Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE VIJU ABRAHAM
FRIDAY, THE 19TH DAY OF JULY 2024 / 28TH ASHADHA, 1946
OP(C) NO. 1508 OF 2024
AGAINST THE ORDER DATED 12.07.2024 IN IA NO.2/2024 IN OS NO.255 OF 2024
OF MUNSIFF COURT,ALUVA
PETITIONER/PETITIONER/PLAINTIFF:
SHRI. RAMESH VANGAL, AGED 69 YEARS
S/O SHRI VAIKUNTANATHAN SRINIVASA,
RESIDING AT NO. 2C-807, 1ST BLOCK, HRBR LAYOUT,
BANASWADI, BANGALORE REPRESENTED BY
HIS POWER OF ATTORNEY HOLDER
SHRI. A. MANIKANDAN, AGED 54 YEARS,
S/O SHRI K. ACHUTHAN,
RESIDING AT GANGA PARADISE APARTMENTS,
20 ABBAIAH REDDY LAYOUT MAIN ROAD,
OPP TO TOOTH ZONE, KAGGADASPURA,
CV RAMAN NAGAR P.O., BENGALURU, PIN - 560043
BY ADVS.SANTHOSH MATHEW (SR.)(K/1376/1995)
MATHEW NEVIN THOMAS
ARUN THOMAS,KARTHIKA MARIA
VEENA RAVEENDRAN,KURIAN ANTONY MATHEW
ANIL SEBASTIAN PULICKEL, SHINTO MATHEW ABRAHAM
APARNNA S.,JOE S. ADHIKARAM
MANASA BENNY GEORGE
RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENTS/DEFENDANTS:
SHRI.OUMA SHANKAR OCHIT
LIQUIDATOR, KATRA HOLDINGS LIMITED,
MAURITIUS (IN LIQUIDATION) NEXIA BAKER & ARESON,
5TH FLOOR, C&R COURT, 49 LABOURDONNAIS STREET,
PORT LOUIS, MAURITIUS, PIN - 11404
STANDARD CHARTERED BANK (MAURITIUS)
6TH FLOOR, STANDARD CHARTERED TOWER,
BANK STREET, EBENE, MAURITIUS REPRESENTED BY ITS
CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER, PIN - 72201
STANDARD CHARTERED BANK (MUMBAI)
FORT BRANCH NO. 90, MAHATMA GANDHI ROAD,
FORT, MUMBAI REPRESENTED BY ITS
OP(C) No.1508 of 2024
CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER, PIN - 400001
KERALA AYURVEDA LIMITED
VII/415, NEDUMBASERRY, ATHANI, P.O. ALWAYE,
ERNAKULAM, KERALA REPRESENTED BY ITS
MANAGING DIRECTOR, PIN - 683585
BSE LIMITED
25TH FLOOR, PHIROZE JEEJEEBHOY TOWERS,
DALAL STREET, MUMBAI REPRESENTED BY ITS
CHAIRMAN, PIN - 400001
KATRA HOLDINGS LIMITED, MAURITIUS
MORCELLEMENT BOUCAN, PHOENIX,
REPUBLIC OF MAURITIUS ALSO AT C/O TRI-PRO
ADMINISTRATORS LTD, LEVEL 5, MAEVA TOWER,
BANK STREET, EBENE, MAURITIUS - 72201
REPRESENTED BY ITS LIQUIDATOR, PIN - 72201
R4 BY ADVS.
ABRAHAM JOSEPH MARKOS
P.G.CHANDAPILLAI ABRAHAM(MAH/002141/2016)
JOSEPH KODIANTHARA (SR.)(J-381)
THIS OP (CIVIL) HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION ON 19.07.2024,
THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
OP(C) No.1508 of 2024
VIJU ABRAHAM, J.
.................................................................
O.P.(C) No.1508 of 2024
.................................................................
Dated this the 19th day of July, 2024
JUDGMENT
The above original petition is filed by the plaintiff in OS No. 255 of
2024 on the file of the Munsiff Court, Aluva seeking the following reliefs:
“(i) Call for records in O.S. No. 255 of 2024 before the Hon’ble Munsiff
Court at Aluva;
(ii) Pass an order restraining Respondent No. 1 from alienating /
transferring the 64,93,435 shares (ownership interest of 53.97%) of
Respondent No. 6 Katra Mauritius in Respondent No.4 KAL, making any
changes in the composition of the Board of Directors of the Respondent
No. 4 company, or interfering in the day-to-day functioning of the
Respondent No.4 company until final orders are passed in I.A. No. 2 of
2024 in O.S. No. 255 of 2024 before the Hon’ble Munsiff Court at Aluva
filed by the Petitioner/ Plaintiff;
(iii) Direct the Hon’ble Munsiff Court to consider and pass orders in I.A. No.
2 of 2024 in O.S. No. 255 of 2024 before the Hon’ble Munsiff Court at
Aluva filed by the Petitioner/ Plaintiff, within a timeline prescribed by this
Hon’ble Court;
(iv) Declare that the Hon’ble Munsiff Court has the jurisdiction to pass adinterim ex-parte orders against foreign respondents in civil matters, despite
issuance of Office Memorandum dated 12 May 2009 by this Hon’ble Court;
(v) Declare that the Office Memorandum dated 12 May 2009 by this
Hon’ble Court is not applicable when the parties reside in a country which
is not a signatory to the Hague Convention on the Service Abroad of
Judicial and Extrajudicial Documents in Civil or Commercial Matters, 1965;
and
OP(C) No.1508 of 2024
(vi) Pass any other order or further orders in favour of the plaintiff, which
this Hon’ble Court may deem fit and proper in the interest of justice.”
2.
It is averred that the petitioner owns 100% of respondent no.6, i.e.
Katra Holdings Ltd. Mauritius and Katra Holdings (India) Pvt Ltd. 4 th
respondent is a listed public company incorporated in India in which 6 th
respondent holds 53.97% of ownership interest. It is further averred that
one MGM Maran, the then Chairman and Director of Tamilnad Mercantile
Bank Ltd during 2016 acquired an exclusive option from a group of
companies called the Sterling Group to purchase their 33.6% stake for
INR 166.6 Crores. The said MGM Maran assigned this option to the 6th
respondent herein as per an agreement for assignment and the 6 th
respondent agreed to fund 10% advance, find potential investors and act
as an “arranger” for the sellers. It is also contended that Maran and the 6 th
respondent agreed to acquire a further 17% shares of Tamilnad Mercantile
Bank Ltd. for further consideration of INR 150 Crores.
All in all, the
funding requirement for the transaction was around INR 320 Crores. The
6th respondent reached out to Corsair Investments LLC, a New York-based
private equity firm that agreed to act as placement agents/arrangers for
foreign investors and in May 2006, Corsair entered into an agreement with
the 6th respondent in this regard.
The said Corsair introduced 2 nd
respondent, Standard Chartered Bank, Mauritius to the 6th respondent.
Thereupon, Corsair recommended the Standard Chartered Bank to
OP(C) No.1508 of 2024
refinance the 6th respondent’s existing loans and the 2nd respondent
advanced a loan of USD 20,000,000 to 6 th respondent which was
advanced as per Ext.P2 facility letter. The said loan was to be secured by
deposit of title deeds of property of 62 acres of land in Bangalore owned
by the petitioner, pledge of 28.7% of shares of Scandent Holding,
Mauritius Ltd and by deposit of 112151 Tamilnad Mercantile Bank Ltd
shares of the Sterling Group and other Indian Sellers. The 3 rd respondent
is the Standard Chartered Bank, Mumbai Branch. Later an escrow
agreement was executed between Corsair, 6th respondent and 2nd
respondent and the principal objective of the said agreement was to effect
the transaction by procuring the deposit of Tamilnad Mercantile Bank Ltd
shares amounting to 40% of the Bank’s paid-up share in escrow with an
arrangement that the shares would be released on sale to foreign
investors sourced by Corsair. Petitioner contends that the 3 rd respondent
did not seek or apply for RBI approval in opening the escrow accounts. It
is also contended that under the finalised Corsair transaction structure,
instead of transferring the allocated Tamilnad Mercantile Bank Ltd shares
to approved foreign investors named in the RBI approval, the shares were
transferred by respondents nos.1 to 3 to “purchasing entities” which were
Mauritian subsidies of Cayman Holding Company. Petitioner contends that
the 3rd respondent was under a statutory duty to ensure compliance with
RBI approval and FEMA. It is contended that a substantial amount of loan
OP(C) No.1508 of 2024
has already been repaid and some default occurred on account of FEMA
contraventions by 3rd respondent. Certain litigations were initiated by the
shareholders before the Madras and Bombay High Court which ultimately
resulted in Ext.P3 order passed by the Deputy Governor of the Reserve
Bank of India, the operative portion of which reads as follows:
“In the circumstances, I do not consider that the investors mentioned in
the order dated October 12, 2009 have satisfied the criteria fixed by the
RBI for acknowledgement purpose. Therefore, I have no other choice but
to decline to acknowledge the holding of 5% or more of the paid up
capital of TMBL by the group consisting of M/s.RST Limited, Katra
Holdings Limited, GHI Limited, Kamehameha Mauritius Limited, FI
Investments (Mauritius) Limited, Cuna Group (Mauritius) Limited, Swiss
Re-investors (Mauritius) Limited, Shri Gokul Patnaik, Vector Programme
Private Limited, Shri Sathiyaseelan, Hemangini Finance and Leasing P
Limited, Shanmuga Financial Services P Limited, Shri L Sridharan, Shri N
Ganesan, Shri R.Chinnakannan, Smt Chandrammal, Shri M G M Maran
and Shri M G Muthu. The Group holding in the aggregate should be
below 5% of the paid up capital of TMBL.”
The Enforcement Directorate issued Ext.P4 show-cause notice alleging
FEMA, 1999 violation, and later Ext.P5 order was issued by the
Enforcement Directorate whereby action was initiated against various
entities including Tamilnad Mercantile Bank Ltd and Standard Chartered
Bank.
3.
Thereafter, the 6th respondent initiated arbitration proceedings
against Standard Chartered Bank and Corsair for failure to perform
obligations, but the Arbitral Tribunal dismissed their claim. Meanwhile, the
OP(C) No.1508 of 2024
2nd respondent initiated bankruptcy proceedings in the Mauritian Court
seeking the winding up of 6th respondent. While proceedings were initiated
against the 6th respondent, they approached the Supreme Court of
Mauritius and the Court after considering the contentions raised by both
sides declined to interfere with the challenge raised by the 6 th respondent
as per Ext.P6 order. An appeal was preferred by the 6 th respondent before
the judicial committee of the Privy Council, England and Wales but the
same was also rejected as per Ext.P7 order. In Ext.P7 order, it was also
ordered that the stay on the judge’s winding-up order will be lifted so that
the winding-up may immediately proceed.
4.
Later the Supreme Court of Mauritius issued Ext.P9 order
appointing the 1st respondent as a liquidator of the 6 th respondent. On the
strength of the said appointment, the 1st respondent issued Ext.P10
communication to the 4th respondent company in which the 6th respondent
holds 53.97% of ownership interest. In Ext.P10, it is intimated that no
further transaction in respect of the 4th respondent company can be
approved by the Company’s Director and/or previously designated
personnel and all trading has to be authorized by the liquidator. It is further
averred that the petitioner is reserving his right to challenge the
appointment of 1st respondent liquidator at the behest of 2 nd respondent,
especially in view of the petition pending before the Mauritian Supreme
Court to rescind the winding up order which is listed for hearing on
OP(C) No.1508 of 2024
31.07.2024. It is aggrieved by the hurried action as evidenced by Ext.P10
communication while the proceedings for rescinding the winding up order
is pending before the competent court in Mauritius that the petitioner has
approached the Munsiff’s Court, Aluva by filing O.S. No.255 of 2024 and
sought for an ex parte ad interim injunction against the 1st respondent from
acting in furtherance of Ext.P9 order of the Supreme Court of Mauritius.
5.
The present original petition is filed since the trial court did not pass
any orders on Ext.P2 application seeking interim injunction which is filed
as I.A. No.2 of 2024 in O.S. No.255 of 2024. Petitioner contends that the
trial court as per order dated 12.07.2024 issued notice to the respondents
with a direction to take steps to issue notice as provided in OM of this
Court dated 12.05.2009 regarding service of judicial process to persons
residing abroad and posted the case to 23.09.2024. Petitioner would
contend that the purpose of office memorandum dated 12.05.2009 which
was relied on by the Trial Court for issue of notice to the respondents is to
direct service of notice as per the terms of the Hague Convention.
Petitioner further contends that Mauritius is not a signatory to the Hague
Convention and therefore there was no necessity for complying with the
OM dated 12.05.2009. Petitioner relying on Ext.P14 Hague Convention
1965 submits that the only interdiction in Article 15 of the Hague
Convention is not to pass a judgment without issuing notice as provided
therein and that the court considering the matter can order, in case of
OP(C) No.1508 of 2024
urgency any provisional or protective measures. It is aggrieved by nonconsideration of Ext.P12 application seeking interim injunction that the
present original petition is filed under Article 227 of the Constitution of
India.
6.
Heard the respective senior counsel appearing for the petitioner as
well as the 4th respondent.
7.
As per the averment in the original petition, the proceeding against
statutory demand from the 6th respondent was challenged before the
Supreme Court of Mauritius and the challenge was repelled by the Court
as per Ext.P6 and the appeal preferred against the same before the Privy
Council was also dismissed as per Ext.P7 order. Thereafter, a liquidator
was appointed by the Supreme Court of Mauritius as per Ext.P9. As
averred in the original petition, a petition is pending before the Supreme
Court of Mauritius to rescind the winding up order and the same is posted
for hearing on 31.07.2024 and it is only due to the hurried action by the 1 st
respondent on the instruction of the 2nd respondent that the petitioner was
compelled to seek protective action before this Court.
The scope of interference under Article 227 of the Constitution of
India is limited to the extent focused on ensuring that the trial courts or
Tribunals function within the limits of their authority. It is to be noted that
the petitioner has already moved the Civil Court by filing O.S. No. 255 of
2024 in which Ext.P12 application, I.A. No.2 of 2024 is filed seeking an
OP(C) No.1508 of 2024
interim injunction and the court was pleased to issue notice to the
respondents both in the interlocutory application and in the suit. Since
Ext.P12 application is pending consideration before the Munsiff’s Court,
Aluva, it is for the petitioner to move the said court seeking early
consideration of the said application. Since I.A. No. 2 of 2024 in O.S.
No.255 of 2024 (Ext.P12) is pending consideration before the Munsiff’s
Court, Aluva, the above original petition is disposed of granting liberty to
the petitioner to seek for early consideration of I.A. No.2 of 2024, in the
event of which the Munsiff’s Court, Aluva shall take all endeavour to
consider the same in accordance with law at the earliest, preferably within
an outer limit of three weeks from the date of receipt of a copy of this
judgment.
With the above said direction, the original petition is disposed of.
Sd/-
VIJU ABRAHAM
JUDGE
cks
OP(C) No.1508 of 2024
APPENDIX OF OP(C) 1508/2024
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
Exhibit P1
A TRUE COPY OF THE A-DIARY OF THE HON'BLE
MUNSIFF COURT AT ALUVA DATED 12 JULY 2024,
WITH THE PROCEEDINGS IN O.S. NO. 255 OF
2024 INCLUDING IN I.A. NO. 2 OF 2024.
Exhibit P2
A TRUE COPY OF THE FACILITY LETTER DATED
DECEMBER 29, 2006 EXECUTED BETWEEN THE
KATRA
HOLDINGS
LIMITED,
MAURITIUS
AND
STANDARD CHARTERED BANK (MAURITIUS) LIMITED
FOR A LOAN OF USD 20,000,000/- (US DOLLARS
TWENTY MILLION)
Exhibit P3
A TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER PASSED BY THE
DEPUTY GOVERNOR RESERVE BANK OF INDIA ON
MARCH 31, 2011
Exhibit P4
A TRUE COPY OF THE SHOW CAUSE NOTICE
BEARING F. NO. T-4/10/BGZO/SRO/2014 DATED
DECEMBER 17, 2014 ISSUED BY THE ENFORCEMENT
DIRECTORATE
Exhibit P5
A TRUE COPY OF ORDER DATED AUGUST 14, 2020
PASSED
BY
THE
ENFORCEMENT
DIRECTORATE
BEARING ORDER NO. SDE/SRO/CEZO/10/2020(SK)
Exhibit P6
A TRUE COPY OF THE JUDGEMENT DATED JULY 05,
2017, PASSED BY THE SUPREME COURT OF
MAURITIUS
IN
RECORD
NO.
SC/COM/MOT/01320/2015
BETWEEN
KATRA
HOLDINGS LIMITED, MAURITIUS AND STANDARD
CHARTERED BANK (MAURITIUS) LIMITED
Exhibit P7
A TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER DATED APRIL 09,
2024 PASSED BY JUDICIAL COMMITTEE OF THE
PRIVY COUNCIL, ENGLAND & WALES IN PRIVY
COUNCIL APPEAL NO 0044 OF 2022
Exhibit P8
A TRUE COPY OF SHOW CAUSE NOTICE BEARING F.
NO. T4/15/CEZO-1/SRO/2017 DATED NOVEMBER
09,
ISSUED
BY
THE
ENFORCEMENT
DIRECTORATE
Exhibit P9
A TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER DATED JUNE 19,
2024, PASSED BY SUPREME COURT OF MAURITIUS
OP(C) No.1508 of 2024
IN SC/COM/MOT/000503/2024, APPOINTING SHRI.
OUMA SHANKAR OCHIT AS THE LIQUIDATOR OF
KATRA HOLDINGS LIMITED, MAURITIUS
Exhibit P10
A TRUE COPY OF THE NOTICE DATED JULY 08,
2024, ISSUED BY SHRI. OUMA SHANKAR OCHIT,
LIQUIDATOR,
KATRA
HOLDINGS
LIMITED,
MAURITIUS
(IN
LIQUIDATION)
TO
KERALA
AYURVEDA LIMITED
Exhibit P11
A TRUE COPY OF THE PLAINT IN O.S. NO. 255
OF 2024 DATED 12TH JULY 2024 BEFORE THE
HON'BLE MUNSIFF COURT AT ALUVA
Exhibit P12
A TRUE COPY OF I.A. NO. 2 IN O.S. NO. 255
OF 2024 DATED 12TH JULY 2024 BEFORE THE
HON'BLE MUNSIFF COURT AT ALUVA
Exhibit P13
A TRUE COPY OF THE CASE STATUS OF O.S. NO.
255 OF 2024 BEFORE THE HON'BLE MUNSIFF
COURT AT ALUVA
Exhibit P14
A TRUE COPY OF THE HAGUE CONVENTION, 1965
ALONG WITH THE MODEL FORM AND ACCOMPANYING
GUIDELINES
Exhibit P15
A TRUE COPY OF THE OFFICE MEMORANDUM ISSUED
BY
THE
DEPARTMENT
OF
LEGAL
AFFAIRS
(JUDICIAL SECTION), MINISTRY OF LAW AND
JUSTICE,
GOVERNMENT
OF
INDIA
DATED
18.08.2011
Exhibit P16
A TRUE COPY OF THE DATA RELATING TO KERALA
AYURVEDA
LIMITED
AS
AVAILABLE
ON
THE
WEBSITE OF MINISTRY OF CORPORATE AFFAIRS
AND THE BSE
Exhibit P17
A
TRUE
COPY
OF
THE
APPLICATION
FOR
CERTIFIED COPY SUBMITTED BY THE PETITIONER
DATED 13.07.2024
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review