Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.135 of 2023
Shri Sanjit Kumar Das, S/o Late Sukha Ranjan Das, resident of Rajarbag,
P.O. Rajarbag, Arunachal Sangha Road, Udaipur, Gomati Tripura
………Petitioner(s)
Versus
1. State of Tripura, represented by Secretary to the Govt. of Tripura in the
Finance Department, having its office at Civil Secretariat, New Capital
Complex, P.O- Kunjaban, Agartala, District- West Tripura
2. Commissioner of Taxes and Excise, Government of Tripura, having its
office at P.N. Complex, Gurkha Basti, P.O- Kunjaban, Agartala, Dist.- West
Tripura
3. Secretary to the Government of Tripura in the GA (P&T) Department,
having its office at Civil Secretariat, New Capital Complex, P.O- Kunjaban,
Agartala, District- West Tripura
4. Tripura Public Service Commission, represented by its Chairman, having
its office at Akhaura Road, P.O- Agartala, Dist.- West Tripura
5. Shri Suman Das, S/o- Late Sunil Ch. Das, resident of Town Bordwali,
New Gangail Road, P.O. Agartala, West Tripura
6. Shri Manas Das, S/o Shri Jatindra Ch. Das, resident of Kumari Tilla,
Kunjaban, P.O. Abhoynagar, Agartala, West Tripura
………Respondent(s).
For Petitioner(s)
: Mr. T.D. Majumder, Sr. Advocate,
Mr. T. Halam, Advocate,
Ms. Rimi Debbarma, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
: Mr. D. Sarma, Addl. G.A.,
Mr. S. Lodh, Advocate,
Mr. Raju Datta, Advocate.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
Order
10/07/2023
Heard Mr. T.D. Majumder, learned senior counsel assisted by
Mr. T Halam, learned counsel and Ms. Rimi Debbarma, learned counsel for
the petitioner, Mr. D. Sarma, learned Additional Government Advocate for
the respondents-State, Mr. Raju Datta, learned counsel for Tripura Public
Service Commission and Mr. S. Lodh, learned counsel for the private
respondents.
2.
Petitioner got promoted on 23.12.2021 on ad-hoc basis to the
post of TCS Grade-II from the feeder post of Inspector of Taxes which he
accepted. Thereafter, on his representation and due consideration, he along
with 7(seven) others were reverted to the feeder post to their parent
department. The private respondents, who are also Inspector of Taxes and
belonging to the same Scheduled Caste category, got promoted to the post of
Superintendent of Taxes, the next promotional post, on ad-hoc basis vide
notification dated 09.01.2023 which has aggrieved the petitioner to approach
this Court.
3.
Petitioner seeks consideration of his case for promotion to the
post of Superintendent of Taxes, Finance Department by holding review
DPC with effect from the date his immediate juniors have been promoted. He
also prays for a direction upon the respondents and each of them to step
down respondents No.5 and 6 to the post of Inspector of Taxes and he be
promoted to the post of Superintendent of Taxes. Petitioner has also prayed
that the notification dated 22.06.2021 of the Promotion Policy be called for
and be quashed or read down as it tends to deprive the petitioner for
consideration of promotion from feeder cadre.
4.
Respondents-State, TPSC and private respondents, all have filed
their Counter Affidavit. Petitioner has also filed his Rejoinder Affidavit. It is
not disputed by the petitioner that promotion to TCS Grade-II from the
feeder post of Inspector of Taxes is in the channel of promotion apart from
the promotional post of Superintendent of Taxes also. It is also not in dispute
that petitioner belongs to the same Scheduled Caste category as private
respondents and ranks senior to the respondents No.5 and 6 in the seniority
list dated 26.03.2021. The main grievance of the petitioner is that after
having been reverted to the post of Inspector of Taxes by a notification dated
30.09.2022 [Annexure-6] of the General Administration (Personnel &
Training) Department, Government of Tripura [GA (P&T) Department, for
short] along with 7(seven) others on their own representation to the
substantive post, petitioner does not lose a right to be considered for next
promotional post in the parent department i.e. in Superintendent of Taxes. By
granting promotion to the private respondents, he has been arbitrarily
discriminated. It is further submitted that the guidelines contained in the
Promotion Policy dated 22.06.2021 [Annexure-5] has to be read down as
being in teeth of the recruitment rules. As such, by reverting the respondents
on the principle of last come first go, petitioner should be promoted on the
promotional post of Superintendent of Taxes, as he does not forfeit the claim
for being considered for promotion to the next promotional post under the
Promotion Policy of 2021.
5.
It is the case of the respondents-State that the promotion to the
post of TCS Grade-II on ad-hoc basis by notification dated 23.12.2021 was
as per the Promotion Policy dated 22.06.2021. Petitioner joined the
promotional post on being released from his parent department and later
submitted representation to revert him back to the parent department to the
substantive post owing to various reasons. The department considered the
representation of the petitioner along with 7(seven) others and vide
notification dated 30.09.2022, reverted him after serving 9(nine) months on
the promoted post of TCS Grade-II. Respondents rely upon Clause 8(iv) of
the Promotion Policy, 2021 framed by the GA (P&T) Department on
22.06.2021 which inter alia reads as under :
“8. (iv) Benefit of the ad-hoc appointment on promotion shall be
available to accommodate a candidate to the immediate next higher
promotion post/grade only and such benefit shall not be considered to
accommodate the said candidate to multiple higher posts/grade with
prospective effect.”
Since petitioner has already availed the benefit of ad-hoc promotion as per
Promotion Policy, 2021, there is no scope for promotion on ad-hoc basis for
second time. Promotions on ad-hoc basis are subject to final outcome of the
pending S.L.P and there appears no loss of inter se seniority for not allowing
such reconsideration. It is also contended that petitioner got promoted to the
post of TCS Grade-II from feeder post on ad-hoc basis as one time measure
on probation, subject to the final outcome of the S.L.P. It is also their case
that petitioner cannot avail multiple promotions in view of Clause 8(iv) of
the Promotion Policy, 2021.
6.
Mr. D. Sarma, learned Additional Government Advocate for the
respondents-State, submits that the reversion has been made as per Clause
(4) of Rule 21 of TCS Rules, 1967 and as per FR 9 and 11(2). All ad-hoc
promotions in various departments were made as per guidelines framed by
the Promotion Policy 2021 and DPC conducted in all departments. The first
promotion was allowed to the writ petitioner in TCS Grade-II in GA (P&T)
Department, i.e. to the higher post. Therefore, he cannot claim second
promotion to the higher post; even if the DPC is conducted in the parent
department. Respondents-State finally, at Para 17 of their Counter Affidavit
says that further promotion is made almost in every grade at every
department following the ad-hoc Promotion Policy. Deviation from any of
the conditions of the Policy may have chain effect if the reverted employees
are further promoted by demotion of an already promoted employee as it
may result in administrative chaos. Therefore, the writ petition is without any
merit and deserves to be dismissed.
7.
Mr. Raju Datta, learned counsel for the Tripura Public Service
Commission, has also filed a Counter Affidavit and categorically stated at
Para 5 that while considering the cases of the private respondents for
promotion to the post of Superintendent of Taxes, the advice of GA (P&T)
Department was taken. The GA (P&T) Department, however, came out with
a clear advice that after the petitioner has been reverted on his own request in
terms of the Promotion Policy, 2021, his case cannot be considered for
promotion for second time on ad-hoc basis to the post of Superintendent of
Taxes. Such promotions are ad-hoc in nature and subject to final outcome of
pending S.L.P and there appears to be no loss of seniority for not allowing
such reconsideration. Therefore, petitioner’s case does not have any merit.
8.
Mr. S. Lodh, learned counsel for the private respondents No.5
and 6, also submits that the private respondents were in line of promotion to
the post of TCS Grade-II when the petitioner was considered and promoted
on 23.12.2021. Had the petitioner refused to accept the promoted post of
TCS Grade-II, respondents No.5 at least could have been considered for
promotion to that post. Petitioner accepted the post, continued in that post for
9(nine) months and then was reverted on his own request in terms of the
relevant service rules and fundamental rules. Now, in view of the Promotion
Policy, 2021, the respondents No.5 and 6 have thereafter been promoted as
Superintendent of Taxes, therefore petitioner again cannot claim to be
considered for promotion to the post of Superintendent of Taxes thereby
excluding the chance of promotion of the respondents No.5 and 6. He also
states that though Respondents No.5 and 6 are admittedly junior to the
petitioner as per the seniority list but the petitioner cannot claim multiple
promotion in teeth of the Promotion Policy 2021. The principle of approbate
and reprobate would apply in such case. It is further submitted that the
Promotion Policy of 2021 is being applied uniformly in view of the
pendency of the S.L.P and any deviation therefor may result in
administrative chaos as is also the case of the respondent department.
9.
Mr. T.D. Majumder, learned senior counsel for the petitioner,
has drawn the attention of this Court to the notification dated 10.05.2023
[Annexure-2] by which one Shyamal Chandra Das, Superintendent of Taxes
who was appointed to the post of TCS Grade-II on ad-hoc basis vide
notification dated 23.12.2021 has been reverted to his substantive post of
Superintendent of Taxes on his own request. It is further pointed out that two
other persons – Sri Manish Kumar Deb (promoted against UR quota) and Sri
Shantanu Deb Barman (promoted against ST Supernumerary post) to the
post of Superintendent of Taxes on ad-hoc basis along with 10(ten) others
vide notification dated 09.01.2023, have also been reverted to the next lower
grade from which they were earlier promoted in view of FR 9 of the F.R.S.R.
to accommodate Sri Shyamal Chandra Das in the grade of Superintendent of
Taxes. As such, precedence are there for accommodation of a promoted
employee to the equivalent promotional post in the parent department i.e.
Superintendent of Taxes. Respondents-State and TPSC, therefore, should not
be allowed to make an exception in the case of the petitioner.
10.
Mr. D. Sarma, learned Additional Government Advocate for the
respondents-State, categorically rebuts the aforesaid contention based on the
notification dated 10.05.2023 and submits that the reversion of one Sri
Shyamal Chandra Das from TCS Grade-II has not been to the lower post but
to the equivalent post of Superintendent of Taxes on his representation and
as such, the two persons – Sri Manish Kumar Deb and Sri Shantanu Deb
Barman have been reverted to their substantive post of Inspector of Taxes as
per FR 9 of the F.R.S.R. It is not a case that Sri Shyamal Chandra Das got
reverted to his substantive post of Inspector of Taxes and then has been
allowed promotion to the post of Superintendent of Taxes by reverting the
earlier promoted persons. As such, parity cannot be drawn on that instance.
11.
I have considered the submission of learned counsel for the
parties, taken note of the relevant materials placed from the records by them
including the order of promotion of the petitioner dated 23.12.2021, the
notification of his reversion dated 30.09.2022, notification of promotion
dated 09.01.2023 of the private respondents, the Promotion Policy, 2021
notified on 22.06.2021 and also the notification dated 10.05.2023
[Annexure-2] apart from the other documents placed by the parties. Here is a
case where the petitioner, after having accepted joining on a promoted post
in the normal channel of promotion from the feeder substantive post of
Inspector of Taxes in TCS Grade-II sought reversion during his period of
probation on his own application. That request was considered along with
7(seven) other such applicants and petitioner was reverted after 9(nine)
months of serving on the promoted post of TCS Grade-II. These ad-hoc
promotions are being done as per Promotion Policy, 2021 notified on
22.06.2021 in view of the pendency of the S.L.P on the larger issue and the
interim order granted by the Apex Court to carry on ad-hoc promotions to the
promotional posts by the respective State Governments. The Promotion
Policy, 2021, issued by GA (P&T) Department, has been applied uniformly
in all such cases. In fact, while considering the promotion of the private
respondents, the TPSC sought opinion from the GA (P&T) Department as to
whether an incumbent reverted to his parent post after accepting promotion
on the higher post on ad-hoc basis could still be considered for promotion to
the next higher post in an independent exercise along with other eligible
persons. GA (P&T) Department has categorically opined against it and also
taken the plea that it would result in administrative chaos. The petitioner has
challenged the Promotion Policy, 2021. However, the Promotion Policy,
2021 has been framed in view of the peculiar situation operating in the
departments of the State Government since regular promotions were not
being granted in view of the pendency of the S.L.P before the Apex Court.
Therefore, ad-hoc promotions are being granted under certain guidelines and
conditions. One of the guidelines at Clause 8(iv) of the Promotion Policy
stipulates that a person cannot be allowed to avail multiple promotions after
grant of ad-hoc promotion and that too in the present case when the
petitioner has duly accepted the promotion to the next higher post of TCS
Grade-II and served on that post for almost 9(nine) months. The plea, that the
Promotion Policy, 2021 cannot operate in teeth of the recruitment rules, does
not cut ice as apparently the Promotion Policy has been issued by the GA
(P&T) Department taking into consideration the interim order passed by the
Apex Court on 27.07.2015 and that promotion in the services of the State
Government had remained withheld since 01.04.2017 whereby quite a large
number of posts to be filled up on promotion had to remain vacant thereby
causing hindrance in the day-to-day discharge of administration of the State
Government to the detriment of public interest. Therefore, in order to
augment efficiency of State administration, the State Government decided to
fill up posts lying vacant on ad-hoc basis pending determination of the
appeal sub judice before the Apex Court. It also considered that promoting
eligible State Government employees on ad-hoc basis by following the
process contemplated under the different recruitment rules regulating
promotion criteria and procedures for such posts would be in the larger
interest of the State administration and the employees.
12.
Following the above policy, the DPC identifies employees
eligible for promotion to a particular post against the available vacancies.
After the exercise, DPC considers another exercise taking into account the
procedure as stated in Rule 9(2) of the Tripura SC & ST Reservation Rules,
1992 and in such exercise, if any candidate is found fit, then he is
recommended for ad-hoc promotion by creating supernumerary post(s) also.
Para 8 of the Promotion Policy, 2021 prescribes certain guidelines which are
relevant for appreciation of the issue at hand and are extracted hereunder :
“8. It has also been decided by the Government to allow such
appointment on ad-hoc promotion as one time measure, following the
below mentioned conditions:(i) Appointment on Promotions may be allowed purely on ad-hoc
basis subject to final outcome of the SLP pending before the Hon’ble
Supreme Court of India.
(ii) Ad-hoc appointment on promotion shall be considered keeping in
view of the latest available seniority list of the feeder post/grade
subject to condition that he/she is otherwise suitable & eligible for
promotion.
(iii) No inter-se seniority list shall be determined/published in respect
of these ad-hoc promotions.
(iv) Benefit of the ad-hoc appointment on promotion shall be
available to accommodate a candidate to the immediate next higher
promotion post/grade only and such benefit shall not be considered to
accommodate the said candidate to multiple higher posts/grade with
prospective effect.
(v) To create supernumerary posts, administrative Department shall
assess the number of posts to be created to materialize the promotion
as per above procedure and inform the total number of posts so
determined to Finance Department. No, further concurrence of
Finance Department is required.
(vi) This ad-hoc appointment on promotion shall not be treated as
regular appointment on promotion.
(vii) The ad-hoc appointment on promotion as per guidelines
illustrated above shall be started in the highest grade of a
cadre/service first. Due to such promotion, the resultant vacancies
shall be added with the vacancies in the lower grade, and to be filled
up subsequently.
(viii) Regular DPC may be held based on the existing seniority list.
However, while issuing the orders it should be stipulated that these
promotions are provisional and subject to the final outcome of the
S.L.P. pending before the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India.
Subsequently, when the directions become available, a review DPC
may be held and the necessary adjustments be made in the
promotions of officers based upon the revised seniority list. In case
any of the officers/candidate appointed on ad-hoc promotion do not
figure in the list approved by the review DPC they may be reverted to
the posts held by them earlier.”
It clearly stipulates that benefit of ad-hoc promotion on appointment by
promotion shall be available to accommodate a candidate to the immediate
next higher promotional post/grade only and such benefit shall not be
considered to accommodate the said candidate to multiple higher
posts/grades with prospective effect. As per Para 8 Clause (iii), no inter-se
seniority shall be determined/published in respect of these ad-hoc
promotions. It is true that when the petitioner was promoted in TCS Grade-II,
no inter-se seniority amongst the petitioner and private respondents were
disturbed. Once having accepted the promotion, petitioner has been reverted
on his own request. Petitioner, therefore, cannot be allowed to approbate and
reprobate in such circumstances and then question the Promotion Policy,
2021 under which only he had promoted to the post of TCS Grade-II.
13.
From perusal of the notification dated 10.05.2023, it appears
that it is not a case of reversion of one Sri Shyamal Chandra Das who was
promoted to the post of TCS Grade-II on ad-hoc basis to his substantive
feeder post of Inspector of Taxes. He has only been reverted to the parent
department on the equivalent post of Superintendent of Taxes on his request
and to accommodate him, two persons have been reverted from different
categories to the substantive post of Inspector of Taxes as per FR 9 of
F.R.S.R. As such, the case of the petitioner cannot stand on the same footing
as that of Sri Shyamal Chandra Das covered under notification dated
10.05.2023. It cannot be said that the Promotion Policy, 2021 issued
purportedly in exercise of the powers under Article 162 of the Constitution
of India are in teeth of the recruitment rules in fact, it intends to fill up the
gaps in matters of promotions on ad-hoc basis in the peculiar circumstances
when the matter is sub judice before the Apex Court and vide interim order
dated 27.07.2015, the State parties have been allowed to conduct promotion
exercise to fill up large number of posts which had remained vacant affecting
discharge of administration of the State Government to the detriment of
public interest. If the Promotion Policy, 2021 has been applied uniformly and
without any discrimination, it cannot be said that it operates arbitrarily or
discriminatively to the disadvantage of one or the other employee and is in
teeth of the recruitment rules.
14.
As such, this Court does not find any merit in the writ petition,
which is accordingly dismissed. Pending application(s), if any, also stands
disposed of.
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH), CJ
MUNNA SAHA
Pijush
Date: 2023.07.13 18:05:10 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review