Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
CRL.REV.P. NO. 23 OF 2023
1. Shri. Milanmoy Dewan,
S/O. Late Nripendra Lal Dewan,
Resident of C-53,
ONGC South Colony, South Badarghat,
P.O. ONGC,
Agartala, Pin-799014
......Petitioner(s)
Versus
1. Smt. Sharmistha Dewan (Ghosh),
W/o. Milanmoy Dewan,
C/o. Satyendra Nath Ghosh,
Resident of Krishnanagar Main Road,
P.O. Agartala, P.S. West Agartala,
Pin- 799001
…...Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. C.S. Sinha, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. P. Roy. Barman, Sr. Adv.
Mr. S. Bhattacharjee, Adv.
Date of Hearing &
Judgment and Order :
22.12.2023
Whether fit for
Reporting
NO
:
HON‟BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order(Oral)
This revision petition is filed under Section 397 read
with section 401 of the Code of the Criminal Procedure
(Cr.P.C.) read with Section 19 of the Family Courts Act, 1984
against the judgment passed by Learned Judge, Family
Court, Agartala, West Tripura in connection with case No.
Crl. Misc 647 of 2019.
02.
Brief facts leading to this revision petition are as
under:
The
respondent
Smt.
Sharmistha
Dewan(Ghosh)
as
petitioner filed one maintenance petition under Section 125
of Cr.P.C. against her husband i.e. the present petitioner,
Shri Milanmoy Dewan before the Learned Judge, Family
Court Agartala, West Tripura which was numbered as Crl.
Misc. 647 of 2019. The respondent (wife) in her maintenance
petition stated that her marriage was solemnized /registered
under Special Marriage Act 1954 on 17.10.2003 with the
present petitioner. While she married the petitioner husband,
she had a daughter from her past marriage who was 19
years old and before her marriage with the present petitioner
her earlier marriage was dissolved by a decree of divorce
granted
by
Learned
District
Judge,
West
Tripura
on
17.01.2001. The petitioner husband also had a daughter
from his first wife who died and after the death of his first
wife the petitioner husband married the present respondent
(wife). No child was begotten to their present marriage.
03.
The
respondent
(wife)
had
brought
several
allegations of cruelty against the present petitioner and it
was alleged by her that soon after the marriage they lived
together as husband and wife peacefully for a period of two
years and after that their mal-adjustment /troubles started.
According to the respondent wife, after her marriage with the
present petitioner she kept her daughter with her parents for
a period of three years and thereafter she brought her
daughter back to her matrimonial home with the consent of
the present petitioner husband. The present petitioner was
that time under ONGC as Asst. Engineer who later on
elevated to the post of Chief Engineer in ONGC Tripura Asset.
After that he went to Mumbai for off-shore duty and during
his off duty period for fourteen days he used to visit Tripura
time to time at Agartala to see the respondent wife and the
children at Agartala but the respondent wife never neglected
in taking care of her husband and his daughter. Her husband
was a Buddhist by religion and she was Hindu and the
present petitioner used to interfere with her religious practice
for which she used to get hurt and when the present
petitioner was posted in ONGC Tripura asset that time also
the petitioner husband attended his side duty and during the
absence of the petitioner husband, she used to take care of
her daughter and also the minor daughter of the petitioner
husband and the minor daughter of the petitioner husband
performed well in examination and she could get admission
to M.B.B.S course in TMC and by this time she had
completed her final semester of the course. The food habit of
the respondent wife and petitioner husband was different
and the petitioner husband was very addicted to dry fish and
pork and on the other hand, the respondent (wife) suffered
from IBS problem resulting which she could not take any dry
fish or pork but the petitioner husband used to insist her to
follow his food habits. He also did not allow her to cook some
dishes at her own taste and choice. It was the further case of
the respondent wife that if there was any difference of
opinion amongst them he was not ready to accept different
of opinion and very often on difference of opinion of any
domestic issue, the petitioner husband used to assault the
respondent wife frequently and for that she informed her
parents
and
near
relatives
about
the
assault
being
committed to her by the petitioner husband and on so many
occasions her parents and relatives talked with petitioner
husband and requested him not to cause any physical and
mental torture upon the respondent wife and in the month of
2016 a quarrel took place in between the daughter of the
respondent wife and the petitioner husband over an issue of
electric
extension
cord
to
which
the
respondent
wife
interfered to specify the situation but the petitioner husband
repeatedly slapped the respondent wife as a result of which
her spectacles were broken and she suffered black patch
over her nose and that time the daughter of the petitioner
husband Fortuna was at home and she being a doctor
examined Ritika and gave her First Aid and Fortuna informed
the matter to the brother of the respondent wife who was in
U.S.A, over telephone and on getting such information the
parents and close relatives of the respondent wife came to
her house and arranged the treatment of the respondent
wife. During last 3 years the petitioner husband did not
contribute
anything
towards
the
maintenance
of
the
respondent wife for which she had to maintain herself for
taking financial help from her father and in case of demand
the petitioner husband used to taunt and humiliate her
saying that to claim money from her brother and by this act
the respondent wife became a psychiatric patient and had to
consult Dr.Santanu Ghosh, Psychiatric, TMC and undergo
counseling session for the recovery. The respondent wife
further asserted that the petitioner husband did not allow her
to sit for TCS examination and also for taking chance for
getting job at Pramananda Vidyamandir and Holy Cross
School and also to attend coaching classes on the pretext
that it will affect the upbringing of his daughter. Thus, the
petitioner husband was not providing the minimum basic
provisions to her and thereafter she took a private job at
O.N.G.C, Montessori School from where she used to get Rs.
8000/- per month and from her meagre amount she had to
maintain her daughter Ritika. On 26.07.2019 the petitioner
husband raised hue and cry regarding the domestic help
when the respondent wife convinced the petitioner husband
that the domestic help did not commit any wrong but the
petitioner husband was not ready to hear the respondent
wife and thus, petitioner husband became furious and
directed a punch towards her face and the respondent wife
anyhow by her forearm saved her face but she suffered the
punch on her forearm. Again the petitioner husband tried to
gave a punch on her face and on that occasion the
respondent wife saved her face and thereafter the petitioner
husband
dragged
out
the
respondent
wife
from
her
matrimonial home and blocked the door from inside and
finding no option she had to take shelter in her parents’
house and again at 2 p.m she returned back to her home
and found the home under lock and key. She tried to contact
her husband i.e. the petitioner by ringing him thrice but the
petitioner husband did not receive her calls. The matter was
informed to Principal ONGC School and to her parents and on
the following day she had to lodge a complaint at Amtali P.S.
and also informed the matter to Tripura Commission for
Women and on 26.07.2019 the respondent wife attended
ONGC Dispensary for her treatment. The respondent wife
was asked to attend TMC and on the following day she
attended Dr.S. Ghosh, TMC and referred to Orthopedic
Department.
Thus,
according
to
respondent
wife,
the
petitioner husband deserted the respondent wife since
26.07.2019 and since then she had been living in her
parents’ house. It was the further case of the respondent
wife that the monthly salary of petitioner husband was Rs. 3
lakhs and he was getting monthly rent of 3BHK Flat in Rose
Valley Apartment, Lichubagan at the rate of Rs.22,000/- per
month and thus she claimed maintenance at the rate of Rs.1
lakh per month from her husband i.e. the present petitioner
of this revision petition. The present petitioner contested the
proceeding denying the grounds asserted by the respondent
wife, rather he took the plea that the respondent wife
suppressed the fact of having a child with her earlier
husband before marrying the present petitioner and after 3
years of marriage when the present petitioner husband was
aware of the fact, that time the respondent wife had brought
her child to live with her and insisted him to adopt her legally
and when he denied her proposal, the respondent wife, that
time left him voluntarily and filed maintenance case under
Section 125 of Cr.P.C.
04.
Before the Learned Court below, both the parties
have adduced their evidences and after hearing both the
sides the Learned Judge, Family Court passed an order on
31.01.2023 directing the present petitioner husband to pay
monthly maintenance allowance at the rate of Rs. 50,000/per month to the respondent wife w.e.f 01.01.2023, which is
presently under challenge before this Court.
05.
In course of hearing Learned Counsel, Mr. C.S.
Sinha, appearing on behalf of the petitioner husband
submitted that Learned Court below in deciding the case did
not consider the fact raised by the husband petitioner that he
could know the existence of one daughter of the respondent
wife of her earlier marriage after 3 years and thus, the
respondent wife suppressing the said fact cheated him and
applied
fraud
upon
him.
He
also
submitted
that
the
respondent wife voluntarily left her matrimonial home as
such she was not entitled to get any maintenance but the
Learned Court below did not consider the said fact. Learned
Counsel further drawn the attention of the Court referring
the final order of the Learned Court below, that there is no
observation/ findings as to how Learned Court determined
the quantum of maintenance and in absence of any proper
findings/ observation regarding quantum of maintenance to
be awarded, there is no scope to sustain that order and
urged before the Court to set aside the order passed by
Learned Court below. He also referred some citations which
would be discussed in due course.
06.
Roy.
On the contrary, Learned Senior Counsel, Mr. P.
Barman,
assisted
by
Mr.
Samarjit
Bhattacharjee
submitted that the Learned Court below rightly passed the
final order fixing maintenance at the rate of Rs. 50,000/- per
month. He also submitted that the grounds as projected in
the revision petition are vague and cannot be considered
because according to Learned Senior Counsel if for argument
sake the husband petitioner could know the existence of a
daughter of respondent wife after 3 years of marriage in that
case he could challenge that marriage. But since from the
year 2003 to 2019, no legal step was taken on his part
challenging the marriage. So, this part cannot be legally
accepted. Furthermore, the petitioner husband is holding a
good post in O.N.G.C and he is drawing salary more than Rs.
3 lakhs per month. So, considering the huge income of the
petitioner husband Rs. 1 lakh was supposed to be awarded in
his favour. But the Learned Court below only awarded Rs.
50,000/- and urged before this Court to enhance the
quantum of maintenance awarded by the Learned Trial Court
dismissing the revision petition. Learned Senior Counsel
further referred few citations and referring those citations he
tried to convince the Court as to why this present revision
petition is not maintainable. I have heard detailed arguments
of Learned Counsels of both the parties and gone through
the record of the Learned Court below very carefully.
07.
Admittedly, at the time of deciding the case
Learned Court below determined the following points for
decision:
(i) Whether the petitioner is the legally married wife of
the OP?
(ii) Whether the petitioner has left her matrimonial
home unreasonably and voluntarily?
(iii) Whether the OP-husband having sufficient means
neglects or refuses to maintain the petitioner?
(iv) Whether the petitioner is entitled to maintenance
from the OP and if so, to what extent?
08.
Further it also appears that to substantiate the
petition, the respondent wife has adduced 3 witnesses. On
the other side, the petitioner husband also has adduced 4
witnesses in support of his defence.
09.
It is also on record that during continuation of the
proceeding before the Learned Court below, the respondent
wife
submitted
one
application
for
granting
interim
maintenance till disposal of the original proceeding and by
order dated 07.02.2020 the then Learned Family Judge
rejected the petition for granting interim maintenance.
Challenging that order, the respondent wife preferred a
revision petition before the High Court and this Court by
judgment dated 17.02.2021 was pleased to set aside the
order dated 07.02.2020 passed by the Learned Family Judge
in
Crl.
Misc.
No.
of
and
awarded
interim
maintenance at the rate of Rs. 50,000/- per month w.e.f.
07.02.2020 till disposal of the original proceeding in favour
of respondent wife. Challenging that order the present
petitioner
husband
preferred
SLP
before
the
Hon’ble
Supreme Court and the Hon’ble Supreme Court by order
dated 28.04.2021 in Special Leave to Appeal (Crl.) No.
3219/2021 was pleased to dismiss that petition upholding
the order of this Court and directed the Learned Trial Court
to refer the matter to the mediation in case any petition is
filed. But finally no settlement could take place by way of
mediation.
10.
As referred by Learned Counsel, Mr. C.S. Sinha,
reported in AIR 2003 Mad 212, I (2003) DMC 799,
(2003) I MLJ 752 in Manokaran @ Ramamoorthy vs. M.
Devaki dated 21.02.2003, Hon’ble the Supreme Court in
Para No.5 has been observed as under:
“5. There is no dispute that the petition has
been filed by the respondent/wife claiming
maintenance pendente lite and expenses of
the proceedings under S. 24 of the Hindu
Marriage Act. Section 24 reads thus:
"24. Maintenance pendente lite and
expenses of proceedings.- Where in any
proceedings under this Act it appears to
the court that either the wife or the
husband, as the case may be, has no
independent income sufficient for her or
his support and the necessary expenses
of the proceeding, it may, on the
application of the wife or the husband,
order the respondent to pay to the
petitioner
the
expenses
of
the
proceeding, and monthly during the
proceeding such sum as, having regard
to the petitioner's own income and the
income of the respondent, it may seem
to the Court to be reasonable."
The above provision would show that for
grant of maintenance pendente lite, the party
should not have sufficient independent
income for her/his support. In other words, if
it is found that the applicant has found
sufficient income for his/her support, no
amount can be allowed as maintenance
pendente lite as per Section 24 of the Act.
While construing the very same provision in
similar
circumstance,
A.S.
Venkatachamoorthy, J. in Kumaresan v.
Aswathi [(2002) 2 Mad LJ 760 has arrived at a
similar conclusion. Now I shall consider
whether
the
respondent/wife
has
any
independent income which is sufficient for her
survival and for the proceedings. In para 10
of the counter statement filed by the wife in
O.P. No. 1310/2000, she herself admitted
that, .....Now the respondent (wife) had got
her present job in private body and running
her life with the salary and staying with her
brother...". The above statement shows that
she is employed in a private concern, getting
salary and staying with her brother. In the
application for interim maintenance, the
husband has filed a counter affidavit wherein
he has specifically stated that his wife is
drawing a salary of Rs.4,500/- from a private
concern. In para 5 of the counter affidavit it is
stated that,
"5. The respondent denies all the
allegations in para 5 and put the
petitioner to strict proof of the same. The
averment about I am literally suffering
without financial assistants is put to
strict proof since this petitioner is
working in the organization Kumari
Neruvanam at No. 40, Venkat Narayanan
Road, T. Nagar, Chennai 600 017, and
drawing a salary of Rs.4500/- she also
disclosed this before the All Women
Police Station, Thousand Lights, and this
petitioner also admitted in her counter
statement that she is working in private
and running her life. But contradictory to
her statement in counter statement now
this petitioner came forward with a plea
that she is without financial assistance.
This petitioner is working as typist and
main organizer for a programme in
Neingalum
Pachalar
Agalam
a
programme telecaste in RAJ TV during
Sunday 8.00 A.M, from her company
Kumari Neruvanam. The averment about
that this respondent is owner of the
"Venkataswari
Turning
Works"
at
Muthumariamman Koil Street, Anna
Nagar, Chennai-600 040 is put to strict
proof since this respondent is not the
owner of the said company and A.
Loganathan is the owner of the said
Turning works and this respondent is
working in Senthil Auto Garage at Annai
Sathya
Nagar,
Anna
Nagar
(East)
Chennai-600 102, and drawing a salary
of Rs.2000/- and this respondent need
not to give any monetary assistance to
the petitioner for her claim."
The above averment shows that the petitioner
herein/husband is working in Senthil Auto
Garage, Annai Sathya Nagar, Chennai-102 and
drawing a salary of Rs.2000/- per month.
Likewise, it is also seen that the respondent
herein/wife is working in Raj T.V and drawing
a salary of Rs.4,500/-. Though the said aspect
has not been substantiated, I have already
referred to the admission of the respondent
herein in her counter statement filed in the
main O.P.1310/2000 wherein she admitted
that she secured a private job and is getting
salary and staying with her brother. On the
other hand, it is established particularly from
Ex. R-1, the petitioner herein is getting only
Rs.70/- per day or Rs.2000/- per month by
working in Senthil Auto Garage. I have
already referred to the language used in
Section 24 which makes it clear that for grant
of maintenance pendente lite the party should
not have sufficient independent income for
her support. In the light of the materials
available, particularly the admitted case of
the respondent/wife, she is employed in a
private Satelite T.V. and earning for her
livelihood staying with her brother, it cannot
be construed that she is not having sufficient
independent income. The Family Court lost its
sight to consider the above material aspect.”
Referring the said citation, Learned Counsel for
the petitioner husband submitted that Learned Trial Court
below at the time of coming to the conclusion did not give
any reasonable finding as to how the Learned Court decided
to fix Rs. 50,000/- per month as maintenance allowance for
which the judgment is liable to be interfered with. He also
submitted that no specific issue/point was determined by the
Learned Trial Court regarding suppression of the fact of
having one girl daughter of the respondent wife at the time
of her marriage with the present petitioner and just on the
basis of mere conjecture and surmise, delivered the final
order/judgment. He further submitted that the respondent
wife is drawing Rs. 10,000/- per month from her place of
employment which has now increased to Rs. 15,000/although there is no such evidence on record like that but
the Learned Court below did not consider the said fact and
awarded exorbitant amount which has caused prejudice to
the petitioner husband.
11.
Learned Counsel further referred another citation
and submitted that in Sanjay Sudhakar Bhosale vs.
Khristina, reported in (2008) 3 AIR Bom R 325, w/o
Sanjay Bhosale in Bombay High Court dated 08.04.2008 in
Para Nos. 9, 10, 11, 12 and 13 observed as under:
“9. There is solitary and interested version of
PW-Khristina in support of her application for
separate maintenance allowance. Her version
gives inconsistent account about so-called
unlawful demand. She deviated from her
pleadings. The findings of the learned
Magistrate are based on due appreciation of
the evidence. The further development may
be noticed. The petitioner filed an application
for restitution of conjugal rights in the Family
Court at Pune. His application (P.A. No. 500 of
2002) is allowed by the Family Court on 21st
July 2003. So far, the respondent (wife) has
not challenged the Judgment of the Family
Court. The Family Court raised a specific issue
as follows:
“Whether the petitioner proves that the
respondent without any reasonable
excuse has withdrawn from the society?”
10. The learned Judge of the Family Court
recorded an affirmative finding on the said
issue. It is manifest, therefore, that not only
the
learned
Judicial
Magistrate,
on
appreciation of the evidence tendered by the
spouses, came to the conclusion that she left
his house, probably under burden of the
domestic chores, but the civil Court also found
that she is guilty of deserting him without any
reasonable excuse.
11. The impugned Judgment reveals that the
learned
Sessions
Judge
undertook
reassessment of the entire evidence though
he was supposed to exercise the revisional
jurisdiction. The, learned Sessions Judge did
not find any particular fault in the process of
appreciation of evidence, as done by the
learned Magistrate. The relevant observations
of the learned Sessions Judge may be
reproduced as follows:
“14.
On
carefully
scrutinising
the
evidence of the applicant and opponent it
will reveal that the matrimonial life of
the applicant was not smoothly going on
due to some quarrel and ultimately, it
was resulted into leaving the house of
opponent, by the applicant. Observations
made by the lower Court that the
applicant had stayed for short period in
the house of the opponent and therefore,
there is no possibility of ill-treatment,
does not appear to be proper and legal in
the circumstances of the case. When the
applicant has positively stated that she
was subjected to ill-treatment not only
that but she has lodged complaint in
Yerwada Police Station, this will primafacie give rise that she was ill-treated
and, therefore, she has left the house of
the opponent. Provisions of Section 125
of Code of Criminal Procedure need not
require that there must be a strict proof
of cruelty.
12. The above observations of the learned
Sessions Judge would indicate that he
accepted version of the wife only because she
gave positive statement that she was
subjected to ill-treatment and had lodged the
complaint at Yerwada Police Station. As
stated before, there is no scintilla of evidence
to show that really she had lodged a
complaint about the matrimonial cruelty. Nor
her so-called positive statement finds support
from her pleadings. In this view of the matter,
it is difficult to countenance the findings of
the learned Sessions Judge. Her mere
statement could not have been taken as
gospel truth as regards neglect and refusal of
the husband to maintain her. It is overlooked
by the learned Sessions Judge that within a
short span of the marriage, the wife left his
company and no notice was given within a
reasonable time by her, seeking restitution of
the conjugal rights.
13. The Apex Court, in “Deb Narayan Haider v.
Smt. Anushree Haider”, (2003) 3 B Cr C 286 :
((2003) 11 SCC 303 : AIR 2003 SC 3174). held
that the appellate Court or revisional Court
while setting aside findings recorded by Court
below must notice those findings and where
the findings are of facts, evidence on record
must be discussed, which should justify
reversal of findings recorded by the Court
below. The Apex Court held that when the
maintenance application of the wife was
rejected by the learned Magistrate, holding
that she had on her own left the matrimonial
home, the High Court was not justified in
reversing such findings recorded by the trial
Court and to grant maintenance to the wife.”
Referring the above, Learned Counsel for the
petitioner submitted that mere statement of the respondent
wife could not have been taken as a gospel truth as regards
neglect and refusal of the husband petitioner to maintain her
which was over looked by the Learned Trial Court. Finally,
Learned Counsel has drawn the attention of this Court to
allow the revision petition and to set aside the order of the
Learned Trial Court and to pass appropriate order.
12.
On the contrary, Learned Senior Counsel Mr. P.
Roy Barman, assisted by Mr. S. Bhattacharjee in course of
hearing referred few citations one by one and urged before
the Court to consider the principles of the said citations in
deciding this present revision petition.
13.
In Amit Kapoor vs Ramesh Chander and
Another in Criminal Appeal No. 1407 of 2012 dated
13.09.2012 reported in (2012) 9 SCC 460 in Para No. 12,
Hon’ble Supreme Court observed as under:
“12. Section 397 of the Code vests the court
with the power to call for and examine the
records of an inferior court for the purposes
of satisfying itself as to the legality and
regularity of any proceedings or order made
in a case. The object of this provision is to set
right a patent defect or an error of jurisdiction
or law. There has to be a well-founded error
and it may not be appropriate for the court to
scrutinise the orders, which upon the face of
it bears a token of careful consideration and
appear to be in accordance with law. If one
looks into the various judgments of this Court,
it emerges that the revisional jurisdiction can
be invoked where the decisions under
challenge are grossly erroneous, there is no
compliance with the provisions of law, the
finding recorded is based on no evidence,
material evidence is ignored or judicial
discretion
is
exercised
arbitrarily
or
perversely. These are not exhaustive classes,
but are merely indicative. Each case would
have to be determined on its own merits.”
Referring the same, Learned Counsel submitted
that under Section 397 of Cr.P.C. the power of the Court is
very limited. The Court is to satisfy itself as to the legality,
irregularity and impropriety of any proceeding or order of the
Court below. But in the present case from the order of the
Learned Trial Court the petitioner husband could not satisfy
as to how the order passed was erroneous.
14.
In the State of Kerala vs. Puttumana Illath
Jathavedan Namboodiri in Criminal Appeal No. 554 of
1995 dated 11.02.1999 reported in (1999) 2 SSC 452 in
Para No. 5, Hon’ble the Supreme Court observed as under:
“5.Having examined the impugned Judgment
of the High Court and bearing in mind the
contentions raised by the learned counsel for
the parties, we have no hesitation to come to
the conclusion that in the case in hand, the
High Court has exceeded its revisional
jurisdiction. In Its revisional jurisdiction, the
High Court can call for and examine the
record of any proceedings for the purpose of
satisfying itself as to the correctness, legality
or propriety of any finding, sentence or order.
In other words, the jurisdiction is one of
Supervisory Jurisdiction exercised by the High
Court for correcting miscarriage of justice.
But the said revisional power cannot be
equated with the power of an Appellate Court
nor can it be treated even as a second
Appellate Jurisdiction. Ordinarily, therefore, it
would not be appropriate for the High Court to
re-appreciate the evidence and come to its
own conclusion on the same when the
evidence has already been appreciated by the
Magistrate as well as the Sessions Judge in
appeal, unless any glaring feature is brought
to the notice of the High Court which would
otherwise tentamount to gross miscarriage of
justice.
On
scrutinizing
the
impugned
Judgment of the High Court from the
aforesaid stand point, we have no hesitation
to come to the conclusion that the High Court
exceeded its jurisdiction in interfering with
the conviction of the respondent by reappreciating the oral evidence. The High Court
also committed further error in not examining
several items of evidence relied upon by the
Additional Sessions Judge, while confirming
the conviction of the respondent. In this view
of the matter, the impugned Judgment of the
High Court is wholly unsustainable in law and
we, accordingly set aside the same. The
conviction and sentence of the respondent as
passed by the Magistrate and affirmed by the
Additional Sessions Judge in appeal is
confirmed. This appeal is allowed. Bail bonds
furnished stand cancelled. The respondent
must surrender to serve the sentence.”
Referring
the
same,
Learned
Senior
Counsel
further drawn the attention of this Court that in revisional
jurisdiction High Court can call for and examine the record of
any proceeding for the purpose of satisfying itself as to the
correctness, legality or propriety of any finding, sentence or
order and the jurisdiction of the High Court is supervisory
jurisdiction only for correcting miscarriage of justice and said
revisional power cannot be equated with the power of an
appellate Court nor it can be treated as a second appellate
jurisdiction. And also submitted that it would not be
appropriate for the High Court to re-appreciate the evidence
and come to its own conclusion when the evidence has
already been appreciated by the Learned Trial Court, unless
any glaring feature is brought to the notice of the High Court
which would otherwise tantamount to gross miscarriage of
justice.
15.
In Pyla Mutyalamma Alias Satyavathi vs. Pyla
Suri Demudu and Another, in Criminal Appeal No. 219 of
2007 dated 09.08.2011 reported in (2011) 12 SCC 189,
Hon’ble the Supreme Court in Para No. 16 is further
observed:
"16. In a revision against the maintenance
order passed in proceedings under Section
125 Cr.P.C., the Revisional Court has no
power to re-assess evidence and substitute its
own findings. Under revisional jurisdiction,
the questions whether the applicant is a
married
wife,
the
children
are
legitimate/illegitimate, being pre-eminently
questions of fact, cannot be reopened and the
Revisional Court cannot substitute its own
views. The High Court, therefore, is not
required in revision to interfere with the
positive finding in favour of the marriage and
patronage of a child. But where finding is a
negative one, the High Court would entertain
the revision, re-evaluate the evidence and
come to a conclusion whether the findings or
conclusions reached by the Magistrate are
legally sustainable or not as negative finding
has evil consequences on the life of both child
and the woman. This was the view expressed
by the Supreme Court in Santosh v. Naresh
Pal (1998) 8 SCC 447, as also in Pravati Rani
Sahoo v. Bishnupada Sahoo. Thus, the ratio
decidendi which emerges out of a catena of
authorities on the efficacy and value of the
order passed by the Magistrate while
determining maintenance under Section 125
Cr.P.C. is that it should not be disturbed while
exercising revisional jurisdiction.”
Referring the same, Learned Senior Counsel also
drawn the attention of this Court that revisional Court has no
power to re-assess evidence and substitute its own findings.
The High Court is therefore not required in revision to
interfere with the positive findings. But where the finding is a
negative one, the High Court would entertain the revision,
re-evaluate the evidence and come to a conclusion whether
the findings or conclusion reached are legally sustainable or
not. Here in the case at hand, according to Learned Senior
Counsel, Learned Trial Court after elaborate discussions
came to a positive finding. So, at this stage there is no scope
to interfere to the findings of Learned Trial Court.
16.
In Badshah vs. Urmila Badshah Godse and
Another in Criminal Miscellaneous Petition No. 19530 of
2013 dated 18.10.2013 reported in (2014) 1 SCC 188,
Hon’ble the Supreme Court further observed in Para Nos. 14
and 20 observed as follows:
“14. Of late, in this very direction, it is
emphasized that the courts have to adopt
different
approaches
in
“social
justice
adjudication”, which is also known as “social
context adjudication” as mere “adversarial
approach” may not be very appropriate. There
are number of social justice legislations giving
special protection and benefits to vulnerable
groups in the society. Prof. Madhava Menon
describes it eloquently:
“It is, therefore, respectfully submitted
that „social context judging‟ is essentially
the application of equality jurisprudence
as evolved by Parliament and the
Supreme Court in myriad situations
presented before courts where unequal
parties
are
pitted
in
adversarial
proceedings and where courts are called
upon to dispense equal justice. Apart
from the social- economic inequalities
accentuating the disabilities of the poor
in an unequal fight, the adversarial
process
itself
operates
to
the
disadvantage of the weaker party. In
such a situation, the judge has to be not
only sensitive to the inequalities of
parties involved but also positively
inclined to the weaker party if the
imbalance
were
not
to
result
in
miscarriage of justice. This result is
achieved by what we call social context
judging or social justice adjudication.”
20. Thus, while interpreting a statute the
court may not only take into consideration the
purpose for which the statute was enacted,
but also the mischief it seeks to suppress. It
is this mischief rule, first propounded in
Heydon Case (1584) 3 Co Rep 7a which
became the historical source of purposive
interpretation. The court would also invoke
the legal maxim of construction ut res magis
valeat quam pereat, in such cases i.e. where
alternative constructions are possible the
court must give effect to that which will be
responsible for the smooth working of the
system for which the statute has been
enacted rather than one which will put a road
block in its way. If the choice is between two
interpretations, the narrower of which would
fail to achieve the manifest purpose of the
legislation should be avoided. We should
avoid a construction which would reduce the
legislation to futility and should accept the
bolder construction based on the view that
Parliament would legislate only for the
purpose of bringing about an effective result.
If this interpretation is not accepted, it would
amount to giving a premium to the husband
for defrauding the wife. Therefore, at least for
the purpose of claiming maintenance under
Section 125 Cr.P.C., such a woman is to be
treated as the legally wedded wife.”
Referring the aforesaid citation, Learned Counsel
Mr. S. Bhattacharjee again has drawn the attention of this
Court that considering the nature of the present proceeding
being social justice adjudication, the Court should take
lenient view in settling the case in favour of the respondent
wife.
17.
In Shamima Farooqui vs. Shahid Khan in
Criminal Appeals Nos. 564-65 of 2015 dated 06.04.2015
reported in (2015) 5 SCC 705, Hon’ble the Supreme Court
in Para Nos. 16, 17 and 20 observed as under:
“16. Grant of maintenance to wife has been
perceived as a measure of social justice by
this Court. In Chaturbhuj v. Sita Bai (2008) 2
SCC 316, it has been ruled that (SCC p.320,
para 6):"6. … Section 125 CrPC is a measure of
social justice and is specially enacted to
protect women and children and as
noted by this Court in Capt. Ramesh
Chander Kaushal v. Veena Kaushal
(1978) 4 SCC 70 falls within the
constitutional sweep of Article 15(3)
reinforced
by
Article
of
the
Constitution of India. It is meant to
achieve a social purpose. The object is to
prevent vagrancy and destitution. It
provides a speedy remedy for the supply
of food, clothing and shelter to the
deserted wife. It gives effect to
fundamental rights and natural duties of
a man to maintain his wife, children and
parents when they are unable to
maintain themselves. The aforesaid
position was highlighted in Savitaben
Somabhai Bhatiya v. State of Gujarat
(2005) 3 SCC 636."
17. This being the position in law, it is the
obligation of the husband to maintain his
wife. He cannot be permitted to plead that he
is unable to maintain the wife due to financial
constraints as long as he is capable of
earning.
20. In the instant case, as is seen, the High
Court has reduced the amount of maintenance
from Rs.4,000 to Rs.2,000. As is manifest, the
High Court has become oblivious of the fact
that she has to stay on her own. Needless to
say, the order of the learned Family Judge is
not manifestly perverse. There is nothing
perceptible which would show that order is a
sanctuary of errors. In fact, when the order is
based on proper appreciation of evidence on
record, no Revisional Court should have
interfered with the reason on the base that it
would have arrived at a different or another
conclusion. When substantial justice has been
done, there was no reason to interfere. There
may be a shelter over her head in the parental
house, but other real expenses cannot be
ignored. Solely because the husband had
retired, there was no justification to reduce
the maintenance by 50%. It is not a huge
fortune that was showered on the wife that it
deserved reduction. It only reflects the nonapplication of mind and, therefore, we are
unable to sustain the said order.”
Referring the above, Learned Senior Counsel
submitted that in a proceeding under Section 125 of Cr.P.C.
it is the obligation of the husband to maintain his wife and
where substantial justice has been done there is no reason to
interfere the order of the Learned Trial Court below.
18.
Lastly, Learned Senior Counsel referred another
judgment
Kalyan
Dey
Chowdhury
vs.
Rita
Dey
Chowdhury Nee Nandy in Civil Appeal No. 5369 of 2017
dated 19.04.2017 reported in (2017) 14 SCC 200. In Para
No. 15 of the said judgment Hon’ble the Supreme Court
observed that 25% of the husband’s net salary would be just
and proper to be awarded as maintenance to the respondent
wife.
“15. The review petition under Order 47 Rule
1 CPC came to be filed by the respondent-wife
pursuant to the liberty granted by this Court
when the earlier order dated 02.02.2015 Rita
Dey Chaudhury v. Kalyan Dey Chowdhury,
2015 SCC OnLine Cal 10447 awarding a
maintenance
of
Rs.16,000/to
the
respondent-wife as well as to her minor son
was under challenge before this Court. As
pointed out by the High Court, in February
2015, the appellant- husband was getting a
net salary of Rs.63,842/- after deduction of
Rs.24,000/on
account
of
GPF
and
Rs.12,000/- towards income-tax. In February,
2016, the net salary of the appellant is stated
to be Rs.95,527/-. Following Kulbhushan
Kumar v. Raj Kumari (1970) 3 SCC 129, in this
case, it was held that 25% of the husband‟s
net salary would be just and proper to be
awarded as maintenance to the respondentwife. The amount of permanent alimony
awarded to the wife must be befitting the
status of the parties and the capacity of the
spouse to pay maintenance. Maintenance is
always dependant on the factual situation of
the case and the court would be justified in
moulding the claim for maintenance passed
on various factors. Since in February, 2016,
the net salary of the husband was Rs.
95,000/- per month, the High Court was
justified in enhancing the maintenance
amount. However, since the appellant has
also got married second time and has a child
from the second marriage, in the interest of
justice, we think it proper to reduce the
amount of maintenance of Rs.23,000/- to
Rs.20,000/- per month as maintenance to the
respondent-wife and son.”
Referring the aforesaid citation Learned Counsel,
Mr. S. Bhattacharjee again drawn the attention of this Court
that the petitioner husband before the Learned Court could
not adduce any contrary evidence on record that his salary
was less than Rs.3 lakhs per month. So, considering the
entire evidence on record Learned Court below awarded
maintenance in favour of the respondent wife at the rate of
Rs. 50,000/- per month which was reasonable and justified
commensurate with the income of the petitioner husband
and more so, in awarding maintenance, the Court should
also see that considering the status of the wife befitting
amount of maintenance allowance to be granted in her
favour for her proper livelihood which the Learned Court
below
considered
at
the
time
of
delivering
the
final
judgment.
19.
I have heard submissions of both the sides and
also perused the aforesaid citations and the record of the
Learned Court below. Here in the case at hand there is no
dispute on record in respect of the marriage of the petitioner
husband with the respondent wife under Special Marriage
Act. It is also on record that both the parties had their
children of their earlier marriage. Their marriage took place
in the year 2003. The maintenance case was filed in the year
2019. So, it is apparent on record that since from the year
2003 to 2019 there were no other cases amongst the
parties.
As
already
stated
Learned
Court
below
has
determined four points to decide the proceeding. As I have
already stated the marriage has not been disputed by the
petitioner husband of this case. The petitioner husband in
this petition confined his arguments only on two points.
Firstly,
their
argument
was
that
no
issue/point
was
determined by the Learned Court below regarding the
suppression of fact of having daughter of the respondent
wife to the petitioner husband at the time of marriage and
secondly, at the time of fixation of monthly maintenance
allowance of Rs. 50,000/-, no specific observation/ finding
was made by the Learned Court below. Learned Court below
in disposing of the case has discussed the evidence on record
of both the sides in detail and came to the conclusion of this
proceeding. There is no evidence on record from the side of
petitioner husband that he had ever taken any step against
his wife for suppression of the fact of marriage by his wife
save and except in his written objection. From the evidence
on record it appears to me that their existed some
matrimonial discord amongst the parties on some issues and
ultimately, the respondent wife had to leave her matrimonial
home and started residing in the residence of her parents. It
is also on record that the petitioner husband being the lawful
husband of the respondent wife refused/neglected to provide
maintenance to the respondent wife. It is further on record
that the monthly income of the petitioner husband is more
than Rs. 3 lakhs. It is also the admitted position that the
respondent wife is earning Rs. 10,000/- per month from her
school. But this amount is not sufficient to maintain her
livelihood. On the other side, the petitioner husband is under
legal obligation to provide food, shelter etc. to his wife. The
petitioner husband in course of cross-examination of the
witnesses of the respondent wife could not make any
cloud/doubt to the case of the respondent wife regarding
refusal to provide maintenance by the petitioner husband to
his wife. As observed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court as
discussed there is very least scope on the part of the
revisional Court to re-assess the evidence on record on the
basis of which the judgment was delivered and after going
through the evidence on record it appears that the Learned
Trial Court after considering everything and after elaborate
discussions of the evidence of both the parties came to the
conclusion of this proceeding. The citations as referred by
Learned Counsel for the respondent wife are very much
relevant for just decision of this case and in deciding this
case I have taken note of the principles of the aforesaid
citations. Learned Counsel for the petitioner in course of
hearing save and except raising two points could not raise
any other issue/points to interfere the proceedings of the
Learned Court below and those points as raised by Learned
Counsel are not relevant for the decision of this present
petition
as
those
are
already
been
adjudicated.
And
furthermore, there is also no cogent evidence on record from
the side of petitioner husband that he came to know the fact
of existence of the daughter of the respondent wife after 3
years of marriage. Rather it appears that, prior to his
marriage he had full knowledge about the daughter of his
wife from her first marriage who came to his residence after
3 years of his marriage with the respondent wife from the
residence of her grandfather. So, I cannot agree with the
submission of the Learned Counsel for the petitioner made in
course of hearing of arguments of this case.
20.
Thus, it appears to me that the Learned Court
below after taking into consideration of all aspects has rightly
and reasonably allowed maintenance allowance at the rate of
50,000/- per month in favour of the present respondent wife
which does not need any interference at this stage by this
Court.
21.
hereby
In the result, the revision petition fails and is
dismissed
on
contest.
The
judgment
dated
31.01.2023 passed in connection with case No. Criminal
Misc. 647 of 2019 by Learned Judge, Family Court, Agartala,
West Tripura is hereby affirmed.
No costs.
22.
A copy of this order/judgment be communicated
to the Learned Court below along with LCR.
JUDGE
signed by
MOUMITA Digitally
MOUMITA DATTA
Date: 2023.12.22
DATTA
17:48:35 +05'30'
Purnita
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review