Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) NO.655 OF 2021
Shri Prasenjit Acharjee,
S/o Sri Parimal Acharjee,
Resident of Ramnagar Road No.8, last,
P.O.- Ramnagar, P.S.- West Agartala,
Sub-Division- Agartala, District- West Tripura,
Aged 31 years
……… Petitioner(s)
Vs.
1. ONGC, Tripura Power Company Ltd.,
(a Joint Venture company of ONGC, IL & FS, IIF-II &
Government of Tripura) Udaipur- Kakraban Road,
P.O.- Palatana, District- Gomati, Tripura, PIN-799105,
represented by its Managing Director.
2. Managing Director, ONGC Tripura, Power Company,
Ltd., (Joint Venture Company of ONGC, IL & FS, IIF-II &
Government of Tripura) Udaipur-Kakraban Road,
P.O.- Palatana, District- Gomati Tripura,
PIN-799105(Appellate Authority).
3. AGM & HEAD(HR & A) ONGC, Tripura, Power Company
Ltd.,(Joint Venture Company of ONGC, IL & FS, IIF-II &
Government of Tripura) Udaipur-Kakraban Road, P.O.Palatana, District- Gomati, Tripura, PIN -799105;
4. Sri Sanjay Agarwal, EX-CJM(HR), ONGC, C-1506 D.B.,
Woods, Krishna Vatika Marg, GokulDham, Goregaon(E),
Mumbai, 400063, (Enquiry Officer).
……. Respondent(s)
For the Petitioner(s)
: Mr. S. Lodh, Advocate.
Ms. A. Saha, Advocate.
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. A. Puri, Advocate.
Mrs. V. Poddar, Advocate.
Date of hearing and delivery of
Judgment & Order
: 26/04/2023.
Whether fit for reporting : YES.
HON’BLE MR JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
JUDGMENT AND ORDER(ORAL)
This present writ petition has been filed under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India. The brief fact of this
case is that vide order dated 27.10.2020, the petitioner was
suspended on the ground that a criminal case is pending against
him. Thereafter respondent No.3 issued a charge sheet framing
4(four) articles of charges. The petitioner made representation
to engage an Advocate during the course of the proceeding.
Respondent No.3 appointed respondent No.4 as inquiry officer,
and Mr. V. Siddharth, Advocate, was appointed as presenting
officer of the Disciplinary Proceeding. Thereafter the proceeding
ended, and the punishment of dismissal from the service was
imposed
upon
the
petitioner.
Challenging
the
same,
the
petitioner filed an appeal before the Appellate Authority, and the
said appeal was also dismissed. Challenging the same, the
petitioner has filed this instant writ petition seeking the following
reliefs:“ i. Issue Rule, calling upon the respondents and each one of
them, to show cause as to why a writ of certiorari and/or in the nature
thereof, shall not be issued, for calling for the records, lying with the
respondents, for rendering substantial and conscionable justice to the
petitioner, and for quashing/setting aside impugned Enquiry Report dated
20.02.2021(Annexure-10 supra), Order No.OTPC/HR/Disciplinary/2021-
22/003, dated 26.04.2021(Annexure-12 supra) and order dated
29.07.2021(Annexure-15 supra).
ii. Issue Rule, calling upon the respondents and each one of
them, to show cause as to why a writ of mandamus and/or in the nature
thereof, shall not be issued, for mandating/directing them, to revoke/rescind
the impugned Enquiry Report dated 20.02.2021(Annexure-10 supra), Order
No.OTPC/HR/Disciplinary/2021-22/003, dated 26.04.2021 (Annexure-12
supra)
and
Order
No.OTPC/MD/Disciplinary/2021-22/014,
dated
29.07.2021(Annexure-15 supra).
iii. Call for the records, appertaining to this petition.
iv. After hearing the parties, be pleased to make the Rule
Absolute in term of i. & ii. above.
v. Costs of an incidental to this proceeding;
vi. Any other relief(s) as to this Hon’ble High Court may deem
fit and proper.”
2.
Heard Mr. S. Lodh, learned counsel assisted by Ms.
A. Saha, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner as well as
Mr. A. Puri, learned counsel assisted by Ms. V. Poddar, learned
counsel appearing for the respondents.
3.
At the very outset, while Mr. Lodh, learned counsel
appearing for the petitioner was advancing his argument, the
respondent-counsel
raised
an
objection
on
the
point
of
maintainability of the writ petition and in view of the same, since
the preliminary objection has been raised, this Court has framed
the following issue:i) Whether the writ petition lies under Article 226 of
the Constitution of India against the respondents or not?
ii) Whether the respondent is state as defined
under Article 12 of the Constitution of India?
4.
To
properly
adjudicate
the
matter
we
may
reproduce Articles 12 and 226 of the Constitution of India:-
12. Definition In this part, unless the context otherwise requires, the State
includes the Government and Parliament of India and the Government and the
Legislature of each of the States and all local or other authorities within the
territory of India or under the control of the Government of India
“226. Power of High Courts to issue certain writs
(1) Notwithstanding anything in Article 32 every High Court shall have powers,
throughout the territories in relation to which it exercise jurisdiction, to issue to
any person or authority, including in appropriate cases, any Government, within
those territories directions, orders or writs, including writs in the nature of
habeas corpus, mandamus, prohibitions, quo warranto and certiorari, or any of
them, for the enforcement of any of the rights conferred by Part III and for any
other purpose
(2) The power conferred by clause ( 1 ) to issue directions, orders or writs to
any Government, authority or person may also be exercised by any High Court
exercising jurisdiction in relation to the territories within which the cause of
action, wholly or in part, arises for the exercise of such power, notwithstanding
that the seat of such Government or authority or the residence of such person
is not within those territories
(3) Where any party against whom an interim order, whether by way of
injunction or stay or in any other manner, is made on, or in any proceedings
relating to, a petition under clause ( 1 ), without
(a) furnishing to such party copies of such petition and all documents in support
of the plea for such interim order; and
(b) giving such party an opportunity of being heard, makes an application to
the High Court for the vacation of such order and furnishes a copy of such
application to the party in whose favour such order has been made or the
counsel of such party, the High Court shall dispose of the application within a
period of two weeks from the date on which it is received or from the date on
which the copy of such application is so furnished, whichever is later, or where
the High Court is closed on the last day of that period, before the expiry of the
next day afterwards on which the High Court is open; and if the application is
not so disposed of, the interim order shall, on the expiry of that period, or, as
the case may be, the expiry of the aid next day, stand vacated
(4) The power conferred on a High Court by this article shall not be in
derogation of the power conferred on the Supreme court by clause ( 2 ) of
Article 32
5.
Further the meaning of mandamus as defined is
given herein under “Whenever a public officer or government has
done some act which violates the fundamental right of a person, the
Court would issue a writ of mandamus, restraining the public officer
or government from enforcing that order or doing that act against the
person whose fundamental right has been violated”.
6.
Thereafter, Mr. Lodh, learned counsel appearing for
the petitioner on the point of maintainability of the writ petition
submits that in the General Election of Tripura held in 2023, the
4(four) staff of the respondent-Company were appointed as
Micro observers to look after the Election proceeding. Micro
observers are appointed from the employees who are from an
organization/department/company
of
Central
Government
undertaking not below the rank of Group-C. So this action of the
Election Commission proves that the respondent-Company is a
Government entity in itself. Learned counsel further submitted
that Government Company means any company in which not
less than fifty-one percent of the [paid-up share capital] is held
by the Central Government, or by any State Government or
Governments, or partly by the Central Government and partly
by one or more State Governments and includes a company
which is a subsidiary of a Government company as thus defined.
Learned counsel further submits that the respondent company is
a subsidiary company in terms of Section 2(87) Subsidiary
Company. In terms of annexure-19 of the writ petition, learned
counsel further submits that the share of ONGC is 50%, the
share of IL & FS is 26% and the share of GOT is 0.5% in the
said Company. Further, the Board consists of not less than 8
and not more than 10 directors, and ONGC has the right o
nominate at least 4(four) Directors to the Board of the Company
till it continues to hold at least 50% of the shareholding of the
Company, IL & FS have the right to nominate 2(two) Directors
to the Board of Companies and GOT have the right to nominate
1(one) Director to the Board of Company, ONGC and IL & FS
each have the right to nominate 1(one) Director to the Board of
Company and ONGC have the right to appoint the chairman of
the Board from amongst its nominee. As such ONGC has the
control of the Board as such the said Company is the subsidiary
company of ONGC so it comes under the preview of the
Government Company. So the objection of the respondents’ side
that the said Company is not a Government Company prior to
January 2022 is totally wrong. Stating thus learned counsel
submits that the present writ petition is maintainable.
7.
On the other side, Mr. A. Puri, learned counsel
appearing for the respondents submits that the writ petition filed
by the petitioner is not maintainable. The respondent No.1
Company at the relevant time was not a Government Company
in terms of Section 2(45) of the Companies Act, 2013. It is
further submitted that respondent No.1 cannot be considered as
an instrumentality of the State as the entire shareholding was
neither with the Central nor the State Government. Further
respondent No.1 does not get financial assistance from State, to
the extent of meeting the expenditure of the Company.
Respondent No.1 does not enjoy monopoly status, nor there is
any evidence of pervasive State control. The activities of
respondent No.1 is in the power generation business and do not
constitute Government Function. Accordingly, respondent No.1
Company cannot be considered as ‘State' within the meaning
under Article 12 of the Constitution of India at the relevant point
of time. Learned counsel further submitted that under Section
2(45) of the Companies Act, 2013, respondent No.1 is not a
Government Company. The respondent No.1 Company operated
as any other private Sector Companies. In terms of Section
2(87) of the Companies Act 2013, the said Company is also not
a subsidiary Company. Learned counsel further submits that the
Registrar of Companies issued a certificate saying that his client
is a non-governmental company and at no point of time they
were more than half the directors. They were not having more
than 50% share also and they were not managing the company,
as on the date prior to 4th January 2022, the company is private
concerned, and shares were not taken over. Vide order dated
26.04.2021, the petitioner was terminated. The appeal against
the impugned order of dismissal was filed on 17.05.2021. The
appellate order was also given 29.07.2021. All these dates fall
prior to 4th January, 2022 and it on that date and the company
was holding its private identity, it was not a state
8.
Heard both sides and perused the evidence on
record.
9.
To
come
to
a
conclusion
on
the
point
of
maintainability of this writ petition, let us first reproduce Section
2(45) and Section 2(87) of the Companies Act, 2013:“ 2(45). “Government company” means any company in
which not less than fifty-one per cent of the paid-up share capital is held by
the Central Government, or by any State Government or Governments, or
partly by the Central Government and partly by one or more State
Governments, and includes a company which is a subsidiary company of such
a Government company.
2(87). subsidiary company” or “subsidiary”, in relation to any
other company (that is to say the holding company), means a company in
which the holding company—
(i) controls the composition of the Board of Directors; or
(ii) exercises or controls more than one-half of the total voting power either at
its own or together with one or more of its subsidiary companies
10.
This Court finds force in the argument of the
learned counsel appearing for the respondents. Moreover it, is
revealed from the record that at the relevant point of time, the
respondent-company herein was not holding 51% percent share
as per Section 2(45) of the Companies Act. Further, the
respondent-Company does not control the composition of the
Board of Directors or exercise or control more than one-half of
the total voting power either on its own or together with one
more of its subsidiary companies. So it evident from the above
observation that the respondent Company cannot be termed as
'State’ in terms of Article 12 of the Constitution of India. Vide
order dated 26.04.2021, the petitioner was terminated. The
appeal against the impugned order of dismissal was made on
17.05.2021. The appellate order was also given 29.07.2021. At
that relevant point of time, the respondent-Company was
holding its private entity.
11.
In view of the above discussion, this Court is
of the view that the present writ petition is not maintainable.
Accordingly, without going to the merits of the order of
termination by the appellate authority, this present writ petition
is dismissed as not maintainable. However, the petitioner is at
liberty to avail the remedies under the law if so advised in
adjudicating the order of termination.
12.
With the above observation and directions, this
present petition is dismissed. As a sequel stay if any stands
vacated. Pending application(s), if any also stands closed.
JUDGE
suhanjit
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review