Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page 1
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.330 of 2021
Sri Shyamal Sarkar, son of late Babulal Sarkar, resident of Lankamura, P.O.
Lankamura, District- West Tripura
-VERSUS-
…..Petitioner
1.
The State of Tripura,
represented by the Secretary, Government of Tripura, Department of
Home, having its office at Civil Secretariat, New Capital Complex, P.O.
Kunjaban, Agartala, District- West Tripura
Government of India, New Delhi-110017
2.
The Director General of Police,
Government of Tripura, having its office at Fire Brigade Chowmuhani, P.O.
Agartala, District- West Tripura
3.
The Assistant Inspector General of Police (Esstt),
having its office at Fire Brigade Chowmuhani, P.O. Agartala, District- West
Tripura
4.
The Superintendent of Police (Security) Tripura,
having its office at Fire Brigade Chowmuhani, P.O. Agartala, District- West
Tripura
….Respondents.
For the Petitioner (s )
:
Mr. TD Majumder, Sr. Advocate
Ms. R. Debbarma, Advocate
For the Respondent (s)
:
Mr. D. Bhattacharjee, GA
Mr. K. Dey, Addl. GA
Date of hearing & delivery :
13.02.2023
of judgment & order
Whether fit for reporting :
Yes
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
1.
This is a case where a person is deprived of protection of
service as enshrined under Section 47 of the Persons with
Disabilities (Equal Opportunities, Protection of Rights and Full
Participation) Act, 1995 (for short, “PWD Act, 1995”) read with
Page 2
Sections 3 and 4 of The Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act,
2016 (for short, “RPwD Act”).
2.
The petitioner, Sri Shyamal Sarkar was serving as Constable
under the State-respondents. During the performance of his
duties, he suffered cerebral attack which incapacitated him from
performing his normal duties. State-respondents have alleged that
the
petitioner
made
an
application
on
19.10.2019
to
the
Superintendent of Police praying for voluntary retirement, which
was accepted by the competent authority. Later on, the son of the
petitioner submitted an application to the competent authority of
the police department (Annexure 6 to the counter affidavit)
wherein he sought for compassionate appointment commensurate
to his qualification on the pretext that his father was allowed
invalid pension entitling him to come within the purview of suitable
appointment under the State‟s “Die-in-harness scheme”. After one
year
of
the
compassionate
application
of
the
son
of
the
petitioner
for
appointment,
the
competent
authority
had
regretted his claim on the ground that his father, that is, the
petitioner herein had sought for voluntary retirement on his own
accord, and the employee seeking for voluntary retirement would
not be entitled to get the benefit of the scheme in vogue. It is the
further case of the petitioner that his service is protected under
Section 47 of the PWD Act, 1995. Having come to learn the legal
Page 3
position, he approached this court seeking to invoke this court‟s
discretionary and extra-ordinary jurisdiction under Article 226 of
the Constitution of India.
3.
The respondents-State submitted counter affidavit. In the
counter affidavit, they have stated that neither the petitioner is
entitled to be reinstated in service nor his son is eligible for
appointment under the die-in-harness scheme since the petitioner
herein himself has sought for voluntary retirement.
4.
In the above context, I have heard Mr. TD Majumder,
learned senior counsel assisted by Ms. R. Debbarma, learned
counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioner. I have also heard
Mr. D. Bhattacharjee, learned GA assisted by Mr. K. Dey, learned
Additional GA appearing for the State-respondents.
5.
At the very outset, Mr. Majumder, learned senior counsel
drawing
my
attention
to
the
letter
dated
19.10.2019
(Annexure 1 to the counter affidavit) written by the petitioner
to the Superintendent of Police, Security Unit, has submitted
that the contents of the said letter does not justify the
statements made by the respondent that the petitioner had
ever sought for voluntary retirement, rather, it transpires that
the petitioner asked only for „retirement‟ and not for
„voluntary retirement‟ from service. The word “voluntary”
Page 4
appeared to be missing initially and added afterwards in the
said correspondence.
5.1. This court in its order dated 20.01.2023 requested the
learned GA to produce the “Orderly Rule Register” wherein
relevant official notes of the concerned authorities were
reflected. From the note it clearly reveals that initially the
note was that “C/752, Shyamal Sarkar of Security unit submitted a
prayer on 19.10.19 and seek retirement from service on medical ground”.
The file being produced before this court and on close scrutiny
with bird‟s eye view, it comes to fore that this portion of the
note
containing
the
words
“seek
voluntary”
had
been
manipulated and interpolated. The word „seek‟ was very
cleverly and unscrupulously added with suffix „-ing‟ and the
word „voluntary‟ was inserted before the word „retirement‟, so
that this portion of the note was to be read and understood as
“seeking voluntary retirement’. Moreso, it is noticed that
natural continuous flow in adding the suffix- „ing‟ with the
word „seek‟ followed by the word “voluntary” is found to be
missing.
In a separate note the concerned authority sent the
petitioner to the District Disability Medical Board of West
Page 5
Tripura District. The petitioner was examined and the medical
board declared him 100% disabled. Thereafter, the petitioner
was asked to go on retirement w.e.f. 31.10.2019 and he was
given pension.
5.2. On conjoint reading of the 2 (two) aforesaid “Notes” as
stated
above,
this
court
unhesitently
has
come
to
a
conclusion that such manipulation and interpolation in the
correspondence dated 19.10.2019 were caused and aimed to
confuse the entire contour of the true and honest intention of
the petitioner to declare him permanently invalid so that he
could get all sorts of service benefits considering his
permanent disability.
6.
Mr. Datta Majumder, learned senior counsel has submitted
that the respondents having found the petitioner 100% disabled
arbitrarily asked him to go on retirement, instead, his service
ought to have been protected under Section 47 of the PWD Act,
1995,
which
the
respondents
should
have
rectified
now.
Alternatively, as urged by learned senior counsel for the petitioner
is that the petitioner may be allowed to go on permanent invalid
pension as envisaged under Rule 38 of the CCS (Pension) Rules,
1972, adopted in the State of Tripura so that his son may come
within the purview of State‟s „Die-in-harness scheme‟.
Page 6
7.
To counter the submissions of leaned senior counsel
appearing on behalf of the petitioner, Mr. Bhattacharjee, learned
GA has reiterated the contentions made in the counter affidavit
that the petitioner is not entitled to be reinstated in service and his
son is also not entitled to get appointment under die-in-harness
scheme. However, learned GA has drawn my attention to Clause
2.10 of the “Scheme for Compassionate Appointment/Benefit
for Government Employees in Tripura”.
8.
I have perused the scheme. The object of the Scheme is
to extend benefits either by an appointment in the Government
service
on
compassionate
ground
or
admissible
financial
assistance to an eligible dependant member of the family of a
government servant dying-in-harness or in case of permanent
physical invalidity while on government duty or missing, thereby
leaving his family in penury and without any means of
livelihood. The scheme is meant to relieve the family of the
government servant concerned from financial destitution and to
help it get over the emergency. To achieve the objectives,
necessary provisions have been made to extend the benefit of
the scheme to a government employee who has suffered
permanent invalidity while on duty, causing incapacitation to
perform government duties. Here, it would be useful to extract
Clause 2.10 of the Scheme, which reads as under:
Page 7
“2.10. “Permanent invalidity of Government Servants” means the
Government servant is suffering from permanent invalidity while on duty,
causing incapacitation to perform Government duties.
Provide that the State Government Medical Board has recommended and
certified the permanent invalidity and the competent authority has full
satisfaction on such permanent invalidation”.
9.
Having given much emphasis upon this Clause, learned GA
has fairly urged this court to refer the matter to State
Government Medical Board for physical examination of the
petitioner so that the respondents can take an appropriate
decision regarding re-instatement of the petitioner in service or
alternately to declare him as permanently invalid so that his son
may be considered for appointment under invalidity pension
scheme as embodied in Rule 38 of the CCS (Pension) Rules,
1972.
10. I have considered the respective submission advanced by
learned counsel appearing for the parties.
11. Without making further comments relating to manipulation
of the “notes” prepared by the concerned authorities, I am of
the considered view that even the petitioner had sought for
voluntary retirement, then, also it was the bounden duty of the
authorities concerned to inform the legal position qua the right
of the petitioner under the PWD Act, 1995. In the opinion of this
court, the concerned authorities and the respondents being the
benevolent employer acted arbitrarily in allowing the petitioner
Page 8
to go on retirement from service before the actual date of his
superannuation.
12. The schematic pattern of Section 47 of the PWD Act, 1995
clearly indicates its mandatory nature. The very opening part of
the sentence under section 47 of the PWD Act, 1995 reads as
„no establishment shall dispense with, or reduce in rank, an
employee who acquires a disability during his service‟. In this
context, Mr. Datta Majumder, learned senior counsel for the
petitioner has referred to a judgment of the Hon‟ble Apex court
rendered in Bhagwan Dass and another vs. Punjab State
Electricity Board, reported in (2008) 1 SCC 579 (paras 18,
19 and 20).
13. For convenience, Section 47 of the PWD Act, 1995, may
be reproduced here-in-below:
“47. Non-discrimination in Government employments.— (1) No establishment shall
dispense with, or reduce in rank, an employee who acquires a disability during his
service:
Provided that, if an employee, after acquiring disability is not suitable for the
post he was holding, could be shifted to some other post with the same pay scale
and service benefits:
Provided further that if it is not possible to adjust the employee against any
post, he may be kept on a supernumerary post until a suitable post is available or he
attains the age of superannuation, whichever is earlier.
(2) No promotion shall be denied to a person merely on the ground of his disability:
Provided that the appropriate Government may, having regard to the type of
work carried on in any establishment, by notification and subject to such conditions,
if any, as may be specified in such notification, exempt any establishment from the
provisions of this section.”
Page 9
14. The Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievance & Pensions,
Department of Personnel & Training issued office memorandum
dated 25.02.2015, which reads as under:
“ No. 18017/1/2014-Estt(L)
Government of India
Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances & Pensions
Department of Personnel & Training
New Delhi, the 25th February, 2015
OFFICE MEMORANDUM
Subject:
Amendment to Central Civil Service (Leave) Rules, 1972- Persons with
Disabilities (Equal Opportunities, Protection of Rights and Full
Participation) Act, 1995 (PWD Act, 1995)- regarding
The Central Civil Services (Leave) Rules, 1972 were amended vide the
Department of Personnel and Training Notification No. 13026/1/2002-Estt(L) dated
the 15/16th January, 2004 consequent to the Persons with Disabilities (Equal
Opportunities, Protection of Rights and Full Participation) Act, 1995 (PWD Act, 1995)
which came into force from 7th February, 1996.
2.
Section 47 of the PWD Act, 1995 provides that services of no employee can
be terminated nor can he be reduced in rank in case the employee has acquired a
disability during his service. The first proviso to the Section 47 lays down that if such
an employee is not suitable for the post he was holding, he could be shifted to some
other post. However, his pay and service benefits would be protected. The second
proviso provides that if it is not possible to adjust such an employee against any
post, he would be kept on a supernumerary post until a suitable post is available or
he attains the age of superannuation, whichever is earlier. Further, the Clause (2) of
Section 47 provides that no promotion shall be denied to a person merely on ground
of his disability. In Kunal singh v Union of India (2003) 4 SCC 524, Hon’ble Supreme
Court has observed that the very frame and contents of Section 47 of the PWD Act,
1995 clearly indicate its mandatory nature.
3.
the issues relating to leave or absence of Government servants who have
acquired a disability while in service are required to be dealt with in the light of the
provisions of the Section 47 of Persons with Disabilities (Equal Opportunities,
Protection of Rights and Full Participation) Act, 1995 (PWD Act, 1995). The case of a
disabled government servant who is declared fit to resume duty but who may not
able to perform the duties of the post he was holding earlier may be dealt with as
per the first proviso to Section 47 of the PWD Act, 1995. The second proviso shall
apply if it is not possible to adjust him against any existing post. In all such cases, the
Government servant so adjusted shall be entitled to the pay scale and other service
benefits attached to the post he was holding.
4.
A disabled Government servant who is not fit to return to duty shall be
adjusted as per second proviso to the Section 47 mentioned above, until he is
declared fit to resume duty or attains the age of superannuation whichever is
earlier, with the same pay scale and service benefits. On being declared fit for
resuming duty, the Government servant who is not fit for the post he is holding, may
be adjusted as per the first proviso to Section 47.
5.
Leave applied on medical certificate in connection disability should not be
refused or revoked without reference to a Medical Authority, whose advice shall be
binding. The ceiling on maximum permissible leave laid down in rule 12 may not be
applied to leave on medical certificate applied in connection with the disability. Any
Page 10
leave debited for the period after a Government servant is declared incapacitated
shall be remitted back into his/her leave account.
6.
For a government servant who is unable to submit an application or medical
certificate on account of disability, an application/medical certificate submitted by a
family member may be accepted. The provisions relating to examination of disabled
Government servants and the Medical Authorities competent to issue such
certificates are also being amended.
7.
Necessary amendments to the Central civil Services (Leave) Rules, 1972 are
being notified separately.”
15. PWD Act, 1995, being repealed is replaced by The
Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act, 2016 (for short,
“RPwD”Act) w.e.f. 19.04.2017. RPwD Act, 2016 was enacted
to give effect to the United Nations Convention on the Rights of
Persons with Disabilities and for matters connected therewith or
incidental thereto. More rights have been conferred on the
disabled persons and more categories have been added. Access
to justice, free education, role of local authorities, National fund
and State fund for persons with disabilities have been created.
RPwD Act, 2016 is noticeably a sea-change in the
perception and requires a march forward look with
regard to the persons with disabilities and the role of the
States, local authorities, educational institutions and the
companies. [Justice Sunanda Bhandare Foundation v.
Union of India, (2017) 14 SCC 1]
16. The
United
Nations
General
Assembly
adopted
its
Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities on the 13 th
day of December, 2006. The aforesaid Convention lays down
Page 11
the following principles for empowerment of persons with
disabilities“(a) respect for inherent dignity, individual autonomy including the freedom to make
one's own choices, and independence of persons;
(b) non-discrimination;
(c) full and effective participation and inclusion in society;
(d) respect for difference and acceptance of persons with disabilities as part of
human diversity and humanity;
(e) equality of opportunity;
(f) accessibility;
(g) equality between men and women;
(h) respect for the evolving capacities of children with disabilities and respect for the
right of children with disabilities to preserve their identities;
And whereas India is a signatory to the said Convention;
And whereas India ratified the said Convention on the 1st day of October, 2007;
And whereas it is considered necessary to implement the Convention aforesaid.”
17. PWD Act, 1995 was enacted to give effect to the
Proclamation on the Full Participation and Equality of the People
with Disabilities in the Asian and Pacific Region. Over a period of
time, the conceptual understanding of the rights of persons with
disabilities has
become
more
clear and there
has
been
worldwide change in approach to handle the issues concerning
persons with disabilities. India being one of the participant
countries had signed the United Nations Convention and
subsequently ratified the same on 1st day of October, 2007. The
Convention came into effect on the 3rd day of May, 2008. Being
the signatory to the Convention, India has an international
obligation to comply with the provisions of the said Convention
which requires entirely a new legislation. A Constituted Expert
Committee being formed in the year 2010 submitted its report
Page 12
in 2011, suggesting a draft bill relating to the Rights of Persons
with Disabilities. The draft bill was extensively debated upon at
various levels involving State Government and Union Territories
and various stakeholders. The salient features of the Rights of
Persons with Disabilities Bill, 2014, inter alia are as under:“(i) Nineteen specified disabilities have been defined;
(ii) The persons with disabilities enjoy various rights such as right to equality, life
with dignity, respect for his or her integrity, etc., equally with others;
(iii) Duties and responsibilities of the appropriate Government have been
enumerated;
(iv) All educational institutions funded by appropriate Government shall provide
inclusive education to the children with disabilities;
(v) A National Fund is proposed to provide financial support to persons with
disabilities;
(vi) Stakeholders’ participation in the policy making through Central and State
Advisory Boards;
(vii) Increase in reservation in posts from existing three per cent to five per cent in
the vacancies for persons or class of persons with benchmark disabilities in every
establishment and reservation of seats for students with benchmark disabilities in
higher educational institutions;
(viii) Setting up of National Commission and State Commissions to act as Grievance
Redressal Mechanism, monitor implementation of the proposed legislation replacing
the Chief Commissioner and State Commissioners for persons with disabilities,
respectively;
(ix) Guidelines to be issued by the Central Government for issuance of certificates of
specified disabilities;
(x) Penalties for offences committed against persons with disabilities; and
(xi) Court of Session to be designated as Special Court by the State Government in
every district to try offences.”
18. Ultimately, to achieve the objects, RPwD Act was brought
into
force
w.e.f.
19.04.2017
[vide
S.O.
1215(E)
dated
19.04.2017].
(i) Section 2(h) of the RPwD Act defines “discrimination”,
which reads as follows:
“(h) “discrimination” in relation to disability, means any distinction, exclusion,
restriction on the basis of disability which is the purpose or effect of impairing or
nullifying the recognition, enjoyment or exercise on an equal basis with others of all
human rights and fundamental freedoms in the political, economic, social, cultural,
Page 13
civil or any other field and includes all forms of discrimination and denial of
reasonable accommodation.”
(ii) Section 2(i) of the RPwD Act defines “establishment”,
which reads as under:
“(i) “establishment”
establishment.”
includes
a
Government
establishment
and
private
(iii) Section 2(t) of the RPwD Act enumerates “person with
disability having high support needs”, which means a person
with benchmark disability certified under clause (a) of subsection (2) of Section 58 who needs high support.
(iv) Section 2(y) of the RPwD Act defines “reasonable
accommodation”, which means necessary and appropriate
modification
and
adjustments,
without
imposing
a
disproportionate or undue burden in a particular case, to
ensure to persons with disabilities the enjoyment or
exercise of rights equally with others.
(v) Section 3 of the RPwD Act, is an important facet of the
said
Act,
which
speaks
about
“Equality
and
Non-
discrimination”. It provides thus:
“3. Equality and non-discrimination.—(1) The appropriate Government shall ensure
that the persons with disabilities enjoy the right to equality, life with dignity and
respect for his or her integrity equally with others.
(2) The appropriate Government shall take steps to utilise the capacity of persons
with disabilities by providing appropriate environment.
(3) No person with disability shall be discriminated on the ground of disability,
unless it is shown that the impugned act or omission is a proportionate means of
achieving a legitimate aim.
(4) No person shall be deprived of his or her personal liberty only on the ground of
disability.
(5) The appropriate Government shall take necessary steps to ensure reasonable
accommodation for persons with disabilities.”
Page 14
19. The opening of sub-sections (3) and (4) of Section 3 of the
said Act starts with no person with disability shall be
discriminated on the ground of disability and no person
shall be deprived of his or her personal liberty.
20. Section
of
the
RPwD
Act
speaks
about
non-
discrimination in employment. Expressing the importance
and consequence of sub-section (4) of Section 20 of the RPwD
Act, a three-Judge Bench of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in
Ravinder Kumar Dhariwal and another vs. Union of India and
others, reported in (2023) 2 SCC 209, noticed limited scope of
Section 47 compared to Section 20 of the RPwD Act and
observed as under:
“42. The limited nature of Section 47 becomes apparent when it is compared
with Section 20 of the RPwD Act. Section 20 of the RPwD Act reads thus:
“Section 20 - Non-discrimination in employment (1) No Government
establishment shall discriminate against any person with disability in any
matter relating to employment:
Provided that the appropriate Government may, having regard to the
type of work carried on in any establishment, by notification and subject to
such conditions, if any, exempt any establishment from the provisions of this
section.
(2) Every Government establishment shall provide reasonable
accommodation and appropriate barrier free and conducive environment to
employees with disability.
(3) No promotion shall be denied to a person merely on the ground of
disability.
(4) No Government establishment shall dispense with or reduce in
rank, an employee who acquires a disability during his or her service Provided
that, if an employee after acquiring disability is not suitable for the post he
was holding, shall be shifted to some other post with the same pay scale and
service benefits:
Page 15
Provided further that if it is not possible to adjust the employee
against any post, he may be kept on a supernumerary post until a suitable
post is available or he attains the age of superannuation, whichever is earlier.
(5) The appropriate Government may frame policies for posting and
transfer of employees with disabilities.”
(emphasis supplied)
43. Section 47 of the PwD Act, unlike Section 20 of the RPwD Act, does not
contain a provision in the nature of sub-Section (1) of Section 20 which
provides that a government establishment cannot discriminate against a
person with a disability in “any matter” relating to employment. While we
are not interpreting the contours of “any matter” used in Section 20 of the
RPwD Act in the present case, it would suffice to say that Section 20 of the
RPwD Act casts a net of protection wider than Section 47 of the PwD Act.
44. Moreover, India is a signatory to and has ratified the United Nations
Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (“CRPD”). Article 5 of
CRPD incorporates the principles of non-discrimination and equality, in both
its formal and substantive forms. Article 5 reads as follows:
“5. Equality and Non-Discrimination:
1. States Parties recognise that all persons are equal before and under the
law and are entitled without any discrimination to the equal protection and
equal benefit of the law.
2. States Parties shall prohibit all discrimination on the basis of disability and
guarantee to persons with disabilities equal and effective legal protection
against discrimination on all grounds.
3. In order to promote equality and eliminate discrimination, States Parties
shall take all appropriate steps to ensure that reasonable accommodation is
provided.
4. Specific measures which are necessary to accelerate or achieve de facto
equality of persons with disabilities shall not be considered discrimination
under the terms of the present Convention.”
(emphasis supplied)
For convenience, the Bench has made a comparison
between Section 47 of the PWD Act and Section 20 of the RPwD
Act. At para 52 of the said judgment (Ravinder Kumar
Dhariwal, supra), the court has held thus:
Section 47 of the PwD Act
“47. Non-discrimination in Government
employments- (1) No establishment
shall dispense with, or reduce in rank,
an employee who acquires a disability
during his service.
Section 20 of the RPwD Act
“20. Non-discrimination in employment-(1)
No
government
establishment
shall
discriminate against any person with
disability in any matter relating to
employment:
Page 16
Provided that, if an employee, after
acquiring disability is not suitable for
the post he was holding, could be
shifted to some other post with the
same pay scale and service benefits.
Provided further that if it is not possible
to adjust the employee against any
post, he may be kept on a
supernumerary post until a suitable
post is available or he attains the age of
superannuation, whichever is earlier
Provided that the appropriate Government
may, having regard to the type of work
carried on in any establishment, by
notification and subject to such conditions, if
any, exempt any establishment from the
provisions of this section.
(2) Every Government establishment shall
provide reasonable accommodation and
appropriate barrier free and conducive
environment to employees with disability.
(3) No promotion shall be denied to a person
(2) No promotion shall be denied to a merely on the ground of disability.
person merely on the ground of his
disability.
(4) No Government establishment shall
dispense with or reduce in rank, an
Provided
that
the
appropriate employee who acquires a disability during
Government may, having regard to the his or her service:
type of work carried on in any
establishment, by notification and
subject to such conditions, if any, as Provided that, if an employee after acquiring
may be specified in such notification, disability is not suitable for the post he was
exempt any establishment from the holding, shall be shifted to some other post
provisions of this section.”
with the same pay scale and service
benefits:
Provided further that if it is not possible to
adjust the employee against any post, he
may be kept on a supernumerary post until
a suitable post is available or he attains the
age of superannuation, whichever is earlier.
(5) The appropriate Government may frame
policies for posting and transfer of
employees with disabilities.”
Thus, it can safely be said that Section 20 of the RPwD
Act, covers wider ambit when compared with Section 47 of the
PWD Act. Section 20 fo the RPwD Act, provides for nondiscrimination based on disabilities, which is a provision in
pursuance of equality mandated in Article 5 of the Convention of
Rights to Persons with Disabilities, 2006 (for short, “CRPD”) Act.
Page 17
Section 20(2) of the RPwD Act, states that every government
establishment shall provide reasonable accommodation and
appropriate
barrier
free
and
conducive
environment
to
employees with disability.
[Emphasis supplied]
21. It is further observed that the said provision advances the
guarantee of reasonable accommodation to the persons with
physical or mental disabilities. The government establishment
has a positive obligation to shift an employee who is affected
with disability during service to a suitable post with same payscale and service benefits. The provision further states that if it
is not possible to adjust the employee against any post, he may
be kept on a supernumerary post until a suitable post becomes
available or when he attains the age of superannuation,
whichever is earlier. Further, reasonable accommodation is a
component of the right to equality and non-compliance of
principle
of
reasonable
accommodation
would
result
discrimination.
[Emphasis supplied]
22. The Bench in Ravinder Kumar Dhariwal (supra) further
observed that “in light of Section 20(4) and the general
guarantee of reasonable accommodation that accrues to
persons with disabilities, the appellant is entitled to be
Page 18
reassigned to a suitable post having the same pay scale
and benefits”.
It
further
held
that
“section
2(h)
prohibits
discrimination on the basis of disability. It is pertinent to
note that the provision does not use the phrase ‘only’ on
the basis of disability. This Court in its decisions has
observed that while a causal connection may need to be
established between the ground for discrimination and
the discriminatory act, it is not required to be shown that
the discrimination occurred solely on the basis of the
forbidden ground. As long as it can be shown that the
forbidden ground played a role in the discriminatory
action, the action will violate the guarantee against nondiscrimination.” [SCC p. 278, para 128]
23. In addition to the above analysis of law on the subject, it
is noticed that the framers of the RPwD Act used the word “no”
to start the provisions under Sub-sections 3 and 4 of Section 3
and under Sub-section 4 of Section 20 of the said Act. According
to me, using the word “no”, the legislature intended to
mandatorily negate any action adverse to the interest related to
the employment in service of the employees suffered with
physical or mental disability, and further asserts affirmative
action not to discriminate such employees in providing all
Page 19
service benefits including seniority, promotion, pay structures,
etc. till the date of his superannuation. To achieve the
objectives of the Act, the employers are obligated to provide
reasonable
accommodation
by
way
of
making
necessary
adjustments to a suitable post in the same pay-scale to ensure
to
persons/employees
with
disabilities
the
enjoyment
or
exercise of right equally with others. In appropriate cases, even
the employer may have to create supernumerary post to
accommodate a permanently disabled employee in service
because the schematic pattern of the Act suggests that any
factor or barrier in any form or manner whatsoever as
envisaged in Section 2(c) of the RPwD Act must not hamper a
person with long term physical or other forms of disabilities in
his/their full and effective participation in institutional and
societal activities.
[Emphasis supplied]
24.
Now,
to
consider
the
prayer
for
compassionate
appointment, it would be useful to have a look to the
notification dated 2nd March, 2019, wherein the Government of
Tripura
has
revised
the
Die-in-harness
scheme
for
compassionate appointment/benefit of government employees
of Tripura.
Page 20
(i) Clause 2.2. of the said Scheme defines “Affected
Government
Servant”,
which
means,
(i)
Government
servant dying-in-harness, or (ii) Government servant
attained permanent invalidity while on Government duty,
or (iii) Missing.
(ii) Clause 2.6. of the said Scheme defines “Dependant
family members”, which reads thus:
“(i)
(ii)
(iii)
(iv)
(v)
(vi)
(vii)
(viii)
(ix)
(x)
Wife or husband, as the case may be;
Legitimate children;
Legitimate step children;
Adopted children;
Dependent daughter-in-law;
Dependent parents;
Dependent unmarried brother(s);
Dependant unmarried sister(s);
Dependent widowed daughter(s) and
Dependent legally divorced daughter(s)
(iii) Clause 2.10. of the said Scheme defines “Permanent
invalidity
of
government
Government
Servant”,
which
means
servant
suffering
from
permanent
is
the
invalidity while on duty causing incapacitation to perform
Government duties.
Provided that the State Government Medical Board
has recommended and certified the permanent invalidity
and the competent authority has full satisfaction on such
permanent invalidation.
(iv) Clause 2.13. of the said Scheme defines “Eligibility”,
which reads as under:
Page 21
“Eligibility” shall be determined as on the date of occurrence of the
deceased/missing/permanently invalidity of the Government employee.
(a) The family is indigent and deserves immediate assistance for relief from financial
destitution; and
(b) Applicant for compassionate appointment should be eligible and suitable for the
post in all respects under the provisions of the relevant Recruitment Rules.”
25. From the above schemes, it is clear that in case a
government employee suffers from permanent invalidity, one of
the eligible dependent family members of such employee would
be entitled to be provided with a job commensurate to his
qualification.
26. Now, coming to the context of the case, and having regard
to the ultimate submission of the learned GA to refer the
petitioner to State Government Medical Board to examine the
petitioner as regards his claim of permanent disability and
necessary certification in this regard, I am constrained to pass
the following directions:
(i) The petitioner to appear before the State Medical Board
within a period of 3 (three) weeks from the date of receipt of
the copy of this order;
(ii) The State Medical Board will physically examine the
petitioner and the extent of his disability shall be determined
keeping in mind that State Disability Board declared him 100%
disabled in contrast to his work as Constable;
(iii) The state-respondents must act and take an affirmative
decision whether they will re-instate the petitioner allowing him
Page 22
to continue in service or to declare him
causing
incapacitation
to
perform
permanently invalid
government
duties
as
embodied in Clause 2.10 of the Die-in-harness scheme read
with Rule 38 of the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972, providing him
with all service benefits till the date of his normal retirement;
(iv) The state-respondents shall treat the period of his
retirement as on duty and restore all service benefits till the
date of his re-induction/re-joining in the service;
(v)
The state-respondents shall pay arrear of salary minus the
amount, the respondents paid in this intervening period towards
his pension;
(vi) Alternatively, declare the petitioner permanently invalid in
terms of the afore-stated relevant provisions so that his son
being
one
of
the
“dependent
considered for appointment under
family
members”
may
be
the Die-in-harness scheme
prevalent in the State; and
(vii) In case, the son of the petitioner is provided with a job
under die-in-harness scheme, then, the state-respondents shall
treat the petitioner as on duty till the date of joining of the son
of the petitioner to the post he would be appointed.
27. In the light of the above observations and directions, the
D.O. no. 701/2019 dated 31.10.2019 issued by the respondents
Page 23
asking the petitioner to go on voluntary retirement is set-aside
and quashed. Resultantly, the instant writ petition is allowed in
the terms as indicated here-in-above.
Pending application, if any, also stands disposed.
JUDGE
Saikat
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review