The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
26. 02.2019. [5] Being aggrieved, the petitioner submitted a representation dated 27.04.2019 to the Directorate General Assam Rifles (Grievance Cell/Record Branch), Shillong for considering for promotion to the rank of Sub (Clk) and also submitted another representation dated 27.07.2019 to the Directorate General Assam Rifles (Grievance Cell/Record Branch), Shillong to consider him in the merit of the case. [6] The present writ petition has been filed amongst the following grounds: WP(C) No. 115 of 2021 Page 2 (i) The actions of the respondents are illegal, arbitrary, discriminatory and unconstitutional. (ii) The weak rating of ACR for the year, 2016-2017 had not been communicated to the petitioner and as such, noncommunication of the ACR criteria of the petitioner is against the Record Office Instruction (in short ROI) bearing No. 4/97 contained in para Nos. 32 and 40. (iii) The respondents have failed to follow the instruction at para No. 1 which is contained in the letter dated
06. 06.2002 and vide letter dated 29.05.2019, promoting the petitioner to the rank of Sub (Clerk) was not recommended by the DPC held in the year 2019 due to lacking of ACR for the year 2016-17 and as per the instruction contained at Para No. 1 (b) and (c) of the letter dated 06.06.2002, before endorsing Weak Point or Adverse Remarks warnings/performance at ACR, counselling a periodical should be administered to the ratee (the present petitioner). (iv) vide letter dated 16.05.2017, the DGAR, Shillong circulated the instruction for review of ACRs for the year, 2016 wherein it is stated that Grading the incumbent below “Very Good” in the ACR will be considered as “Adverse Report” and if the ACR is not reviewed and graded below “Very Good” the same should be justified in detail in the pen picture and should be marked with red ink on top of the first page of CR as “Reviewed”. But in case of the petitioner, it was not done by the concerned authority and as such, it was illegal, arbitrary and discriminatory. WP(C) No. 115 of 2021 Page 3 (v) As per the ACR criteria for promotion from Naib/Sub (Clerk) to the rank of Subedar (Clerk), as per the instruction contained in the letter dated 29.12.2016, the petitioner is entitled for promotion to Sub (Clerk). [7] In the counter affidavit of the respondents, it is stated that the petitioner came up for promotion from Naib Subedar (Clerk) to Subeda…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WP(C) No. 115 of 2021
Shri Satyendra Prasad Singh, aged about 57 years, S/o (Late) Ganga
Prasad Singh, a permanent resident of Khoksa Buzurg, P.O. Khosa
Buzurg, P.S. Desari, Vaishali District, Bihar, Pin-844504 presently
posting at 29 Assam Rifles, L Khunou, Manipur, Pin-932029, C/o 99
APO.
…... Petitioner/s
- Versus -
1.
The Union of India through the Secretary, Ministry of Home
Affairs, Government of India, New Delhi-110001.
2.
The Director General Assam Rifles, Records Branch, Shilong,
Pin:793011.
3.
The HQ, 21 Sector Assam Rifles, Pin-932421 C/o 99 APO.
4.
The Commandant, 42, Assam Rifles, Pin-932042, C/o 99 APO.
5.
The Commandant, 29 Assam Riles, Pin-932029, C/o 99 APO.
........Respondent/s
B E F O R E
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE A. GUNESHWAR SHARMA
For the petitioner
::
Mrs. Momota Devi Oinam, Advocate &
Mrs. Runashree Saikia, Advocate
For the respondents
::
Mrs. S. Samarjeet, Sr. PCCG
Date of Hearing
::
29.02.2024
Date of Judgment and Order
::
22.04.2024
WP(C) No. 115 of 2021
Page 1
JUDGEMENT & ORDER (CAV)
[1]
Heard Mrs. Momota Devi Oinam, learned counsel for the
petitioner and Mr. S. Samarjeet, learned Sr. PCCG for the respondents.
[2]
The present writ petition has been filed challenging the
decisions contained in the letters dated 01.07.2019 and 25.09.2019 issued
by the Directorate General Assam Rifles, Records Branch, Shillong with a
prayer for quashing/setting aside the reviewed ACR of the petitioner for the
year 2016-17 and for giving promotion to the rank of Sub/Clerk.
[3]
The petitioner was initially appointed as Riflemen (General
Duty) on 31.12.1985 and re-mustered as Lance Naik/Writer (now Warrant
Officer) on 01.10.1986 and subsequently promoted to Naib Subedar/Clerk
on 01.01.2007 and posted at 29 Assam Riles since June, 2018 and presently
attached at L Khunou, Noney District, Manipur since August, 2020 till date.
As the petitioner has completed 13 (thirteen) years in the grade of Naib Sub
(Clek), he is eligible for promotion to the higher rank of Sub(Clk).
[4]
The DPC was held in the year 2019 for promotion to the rank
of Sub (Clk), the petitioner, who is at Sl. No. 44 of the Seniority list of Naib
Subedar Clerk published on 19.01.2018 by the Directorate General Assam
Rifles (Record Branch), Shillong, was superseded by one of his juniors
namely Md. Yasin, who is at Sl. No. 45, vide promotion order dated
26.02.2019.
[5]
Being aggrieved, the petitioner submitted a representation
dated 27.04.2019 to the Directorate General Assam Rifles (Grievance
Cell/Record Branch), Shillong for considering for promotion to the rank of
Sub (Clk) and also submitted another representation dated 27.07.2019 to
the Directorate General Assam Rifles (Grievance Cell/Record Branch),
Shillong to consider him in the merit of the case.
[6]
The present writ petition has been filed amongst the following
grounds:
WP(C) No. 115 of 2021
Page 2
(i)
The actions of the respondents are illegal, arbitrary,
discriminatory and unconstitutional.
(ii)
The weak rating of ACR for the year, 2016-2017 had not
been communicated to the petitioner and as such, noncommunication of the ACR criteria of the petitioner is
against the Record Office Instruction (in short ROI)
bearing No. 4/97 contained in para Nos. 32 and 40.
(iii)
The respondents have failed to follow the instruction at
para No. 1 which is contained in the letter dated
06.06.2002 and vide letter dated 29.05.2019, promoting
the petitioner to the rank of Sub (Clerk) was not
recommended by the DPC held in the year 2019 due to
lacking of ACR for the year 2016-17 and as per the
instruction contained at Para No. 1 (b) and (c) of the
letter dated 06.06.2002, before endorsing Weak Point or
Adverse
Remarks
warnings/performance
at
ACR,
counselling
a
periodical
should
be
administered to the ratee (the present petitioner).
(iv)
vide letter dated 16.05.2017, the DGAR, Shillong
circulated the instruction for review of ACRs for the year,
2016 wherein it is stated that Grading the incumbent
below “Very Good” in the ACR will be considered as
“Adverse Report” and if the ACR is not reviewed and
graded below “Very Good” the same should be justified
in detail in the pen picture and should be marked with
red ink on top of the first page of CR as “Reviewed”. But
in case of the petitioner, it was not done by the
concerned authority and as such, it was illegal, arbitrary
and discriminatory.
WP(C) No. 115 of 2021
Page 3
(v)
As per the ACR criteria for promotion from Naib/Sub
(Clerk) to the rank of Subedar (Clerk), as per the
instruction contained in the letter dated 29.12.2016, the
petitioner is entitled for promotion to Sub (Clerk).
[7]
In the counter affidavit of the respondents, it is stated that the
petitioner came up for promotion from Naib Subedar (Clerk) to Subedar
(Clerk) as per his seniority in the year 2019 and he was screened by the
Departmental Promotion Committee (DPC) 2019 along with his batch mates.
The DPC was centrally held at Directorate General Assam Rifles, Shillong
in the month of January 2019. The DPC 2019 found the petitioner at serial
No.23 ineligible for promotion due to lacking in Annual Confidential Report
(ACR) criteria, as he was graded ‘High Average’ with 05 points in the ACR
for the year 2016-17. It is further stated that to be eligible for promotion, the
petitioner should have been graded at least ‘Above Average’ with 07 points
in that ACR. Accordingly, the petitioner was superseded for promotion by his
junior Naib Subedar (Clerk) Md. Yashin. As per relevant rule, for promotion
from Naib Subedar to Subedar, a person should have 3 ‘Above Average’, ie,
07 points (Very Good) and 2 not below ‘High Average’, ie, 05 points (Good)
in the last 5 ACRs. The policy of enhancement of bench mark for grant of
promotion and Modified Assured Carrer Progression Scheme benefits as per
7th Central Pay Commission from ‘Good’ to ‘Very Good’ was also adopted in
Assam Rifles. The ACR gradings of the petitioner taken into account by DPC
2019 for the last five years, ie, 2013-2014 to 2017-2018 are given below:
Sl No
Year
Points
Grading
Recommended Remarks
2013-14
Above
Recommended Eligible
Average
2014-15
Above
Average
2015-16
Above
Average
WP(C) No. 115 of 2021
for
promotion
Recommended Eligible
for
promotion
Recommended Eligible
for
promotion
Page 4
2016-17
High
Recommended Lacking
Average
2017-18
Above
promotion
Recommended Eligible
Average
[8]
for
for
promotion
It is stated that in the Bench Mark for Performance Appraisal for
Promotion dated 29.12.2016 issued by DGAR, Shillong for the DPC 2019 for
promotion from ‘Nb Sub to Sub’, 3 ACRs (ie, 2016 to 2018) should not be below
‘Very Good’ (Above Average- 7 points) and remaining 2 ACRs should not be
below ‘Good’ (High Average- 5 points). Since the petitioner was lacking in ACR
for the year 2016-2017, he was not found eligible and hence not recommended
for promotion and in his place his junior was recommended and promoted. It is
further clarified that since the ACR for the year 2016-17 was not an adverse
report, communicating the grading to the petitioner was done away.
[9]
In the rejoinder affidavit, the petitioner states that as per counter
affidavit of the respondents, the ACR for the year 2016-17 graded as ‘High
Average’ was not an adverse report, but no reason has been provided for not
promoting the petitioner. It is pointed out that ‘not adverse report’ and ‘ineligible
for promotion’ are contradictory and the uncommunicated adverse/negative
report cannot be used to deny promotion to the petitioner.
[10]
Mrs. O. Momota, learned counsel for the petitioner submits that as
per reply dated 25.09.2019 issued by Records Branch, DGAR, Shillong, ‘High
Average’ grading is ‘not an adverse’ and hence not communicated to the
petitioner. On the other hand, in another communication dated 01.07.2019
issued by Records Branch, it is mentioned that the petitioner did not meet the
enhanced bench mark for promotion and hence was not considered for
promotion. Learned counsel has pointed out that the ACR for year 2016-17 of
‘High Average 5 points’ of the petition was considered below bench mark
earmarked by DPC for the year 2019 and the same is to be treated as an
‘adverse entry’. It is submitted that such adverse grading ought to be informed
to the petitioner. Mrs. O. Momota draws the attention of this Court to the
important fact that for the last five ACRs, the petitioner was graded 4 times as
‘Above Average- 7 points’ and 1 time as ‘High Average- 5 points’ and as such
WP(C) No. 115 of 2021
Page 5
he had more than the minimum bench mark of 3 ‘Above Average- 7 points’
grading and he ought to be recommended for promotion. It is submitted that no
cogent reason is given for not promoting the petitioner who has obtained
grading more than the minimum bench mark.
[11]
Mrs. O. Momota, learned counsel for the petitioner relies on the
following decisions with regard to mandatory intimation of adverse report and
uncommunicated adverse report cannot be a basis for denying benefit: entry in
ACR
(a)
Dev Dutt v. Union of India: (2008) 8 SCC 725 @ Para
9,10,17&18 to the effect that nomenclature is not relevant and it is the
effect of the entry which determines whether it is adverse or not. It was
also held that an adverse entry in ACR must be communicated,
otherwise it will be in violation of the principle of fairness which is the
soul of natural justice.
(b)
Vijay Kumar v. State of Maharastra: 1988 (Supp) SCC 674 @
Para 3 holding that ‘It is the settled principle that an uncommunicated
adverse report should not form the foundation to deny benefits to a
government servant when similar benefits are extended to his junior’.
(c)
UP Jal Nigam V. Prabhat Chandra Jain: (1996) 2 SCC 363 @
Para 2,3 where it has been held that reason for downgrading should be
recorded and informed to the employee.
(d)
State of Gujarat v. Suryakant Chunilal Shah: (1999) 1 SCC 529
@ Para 25 which held that the purpose of adverse entry is primarily to
forewarn the government servant to mend his ways and to improve his
performance and such entry is required to be communicated.
(e)
In the case of Rajib Kumar Sarkar v. Union of India: WP(C) No.
145 of 2016 order dated 24.04.2019, Meghalaya High Court set aside
the denial of promotion on the basis enhanced bench mark when the
petitioners grading during the relevant time the ACR grading was not
adverse and within benchmark.
(f)
In the case of Dev Datta Sharma v. Union of India: WP(C) No.
447 of 2019 order dated 07.10.2023, High Court of Manipur set aside
WP(C) No. 115 of 2021
Page 6
denial of promotion on the basis of uncommunicated adverse report and
directed for giving promotion with respect to Assam Rifles.
[12]
Relying on the above referred case laws, Mrs. O. Momota,
learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the impugned orders be set
aside, as the denial of promotion to the petitioner was on the basis of
uncommunicated adverse entry in ACR and prays for giving a direction to the
respondents to grant promotion to the petitioner with consequential reliefs from
the date on which his junior was promoted. During the course of hearing, it has
been informed that the petitioner was subsequently promoted to Nb Sub (Clk)
vide order dated 20.01.2023 and his junior Md. Yasin was also further promoted
to the post of Sub Maj (Clk). It is further pointed out that the petitioner retired
from service in the month of January 2024 on attaining the age of
superannuation. It is prayed that the petitioner be given subsequent promotion
to the post of Sub Maj (Clk) as granted to his junior with all consequential relief.
[13]
Mr. S. Samarjeet, learned Sr.PCCG for the respondents has
submitted that as per the bench mark for DPC 2019, the petitioner should have
grading of 3 ‘Above Average’ for the years 2016 to 2018 and 2 ‘High Average’
for the remaining years. But the petitioner has only ‘High Average’ for the year
2016 in terms of enhanced bench mark as per 7th CPC and he was not rightly
considered for promotion and his junior was considered and promoted to Nb
Sub. It is also pointed out that the petitioner has not challenged the instruction
dated 29.12.2016 issued by DGAR, Shillong prescribing the bench mark for
promotion and has not impleaded Md. Yasin who had superseded him and
hence writ petition is not maintainable. Reliance is placed on the decision
reported as AIR 1977 SC 1701 holding that writ petition is bad for nonjoinder of
necessary party. On merit, it is pointed out that in the case reported as AIR
2008 SC 2513 @ para 40 & 41, Hon’ble Supreme Court held that
communication of adverse report in ACR will not be appliable to military. It is
prayed that the writ petition be dismissed.
[14]
Mrs. O. Momota, learned counsel for the petitioner has clarified
that the petitioner is not challenging the promotion of his junior, but he only
claims parity with him and as such he was not impleaded as a party. It is further
WP(C) No. 115 of 2021
Page 7
pointed out that the conditions of service of Assam Rifles is not governed by
Army Act and hence the decision in AIR 2008 SC 2513 will not be applicable in
the facts of the present case and as such adverse entry in ACR must be
communicated, otherwise the same cannot be used to deny promotion to the
petitioner.
[15]
This Court has perused the materials on record and considered
the submissions made at bar and relevant law in this regard. In the present
case, the petitioner was graded as 4 ‘Above Average 7 pts’ and 1 ‘High Average
5 pts’ during the last five years, while the rules required only 3 ‘Above Average
7 pts’ and 2 ‘High Average 5 pts’ during the last 5 years. But, for the DPC 2019,
the bench mark for promotion from ‘Nb Sub to Sub’ was laid down as 3 ‘Above
Average 7 pts’ for the year 2016-18 and 2 ‘High Average 5 pts’ for other years.
The DPC 2019 did not consider the petitioner as eligible, as he got only ‘High
Average’ during the year 2016-17 instead of ‘Above Average’ as prescribed by
DPC 2019. In other words, the rating of the petitioner for the year 2016-17 was
treated as below bench mark fixed by relevant rule and hence it is deemed to
be an adverse entry. It is also a fact that this entry was not communicated to
the petitioner as admitted by the respondents on the plea of the same ‘not
adverse entry’, but the same was considered below bench mark by the
respondents to deny promotion to the petitioner.
[16]
This Court is of the considered view that the stand of the
respondents is not consistent and as opposed to relevant rules. On one hand,
it is stated that the grading of ‘High Average’ for the year 2016-17 was not
‘adverse entry’, but the petitioner was denied promotion on the ground of below
bench mark grading. As held in the case of Vijay Kumar (supra),
uncommunicated adverse entry in ACR cannot be a ground to deny promotion
to the petitioner. Another fallacy in the stand of the respondents is that the rule
requires only 3 ‘Above Average’ during the last five years and 2 ‘High Average’
and the petitioner was graded 4 ‘Above Average’ during the last five years and
well above the minimum bench mark. Denial of the promotion to the petitioner
on the basis of instruction dated 29.12.2016 is arbitrary, irrational and without
any basis. This Court is of firmed opinion that executive instructions cannot
WP(C) No. 115 of 2021
Page 8
override the statutory requirements and the plea of the respondents that the
petitioner did not challenge the instructions dated 29.12.2016 for DPC 2019 is
without any substance and hence rejected.
[17]
In the circumstances, the writ petition is allowed with the following
directions:
(a)
Letters dated 01.07.2019 and dated 25.09.2019 issued by Directorate
General Assam Rifles, Shillong are set aside;
(b)
Uncommunicated entry of ‘High Average’ in the ACR for the year 2016-
17 cannot be used to deny promotion to the petitioner as per the instructions
dated 29.12.2016, when the petitioners had 4 ‘Above Average- 7 points’ as per
rules;
(c)
The petitioner be promoted to the post of Sub (Clk) wef 26.02.2019, the
date from which his junior was promoted with all consequential benefits; and
(d)
The petitioner also be considered for promotion to the post of Sub Maj
(Clk) wef 16.01.2023, the date from which his junior was promoted with all
consequential benefits, if found eligible as per rules, within a period of 3 months
from the date of receipt of a copy of this order.
[18]
With the above directions and observations, the writ petition is
allowed. No cost.
[19]
Registry is directed to send a copy of this order to Director General
of Assam Riles, Shillong for information and necessary compliance.
JUDGE
FR/NFR
joshua
KH.
JOSHUA
MARING
KH. JOSHUA
MARING
Date: 2024.04.22
13:10:03 +05'30'
WP(C) No. 115 of 2021
Page 9
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review