Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
RFA NO.100116/2019
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA, AT DHARWAD
DATED THIS THE 14TH DAY OF JANUARY, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR JUSTICE MOHAMMAD NAWAZ
AND
THE HON'BLE MRS JUSTICE GEETHA K.B.
REGULAR FIRST APPEAL NO.100116 OF 2019 (PAR/POS)
BETWEEN
1. SHRI MALLIKARJUN
S/O. REVANASIDDAPPA NAINEGALI,
AGE: 59 YEARS,
OCC: ASSISTANT EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,
BAGALKOT TOWN DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY,
R/O. R.S.NO.128D, PLOT NO.2,
VEDANT NILAY, ROAD NO.16,
VIDYAGIRI, BAGALKOT-587 102.
2. SMT. SAVITA
W/O. MALLILARJUN NAINEGALI,
AGE: 55 YEARS,
OCC: HOUSEHOLD WORK,
C/O. MALLIKARJUN
S/O. REVANASIDDAPPA NAINEGALI,
R/O. PLOT NO.@-12,
SECTOR NO.55,
ROAD NO.16, VIDYAGIRI,
BAGALKOT-587 102.
...APPELLANTS
(BY SRI. SHIVARAJ S. BALLOLI, ADVOCATE)
RFA NO.100116/2019
AND
SHRI SOMALINGAPPA
S/O. REVANASIDDAPPA NAINEGALI,
AGE: 65 YEARS,
OCC: RETIRED PENSIONER,
R/O. PLOT NO.22/2, RS NO.128D,
ROAD NO.16, VIDYAGIRI,
BAGALKOT-587 102.
…RESPONDENT
(BY SRI. S.B. HEBBALLI, ADVOCATE)
THIS REGULAR FIRST APPEAL IS FILED UNDER ORDER 41
RULE 1 READ WITH SECTION 96 OF CPC., PRAYING TO SET
ASIDE THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED 12/02/2019 PASSED
IN O.S.NO.92/2014 ON THE FILE OF THE I ADDITIONAL SENIOR
CIVIL
JUDGE
AND
JUDICIAL
MAGISTRATE
FIRST
CLASS,
BAGALKOT BY ALLWOING THE TOP NOTED APPEAL TO MEET THE
ENDS OF JUSTICE AND EQUITY.
THIS APPEAL HAVING BEEN HEARD AND RESERVED FOR
JUDGMENT
ON
05.01.2026
AND
COMING
ON
FOR
PRONOUNCEMENT OF JUDGMENT THIS DAY, DELIVERED THE
FOLLOWING:
RFA NO.100116/2019
CAV JUDGMENT
(PER: THE HON'BLE MRS JUSTICE GEETHA K.B.)
Appellants-defendants have filed this appeal under
Order XLI Rule 1 R/W Section 96 of CPC, praying for setting
aside the judgment and decree dated 12.02.2019 passed in
O.S.No.92/2014 on the file of I Additional Senior Civil Judge
and JMFC., Bagalkot and to dismiss the suit.
2.
Parties would be referred with their ranks, as
they were before trial Court for the sake of convenience and
clarity.
3.
Plaintiff has filed the suit before trial Court,
praying for partition and separate possession of his half
share in suit schedule property situated at Vidyagiri,
Bagalkot bearing R.S.No.128D of Murnal, old Plot No.22,
new plot No.22/1 & 22/2 Measuring 12x19 meters by metes
and bounds; for mesne profits; for Court costs and for such
other reliefs.
4.
The case of plaintiff before the trial Court in
nutshell is that suit schedule property shown in two
RFA NO.100116/2019
different sub-divisions was formally described as Plot No.22.
The suit schedule property belonged to one Jagannath
Karabassaya Balulamath and Parvati Mallinath Balulamath;
plaintiff and defendant No.1 have jointly purchased suit
schedule property from them under registered sale deed
dated 25.01.2001, for a sum of Rs.1,29,000/-. Both plaintiff
and defendant No.1 have paid equally for purchase of this
property jointly in their names. Plaintiff and defendant No.1
are brothers and by virtue of sale deed, they became
owners of entire suit schedule property and their names are
entered in the Record of Rights as joint owners by
M.E.No.9288. Thereafter, they have given application to
Municipal Counsel, Bagalkot for permission to construct
buildings in the entire property and a map was prepared
showing two tenements in the said plot. The said application
was considered. Plaintiff and defendant No.1 with an
intention that in future, they can divide the property and
each would be allotted with half share, have constructed
two tenements and the construction cost has been jointly
contributed by both plaintiff and defendant. They have paid
RFA NO.100116/2019
taxes jointly. Even, the self-declaration assessment form is
filed jointly by both plaintiff and defendant and taxes were
also paid. For convenience, plaintiff and defendant began to
reside in separate constructed buildings. But, they have not
been separated and no partition has taken place between
plaintiff and defendant No.1. About one year prior to filing
of the suit, defendant No.1 with malafide intention to cause
loss and harassment to plaintiff has filed O.S. No.246/2013
on the file of Civil Judge, Bagalkot for partition of property
bearing No.47 situated at Gaddanakeri. It is defended by
the plaintiff who is defendant No.1 in said suit. Said suit is
still pending. When suit summons was issued to the present
plaintiff, the present defendant No.1 started behaving
differently with ill-will against plaintiff and then plaintiff
doubted that some false entries in Record of Rights might
have entered. 2-3 months prior to filing of the suit,
defendant No.1 represented that already he got effected
separate names for properties constructed in the suit plot
and has succeeded in getting the said entries. Suspecting
the conduct of defendant No.1, plaintiff has made enquiry
RFA NO.100116/2019
and obtained certified copies and then came to know that
ME No.1462 is entered in Record of Rights, got entered the
name of defendant No.1 to Plot No.22/1 and name of
plaintiff to Plot No.22/2; defendant No.1 did so without the
knowledge and consent of plaintiff and by forging the
signature of plaintiff. The said alleged partition is not at all
acted upon and no document of partition is executed.
Hence, prays for appropriate reliefs.
5.
After service of suit summons, defendant No.1
appeared
through
his
counsel
and
filed
his
written
statement wherein he admitted the relationship between
plaintiff and defendant No.1; admitted about the joint
purchase of suit schedule property under registered sale
deed dated 25.01.2001; admitted about construction of two
tenements in the building and also admitted about filing of
O.S.No.246/2013.
He further contended that said suit is
not pertaining to suit schedule property but pertaining to
some
other
property
bearing
Plot
No.47
situated
at
Gaddanakere Village. He admitted about ME No.1462 and
RFA NO.100116/2019
two separate plot Nos.22/1 and No.22/2 given to suit
schedule property. However, his contention is that said
entry is agreed between both plaintiff and defendant No.1
and with the knowledge of plaintiff. He further contended
that both plaintiff and defendant No.1 with an intention to
divide, have constructed two separate tenements in a single
plot and after such construction, they started residing
separately and it is based on the partition between them. It
was agreed between plaintiff and defendant No.1 that
plaintiff should take eastern half portion and defendant
should take western half portion. It was agreed that some
portion in said property towards north side should be left
vacant
for
the
common
enjoyment
of
plaintiff
and
defendant. Accordingly, plaintiff and defendant prepared
plans for construction of houses in their respective areas. In
order to save more open area, they have decided to
construct two houses by putting common wall in between
two houses. Since, the property is standing jointly in the
names of plaintiff and defendant; they have jointly taken
loan from the bank, but plaintiff and defendant utilized their
RFA NO.100116/2019
loan amount separately and credited installments of their
share in said loan separately. Defendant has constructed
house on western portion as per his desire and wish;
likewise plaintiff constructed house on eastern portion as
per his desire and wish. Defendant is a Civil Engineer.
Hence, to help the plaintiff, who is his elder brother,
defendant has supervised the entire construction work.
Though, plaintiff and defendant have constructed their
houses separately, the wall in between their house is a
common wall. The defendant has opened two doors to his
house, one is on western side and another is on northern
side. Defendant has constructed steps to go to his house by
using said two doors. He has put up steps within his area;
likewise, plaintiff also put up steps in his area. About 8 - 9
years prior to filing of the written statement, defendant has
constructed first floor by spending more than 5 - 6 lakhs of
rupees. Defendant is absolute owner in possession of said
portion and open space constructed within western portion
of his property under oral partition. Defendant has no right,
title or interest in or over the eastern portion fallen to the
RFA NO.100116/2019
share of plaintiff; likewise, plaintiff has no right, title or
interest in or over the portion which is fallen to the share of
defendant No.1. Of late, plaintiff is acting adverse to the
interest of defendant. He was not cooperating in payment of
taxes and other works. Hence, with an intention to get
separation, defendant has filed an application before Deputy
Tahsildar, Kaladagi for sub-division of the property as per
the oral partition. On the basis of said application, ME
No.1462 was prepared. Deputy Tahsildar issued notice to
plaintiff prior to certificate of said mutation entry. Plaintiff
objected for said certification. Hence, it was registered as
dispute in RTS/Takarar/CR-7/10-11 and notice was issued
to both plaintiff and defendant No.1. They have appeared
before Deputy Tahsildar. Deputy Tahsildar, Kaladagi has
visited the spot and made spot inspection and after holding
full-fledged enquiry, has certified the ME No.1462 on
30.09.2010. Accordingly, the Plot No.22 was divided into
two parts i.e. Plot No.22/1 and Plot No.22/2. Plaintiff is
party to those proceedings and never challenged the said
order. Partition between plaintiff and defendant No.1 is
RFA NO.100116/2019
acted upon and accepted by both plaintiff and defendant
No.1. Plaintiff has allowed defendant to make improvement
and to construct first floor over portion of the property
fallen to his share in the oral partition. At this belated stage,
plaintiff is estopped from contending that no partition has
taken place. Plaintiff issued legal notice dated 12.07.2010
through his advocate to defendant No.1 in respect of
common passage left for common use and enjoyment.
Defendant has given proper reply to it. Plaintiff kept quiet
for all these years knowing fully well that he is owner of the
house constructed on eastern portion and defendant is
owner of the house constructed on western side including
first floor. Now, the difference of opinion is widened
between
them.
Plaintiff,
brother
Siddalingappa
defendant
jointly
No.1
and
another
purchased
a
plot
at
Gaddanakere village. Plaintiff is acting adverse to the
interest of defendant No.1 in respect of said property.
Hence, defendant No.1 has filed suit in O.S.No.246/2013
claiming 1/3rd share in said property. Afterwards, plaintiff
appeared in said suit and filed his written statement.
RFA NO.100116/2019
Defendant No.1 has relinquished his rights over Plot
No.22/1 in favour of his wife Smt.Savitha (defendant No.2)
by
executing
22.08.2013.
a
registered
Hence,
relinquishment
presently
his
wife
deed
Smt.
dated
Savitha
(defendant No.2) is the absolute owner in possession of the
property bearing No. 22/1 and not defendant No.1. Hence,
the suit is bad for non-joinder of necessary party and
hence, prayed for dismissal of suit with compensatory costs
of Rs.25,000/-.
6.
After filing the written statement, plaintiff has
impleaded the wife of defendant No.1 as defendant No.2
who has filed her written statement and took the similar
contention which is taken by defendant No.1 and prayed for
dismissal of the suit.
7.
After completion of pleadings, the trial Court has
framed the following issues and additional issues:-
RFA NO.100116/2019
ISSUES
1.
Whether the plaintiff proves that, suit
schedule
property is joint property of plaintiff and
defendant and defendant and he had joint
share in the suit schedule property?
2.
Whether the plaintiff prove that, he had
1/2 share in
3.
suit schedule property?
Whether
the
defendant
prove
prior
partition
in
between
plaintiff
and
defendants?
4.
Whether suit is bad for non joinder of
necessary parties?
5.
Whether the plaintiff is entitled for the
relief sought for?
6.
What order or decree?
Additional issues
1. Whether defendant No.2 proves that,
she is the absolute owner and possessor
of the suit property bearing Plot No.22/1
in R.S.No.128D
of
Muranal
(Vidyagiri
RFA NO.100116/2019
Bagalkot)
relinquishment
as
per
deed
registered
execute
by
defendant No.1 in her favour on 22-082013?
2. Whether defendant No.2 proves that,
suit of the plaintiff is barred by law of
limitation?
8.
On behalf of plaintiff, plaintiff was examined as
P.W.1 apart from marking Exs.P.1 to P.6 before trial court.
On behalf of defendants, defendant No.1 was examined as
D.W.1 and examined a witness as D.W.2 apart from
marking Exs.D.1 to D.7 before trial Court.
9.
After recording evidence of both sides and
hearing arguments of both sides, the learned Trial Judge
came to the conclusion that plaintiff has proved that both
plaintiff and defendant No.1 have equal share in suit
schedule property and there is no partition effected between
them and thus decreed the suit by granting half share to
plaintiff.
RFA NO.100116/2019
10.
Aggrieved by the said judgment and decree,
defendants/appellants have filed this appeal.
11.
Heard arguments of both sides.
12.
Learned counsel for the appellants Sri.Shivaraj S.
Balloli would submit that at the time of purchase of property
itself, there was an intention for plaintiff and defendant to
put up two separate houses in the property and to get equal
half share between them in this property. Accordingly, both
of them have constructed two separate houses in suit
schedule property and since 2002, both plaintiff and
defendant No.1 is residing separately in two portions of suit
schedule property. Plaintiff is residing in eastern portion and
defendants are residing in western portion. Both houses of
ground
floor,
constructed
on
eastern
and
western
portion
simultaneously
and
sometime
were
afterwards
defendant No.1 has put up construction of first floor. After
construction of first floor by defendant No.1, the differences
arose between parties. Hence, plaintiff and defendant No.1
have
divided
their
properties
under
oral
partition.
RFA NO.100116/2019
Accordingly, the application was given to Deputy Tahsildar,
who has visited the spot and has certified that this property
consists of two tenements and has given plot No.22/1 and
Plot No.22/2 to the property of defendants and plaintiff
respectively by making mutation entry in ME No.1462. Even
plaintiff has admitted these facts in his cross examination.
These admitted facts clearly and categorically establish that
there is partition between plaintiff and defendants. Hence,
the suit ought not to have been decreed. By spending huge
amount, defendants have constructed first floor building
and plaintiff has not spent any amount for its construction.
He would further submit that even though both plaintiff and
defendants have constructed the houses on ground floor
separately they spent the amount separately. Hence,
prayed for dismissal of suit by allowing the appeal.
13.
Learned counsel for respondent Sri S.B.Hebballi
would submit that the defendants have not produced any
iota of material or any document to show that there was
partition between plaintiff and defendant No.1. At one
RFA NO.100116/2019
stretch, defendant No.1 says that the partition has taken
place under a deed of partition and at another stretch, he
contends that it was oral partition. But to prove the oral
partition or to prove the written partition executed between
the parties, defendants have not produced any material.
Considering all these facts in a proper and right perspective,
the learned trial judge has decreed the suit and it needs no
interference.
Learned counsel would further submit that
this construction of first floor by defendants can be
considered in final decree proceedings. Hence, prayed for
dismissal of appeal with costs throughout.
14.
Having heard the arguments of both sides and
verifying the appeal memo and the trial Court records, the
points that arise for consideration are:
1)
Whether appellants/defendants establish that
there was earlier partition between plaintiff
and defendants and thus decree of suit by the
trial Court is erroneous?
RFA NO.100116/2019
2)
Whether interference of this court on the
judgment
and
decree
of
trial
Court
is
required?
3)
15.
What order or decree?
The admitted facts of the case are that plaintiff
and defendant No.1 are brothers and they have jointly
purchased
suit
schedule
property
bearing
plot
No.22
situated at Vidhyagiri, Bagalkot under registered sale deed
dated 25.01.2001 for a sum of Rs.1,29,000/- from its
erstwhile owners and after such purchase, said property is
mutated into the joint names of plaintiff and defendant No.1
as per M.E.No.9288. Both plaintiff and defendant No.1
together were paying taxes jointly to this property and they
were submitting self-declaration assessment form jointly. It
is also an admitted fact that both plaintiff and defendant
No.1 have constructed two tenements in suit schedule
property and the tenement bearing No.22/1 situated on
western side is in occupation of defendants and tenement
bearing No.22/2 on eastern side is in occupation of plaintiff.
RFA NO.100116/2019
16.
In the cross-examination, plaintiff admitted that
both plaintiff and defendant No.1 have constructed two
tenements separately in suit schedule property and at that
time to avoid leaving set back, they have put up a common
wall in between their houses and thus he has constructed
house on eastern side and defendant has constructed house
on western side and started residing separately. Plaintiff
further admitted in his evidence that there are two separate
staircases to go to upstairs for both tenements. He has
deposed that he has left vacant space on eastern and
western side of staircase of his house. He further admitted
that he has put up house as per his will and wish within his
house
property and
improved
said
property;
likewise
defendant No.1 has also put up construction inside of his
house at his will and wish and there are two separate
electricity meters to both houses and they have constructed
two houses separately as per their oral agreement in the
year 2001.
RFA NO.100116/2019
17.
Plaintiff in his cross-examination further admitted
that defendant No.1 being Civil Engineer has supervised the
construction
of
his
house
as
well
as
the
house
of
defendants; defendant No.1 has put up two doors to his
house, one on western side and another on northern side
and the door on western side is main door; defendant No.1
has put up staircase on northern side of his house.
18.
Plaintiff
in
his
cross-examination
further
categorically admitted that after sometime, defendant No.1
has put up construction of first floor house and at that time
he has raised objection that said first floor house causes
obstruction
to
plaintiff to
reach
upstairs through
his
staircase. In this regard he has issued legal notice dated
12.07.2010 to defendant No.1 and defendant No.1 has
given reply to it. He categorically admitted that only after
putting up of construction of first floor by defendant, the
dispute commenced between him and defendant No.1.
19.
This
examination
admission
clearly
of
establish
plaintiff
that
in
plaintiff
his
cross-
has
not
RFA NO.100116/2019
challenged the construction of first floor by defendant No.1,
but challenged only that it obstructs his way to reach
upstairs.
If really, there was no partition; plaintiff would
not have raised such objection.
20.
After
sometime,
defendant
No.1
has
given
application to the Municipal office, Bagalkot to give two
separate numbers to the two tenements and in that regard
notice was served upon plaintiff and plaintiff has raised
objection for it and in that regard a case was initiated
before Deputy Tahsildar and in that case Deputy Tahsildar
has made spot inspection and recorded the statements of
plaintiff and defendant No.1 separately. In that statement,
plaintiff categorically stated that first defendant has put up
construction towards northern side of his property and it
causes obstruction to plaintiff to use his portion of the
property. Plaintiff categorically admitted that he has given
statement as per Ex.D.1 before the Deputy Tahsildar.
21.
In the said statement, the plaintiff has stated
that there is a common wall in between the house of
RFA NO.100116/2019
plaintiff and defendant and they have put up separate
staircases. Staircase of defendant No.1 measures 3.5 feet
width and 8 feet length and half of it comes in his property
and half of it comes in the property of defendant No.1 and
thus it is causing hindrance for plaintiff to take his vehicles
and hence requested to shift the staircase of defendant No.
1 from front side towards back side. He also admitted that
they are having two separate electricity meters and they
are paying electricity bills separately.
22.
Since 2001, this arrangement is being done and
at the time of construction of ground floor house only both
plaintiff and defendant No.1 have put up separate staircases
and there was no objection by the plaintiff.
23.
It is to be noted here that there is another plot of
property bearing No.47 which was purchased by plaintiff
defendant No.1 and another brother Siddhalingappa jointly.
In respect of the said property, defendant No.1 has filed
suit for partition in O.S.No.246/2013 and only after service
RFA NO.100116/2019
of suit summons of said suit, the plaintiff has issued legal
notice to defendant No.1 and has filed the present suit.
24.
Only after defendant No.1 put up construction
on first floor in the property allotted to him, in the western
side of the property and after defendant No.1 filed suit in
respect of other joint property of plaintiff, himself and their
another brother, the dispute commences between parties.
25.
It is the specific contention of defendant No.1
that there was partition between him and plaintiff in respect
of these two tenements and he has put up construction of
first floor by spending about Rs.5 - 6 lakhs. This point that
defendant No.1 had spent Rupees 5 - 6 lakhs and put up
construction of first floor is not disputed by plaintiff while
cross-examining defendant No.1.
26.
The plaintiff denied the partition between him
and defendant No.1 in respect of suit schedule property.
However, defendant No.1 has taken specific contention of
partition. Hence, it is the initial burden of defendants to
establish that there is partition between them in respect of
RFA NO.100116/2019
the present suit schedule property before filing of the suit.
This partition between parties can be established by
producing, deed of partition or if it is oral partition then by
implication or by the act of both parties, it could be inferred.
27.
Only when defendant No.1 has given application
to give two separate numbers to two tenements of suit
schedule property, the plaintiff has raised objection and
after hearing both sides, the Deputy Tahsildar has passed
an order and has given two separate numbers i.e., Plot
No.22/1 and Plot No.22/2 to the properties of defendant
and plaintiff respectively. Afterwards, the defendant No.1
has alienated this property in favour of his wife i.e.,
Defendant No.2 by way of gift.
28.
The Deputy Tahsildar has passed an Order dated
30.09.2010 and changed the plot numbers as 22/1 and
22/2 in respect of two portions of suit schedule property by
making M.E.No.1462. A certified copy of said order is
produced as per Ex.P.4. Before passing the said order, the
Deputy Tahsildar has issued notices to both parties and has
RFA NO.100116/2019
made
spot
inspection.
Plaintiff
himself
has
produced
documents in respect of this revenue transaction. These
revenue entries will not create any ownership over the
property unless and until there is a registered document.
However, in case of partition between brothers, only by
taking their statements and by making spot inspection, the
Deputy Tahsildar can mutate the properties which were
allotted to brothers separately and it is permissible and it
does not require any registered document.
29.
Under these circumstances, from implication, one
can gather that there was partition between plaintiff and
defendant No.1 in respect of suit schedule property and
eastern portion was allotted to plaintiff and western portion
is allotted to defendant No.1 and both of them have put up
two separate houses in those two portions separately and
residing separately since 2001. Furthermore, defendant
No.1 has relinquished his rights in favour of his wife in
respect
of
this
property
by
executing
registered
relinquishment deed and these facts are not in dispute.
RFA NO.100116/2019
30.
According to defendant No.1, there was partition
between plaintiff and defendant No.1 before Nadakacheri,
Kaladagi Tahsildar and both houses are having same value.
Some suggestions are given to defendant No.1 at the time
of his cross-examination that as both houses are having
same value and same facilities, whether he is ready to
exchange the house property in his possession with the
house property of plaintiff and he has not accepted said
suggestion.
31.
Some suggestions were given to defendant No.1
that he has misused the amount given by plaintiff at the
time of construction of house and he has used good quality
materials for construction of his house and used bad quality
materials to the house of plaintiff which is denied by him.
32.
There is no such pleading either in the plaint or
in the affidavit evidence of plaintiff. Only for the first time
such suggestion was made to defendant No.1 which is
denied by him. Without the pleadings, any amount of
evidence will not establish the case. Even defendant No.1
RFA NO.100116/2019
has not admitted this suggestion. Hence, it is not useful for
plaintiff.
33.
In
the
cross-examination
defendant
No.1
admitted that he has stated in his written statement that
there is oral partition between him and plaintiff in respect of
suit schedule property. There is no written document to
prove the same. Only plaintiff and defendant No.1 have
partitioned it.
34.
As discussed above, by implication and by the
act and attitude of both parties, it could be inferred that by
spending
the
amount
separately
both
plaintiff
and
defendant No.1 have put up construction of two tenements
in the same property and they started residing separately in
those two tenements without any obstacle from 2001-2002
till 2014 and only after defendant No.1 put up the
construction of first floor in his property and only after he
filed a suit for partition in respect of another plot of
property against the plaintiff and his another brother in OS
No.248/2013, the plaintiff has raised objection and filed
RFA NO.100116/2019
present suit for partition. These things establish that there
is already oral partition between plaintiff and defendant
No.1 in respect of suit schedule property.
35.
Learned trial judge has not examined these
aspects but has come to a wrong conclusion only based on
some stray evidence that both plaintiff and defendant No.1
have given joint application to Municipal Council for license
and they have given joint self-assessment form and were
paying taxes jointly. The learned trial judge held that there
was no partition between parties and thus partition of suit
schedule property in two equal half in favour of both
plaintiff and defendant No.1. As discussed above, already
both plaintiff and defendant No.1 started utilizing the
portion of properties which were fallen to their shares
separately as per their will and wish; then again granting
decree of partition will lead to multiplicity of problems, as
first defendant has already constructed first floor in his
property by spending huge amount separately and there
was no contribution by plaintiff for construction of first floor.
RFA NO.100116/2019
36.
Learned counsel for plaintiff would submit that
this fact can be agitated in final decree proceedings. In final
decree proceedings, both parties would get equal share not
only in the land of property but also on the structures put
up on it.
Hence, said argument of learned counsel for
plaintiff is not tenable. Hence, granting decree of partition
by
learned
trial
interference.
judge
Accordingly,
is
erroneous
point
and
numbers
it
requires
&
are
answered in affirmative.
37.
In view of findings on point Nos.1 and 2, we
proceed to pass the following:
ORDER
Appeal filed by appellants under Order XLI,
Rule (1) R/w Section 96 CPC is allowed by
setting aside the judgment and decree passed in
O.S. No.92/2014 dated 12.02.2019 on the file of
I Additional Senior Civil Judge and JMFC.,
Bagalkot.
RFA NO.100116/2019
Consequently, the suit filed by plaintiff is
dismissed.
Under the facts and circumstances of the
case, parties are directed to bear their own
costs.
Sd/(MOHAMMAD NAWAZ)
JUDGE
Sd/(GEETHA K.B.)
JUDGE
HMB
CT-MCK
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review