL AHMED, ADV. FOR SRI. A. S. PATIL, AND
SRI. S. K. HOSAMANI, ADVOCATES)
-3NC: 2026:KHC-D:1350-DB
RFA No. 100337 of 2019
HC-KAR
AND
1.
SMT. NAGI KOM. BHIMA GOWDA,
AGE: 66 YEARS, OCC: AGRICULTURE,
R/O. SANEMAKKI, AMADALLI, TALUK: KARWAR,
DIST: UTTARA KANNADA-581301.
2.
SHRI JAYA S/O. DINGA GOWDA,
SINCE DECEASED BY HER L.R.,
SMT. TIMMI W/O. JAYA GOWDA,
AGE: 64 YEARS, OCC: AGRICULTURE,
R/O. OKKALKERI, BINAGA, TQ: KARWAR,
DIST: UTTARA KANNADA-581301.
3.
SMT. SUMITRA KOM. LOKU GOWDA,
AGE: 61 YEARS, OCC: AGRICULTURE,
R/O. OKKALKERI, BINAGA TQ: KARWAR,
DIST: UTTARA KANNADA-581301.
4.
SMT. VASANTI KOM. MANI GOWDA,
AGE: 59 YEARS, OCC: AGRICULTURE,
R/O. BRAHMADEVWADA, AMADALLI,
TQ: KARWAR, DIST: UTTARA KANNADA-581301.
5.
SMT. YENKI KOM. GIDDA GOWDA,
AGE: 57 YEARS, OCC: AGRICULTURE,
R/O. BALERSAHI, POST: AMADALLI,
TQ: KARWAR, DIST: UTTARA KANNADA-581301.
6.
SHRI UGA DINGA GOWDA,
AGE: 55 YEARS, OCC: AGRICULTURE,
R/O. OKKALKERI, BINAGA, TQ: KARWAR,
DIST: UTTARA KANNADA-581301.
7.
SHRI CHANDU S/O. MANI GOWDA,
AGE: 57 YEARS, OCC: COOLIE,
R/O. HUNSEMAKKI, AMADALLI, TQ: KARWAR,
DIST: UTTARA KANNADA-581301.
8.
SHRI PRABHAKAR S/O. MOTA GOWDA,
AGE: 62 YEARS, OCC: AGRICULTURIST,
R/O. SEA BIRD COLONY, TODUR, TQ: KARWAR,
-4NC: 2026:KHC-D:1350-DB
RFA No. 100337 of 2019
HC-KAR
DIST: UTTARA KANNADA-581301.
9.
SMT. GEETA UDAY GOWDA,
DECEASED, BY HER L.R.
9A.
UFM SHRI UDAY BANTA GOWDA,
AGE: 42 YEARS, OCC: COOLIE,
R/O. TODUR, TALUK: KARWAR,
DIST: UTTARA KANNADA-581301.
10.
SMT. NARAYANI KOM. BABU GOWDA,
AGE: 71 YEARS, OCC: HOUSEHOLD,
R/O. TODUR SEA BIRD, REHABILITATION
COLONY, TODUR, TALUK: KARWAR,
DIST: UTTARA KANNADA-581301.
11.
SHRI VASU S/O. JARU GOWDA,
AGE: 66 YEARS, OCC: COOLIE,
R/O. OKKALKERI, BINAGA, TQ: KARWAR,
DIST: UTTARA KANNADA-581301.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. GIRISH A. YADAWAD, ADV. FOR R1 TO R6 AND R11;
SRI. P. G. MOGALI, ADV. FOR R7;
SRI. RAM P. GHORPADE, ADV. FOR R9(A);
NOTICE TO R8 & R10 ARE SERVED, BUT UNREPRESENTED)
THIS REGULAR FIRST APPEAL IS FILED UNDER SECTION 96
READ WITH ORDER 41 RULE 1 OF CPC., PRAYING TO SET ASIDE THE
JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED 21/12/2018 PASSED BY THE COURT
OF THE PRL. SENIOR CIVIL JUDGE, KARWAR IN O.S.NO.32/2013 AND
DISMISS THE SUIT O.S.NO.32/2013 ON THE FILE OF THE COURT OF
THE PRL. SENIOR CIVIL JUDGE, KARWAR, IN THE INTEREST OF
JUSTICE AND EQUITY.
THIS REGULAR FIRST APPEAL, HAVING BEEN HEARD AND
RESERVED ON 17.11.2025, COMING ON FOR ‘PRONOUNCEMENT OF
JUDGMENT’, THIS DAY, THE COURT PRONOUNCED THE FOLLOWING:
CORAM:
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE R.DEVDAS
AND
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE B. MURALIDHARA PAI
-5NC: 2026:KHC-D:1350-DB
RFA No. 100337 of 2019
HC-KAR
CAV JUDGMENT
(PER: THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE B. MURALIDHARA PAI)
Defendant Nos. 1, 3 to 6 and 8 in O.S. No.32/2013 have
filed this regular first appeal, praying to set aside the judgment
and decree dated 21.12.2018 by the learned Principal Senior
Civil Judge, Karwar, and secure dismissal of the suit.
2.
Parties in this appeal retain their original designations
from the trial court proceedings.
3.
The plaintiffs - Smt. Nagi and others, filed O.S. No.
32/2013, seeking a declaration that Plaintiff No. 1 holds a 5/20th
share, while Plaintiff Nos. 2 to 6 each hold a 1/20th share, in the
suit schedule properties. They further prayed for disbursement of
their respective portions from the compensation awarded for
acquisition of these lands under the Seabird Naval Base Project,
Karwar.
4. The Plaintiffs contended that the suit schedule properties
constituted joint family assets among the parties, undivided by
metes and bounds. They noted acquisition of these lands for the
Seabird Naval Base Project, Karwar, with partial compensation
-6NC: 2026:KHC-D:1350-DB
RFA No. 100337 of 2019
HC-KAR
already
deposited
in
the
concerned
court.
In
these
circumstances, the plaintiffs instituted the suit to secure their
shares, alleging defendants' refusal to disburse these legitimate
entitlements.
5. The suit originally arrayed Defendant Nos. 1 to 8, with
37 items listed in Schedules A and B. During the pendency of the
suit, Sri Chandu joined as Plaintiff No. 7; Smt. Narayani and Sri
Vasu were added as Defendant Nos. 9 and 10; and the plaintiffs
incorporated eight additional items as Schedule C.
6.
Upon service of summons, all the defendants entered
appearance through counsel. Defendant Nos. 2 and 9 filed
separate written statements, admitting plaintiffs' claims and
seeking decree as prayed, along with allocation of their own
shares in the compensation.
7. Defendant Nos. 7 and 10 abstained from filing a written
statement or contesting the suit.
8. Defendant Nos. 1 and 3 to 8 submitted a joint written
statement, denying all plaintiffs' averments. They asserted no
joint family ever existed among the parties; the plaintiffs never
-7NC: 2026:KHC-D:1350-DB
RFA No. 100337 of 2019
HC-KAR
resided in Kodar Village or derived usufruct from the properties
since 1961 until acquisition. They further pleaded separation post
the demise of Putta between Defendant No.1 and his natural
father, followed by partition involving Defendant No. 2 and
others, rendering the suit untenable and time-barred.
9.
Based on the above pleadings, and the documents
available on record, the trial Court framed following issues and
additional issues for its consideration:
ISSUES
1.
Whether the schedule 'A' and 'B' suit property
were the JFP of plaintiffs and defendants?
2.
Whether the suit is bad for non-joinder of
necessary parties?
3.
Whether the defendant No.1 proves that he alone
is entitled to the compensation amount in LAC
1/04 and in LAC 54/06?
4.
Whether the suit is bad for non inclusion of all the
properties?
5.
Whether the suit is bad for mis-joinder of
properties?
6.
Whether the suit is bad for mis-joinder of cause
of action?
7.
Whether the plaintiffs prove that the 1st plaintiff
has 5/20 share; 2 to 6 plaintiffs have 1/20 share
-8NC: 2026:KHC-D:1350-DB
RFA No. 100337 of 2019
HC-KAR
in the compensation amount pertaining to the suit
schedule property?
8.
Whether the plaintiffs are entitled for the reliefs
sought for?
9.
What Decree or order?
ADDITIONAL ISSUES FRAMED ON 09.11.2015
1.
Whether the plaintiff proves that the suit is within
time?
2.
Whether the plaintiff proves that valuation of suit
schedule properties is correct and court fees paid
thereof is proper?
3.
Whether the plaintiff proves that this Hon'ble
court has got jurisdiction to try and decide the
suit?
4.
Whether
the
suit
is
maintainable
without
impleading the S.L.A.O., as necessary party?
10. In support of their case, the plaintiffs examined Plaintiff
No.6 as PW-1, one more witness as PW-2, and got marked
documents at Ex.P1 to Ex.P50. Defendant Nos. 1 and 3 testified
as DW-1 and DW-2 respectively and got marked documents at
Ex.D1 to Ex.D94.
11. After hearing both sides and evaluating the record, the
trial court delivered the impugned judgment and decree holding
-9NC: 2026:KHC-D:1350-DB
RFA No. 100337 of 2019
HC-KAR
that Plaintiff No.1 entitled to a 1/4th share, Plaintiff Nos. 2 to 6
and Defendant No. 10 jointly to another 1/4th share, and
Defendant Nos.1 to 9 entitled to remaining ½ share in Item
Nos.1, 3, 7, and 9 to 39 of the schedule properties and their
compensation. The trial court dismissed the suit of Plaintiff No. 7
for want of evidence, proving his status as son of the deceased
Pokki, the eldest daughter of Rami.
12. Aggrieved, Defendant Nos. 1, 3 to 6, and 8 preferred
this appeal, assailing the judgment and decree as contrary to
evidence and law. Learned Counsel Sri Sabeel Ahmed, for Sri
A.S. Patil and Sri S.K. Hosamani, Advocates for Appellants, urged
that the trial court overlooked plaintiffs’ exclusion from joint
possession and usufruct sharing, of the properties in question
since 1961, alongside defendants’ open and exclusive enjoyment
of those properties as absolute owners thereof. Despite framing
a limitation issue, the trial court erroneously decreed the suit,
ignoring plaintiffs’ ouster over 52 years. Counsel highlighted the
acquisition of the properties, rendering it non-existent at filing of
the suit and the trial court's failure to address questions of
estoppel, waiver, and latches on the part of the plaintiffs and
- 10 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1350-DB
RFA No. 100337 of 2019
HC-KAR
prayed for reversal of the decree.
13.
Per contra, Sri Girish A. Yadawad, Counsel for
Respondent Nos.1 to 6 and 11, Sri P.G. Mogali, Counsel for
Respondent No.7, and Sri Ram P. Ghorpade, Counsel for
Respondent
No.9(a)
maintained
that
the
properties
were
undivided joint family assets of Laxman and Krishna. Revenue
entries in names of Putta @ Putanya, Mota, and others served
the family's collective interest. Upholding the trial court's findings
as evidence-based, they urged dismissal of the appeal for want
of merit.
14.
Having meticulously considered rival contentions and
re-appraised the record, the core issue for determination
emerges - whether the trial court was justified in declaring the
properties in question as joint family properties and that the
plaintiffs are entitled for a share in the compensation amount
awarded in respect of acquired properties.
15.
First of all, the averments of the plaint gives an
impression that the plaintiffs have claim over all 45 items of
properties mentioned at Schedule A to Schedule C of the plaint.
- 11 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1350-DB
RFA No. 100337 of 2019
HC-KAR
A careful scrutiny of the averments, however, reveals that the
claim of the plaintiffs is only in the compensation amount, arising
from LAC Nos. 1/2004 and 54/2006.
16.
The Plaintiffs have tendered certified copies of
judgments in LAC No.1/2004 and LAC No. 54/2006 at Ex.P43
and Ex.P44. These documents go to show that these proceedings
were the references under Section 18 of the Land Acquisition
Act, initiated by Defendant No.1 - Sri Sudhakar, and his mother Smt. Nagi, Wife of Mota Gouda, seeking enhanced compensation
for 33 items of properties, situated in Kodar Village, Karwar
Taluk, which were acquired for Seabird Naval Base Project,
Karwar. Thereby, it becomes clear that the claim of the plaintiffs
is restricted to only 33 items of properties referred in LAC
Nos.1/2004 and 54/2006.
17.
At this stage, it would be useful to refer to the
written submissions of the plaintiffs, filed before the trial court
on 01.12.2018 during the course of final arguments, which reads
as under :
“Though the suit schedule properties at Serial Nos.2, 4 to
6, 8, 15, 40 to 45 were once the joint family properties. But,
- 12 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1350-DB
RFA No. 100337 of 2019
HC-KAR
in the passage of time, they went out of the hands of the
plaintiffs and the defendants. Hence, those properties are no
longer the joint family properties of the plaintiffs and the
defendants and they do not have any share in them.
The suit schedule properties at Serial Nos.1, 3, 7, 9 to 38
and 39 are the joint family properties. Also, these properties
have been acquired for the Sea-Bird Naval Base Project,
Karwar and award enhancing the compensation of these
lands is passed by the Hon’ble Court of Senior Civil Judge,
Karwar.
The plaintiff No.1 being the daughter of Laxman and the
plaintiff Nos.2 to 6 and defendant Nos.10 and 11 being the
L.Rs of Smt. Rami who was another daughter of Laxman, are
entitled for share in the suit schedule properties except at
serial Nos.2, 4 to 6, 8, 15, 40 to 45 and also the enhanced
compensation in respect of those lands. The award LAC
No.1/04 is at Exhibit P.43 and the award LAC No.54/06 is at
Exhibit P.44.”
18.
trial
court
Further, in para 29 of the impugned judgment, the
has
referred
to
the
above
mentioned
written
submissions filed on behalf of the plaintiffs and proceeded to
decree the suit by declaring the rights of the parties only in
respect of Item Nos.1, 3, 7 and 9 to 39 of suit schedule
properties.
- 13 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1350-DB
RFA No. 100337 of 2019
HC-KAR
19.
In their
written
submission,
the
plaintiffs have
specifically stated that the property mentioned at Sl.No.15 is no
longer a joint family property and that they do not have any
share
in the
said property. In spite
of such categorical
statement/admission, the trial court proceeded to pass a decree
even in respect of the property mentioned at Item No.15, which
was a gross error. In view of the same, it is to be held that the
claim of the plaintiffs needs to be considered only in respect of
the properties mentioned at Item Nos.1, 3, 7, 9 to 14, 16 and 17
in Schedule A, Item Nos.18 to 37 in Schedule B and Item Nos.38
and 39 in Schedule C of the plaint.
20.
The details of the properties involved in LAC
Nos.1/2004 and 54/2006 and details of corresponding suit
schedule properties are as under:
In LAC No.1/2004
In O.S. No.32/2013
Sl. No.
Sy. No.
Extent
Sl.No
Sy. No.
Extent
159/1
00.18.00
159/1
00.19.08
126/7
00.37.00
126/7
01.08.00
171/12
00.06.08
171/12
00.06.08
- 14 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1350-DB
RFA No. 100337 of 2019
HC-KAR
171/9
00.02.00
171/9
00.02.02
167/10
00.06.00
167/10
00.06.00
167/6
00.06.00
167/6
00.06.00
165/5A
00.04.00
165/5A
00.04.00
162/21
00.02.12
162/21
00.02.12
&
162/24
00.10.18
162/24
00.10.08
126/13
00.02.08
126/13
00.02.08
126/15
00.06.00
126/5
00.06.00
126/17
00.02.12
-
-
-
01.24.00
01.24.00
162/2
00.04.04
162/2
00.04.04
62/26
00.06.12
162/26
00.06.12
171/1
00.28.00
171/1
00.28.00
162/18
00.05.12
162/18
00.05.12
162/9
00.08.08
162/9
00.08.08
- 15 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1350-DB
RFA No. 100337 of 2019
HC-KAR
162/6
00.03.12
162/6
00.03.12
162/14
00.02.02
162/14
00.02.02
00.04.04
00.04.04
171/13
00.07.00
171/13
00.07.00
148A1/B
01.11.00
148A/1B
01.11.00
In LAC No.54/2006
215A/1
01.33.00
2 15A/1
01.33.00
215A/2
00.06.08
215A/2
00.06.08
215A/9
01.25.12
215A/9
02.03.00
215A/4
00.03.04
215/4
00.03.04
215A/20
00.26.04
215A/20
00.30.00
215A/11
00.06.00
215A/11
00.06.00
01.01.00
01.01.00
215A/15
00.10.00
215A/15
00.10.00
- 16 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1350-DB
RFA No. 100337 of 2019
HC-KAR
00.04.04
00.04.04
01.24.00
01.24.00
21.
The contents of the above table go to show that the
plaintiffs have not claimed any right in the property mentioned
as Item No.12 i.e, Sy. No.126/17 measuring 00.02.12 of Kodar
Village. Further, the plaintiffs have shown the same property i.e,
Sy.No.162/21 measuring 00.02.12 as Item Nos.9 and 25 as if
those were two different properties. In the absence of sufficient
evidence on record to support such claim of the plaintiffs, any
one of these items i.e, 9 or 25, can be considered for the
purpose of the suit. Similarly, in LAC Nos.1/2004 and 54/2006,
both
the
claimants
compensation
in
have
respect
sought
of
two
for
enhancement
properties
of
of
identical
descriptions i.e, Sy.Nos.255 measuring 1.24 acres and 260
measuring 0.04.04 acre. Whereas, the plaintiffs have mentioned
about these properties only at Item Nos. 35 and 36. In the above
circumstances, it is to be held that the plaintiffs are claiming
their share in the compensation amount awarded in respect of
properties mentioned at Sl.Nos.1, 3, 7, 9 to 11, 13, 14, 16 to 24
- 17 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1350-DB
RFA No. 100337 of 2019
HC-KAR
and 26 to 37 only.
In other words, they have claimed their
share in the compensation awarded in respect of 10 items of
properties in Schedule A and 19 items of properties in Schedule
B, in all 29 items of suit schedule properties.
22.
The materials on record make it clear that the parties
are not at dispute regarding their inter-se relationship. One
Sukru Gouda was the propositus of the family. He had two sons
by name Laxman and Krishna.
23.
Admittedly, Krishna died on 03.02.1934 leaving
behind his three children namely Mota, Putta and Nagamma.
Putta died on 16.11.1975. Mota died on 22.07.1980. Even
Nagamma is dead. Further, Putta and Nagamma died issueless.
Defendant Nos.1 to 6 and defendant No.9 are the children of
Mota. He had one more daughter by name Sushila. She died
leaving behind her two daughters i.e., Defendant Nos.7 and 8.
24.
Further, Laxman died on 06.03.1961 leaving behind
two daughters namely Rami and Nagi, Plaintiff No.1 herein. Rami
died on 09.10.1999. Plaintiff Nos.2 to 6 are the children of Rami.
She had one more daughter by name Pokki, who died in the year
- 18 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1350-DB
RFA No. 100337 of 2019
HC-KAR
1969 leaving behind a son by name Chandu. He is Plaintiff No.7
in the suit.
25.
At this stage, it would be proper to refer to the
relevant averments in para 1 of the plaint, for better appreciation
of the claim of the plaintiffs, which reads as follows:
“Laxman Sukru Gouda and Krishna Sukru Gouda are
the full blood brothers and were residing jointly in
Kodar Village of Karwar Taluka.
The suit schedule A
properties were in the name of Laxman Sukru Gouda
and the suit schedule B properties were in the name of
Krishna Sukru Gouda. Though in the Record of Rights
the properties were mentioned separately, there was
no partition in the family by metes and bounds. Only
for the sake of convenience, some of the properties
were in the name of Laxman Sukru Gouda and rest of
the properties were in the name of Krishna Sukru
Gouda. Suit schedule A and B properties are the joint
family properties of the joint brothers….”
26.
The
above averments of the
plaint clearly
indicate that out of 29 items of properties in question, 10
items of properties in Schedule A were standing in the name
of Laxman and remaining 19 items of properties in Schedule
- 19 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1350-DB
RFA No. 100337 of 2019
HC-KAR
B were standing in the name of Krishna.
The revenue
entries in the individual names of Laxman and Krishna,
presupposes that these properties being their absolute and
separate properties.
As such, the burden was on the
plaintiffs to plead and prove that all those properties were
the joint family properties. Yet, the plaint offers no specific
details on how or through what means Laxman and Krishna
acquired these properties, nor evidence of their blending or
throwing into common stock for joint possession and
enjoyment.
Instead,
the
plaintiffs
merely
alleged
a
convenient arrangement, but failed to produce cogent
evidence in support.
27.
Additionally, the plaintiffs assert that following
Krishna's death, the Schedule B properties were transferred
to Putta @ Putanya Krishna Gouda as manager of the
undivided family, and later, upon Putta's demise, to his
brother Mota Krishna Gouda. These transfers raise no
irregularity, as admittedly both were Krishna's legal heirs
and from his branch. Such mutation from father to sons
represents a routine and logical succession.
- 20 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1350-DB
RFA No. 100337 of 2019
HC-KAR
28.
The plaintiffs maintain that Schedules A and B
properties were the joint family properties of Laxman and
Krishna.
Despite
this,
they
offer
no
explanation
for
transferring Schedule B properties from the name of Krishna
to his sons while his brother Laxman remained alive. Their
vague claim is that the properties passed to Putta as family
manager post Krishna's death on 3.2.1934, which lacks
supporting evidence. Laxman, the eldest family member,
who survived until 6.3.1961 and outliving Krishna by over
27 years. Had these been joint family holdings, mutation
would naturally have occurred in Laxman's name. In the
absence of proof, the plaintiffs fail to establish that
Schedules A and B constituted joint or family properties of
Laxman and Krishna, or of the suit parties.
29.
The record discloses that during the life-time of
Mota, certain properties in his name were mutated in the
names of Defendant No.1, Nanibai, and his wife namely Nagi
Mota Gouda. Post Mota's death, his remaining properties
passed to his son - Defendant No.2, as family manager. The
plaintiffs can raise no objection to these mutations in
- 21 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1350-DB
RFA No. 100337 of 2019
HC-KAR
respect of Schedule B properties as they trace title through
Laxman and distinct from Krishna's lineage.
30.
In contrast, the contesting defendants provide a
cogent account.
Following the death of Putta @ Puttanya,
the properties standing in his name were partitioned among
Defendants Nos.1 to 9, as reflected in revenue entries in ME
2070 and 2167. They further aver that Defendant No.1, who
was biological son of Mota, was adopted by Putta during
minority. The Aadhaar Card produced at Ex.D46 and Voter
ID produced at Ex.D47, both identify Defendant No.1 as the
son of Putta.
Moreover, in the plaint of O.S. No.7/2011
(produced at Ex.D49), filed by Defendant No.2 against
Defendants Nos.3 to 6 before the Principal Senior Civil
Judge, Karwar, seeking a share in the compensation
awarded in LAC No.54/2006, Defendant No.1 is shown as
the son of Putta.
This acknowledgment on the side of
Defendant No.2 coupled with the revenue entries over a
period of time and the claims of Defendant No.1 and his
mother in LAC Nos.1/2004 and 54/2006, bolster the
contention of the defendants.
- 22 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1350-DB
RFA No. 100337 of 2019
HC-KAR
31.
The
final
issue
concerns
the
mutation
of
Laxman's Schedule A properties to Putta @ Putanya Krishna
Gouda and its implications. The plaintiffs submit that post
Laxman's death, these should have passed to his daughters
namely Rami and Nagi. Instead, they were entered in the
name of Putta as joint family manager. They allege such
RTC entries rotated among managers per family decisions,
aiding collective benefit.
32.
Primarily, the plaintiffs have not established that
Laxman and Krishna resided jointly or that Schedule A and B
properties were family properties.
Absent this foundation,
claims of mutations to managers like Putta for family
welfare merit rejection. Records confirm that after Laxman's
death, some Schedule A properties mutated to Putta vide
ME 1837 dated 13.3.1962, which were later on transferred
in the name of Mota and others. However, it is to be noted
that the contesting defendants, in para 3 of their written
statement, contended that –
“… The Defendant No.1 was a minor probably about
4 years of age and Defendant No.3-8 were not even
- 23 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1350-DB
RFA No. 100337 of 2019
HC-KAR
born at the time of death of said Lakshman. Therefore
the allegation in Para 2 of the plaint is not within the
knowledge of these defendants and therefore plaintiffs
are put to strict proof of the death, his residence, etc.
From the alleged ME No.1837 it is evident that the said
Lakshman Sukru Gouda died at Amadalli. It is for the
plaintiffs to explain why their name was not mutated if
they were in possession and cultivation of Schedule A
properties…”.
In view of the same, it is to be held that the revenue entries
alone yield no presumption favoring plaintiffs without discharging
the initial burden of proving their case.
33.
Notably,
despite
initial
mutation
in
and
subsequent entries excluding Laxman's daughters and his heirs,
the plaintiffs neither sought their own inclusion nor challenged
exclusions. This inaction defies explanation.
Further, the
acquisition of lands for Seabird Naval Base Project began with
S.4(1) notification issued on 20.10.1986, followed by S.11 award
on 27.4.1988. Later, based on objections to the quantum of the
compensation awarded, the matters were referred to the court
for its adjudication.
Accordingly, the references pertaining to
Defendant No.1 and his mother in LAC Nos.1/2004 and 54/2006,
- 24 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1350-DB
RFA No. 100337 of 2019
HC-KAR
came to be decided on 31.3.2006 and 5.7.2008 respectively.
During these developments, the plaintiffs asserted no claim
either to the properties or for compensation.
34.
The plaintiffs filed this suit on 09.10.2013, alleging
cause of action on 25.09.2013 when the defendants refused
them share in the compensation amount. They claim that at this
point of time, on verification they came to know about the
revenue entries in the name of Defendant No.1. Against the
factual matrix, this reveals lack of due diligence on the part of
the plaintiffs in protecting their interest if any, in Schedule A
properties within legal limits.
35.
The trial court deemed Schedule A and B as joint
family properties by relying on RTC entries showing Laxman and
Putta's half-shares and mention about properties being in
'Samayak' status. On re-appreciating the materials available on
record, we find the trial court has overlooked the pleadings and
proof. No reasoned basis supports joint ownership between
Laxman and Krishna. The impugned judgment and decree is thus
erroneous and liable to be set aside.
- 25 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1350-DB
RFA No. 100337 of 2019
HC-KAR
36.
In the result, this Court proceeds to pass the
following:
ORDER
(i)
Appeal is allowed with cost throughout.
(ii)
The judgment and decree dated 21.12.2018
passed in O.S.No.32/2013 by learned Principal
Senior Civil Judge, Karwar is set aside and
consequently the suit is dismissed.
(iii)
Draw a decree accordingly.
(iv)
The registry is directed to send back entire trial
court record to concerned court along with a
copy of judgment and decree.
Sd/(R.DEVDAS)
JUDGE
Sd/(B. MURALIDHARA PAI)
JUDGE
VB, CKK
CT:AN
List No.: 19 Sl No.: 1
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review