The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
21. 08.2021 and again from 22.12.2021 to 23.03.2022 was justified and the remaining period of absence w.e.f. 22.08.2021 to 21.12.2021 and then from 24.03.2022 to 26.03.2023 i.e., the total period of absence of 490 days was unjustified as noted in the impugned memorandum. As already indicated above, no such material has been placed before this Court by the respondents to justify their such contention based on any such report issued by the medical board of AGMC & GBP, Agartala. Therefore, in the absence of or for withholding any such vital document which forms the basis of issuing the impugned memorandum by respondent No.2 terminating the petitioner from the service, the memorandum issued on 25.12.2023 (Annexure-9 to the writ petition) is liable to be quashed as ultra vires and illegal for want of any supporting basis.
10. In view of above discussion, the memorandum dated
25. 12.2023 (Annexure-9 to the writ petition) issued by respondent No.2 is, accordingly, quashed. However, respondents are at liberty to decide the matter afresh within 04(four) weeks of receipt of the copy of this judgment, after furnishing copy of the report of Medical Board, if any, to the petitioner and after giving him an opportunity of personal hearing, if he so desires. Needless to say, the petitioner will also have the liberty to raise all the contentions before the competent authority of the respondents, which are raised before this Court in this writ petition, apart from any other grounds which he intends to agitate. With such observations and directions, the writ petition is disposed of. Pending application(s), if any, shall also stands disposed of. SATABD Digitally I DUTTA 18:25:10 +05'30' Dinashree
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.812 of 2024
Sri Sibu Paul,
S/o. Shri Kshitish Chandra Paul,
Resident of Manubazar, Sabroom, South Tripura.
……..Petitioner(s)
–Versus–
1. The State of Tripura,
Represented by the Principal Secretary to the Government of
Tripura, Secondary Education, Civil Secretariat, Capital Complex,
Agartala.
2. The Director of Secondary Education,
Government of Tripura, Agartala, West Tripura.
…….. Respondent(s)
For the Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. Sankar Kr. Deb, Sr. Advocate.
Mr. Saugat Datta, Advocate.
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Haradhan Sarkar, Advocate.
Date of hearing and delivery :
of Judgment & Order
10th July, 2025.
Whether fit for reporting
NO
:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. DATTA PURKAYASTHA
JUDGMENT & ORDER (Oral)
Heard Mr. Sankar Kr. Deb, learned senior counsel appearing
for the petitioner and Mr. Haradhan Sarkar, learned counsel appearing
for the respondents.
2.
Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel submits that the petitioner,
a graduate teacher (B.A.), posted at Sabroom English Medium Higher
Secondary School, South Tripura, was transferred from his existing
place of posting to Twikarma Twisa H.S. School, L.T. Valley, Dhalai, vide
memorandum issued on 15.07.2021 (Annexure-1 to the writ petition).
By said memorandum, he was also stand released w.e.f. 23.07.2021.
Thereafter, he did not join his new place of posting for a considerable
period, and on 28.03.2023, he submitted an application to the
respondent No.2 to allow him to join at his new place of posting, but he
was not allowed to do so. Thereafter, respondent No.2 issued another
memorandum dated 03.05.2023 (Annexure 3), directing him to explain
within 15.06.2023 as to why he shall not be deemed to have resigned
from Government service by invoking the provision of TSCS (Leave)
(11th Amendment) Rules, 2013, read with notification bearing No.F.1(1)FIN(G)/86
dated
20.06.2013
of
the
Finance
Department
and
memorandum bearing No.F.20(1)-GA(P&T)/18(Part) dated 12.12.2018
of the GA(P&T) Department, for remaining in unauthorized absence for
more than one year at a stretch (w.e.f. 23.07.2021 till the date of the
issuance of the memorandum), failing which a termination letter would
be issued to him.
3.
The petitioner thereafter submitted a reply vide Annexure-4
on 25.05.2023, mainly stating that he had fallen sick on the night of
22.07.2021 and underwent treatment under a government medical
attendant/practitioner on 23.07.2021 and as such, he could not join in
his new place of posting and thereafter also the illness continued, and
after recovery from such prolonged illness, even once he was attacked
by some miscreants on 12.01.2022, for which a separate FIR bearing
No.2022/SBM/002 under Sections 341/323/427/34 of Indian Penal Code
was lodged at Sabroom P.S. According to him, after his recovery from
the illness on 27.03.2023, he became fit to join and accordingly applied
for allowing him to join to his place of posting.
4.
On consideration of his reply, respondent No.2 thereafter
referred him to appear before the Standing Medical Board, Agartala,
AGMC & GBP Hospital vide memorandum dated 10.07.2023 (Annexure 5
to the writ petition), and accordingly, he appeared there. Certain papers
containing advice of the Medical Officer in the OPD with pathological
reports are relied on by both the sides, under Annexure-6 and
Annexure-R/1 in this regard. Learned senior counsel also refers to
another memorandum dated 25.12.2023 under Annexure-9 whereby
respondent
No.2,
upon
examination
of
the
entire
facts
and
circumstances, treated the petitioner’s absence as deemed resignation
from Government service w.e.f. 23.07.2021, with the observation that
he was absent from duty for more than one year at a stretch w.e.f.
23.07.2021 till date. The relevant paragraphs of the said memorandum
are extracted hereunder:
“Therefore, after careful examination of the
entire facts and circumstances, Sri Sibu Paul, G/T of
Sabroom English Medium H.S. School, Sabroom, South
Tripura is hereby treated as deemed to have resigned from
the Govt. Service w.e.f. 23-07-2021 under TSCS (Leave)
(11th Amdendment) Rules, 2013 (i.e. as per Finance
Department’s Notification No.F.1(1)-FIN(G)/86, dated 2006-2013) and as per General Administration (Personnel &
Training)
Department’s
Memorandum
No.F.20(1)GA(P&t)/18(Part),
dated
12-12-2018
for
remaining
unauthorized absent from duty for more than 01 (one) year
at a stretch w.e.f. 23-07-2021 to till date.
This has issued as per approval of the higher
authority vide U.O.No.4903/CM/2023 dated, 16-10-2023.”
Said memorandum is impugned herein.
5.
In
the
said
memorandum,
it
was
also
observed
by
respondent No.2 that the Chairman, Standing Medical Board, AGMC &
GBP, Hospital, after careful observation of the petitioner and his relevant
documents relating to his treatment, opined that the petitioner’s
absence for a period of 122 days was justified but remaining period of
490 days was unjustified. Challenging the said memorandum, the
present writ petition has been filed.
6.
Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel strenuously argues that the
very basis or foundation of the decision of respondent No.2 was the
report of the Standing Medical Board, but neither the said report of the
said Medical Board was supplied to the petitioner, giving him any
opportunity to be heard on it, nor was the said report is placed in the
record by the respondents. Therefore, the general presumption will be
that there was no such medical report at all. Learned senior counsel,
also refers to Rule 12 of Tripura State Civil Services (Leave) Rules, 1986
[For short- TSCS (Leave) Rules, 1986] as amended vide TSCS (Leave)
(11th Amendment) Rules, 2013, which is extracted hereunder:
“12. Maximum amount of continuous leave
Unless the Governor, in view of the exceptional
circumstances of the case otherwise determines, no
Government servant shall be granted leave of any kind for a
continuous period exceeding five years.
[Inserted by the Tripura State Civil Services (Leave)
(11th Amendment) Rules, 2013, vide Finance Dept.
notification No.F.1(1)-FIN(G)/86, dt. 20.06.2012][(1): A
government servant shall be deemed to have resigned from
the service if he(a) is absent without authorization for a period of
one year; or
(b) remains absent from duty for a continuous period
of five years, with or without leave; or
(c) continues on foreign service beyond the period
approved by the Government:
Provided that a reasonable opportunity to explain the
reason for such absence or continuation on foreign service
shall be given to the servant before the provisions of this
rules are invoked.]”
7.
Learned senior counsel submits that by using the words
absent from duty at a stretch for more than one year the department
resorted to the provision of Sub-Rule 1(b) of Rule 12 though according
to the said Sub-rule 1(b), action may be taken against a Government
employee if he is absent from duty for a continuous period of 5(five)
years, with or without leave and not for absence of only 1(one) year or
so, and therefore, on that ground also the memorandum issued by
respondent No.2 is illegal and ultra vires.
8.
Mr. Sarkar, learned counsel, relies on the documents related
to the examination of the petitioner in AGMC & GBP Hospital, Agartala,
in the OPD, as placed under Annexure-R/1 and submits that the
petitioner was absent for a period of 490 days without any justified
ground for which in accordance with the provisions of Rule 12 of said
TSCS (Leave) Rules, 1986, respondent No.2 was justified in treating the
absence of the petitioner to be deemed resignation and thereby
terminating him from service.
9.
This Court has given due consideration to the submission of
both sides and has also taken note of all the materials as placed in the
record. On perusal of the medical papers placed under Annexure-6 and
Annexure-R/1, nothing is found therein containing any opinion of the
Standing
Medical
Board.
No
material
has
been
placed
by
the
respondents before the Court to justify their assertion that the
petitioner’s absence for total of 122 days w.e.f. 23.07.2021 to
21.08.2021 and again from 22.12.2021 to 23.03.2022 was justified and
the remaining period of absence w.e.f. 22.08.2021 to 21.12.2021 and
then from 24.03.2022 to 26.03.2023 i.e., the total period of absence of
490 days was unjustified as noted in the impugned memorandum. As
already indicated above, no such material has been placed before this
Court by the respondents to justify their such contention based on any
such report issued by the medical board of AGMC & GBP, Agartala.
Therefore, in the absence of or for withholding any such vital document
which forms the basis of issuing the impugned memorandum by
respondent No.2 terminating the petitioner from the service, the
memorandum issued on 25.12.2023 (Annexure-9 to the writ petition) is
liable to be quashed as ultra vires and illegal for want of any supporting
basis.
10.
In view of above discussion, the memorandum dated
25.12.2023 (Annexure-9 to the writ petition) issued by respondent No.2
is, accordingly, quashed. However, respondents are at liberty to decide
the matter afresh within 04(four) weeks of receipt of the copy of this
judgment, after furnishing copy of the report of Medical Board, if any, to
the petitioner and after giving him an opportunity of personal hearing, if
he so desires. Needless to say, the petitioner will also have the liberty to
raise all the contentions before the competent authority of the
respondents, which are raised before this Court in this writ petition,
apart from any other grounds which he intends to agitate.
With such observations and directions, the writ petition is
disposed of.
Pending application(s), if any, shall also stands disposed of.
JUDGE
signed by
SATABD Digitally
SATABDI DUTTA
Date: 2025.07.11
I DUTTA 18:25:10 +05'30'
Dinashree
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review