The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
25. The respondent authority is bound to dispose of the representation in the backdrop of the allegations set out in the representation. As stated supra, the representation of the petitioner has been disposed of in a hurried manner. Therefore, this is a fit case to remit the matter to respondent authorities for consideration of the issue afresh and pass orders in accordance with law. If the matter is remitted to the respondent authorities, no prejudice would be caused to either of the parties.
26. In the result, (i) WP(C) No. 809 of 2018 The writ petition is disposed of. P a g e | 14 (ii) The impugned Memorandum dated
4. 4.2017 issued by the Under Secretary (FD/PIC-II), Government of Manipur is set aside and the matter is remanded to the respondent authorities for consideration of the issue afresh and pass orders in accordance with law after affording reasonable opportunity to the petitioner. (iii) The aforesaid exercise is directed to be completed within a period of twelve weeks from the date of receipt of a copy of this order. (iv) No costs. FR/NFR Sushil WP(C) No. 809 of 2018
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
SUSHIL SHARMA
Date: 2023.08.25 15:24:12 +05'30'
Page |1
SHAMURAILATPAM SUSHIL
SHARMA
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WP(C) No. 809 of 2018
Shri Ksh. Ranjit Singh, aged about 65 years, S/o (Late) Ksh.
Jugeshor Singh, a resident of Kangjabi Leirak, Meinam Leikai,
P.O. Lamphel, Imphal West District, Manipur – 795001.
… PETITIONER
-VERSUS1.
The
State
of
Manipur,
represented
by
the
Commissioner/Secretary (Finance), Government of Manipur,
Old Secretariat Complex, Babupara, Imphal- 795001.
2.
The Director, Treasuries & Accounts, Government of Manipur,
Imphal, D.C. Complex, Lamphel, Pin No. 795004.
3.
The Joint Secretary (Pension Cell), Government of Manipur,
Imphal, New Secretariat Building, Babupara, Pin No. – 795001.
4.
The Accountant General, Manipur, P.O. & P.S. Imphal, District
Imphal West, Manipur, Babupara, Pin No. 795001.
… RESPONDENTS
BEFORE
HON’BLE THE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE M.V. MURALIDARAN
For the Petitioner
::
Mr. A. Mohendro, Adv.
For the Respondents
::
Mr. Sh. Shyam Sharma, GA
Mr. S. Suresh, Advocate
Date of Hearing and
reserving Judgment & Order ::
14.08.2023
Date of Judgment & Order
23.08.2023
WP(C) No. 809 of 2018
::
Page |2
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
(CAV)
Heard Mr. A. Mohendro, learned counsel for the
petitioner; Mr. Sh. Shyam Sharma, the learned Government
Advocate for the respondent State and Mr. S. Suresh, the
learned counsel for the fourth respondent.
2.
This writ petition has been filed by the petitioner to
quash the impugned memorandum dated 4.4.2017 and to direct
the respondents to give effect the Manipur Services (Revised
Pay) (3rd Amendment) Rules, 2016 for cash payment from
1.9.2011 to the petitioner at par with the date of cash payment
for the Head Clerk.
3.
Mr. A. Mohendro, the learned counsel for the
petitioner submitted that the petitioner was initially appointed as
Lower Division Clerk on 12.11.1976 and further appointed to the
post of Upper Division Clerk in the Directorate of Treasuries and
Accounts, Government of Manipur.
From the post of Upper
Division Clerk, he was further appointed on promotion as Senior
Accountant on 3.1.1991. On recommendation of the DPC, the
petitioner was appointed on promotion to the post of Senior
Accountant vide order dated 13.3.1995. After rendering more
WP(C) No. 809 of 2018
Page |3
than 33 years of service, the petitioner retired from service on
attaining the age of superannuation on 28.2.2010.
4.
The learned counsel further submitted that the
petitioner’s pay from Rs.5000-150-8000/- was revised to
Rs.5200-20200+GP 2800 with effect from 1.1.2006.
In the
Manipur Services (Revised Pay) (3rd Amendment) Rules, 2016
pertaining to the post of Senior Accountant, the scale of Rs.520020200 with GP 2800 has been revised to Rs.9300-34800 with GP
4200. The third amendment further stipulates that the said rules
shall be deemed to have come into force on 1.1.2006 notionally
with cash payment from 1.3.2016.
5.
The learned counsel submits that while adopting the
6th Pay Commission through the Manipur Services (Revised Pay)
(2nd Amendment) Rules, 2011, the Government had revised the
pay scale of Head Clerk in the scale of Rs.9300-34800 with GP
4200 notionally given effect from 1.1.2006 with cash payment
from 1.9.2011, whereas for the promotional post i.e. Senior
Accountant, the pay is revised to Rs.9300-34800 with GP 4200/given effect notionally from 1.1.2006 and cash payment from
1.3.2016. According to the learned counsel, the same is not
tenable in the eyes of law and malafide and also derogates the
WP(C) No. 809 of 2018
Page |4
departmental hierarchy between the feeder and the promotional
post.
6.
The learned counsel for the petitioner submits that
similar post like Head Clerk for which the nature of works and
duties were similar with that of the Senior Accountant has already
been revised to the pay scale of Rs.9300-34800 with GP 4200
giving effect from 1.1.2006 with cash payment from 1.9.2011.
But in the case of the petitioner’s post of Senior Accountant, the
respondents have adopted a different yard stick in giving effect
and benefit of assigning the revised pay at a much later period
i.e. 1.1.2016, thereby curbing 4 years and 7 months of arrears
receivable by the petitioner.
7.
Mr. Sh. Shyam Sharma, the learned Government
Advocate appearing for the respondent State submitted that in
the Recruitment Rules of 1981 for Senior Accountant, the post of
Head Clerk/Accountant/Junior Accountant/UDC were feeder.
However, under ROP, 1982, the pay scale of Senior Accountant
and Head Clerk is same pay scale of Rs.640-1410/- which means
both feeder post and promotion post were placed in the identical
pay scale. In the Recruitment Rules of 1994 for Head Clerk, the
post of UDC/Accountant were feeder.
WP(C) No. 809 of 2018
Page |5
8.
The
learned
Government
Advocate
further
submitted that the Sub-Committee of Officers of Pay Anomaly
submitted a report dated 18.12.2010, in which it recommended
for upgradation of pay scale of both Head Clerk and Senior
Accountant to the Grade Pay of Rs.4200 and the report of the
Committee was placed before the Cabinet.
The Cabinet
accepted the recommendation with regard to those posts which
do not require any change in the Recruitment Rules like Head
Clerk and for those which require changes in Recruitment Rules
like Senior Accountant, the Finance Department was to
coordinate with the Department of Personnel and the concerned
Administrative Department to amend the Recruitment Rules.
Accordingly, for all such posts that does not require any changes
in the Recruitment Rules like Head Clerk, the Finance
Department issued Manipur Services (Revised Pay) (2 nd
Amendment) Rules, 2011 which was made effective notionally
with effect from 1.1.2006 and cash payment from 1.9.2011.
9.
The
learned
Government
Advocate
further
submitted that in regard to the post of Senior Accountant, it was
considered to keep the post of Senior Accountant equivalent to
the post of Head Clerk and to merge the post of Accountants as
Senior Accountant. The same was approved by policy decision
WP(C) No. 809 of 2018
Page |6
of the State Cabinet in its sitting held on 8.5.2014.
The
amendment of Recruitment Rules in regard to Senior Accountant
was notified on 16.2.2016 and in Column 4 of the said
notification, it has been stated that such pay scale shall be in
force as and when the Finance Department prescribes the same
under the Manipur Services (Revised Pay) Rules, 2010.
Accordingly, the Finance Department notified the Manipur
Services (Revised Pay) (3rd Amendment) Rules, 2016 on
28.3.2016, which was made effective notionally with effect from
1.1.2006 and cash payment from 1.3.2016 in regard to the
upgradation of pay scale of Senior Accountant from Rs.520020200+GP2800 to Rs.9300-34800+GP4200/-. The rectified pay
scale of Rs.9300-34800 of Senior Accountant was conditional
upon suitable amendment of Recruitment Rules of the said post
and it is well given fact that the Recruitment Rules cannot be
made effective retrospectively as it will amount to setting back
the hands of clock in a past time.
10.
The
learned
Government
Advocate
further
submitted that under the order dated 14.7.1992 issued by the
Commissioner (Finance), the post of Head Clerk of Treasuries &
Accounts has been redesignated as Senior Accountant.
As
such, the question of Head Clerk being the feeder post of Senior
WP(C) No. 809 of 2018
Page |7
Accountant does not arise in the case of Treasuries and
Accounts. Further, the writ petition is not maintainable without
challenging the notification dated 28.3.2016.
11.
Mr. S. Suresh, the learned counsel for the fourth
respondent submitted that no cause has been shown against the
fourth respondent and the fourth respondent has been wrongly
impleaded as party respondent in the writ petition.
12.
This Court considered the rival submissions and
also perused the materials available on record.
13.
The grievance of the petitioner is that similar post
like Head Clerk for which the nature of works and duties were
similar to that of the Senior Accountant, the pay has already been
revised to the pay scale of Rs.9300-34800 with GP 4200 giving
effect notionally from 1.1.2006 with cash payment from 1.9.2011.
But in the case of the petitioner (Senior Accountant), the authority
have adopted a different yardstick in giving effect and benefit of
assigning the revised pay at a much later period i.e. 1.3.2016
thereby curbing 4 years and 7 months of arrears receivable by
the petitioner.
14.
Aggrieved by the said act of the respondent
authorities, earlier the petitioner had filed W.P.(C) No.944 of
WP(C) No. 809 of 2018
Page |8
2016 alleging that the Directorate of Treasuries and Accounts
supposed to have revised the pay with effect from 1.3.2016
though in case of others it has been made effective from 1.9.2011
and in case of others with different dates and thereby the persons
of Directorate of Treasuries and Accounts have been treated
discriminatorily.
15.
By the order dated 30.11.2016, this Court disposed
of the said writ petition. The operative portion of order reads
thus:
“Upon hearing, it appears that the petitioner,
with respect to grievance which has been
raised here in the writ application, has never
moved to the appropriate authority who is
supposed to take decision in the matter and
thereby this application is disposed of
directing the petitioner to represent the
matter before the appropriate authority,
respondent No.1, within a period of one week
so that representation be disposed of within
a period of six weeks from the date of receipt
of the representation.
Thus, this application stands disposed of.”
16.
The petitioner has made a representation on
20.12.2016 pursuant to the order of this Court. Since the
WP(C) No. 809 of 2018
Page |9
representation of the petitioner was not disposed of, on
27.2.2017,
the
petitioner
sent
a
legal
notice
to
the
Commissioner/Secretary (Finance) for compliance of the order
dated 30.11.2016. Due to the non-compliance of the order dated
30.11.2016 passed in W.P.(C) No.944 of 2016, the petitioner had
filed Contempt Case No.121 of 2017. Pending Contempt Case,
the respondent authorities issued the impugned Memorandum
dated 4.4.2017 and recording the Memoraundum, the Contempt
Case was closed.
17.
It would be appropriate to quote the impugned
Memorandum dated 4.4.2017:
“No.34/1/2015-FD(PIC)(5):
The
representation dated 20.12.2016 submitted
by Shri Ksh. Ranjit Singh addressed to the
Commissioner/Secretary (Finance), Govt. of
Manipur requesting for giving effect the
Manipur
Services
(Revised
Pay)
(3rd
Amendment) Rules, 2016 for cash payment
from 1st September, 2011 at par with the date
of cash payment for the Head Clerk and to
calculate the retirement pension and other
benefits was considered and examined by
the Government.
The decision of the Government regarding
effective
WP(C) No. 809 of 2018
dates
were
indicated
in
the
P a g e | 10
Notification No.34/1/2015-FD(PIC)(5) dated
28.3.2016 issued by the Finance Department
(PIC).
Accordingly,
his
representation
dated
20.12.2016 is disposed of in compliance of
the order dated 30.11.2016 passed in
W.P.(C) No.944 of 2016 by the Hon’ble High
Court of Manipur.”
18.
From the impugned Memorandum, it is clear that
while disposing of the representation of the petitioner, the
authority held that the effective dates were indicated in the
Notification dated 28.3.2016 issued by the Finance Department.
19.
According to the learned Government Advocate,
the writ petition without challenging the Notification dated
28.3.2017 is not maintainable. Admittedly, the petitioner has not
challenged the Notification dated 28.3.2017 specifically.
In
paragraph 6 of the affidavit filed in support of the writ petition, it
has been stated that “the said 3rd amendment further specifies
that the said rules shall be deemed to have come into force on
the 1st day of January, 2006 notionally with cash payment from
1st March, 2016 which is being challenged in the present writ
petition”. However, in the prayer portion, the petitioner sought
writ of mandamus directing the respondents to give effect to the
WP(C) No. 809 of 2018
P a g e | 11
Manipur Services (Revised Pay) (3rd Amendment) Rules, 2016
for cash payment from 1.9.2011 to the petitioner at par with the
date of cash payment for the Head Clerk coupled with a prayer
to quash the impugned Memorandum dated 4.4.2017. Different
reliefs in respect of the same order cannot be prayed for.
20.
It is the case of the respondent State that the
Manipur Services (Revised Pay) (3rd Amendment) Rules, 2016
vide notification dated 28.3.2016 which was made effective
notionally with effect from 1.1.2006 and cash payment from
1.3.2016 in regard to the upgradation of pay scale of Senior
Accountant
from
Rs.5200-20200+GP2800
to
Rs.9300-
34800+GP 4200 of the Senior Accountant was conditional upon
suitable amendment of Recruitment Rules of the said post and
that
the
Recruitment
Rules
cannot
be
made
effective
retrospectively as it will amount to setting back the hands of clock
in a past time.
21.
On a perusal of the notification dated 28.3.2016, it
has been stated that these rules shall be deemed to have come
into force on 1.1.2006 notionally with cash payment from
1.3.2016.
WP(C) No. 809 of 2018
P a g e | 12
22.
In the representation dated 20.12.2016, the
petitioner made a prayer to give effect to the Manipur Services
(Revised Pay) (3rd Amendment) Rules, 2016 for cash payment
from 1st September, 2011 at par with the date of cash payment
for the Head Clerk and to calculate the retirement pension and
other benefits receivable by the petitioner.
23.
According to the respondent State, the post of Head
Clerk of Treasuries and Accounts has been redesignated as
Senior Accountant way back on 14.7.1992 and, therefore, the
question of Head Clerk being the feeder post of Senior
Accountant does not arise in the case of Treasuries and
Accounts.
24.
Admittedly,
there
is
no
whisper
about
the
redesignation of the post of Head Clerk of Treasuries and
Accounts as Senior Accountant way back in the year 1992 in the
impugned Memorandum dated 4.4.2017.
The Memorandum
impugned simply states that the decision of the Government
regarding effective dates were indicated in the notification dated
28.3.2016 issued by the Finance Department.
When the
petitioner sought to give effect to the Manipur Services (Revised
Pay) (3rd Amendment) Rules, 2016 for cash payment from
1.9.2011 at par with the date of cash payment for the Head Clerk,
WP(C) No. 809 of 2018
P a g e | 13
it is the bounden duty of the respondent authority to discuss
about the existence of the alleged order dated 14.7.1992 issued
by the Commissioner (Finance) that the post of Head Clerk has
been redesignated as Senior Accountant and the question of
Head Clerk being the feeder post of Senior Accountant does not
arise while disposing of the representation. As stated supra, no
such discussion was made while disposing of the representation
of the petitioner dated 20.12.2016 and faced with the contempt
proceedings, the authority has hurriedly passed the impugned
Memorandum dated 4.4.2017.
Such an order cannot stand in
the eye of law.
25.
The respondent authority is bound to dispose of the
representation in the backdrop of the allegations set out in the
representation.
As stated supra, the representation of the
petitioner has been disposed of in a hurried manner. Therefore,
this is a fit case to remit the matter to respondent authorities for
consideration of the issue afresh and pass orders in accordance
with law. If the matter is remitted to the respondent authorities,
no prejudice would be caused to either of the parties.
26.
In the result,
(i)
WP(C) No. 809 of 2018
The writ petition is disposed of.
P a g e | 14
(ii)
The impugned Memorandum dated
4.4.2017 issued by the Under Secretary
(FD/PIC-II), Government of Manipur is
set aside and the matter is remanded to
the
respondent
authorities
for
consideration of the issue afresh and
pass orders in accordance with law after
affording reasonable opportunity to the
petitioner.
(iii)
The aforesaid exercise is directed to be
completed within a period of twelve
weeks from the date of receipt of a copy
of this order.
(iv)
No costs.
ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE
FR/NFR
Sushil
WP(C) No. 809 of 2018
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review