Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
A_G_A_R_T_A_L_A
Crl. A(J) No. 58 of 2024
Shri Rakel Munda, son of late Jahan Munda of Chinibagan, Bhuiyapara,
P.S. Kailashahar, District: Unakoti Tripura.
…..Appellant
-V E R S U SThe State of Tripura.
….. Respondent.
B_E_F_O_R_E
HON’BLE JUSTICE DR. T. AMARNATH GOUD
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. DATTA PURKAYASTHA
For Appellant(s)
:
For Respondent(s)
:
Date of hearing and delivery of
judgment and order
:
Whether fit for reporting
:
Ms. A. Saha Hirawat, Advocate.
Mr. R. Saha, Addl. P.P.
04.02.2026
YES/NO
JUDGMENT & ORDER [ORAL]
[Dr. T. Amarnath Goud, J]
Heard Ms. A. Saha Hirawat, learned counsel appearing for the
appellant also heard Mr. R. Saha, learned Addl. P.P. appearing for the
respondent-State.
[2]
This is an appeal filed under Section-374 of Cr. P.C. against the
judgment and order of sentence dated 12.10.2023 passed by the learned
Sessions Judge, Unakoti Judicial District, Kailashahar in connection with
Case No. S.T. 26 (U/K) 2022 (Type-1), whereby and whereunder, the
appellant has been sentenced to suffer rigorous imprisonment for life for the
offence punishable under Section-302 of IPC and also a liability to pay a
fine of Rs.10,000/- for the said offence and in default, to suffer further
rigorous imprisonment for a period of 3 months.
[3]
The facts of the case in brief are that on 19.06.2022 night at
about 2330 hrs the FIR named accused person namely Rakel Munda, the
appellant herein, appeared in the house of complainant and informed him
that he killed his wife namely Moni Munda by blowing with a piece of
firewood on her head. Immediately the complainant rushed to the house of
Rakel Munda and found that the dead body of Moni Munda lying on the
floor of the house with sustaining blood injuries. Then the complainant
immediately informed the matter to neighbours. The next day morning he
informed the matter to one local police personal and accordingly, the police
of Kailashahar PS came to the spot and arrested the accused and took him
their custody by registering a case being no. 2022 KLS 03 dated 20.06.2022
under Sections-302 of IPC and after completion of the investigation, the I.O.
submitted charge-sheet before the learned Court against the accused person
under Sections-302 of IPC.
[4]
On commitment of the case, the learned Sessions Judge,
Unakoti Judicial District, Kailashahar took cognizance of the offence and
framed charge against the present convict appellant under Section-302 of
IPC. After examination of P.Ws and the convict appellant under Section-313
of Cr.P.C. and after hearing argument of both sides, the learned Sessions
Judge, Unakoti, Kailashahar Tripura, passed the impugned judgment and
order of conviction and sentence dated 12.10.2023, in case No. ST 26 (U/K)
of 2022 (T-I), convicting the appellant for commission of offence
punishable under Section-302 of IPC to suffer rigorous imprisonment for
life and also to pay a fine of Rs.10,000/- and in default, to undergo further
rigorous imprisonment for three months.
[5]
On commitment of the case, the learned Sessions Judge took
cognizance of offence and after completion of all legal formalities, framed
charge against the present convict appellant under Section-302 of the IPC
and trial began accordingly. To prove the case, prosecution has examined as
many as 16 (sixteen) witnesses and also exhibited some documents. Defence
did not adduce any evidence. Defence case, however, as revealed from the
trend of the cross-examination of the prosecution witnesses and examination
of the accused person under Section-313 of Cr.P.C is of total denial.
[6]
Having heard the learned counsel appearing for the parties and
gone through the material evidence on record, the learned Court below has
observed as under:
“14. Hence, in the result, I do hereby sentence the convict Shri Rakel Munda
for commission of offence punishable U/S 302 of the IPC to suffer rigorous
imprisonment for life and also to pay a fine of Rs10,000/- (rupees ten
thousand) only, i.d. to undergo further rigorous imprisonment for three (3)
months for commission of offence U/S 302 of IPC.
The fine money, if realized, shall be paid to his family member.
The period of detention undergone by the convict during the period of
investigation and trial will be set off from the period of imprisonment.
The case stands disposed of accordingly on contest.
The seized material, if any, of this case, be disposed of after expiry of appeal
period as per law. Inform Court Inspector, Police Court, Unakoti, Kailashahar
and the 10 through the concerned PS accordingly.
Supply a copy of this judgment free of cost to the convict Rakel Munda.
Also communicate a copy of this judgment to the District Magistrate, Unakoti
District, Kailashahar and also to the District Secretary, District Legal Services
Authority, Unakoti District.
Make necessary entry in the T.R and C.I.S.”
[7]
Being aggrieved by and dissatisfied with the same, has been
preferred before this Court for ends of justice.
[8]
Ms. A. Saha Hirawat, learned counsel appearing has submitted
that there is no direct evidence or eye witness to the incident. All the
prosecution witnesses are hearsay in nature and the appellant has been
convicted based on mere presumption. Hence, the order of conviction and
sentence is liable to be set aside. The learned Court below convicted the
appellant on the basis of extra-judicial confession which is not at all
admissible in law. The facts elicited in cross-examination were not at all
considered by the learned Court below.
[9]
It has been contended that there are material discrepancies
between the statements of the witnesses. PW-5 in her deposition has stated
that on the date of incident after getting information from the convict
appellant regarding the incident she along with her husband PW-9, PW-4,
PW-2 and PW-3 came to the house of the convict and found that the dead
body of Moni Munda in her house on the ground. On the contrary, in their
examination-in-chief the PW-9, PW-4, PW-2 and PW-3 deposed that they
found that the dead body of Moni Munda in her house on the bed. Thus, the
prosecution story is doubtful and baseless. But this fact was not at all
considered by the learned Court below.
[10]
PW-1 Tusumoni Munda, daughter of the deceased and the
convict appellant deposed in her cross-examination that before the said
incident her father was suffering from mental illness. The learned Court
below did not consider this aspect and as such the impugned judgment and
order of conviction and sentence is liable to be set aside. It reveals from the
deposition of PW-1 that one day at about 12:30 am her father Rakel Munda,
the appellant herein, came to her house and told her that he has killed her
mother Moni Munda but being a daughter she didn't visit her father's house
immediately rather went to his house on the next morning which is
unbelievable.
[11]
From the perusal of SFSL report and also from the deposition
of PW-15 it is transpired that the report clearly mentioned that "No alleles
has been amplified from Exhibit A2 (Source: Gauze swab taken from one
fire wooden piece), except amelogenin indicative of human male origin."
The PW-15 also arrived into conclusion that "Genetic profile was not
generated from the blood stain of Exhibit-A2 (source: gauze swab taken
from one fire wooden piece). However, the amplification of amelogenin
indicates the blood stain was human male origin." Meaning thereby, the
said piece of firewood which was projected as "murder weapon" by the
prosecution is not at all proved. But the learned Court below convicted the
appellant on mere presumptions and hypothesis therefore the sentence is
liable to be set-aside.
[12]
From the FIR, it is transpired that due to heavy rain with storm
on the night of alleged date of incident the complainant and other
prosecution witnesses could not inform to the local police about the incident
on that day itself. But such fact was neither deposed by the complainant nor
any other prosecution witnesses before the learned Court which creates a
gross doubt in the prosecution story.
[13]
Every criminal act is done with a motive but in this case,
prosecution failed to prove what can be the motive of the alleged murder.
Thus, the learned Court below did not consider this aspect and as such the
impugned judgment and order of conviction and sentence is liable to be set
aside. There exist many lacunas in the process of investigation as well as in
the development of the chain of events, which creates a doubt in the part of
the IO. The extra judicial confessions are generally a weak piece of evidence
and as such the order of conviction and sentence is liable to be set aside.
[14]
In support her argument, has relied on a decision of the Hon’ble
Apex Court on the point of circumstantial evidence in Reena Hazarika v.
State of Assam reported in (2019) 13 SCC 289, wherein, it has been
observed as under:
“The essentials of circumstantial evidence stand well established by
precedents and we do not consider it necessary to reiterate the same and
burden the order unnecessarily. Suffice it to observe that in a case of
circumstantial
evidence
the prosecution is required to establish the
continuity in the links of the chain of circumstances, so as to lead to
the only and inescapable conclusion of the accused being the
assailant, inconsistent or incompatible with the possibility of any
other hypothesis compatible with the innocence of the accused. Mere
invocation of the last seen theory, sans the facts and evidence in a case, will
not suffice to shift the onus upon the accused under Section 106 of the
Evidence Act,1872 unless the prosecution first establishes a prima facie
case. If the links in the chain of circumstances itself are not complete,
and the prosecution is unable to establish a prima facie case,
leaving open the possibility that the occurrence may have taken
place in some other manner, the onus will not shift to the accused, and
the benefit of doubt will have to be given.”
[15]
Regarding
extra
judicial
confession
in
Ramu
Appa
Mahapatra v. State of Maharashtra, reported in (2025) 3 SCC 565, the
Hon’ble Apex Court has observed as under:
“This ruling significantly reinforces the view that courts must exercise
heightened caution when relying on extra-judicial confessions. Prosecutors
and investigators must now be meticulous in corroborating such admissions
and ensuring that the chain of evidence is free from contradictions or gaps.
Defense attorneys, on the other hand, will likely invoke this precedent to
argue for acquittal in cases where the prosecution relies heavily or solely on
purported confessions not made in the presence of judicial authorities.”
[16]
In view of above and having heard the learned counsel
appearing for the parties and the observations made by the learned Court
below, for a definite conclusion, let us revisit the material evidence once
again. PW-1 Tusumani Munda, is the daughter of the deceased and the
accused person of this case. She stated in her evidence that about 7/8 months
back one day in the night hours at about 12:30 am her father Rakel Munda
came to her house and told her that he has killed her mother Moni Munda.
On that night she could not go to her father's house. On the next morning
she went to her father's house and saw her mother in dead condition there.
Thereafter Police came there and prepared inquest report over the dead body
of her mother and she put her signature on the said inquest report. She
identified her signature on the inquest report which on her identification is
marked as Exbt. P-1. She also put her signature in the seizure list relating to
seizure of body parts of her mother along with some clothes She identified
her signature on the said seizure list which on her identification is marked as
Exbt.P 2. She also stated that she was also brought before the Court by
Police where she gave her statement and put her signature on the said
statement. In her cross-examination she has stated that before the incident
her father was suffering from mental illness.
[17]
PW-5 in her deposition has stated that on the date of incident
after getting information from the convict appellant regarding the incident
she along with her husband PW-9, PW-4, PW-2 and PW-3 came to the
house of the convict and found that the dead body of Moni Munda in her
house on the ground. On the contrary, in their examination-in-chief the PW9, PW-4, PW-2 and PW-3 deposed that they found that the dead body of
Moni Munda in her house on the bed.
[18]
Analyzing the evidence of PW-1 it reveals from her evidence
that accused person made extra-judicial confession before her that he has
killed her mother. She stated in her cross-examination that she has told
before the Magistrate that her father confessed that he killed her mother, but
PW-16, who is the IO of the present case stated in his cross-examination
that PW-1 did not give any judicial statement that her father confessed that
he has killed his wife. Thus, the evidence of PW-1 that her father told her
that he has killed her mother is an improved version, as compared to her
judicial statement given before the Court.
[19]
In our considered opinion, the “sterling witness” should be of a
very high quality and caliber, whose version should, therefore, be
unassailable. The court considering the version of such witness should be in
a position to accept it for its face value without any hesitation. To test the
quality of such a witness, the status of the witness would be immaterial and
what would be relevant is the truthfulness of the statement made by such a
witness. What would be more relevant would be the consistency of the
statement right from the starting point till the end, namely, at the time when
the witness makes the initial statement and ultimately before the court which
is little bit inconsistent in the present case.
[20]
The Hon’ble Apex Court recently held that while extra-judicial
confessions are typically considered weak pieces of evidence, they can still
serve as grounds for conviction if proven to be voluntary, truthful, and free
of inducement. The court must be convinced of the reliability of the
confession, and this evaluation takes into account the surrounding
circumstances. It is trite law that extra judicial confession is considered as a
weak type of evidence and is only used as a corroborative link to lend
credibility to the other evidence on record. The probative value of the
testimonies of the witnesses, as well as, their credibility will though be
examined by the learned Court below at an appropriate stage but an
overview of the statements of the material witnesses tilts the balance in
favour of the appellant for granting relief. It is also not the case of the
prosecution that, the appellant has previous criminal records or there is
possibility of the appellant fleeing from justice.
[21]
Hence, this Court, after evaluating all the evidences on record,
is of the considered view that the incident happened on the spur of the
moment. It was out of anger and due to sudden provocation; the accused got
furious and attacked the victim. In the present case, the convict-appellant
has already been undergone imprisonment for couple of years and
considering the mental condition of the accused-appellant, a lenient view is
taken and the case of the accused is considered as an act of culpable
homicide not amounting to murder. Thus, the ends of justice would be met,
if the punishment under Section-304 of IPC be imposed upon the appellant
instead of Section-302 of IPC as imposed by the learned Court below i.e.
converting the life imprisonment into seven years of punishment.
Accordingly, the same is ordered.
[22]
Consequently, the sentence as imposed by the learned Court
below under Section-302 of IPC is converted into Section-304 of IPC. The
period of detention undergone by the convict during investigation, trial and
sentence be set off. In that view of the matter, the judgment and order of
conviction passed by the learned Court below is modified to the extent as
indicated above. Accordingly, the present appeal stands partly allowed and
thereby, the same is disposed of.
[23]
As a sequel, miscellaneous application(s), pending if any, shall
also stand closed.
S. DATTA PURKAYASTHA, J
A.Ghosh
ANJAN GHOSH Date:
2026.02.12 10:28:10 +05'30'
DR.T. AMARNATH GOUD, J
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review