The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
25. 02.2022 Heard Mr. S Lodh, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner as well as Ms A Banik, learned counsel appearing for the respondents. The petitioner is aggrieved by the order dated 29.09.2021 (Annexure-1 to the writ petition) whereby he has been deputed to the office of the Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Jirania purportedly for looking after the activities related with Ranirbazar Municipal Council at the office of the SubDivisional Magistrate, Jirania with immediate effect and until further orders. From the subsequent order dated 01.10.2021 passed by the SubDivisional Magistrate, Jirania, West Tripura (Anneuxre-4 to the writ petition) it is apparent that the petitioner was assigned the duties in the Election Section which has no relation with the activities of the Municipal Council. Be that as it may, the petitioner has challenged that order of deputation primarily on three grounds, viz, (i) There is no source of power to depute a municipal employee to any other organization unrelated to the municipal bodies. (ii) No consent of the petitioner was ever taken before issuance of the said order of deputation. (iii) The said order of deputation is not only without authority but palpably wrong, as the authority has made a unique innovation for deputing the petitioner and such innovation squarely falls on arbitrariness. For those grounds, according to Mr. Lodh, learned counsel who …
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) 720 of 2021
For petitioner(s)
:
Mr. S Lodh, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Ms A Banik, Adv.
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. TALAPATRA
Order
25.02.2022
Heard Mr. S Lodh, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner as
well as Ms A Banik, learned counsel appearing for the respondents.
The petitioner is aggrieved by the order dated 29.09.2021
(Annexure-1 to the writ petition) whereby he has been deputed to the office
of the Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Jirania purportedly for looking after the
activities related with Ranirbazar Municipal Council at the office of the SubDivisional Magistrate, Jirania with immediate effect and until further orders.
From the subsequent order dated 01.10.2021 passed by the SubDivisional Magistrate, Jirania, West Tripura (Anneuxre-4 to the writ petition) it
is apparent that the petitioner was assigned the duties in the Election Section
which has no relation with the activities of the Municipal Council.
Be that as it may, the petitioner has challenged that order of
deputation primarily on three grounds, viz,
(i) There is no source of power to depute a municipal
employee to any other organization unrelated to the
municipal bodies.
(ii) No consent of the petitioner was ever taken before
issuance of the said order of deputation.
(iii) The said order of deputation is not only without
authority but palpably wrong, as the authority has made a
unique innovation for deputing the petitioner and such
innovation squarely falls on arbitrariness.
For those grounds, according to Mr. Lodh, learned counsel who
has appeared for the petitioner, the impugned order of deputation be
interfered by this court.
It appears that as the petitioner did not obtain any interim order
staying the operation of the order of deputation, the petitioner joined in the
office of the Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Jirania, West Tripura, and he was
assigned only the duties in the election section of the said office, even though
the petitioner has been substantially appointed as the work assistant in the
office of the respondent No.1. In the usual circumstances, he is not supposed
to work in the office, particularly in the Election Department.
Mr. Lodh, learned counsel has submitted that the conditions of
service as laid down in the memorandum dated 17.09.2005 (Annexure-A to
the reply filed by the respondents) may be referred for justifying the action of
the respondents. One of those conditions provide that the appointment of the
petitioner in the post of Work Assistant shall carry the liability to serve in any
part of the State of Tripura. According to Mr. Lodh, learned counsel the
purpose of the said condition cannot be understood or perceived as the
geographical area of the State of Tripura, but to be understood along with
the substantive provision made in the Tripura Municipal Act, 1994.
Section 79 of the Tripura Municipal Act, 1994 provides that the
State government after consultation with the Municipality may place on
deputation as the disposal of the Municipality the services of such officers and
employees of the State Government on such terms and conditions as it may
deem fit. This provision is not relevant in the present context.
However, there is another provision relating to the transfer of
staff under Section 82 of the Tripura Municipal Act, 1994 which provides that
notwithstanding anything contained in the Act or any other law for the time
being in force, the State Government may after consultation with the
Municipality transfer any officer or employee from one Municipality to another
in the interest of the public and the Municipal Administration.
Mr. Lodh, learned counsel has submitted that the transfer is only
permissible from one municipality to another municipality and to no other
body of the State government. But in the present case, the Chief Executive
Officer has deputed the petitioner without any authority to cause deputation
of any employee. Even the general principles of deputation as laid down in FR
110 have not been followed. Those have been interpreted by the apex court
on numerous occasions.
In this regard, Mr. Lodh, learned counsel has relied on a decision
of the apex court in Jawaharlal Nehru University Vs. Dr. KS Jawatkar &
Ors., reported in 1989 Supp (1) SCC 679 wherein it has been observed [in
para 7 of the said judgment] as follows:
“7. ……There is also no doubt that his employment could not be
transferred by the appellant University to the Manipur University
without his consent, notwithstanding any statutory provision to that
effect whether in the Manipur University Act or elsewhere. The
contract of service entered into by the respondent was a contract
with the appellant University and no law can convert that contract
into a contract between the respondent and the Manipur University
without simultaneously making it, either expressly or by necessary
implication, subject to the respondent's consent. When the Manipur
University Act provides for the transfer of the services of the staff
working at the Centre of Postgraduate Studies, Imphal, to
employment in the Manipur University, it must be construed as a
provision enabling such transfer of employment but only on the
assumption that the employee concerned is a consenting party to
such transfer. It makes no difference that the respondent was not
shown in the list of Assistant Professors of the appellant University
or that the provision was not indicated in its budget; that must be
regarded as proceeding from an erroneous conception of the status
of the respondent. The position in law is clear, that no employee can
be transferred, without his consent, from one employer to another.
The consent may be express or implied. We do not find it necessary
to refer to any case law in support of this conclusion.”
[Emphasis added]
It transpires that the position of law as has been declared by the
apex court is unambiguous that no employee can be transferred without his
consent from one employer to another. The consent must be express or
implied. But in the present case in hand, as Mr. Lodh, leaned counsel has
contended, the petitioner never gave any consent for such deputation.
Mr. Lodh, learned counsel has also relied on another decision of
the apex court in State of Punjab & Ors. Vs. Inder Singh & Ors, Etc.
reported in (1997) 8 SCC 372 where the apex court has held in para 19 as
follows:
“19. ……… There can be no deputation without the consent of the
person so deputed and he would, therefore, know his rights and
privileges in the deputation post. …….”
Ms A Banik, learned counsel appearing for the respondents has
strenuously submitted that the Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Jirania, West
Tripura and the Executive Officer of Ranirbazar Municipal Council who is the
appointing authority of the petitioner are the same person. During the
Municipal Election, the petitioner‟s services were placed unilaterally in the
office of the Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Jirania, West Tripura, for smooth
functioning of the election related activities. In this regard, Ms Banik, learned
counsel has submitted that the petitioner‟s service was only utilized in the
Election Section of the said office.
Ms Banik, learned counsel has referred to para 12 of the reply
where the respondents have elaborated their stand. In para 12, the
respondents have stated that the respondent No.4 has been discharging the
dual responsibility as the Chief Executive Officer of the Ranirbazar Municipal
Council and the Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Jirania. Unabashedly, it has been
stated that for smooth functioning of the Ranirbazar Municipal Council as well
as to look after the day to day activities related to Ranir Bazar Municipal
Council, the petitioner, a work Assistant, was deputed to the office of the
Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Jirania by the impugned order dated 29.09.2021. It
has been further stated that such deputation was made to assist the Assistant
Electoral officer (AEO), who is engaged in conducting the general election to
Ranir Bazar Municipal Council.
In the same paragraph, the respondents have made the
following assertion:
“It is to mention here that after joining in the Office of the
Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Jirania, Sri Prasanta Saha, Work
Assistant of Ranir Bazar Municipal council has been
attached in the Election Section of the SDM‟s office, Jirania
and engaged in the duty of election of Ranir Bazar
Municipal Council and to assist the Assistant Electoral
Officer (AEO), who is engaged in General election to Ranir
Bazar Municipal council vide „Office Order‟ No. F.1(2)SDM/JRN/ESTT/2019/4149-52 dated 11.10.2021.”
Finally, Ms Bhowmik, learned counsel has submitted that the
petitioner has failed to obtain any interim order and accordingly, the
petitioner has worked as a deputationist in the office of the Sub-Divisional
Magistrate, Jirania. As such, now he cannot question the validity of the said
order of deputation.
Having appreciated the submissions made by the learned counsel
for the parties and scrutinized the records as placed with the writ petition and
the reply, this court is confronted with two questions:
(i) Whether the explanation given by the respondents that
the petitioner has been taken to work for the Ranir Bazar
Municipal Council is maintainable; and
(ii) Whether deputation can be made without the consent of
the person concerned when there is no source of authority
for making such deputation?
As regards the question No.(i), as noted above, this court finds it
very amusing as conducting the election by the Election Commission of the
local bodies cannot be a part of the municipal work and if it is so that some
work of Ranir Bazar Municipal Council was being carried out in the office of
the Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Jirania, there had been no question of
deputation. It would be a mere posting of some officers to that part of the
Ranir Bazar Municipal Council housed in the office of the Sub-Divisional
Magistrate, Jirania. The explanation is bordering on absurdity and hence, that
cannot be accepted by this court.
The final point is whether there is any source of authority for
deputation. The answer is obviously in the negative. Whether any deputation
can be made without the consent of the employee concerned, in view of the
apex court decisions? The answer must be in the negative. Even though we
are not oblivious that FR 110 provides that no government servant can be
transferred to Foreign Service against his will, provided that this sub-rule shall
not apply to the transfer of government servant to the service of a body,
incorporated or not, which is wholly or substantially owned or controlled by
the Government.
In the wildest circumstances also the Municipal body cannot be
treated as the body which is owned or controlled by the government. These
are autonomous local bodies and as such proviso which exempts obtaining of
consent of the employees will not apply in the present circumstances.
Having observed thus, this court finds that the impugned order
of deputation (Anexure-1 to the writ petition) is without any authority and
hence, arbitrary, offending the provisions of Article 14 of the Constitution of
India and hence, the same is set aside.
Mr. Lodh, learned counsel has stated that the petitioner is still
working in the office of the Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Jirania, West Tripura.
The respondents are directed to allow the petitioner join in his original place
of posting under the Ranir Bazar Municipal Council within a period of ten days
from today.
In view of the above, this writ petition stands allowed.
Copy of this order be supplied to Ms A Banik, leanred counsel for
onward transmission.
JUDGE
lodh
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review