Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page 1
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
W.P.(C) 574/2021
Sri Pankaj Behari Saha, son of late Anil Chandra Saha carrying on the
business of bonded warehouse in the name and style of Udaipur Bonded
Ware House at New Town Road, near Mahadeb Dighi, Udaipur, Gomati,
Tripura, aged about 60 years
---- Petitioner
Versus
1. The State of Tripura, represented by the Chief Secretary, Government of
Tripura, Agartala, New Civil Secretariat, P.O. New Capital Complex (NCC),
P.S. New Capital Complex (NCC), District- West Tripura, PIN- 799006.
2. The Principal Secretary, Finance Department, Government of Tripura,
Agartala, New Civil Secretariat, P.O. New Capital Complex (NCC), P.S.
New Capital Complex (NCC), District- West Tripura, Pin- 799006.
3. The Commissioner of Taxes, Tripura, P.N. Complex, Gurkhabasti, P.O.
Kunjaban, P.S. New Capital Complex (NCC), Agartala, District- West
Tripura, Pin-799006.
4. The Superintendent of Taxes, Charge-Udaipur, P.O. Udaipur, P.S.
Udaipur, District- Gomati, Pin Code- 799120.
----Respondents
For Petitioner(s)
:
Dr. Ashok Saraf, Sr. Advocate
Mr. P. Baruah, Advocate
Mr. Kousik Roy, Advocate
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. K. Dey, Additional GA
Date of hearing and delivery
of Judgment & Order
:
14.03.2023
Whether fit for reporting
:
Yes / No
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE (ACTING)
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
Judgment & Order (Oral)
14/03/2023
(T. Amarnath Goud, ACJ)
Heard Mr. Ashok Saraf, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr. P.
Baruah, learned counsel and Mr. Kousik Roy, learned counsel appearing for
the petitioner as well as Mr. K. Dey, learned Additional GA, appearing on
behalf of the respondents.
Page 2
2.
By means of filing this writ petition, the petitioner has challenged the
notices dated 10.07.2020 and 27.10.2020 (Annexure II and IX to the writ
petition) and order dated 25.09.2020 (Annexure VI to the writ petition)
issued by the respondent no. 3 whereby the respondent no. 3 had set-aside
the assessment order dated 24.03.2015 issued by the respondent no. 4.
3.
Briefly stated, the respondent no. 4, vide order dated 24.03.2015 had
completed the assessment of the petitioner under Section 31(1) of the TVAT
Act, 2004. On 10.07.2020 the respondent no. 3 issued a notice under Section
70(1) of the TVAT Act, upon the petitioner whereby he was asked to appear
in-person or by his authorized representative before the respondent no. 3 to
explain as to why the assessment order dated 24.03.2015 shall not be
cancelled or modified. Upon receipt of the notice dated 10.07.2020, the
petitioner submitted his reply on 04.08.2020 and 22.09.2020 stating that the
notice had been issued basing on the erroneous report of AG Audit and
prayed for dropping the suo moto revision. The respondent no. 3 vide order
dated 25.09.2020 had set-aside the assessment order dated 24.03.2015 and
remanded back for initiating fresh assessment. Thereafter, the respondent no.
3 on 27.10.2020 issued a show-cause notice upon the petitioner as to why a
penalty shall not imposed upon him. The petitioner thereafter submitted his
reply dated 02.11.2020. Subsequently, thereafter, the respondent no. 3 by its
order dated 20.04.2021 had dismissed the revision application of the
petitioner without considering the written statement submitted by the
petitioner.
Page 3
4.
During arguments, Dr. Saraf, learned senior counsel appearing for the
petitioner has submitted that notice dated 10.07.2020 and order dated
25.09.2020 issued by the respondent no. 3 are illegal and passed without
applying his mind. Learned senior counsel has also submitted that the suomoto revision initiated by the respondent no. 3 was much after expiry of the
period of limitation as prescribed under Sections 33 and 74 of the TVAT
Act, 2004. Learned senior counsel has further submitted that the impugned
order dated 20.04.2021 passed by the respondent no. 3 dismissing the
revision application of the petitioner is arbitrary and without jurisdiction.
Lastly, learned senior counsel has urged this court to set-aside the notice
dated 10.07.2020 and the impugned orders passed by the respondent no. 3.
5.
Learned Additional GA has submitted that there is no error in the
notice dated 10.07.2020 and the orders passed by the respondent no. 3 and
the orders have been passed by the revisional authority in accordance with
Act and Rules of the TVAT Act. Learned Additional GA has also urged this
court to dismiss the writ petition as not maintainable and further contended
that appeal lies against the order of revisional authority.
6.
Considered the submission of learned counsel appearing for the
parties. We have also perused the record.
7.
The respondent no. 4 after verification of the relevant documents of
the petitioner had completed the assessment by assessment order dated
24.03.2015. From the face of the record, it is apparent that the respondent
no. 4 on 10.07.2020 i.e. after elapse of more than five years had issued a
Page 4
notice under Section 70(1) of the TVAT Act, upon the petitioner wherein the
petitioner was asked to appear in person or by his authorized representative
and to explain as to why the assessment shall not be cancelled or modified.
As per sections 33 of 74 of the TVAT Act, 2004, the issuance of notice after
elapse of five years is barred by limitation. For convenience, Section 33 and
74 of the TVAT Act, is reproduced here-in-below:“33. No assessment after five years :- (1) No assessment under section 31 and 32 shall be
made after the expiry of five years from the end of the tax period to which the assessment
relates; Provided that in case of offence under this Act for which proceeding for
prosecution has been initiated, the limitation as specified in this subsection shall not
apply.
(2) Any assessment made or penalty imposed under this Chapter shall be without
prejudice to prosecution for any offence under this Act.
74. Power to Rectify Error Apparent on the Record: (1) An assessing, appellate or
revisional authority including the Tribunal may, on an application or otherwise at any time
within three years from the date of any order passed by it, rectify any error apparent on
the face of the record; Provided no such rectification which has the effect of enhancing
the liability to pay tax or penalty or penal interest shall be made unless such authority has
given notice to the person affected and has allowed him a reasonable opportunity of
being heard. (2) Where such rectification has the effect of enhancing the tax liability or
penalty, the Assessing Authority shall give the dealer or other person a notice of
assessment or penalty and the dealer or other person shall pay the tax in the manner
prescribed and when such rectification has the effect of reducing the tax liability or
penalty, the Assessing Authority shall issue refund of the excess tax paid, if any.”
8.
However, in reply to that notice, the petitioner had submitted his
reply/objection before the revisional authority, but the revisional authority
suo-moto initiated a proceeding revisional proceeding against the petitioner
and on 25.09.2020 passed an order setting aside the assessment order dated
24.03.2015 passed by the respondent no. 4 herein and remanded back the
matter for initiating fresh assessment. Thereafter, again on 27.10.2020, the
respondent no. 3 issued notice to the petitioner directing the petitioner to
show-cause as to why a sum by way of penalty shall not be imposed upon
the petitioner. Upon receipt of the said notice, the petitioner has submitted
Page 5
his reply on 02.11.2020 and prayed for consideration of prayers as regard to
his reply. On 09.11.2020, the respondent no. 4 had completed the reassessment of the petitioner and observed as under:
“6. In view of the above discussed facts and figures, taxable turnover is liable to be
considered and determined at Rs. 18,77,20,144/- for the year under assessment. As the
dealer did not pay the due tax/VAT in due course of time, I am satisfied to charge interest
@1.5% per month (@18% per annum) under Section 25(1)(c) of the TVAT Act, 2004 on the
balance amount of tax due. I am also satisfied in judicious consideration of the gravity of
offence, to impose least penalty @10% under Section 75A of the TVAT Act, 2004, on the
balance amount of tax due for concealment of actual taxable sales/turnover and evasion
of due tax thereon. Further, I am of opinion to impose penalty a sum equal to 0.1% of the
turnover under Section 53(3) of the TVAT Act, 2004.”
9.
Thereafter, the petitioner submitted written statement before the
revisional authority disclosing all his grievances, but the revisional authority
without considering his submission had dismissed the revision application
filed by the petitioner vide its order dated 20.04.2021, observing that the
documents submitted by the petitioner squarely proves that he has not
offered any discount and has only inserted some fictitious figure to avoid his
actual tax liability. It was further observed that the documents submitted by
the petitioner on different dates of hearing evidently proves that he adopted
the policy of exhibiting differential liability towards direct tax and indirect
tax and hence the learned Assessing Authority has rightly determined the
turnover and tax liability of the petitioner on documentary evidence and
accordingly the petitioner was rejected and the assessment order dated
09.11.2020 of the respondent no. 4 was upheld.
9.
Having heard learned counsel appearing for the parties, this court
prima facie on perusal of the proceeding dated 27.10.2020, order which is
impugned herein, this court expresses its concern that the revisional
Page 6
authority has not passed any speaking order and has not dealt with the issues
allowing the discounts and to say that the amounts discounted are fictitious.
10.
Accordingly, without entering into the merit of the case, the case is
remanded back to the revisional authority to decide the matter afresh by
passing a speaking order. It is also open for the petitioner to raise all his
objections including the issue of jurisdiction and also to place any judgment
in support of his contentions before the revisional authority. On making of
such submission, the revisional authority shall pass a speaking order in
accordance with law. This exercise shall be completed as expeditiously as
possible. Consequently, the impugned notice dated 27.10.2020 issued by the
respondent no. 3 is set-aside.
JUDGE
Saikat
CHIEF JUSTICE (ACTING)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review