Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page 1
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No. 444 of 2023
Sri Srinibash Bhattacharjee, son of late Ratul Charan Bhattacharjee,
resident of Dhaleswar Road No.3, P.O. Dhaleswar, P.S. East Agartala,
Sub-Division- Agartala, District- West Tripura, PIN 799007
…..Petitioner
-VERSUS1.
The State of Tripura, represented by the Commissioner &
Secretary, Power Department, Government of Tripura, having his office
at Secretariat Building, P.O. Kunjaban-799006, P.S. New Capital
Complex, District- West Tripura.
2.
The Commissioner & Secretary, Power Department,
Government of Tripura, having his office at Secretariat Building, P.O.
Kunjaban-799006, P.S. New Capital Complex, District- West Tripura.
3.
The Additional Secretary, Department of Power, Government
of Tripura, having his office at Secretariat Building, P.O. Kunjaban799006, P.S. New Capital Complex, District- West Tripura.
4.
Tripura State Electricity Corporation Limited, represented by
its Managing Director, having his office at Banamalipur, Agartala.
5.
The Managing Director, Tripura State Electricity Corporation
Limited, having his office at Banamalipur, Agartala.
….Respondents
For Petitioner (s )
:
For Respondent (s) :
Date of hearing & delivery:
of judgment & order
Whether fit for reporting :
Mr. Somik Deb, Sr. Advocate
Mr. P. Chakraborty, Advocate
Mr. Kohinoor N. Bhattacharyya, GA
Mr. N. Majumder, Advocate
18.04.2024
Yes
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
By means of filing the instant writ petition, the petitioner has
challenged the impugned order of rejection of his request to withdraw his
notice of voluntary retirement.
2.
The petitioner had joined in service on 26.11.1986. While
discharging his duties and responsibilities as Deputy General Manager,
(Rev), the petitioner vide his communication dated 20.08.2022 (Annexure 1
Page 2
to the writ petition) addressed to the Managing Director, Tripura State
Electricity Corporation Limited (for short “TSECL”) had expressed his
willingness to go on voluntary retirement w.e.f. afternoon of 30.11.2022.
However, his immediate superior officer vide Note no. 1, dated 26.08.2022,
requested the petitioner to re-think over the matter. Ultimately, under
Memorandum dated 14.10.2022 (Annexure 2 to the writ petition), the
competent authority i.e. the Additional Secretary, Government of Tripura,
accepted the request for voluntary retirement made by the petitioner with
effect from afternoon on 30.11.2022 in terms of notice dated 20.08.2022.
But, the petitioner vide his letter dated 18.11.2022 addressing the Managing
Director, TSECL, requested for allowing him to withdraw his letter of
request for voluntary retirement. The said letter dated 18.11.2022
(Annexure 3 to the writ petition), inter alia, reads as under:
“To,
The Managing director
Tripura State Electricity Corporation Ltd.,
Corporate Office, TSECL, Agartala.
(THROUGH PROPER CHANNEL)
Sub:- Withdrawal of the Notice of Voluntary retirement before the intended date of taking its
effects.
Ref. 1) No. F.2(26-A)/Power/2005/pt-II/2537-45, dated 11.10.2022 of the Addl. Secretary to
the Government of Tripura.
2) No. F.2(14)-TSECL/Estt-II/86/42019-21, Dated 19.10.2022 of the Deputy General
Manager, Corporate, Corporate office, TSECL, Agartala.
Respected sir,
I beg to be allowed the refer to my prayer dated 20.08.2022 addressed to the
Managing Director, T.S.E.C. Ltd. Out of emotion for allowing me to go to the Voluntary
retirement w.e.f. the afternoon of 30.11.2022 which has not attained.
Acceptance of my Voluntary retirement having not been communicated to me, I
have decided to withdraw my prayer/notice of voluntary retirement before the intended date
of taking its effect under provision to rule 48 A(4), CCS(Pension) Rules, 1972.
I would, therefore, humbly request you for allowing me to withdraw my
prayer/notice of Voluntary retirement in view of Rules quoted above.
With due Regards.
Dated, Agartala
Yours faithfully
The 18/11/2022
Sd/(SRINIBASH BHATTACHARJEE)
Deputy General Manager (Rev)
O/O the Deputy General Manager
Electrical Division No. II
Bardowali:Agartala.”
The said request of the petitioner had been rejected by the
competent authority and the same was communicated to the petitioner vide
Page 3
letter dated 07.12.2022 (Annexure 5 to the writ petition). The said letter of
rejection, inter alia, reads as under:“TRIPURA STATE ELECTRICITY CORPORATION LIMITED
(A GOVERNMENT OF TRIPURA ENTERPRISE)
(CIN-U40101TR20045GC007434)
GSTN- 16AACCT2964MIZY
No. F.2(14)-TSECL/13/S/48,357-61,
th
Dated, Agartala, the 7 December, 2022
To,
Shri Srinibash Bhattacharjee
Retd. Executive Engineer (Electrical)
TPES Gr-III on ad-hoc basis,
C/o Lt. Ratul Charan Bhattacharjee,
Dhaleswar Road No. 3
Near Blue Lotus Club, Agartala, Tripura (W)
PIN-799007
Sub:-
Representation dated 18.11.2022 for withdrawal the notice of voluntary retirement
Ref.:-
Your representation dated 18.11.2022.
Sir,
With reference to your afore-said representation dated 18.11.2022 for withdrawal
the notice of voluntary retirement submitted by yourself has been rejected by the Department
of Power, Govt. of Tripura communicated vide U.O. No. 2991/Power/2022 dated 06.12.2022.
This for favour of your kind information please.
Yours Sincerely
Sd/(Er. R. Debbarma)
Dy. General Manager (Corporate)
`
Corporate Office, TSECL”
Feeling aggrieved, the petitioner has filed the instant writ petition
challenging the said order of rejection dated 07.12.2022 alleging that the
same is contrary to the provisions embodied in Rule 48-A(4) of the Central
Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 1972 [for short “CCS(Pension) Rules”]
3.
With the aforesaid background of facts, I have heard Mr. Somik
Deb, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr. P. Chakraborty, learned counsel
appearing for the petitioner, and Mr. N. Majumder, learned counsel
appearing for the respondents No. 4 and 5, TSECL, and Mr. Kohinoor N.
Bhattacharyya, learned GA appearing for the respondents-State.
4.
The main argument advanced by learned senior counsel appearing
for the petitioner, is that, Rule 48-A of the CCS(Pension) Rules provides
that an employee can withdraw his notice/request for voluntary retirement
before the intended date mentioned in his letter of request. According to
Page 4
learned senior counsel, there is no rule debarring an employee from making
such request of withdrawal before the date which he has elected in his
notice for voluntary retirement. In support of his contention, Mr. Deb,
learned senior counsel has pressed reliance upon the following decisions:
(i) Balaram Gupta vs. Union of India and another, reported in 1989 (2)
SLR, 170; (ii) Punjab National Bank vs. Shri P.K. Mittal, reported in
1989 (1) SLR, 596;
5.
On the other hand, Mr. Majumder, learned counsel for the
respondent- TSECL has submitted that the conduct of the petitioner
disentitles him from continuing his service. Mr. Majumder, learned counsel
to persuade this court submits that earlier also the petitioner had made
similar request for voluntary retirement vide letter dated 15.02.2019 w.e.f.
31.07.2019, which was accepted by respondent nos. 3 and 4 on 30.07.2019
allowing him to go on voluntary retirement with effect from 31.07.2019, i.e.
the date he mentioned in his request letter. However, the same was
withdrawn by the petitioner vide letter dated 16.07.2019 and competent
authority of TSECL acceded to his request. Again the petitioner submitted a
letter expressing to go on voluntary retirement w.e.f. 01.08.2020 vide letter
dated 01.05.2020. The respondent-TSECL accepted it vide Memo dated
15.06.2020 and again, the petitioner made request for withdrawal of the
same under communication dated 10.08.2020, which was accepted by the
competent authority.
Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the respondentsTSECL further submits that the petitioner again made a request for
voluntary retirement vide letter dated 20.08.2022 to be effective from
afternoon of 30.11.2022. Under Memo dated 14.08.2022, the competent
Page 5
authority of respondent-TSECL accepted the said request of the petitioner.
This time also, the petitioner had withdrawn the said notice of voluntary
retirement vide letter dated 18.11.2022. Mr. Majumder, has tried to bring to
my notice that the office of the respondents-TSECL had received the same
on 23.11.2022 as it was submitted on the said date.
The main contention of Mr. Majumder, learned counsel for
the respondent-TSECL is that the petitioner is not fit to continue his service
because of his conduct that on 3 occasions he submitted prayers for
voluntary retirement and on each occasion he had withdrawn the same.
Such conduct is not only unexpected from a disciplined employee, but, also
unbecoming and a kind of disobedience towards the authority of the
employer. As such, the impugned order of rejection should not be interfered
with by this court.
6.
In the above backdrop of submissions, this court has to decide
the disputes raised in the writ petition and the only point falls for
consideration is whether the rejection to the request for withdrawal of
voluntary retirement dated 20.08.2022 before the intended date i.e. w.e.f.
30.11.2022 (A/N), is tenable in law?
7.
To look for an answer to the above question, firstly, it would
be apposite to make reference to Rule 48-A(1) (2) and (4) of “CCS(Pension)
Rules”, 1972, which is as under:
“48-A. Retirement on completion of 20 years’ qualifying service.
(1) At any time after a Government servant has completed twenty years’ qualifying
service, he may, by giving notice of not less than three months in writing to the
Appointing Authority, retire from service.
xxx
xxx
xxx
(2) The notice of voluntary retirement given under sub-rule (1) shall require acceptance
by the Appointing Authority:
Provided that where the Appointing Authority does not refuse to grant the
permission for retirement before the expiry of the period specified in the said notice,
the retirement shall become effective from the date of expiry of the said period.
Page 6
(3) xxx
(4) A Government servant, who has elected to retire under this rule and has given the
necessary notice to that effect to the Appointing Authority, shall be precluded from
withdrawing his notice except with the specific approval of such authority:
Provided that the request for withdrawal shall be made before the intended date of
his retirement”.
8.
F.R.56 (k) is also relevant to the context of the instant case,
which reads thus:
“F.R.56(k) (1). Any government servant may, by giving notice of not less than three
months in writing to the appropriate authority, retire from service after he has attained
the age of fifty years, if he is in Group ‘A’ or Group ‘B’ service or post, (and had entered
Government service before attaining the age of thirty-five years), and in all other cases
after he has attained the age of fifty-five years”.
9.
On conjoint reading of the above provisions, it comes to fore
that normal rule to seek voluntary retirement is to request to go on voluntary
retirement within a period not less than 3 months. A government employee
make a request/prayer to the competent authority expressing his willingness
to go on retirement before the normal date of retirement by giving notice of
not less than three months in writing electing a specified date and time of
such voluntary retirement. Proviso to sub-rule(4) to Rule 48-A of CCA
(Pension) rules contemplates that such request/notice of voluntary
retirement may be withdrawn before the intended/elected date the
government employee mentions in his notice of voluntary retirement.
10.
Now, keeping the above statutory schemes, in the context of
the case in hand, it would be apposite to make reference to the letter dated
20.08.2022 addressed to the Managing Director, TSECL with a request
expressing his willingness to go on voluntary retirement w.e.f. the afternoon
on 30.11.2022, which reads as under:
“TRIPURA STATE ELECTRICITY CORPORATION LIMITED
(A Govt. of Tripura Enterprise)
File No. F.TECH/ED-II/27/116-17
Dated 20.08.2022
To,
The Managing Director,
Tripura State Electricity Corporation Limited
Banamalipur, Agartala
(Through Proper Channel)
Page 7
Sub:- Posting as a DGM(Rev) under Electrical Division No.II, Bardowali.
Sir,
With due respect this is to inform you that I have joined in the office of the Deputy
General Manager (Rev) vide office order no F.MD/14.0/TSECL/2022/174435-52, Dt-7th
May 2022 on 18.05.2022 as a DGM (Rev) and rendering my service to increase the
revenue.
It is very painful to me that for close monitoring of revenue activities, I have no
vehicle for movement at Sub-Division level under ED-II (Six no. of Sub-Division) and
other requirements of petty expenditure for boost up of revenue. So proper
maintaining may not be possible.
In different occasion I have placed file before your authority for approval. But no
fruitful corresponding received yet. I don't know about the decision of authority.
In this situation, it is very hard for me to hold the position of last year position in
respect of revenue realization of ED-II Bordowali, even though my sincere works.
So, the authority may kindly be communicating proper work space / guide line in
the interest of TSECL and to perform my service towards revenue boost-up as assigned,
sanctioning minimum requirement of vehicle and petty expenditure.
Since beginning as DGM(Rev), of ED-II, Bordowali I am incapable to deliver the
satisfied service for the lack of mentioned requirement rather I am burdening TSECL.
In this environment I shall bound to enclosing my voluntary retirement letter with
this application for your kind acceptance w.e.f afternoon of 30th November 2022. So, I
hope my submission may be accepted from your end please.
Thanking you.
Yours faithfully
Sd/Srinibash Bhattacharjee
Dy General Manager (Rev)
Electrical Division No. II
Bordowali, Agartala”
The said request was accepted by the competent authority
under Memo dated 14.10.2022, which is quoted here-in-below:
“No.F.2(26-A)/Power/2005/Pt-II/2537-45
Government of Tripura
Department of Power
Tripura:Agartala
Dated:Agartala, the 14th October, 2022
MEMORANDUM
The undersigned is directed to inform that the prayer dated 20.08.2022 of Sri
Srinibash Bhattacharjee, Executive Engineer (Electrical) attached to the office of the
Deputy General Manager, Electrical Division No. II, Bardowali, Agartala, West Tripura
for Voluntary Retirement w.e.f. 30.11.2022 (A.N) is hereby accepted subject to Rule
48(A)(b) of Central Civil Service (Pension) Rule 1972 under clause (a)
S/d U. Sinha
Additional Secretary to the
Government of Tripura”
11.
Having given my thoughtful consideration to the above
provisions, and particularly, the related law that notice period requires at
least 3 (three) months, in my opinion, the legislature intended to enable a
government employee to adjust and re-think over the matter, so that such
government employee is not swayed or surrendered to his emotion or
sentiment due to unfavourable working atmosphere or certain other
Page 8
compelling circumstances which compelled him to seek voluntary
retirement. For this purpose, proviso to Rule 48(A)(4) clearly bestows a
government servant with the liberty, or to say it otherwise, an option to
make a request for withdrawal of his notice of voluntary retirement prior to
the intended date of his retirement. The expression “intended date of
retirement” means and connotes the date and time the government employee
mentions in letter of request for voluntary retirement.
12.
In the instant case, in his letter dated 20.08.2022, the
petitioner requested the competent authority-TSECL to accept his notice of
voluntary retirement w.e.f. 30.11.2022 (afternoon). True it is, that before
expiry of notice period of voluntary retirement, the competent authority had
accepted the said request with effect from the date which was the intended
date of retirement of the petitioner, but, that will not in any way create an
embargo or debar the petitioner from withdrawing his letter of request for
voluntary retirement prior to the date he mentions in his letter of request for
voluntary retirement i.e. on 30.11.2022 (A/N).
13.
Admittedly, the petitioner submitted his letter of request for
withdrawal of the notice of voluntary retirement on 18.11.2022 which was
received by the office of the competent authority on 23.11.2022 i.e. prior to
30.11.2022.
14.
I have carefully gone through the decisions rendered in the
cited cases referred to supra and accept the broad principles in the cases of
Balaram Gupta (supra) and P.K. Mittal (supra) where the Hon’ble
Supreme Court has categorically held that it is the wisdom of the employee
to elect a specific date of voluntary retirement/ resignation and before the
said intended date such employee can withdraw the same.
Page 9
15.
Keeping in view the statutory provisions quoted here-in-
above and the principles delineated in the cases of Balaram Gupta (supra)
and P.K. Mittal (supra), in the context of the case, the impugned order of
rejection of the letter of withdrawal of voluntary retirement made by the
petitioner prior to the intended date of retirement is not sustainable and
accordingly, the impugned order dated 07.12.2022 issued by the competent
authority i.e. Additional Secretary to the Government of Tripura under
Memo dated 14.10.2022 stands set-aside and quashed. As a sequel, the
petitioner is entitled to all service benefits.
At this juncture, Mr. Majumder, learned counsel for the
respondents-TSECL has submitted that consequent to his birth as on
17.10.1963, the petitioner has already been superannuated w.e.f. 31.10.2023
on attaining the age of 60 years. Be that as it may, the respondents are
directed to regularize the service of the petitioner treating his normal date of
retirement on attaining the age of superannuation, that is, 60 (sixty) years in
terms of the observations and directions made here-in-above and provide all
financial and service benefits to the petitioner in accordance with law.
The entire exercise shall be completed within a period of 6 (six)
months from the date of receipt of the copy of this judgment.
16.
The instant writ petition stands allowed and disposed of
accordingly.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
JUDGE
SAIKAT KAR
Date: 2024.04.24 17:51:28
+05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review