Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT I N D O R E
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE VIVEK RUSIA
ON THE 18th OF JANUARY, 2024
MISC. PETITION No. 3541 of 2021
BETWEEN:SHRI KRISHNA GINNING FACTORY THROUGH OMPRAKASH S/O
RADHAKISHAN OJHA, R/O 51, RANI LAXMI BAI MARG, NAGDA
(MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
(BY SHRI ASHOK KUMAR SETHI, SENIOR ADVOCATE ASSISTED BY SHRI
SAMEER ANANT ATHAWALE, ADVOCATE)
AND
1.
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH THROUGH COLLECTOR KOTHI
PALACE UJJAIN (MADHYA PRADESH)
2.
SUB DIVISIONAL
PRADESH)
OFFICER
NAGDA
DIST
UJJAIN
(MADHYA
3. TEHSILDAR TEHSILDAR NAGDA DIST UJJAIN (MADHYA PRADESH)
4.
MUNICIPAL COUNCIL NAGDA THR CHIEF MUNICIPAL OFFICER
MUNICIPAL COUNCIL NAGDA DIST UJJAIN (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(STATE BY SHRI PRADYUMNA KIBE, PANEL LAWYER)
(RESPONDENT NO.4 BY SHRI ROHIT KUMAR MANGAL, ADVOCATE)
This petition coming on for admission this day, the court passed
the following:
ORDER
The petitioner / plaintiff has filed the present petition under
Article 227 of the Constitution of India challenging the order dated
20.09.2021 passed by the Additional District Judge, Nagada, District –
Ujjain, whereby the application filed under Section 151 of the Code of
Signed by: RAVI PRAKASH
Signing time: 1/23/2024
5:38:11 PM
-2-
Civil Procedure, 1908 has been dismissed.
02.
Facts of the case in short are as under
2.1.
The petitioner/plaintiff filed a suit for a decree of title,
possession, declaration of proceedings initiated under Section 182 of the
Madhya Pradesh Land Revenue Code, 1959 (in short MPLRC) and
permanent injunction in respect of suit property i.e. land bearing Survey
No.438 area 3.585 hectare situated at Village – Pandalyakala, Tehsil –
Nagada. According to the plaintiff, on the suit land Shri Krishna
Ginning Factory was established along with some houses and godown
and the remaining land was left vacant. The plaintiff is an absolute
owner and in possession of the suit land, on which the defendants have
no right or title.
2.2.
The defendants / State initiated proceedings under Section 182
of the MPLRC for cancellation of the lease of the suit land given to the
predecessors of the plaintiff. The matter travelled up to the Board of
Revenue and finally decided on 04.04.2016 which gave cause of action
to the plaintiff to file a suit on 09.10.2017.
2.3.
The defendants / State filed a written statement on 26.10.2018.
Thereafter, the issues were framed on 03.01.2019 and the plaintiff filed
an affidavit under Order XVIII Rule 4 of the CPC.
2.4.
The plaintiff filed an application under Order VI Rule 17 of the
CPC, the defendants were given time to file a reply and vide order dated
04.10.2019, application was allowed with the cost of Rs.800/-.
Thereafter, vide order dated 14.10.2019, an application under Section 65
of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 was also allowed and a certified copy
of the sale deed dated 30.01.2019 was taken on record as secondary
evidence. Thereafter, the plaintiff filed an application under Order XIV
Rule 5 of the CPC and time was given to the defendants to file a reply.
Signed by: RAVI PRAKASH
Signing time: 1/23/2024
5:38:11 PM
-3-
Vide order dated 21.01.2020, the application was dismissed. By the
same order, the applications filed under Order XVIII Rule 8 and Order
XXVI Rule 9 by the defendants / State were also rejected. Now the
plaintiff filed an affidavit of Om Prakash Ojha under Order XVIII Rule
of the CPC on 04.02.2020.
2.5.
Defendants / State filed a counterclaim on 07.08.2021 seeking a
declaratory decree to the effect that the State Government is the owner
of the suit land and the order dated 17.01.2018 passed by the Board of
Revenue be declared void. The defendants also sought a decree of
possession by way of counterclaim.
2.6.
The plaintiff filed an application under Section 151 of the CPC
stating that the counterclaim cannot be taken on record which is time
barred because the cause of action arose on 17.01.2018. The defendants
could have filed the counterclaim along with the written statement,
hence, the order to that effect be passed that this counterclaim shall not
be entertained.
2.7.
Vide impugned order dated 20.09.2021, learned District Judge
dismissed the application under Section 151 of the CPC, meaning
thereby, counterclaim has been taken on record. Hence, the present
petition is before this Court.
03.
Shri Sethi, learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner submits that
the defendants had occasion to file a counterclaim along with the written
statement that was filed on 09.10.2018, thereafter, the issues have been
framed and the plaintiff has given evidence by way of an affidavit under
Order XVIII Rule 4 of the CPC, therefore, now the counterclaim under
Order VIII Rule 6-A cannot be taken on record. In support of his
contention, learned Senior Counsel placed reliance upon a judgment
delivered by the Apex Court in the case of Ashok Kumar Kalra v/s
Signed by: RAVI PRAKASH
Signing time: 1/23/2024
5:38:11 PM
-4-
Wing CDR. Surendra Agnihotri & Others reported in (2020) 2 SCC
394, in which it has been held that in any case counterclaim cannot be
taken on record after framing the issues.
04.
Shri Kibe, learned Panel Lawyer for the respondents / State
submits that there is no much progress in the suit after framing the
issues in the civil suit. The plaintiff's witness has not been crossexamined till date. The claim in respect of valuable land belonging to
the State Government is being made by way of counterclaim, therefore,
the State Government cannot be non-suited by rejecting the
counterclaim. Even otherwise fresh suit is also maintainable but that will
lead to multiple litigation, hence, all the issues are liable to be decided in
one proceedings
05.
Shri Rohit Mangal, learned counsel for respondent No.4 /
Corporation, which is a formal party in this case, argued in support of
the State by submitting that the time limit prescribed for submitting a
counterclaim is based upon the accrual of the cause of action, however,
in the present case cause of action was accrued on 17.01.2018. In the
present case, counterclaim was filed based on the cause of action which
was accrued on 17.01.2018 and at that time neither the defendants /
State delivered their defence nor the time limit for delivering the
defence was expired. It is further submitted in the case of Ashok Kumar
Kalra (supra), in paragraph – 21, the Apex Court observed that lis
provided in the judgment is not exhaustive and it is illustrative,
therefore, no interference is called for hence misc. petition is liable to be
dismissed.
06.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties at length and
perused the record.
07.
Signed by: RAVI PRAKASH
Signing time: 1/23/2024
5:38:11 PM
The plaintiff by way of a civil suit claiming a declaration of title
-5-
of the suit land. The defendants / State is also claiming title by way of
counterclaim. The controversy started between the parties and the
plaintiff is claiming ownership by virtue of Section 20 of Jagirdari
Abolition Act, 1951 as the plaintiff and his predecessors were Pakka
Krishak. The defendants came with a plea that the suit land was allotted
by way of lease for the establishment of the Ginning Factory, therefore,
the State Government has the right to cancel the lease under Section 182
of the MPLRC.
08.
Litigation began when the notice was served by the defendants /
State to the father of the plaintiff on 07.02.1982 followed by another
notice dated 06.05.1989 and the matter travelled up to the Board of
Revenue and in between, couple of writ petitions were filed before this
Court. For the filing of a suit by the plaintiff, the cause of action arose
on 06.04.2016 and for the defendants, the cause of action for filing the
counterclaim accrued on 17.01.2018, when the Board of Revenue
passed an order. The trial Court has already framed the issues for
deciding the title of the plaintiff, therefore, simultaneously, by way of
the same set of evidence, the title of the State Government can be
decided, for which the State Government need not to file a separate suit.
Therefore, in order to avoid the multiplicity of the suit and conflict of
verdict, suit and counterclaim both are liable to be decided together.
09.
So far as the contention of the plaintiff that limitation for filing a
counterclaim had expired is concerned, the same can be examined by
framing additional issues. In paragraph – 19 of the judgment delivered
in the case of Ashok Kumar Kalra (supra), the Apex Court has held that
the ''discretion vested with the trial Court to ascertain the
maintainability of the counterclaim is limited by various considerations
based on facts and circumstances of each case and there cannot be a
Signed by: RAVI PRAKASH
Signing time: 1/23/2024
5:38:11 PM
-6-
straitjacket formula, rather there are numerous factor which needs to be
taken into consideration before admitting the counterclaim. The
trial
Court has to exercise the discretion judiciously and come to the
conclusion that by allowing the counterclaim, no prejudice is caused to
the opposite party, the process is not unduly delayed and the same is in
the best interest of justice''. The Apex Court, however, has opined that
''defendants cannot be permitted to file the counterclaim after the issues
are framed and after the suit has proceeded substantially''. Therefore,
there are twin requirements (i) the issues have been framed and (ii) the
suit has proceeded substantially.
11.
In the present case, although the issues have been framed, but
there is no substantial progress in the suit as only one witness of the
plaintiff has filed an affidavit under Order XVIII Rule 4 of the CPC and
cross-objection has not begun so far. Since the order passed by the trial
Court neither suffers from illegality nor any infirmity, I do not find any
reason to interfere with the same.
12.
In view of the above, Miscellaneous Petition stands dismissed.
(VIVEK RUSIA)
JUDGE
Ravi
Signed by: RAVI PRAKASH
Signing time: 1/23/2024
5:38:11 PM
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review