Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No. 979 of 2022
Shri Krishna Bhatta
……Petitioner
Vs.
The State of Tripura and 2 Ors.
……Respondents
For the Petitioner(s)
:
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. T.D. Majumder, Sr. Advocate
Mr. T. Halam, Advocate
Mr. D. Bhattacharya, G.A
Mr. P. Saha, Advocate
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
Order
17/11/2022
Heard Mr. T.D. Majumder, learned senior counsel assisted
by Mr. T. Halam, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner. Also
heard Mr. D. Bhattacharya, learned G.A assisted by Mr. P. Saha,
learned counsel appearing for the respondents no.1 to 6 and Mr. A.
Bhaumik, learned counsel appearing for the respondent no.7.
2.
The fact of the case is that the petitioner, Sri Krishna Bhatta,
serving as a Law Clerk, posted in the Office of the Public
Prosecutor, High Court of Tripura, has challenged his transfer order
dated 19th September, 2020. By the said impugned order, the
petitioner had been transferred and asked to join in the Office of the
Public Prosecutor and Government Pleader, Gomati District,
Udaipur. He was asked to join new place of posting on or before
28.09.2020. On receipt of the said transfer order, the petitioner had
filed a writ petition before this Court which was registered as
WP(C) No. 624 of 2020, titled as Sri Krishna Bhatta vs. The State
of Tripura and Ors. The matter was substantially heard and
disposed of by order dated 25.09.2020.
The learned Single Judge while disposing of the petition took
note of the substance of challenge which may be reproduced herein-below, in verbatim:
“[4] The background leading to the petitioner’s
appointment to the post in question is that under order
dated 26th April, 2002 the petitioner was appointed on a
contractual basis under the Law Department of
Government of Tripura on a fixed pay and posted in the
Office of the Public Prosecutor, Gauhati High Court,
Agartala Bench. Subsequently, under order dated 20th
December, 2007 he was appointed to the post of Law
Clerk,
Group-C
under
Legal
Remembrance
Establishment under Law Department, Government of
Tripura on fixed pay basis. The petitioner filed W.P(C) No.
77/2010 before the Gauhati High Court, Agartala Bench
for grant of regular pay scale. This petition was disposed
of by a judgment dated 06.04.2011. Respondents were
directed to pass appropriate order bearing in mind the
observations made in the said order. Pursuant to the said
judgment Government of Tripura issued an offer of
appointment titled as a memorandum dated 31.10.2011.
The petitioner was appointed on a temporary post of Law
Clerk (Group-C) in the L.R establishment under the Law
Department of Government of Tripura in pay scale of
Rs.4200 – 8650/-(pre-revised) w.e.f 27.04.2007. The terms
and conditions of appointment specified that the
appointment carries the liability of the appointee to serve
in any part of the State of Tripura. Subsequently, the
Government issued order dated 7th February,
2012 appointing the petitioner to the said post, initially on
probation which would last for a period of two years. The
said order recorded that the petitioner should report to the
Office of the Public Prosecutor, Gauhati High Court,
Agartala Bench for performing duties as may be
assigned to him.
[5] It is thus clear that the petitioner was appointed on the
said post of Law Clerk under Legal Remembrance
Establishment under the Law Department, Government of
Tripura and not as a Law Clerk to the
Public Prosecutor, Gauhati High Court, Agartala Bench
or subsequently upon establishment of an independent
High Court of the State, as Law Clerk to the Public
Prosecutor, High Court of Tripura. The offer of
appointment clearly specified that the appointee will have
to serve in any part of the State. The memorandum dated
7th February, 2012 clearly specified that the petitioner
should report to the Office of Public Prosecutor of the
Gauhati High Court, Agartala Bench for performing
duties as may be assigned to him. There is nothing on the
record that the Government of Tripura created a special
post of Law Clerk to the Public Prosecutor and on which
single cadre post the petitioner was appointed
without any liability to work anywhere else.
[6] Reference to the internal notes of the Government by
the counsel of the petitioner, would not persuade me to
change this impression. In the note dated 28.02.2009 while
recommending absorption of the petitioner in the
Government service looking to his satisfactory
past service, it was suggested that the petitioner is dealing
with the matters relating to the Court cases since six years
in the office of the Public Prosecutor and therefore is
entitled for being granted regular pay scale. It is
equivalent to the scale as defined to the Law Clerk under
Health and Family Welfare Department. In a further note
dated 05.03.2009 the Law Secretary noted that the request
of the Law Department was to create a post of Law Clerk
along the same line as in the case of Health and Family
Welfare Department. However, his suggestion was turned
down by the Finance Department. It was opined
that the said decision was unreasonable. Neither of these
two notes would show that any said post exclusively
attached to the Public Prosecutor, High Court of Tripura
was created. All that it shows is that the Law
Department was of the opinion that the petitioner should
be placed in a pay scale which is attached to the Law
Clerk of the Family Welfare Department, Government of
Tripura and that the decision of the Finance
Department to refuse the request is unfortunate. Even
otherwise these notes are in the nature of internal
deliberations
and
do
not
form
the
final
decision of the Government what culminate into the final
decision was an offer of appointment to the petitioner as a
Law Clerk under Legal Remembrance establishment of the
Law Department of Government of Tripura. His offer of
appointment besides clarifying that the appointee
shall have thus all Tripura transfer liability, did not
anywhere specify that his post is that of Law Clerk to the
Public Prosecutor, High Court of Tripura. The contention
of the counsel of the petitioner that this is an
isolated post which no transfer liability cannot be
accepted. Even the reference to the decision of the cabinet
to approve Note No.5 in its meeting dated 5.9.2007 would
change this position. Note in question which the cabinet
approved was as under:
“Creation of 1(one) post of Law Clerk in the Legal
Remembrancer’s Establishment for the Office of the Public
Prosecutor, Gauhati High Court, Agartala Bench to
regularize the service of Shri Krishna Bhatta under Law
Department. (Law Deptt. File No.F.1((6)-LAW/ESTT –
3/02/46 dated 30.08.07).
Going by this decision also, we gather that the cabinet
approved the creation of 1(one) post of Law Clerk in the
Legal Remembrance Establishment in the Office of Public
Prosecutor to regularize the petitioner. This does not
indicate that the petitioner cannot be posted anywhere or
assigned work on equivalent post.
[7] In that view of the matter this petition is dismissed.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.”
3.
I have meticulously perused and considered the above
findings of the learned Judge. What culminates from the aforesaid
discussion and decision is that the learned Single Judge clearly
came to a finding that the terms and conditions of appointment
specified that the appointment carried the liability of the appointee
to serve in any part of the State of Tripura. It was further observed
and clarified that there is nothing on the record that the
Government of Tripura created a special post of law clerk to the
Public Prosecutor and on such Single Cadre post the petitioner was
appointed without any liability to work anywhere else. Clarifying
the submission of learned counsel appearing for the petitioner in
the earlier round of litigation, which submission has also been reiterated by learned senior counsel in this petition that his offer of
appointment clarified that the appointee shall have all Tripura
transfer liability, and nowhere it was specified that his post of Law
Clerk is only limited to the office of the Public Prosecutor, High
Court of Tripura.
4.
The learned Single Judge had repelled the contention of the
counsel of the petitioner in earlier writ petition that the post of Law
Clerk attached to the Office of the Public Prosecutor is an isolated
post having no transfer liability. The learned Single Judge also
interpreted the language used by the Cabinet that “Creation of
1(one) post of Law Clerk in the Legal Remembrancer’s
Establishment for the Office of the Public Prosecutor, Gauhati
High Court, Agartala Bench to regularize the service of Shri
Krishna Bhatta under Law Department. (Law Deptt. File
No.F.1((6)-LAW/ESTT – 3/02/46 dated 30.08.07)”. Ultimately, it
was held that the said note did not indicate that the petitioner could
not be posted anywhere or assigned work on equivalent post.
Accordingly, the earlier writ petition was dismissed by learned
Single Judge.
5.
Mr. Majumder, learned senior counsel has strongly
emphasized on the reply dated 23.08.2022 obtained under R.T.I.
application. In the reply, the Information Officer has stated that it is
a single post. On the basis of this reply, Mr. Majumder has tried to
persuade this Court that since it is a single post, it cannot be
equated with multiple posts.
6.
Having gone through the judgment of the learned Single
Judge in WP(C) No.624 of 2020, which was reproduced here-inabove, I cannot agree with this submission of the learned senior
counsel. The petitioner was basically appointed under the
Establishment of Legal Remambrancer and he was only posted to
the Office of Public Prosecutor where one post was created for Law
Clerk.
7.
In my opinion, this creation of one post attached to the
Public Prosecutor of the then Gauhati High Court does not mean
that he cannot be posted anywhere in the State of Tripura, when in
his appointment letter itself it is written that he can be transferred in
any part of the State and needless to say, that the office of the
Public Prosecutor/ Government Pleader at Gomati District, Udaipur
is also under the direct control of Legal Remembrancer, Govt. of
Tripura.
8.
Mr. Majumder, learned senior counsel has submitted that
learned Single Judge while disposing of the WP(C) No.624 of 2020
could not have an opportunity to deal with the established fact that
the post of Law Clerk is a single post as surfaced under RTI reply,
and for that reason, Ld. Judge did not accept the submission of the
Ld. Counsel in the earlier litigation that it was single post. I have
given due consideration to the submission of Mr. Datta Majumder,
Ld. Senior counsel. In view of the discussion made in the preceding
paragraphs, I do not find any merit in the aforesaid submission.
9.
In the above conspectus, the instant writ petition is
dismissed. However, there shall be no order as to costs.
JUDGE
Snigdha
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review