The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
30. 09.2022. Hence the present writ petition is also liable to be dismissed for the reasons mentioned above. Accordingly, the same stands dismissed. For wasting the time of the Court, this Court directs the petitioner not to venture into such recourse in future and while dismissing this instant PIL, a cost of Rs.25,000/(Rupees Twenty Five Thousand only) is imposed upon the petitioner which is to be deposited in the account of the Tripura High Court Employees Association within one month from today. A copy is marked to the President of the Tripura High Court Employees Association. suhanjit CHIEF JUSTICE (ACTING)
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C)(PIL) NO.1 OF 2023
Shri Nikhil Ch. Debnath
Vs
The State of Tripura and ors.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE (ACTING)
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
Present:
For the Petitioner(s)
: Mr. S.K Deb, Sr. Advocate.
Mr. B. Chowdhury, Advocate.
Mr. B. Debnath, Advocate.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. D. Bhattacharjee, G.A.
Mr. S. Saha, Advocate.
04.01.2023
Order
The case of the petitioner herein is that he is a freelance
journalist and he has filed the present Public Interest Litigation
(for short „PIL‟) challenging the advertisement policy of the State
of Tripura and the resolution/decisions purportedly adopted by
Empowered Advertisement Committed adversely affecting the
freedom of press. The advertisement policy vide Notification
dated 20th May 2021 has conferred unbridled, uncanalised, and
unregulated power upon the Advertisement Committee smacking
of arbitrariness and unfairness.
Hence the petitioner herein by filing this present PIL has
prayed for the following reliefs:“i) Issue a Rule calling upon the State
respondents and each one of them to show cause as to
why the Notification dated, Agartala, the 20th May,
2021 shall not be quashed/set aside;
ii) Issue a Rule calling upon the State
respondents and each one of them to show cause as to
hwy the purported decision taken by the 1st Committed
meeting held on 02.06.2021 shall not be quashed/set
aside;
iii) Issue a Rule calling upon the State
respondents and each one of them to show cause as to
hwy the purported communication under No.F.65(10)ICA/Advt/2021 dated 30th June, 2022 shall not be
quashed/set aside;
iv) Issue a Rule calling upon the State
respondents and each one of them to show cause as to
why the purported decision taken by the 3rd Committee
meeting held on 25.05.2022 shall not be quashed/set
side.
v) Issue a Rule calling upon the State
respondents and each one of them to show cause as to
why a Writ of Mandamus and/or direction shall not be
issued for framing an appropriate policy and/or take
appropriate decision in the
matter of issuing
advertisement to the newspaper in fairness and without
any arbitrariness;
vi) Issue a Rule calling upon the State
respondents and each one of them to show cause as to
why a Writ of Probation and/or in the nature thereof
shall not be issued prohibiting/restraining the
respondents and/or in the nature thereof shall not be
issued prohibiting/restraining the respondents and/or
each one of them from acting upon the Notification
dated 20.05.2021, the Resolution of the 1st Committee
meeting held on 02.06.2021, communication dated 30th
June, 2022 and the alleged Resolution adopted on
25.05.2022;
vii) Call for records; and
viii) After hearing the parties be pleased to
make the Rule absolute in terms of i),ii),iii), iv), v) & vi)
above;
ix) In the interim an order in terms of i), ii),
iii), iv), v) & vi) above during the pendency of this
petition;”
Heard Mr. S.K. Deb, learned Sr. counsel assisted by Mr. B.
Chowdhury, learned counsel, and Mr. B. Debnath, learned
counsel
appearing
for
the
petitioner
as
well
as
Mr.
D.
Bhattacharjee, learned G.A. assisted by Mr. S. Saha, learned
counsel appearing for the respondents.
Mr. S.K. Deb, learned Sr. counsel appearing for the
petitioner
has
contended
that
the
policy
framed
by
the
Government with regard to releasing the advertisement is
without application of mind. It is against the interest of the public
and it is attacking the rights and liberties of the people by not
providing
the
proper
information
as
required
under
the
newspaper publications. Thus learned Sr. counsel prayed to set
aside the same on the ground that the guidelines are not
properly framed.
Heard both sides and perused the evidence on record.
Prima facie, the impugned notification has been issued in
the month of May 2021, and accordingly, the policy has been
initiated. The petitioner herein has not explained as to why he
has not filed the present PIL from May 2021 till December 2022
when he personally claims that he is an active journalist and in
the interest of the public of Tripura he has taken up this
assignment of filing the present PIL. Further, in the affidavit,
there is no contention enlightening this Court to call for taking
cognizance of the issuance of the said notification by the
respondents jeopardizing the public interest. Thereafter, no such
advertisement is placed before this Court to enlighten that by
virtue of the said decision by the committee in releasing the said
advertisement;
the
object
with
regard
to
which
the
advertisement is released has been reached or not reached.
The present petitioner in his affidavit has referred to one
Subal Kr. Dey and stated that, the said person as petitioner had
filed a petition bearing No. WP(C) No.203 of 2014 challenging the
Newspaper Policy of 2009 and this High Court repealed the same
vide judgment dated 16.08.2015. Here it is also pertinent to
mention that this Court recollects that the said Subal Kr. Dey who
is the Owner, Editor, Printer, and Publisher of Syandan Patrika as
petitioner No.2 also filed one writ petition titled as WP(C) No.857
of 2022
for
non-considering
his
newspaper
publication for
empanelling and providing Government advertisement on the
ground of not having a proper circulation as per the Audit Bureau
of Circulation. However the same was withdrawn on the request of
the learned Sr. counsel representing the petitioners vide order
dated 30.09.2022. In that said order, this Court observed thus:“This Court feels that providing advertisement in any
newspaper is the prerogative of the customer and here the
State-Government is the customer and it is for the State
Government to pick and choose the newspaper of its choice
depending on its various parameter including the nature of
advertisement which would serve the purpose in reaching to
the reader of the said newspaper.
It is seen from the record that the petitioner newspaper
is the ownership newspaper company and Abhishek Dey is not
competent to file the representation before the concerned
authorities.”
The
petitioner
cannot
depend
his
PIL
on
the
writ
petition/representation filed by someone else. The petitioner
herein has to establish his own prima facie case. If a petition is a
PIL, he has to make out the cause of the said PIL. He has to
establish that the said litigation is in the public interest and how
the public interest is prejudiced. In this instant PIL, this is not
explained and the petitioner is simply referring to the writ petition
of someone else.
As mentioned herein above, one of the writ
petition filed by said Subal Kr. Dey who is the Owner, Editor,
Printer, and Publisher of Syandan Patrika was already dismissed
as withdrawn. With regard to this, the present petitioner herein
has suppressed the said fact in his affidavit where he has referred
to the representations and grievances of Subal Kr. Dey.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in its landmark judgment
passed in State of Uttaranchal Vs. Balwant Singh Chaufal
and ors., reported in (2010) 3 SCC 402 dated 01.18.2010,
held that the Public Interest Litigation, which has been in
existence in our country for more than four decades, has a
glorious record, This Court and the High Courts by their judicial
creativity and craftsmanship have passed a number of directions
in the larger public interest in consonance with the inherent
spirits of the Constitution. The conditions of marginalized and
vulnerable section of society have significantly improved on
account of Courts directions in the PIL and issued the following
directions ad infra:“ (1) The courts must encourage genuine and bona fide
PIL and effectively discourage and curb the PIL filed for
extraneous considerations.
(2) Instead of every individual judge devising his own
procedure for dealing with the public interest litigation, it
would be appropriate for each High Court to properly
formulate rules for encouraging the genuine PIL and
discouraging
the
PIL
filed
with
oblique
motives.
Consequently, we request that the High Courts who have not
yet framed the rules, should frame the rules within three
months. The Registrar General of each High Court is directed
to ensure that a copy of the Rules prepared by the High
Court is sent to the Secretary General of this court
immediately thereafter.
(3) The courts should prima facie verify the credentials of
the petitioner before entertaining a P.I.L.
(4) The court should be prima facie satisfied regarding the
correctness of the contents of the petition before
entertaining a PIL.
(5) The court should be fully satisfied that substantial
public interest is involved before entertaining the petition.
(6) The court should ensure that the petition which involves
larger public interest, gravity and urgency must be given
priority over other petitions.
(7) The courts before entertaining the PIL should ensure
that the PIL is aimed at redressal of genuine public harm or
public injury. The court should also ensure that there is no
personal gain, private motive or oblique motive behind filing
the public interest litigation.
(8) The court should also ensure that the petitions filed by
busybodies for extraneous and ulterior motives must be
discouraged by imposing exemplary costs or by adopting
similar novel methods to curb frivolous petitions and the
petitions filed for extraneous considerations.
In view of the following principles laid down by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in State of Uttaranchal Vs. Balwant Singh
Chaufal(supra), and the discussions made herein above, this
Court is of the view that the instant PIL has not followed the said
principles and no public interest is involved in this instant
petition.
In view of the above, this Court prima facie feels that this
instant PIL is devoid of any merit and it cannot be treated as PIL.
This Court feels that the petitioner has filed the present petition
at the instigation of some vested interested person. The petition
filed attracts laches for challenging the notification dated
20.05.2021 in December 2022. The petitioner herein has not also
revealed about the dismissal of the WP(C) No.857 of 2022 dated
30.09.2022. Hence the present writ petition is also liable to be
dismissed for the reasons mentioned above.
Accordingly, the
same stands dismissed. For wasting the time of the Court, this
Court directs the petitioner not to venture into such recourse in
future and while dismissing this instant PIL, a cost of Rs.25,000/(Rupees Twenty Five Thousand only) is imposed upon the
petitioner which is to be deposited in the account of the Tripura
High Court Employees Association within one month from today.
A copy is marked to the President of the Tripura High Court
Employees Association.
JUDGE
suhanjit
CHIEF JUSTICE (ACTING)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review