Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page |1
Digitally
KABOR signed by
AMBAM KABORAMBA
M LARSON
LARSO Date:
2022.05.25
15:43:39
N
+05'30'
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
W.P.(C) No.53 of 2019
Shri Oinam Muhindro Singh, aged about 47 years old, S/o O.
Angouba Singh, a resident of Mayang Imphal Chirai P.O. & P.S.
Mayang Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur – 795132.
……. Petitioner/s
– Versus –
1. The State of Manipur, represented by the Principal Secretary/
Commissioner, Department of Education(S), Government of
Manipur, Old Secretariat, South Block Babupara, P.O. & P.S.
Imphal, Imphal District, Imphal, Manipur – 795001.
2. The Director of Education(S), Government of Manipur, Manipur,
Office of the Director of Education(S), Lamphelpat, P.O. & P.S.
Lamphel, Imphal West District, Manipur – 795004.
3. The Additional Director of Education(S), Government of
Manipur, Office of the Director of Education(S), Lamphelpat,
P.O. & P.S. Lamphel, Imphal West District, Manipur – 795004.
.…. Respondent/s
W.P.(C) No.53 of 2019 With W.P.(C) No.1060 of 2018
Page |2
With W.P.(C) No.1060 of 2018
Shri Oinam Muhindro Singh, aged about 47 years old, S/o O.
Angouba Singh, a resident of Mayang Imphal Chirai P.O. & P.S.
Mayang Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur – 795132.
……. Petitioner/s
– Versus –
1. The State of Manipur, represented by the Principal Secretary/
Commissioner, Department of Education(S), Government of
Manipur, Old Secretariat, South Block Babupara, P.O. & P.S.
Imphal, Imphal District, Imphal, Manipur – 795001.
2. The Joint Secretary, Department of Education(S), Government
of Manipur, Old Secretariat, South Block Babupara, P.O. &
P.S. Imphal, Imphal District, Imphal, Manipur – 795001.
3. The Director of Education(S), Government of Manipur,
Manipur, Office of the Director of Education(S), Lamphelpat,
P.O. & P.S. Lamphel, Imphal West District, Manipur – 795004.
.…. Respondent/s
W.P.(C) No.53 of 2019 With W.P.(C) No.1060 of 2018
Page |3
With MC[W.P.(C)] No.282 of 2019
The
State
of
Manipur
Secretary/Commissioner,
represented
by
the
Principal
Department
of
Education(S),
Government of Manipur, Old Secretariat, South Block Babupara,
P.O. & P.S. Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur – 795001 & 2
Ors.
……. Applicant/s
– Versus –
Shri Oinam Muhindro Singh, aged about 47 years old, S/o O.
Angouba Singh, a resident of Mayang Imphal Chirai P.O. & P.S.
Mayang Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur – 795132.
.…. Respondent/s
With MC[W.P.(C)] No.283 of 2019
The
State
of
Manipur
Secretary/Commissioner,
represented
by
the
Principal
Department
of
Education(S),
Government of Manipur, Old Secretariat, South Block Babupara,
P.O. & P.S. Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur – 795001 & 2
Ors.
……. Applicant/s
W.P.(C) No.53 of 2019 With W.P.(C) No.1060 of 2018
Page |4
– Versus –
Shri Oinam Muhindro Singh, aged about 47 years old, S/o O.
Angouba Singh, a resident of Mayang Imphal Chirai P.O. & P.S.
Mayang Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur – 795132.
.…. Respondent/s
With MC[W.P.(C)] No.58 of 2022
Shri Oinam Muhindro Singh, aged about 47 years old, S/o O.
Angouba Singh, a resident of Mayang Imphal Chirai P.O. & P.S.
Mayang Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur – 795132.
……. Applicant/s
– Versus –
The
State
of
Manipur
Secretary/Commissioner,
represented
by
the
Principal
Department
of
Education(S),
Government of Manipur, Old Secretariat, South Block Babupara,
P.O. & P.S. Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur – 795001 & 2
Ors.
.…. Respondent/s
W.P.(C) No.53 of 2019 With W.P.(C) No.1060 of 2018
Page |5
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE M.V. MURALIDARAN
For the Petitioner/s
:
Mr. N. Jotendro, Sr. Advocate
For the Respondent/s
:
Mr. S. Nepolean, GA
Date of Hearing
:
26.04.2022.
Date of Judgment & Order
:
24.05.2022.
JUDGMENT &ORDER
(CAV)
W.P.(C) No.53 of 2019 has been filed by the petitioner to quash
the impugned notification dated 10.1.2019 issued by the Director of Education
(S), Government of Manipur, thereby notifying for appointment to the post of
Vigyan Mandir Officer [for short, “VMO”] by way of transfer from amongst the
Lecturers in Science subject of Government Higher Secondary Schools as per
the existing Recruitment Rules of VMO issued vide notification dated
22.7.2005, thereby notifying to submit the duly filled Proforma on or before
3.00 p.m. of 30.1.2019 and also quash the last pay certificate dated 23.1.2019
issued by the Additional Director of Education (S), Government of Manipur,
coupled with a prayer to direct the Director of Education (S) to accept the
application submitted by the petitioner on 21.1.2019 and to forward the said
W.P.(C) No.53 of 2019 With W.P.(C) No.1060 of 2018
Page |6
application with duly filled Proforma submitted by the petitioner to the Director
of Education (S) in view of the interim orders dated 19.11.2018, 23.11.2018
and 16.1.2019 passed in W.P.(C) No.1060 of 2018 so as to enable to consider
the case of the petitioner as VMO as he has been discharging duties as on
19.11.2018 and 23.11.2018 while passing the status quo order.
[2]
W.P.(C) No.1060 of 2018 has been filed to set aside the
impugned transfer order dated 15.11.2018 issued by the Joint Secretary,
Education (S), Government of Manipur, thereby transferring the petitioner to
the post of Lecturer from the post of VMO on the ground that the probationary
period given in the order was for two years and the same is not yet completed.
[3]
Since the issue involved in these petitions is one and the same,
both the writ petitions were heard together and disposed of by this common
order.
[4]
Heard Mr. N. Jotendro, learned senior counsel for the petitioner
and Mr. S. Nepolean, learned Government Advocate appearing for the
respondent authorities.
[5]
Assailing the impugned notification dated 10.1.2019 and the
impugned transfer order dated 15.11.2018, Mr. N. Jotendro, the learned senior
W.P.(C) No.53 of 2019 With W.P.(C) No.1060 of 2018
Page |7
counsel for the petitioner submitted that while the petitioner was working as
Lecturer in the Government Higher Secondary School, he was transferred to
the post of VMO on 26.11.2016 and till date he is holding the said post. While
holding the transferred post, by the impugned order dated 15.11.2018, the
petitioner was transferred to hold the post of Lecturer in Physics at Lamlai
Higher Secondary School, Government of Manipur. He would submit that
assailing the said transfer order, he has filed W.P.(C) No.1060 of 2018 and by
the order dated 19.11.2018, this Court directed to maintain status quo, which
was still in force. Thus, he submits that the transfer is vitiated by the interim
orders of this Court.
[6]
The learned senior counsel further submitted that while the status
quo order in force, the Director of Education (S) issued the impugned
notification dated 10.1.2019, thereby notifying the appointment to the post of
VMO by way of transfer from amongst the Lecturer in Science subject of
Government Higher Secondary Schools. According to learned senior counsel,
the Director of Education (S) ought not to have issued such notification dated
10.1.2019 pending status quo order. Since the impugned notification dated
10.1.2019 issued in violation of the interim order of this Court, the same is
liable to be quashed.
W.P.(C) No.53 of 2019 With W.P.(C) No.1060 of 2018
Page |8
[7]
Per contra, Mr. S. Nepolean, learned Government Advocate
appearing for the respondents submitted that the writ petition seeking to set
aside the impugned notification dated 10.1.2019 does not deserve to be
entertained, as the said notification was issued as per the direction of the
Hon’ble Division Bench of this Court dated 10.4.2018 in W.A.No.6 of 2017. In
fact, in the said order dated 10.4.2018, this Court clearly stated that the
petitioner shall not be allowed to continue to hold the post of VMO beyond the
period of two months. Thus, in compliance with the said order, the impugned
transfer and posting order dated 15.11.2018 has been issued thereby
transferring the petitioner as Lecturer in Physics at Lamlai Higher Secondary
School and consequently, the service book has been forwarded to the
concerned Higher Secondary School and the last pay certificate has also been
issued.
[8]
The learned Government Advocate further submitted that one
post of VMO has to be filled up by way of transfer and posting from amongst
the Lecturers in Science subject of Government Higher Secondary Schools and,
accordingly, the notification dated 10.1.2019 was issued in that regard. Thus,
the question of quashing the said notification does not arise and therefore, the
writ petition seeking to quash the said notification deserves to be dismissed.
W.P.(C) No.53 of 2019 With W.P.(C) No.1060 of 2018
Page |9
[9]
This Court considered the submissions raised by learned senior
counsel for the petitioner and the learned Government Advocate for the
respondents and also perused the materials available on record.
[10]
There is no dispute that the petitioner was initially appointed to
the post of Science Graduate Teacher on 19.4.2007 and subsequently
promoted to the post of Lecturer in the Government Higher Secondary School
on 16.11.2016. Thereafter, he has been transferred to the post of VMO by an
order dated 26.11.2016.
[11]
According to the petitioner, the Recruitment Rules for the post of
VMO which was published on 22.7.2005 has already been acted upon by giving
effect to the promotion in favour of one R.K.Tennedy Singh to the post of
Science Promotion Officer. According to the petitioner, as per the Recruitment
Rules, there are two modes of appointment for the post of VMO – one is by
way
of
promotion
from
the
eligible
candidates
such
as
Science
Supervisor/Programme Officer having 5 years regular service in the grade and
possessing B.Sc. and B.T./B.Ed. and another by way of transfer from the post
of Lecturer in Science subject from the Government Higher Secondary School.
As the petitioner has already been appointed as Lecturer in Physics on regular
W.P.(C) No.53 of 2019 With W.P.(C) No.1060 of 2018
P a g e | 10
basis in the Government Higher Secondary School by a common promotion
order dated 16.11.2016, he is entitled to hold the post of VMO.
[12]
On a perusal of the Recruitment Rules, this Court finds that it
provides that the post of VMO is a selection post. The method of recruitment
to the said post is by way of (a) by promotion – 50% and (b) by transfer –
50%.
Column 11 of the Recruitment Rules speaks about the manner of
recruitment either by promotion/deputation/transfer. The grade from which
transfer is to be made is from Lecturers in Science subjects of Government
Higher Secondary Schools. The petitioner comes under the transfer category.
[13]
As stated supra, insofar as the case of transfer is concerned, it
only speaks that anyone who are Lecturers in Science subject of Government
Higher Secondary School can be transferred to the post of VMO. There is no
question of seniority to be taken into account. However, the appointment on
transfer of the petitioner to the post of VMO has been challenged by one
L.Dharendra Singh by filing W.P.(C) No.972 of 2016 before this Court.
In the
said writ petition, the petitioner has been arrayed as respondent No.5. By the
order dated 5.12.2016, this Court dismissed the said writ petition and the
operative portion of the order reads thus:
W.P.(C) No.53 of 2019 With W.P.(C) No.1060 of 2018
P a g e | 11
“On perusal of it one would find that seniority is one of the
factors to be considered so far it relates to promotion to the
post of Vigyan Mandir Officer. So far as the matter relating to
transfer is concerned, it only speaks that anyone who are
lecturers in Science subject of Government Higher Secondary
school can be transferred. The rule never does prescribe that
in the matter of transfer, seniority is to be taken into account
and thereby transfer and posting of respondent No.5 to the
post of VMO can never be said to be illegal even if post has
been described as selection post as selection post may be
confined to the matter relating to the promotion. Thus, I do
not find order of transfer and posting never happens to be in
contravention of the Recruitment Rules and thereby the
decision rendered in the case of Tejshree Ghag & Ors (supra)
referred to on behalf of the petitioner is never applicable in
the present case as in that case it has been observed that
executive power in absence of any statutory rule cannot be
exercised which may result in civil or penal consequences.
W.P.(C) No.53 of 2019 With W.P.(C) No.1060 of 2018
P a g e | 12
But here in this case transfer and posting has been made in
terms of the Recruitment Rules.
Thus, the transfer and posting of the petitioner to the post of VMO
seems to be in accordance with statutory rules and hence I do not find
any illegality with the order impugned. Hence, this application stands
dismissed.”
[14]
Aggrieved by the said order, the petitioner preferred W.A.No.6 of
2017 and the Division Bench of this Court, by the judgment dated 10.4.2018,
disposed of the writ appeal in the following lines:
“[6] After having heard learned counsel for the parties and
also considered the materials as proposed by the State, we
are also of the view that the respondent No.5 may be allowed
to function as Vigyan Mandir Officer during the said
intervening period purely on in-charge basis and it is expected
that the authorities will complete the entire process within the
prescribed period of two months from today. The authority
will take appropriate actions promptly and expeditiously to fill
W.P.(C) No.53 of 2019 With W.P.(C) No.1060 of 2018
P a g e | 13
up the post of Vigyan Mandir Officer by way of transfer in
terms of the relevant Recruitment Rules, as the respondent
No.5 will not be allowed to continue to hold the post of Vigyan
Mandir Officer beyond the period of two months.
It is made clear that since the appointment of respondent
No.5 has been challenged in this proceedings, it is directed
that in the selection process which will be initiated by the
respondent authorities for appointment to the post of Vigyan
Mandir Officer through transfer, the respondent No.5 shall not
be associated with the process except being a candidate.
With the above directions, the present appeal stands disposed of.”
[15]
Since the post was not filled up within the aforesaid period of two
months, the petitioner has filed M.C.(WA) No.18 of 2018. By the order dated
6.9.2018, the said petition was rejected by giving liberty to approach in
accordance with law.
The Review Application being Review Application (C)
No.9 of 2018 field by the petitioner also closed on 14.1.2019, in view of the
closure of the contempt petition being Contempt Case (C) No.170 of 2018.
W.P.(C) No.53 of 2019 With W.P.(C) No.1060 of 2018
P a g e | 14
[16]
On a perusal of the order passed in the contempt petition, this
Court finds that the same has been closed recording that the learned counsel
for the contemors has produced notification dated 10.1.2019 giving time line
for taking up proceeding for recruitment of VMO by way of transfer.
[17]
It appears that pending contempt petition and the review petition
filed by the petitioner, the Joint Secretary, Education (S) has issued the
impugned order dated 15.11.2018 transferring the petitioner from the post of
VMO as Lecturer in Physics at Lamlai Higher Secondary School, Manipur with
immediate effect.
According to the petitioner, such transfer order cannot be
issued, inasmuch as the matter is subjudice and that the petitioner cannot be
transferred.
[18]
At this juncture, the learned Government Advocate submitted that
the petitioner shall not be allowed to continue to hold the post of VMO beyond
two months as per the decision in the writ appeal and in compliance of the
order passed in the writ appeal, the transfer order dated 15.11.2018 was
issued, thereby transferring the petitioner as Lecturer in Physics at Lamlai
Higher Secondary School, Manipur and consequently his service book has been
forwarded and the last pay certificate has been issued.
W.P.(C) No.53 of 2019 With W.P.(C) No.1060 of 2018
P a g e | 15
[19]
It is seen from the records that when W.P.(C) No.1060 of 2018
was taken up for hearing, on 19.11.2018, this Court directed the parties to
maintain status quo as on that date and the said interim order still continued.
Resultantly, the transferred order dated 15.11.2018 has not given effect to. It
also appears that pending the aforesaid status quo order, the impugned
notification dated 10.1.2019 has been issued by the respondent authorities. By
the order dated 28.1.2019, the impugned notification dated 10.1.2019 as well
as the letter dated 23.1.2019 issued by the Additional Director of Education (S)
remain suspended and the said interim order also till continuing.
The
respondent State filed two miscellaneous petitions being M.C.No.282 of 2019 in
W.P.(C) No.53 of 2019 and M.C.No.283 of 2019 in W.P.(C) No.1060 of 2018 to
vacate those two orders and those petitions were also heard along with these
writ petitions.
[20]
At this juncture, learned senior counsel for the petitioner
submitted that the petitioner had also applied pursuant to the notification
dated 10.1.2021 on 21.1.2019 by submitting his application along with duly
filled Proforma and the same was also received by the Office of the Directorate
of Education (S), Manipur on the same date under R.R.No.0126. However, till
W.P.(C) No.53 of 2019 With W.P.(C) No.1060 of 2018
P a g e | 16
today, no reply has been given by the officials of the Directorate of Education
(S) for accepting the application of the petitioner.
[21]
In reply, the learned Government Advocate submitted that
pursuant to the order in W.A.No.6 of 2017, the State Government issued the
notification dated 10.1.2019 thereby inviting applications from the intending
eligible Lecturers of Government Higher Secondary Schools and only after
proper verification, the eligible candidates shall be informed accordingly. Thus,
the question of reply for accepting the application of the petitioner does not
arise.
[22]
According to the petitioner, the only person seeking appointment
to the post of VMO is L.Dharendra Singh, the writ petitioner in W.P.(C) No.972
of 2016. According to the petitioner, the aforesaid L.Dharendra Singh serving
dual service both in the Higher Secondary School as also at Moreh College and
also working as Lecturer (Physics), Johnstone Higher Secondary School,
Manipur and his ex-post facto resignation was approved on 17.10.2019 by the
Deputy Director, Education (S). By concealing these facts, he had challenged
the appointment of the petitioner as VMO. Thus, it is the say of the petitioner
that L.Dharendra Singh is the contender for the post of VMO against the
petitioner and since he had already regularized as an Assistant Professor of
W.P.(C) No.53 of 2019 With W.P.(C) No.1060 of 2018
P a g e | 17
Physics in Moreh College, Moreh, the post of VMO now holding by the
petitioner may be considered for regularization in favour of the petitioner.
[23]
The consideration of the petitioner for regularization to the post of
VMO is upto the decision of the respondent authorities and in accordance with
law and this Court cannot direct the respondent authorities to regularize the
services of the petitioner in the post of VMO as prayed for by him.
[24]
Since the status quo order in respect of the transfer of the
petitioner vide order dated 15.11.2018 from the post of VMO as Lecturer in
Physics at Lamlai Higher Secondary School, Manipur is in force and the
impugned notification dated 10.1.2019 calling for applications in the prescribed
Proforma from the intending and eligible Lecturers of Government Higher
Secondary Schools for recruitment by transfer to one post of VMO of the
Department of Education (S) and also the letter dated 23.1.2019 of the
Additional Director of Education (S) to the Principal, Lamlai Higher Secondary
School, Manipur forwarding the original service book and last pay certificate in
respect of the petitioner remain suspended by this Court by way of an interim
order dated 28.1.2019 and the same are still continuing, remanding the matter
to the respondent authorities is the best course of action in the interest of
justice for considering the claim of the petitioner in accordance with law.
W.P.(C) No.53 of 2019 With W.P.(C) No.1060 of 2018
P a g e | 18
While considering the claim of the petitioner by the respondent authorities, if
they found that regularization of the petitioner to the post of VMO is not
feasible, he can be considered as a candidate as held by the Division Bench of
this Court in W.A.(C) No.6 of 2017.
[25]
As rightly stated by the petitioner, since the impugned transfer
order dated 15.11.2018 was issued while the matter pending before the
Division Bench and since the same has not been acted upon, there is no
impediment in set aside the transfer order dated 15.11.2018.
[26]
As stated supra, since the petitioner had also applied pursuant to
the notification dated 10.1.2019 for the post of VMO and the said application is
pending consideration before the respondent authorities, quashing the
impugned notification as a whole is not appropriate at this stage. On the other
hand, as stated supra, in the interest of justice, this Court can direct the
respondent authorities to consider the candidature of the petitioner provided
he had applied in the prescribed format with required particulars.
[27]
While setting aside the impugned transfer order of the petitioner
dated 15.11.2018, the matter is remanded back to the respondent authorities
for consideration of the candidature of the petitioner as stated supra.
W.P.(C) No.53 of 2019 With W.P.(C) No.1060 of 2018
P a g e | 19
[28]
With the aforesaid observation and direction, W.P.(C) No.1060 of
2018 is allowed and W.P.(C) No.53 of 2019 is disposed of and the matter is
remanded back to the respondent authorities for consideration of the
candidature of the petitioner in accordance with law and also as stated supra.
Consequently, M.C.(WP) No.282 of 2019 in W.P.(C) No.53 of 2019 and
M.C.(WP) No.283 of 2019 in W.P.(C) No.1060 of 2018 are dismissed. M.C.(WP)
No.58 of 2022 in W.P.(C) No.53 of 2019 is closed. No costs.
JUDGE
FR/NFR
-Larson
W.P.(C) No.53 of 2019 With W.P.(C) No.1060 of 2018
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review