The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
41. In view of the above, we are of the opinion that the decision of this Court in Bhanu Prasad Panda (Dr.)case cannot be read as a Euclid's formula or treated as a precedent, since it has not given any reason for holding that Political Science and Public Administration are distinct and separate subjects, and since the aforesaid decision was given on a concession.” [18] The Court has appreciated the submissions of learned counsel of both sides and also considered the decisions as referred by both the parties as discussed above. The concerned Advertisement No.5 of 2025 contains the essential qualifications for the post of Assistant Professor and in Paragraph No. (I)A(i), the followings are prescribed: “(I) ESSENTIAL QUALIFICATIONS: A (i) A Master’s Degree with at least 55% of the marks (or equivalent grade in a point-scale wherever the grading system is followed) in a concerned/relevant/allied subject from an Indian University on an equivalent degree from an accredited foreign University. (ii) [19] *** *** ” As it appears, the essential qualifications as mentioned in the said advertisement were prescribed maintaining conformity with what is prescribed in the related RR. In the said RR also similar essential qualifications are specified as mentioned in the said advertisement. Thus, it is clear that both as per the RR as well as per the advertisement, the required qualifications for t…
01. 04.2025 issued by the Additional Secretary to the Govt. of Tripura to the under Secretary, TPSC [Annexure-R/6 to the counter affidavit] and subsequent notification dated 17.04.2025 issued by the Secretary, TPSC are required to be quashed only with reference to the subject Political Science. [21] Accordingly, the writ petition is allowed. The letter dated
01. 04.2025 issued by the Additional Secretary to the Govt. of Tripura to the under Secretary, TPSC [Annexure-R/6 to the counter affidavit] and subsequent notification dated 17.04.2025 issued by the Secretary, TPSC are hereby quashed so far it relates to the subject in Political Science. [22] The petitioner is given liberty to submit a fresh representation to the TPSC authority with all necessary supporting documents to justify his claim that his subject „Public Administration‟ comes within the purview of allied subject of Political Science, within 7 days on receipt of copy of this judgment. [23] The respondents shall thereafter decide whether the said subject „Public Administration‟ can be treated as allied subject of „Political Science‟, within two weeks thereafter and shall communicate their v, with a reasoned decision, to the petitioner within next one week. [24] If it is found by the respondents that said subject of the petitioner is the allied subject of „Political Science‟, he shall be allowed to submit his application for the post of Assistant Professor. The entire process shall preferably be completed within four weeks on receipt of the copy of this judgment by the respondents. [25] The writ petition is accordingly disposed of. Interim application(s), if any, shall also stand disposed. Saikat Sarma/Sanjay
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:THC:552
TRHC010009122025
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C)No.323 of 2025
Shri Rupak Biswas,
S/o- Lt Rakesh Biswas of Chentail,
Kailasahar, Unokoti,Tripura – 799279.
… Petitioner(s).
Versus
1.The State of Tripura, represented by the
Secretary of Higher Education,
New Secretariat Complex, Agartala, Kunjaban-799006.
2.The Director,
Department of Higher Education,
Govt. of Tripura, Shiksha Bhawan, Agartala-799001.
3.Tripura Public Service Commission represented by the
Secretary, Agartala, Tripura.
4.University Grants Commission, represented by its
Secretary, Bahadur Shah Zafar Marg, New Delhi-110002.
….Respondent(s).
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. DATTA PURKAYASTHA
For Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. D. Bhattacharya, Sr. Advocate.
Ms. R.Bhattacharjee, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Kohinoor N.Bhattacharyya, GA.
Mr. Kundan Pandey, Advocate.
Date of hearing
:
03.03.2026
Date of delivery of
Judgement & Order
:
30.04.2026
Whether fit for reporting :
YES
NO
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
Heard learned counsel of both sides.
[2]
Learned Sr. Counsel, Mr. Debalay Bhattacharya for the
petitioner submits that an advertisement was issued vide No.05/2025
(Annexure-7) on 31.01.2025 by the Tripura Public Service Commission
[here-in-after referred to as „TPSC‟] for filling up several vacant posts of
Assistant Professor in different disciplines in the Government (General)
Degree Colleges and said advertisement also contains total 14 numbers
of vacant posts in the discipline of „Political Science‟. According to learned
counsel of the petitioner, the eligibility criteria, as was mentioned in the
advertisement, were in conformity with the essential qualifications as
mentioned in the Recruitment Rules [here-in-after referred to as „RR‟]
meant for the post of such Assistant Professor.
[3]
According to learned Sr. Counsel, the petitioner intended to
apply for the said post in respect of the discipline „Political Science‟, but,
he is having the Masters degree in „Public Administration‟ which comes
within the group of „allied subject‟ of Political Science as mentioned in the
said advertisement. Therefore, according to learned Counsel, the
petitioner possesses such required qualification for the post of Assistant
Professor in respect of discipline Political Science. He attempted to apply
online for the post in due time, but he was denied. Thereafter, he sent a
mail dated 05.03.2025 in this regard for allowing him to apply for the said
post and as it appears, simultaneously, another representation was also
received from another prospective candidate.
[4]
The TPSC, thereafter, vide letter dated 13.03.2025(Annexure-
R/3) referred the matter to the Secretary, Education (Higher) Department
seeking views of the parent department in this regard. The State
Government thereafter, formed a committee vide memorandum dated
19.03.2025 (Annexure-R/4) which was also further re-constituted vide
memorandum dated 25.03.2025, and after taking the opinion of the said
Expert Committee into consideration, the Addl. Secretary to the Govt. of
Tripura vide communication dated 01.04.2025, sent the clarification to the
TPSC in the following manner :
“……………………….
I.
For the post of Assistant Professor in Commerce:A candidate should have
(i)
Master Degree in Commerce and
(ii) NET/SLET/SET/Ph.D in Commerce
As essential Qualifications
II.
For the post of Assistant Professor in Political Science :A candidate should have
(i)
Master Degree in Political Scienc and
(ii) NET/SLET/SET/Ph.D in Political Science
As essential Qualifications
III.
For the post of Assistant Professor in Environmental Science :A candidate should have
(i)
Master Degree in Environmental Science and
(ii) NET/SLET/SET/Ph.D in Environmental Science
As essential Qualifications
IV. For the post of Assistant Professor in Botany :A candidate should have
(i)
Master Degree in Botany and
(ii) NET/SLET/SET/Ph.D in Botany
As essential Qualifications……”
[5]
Now, it is the grievance of the present petitioner that in the
name of such clarification, the respondents have already altered the RR
by deleting the words „allied subject‟ in the column of „Essential
Qualifications‟ for the said post and now as per the said clarification, only
a candidate who is having Master‟s degree in Political Science can apply
for the said post and the persons who are having Master‟s degree in allied
subjects are debarred from applying for said post.
[6]
Learned Counsel, Mr. Bhattacharya, submits that on an
earlier occasion also, a similar advertisement was issued vide
advertisement No.1/21 by TPSC (Annexure-13) which also included the
matter of filling up of 4 vacant posts in the discipline of „Political Science‟
and similar to the present advertisement, in that advertisement also it was
mentioned that a person having 55% marks in the Master‟s degree in a
concerned/relevant/allied subject from an Indian University can apply for
the same, and when the petitioner submitted his application in the said
selection process, his application was accepted by the respondents, but,
this time he has been debarred from the said post due to omission of said
words „allied subject‟ in the subsequent clarificatory notification.
[7]
Being aggrieved by the same, the petitioner has filed this
present writ petition seeking following reliefs:
“……….
(a) to set aside/ quash the Notification F.11(36-54)RECTT/TPSC/2024-74 dated 17.04.2025;
(b) to set aside/ quash the Notification F.11(28-4)RECTD/TPSC/2022 dated 19.05.2025;
(c) directing the respondents & each of them to accept
letters of request dated 24.03.2025 and 30.04.2025;
(d) to direct the Respondents to allow the Petitioner to
participate in the Advertisement no.05/2025 in the post of
Assistant Professor, Political Science discipline…….”
[8]
Learned Sr. Counsel, Mr. Debalay Bhattacharya strenuously
argues that the Rule of game cannot be changed when the game has
already been started and moreover, such Expert Committee has no
authority to change, directly or indirectly, the RR or the main
advertisement. According to learned Sr. Counsel, if such clarificatory
notification is allowed to remain on force, required essential qualifications
for the said post as available in the RR as well as in the main
advertisement will be altered and scope of the prospective applicants to
submit their application for the said post will be narrowed down. Learned
Sr. Counsel also submits that he is not pressing at this stage, for any
scrutiny by this Court as to whether the petitioner has the eligibility for
applying for the said post or not, and whether the subject, Public
Administration comes within the category of „allied subject‟ or not. But his
basic challenge is regarding issuance of said clarificatory letter dated
17.04.2025 (Annexure-8) by which said expert opinion was carried out
mentioning that for the post of Assistant Professor, only candidates having
Master‟s degree in Political Science shall be allowed to apply for.
[9]
In support of his submission, learned Sr. Counsel also relies
on a decision of Hon‟ble Supreme Court in case of Abhay Kumar Patel
and Others vs. State of Bihar and Others; (2026) SCC OnLine SC 20.
In said case, during continuation of a recruitment process, the Bihar
Engineering Service, Class–II Recruitment Rules, 2019, under which said
recruitment process was initiated, was changed vide Bihar Engineering
Service, Class–II Recruitment (Amendment) Rules of 2022, giving
retrospective effect of the same, from the date when the original Rule of
2019 came into force and thereby introducing some weightages for the
candidates who were casual worker in the department. Challenging the
retrospective operation of said amendment of 2022, writ petition was filed
by the affected candidates, which was dismissed. Finally, Hon‟ble
Supreme
Court
held
that
such
amendment
cannot
be
applied
retrospectively as the recruitment process in question was initiated under
the 2019 Rules, governing the selection on the date of issuance of the
advertisement and therefore, the said amendment Rules of 2022 had no
application in the said recruitment process.
[10]
Learned Sr. Counsel therefore, prays for quashing the said
notification dated 17.04.2025 (Annexure-8) and with further direction to
allow the petitioner to apply for the said post.
[11]
Learned counsel, Mr. Kundan Pandey for the TPSC,
strenuously argues that it is the parent department who is to decide
regarding the required eligibility of the candidates who are to be selected
for a particular post and in the case in hand, they have constituted Expert
Committee to explain which are to be treated as „allied subject‟ in respect
of discipline „Political Science‟ and here, the duly constituted Expert
Committee has given their own opinion based on which the application of
the petitioner was not allowed and said Expert Committee report was
submitted in respect of the representation submitted by the petitioner.
[12]
Learned Counsel also submits that in the writ jurisdiction,
what should be the eligibility criteria of a candidate for a particular post
cannot be revisited by the Court. Learned Counsel, Mr. Pandey also relies
on a decision of Hon‟ble Supreme Court in case of Maharashtra Public
Service Commission through its Secretary vs. Sandeep Shriram
Warade and Others; (2019) 6 SCC 362, wherein Hon‟ble Supreme Court
at paragraph 9 observes that the essential qualifications for appointment
to a post are for the employer to decide and the employer may prescribe
additional or desirable qualifications, including any grant of preference. It
is the employer who is best suited to decide the requirement of a
candidate must possess according to the needs of the employer and the
nature of work and the court cannot lay down condition of eligibility, much
less can it delve into the issue with regard to desirable qualification being
on a par with the essential eligibility by an interpretative re-writing of the
advertisement.
[13]
Mr. Pandey, Learned Counsel also relies on another decision
of Hon‟ble Supreme Court in case of Union of India vs. Uzair Imran and
Others; (2024) 20 SCC 345 wherein at paragraph 22, the following were
observed by the Hon‟ble Supreme Court:
“22. Normally, it is not the function of the court to determine equivalence of two
qualifications and/or to scrutinise a particular certificate and say, on the basis of
its appreciation thereof, that the holder thereof satisfies the eligibility criteria
and, thus, is qualified for appointment. It is entirely the prerogative of the
employer, after applications are received from interested candidates or names of
registered candidates are sponsored by the Employment Exchanges for public
employment, to decide whether any such candidate intending to participate in
the selection process is eligible in terms of the statutorily prescribed rules for
appointment and also as to whether he ought to be allowed to enter the zone of
consideration i.e. to participate in the selection process. It is only when evidence
of a sterling quality is produced before the court which, without much argument
or deep scrutiny, tilts the balance in favour of one party that the court could
decide either way based on acceptance of such evidence.”
[14]
Learned GA, Mr. Kohinoor N. Bhattacharyya also submits that
in the advertisement the use of words „relevant/ allied subject‟ are only
suggestive of the fact of certain alternative arrangement and main subject
is the Political Science, and it is for the department to decide whether
against the discipline of Political Science they will take any other subject
into consideration as allied subject or relevant subject and in the case in
hand the Expert Committee has already decided that only the candidates
having Master‟s degree in Political Science shall be taken into
consideration which is completely within the domain of an employer.
Therefore, according to learned GA no interference is required in the writ
petition.
[15]
Learned GA also relies on a decision of Hon‟ble Supreme
Court in case of Shifana P.S. vs. State of Kerala and Others; (2024) 8
SCC 309, wherein the followings were observed in paragraph 12 and 13:
“12. Indisputably, the qualifying criteria prescribed for the post
advertised vide Notification dated 30-4-2008 was a degree in BSc
(Chemistry). Admittedly, the appellant does not hold such a degree.
It is the case of the appellant that BSc (Polymer Chemistry) degree
acquired by her is required to be treated as equivalent to a degree
in B.Sc (Chemistry). However, the said argument does not hold
water and is misconceived.
13. This Court in the case of Zahoor Ahmad Rather v. Sk. Imtiyaz
Ahmad held that judicial review can neither expand the ambit of the
prescribed qualifications nor decide the equivalence of the
prescribed qualifications with any other given qualification.
Therefore, the equivalence of a qualification is not a matter that can
be determined in the exercise of the power of judicial review.
Whether a particular qualification should or should not be regarded
as equivalent is a matter for the State, as the recruiting authority, to
determine.
(emphasis supplied)”
[16]
Learned GA relies on another decision of Hon‟ble Supreme
Court in case of Md. Firoz Mansuri and Others vs. State of Bihar and
Others; 2026 SCC OnLine SC 88; wherein at paragraph no. 59 it was
observed that it is for the employer to determine and decide the relevancy
and suitability of qualification. The power of judicial review in the matters
of recruitment is limited to examining legislative competence, arbitrariness
or violation of fundamental rights, if any. Court cannot rewrite the service
rules, determine the equivalence of qualification, or substitute their own
assessment for that of the employer.
[17]
In reply to the submissions made by the learned counsel of
the respondents, learned Sr. Counsel, Mr. Debalay Bhattacharya relies on
another decision of Hon‟ble Supreme Court in case of Rajbir Singh Dalal
(Dr.) vs. Chaudhari Devi Lal University, Sirsa and Another; (2008) 9
SCC 284 and more particularly paragraph no. 31 and 41 of said decision
which are also extracted hereunder:
“31. We agree with Mr. Patwalia, learned counsel, that it is not appropriate for
this Court to sit in appeal over the opinion of the experts who are of the view
that Political Science and Public Administration are interrelated and
interchangeable subjects, and hence a candidate who possesses Masters degree
in Public Administration is eligible for the post of Lecturer in Political Science
and vice versa. We are told that a large number of persons having qualifications
in the interchangeable/interrelated subjects have been appointed Readers/
Professors/ Lecturers and are continuing as such in various colleges and
universities in the State.
****
****
41. In view of the above, we are of the opinion that the decision of this Court
in Bhanu Prasad Panda (Dr.)case cannot be read as a Euclid's formula or treated
as a precedent, since it has not given any reason for holding that Political
Science and Public Administration are distinct and separate subjects, and since
the aforesaid decision was given on a concession.”
[18]
The Court has appreciated the submissions of learned
counsel of both sides and also considered the decisions as referred by
both the parties as discussed above. The concerned Advertisement No.5
of 2025 contains the essential qualifications for the post of Assistant
Professor and in Paragraph No. (I)A(i), the followings are prescribed:
“(I) ESSENTIAL QUALIFICATIONS:
A (i) A Master’s Degree with at least 55% of the marks (or
equivalent grade in a point-scale wherever the grading system
is followed) in a concerned/relevant/allied subject from an
Indian University on an equivalent degree from an accredited
foreign University.
(ii)
[19]
***
*** ”
As it appears, the essential qualifications as mentioned in the
said advertisement were prescribed maintaining conformity with what is
prescribed in the related RR. In the said RR also similar essential
qualifications are specified as mentioned in the said advertisement. Thus,
it is clear that both as per the RR as well as per the advertisement, the
required qualifications for the post of Assistant Professor is Master‟s
Degree with at least 55% marks or equivalent grade in the point-scale
whenever the grading system is followed in the concerned/relevant/allied
subject (emphasis laid) from an Indian University. But while giving
clarification to the same, the Expert Committee constituted for the purpose
has restricted the academic qualifications for the post of Assistant
Professor in Political Science only to MA in Political Science in the
following manner:
“II. For the post of Assistant Professor in Political Science:A Candidate should have
i) Master Degree in Political Science and
ii) NET/SLET/SET/Ph.D in Political Science as Essential
Qualifications.”
[20]
The matter was referred to the said Expert Committee by the
Director of Higher Education for examining the equivalency of the subjects
on being referred to them by TPSC seeking clarification and not to change
or narrow down the requisite qualifications as embodied in the RR or in
the advertisement. But, going beyond the point of reference for such
clarification regarding equivalency of subject, they have even removed the
„equivalent subject‟ itself so far the discipline „Political Science‟ is
concerned. Such act of the Committee is beyond their authority. They
were supposed to simply clarify as to what was the allied subject of Master
Degree in Political Science and whether the subject „Public Administration‟
fell within the category of allied subject or not. They have travelled beyond
what was sent to them for clarification. Therefore, the letter dated
01.04.2025 issued by the Additional Secretary to the Govt. of Tripura to
the under Secretary, TPSC [Annexure-R/6 to the counter affidavit] and
subsequent notification dated 17.04.2025 issued by the Secretary, TPSC
are required to be quashed only with reference to the subject Political
Science.
[21]
Accordingly, the writ petition is allowed. The letter dated
01.04.2025 issued by the Additional Secretary to the Govt. of Tripura to
the under Secretary, TPSC [Annexure-R/6 to the counter affidavit] and
subsequent notification dated 17.04.2025 issued by the Secretary, TPSC
are hereby quashed so far it relates to the subject in Political Science.
[22]
The petitioner is given liberty to submit a fresh representation
to the TPSC authority with all necessary supporting documents to justify
his claim that his subject „Public Administration‟ comes within the purview
of allied subject of Political Science, within 7 days on receipt of copy of
this judgment.
[23]
The respondents shall thereafter decide whether the said
subject „Public Administration‟ can be treated as allied subject of „Political
Science‟, within two weeks thereafter and shall communicate their v, with
a reasoned decision, to the petitioner within next one week.
[24]
If it is found by the respondents that said subject of the
petitioner is the allied subject of „Political Science‟, he shall be allowed to
submit his application for the post of Assistant Professor. The entire
process shall preferably be completed within four weeks on receipt of the
copy of this judgment by the respondents.
[25]
The writ petition
is accordingly disposed
of. Interim
application(s), if any, shall also stand disposed.
JUDGE
SANJAY GHOSH
Saikat Sarma/Sanjay
Date: 2026.04.30 14:59:31 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review