Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) 835 OF 2021
Sri Pintu Das, son of Late Jagabandu Das, aged about 52 years,
Resident of Gandhighat, PS-West Agartala,
P.O. & Sub-Division-Agartala, District-West Tripura.
Vrs.
1. State of Tripura, represented by the Principal Secretary,
General Administration (AR) Department, Government of Tripura,
New Capital Complex, P.O. Kunjaban, PS-New Capital Complex,
Agartala, District-West Tripura.
2. Principal Secretary, General Administration (AR) Department,
Government of Tripura, New Capital Complex, P.O. Kunjaban, PS-New
Capital Complex, Agartala, District-West Tripura (Disciplinary Authority).
3. Chief Secretary, Government of Tripura, New Capital Complex,
P.O. Kunjaban, PS- New Capital Complex, Agartala,
District-West Tripura (Appellate Authority).
4. District Magistrate & Collector, West Tripura, Agartala.
5. Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Sadar, District-West Tripura.
6. Commissioner of Department Enquiries, Secretariat Annexe,
Pandit Nehru Complex, P.O. Kunjaban, Agartala, District-West Tripura.
7. Tripura Public Service Commission, represented by its Secretary,
A.K. Road, Near Fire Service Chowmohani, P.S. West Agartala,
District-West Tripura, Pin-799001.
8. The Secretary, Tripura Public Service Commission, A.K. Road,
Near Fire Service Chowmohani, PS-West Agartala, District-West Tripura,
Pin-799001.
Present:
For the petitioner (s)
For the respondent (s)
: Mr. S. Lodh, Advocate.
: Mr. M. Debbarma, Addl. G.A.
Mr. Raju Datta, Advocate.
Date of hearing and
delivery of judgment
and order
: 07.01.2023
Whether fit for
reporting
: Yes
HON’BLE MR.JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
Judgment & Order(Oral)
By way of filing the present writ petition, the petitioner has
challenged the impugned order of penalty issued by the respondents vide
No.F.11(1)-GA(AR)/2014/571-73, dated 15.02.2021 [Annexure- 16 to the
writ petition] wherein his three increments were withheld with cumulative
effect. The petitioner has further challenged the memorandum No.F.35(29)(P&T)/2011 dated 05.05.2021 [Annexure-20 to the writ petition] wherein
the petitioner was informed that he was not entitled to get pay and
allowances for the period of suspension i.e. 27.11.2013 to 28.05.2014 and
the said period shall not be treated as spent on duty for all purposes.
2.
Background facts, are, while the petitioner was posted as
Deputy Collector and Magistrate in Sadar Sub-Division, at that time, a
news was published in a local daily that he forged the Epic Card of a lady
and visited Kolkata with that lady. The petitioner reacted to the said news
item and suo moto informed his higher authority denying the said news
item. Thereafter, Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Sadar, asked the petitioner to
submit additional representation, and in response to that query, the
petitioner denied that he had any involvement with the lady, named, Smt.
Nita Das.
However, the petitioner was put on suspension having
proposed to initiate a departmental proceeding. Accordingly, during his
suspension period a departmental proceeding was initiated and five
numbers of Articles of Charges were framed. Inquiry was conducted and
after its conclusion, the Inquiring Authority held that Articles of charges
No. I, II & III had not been proved. However, the Articles of Charges no.
IV and V were held to be proved. On the basis of enquiry report,
provisional penalty order of withholding three increments with cumulative
effect was proposed and by issuing a show cause notice the petitioner was
asked to submit representation. Accordingly, he submitted representation.
The Disciplinary Authority after consideration of his representation and the
evidences on record concurred the finding of guilt recorded by the
Inquiring Authority and thereby imposed penalty as aforestated.
3.
The petitioner preferred statutory appeal. The Appellate
Authority on perusal of the materials upheld and affirmed the penalty
imposed by the Disciplinary Authority.
4.
Being aggrieved, the petitioner has filed the present writ
petition challenging the penalty imposed with a prayer for treating him as
on duty during his suspension period for regularization of his pay and
allowances and claims that he is entitled to pay and allowances for the
period he was under suspension for the reason that in the revocation order
of suspension dated 28.05.2014 the competent authority concerned had not
passed any order as regards his pay and allowances during the suspension
period.
5.
Keeping in mind the challenge posed by the petitioner, at the
outset, it would be relevant to reproduce here-in-below the two charges,
which are held to be proved:
“Article-IV
Shri Pintu Das, Ex-DCM, Sadar while working in the
O/o the SDM, Sadar failed to maintain absolute integrity and
devotion to duty as enjoined in Rule-3 of TCS (Conduct) Rules,
1988 as he has misused his official position in certifying 24
Nos. of false vouchers amounting to Rs.21,600/- only
submitted by Shri Subhaji Parial being the hiring charges of
vehicles on different occasions. It is evident that the vouchers
submitted by Shri Parial, he has mentioned himself as Driver
of the vehicle. But, in fact at the relevant period he is working
as Data Entry Operator in the O/o the DCM, Sadar. It is
evident from the above that Shri Pintu Das, Ex-DCM has an
unholy alliance with Shri Subhajit Parial, Data Entry
Operator since long and by using such alliance he could
utilize the service of Shri Parial in manipulating the EPIC
No.HJRO386029 for his personal interest.
Thus, the said Shri Pintu Das, former DCM, Sadar has
committed gross misconduct, lack of integrity and devotion to
duty and violated Rule-3 of the Tripura Civil Services
(Conduct) Rules, 1988.
Article-V
Shri Pintu Das, Ex-DCM, Sadar while working in the
O/o the SDM, Sadar failed to maintain absolute integrity and
devotion to duty as enjoined in Rule-3 of TCS(Conduct) Rules,
1988 as he has misrepresented the facts in his defence to the
DM & Collector, West Tripura with a copy to the SDM, Sadar
on 26-11-2013 and another to SDM, Sadar on 07-12-2013
regarding his stay at Kolkata with one lady names Smt. Nita
Das, W/o Shri Manik Lal Das. Shri Pintu Das, Ex-DCM had
not mentioned the name of Smt. Nita Das, W/o Shri Manik Lal
Das in his letter dated 26-11-2013 to the DM & Collector,
West Tripura whereas in his letter dated 07-12-2013
addressed to the SDM, Sadar has mentioned the name of Smt.
Nita Das, W/o Shri Manik Lal Das who stayed with him at
Kolkata in building at Spacecircular, Green Valley, Kailkhali,
Kolkata. It is pertinent to mention here that the holder of the
EPIC No.HJRO386029 is Smt. Nita Das.
Thus, the said Shri Pintu Das, former DCM, Sadar has
committed gross misconduct, lack of integrity and devotion to
duty and violated Rule-3 of the Tripura Civil Services
(Conduct) Rules, 1988.”
6.
I have heard Mr. S. Lodh, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner. Also heard Mr. M. Debbarma, learned Addl. G.A. appearing for
the State-respondents and Mr. Raju Datta, learned counsel appearing for
the Tripura Public Service Commission.
7.
Mr. Lodh, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner, firstly,
has urged this court to take on the charge framed under Article-V. Learned
counsel for the petitioner submits that from the very beginning the
petitioner, Sri Pintu Das was denying the allegations that he visited Kolkata
with Smt. Nita Das. The petitioner in his representation also narrated that
both the petitioner and Smt. Nita Das and her husband had family relations
and there was no merit in the reports published in the local daily. The
petitioner also denied that he forged/manipulated the Epic Card
No.HJRO386029 for his personal interest. In the departmental proceeding,
Smt. Nita Das had adduced evidence as a witness and in her evidence she
denied the entire allegations involving her with the petitioner. The
Inquiring Authority while deciding the charge under Article-III, held that
the charge of forging/manipulating Epic Card No. HJRO386029 had not
been proved which was also confirmed by the Disciplinary Authority and
the Appellate Authority as well.
8.
On perusal of the findings of the Inquiring Authority, I am of
the opinion that the Charge No.III has a direct link with Charge No.V and
since the Charge of forging/manipulating the EPIC Card of the lady i.e.
Smt. Nita Das for his personal interest has not been proved, the findings of
guilt as regards the Charge No. V that the petitioner committed misconduct
staying in a hotel at Kolkata with Smt. Nita Das by way of forging her
EPIC Card for his personal interest is perverse being based on no evidence.
9.
Next, criticizing the findings of guilt as regards the Charge
No.IV, Mr. Lodh, learned counsel for the petitioner has strenuously argued
that the owner of the vehicle himself appeared and adduced evidence that
he received the bill to the tune of Rs.21,600/- (Rupees twenty one thousand
six hundred) only for hiring his vehicle by the department. In this situation,
question arises as to why the petitioner knowing fully-well that Sri Subhajit
Parial had no authority to raise the bill on behalf of the owner of the
vehicle, who styled himself as the driver of the vehicle, had certified 25
nos. of vouchers amounting to Rs.21,600/- only being the hiring charges of
the vehicle on different occasions. It was within the full knowledge of the
petitioner that Sri Shubhajit Parial at the relevant point of time was
working as Data Entry Operator in his own office, i.e., Office of the DCM,
Sadar. In view of this, the findings of the Disciplinary Authority as well as
the Appellate Authority that the petitioner had an unholy alliance with
Subhajit Parial, Data Entry Operator cannot be said to be perverse finding
and hence, does not call for interference.
10.
Next, Mr. Lodh, learned counsel submits that under Sub-Rule
(iv) of Rule 11 of Central Civil Services (Classification, Control and
Appeal) Rules,1965 [here-in-after referred to as the “Rules”] withholding
of increment of pay is a minor penalty. Mr. Lodh, learned counsel has
strenuously argued that the court should give literal meaning of the said
Sub-Rule (iv) of Rule 11 of the Rules. Under the normal rule of
interpretation, the court should not mend or incorporate any other words in
a statute when the language of the statute is clear, plain and unambiguous
to give a different meaning to the language used in the statute. I have no
quarrel with this submission of learned counsel appearing for the petitioner.
11.
The above submission prompts me to have a re-look to Rule
11 of the Rules. Here, it would be appropriate to reproduce here-in-below
the relevant rules regarding imposition of penalties upon a civil servant.
“11. Penalties -The following penalties may, for good and sufficient reasons and
as hereinafter provided, be imposed on a Government servant, namely
:Minor Penalties –
(i) censure;
(ii) withholding of his promotion;
(iii) recovery from his pay of the whole or part of any pecuniary loss
caused by him to the Government by negligence or breach of orders;
(iii a) reduction to lower stage in the time-scale of pay by one stage
for a period not exceeding three years, without cumulative effect and
not adversely affecting his pension.
(iv) withholding of increments of pay;
Major Penalties –
(v) save as provided for in clause (iii) (a), reduction to a lower stage
in the timescale of pay for a specified period, with further directions
as to whether or not the Government servant will earn increments of
pay during the period of such reduction and whether on the expiry of
such period, the reduction will or will not have the effect of
postponing the future increments of his pay;
(vi) reduction to lower time-scale of pay, grade, post or Service for a
period to be specified in the order of penalty, which shall be a bar to
the promotion of the Government servant during such specified period
to the time-scale of pay, grade, post or Service from which he was
reduced, with direction as to whether or not, on promotion on the
expiry of the said specified period –
(a) the period of reduction to time-scale of pay, grade, post or service
shall operate to postpone future increments of his pay, and if so, to
what extent; and
(b) the Government servant shall regain his original seniority in the
higher time scale of pay, grade, post or service.
(vii) compulsory retirement;
(viii) removal from service which shall not be a disqualification for
future employment under the Government;
(ix) dismissal from service which shall ordinarily be a disqualification
for future employment under the Government.
Provided that, in every case in which the charge of possession of
assets disproportionate to known-sources of income or the charge of
acceptance from any person of any gratification, other than legal
remuneration, as a motive or reward for doing or forbearing to do
any official act is established, the penalty mentioned in clause (viii) or
clause (ix) shall be imposed :
Provided further that in any exceptional case and for special reasons
recorded in writing, any other penalty may be imposed.”
12.
On careful reading of the above provisions under Rule 11, in
the opinion of this court, it is clear that withholding of increments of pay
simpliciter without any impact over employee’s future pay structure would
certainly comes within the meaning of Sub-Rule (iv), but, when penalty
was imposed withholding increments of pay with cumulative effect, it
would certainly mean that the increments earned by the employee was cut
off as a measure of penalty for ever in his upward movement of earning
higher scale of pay during his future tenure of service. The stoppage of
increment or increments would not be counted in determining his future
time scale of pay which will ultimately affect his pensionary benefits. In
that eventuality, stoppage of even one increment with cumulative effect, by
no stretch of imagination, falls within the ambit of Sub-Rule (iv) of Rule 11
of the Rules. In other words, withholding of increments of pay with
cumulative effect would reduce the pay scale of an employee to a lower
stage in the time scale of pay permanently effecting the employee’s
ultimate salary and allowances. In view of this, withholding of increments
of pay and allowances with cumulative effect would not be treated as minor
penalty, but a major penalty. So, the submission of learned counsel for the
petitioner does not have any legal support.
13.
Mr. Lodh, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the
petitioner further submitted that the respondents had not indicated in the
order as to how the suspension period would be reckoned, and further, no
decision was taken as regards the entitlement of full salary and allowances
for the period the petitioner remained under suspension.
14.
In the instant case, the respondents while revoking the
suspension or within the reasonable time thereof no order was passed
pertaining to pay and allowances for the period the petitioner was put under
suspension. FR-54B legally obligates the competent authority to deal with
the suspension period, i.e. as to how the suspension period would be treated
or payment of salary and allowances for suspension period while
reinstating Government servant after revocation of his suspension
otherwise, the said authority would be precluded from exercising his power
under FR-54B. Keeping in mind the legal position that while revoking the
suspension or within a reasonable time thereof if no order is passed
pertaining to pay and allowances for the period of suspension, the authority
considered is denuded from passing any order subsequently i.e. at a belated
stage and at the stage of imposing punishment disentitling him from getting
full pay and allowances for the period of suspension and in that case, the
delinquent employee, would be entitled to full pay and allowances for the
period he remained under suspension. [Ref.Vijay Kumar Agarwal Vrs.
Union of India & Anr., (2015) 17 SCC 625, paras 20-21].
15.
In the case in hand, the suspension order was revoked vide
order dated 28.05.2014 and the order disentitling the petitioner from getting
full pay and allowances for the suspension period was passed under
Memorandum dated 5th May,2021 along with the impugned order of
penalty imposed upon the petitioner. As such, the order passed by the
respondents i.e. the Department of General Administration (Personnel &
Training), Government of Tripura, disqualifying the petitioner from the
benefit of full pay and allowances for the period of suspension is
inconsistent with the settled law as stated above and this part of the order is
liable to be interfered with.
16.
At this juncture, Mr. Lodh, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner has tried to persuade this court that the penalty imposed upon the
petitioner withholding of 3 (three) increments with cumulative effect is
disproportionate to the charges proved against him.
17.
I have considered this aspect. This court has set aside one
Charge i.e. Charge No.V. In view of this, according to this court,
withholding of one increment with cumulative effect will commensurate to
the gravity of the misconduct committed by the petitioner as is charged
under Article-IV, which also amounts to a major penalty.
18.
In the light of above analysis, this court deems it appropriate
to allow the writ petition with the following directions:
(i)
The Articles of Charges framed under Charge No.V is
set aside;
(ii)
The penalty of withholding 3 (three) increments with
cumulative effect is modified and reduced to the extent
of withholding 1(one) increment with cumulative
effect, which is treated to be a major penalty;
(iii) The petitioner is entitled to full pay and allowances for
the period he remained under suspension; and
The instant writ petition stands allowed in part in the above
terms and thus, disposed of.
JUDGE
sanjay
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review