Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
--1--
IN THE
HIGH COURT
OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT I N D O R E
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE HIRDESH
ON THE 24th OF JANUARY, 2024
MISC. APPEAL No. 1382 of 2019
BETWEEN:SHRI RAM GENERAL INSURANCE CO. LTD. THROUGH LEGAL
MANAGER LEGAL MANAGER 2ND FLOOR ANMOL SPACE BUILDING
KHAJRANA ROAD INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....APPELLANT
(SHRI MAYANK UPADHYAY, LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE APPELLANT)
AND
1. BHAYYALAL S/O CHATAR SINGH GURJAR, AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS,
VILLAGE NANGPACHLANA TEHSIL TONK KHURD, PS. PIPALRAWA
DISTT DEWAS (MADHYA PRADESH)
2. SMT. SAURAM BAI W/O BHAYYALAL, AGED ABOUT 48 YEARS,
VILLAGE NANGPACHLANA TEHSIL TONK KHURD, PS. PIPALRAWA
DISTT DEWAS (MADHYA PRADESH)
3. RAMKUNWAR BAI D/O CHATARSINGH, AGED ABOUT 70 YEARS,
VILLAGE NANGPACHLANA TEHSIL TONK KHURD, PS. PIPALRAWA
DISTT DEWAS (MADHYA PRADESH)
4. RAHUL S/O VIKRAM SINGH JAWARIYA, AGED ABOUT 32 YEARS,
OCCUPATION: OWNER AVANTIPUR BARODIYA, P.S. AVANTIPUR
BADODIYA (MADHYA PRADESH)
5. SANTOSH S/O SUNDERLAL, AGED ABOUT 23 YEARS, VILLAGE
KHAMKHEDA BAIJNATH, TEH. ASHTA (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(SHRI VIPUL BHARGAVA, LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE RESPONDENTS)
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MISC. APPEAL No. 164 of 2020
BETWEEN:1. BHAYYALAL S/O CHATARSINGH, AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS, VILLAGE
--2-NAAGPACHLANA TEH TAAK KHURD PS PIPLARAVA DEWAS (MADHYA
PRADESH)
2. SMT. SOURAMBAI W/O BHAYYALAL, AGED ABOUT 48 YEARS,
VILLAGE NAAGPACHLANA TEH. TAAK KHURD P.S. PIPLARAVA DIST.
DEWAS (MADHYA PRADESH)
3. RAMKUNWAR BAI W/O CHATARSINGH, AGED ABOUT 70 YEARS,
VILLAGE NAAGPACHLANA TEH. TAAK KHURD P.S. PIPLARAVA DIST.
DEWAS (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....APPELLANTS.
(SHRI VIPUL BHARGAVA, LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE APPELLANTS)
AND
1. RAHUL S/O VIKRAM SINGH JAWARIYA, AGED ABOUT 32 YEARS,
OCCUPATION: OWNER OF VEHICLE AWANTIPURA BADODIYA PS
AWANTIPURA BADODIYA SHAJAPUR (MADHYA PRADESH)
2. SANTOSH S/O SUNDERLAL, AGED ABOUT 23 YEARS, OCCUPATION:
DRIVER VILLAGE KHAAMKHEDA BAIJNATH TEH. AASTA DIST.
SEHORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
3. THROUGH BRANCH MANAGER THE SHRI RAM GENERAL
INSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED BRANCH OFFICE I.C.T FLOOR PLOT
NO. 48 MP NAGAR ZONE 2 BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(SHRI MAYANK UPADHYAY, LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE RESPONDENT
[R-3])
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
These appeal coming on for admission this day, the court passed the
following:
ORDER
Both these appeals have been analogously heard and are being
decided by this common order.
2.
M.A. No.1382/2019 has been filed by the insurance company under
under Section 173 (1) of Motor Vehicle Act challenging the impugned
award dated 12.12.2018 passed by Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Indore
in Claim Case No.23/2017 seeking exoneration of the liability of insurance
company.
--3-3.
M.A. No.164/2020 has been filed by the claimants under under
Section 173 (1) of Motor Vehicle Act challenging the same award
mentioned as above on account of inadequacy of compensation and seeking
enhancement of compensation.
4.
The brief facts of the case are that on 24.02.2017, deceased-Shyamlal
along with Vijendra were coming towards Shivalay Temple from Avantipur
Badodiya by driving motorcycle. The deceased was driving the motorcycle
carefully and slowly, meanwhile, non-applicant No.2- Santosh who was
driving vehicle bearing registration No.MP37-MK-6442 with rashly and
negligently and hit the deceased's motorcycle because of which Shyamlal
died on the spot and Vijay received injuries.
5.
Claimants of Shyamlal filed claim petition seeking compensation to
the tune of Rs.25,00,000/- in different heads against the respondents on
account of death of Shaymlal.
6.
Respondents denied the allegations pleaded in the pleadings.
7.
Tribunal framed issues after considering the evidence of both the
parties and the claim of the claimants was partly allowed and compensation
to the tune of Rs.4,66,600/- was awarded with interest.
8.
Being aggrieved by the above award, claimants filed this appeal
(M.A. No.164/2020) by stating that the compensation amount awarded by
the tribunal is on lower side and the tribunal has committed error in
assessing the income of the deceased, which is very lower side and also has
not given compensation in other heads. It has been also submitted that
compensation was awarded by tribunal assessing the income of the
deceased as Rs.3000/- per month which is inadequate looking to the fact
that the deceased was healthy and doing agricultural work, therefore, his
income must be assessed as Rs.8000/- per month and accordingly,
--4-reasonable compensation amount in other heads must be awarded
reasonably.
9.
On the other hand, learned counsel for the insurance company
contended that claims tribunal has awarded compensation in higher side
and prayed for rejection of this appeal.
10.
M.A. No.1382/2019 has been filed by the insurance company on the
ground that tribunal has committed grave error in not dismissing the claim
petition on the ground of false involvement of motorcycle No. MP37-MK6442 in the accident. He further submitted that motor accident claims
tribunal ought to have considered the fact that F.I.R. was lodged after 10
days of the accident against unknown vehicle which was seized and in this
aspect of the matter, there is no cogent proof for causing accident by the
alleged motorcycle, hence, it is prayed that insurance company may be
exonerated from liability.
11.
After hearing the learned counsel for both the parties and perusal of
the record, first of all, we discuss M.A. No.1382/2019 filed by the
insurance company.
12.
In M.A. No.1382/2019, the contention of the appellant/insurance
company is that F.I.R. was lodged with delay. It is submitted that accident
occurred on 24.02.2017 and F.I.R. was lodged on 06.03.2017 according to
Ex.P-2 and no explanation has been given by the claimants in this regard.
13.
It is true that according to Ex.P-2, F.I.R. was lodged on 06.03.2017
but, on perusal of the record, it is found that police station inquired Merg
intimation No.6/17 then after completing inquiry, registered F.I.R. (Ex.P-2).
It is very settled principle of law that delay in filing F.I.R. is not fatal either
in criminal case or in claim case provided that sufficient and cogent reason
for delay in filing the F.I.R. is given. The Apex Court in case of Ravi Vs.
--5-Badrinarayan and Others AIR 2011 SC 1226 in para 20 and 21 has held
as under:20. It is well-settled that delay in lodging FIR cannot be
a ground to doubt the claimant’s case. Knowing the
Indian conditions as they are, we cannot expect a
common man to first rush to the Police Station
immediately after an accident. Human nature and family
responsibilities occupy the mind of kith and kin to such
an extent that they give more importance to get the
victim treated rather than to rush to the Police Station.
Under such circumstances, they are not expected to act
mechanically with promptitude in lodging the FIR with
the Police. Delay in lodging the FIR thus, cannot be the
ground to deny justice to the victim. In cases of delay,
the courts are required to examine the evidence with a
closer scrutiny and in doing so; the contents of the FIR
should also be scrutinized more carefully. If court finds
that there is no indication of fabrication or it has not
been concocted or engineered toimplicate innocent
persons then, even if there is a delay in lodging the FIR,
the claim case cannot be dismissed merely on that
ground.
21. The purpose of lodging the FIR in such type of cases
is primarily to intimate the police to initiate investigation
of criminal offences. Lodging of FIR certainly proves
factum of accident so that the victim is able to lodge a
case for compensation but delay in doing so cannot be
the main ground for rejecting the claim petition. In other
words, although lodging of FIR is vital in deciding
motor accident claim cases, delay in lodging the same
should not be treated as fatal for such proceedings, if
claimant has been able to demonstrate satisfactory and
cogent reasons for it. There could be variety of reasons
in genuine cases for delayed lodgment of FIR. Unless
kith and kin of the victim are able to regain a certain
level of tranquility of mind and are composed to lodge
it, even if, there is delay, the same deserves to be
condoned. In such circumstances, the authenticity of the
FIR assumes much more significance than delay in
lodging thereof supported by cogent reasons.
14.
In the present case, perusal of the criminal case, it is found that
--6-accident occurred on 24.02.2017 and the deceased died on 27.07.2017
during treatment. On perusal of Ex.P-11, it is clear that information from
the hospital was sent to police station- Tukoganj, Indore that a personShyamlal has come for treatment injured in road traffic accident so
according to criminal record, information was given to police from the
hospital and police investigated the matter and thereafter police registered
the case. After registration of case, police investigated the matter and
during investigation, police found that driver of the offending vehicle
caused accident and after the investigation, charge-sheet was filed before
competent magistrate court for trial. Therefore, the delay in filing F.I.R. has
been sufficiently explained, hence, arguments canvassed by the learned
counsel for the insurance company stating that delay in registration of
F.I.R. was for planting offending vehicle for seeking compensation, has not
substance.
15.
Learned counsel for the claimants submitted that tribunal assessed
the income of the injured is on lower side. He submitted that on the date of
accident 24.02.2017, as per Minimum Wages Act, income of unskilled
labour was Rs.5350/- per month but, tribunal assessed the income only as
Rs.3000/- per month so considering the evidence, tribunal has committed
committed error in assessing the income of the deceased as lower side. So
in the considered opinion of this Court, just and proper income of the
deceased will be Rs.5350/- per month.
16.
In the case of National Insurance Company Limited vs. Pranay
Sethi reported in 2017 ACJ 2770, the Apex Court held that if the deceased
was self employed and was having a fixed salary then the addition of 40%
of the established income would be warranted where the deceased was
below than the age of 40 years. In the present case, the deceased was aged
19 years at the time of accident, so in the head of future prospects 40% of
--7-his income is rquired to be added. Hence, the calculation will be as under;(Rs.5350x12 = 64200+25680 (40% future prospects of 64200)
=89880/Deduction towards personal expenses= Rs.89880/2= Rs.44,940/Applying multiplier of 18, total income comes to Rs.44,940x18=
Rs.8,08,920/Accordingly,
the
appellants/claimants
are
entitled
to
get
compensation amount under the following heads:
Total income Rs.44,940x18 =Rs.8,08,920/Funeral Expenses
= Rs.15,000.00
Loss of Estate
= Rs.15,000.00
Loss of parental consortium = Rs.80,000.00
-------------------------------------------------------------Total Amount = Rs.9,18,920/MACT Awarded amount = Rs.4,65,000/-------------------------------------------------------------------Enhanced Amount = Rs. 4,53,920/17.
In view of above, the amount is enhanced from Rs.4,65,000/- to
Rs.9,18,920/-. After deducting Rs.4,65,000/- from Rs.9,18,920/-, the
enhanced amount comes to Rs.4,53,920/- over and above the amount
already awarded by the Tribunal.
18.
In the result, the appeal is allowed in part to the extent indicated
here-in-above. The enhanced amount is Rs.4,53,920/- which shall bear
interest at the same rate as awarded by the Tribunal. The other findings
--8-recorded by the Tribunal shall remain intact.
19.
Appellants/claimants have valued this appeal to the extent of Rs.4
Lacs and paid court fees on the same, however, remaining part of above
Rs.4 lacs will be paid by the claimants within a period of one month and
thereafter, the amount shall be released by the insurance company on
receipt of the certificate. In case, the certificate is not filed by the claimants
upto the period of 3 months, claimants shall not be entitled for the interest
on the enhanced amount of compensation.
(HIRDESH)
JUDGE
N.R.
NARENDRA KUMAR
RAIPURIA
Date: 2024.01.30
13:34:39 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review