Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1NC: 2026:KHC-D:440
RSA No. 1026 of 2007
HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA, AT DHARWAD
DATED THIS THE 14TH DAY OF JANUARY, 2026
BEFORE
R
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE HANCHATE SANJEEVKUMAR
REGULAR SECOND APPEAL NO. 1026 OF 2007 (INJ)
BETWEEN:
SHRI NAGAPPA YALLAPPA PATIL,
SINCE DECEASED BY LRS.
1.
SMT. TANGEWA W/O. NAGAPPA PATIL,
AGE: 70 YEARS OCC: HOUSEHOLD,
R/O. MANGYANKOP-591302,
TAL: KHANAPUR, DIST. BELGAUM.
SINCE DECEASED BY HER LRS.
2.
SHRI NINGAPPA NAGAPPA PATIL,
AGE: 55 YEARS, OCC: SERIVCE,
R/O. 1638, SECTOR NO.8,
ANJANEY NAGAR, BLEGUAM-590016.
3.
SHRI VITHAL NAGAPPA PATIL,
AGE: 50 YEARS, OCC: AGRICULTURE,
R/O. MANGYANKOP-591302,
TAL: KHANAPUR, DIST. BELGAUM.
4.
SRI RAMESH NAGAPPA PATIL,
AGE: 40 YEARS,
R/O. MANGYANKOP-591302,
TAL: KHANAPUR, DIST. BELGAUM.
5.
SRI VIJAY NAGAPPA PATIL,
AGE: 30 YEARS OCC: SERVICE,
R/O. POLICE QUARTERS, NIPANI-591237,
TALUK: CHIKODI, DIST. BELGAUM.
6.
SMT. MALLAWA W/O. KRISHNA PATIL,
Digitally signed
by MALLIKARJUN
RUDRAYYA
KALMATH
Location: High
Court of
Karnataka,
Dharwad Bench
-2NC: 2026:KHC-D:440
RSA No. 1026 of 2007
HC-KAR
AGE: 52 YEARS OCC: HOUSHOLD,
R/O. MASKENHATTI-591302,
TAL: KHANAPUR, DIST. BELGAUM.
7.
SMT. AWAKKA W/O. TOPANNA HANABAR,
AGE: 51 YEARS, OCC: AGRICUTLURE,
R/O. VEERAPPANKOPP, POST MUTNAL,
TAL. & DIST. BELGAUM-590001.
SINCE DECEASED BY HER LR’S.
7A. TOPANNA MOKAPPA HANABAR,
AGE: 77, OCC: AGRIL.
R/O. VEERAPPANKOPP, POST: MUTNAL,
TQ. & DIST. BELAGAVI.
7B. MOKAPPA TOPANNA HANABAR,
AGE: 48, OCC: AGRIL.
R/O. VEERAPPANKOPP, POST: MUTNAL,
TQ. & DIST. BELAGAVI.
7C. MANJULA W/O. VIJAY PATIL,
AGE: 45, OCC: HOUSEHOLD,
R/O. POLICE HEAD QUARTUS,
NIPPANI, DIST. BELAGAVI.
8.
SMT. SUSHILA W/O. YALLAPPA MUMMINAGATTI,
AGE: 35 YEARS OCC: SERVICE,
R/O. C/O. RANGE FOREST OFFICE,
DHARWAD-580001.
…APPELLANTS
(BY SRI B. S. KAMATE, ADVOCATE.)
AND:
SHRI GIREPPA GANGAPPA ITAGIKAR,
AGE: 75 YEARS, OCC: AGRICULTURE,
R/O. MANGYANKOP-591302,
TAL: KHANAPUR, DIST. BELGAUM.
…RESPONDENT
(BY SRI ASHOK R. KALYANASHETTY, ADVOCATE)
-3NC: 2026:KHC-D:440
RSA No. 1026 of 2007
HC-KAR
THIS REGULAR SECOND APPEAL IS FILED UNDER SECTION
100 OF THE CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE, PRAYING TO AFTER
CALLING FOR THE RECORDS AND PROCEEDINGS OF THE CASE,
THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED: 22.01.2007 PASSED BY
THE LEARNED IIND ADDL. CIVIL JUDGE (SR.DN), BELAGAVI AT:
KHANAPUR IN R.A.NO.308/99 AND THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE
DATED 31.08.1999 PASSED BY THE LEARNED ADDL. CIVIL
JUDGE (JR.DN), KHANAPUR IN O.S.NO.72/1992 MAY KINDLY BE
SET ASIDE BY ALLOWING THIS R.S.A. WITH COSTS IN THE
INTEREST OF JUSTICE.
THIS APPEAL, COMING ON FOR FURTHER HEARING, THIS
DAY, JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
ORAL JUDGMENT
(PER: THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE HANCHATE SANJEEVKUMAR)
This regular second appeal is filed by the defendant
challenging the judgment and decree dated 22.01.2007 passed
in R.A.No.308/1999 on the file of II Additional Civil Judge
(SR.DN.), Belagavi1, which confirmed the judgment and decree
dated 31.08.1999 passed in O.S.No.72/1992 on the file of
Additional Civil Judge (JR.DN.) and JMFC, Khanapur2, thereby the
suit for permanent and mandatory injunction was decreed and
the defendant was permanently restrained from interfering with
the plaintiff’s possession of the suit property and further directed
to remove the gobar gas plant constructed by him in the suit
Hereinafter referred to as the ‘First Appellate Court’
Hereinafter referred to as the ‘Trial Court’
-4NC: 2026:KHC-D:440
RSA No. 1026 of 2007
HC-KAR
property by way of mandatory injunction, which is confirmed by
the First Appellate Court.
2.
Being aggrieved by the said judgments and decrees
passed by the Trial Court and the First Appellate Court, the
defendant has preferred the present regular second appeal.
3.
For the purpose of convenience and easy reference,
ranking of the parties is referred to as per their status before the
Trial Court.
4.
The plaintiff filed a suit for permanent and mandatory
injunction. The prayer for mandatory injunction has the effect of
directing
the
defendant
to
remove
the
gobar
gas
plant
constructed and installed on a portion of the suit schedule
property. It is pertinent to mention here that the plaintiff has not
sought any relief of declaration. The plaintiff has described the
suit property as an open space forming part of MPC No.165,
situated at Mangenkoppa village of Khanapur Taluk, measuring
12 feet on the east-west side and 144 feet on the north-south
side.
-5NC: 2026:KHC-D:440
RSA No. 1026 of 2007
HC-KAR
5.
It is the case of the plaintiff that he is the owner of the
suit property, which is an open space attached to the property
bearing
MPC
No.165.
The
defendant
is
alleged
to
have
encroached upon the said open space and constructed a gobar
gas plant thereon. Therefore, the plaintiff filed the suit seeking
the aforesaid reliefs.
6.
The defendant appeared and filed a written statement
contending that the house property bearing MPC No.165 was
belonged to the defendant and that, as the plaintiff is related to
him, the plaintiff was permitted to use the same. After coming
into force of the Panchayat Act, the name of the plaintiff’s father
was entered in the records. The defendant is the owner of
properties bearing MPC Nos.164 and 166, and the open space
now claimed by the plaintiff does not form part of MPC No.165
but belongs to the defendant.
7.
It is further the case of the defendant that though the
plaintiff is the owner of the house property bearing MPC No.165,
but is not the owner of the courtyard/open space, which belongs
to the defendant. It is also submitted that the house property
bearing MPC No.165 is bounded on three sides by the properties
-6NC: 2026:KHC-D:440
RSA No. 1026 of 2007
HC-KAR
of the defendant and on one side by a public road, and even the
Secretary of the VPC (Village Panchayat Committee) has issued a
certificate to that effect. Thus, the defendant contends that the
plaintiff, being his sister’s son, has filed the suit for permanent
and mandatory injunction with an intention to grab the suit
property.
8.
The Trial Court, after considering the evidence adduced
by both parties, decreed the suit, granting a permanent
injunction
and
also
a
mandatory
injunction
directing
the
defendant to remove the gobar gas plant constructed on the suit
open space.
9.
Being aggrieved by the judgment and decree passed by
the Trial Court, the defendant preferred a regular appeal before
the First Appellate Court. The First Appellate Court dismissed the
appeal, thereby confirming the judgment and decree of the Trial
Court. Consequently, the defendant has filed the present regular
second appeal.
10.
Against the concurrent findings of both the Trial Court
and the First Appellate Court, the defendant has preferred the
-7NC: 2026:KHC-D:440
RSA No. 1026 of 2007
HC-KAR
present appeal by raising various grounds. This Court, on
17.04.2007, has framed the following substantial question of
law:
“Whether the Courts below were justified in
granting the mandatory injunction in the
absence of relief of declaration sought by the
defendant.”
11.
Learned counsel appearing for the defendant/appellant
submitted that, while it is not in dispute that the plaintiff is the
owner of the property bearing MPC No.165, but he is not the
owner of the backyard, which is an open space not attached to
the property of MPC No.165. It is further submitted that the
defendant is the owner of the open space allegedly being claimed
by the plaintiff. Therefore, insofar as the open space is
concerned, there is a dispute regarding title. The defendant does
not dispute the plaintiff’s ownership of the houses bearing MPC
Nos.165 and 167, but specifically disputes ownership of the open
space not attached to the property bearing MPC No.165, but
contending that it does not form part of the suit property.
-8NC: 2026:KHC-D:440
RSA No. 1026 of 2007
HC-KAR
12.
It is further submitted that, in view of this dispute over
title, the suit solely for the relief of permanent and mandatory
injunction is not maintainable. When the defendant is disputing
the title over the open space on which he has constructed the
gobar gas plant, the plaintiff bears the burden of filing suit
seeking the relief of declaration and to establish title over the
open space but not sought relief of declaration. Therefore, a
mere suit for mandatory injunction, without establishing title, is
not maintainable and hence, prays to allow the appeal.
13.
Learned counsel appearing for the defendant/appellant
places reliance on the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court
between Anathula Sudhakar Vs. P. Buchi Reddy (Dead) by
LRs. And Others3, and the judgment of this Court between Shri
Baban @ Maruti Govind Jadhav (Dead) by LRs. And Others
Vs. Shri Uttam Anant Sarolkar and Others4.
14.
On the other hand, learned counsel appearing for the
plaintiff/respondent submitted that the Trial Court has answered
issue Nos.1 to 4 in favour of the plaintiff holding that the plaintiff
is the owner of property bearing MPC No.165. Therefore, justified
(2008) 4 Supreme Court Cases 594
Miscellaneous Second Appeal No.540/2012 decided on 16.06.2025
-9NC: 2026:KHC-D:440
RSA No. 1026 of 2007
HC-KAR
the judgment and decree passed by the Trial Court. It is further
submitted that there is no substantial question of law involved in
entertaining the appeal, relying on the provisions of Sub Section
(5) of Section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908. It is
further submitted that the plaintiff is admittedly owner of the
property bearing MPC No.165, while the defendant is the owner
of the properties bearing MPC Nos.164, 166 and 167. In view of
this, the open space on which the gobar gas plant was
constructed is attached to the property bearing MPC No.165, and
there is no dispute regarding title over this open space. The Trial
Court and the First Appellate Court have rightly considered this
fact. Accordingly, prayed for dismissal of the appeal.
15.
The Trial Court, after appreciating both oral and
documentary evidence, held that the plaintiff is the owner of the
property bearing MPC No.165. The plaintiff produced Ex.P2-hand
sketch, Ex.P3 and Ex.P4, which are property tax extracts of MPC
No.165 for the years 1961-62 and 1991-92, and Ex.P5-property
certificate issued by MPC Mangyankoppa, all of which establish
the plaintiff’s ownership of the property bearing MPC No.165.
The evidence also establishes that the defendant is the owner of
- 10 NC: 2026:KHC-D:440
RSA No. 1026 of 2007
HC-KAR
the properties bearing MPC Nos.164, 166 and 167. On the basis
of this evidence, the Trial Court has held that the plaintiff is the
owner of the property bearing MPC No.165 and accordingly
decreed the suit. The First Appellate Court, upon re-appreciating
the evidence in light of the Trial Court’s findings, has confirmed
the judgment and decree passed by the Trial Court.
16.
Upon considering the findings given by the Trial Court
and the First Appellate Court as well as the submissions made by
both counsels, it is not in dispute that the plaintiff is the owner of
house property bearing MPC No.165. The dispute pertains only to
the title over the open space attached to the property bearing
MPC Nos.164, 165 and 166. The subject matter involved in
dispute is not the house property itself, but the open space
claiming to be attached to the house property bearing No.165.
According to the defendant, the property bearing MPC No.165
does not have open space and the said property is only house
property.
17.
Upon considering of the pleadings of the defendant, it is
evident that the defendant has denied the title of the plaintiff
over the suit open space, which is claimed to be attached to the
- 11 NC: 2026:KHC-D:440
RSA No. 1026 of 2007
HC-KAR
property bearing MPC No.165. Even as per the description of the
suit property furnished by the plaintiff, the schedule property is
an open space and is bounded by property of the defendant both
on eastern and western sides. As per the boundaries shown in
the plaint, the suit open space is bounded on the east and west
side property of the defendant and on the north by the house
property bearing MPC No.165. Therefore, the question that arises
for consideration is whether the open space, on which the gobar
gas plant is constructed, is attached to the property of the
defendant either on the eastern or western side, or whether it
forms part of the plaintiff’s property situated on the northern
side.
18.
The defendant has not admitted the ownership of the
plaintiff over the suit open space and has specifically disputed
the plaintiff’s title thereto. When this being the contention of the
defendant disputing the title of the plaintiff over the suit open
space, the question that arises for consideration is whether a
mere
suit
for
mandatory
and
permanent
injunction
maintainable without seeking the relief of declaration of title.
is
- 12 NC: 2026:KHC-D:440
RSA No. 1026 of 2007
HC-KAR
19.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court, in the judgment in
Anathula Sudhakar (supra), has laid down the principles of law
governing the appropriate reliefs to be sought for in the suit
proceedings, particularly in cases involving dispute over title,
which reads as follows:
12.
On
the
contentions
urged,
the
following
questions arise for our consideration in this appeal:
(i) What is the scope of a suit for prohibitory
injunction relating to immovable property?
(ii) Whether on the facts, the plaintiffs ought to
have filed a suit for declaration of title and
injunction ?
(iii) Whether the High Court, in a second appeal
under section 100 CPC, could examine the factual
question of title which was not the subject matter
of any issue and based on a finding thereon,
reverse the decision of the first appellate court?
Re: Question (i)
13. The general principles as to when a mere suit for
permanent
injunction
necessary to
file
a
will
lie,
suit for
and
when
it
is
declaration and/or
- 13 NC: 2026:KHC-D:440
RSA No. 1026 of 2007
HC-KAR
possession with injunction as a consequential relief,
are well settled.
We may refer to them briefly.
13.1. Where a plaintiff is in lawful or peaceful
possession of a property and such possession is
interfered or threatened by the defendant, a suit for
an injunction simpliciter will lie. A person has a right
to protect his possession against any person who
does not prove a better title by seeking a prohibitory
injunction. But a person in wrongful possession is not
entitled to an injunction against the rightful owner.
13.2. Where the title of the plaintiff is not disputed,
but he is not in possession, his remedy is to file a suit
for possession and seek in addition, if necessary, an
injunction. A person out of possession, cannot seek
the relief of injunction simpliciter, without claiming
the relief of possession.
13.3. Where the plaintiff is in possession, but his title
to the property is in dispute, or under a cloud, or
where the defendant asserts title thereto and there is
also a threat of dispossession from the defendant,
the plaintiff will have to sue for declaration of title
and the consequential relief of injunction. Where the
title of plaintiff is under a cloud or in dispute and he
is
not
in
possession
or
not
able
to
establish
- 14 NC: 2026:KHC-D:440
RSA No. 1026 of 2007
HC-KAR
possession, necessarily the plaintiff will have to file a
suit for declaration, possession and injunction.
21. To summarize, the position in regard to suits for
prohibitory injunction relating to immovable property,
is as under :
(a) Where a cloud is raised over plaintiff's title
and he does not have possession, a suit for
declaration and possession, with or without a
consequential injunction, is the remedy. Where
the plaintiff's title is not in dispute or under a
cloud, but he is out of possession, he has to sue
for possession with a consequential injunction.
Where there is merely an interference with
plaintiff's
lawful
possession
or
threat
of
dispossession, it is sufficient to sue for an
injunction simpliciter.
(b) As a suit for injunction simpliciter is
concerned only with possession, normally the
issue of title will not be directly and substantially
in issue. The prayer for injunction will be decided
with reference to the finding on possession. But in
cases where de jure possession has to
be
established on the basis of title to the property,
as in the case of vacant sites, the issue of title
may
directly
and
substantially
arise
for
- 15 NC: 2026:KHC-D:440
RSA No. 1026 of 2007
HC-KAR
consideration, as without a finding thereon, it will
not be possible to decide the issue of possession.
(c) But a finding on title cannot be recorded in
a suit for injunction, unless there are necessary
pleadings and appropriate issue regarding title
(either
specific,
or
implied
as
noticed
in
Annaimuthu Thevar v. Alaganmal5). Where the
averments regarding title are absent in a plaint
and where there is no issue relating to title, the
court will not investigate or examine or render a
finding on a question of title, in a suit for
injunction.
Even
pleadings
and
where
issue,
if
there
are
necessary
the
matter
involves
complicated questions of fact and law relating to
title, the court will relegate the parties to the
remedy
by
way
of
comprehensive
suit
for
declaration of title, instead of deciding the issue
in a suit for mere injunction.
(d)
Where
there
are
necessary
pleadings
regarding title, and appropriate issue relating to
title on which parties lead evidence, if the matter
involved is simple and straight-forward, the court
may decide upon the issue regarding title, even in
a suit for injunction. But such cases, are the
exception to the normal rule that question of title
(2005) 6 SCC 202
- 16 NC: 2026:KHC-D:440
RSA No. 1026 of 2007
HC-KAR
will not be decided in suits for injunction. But
persons having clear title and possession suing
for injunction, should not be driven to the costlier
and more cumbersome remedy of a suit for
declaration,
merely
because
some
meddler
vexatiously or wrongfully makes a claim or tries
to encroach upon his property. The court should
use its discretion carefully to identify cases where
it will enquire into title and cases where it will
refer
to
plaintiff
to
a
more
comprehensive
declaratory suit, depending upon the facts of the
case.
20.
Further, this Court, in Shri Baban @ Maruti Govind
Jadhav (Dead) by LRs. And Others (supra), has held that
where a relief of mandatory injunction is sought, the plaintiff is
required to establish and prove his title. Only thereafter the
question of granting a decree for mandatory injunction arises.
21.
Considering the principles of law stated above and the
factual matrix as pleaded in the written statement, it is evident
that the defendant has not admitted the title of the plaintiff over
the suit open space. On the contrary, in the written statement, it
is evident that the defendant has specifically disputed the
plaintiff’s title to the suit open space.
- 17 NC: 2026:KHC-D:440
RSA No. 1026 of 2007
HC-KAR
22.
Furthermore, the Trial Court, while answering issue
Nos.1 to 4, has observed that the plaintiff has proved ownership
of the house bearing MPC No.165; however observed the
ownership of the land on which the gobar gas plant is
constructed is disputed. Upon appreciation of the evidence on
record, the Trial Court itself raised a question regarding the
ownership and possession of suit open space.
23.
The Trial Court further appreciated the evidence of the
defendant, who denied the plaintiff’s title to the backyard
attached to the property bearing MPC No.165. It was also
observed by the Trial Court that there is no fencing separating
the backyards of properties bearing MPC Nos.163, 164, 165 and
166.
24.
In view of these observations, it is clear that there
exists a genuine dispute with regard to the title of the suit open
space. Unless and until the plaintiff establishes his title by
seeking and obtaining a declaration that the suit open space
belongs to him and forms part of property bearing MPC No.165,
the question of granting a decree for mandatory injunction
directing removal of the gobar gas plant does not arise.
- 18 NC: 2026:KHC-D:440
RSA No. 1026 of 2007
HC-KAR
However, in the present case, the plaintiff has not sought the
relief of declaration and has merely filed the suit for mandatory
and
permanent
injunction.
Therefore,
unless
a
suit
for
declaration is filed in case of dispute over the title of property,
there is no question of granting decree of mandatory injunction.
25.
Hence, as per the principles of law laid down by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court and this Court, if there is a dispute
regarding title, then it is incumbent upon the plaintiff to seek
relief of declaration and to prove his title over the suit property.
Then, the relief of mandatory injunction can be granted with
consequential relief of permanent injunction.
26.
If the plaintiff desires to seek relief of mandatory
injunction for removal of encroachment, then firstly, he has to
establish the title over the property and it is burden on the
plaintiff to prove the title. After establishing the title by seeking
relief of declaration, then the plaintiff is entitled to relief of
decree of mandatory injunction with consequential relief of
permanent injunction. Otherwise, a mere suit for mandatory
injunction in the absence of relief of declaration where title is in
- 19 NC: 2026:KHC-D:440
RSA No. 1026 of 2007
HC-KAR
dispute,
the
suit
for
mere
mandatory
injunction
is
not
maintainable.
27.
Therefore, considering the above principles of law laid
down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court and this Court and
considering the above facts, the defendant has raised dispute
regarding the title of the plaintiff over the suit property on which
gobar gas plant is constructed. Also, this is discussed by the Trial
Court in its judgment, which is confirmed by the First Appellate
Court. When the Trial Court took a specific opinion that there is
dispute regarding title over the suit properties, then both the
Trial Court and the First Appellate Court ought to have dismissed
the suit, but granting decree of mandatory injunction in the
absence
relief
of
declaration
is
not
maintainable.
Hence,
substantial question of law is answered holding that both the
First Appellate Court and the Trial Court are not justified in
decreeing the suit for mandatory injunction in the absence of
relief of declaration. Thus, both the judgment and decree passed
by the Trial Court and the First Appellate Court are liable to be
set aside.
- 20 NC: 2026:KHC-D:440
RSA No. 1026 of 2007
HC-KAR
28.
However,
the
plaintiff
is
given
liberty
to
file
a
comprehensive suit for declaration to establish the title over the
suit schedule properties and also for other reliefs as deems fit by
the plaintiff.
29.
In the result, I proceed to pass the following:
ORDER
i. The Regular Second Appeal is allowed.
ii. The
judgment
and
decree
dated
22.01.2007
passed in R.A.No.308/1999 on the file of II
Additional Civil Judge (SR.DN.), Belagavi, and the
judgment and decree dated 31.08.1999 passed in
O.S.No.72/1992 on the file of Additional Civil
Judge (JR.DN.) and JMFC, Khanapur, are hereby
set aside.
iii. However, liberty is reserved to the plaintiff to file a
comprehensive suit for declaration for establishing
his title over the suit open space and for other
reliefs as deems fit by the plaintiff.
- 21 NC: 2026:KHC-D:440
RSA No. 1026 of 2007
HC-KAR
iv. No order as to costs.
Sd/(HANCHATE SANJEEVKUMAR)
JUDGE
PMP Para Nos.1 to 24
SRA Para Nos.25 to end
CT-AN
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 48
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review