Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
signed by
SHAMURAILATPA Digitally
SHAMURAILATPAM SUSHIL
M SUSHIL SHARMA SHARMA
Date: 2022.12.05 12:40:37 +05'30'
Page |1
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017
1.
Shri K. Meghachandra Singh aged about 44 years,
S/o. (L) K. Lukhoi Singh, a resident of Okshongbung
Leikai, PO & PS Moirang, Bishnupur District,
Manipur.
2.
Shri Thokchom Vikramjit Singh, aged about 43
years, S/o. (L) Thh. Navakumar Singh, resident of
Sagolmang Mamang Leikai, PO & PS Lamlai,
Imphal East District, Manipur.
3.
Shri Wahengbam Singhajeet Singh, aged about 43
years, resident of Nambol Khathong, PO & PS
Nambol, Bishnupur District, Manipur.
… PETITIONER
-VERSUS-
1.
The State of Manipur represented by the Chief
Secretary,
Department
Administrative
Reforms
of
Personnel
(Personnel
and
Division)
Government of Manipur.
2.
The Addl. Chief Secretary (Home), Government of
Manipur.
3.
The Director General of Police, Government of
Manipur
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
Page |2
4.
The Manipur Public Service Commission (MPSC)
through the Secretary.
…RESPONDENTS
5.
T. Arunkumar Singh.
6.
S. Nandakishore Singh
7.
Sh. Jugeshore Sharma
8.
R.K. Khomdon Singh
9.
S. Somorjit Singh
10. Th. Nungsi Singh.
11. W. Mubi Singh.
12. Th. Sarat Singh.
13. K. Mangi Singh.
14. S. Surendra Sharma.
15. L. Kulachandra Singh.
16. S. Shamu Singh (SC)
17. Akhuba Kabui (ST).
18. Thamei Gaipuiril Kabui.
19. S. Ingo Singh.
20. S. Punyaban Singh.
21. S. Meghachandra Singh.
22. H. Gyaneshore Singh.
23. M. Kumarjit Singh.
24. Y. Rajendro Singh.
25. P. Binod Ranjan Singh.
26. I. Chitaranjan Singh.
27. Mangkhojang Kipgen.
28. Seikhomang Touthang.
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
Page |3
29. K. Ajitkumar Singh.
30. N. Manglemba Singh.
31. H. Jitendra Singh.
32. N. Dhange Meetei.
33. K. Pukehao Mao.
34. L. Thangboi Kuki (ST).
35. N. Angam Ningsiam (ST).
36. S. Ashok Kumar Singh.
37. Ksh. Rajendra Singh.
38. T. Thangjapao (ST).
39. H. Pearlson TKL.
40. Ningam Siro.
41. N.L. Kongam Anal (ST)
… PRIVATE RESPONDENTS
WP(C) No. 346 of 2021
Lunkhomang Khongsai, aged about 43 years,
S/o Lhunhol Khongsai, resident of Langching
Village, P.O. & P.S. Sugnu, Chandel District,
Manipur. Pin: 795127;
2.
S. David Piaklian, aged about 39 years, S/O S.
Thuamza Dam, resident of New Lamka, P.O. &
P.S. Churchandpur, Churchandpur District,
Manipur, PIN 795128;
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
Page |4
3.
Luikham Lanmiyo, aged about 41 years, S/O L.
Asing, Addl. SP, Bishnupur, Bishnupur District,
P.O. & P.S. Bishnupur, Manipur, Pin: 795134;
4.
Sarangthem Ibomcha Singh, aged about 45
years, S/o (L) S. Kulla Singh, resident of Kongba
Uchekon, P.O. Imphal, P.S. Porompat, Imphal
East District, Manipur, Pin: 795005;
5.
Watham Basu Singh aged about 37 years, S/O
W.
Brajachand
Singh,
resident
of
Thangmeiband Watham Leirak, P.O. Lamphel,
P.S. Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur, Pin:
795004;
6.
Wahengbam Singhajit Singh, aed avout 47
years, resident of Nambol Khathong, P.O. &
P.S. Nambol, Bishnupur District, Manipur,
Pin:795134;
7.
Rajkumar
Manbindu
Singh,
aged
about,
resident of Sangolband Ingudam Leirak, P.O. &
P.S. Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur, Pin:
795001;
8.
Polem Manjit Singh, aged about 39 years, S/O
P. Ranjit Singh, Khoyathong Polem Leikai, P.O.
& P.S. Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur,
PIN: 795001;
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
Page |5
9.
K. Meghachandra Singh, aged about 48 years,
S/O
(L)
K.
Lukhoi
Singh,
resident
of
Okshongbung Leikai, P.O. & P.S. Moirang,
Bishnupur District, Manipur, Pin: 795133
… PETITIONERS.
-VERSUS1.
The Union Public Service Commission through
its Secretary, having its office at Dholpur House
Shahjahan Road New Delhi, Chanakyapuri,
New Delhi, Pin: 110069;
2.
Department of Personnel and Training (DoPT)
through its Secretary having its office at North
Block, Central Secretariat, New Delhi, Pin:
110001;
3.
The Ministry of Home Affairs through its
Secretary having its office at North Block,
Raisina Hill, Delhi, Pin: 110001;
4.
The State of Manipur represented by Chief
Secretary,
Department
of
Personnel
and
Administrative Reforms (Personnel Division),
Government of Manipur, having its office at
Secretariat Building, Babupara, P.O. & P.S.
Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur, Pin:
795001
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
Page |6
5.
The Joint Secretary (D.P.) Government of
Manipur,
having
its
office
at
Secretariat
Building, Babupara, P.O. & P.S. Imphal, Imphal
West District, Manipur, Pin:795001
… OFFICIAL RESPONDENTS
6.
Ningam Siro S/O (L) Thodai Siro Leishiphung
Vill. A/P Tribal Colony, Qtr. No. 6/III Checkon,
Imphal East District, Manipur, Pin: 795005;
7.
S. Somorjit Singh, Commandant 8th MR, Leikun,
P.O. & P.S. Chandel, Chandel District, Manipur,
Pin 795127;
8.
L. Deben Singh aged about 53 years, S/O L.
Tompok Singh of Khoyathong Polem Leikai,
P.O. & P.S. Imphal, District, Imphal West,
Manipur, Pin: 795001;
9.
A. Ghanashyam Sharma, Superintendent of
Police, Jiribam, Jiribam District, Manipur; Pin:
795116;
10. Jemkhansuan Paite, Commandant 6 MR,
Ukhrul, Pin: 795142;
11. Ch. Adani Mao Superintendent of Police.
Kamjong, Kamjong District, Manipur, Pin:
795145;
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
Page |7
12. M. Kumarjit Singh, Commandant 6 IRB, Pangei,
Imphal East District, Manipur, Pin: 795005;
13. I. Chitaranjan Singh Superintendent of Police,
CPCR near 1st MR Jail Road, Imphal, Imphal
West District Manipur, Pin: 795001;
14. Mangkhojang Kipgen Commandant 7 IRB,
Uchathon,
Jiribam
District,
Manipur,
Pin:
795116;
15. Seikhomang
Touthang
Assistant
Director
Manipur Police Training Centre, Pangei, Imphal
East District Manipur, Pin: 795005;
16. K. Ajit Kumar Sharma Superintendent of Police
Ukhrul, Ukhrul District, Manipur, Pin: 795142;
17. L. Thangboi Kuki Assistant Director, Manipur
Police Training Centre, Pangei, Imphal East
District, Manipur, Pin: 795005;
18. Angam Ninghian Superintendent of Police
Immigration, C/O Police Head Quarter, Imphal,
Manipur, Pim:795001 and
19. T.
Thongjapao
Commandant
2nd
IRB,
Naransena, Bishnupur District, Manipiur, Pin:
795134
… PRIVATE RESPONDENTS
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
Page |8
WP(C) No. 923 of 2021
1. Polem Manjit Singh, aged about 39 years, S/o P.
Ranjit Singh a resident of Khoyathong Polem Leikai,
P.O. & P.S. Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur795001.
2. Dr. Sarangthem Ibomcha Singh, aged about 49
years, S/o (L) S. Kulla Singh, a resident of Kongba
Uchekon P.O. Imphal, P.S. Porompat, Imphal East
District, Manipur-795001.
3. Victoria Yengkhom, aged about 41 years,
D/o
Yengkhom Pushkar Singh presently residing at Qtr
No.6, Manipur Police Housing Corporation Ltd.,
Imphal-795001.
4. Rashini Yengkhom, aged about 47 years, D/o Y.
Nimai Singh a resident of Kakching Turel Wangma,
P.O. & P.S. Kakching, Kakching District, Manipur.
5. Sarangthem Asana, aged about 38 years, d/o
Sarangthem Dinokumar a resident of Haobam
Marak Keisham Leikai, P.O. & P.S. Imphal, Imphal
West District, Manipur.
6. Bembem Nongthombam, aged about 37 years, D/o
N. Dilipkumar Singh a resident of Moirangkhom
Makha Loklaobung, P.O. & P.S. Imphal, Imphal
West District, Manipur.
… Petitioners
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
Page |9
- Versus 1. The
State
of
Manipur
through
the
Chief
Secretary/Special Secretary/ Commissioner (DP &
AR) Government of Manipur, Secretariat, South
Block, Babupara, P.O. & P.S. Imphal, Imphal West
District, Manipur-795001.
2. The Chief Secretary (Home), Government of
Manipur, Secretariat Building, Babupara P.O. & P.S.
Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur-795001.
3. The
Manipur
Public
Service
Commission
represented by its Secretary, North A.O.C., P.O. &
P.S. Imphal-795001.
4. The Union of India represented by the Secretary,
Department of Personnel and Training (DoPT),
Government of India, North Block , Central
Secretariat, New Delhi-110001
5. The Secretary, Ministry of Home Affairs, North
Block, Rasina Hill, Delhi-110001.
6. Union Public Service Commission through its
Secretary, Dholpur House Shahjahan Road New
Delhi, Chanakyapuri, New Delhi-110069.
… Respondents.
7. Shri T. Arunkumar Singh
8. S. Nandakishore Singh
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 10
9. Thamei Gaipuiril Kabui
10. Sh. Jugeshore Sharma
11. R.K. Khomdon Singh
12. S.Somorjit Singh
13. Th. Nungshi Singh
14. W. Mubi Singh
15. L. Deben Singh
16. A. Ghanashyam Sharma
17. Th. Sarat Singh
18. K. Mangi Singh
19. A.Surendra Sharma
20. L. Kulachandra Singh
21. S. Shamu Singh(SC)
22. Akhuba Kabui (ST)
23. S. Ingo Singh
24. S. Punyaban Singh
25. S. Meghachandra Singh
26. H. Gyaneshore Singh
27. M. Kumarjit Singh
28. Y. Rajendro Singh
29. P. Binod Ranjan Singh
30. I. Chitaranjan Singh
31. Mangkhojang Kipgen
32. Seikhomang Thouthang (ST)
33. K. Ajitkumar Sharma
34. N. Manglemba Singh
35. K. Pukehao Mao
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 11
36. L. Thangboi Kuki(ST)
37. N. Angam Ningsiam (ST)
38. T. Thongjapao (ST)
39. JS Peter Makanmi (ST)
40. H. Pearlson TKL
41. Ningam Siro
42. N.L. Kongam Anal (ST)
43. Swelling Hope Chiru
44. G. Jemkhansuan Paite(ST)
45. Ch. Adani Mao(ST)
46. Ginjamang Vaphei(ST)
…Private Respondents
MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022
REF: - (i) W.P. (C) NO. 923 OF 2021; and
(ii) MC(WP(C)) NO. 317 OF 2021
1.
Salam Somorjit Singh, MPS, aged about 56
years, S/o (L) S. Ningthemjao Singh a resident of
Sagolband Sayang Kurao Makhong, PO & PS
Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur – 795001;
2.
Adhikarimayum Ghanashyam Sharma, aged
about 56 years, S/o. (L) A. Mani Sharma of
Brahmapur Aribam Leikai, PO & PS Porompat,
Imphal East District, Manipur – 795005;
3.
Shamurailatpam Jugeshwor Sharma, aged
about 59 years, S/o. (L) Sh. Shamungou Sharma
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 12
of Khongman Mangjil Mamang Kongba Road, PO
Porompat, PS Irilbung, Imphal East District,
Manipur – 795005.
… APPLICANTS
-VERSUS1.
Shri Polem Manjit Singh, aged about 39 years,
S/o. P Ranjit Singh a resident of Khoyathong
Polem Leikai, PO & PS Imphal, Imphal West
District, Manipur – 795001.
2.
Dr. Sarangthem Ibomcha Singh, aged about 49
years, S/o (L) Kulla Singh, a resident of Kongba
Uchekon, P.O. Imphal, P.S. Porompat, Imphal
East District, Manipur-795001.
3.
Victoria Yengkhom, aged about 41 years, D/o
Yengkhom Pushkar Singh presently residing at
Qtr. No. 6, Manipur Police Housing Corporation
Ltd., Imphal-795001.
4.
Rashini Yengkhom aged about 47 years, D/o Y.
Nimai Singh a resident of Kakching Turel
Wangma, P.O. & P.S. Kakching, Kakching
District, Manipur.
5.
Sarangthem Asana, aged about 38 years, D/o
Sarangthem Dinokumar a resident of Haobam
Marak, Keisham Leikai, P.O. & P.S. Imphal,
Imphal West District, Manipur.
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 13
6.
Bembem Nongthombam, aged about 37 years,
D/o
N.
Dilipkumar
Singh
a
resident
of
Moirangkhom Makha Loklaobung, P.O & P.S.
Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur.
…RESPONDENTS
7.
The
State
of
Manipur
through
the Chief
Secretary/ Special Secretary/ Commissioner (DP
&AR) Government of Manipur, Secretariat, South
Block, Babupara, P.O. & P.S. Imphal, Imphal
West District, Manipur - 795001.
8.
The Chief Secretary (Home), Government of
Manipur, Secretariat Building, Babupara, P.O. &
P.S. Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur795001.
9.
The
Manipur
Public
Service
Commission
represented by its Secretary, North A.O.C., P.O.
& P.S. Imphal - 795001.
10. The Union of India represented by the Secretary
Department of Personnel and Training (DoPT),
Government of India, North Block, Central
Secretariat, New Delhi - 110069.
11. The Secretary, Ministry of Home Affairs, North
Block, Rasina Hill, Delhi - 110001.
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 14
12. Union Public Service Commission through its
Secretary, Dholpur House Shahjahan Road New
Delhi, Chanakyapuri, New Delhi - 110069.
13. Shri T. Arunkumar Singh.
14. S. Nandakishore Singh.
15. Thamei Gaipuiril Kabui.
16. R.K. Kohomdon Singh.
17. Th. Nungshi Singh.
18. W. Mubi Singh.
19. I. Deben Singh.
20. Th. Sarat Singh.
21.
K. Mangi Singh
22. A. Surendra Sharma
23. L. Kulachandra Singh
24. S. Shamu Singh(SC)
25. Akhuba Kabui (ST)
26. S. Ingo Singh
27.
S. Punyaban Singh
28. S. Meghachandra Singh
29. H Gyaneshore Singh
30. M. Kumarjit Singh
31. Y. Rajendro Singh
32. P. Binod Ranjan Singh
33. I. Chitaranjan Singh
34. Mangkhojang Kipgen
35. Seikhomang Thouthang (ST)
36. K. Ajitkumar Sharma
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 15
37. N. Manglemba Singh
38.
K. Pukehao Mao
39. L. Thangboi Kuki (ST)
40. N. Angam Ningsiam (ST)
41. T. Thongjapao (ST)
42. JS Peter Makanmi (ST)
43. H. Pearlson TKL
44. Ningam Siro
45. N.L. Kongam Anal (ST)
46. Swelling Hope Chiru
47. G. Jemkhansuan Paite (ST)
48. Ch. Adani Mao(ST)
49. Ginjamang Vaphei (ST)
… PROFORMA RESPONDENTS
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022
Ref:- WP(C) No. 346 of 2021
1. Lunkhomang Khongsai, aged about 43 years, S/o
Lhunhol Khongsai, resident of Langching Village,
P.O. & P.S. Sugnu, Chandel District, Manipur.
Pin: 795127;
2. S. David Piaklian, aged about 39 years, S/O S.
Thuamza Dam, resident of New Lamka, P.O. &
P.S.
Churchandpur,
Churchandpur
District,
Manipur, PIN 795128;
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 16
3. Luikham Lanmiyo, aged about 41 years, S/O L.
Asing, Addl. SP, Bishnupur, Bishnupur District,
P.O. & P.S. Bishnupur, Manipur, Pin: 795134;
4. Sarangthem Ibomcha Singh, aged about 45
years, S/o (L) S. Kulla Singh, resident of Kongba
Uchekon, P.O. Imphal, P.S. Porompat, Imphal
East District, Manipur, Pin: 795005;
5. Watham Basu Singh aged about 37 years, S/O
W. Brajachand Singh, resident of Thangmeiband
Watham Leirak, P.O. Lamphel, P.S. Imphal,
Imphal West District, Manipur, Pin: 795004;
6. Wahengbam Singhajit Singh, aed avout 47 years,
resident of Nambol Khathong, P.O. & P.S.
Nambol,
Bishnupur
District,
Manipur,
Pin:795134;
7. Rajkumar Manbindu Singh, aged about, resident
of Sangolband Ingudam Leirak, P.O. & P.S.
Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur, Pin:
795001;
8. Polem Manjit Singh, aged about 39 years, S/O P.
Ranjit Singh, Khoyathong Polem Leikai, P.O. &
P.S. Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur, PIN:
795001;
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 17
9. K. Meghachandra Singh, aged about 48 years,
S/O
(L)
K.
Lukhoi
Singh,
resident
of
Okshongbung Leikai, P.O. & P.S. Moirang,
Bishnupur District, Manipur, Pin: 795133
… PETITIONERS.
-VERSUS1.
The Union Public Service Commission through
its Secretary, having its office at Dholpur House
Shahjahan Road New Delhi, Chanakyapuri,
New Delhi, Pin: 110069;
2.
Department of Personnel and Training (DoPT)
through its Secretary having its office at North
Block, Central Secretariat, New Delhi, Pin:
110001;
3.
The Ministry of Home Affairs through its
Secretary having its office at North Block,
Raisina Hill, Delhi, Pin: 110001;
4.
The State of Manipur represented by Chief
Secretary,
Department
of
Personnel
and
Administrative Reforms (Personnel Division),
Government of Manipur, having its office at
Secretariat Building, Babupara, P.O. & P.S.
Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur, Pin:
795001
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 18
5.
The Joint Secretary (D.P.) Government of
Manipur,
having
its
office
at
Secretariat
Building, Babupara, P.O. & P.S. Imphal, Imphal
West District, Manipur, Pin:795001
… OFFICIAL RESPONDENTS
6.
Ningam Siro S/O (L) Thodai Siro Leishiphung
Vill. A/P Tribal Colony, Qtr. No. 6/III Checkon,
Imphal East District, Manipur, Pin: 795005;
7.
S. Somorjit Singh, Commandant 8th MR, Leikun,
P.O. & P.S. Chandel, Chandel District, Manipur,
Pin 795127;
8.
L. Deben Singh aged about 53 years, S/O L.
Tompok Singh of Khoyathong Polem Leikai,
P.O. & P.S. Imphal, District, Imphal West,
Manipur, Pin: 795001;
9.
A. Ghanashyam Sharma, Superintendent of
Police, Jiribam, Jiribam District, Manipur; Pin:
795116;
10. Jemkhansuan Paite, Commandant 6 MR,
Ukhrul, Pin: 795142;
11. Ch. Adani Mao Superintendent of Police.
Kamjong, Kamjong District, Manipur, Pin:
795145;
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 19
12. M. Kumarjit Singh, Commandant 6 IRB, Pangei,
Imphal East District, Manipur, Pin: 795005;
13. I. Chitaranjan Singh Superintendent of Police,
CPCR near 1st MR Jail Road, Imphal, Imphal
West District Manipur, Pin: 795001;
14. Mangkhojang Kipgen Commandant 7 IRB,
Uchathon,
Jiribam
District,
Manipur,
Pin:
795116;
15. Seikhomang
Touthang
Assistant
Director
Manipur Police Training Centre, Pangei, Imphal
East District Manipur, Pin: 795005;
16. K. Ajit Kumar Sharma Superintendent of Police
Ukhrul, Ukhrul District, Manipur, Pin: 795142;
17. L. Thangboi Kuki Assistant Director, Manipur
Police Training Centre, Pangei, Imphal East
District, Manipur, Pin: 795005;
18. Angam Ninghian Superintendent of Police
Immigration, C/O Police Head Quarter, Imphal,
Manipur, Pim:795001 and
19. T.
Thongjapao
Commandant
2nd
IRB,
Naransena, Bishnupur District, Manipiur, Pin:
795134
… PRIVATE RESPONDENTS
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 20
MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
Ref:- (i) WP(C) No. 923 of 2021
(ii) MC(WP(C)) No. 317 of 2021
Lourembam Deben Singh aged about 57 years S/o
L. Tompok Singh presently serving as Manipur
Police Training , resident of Khuyathong Polem
Leikai, P.O. & P.S.- Lamphel, Imphal West District,
Manipur.
…..Applicant
-VERSUS1.
Polem Manjit Singh, aged about 39 years, S/o.
P. Ranjit Singh, a resident of Khoyathong
Polem Leikai, PO & PS Imphal, Imphal West
District, Manipur-795001;
2.
Dr. Sarangthem Ibomcha Singh, aged about
49 years, S/o (L) Kulla Singh, a resident of
Kongba
Uchekon,
P.O.
Imphal,
P.S.
Porompat, Imphal East District, Manipur795001;
3.
Victoria Yengkhom, aged about 41 years, D/o
Yengkhom Puskar Singh, presently residing at
Qtr No. 6, Manipur Police Housing Corporation
Ltd., Imphal-795001;
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 21
4.
Rashini Yengkhom aged about 47 years, D/o
Y. Nimai Singh, a resident of Kakching Turel
Wangma, P.O. & P.S. Kakching, Kakching
District Manipur.
5.
Sarangthem Asana, aged about 38 years, D/o
Sarangthem Dinokumar, a resident of Hoabam
Marak, Keisham Leikai, P.O. & P.S. Imphal,
Imphal West District, Manipur.
6.
Bembem Nongthombam, aged about 37
years, D/o N. Dilipkumar Singh, a resident of
Moirangkhom Makha Loklaobung, P.O. & P.S.
Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur.
…. Respondents
7.
The State of Manipur, through the Chief
Secretary/Special Secretary Commissioner
(DP
&
AR),
Government
of
Manipur,
Secretariat, South Block, Babupara, P.O. &
P.S. Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur795001;
8.
The Chief Secretary (Home), Government of
Manipur, Secretariat Building, Babupara,
P.O. & P.S. Imphal, Imphal West District,
Manipur -795001;
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 22
9.
The Manipur Public Service Commission,
represented by its Secretary, North A.O.C.,
P.O. & P.S. Imphal-795001;
10.
The Union of India, represented by the
Secretary, Department of Personnel and
Training (DoPT), Government of India, North
Block,
Central
Secretariat,
New
Delhi-
110069;
11.
The Secretary, Ministry of Home Affairs, Noth
Block, Rasina Hill, Delhi -11001;
12.
Union Public Service Commission through its
Secretary, Dholpur House Shajahan Road,
New
Delhi,
Chanakyapuri,
New
Delhi-
110069;
13.
Shri T, Arunkumar Singh;
14.
S. Nandakishore Singh;
15.
Thamei Gaipuiril Kabui;
16.
Sh Jugeshore Singh;
17.
R.K. Khomdon Singh;
18.
S. Somorjit Singh;
19.
Th Nungshi Singh;
20.
W. Mubi Singh
21.
A. Ghanashyam Sharma
22.
Th Sarat Singh
23.
K. Mangi Singh’
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 23
24.
A. Surendra Sharma
25.
L. Kulachandra Singh
26.
S. Shamu Singh (SC)
27.
Akhuba Kabui (ST)
28.
S. Ingo Singh
29.
S. Punyaban Singh
30.
S. Meghachandra Singh
31.
H. Gyaneshore Singh
32.
M. Kumarjit Singh
33.
Y. Rajendro Singh
34.
P. Binod Ranjan Singh
35.
I. Chitaranjan Singh
36.
Mangkhojang Kipgen
37.
Seikhomang Thouthang (ST)
38.
K. Ajitkumar Sharma
39.
N. Manglemba Singh
40.
K. Pukehao Mao
41.
L. Thangboi Kuki (ST)
42.
N. Angam Ningsiam (ST)
43.
T. Thongjapao (ST)
44.
JS Peter Makanmi (ST)
45.
H. Pearlson TKL
46.
Nigam Siro
47.
N.L. Kongam Anal (ST)
48.
Swelling Hope Chiru
49.
G. Jemkhansuan Paite (ST)
50.
Ch. Adani mao (ST)
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 24
51.
Ginjamang Vaiphei (ST)
… PROFORMA RESPONDENTS
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE M.V. MURALIDARAN
For the Petitioner
::
Mr. HS Paonam, Sr. Adv.
For the Respondents
::
Mr. S. Biswajit, Advocate
Mr. O. Ratan Kumar, Advocate
Mr. A. Mohendro, Advocate
Mr. H. Debendra, GA
Mr. RS Reisang, Sr. Advocate
Date of Hearing and
reserving Judgment & Order ::
08.09.2022
Date of Judgment & Order ::
24.11.2022
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
(CAV)
W.P.(C) No.867 of 2017 has been filed by the
petitioners to set aside the impugned proceedings of the review
DPC meeting held on 1.7.2013 and 19.8.2016 and the orders
dated 18.10.2013 and 15.9.2016 and to restrain the respondents
from publishing final seniority list of MPS Grade-II on the basis of
tentative seniority list dated 15.9.2017.
2.
W.P.(C) No.346 of 2021 has been filed by the
petitioners to set aside the impugned placement order dated
31.3.2021 from MPS Grade-I to MPS Junior Administrative Officer
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 25
in respect of the private respondents issued by the Department of
P&AR (Personnel Division), Government of Manipur and to direct
the official respondents not to consider the private respondents in
their next induction to the cadre of Indian Police Service from
Manipur Police Service till the disposal of pending W.P.(C)
Nos.867 of 2017; 101 of 2021 and 885 of 2016.
3.
W.P.(C) No.923 of 2021 has been filed by the
petitioners to set aside the impugned proceedings of the DPC held
for promotion of 41 posts of MPS Grade-II dated 21.1.2007; review
proceedings held on 19.8.2016 along with promotion order dated
1.3.2007; orders dated 18.10.2013 and 15.9.2016 and to direct the
respondents not to give effect to the proceedings made on the
basis of the letter dated 28.5.2021 in any manner pending disposal
of the writ petition.
4.
Since the prayers made in these writ petitions are
intertwined with common petitioners and respondents and also the
issue involved is one and the same, all the writ petitions were
heard together and disposed of by this common order.
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 26
FACTS:
5.1.
The case of the petitioners in W.P.(C) No.867 of
2017 is that they are direct recruits selected through Manipur
Public Service Commission to the post of MPS Grade-II on
14.8.2007 and after completion of their training and discharging
their duties at various police stations in Manipur Police
Department in the capacity of SDPO, Assistant Commandant etc.,
they were promoted to the post of MPS Grade-I and were allowed
to discharge as in-charge Superintendent of Police and
Commandant in the Manipur Police and Manipur Rifles, including
the Indian Reserve Battalion. As per Rule 5(b) of the Manipur
Police Service Rules, 1965, the Inspector of Police/Subedar were
promoted to the post of MPS Grade-II vide Departmental
Promotion Committee (DPC) held on 12.1.2007 and its
recruitment process was initiated only in the month of January,
2007. 40 Inspectors of Police/Subedar promotees were promoted
to the post of MPS Grade-II on 1.3.2007 and on 25.8.2006 a
proposal was sent by the DGP to the Chief Secretary for
immediate filling up of vacancies in
MPS Grade-II under
promotion quota.
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 27
5.2.
Challenging the promotion order dated 1.3.2007,
aggrieved persons have filed W.P.(C) No.265 of 2007 before the
Gauhati High Court, Imphal Bench and the said writ petition was
allowed thereby quashing the promotions to the post of MPS
Grade-II. Challenging the order in W.P.(C) No.265 of 2007, writ
appeal, being W.A.No.174 of 2012 has been filed and the same
was dismissed on 13.9.2012. After setting aside the promotion
order, a review DPC was held on 1.7.2013 for promotion from
Inspector/Subedar
to
MPS
Grade-II
and
as
per
the
recommendation of the review DPC dated 1.7.2013, 40
Inspectors/ Subedars were promoted to the post of MPS Grade-II
by inserting 4 new incumbents and 4 Inspectors of Police/Subedar
who were already promoted in the DPC meeting held on 12.1.2007
have been reverted to their respective post with effect from
1.3.2007.
5.3.
According to the petitioners, aggrieved by the
proceedings of the review DPC dated 1.7.2013 and its promotion
order dated 18.10.2013, W.P.(C) No.816 of 2013 has been filed
and by the order dated 23.10.2015, this Court quashed the
proceedings of the review DPC dated 1.7.2013 and the promotion
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 28
order dated 18.10.2013 and, inter alia, directed for convening
review DPC to consider all the cases of eligible candidates who
were within the zone of consideration as on 12.1.2007 for
appointment to the post of MPS Grade-II. Consequently, review
DPC was held on 19.8.2016 for filling up of 41 vacant posts, for
the vacancy year 2005-2006 and 2006-2007 and the order dated
15.9.2016 was issued thereby promoting the private respondents
numbering 40 with effect from 1.3.2007. However, in the review
DPC meetings held on 1.7.2013 and 19.8.2016, the 19 posts for
50% of the deputation/training/leave reserve and 6 post for the
remaining 50% of vacancies going to be created by promotion of
12 MPS Grade-II officers to Grade-I on the basis of the DPC held
on 24.8.2006.
According to the petitioners,
the respondent
authorities published a tentative seniority list of the MPS on
15.9.2017 by placing the private respondents above the
petitioners. Challenging the same, the said writ petition has been
filed.
6.1.
The case of the petitioners in W.P.(C) No.346 of
2021 is that they are direct recruits selected through MPSC and
appointed on 14.8.2007 through direct recruitment. The private
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 29
respondents cannot claim their promotion under regular vacancy.
The DGP, Manipur and the Under Secretary (Home), Government
of Manipur have written a DPC Note to the higher authority for
filling up the vacant posts of 2 for 2005-2006 and 20 vacancies for
the year 2006-2007 and 19 posts for reserve posts like deputation
reserve/leave reserve and training reserve. Hence, the private
respondents cannot be above the petitioners in the final seniority
list of MPS in the Manipur Police Department.
The State
Government shall prepare a seniority list afresh in respect of MPS
officers as per the observation made in W.P.(C) No.366 of 2013.
6.2.
MPS
It is stated that while preparing the seniority list of
officers,
the
State
Government
shall
follow
the
guidelines/instructions contained in the Office Memorandum dated
7.2.1986 and 13.11.1987 as directed vide order dated 18.2.2013
passed in W.P.(C) No.235 of 2012. But the respondent authorities
published the final seniority list dated 21.12.2020 by violating Rule
28 and the Office Memorandum dated 29.4.1999 and challenging
the same, W.P.(C) No.101 of 2021 has been filed. The final
seniority list dated 21.12.2020 placing the MPS Grade-I to MPS
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 30
Grade-I Junior Administrative Officer (non-functional officer) was
issued on 31.3.2021 without considering the pending cases.
7.
The case of the petitioners in W.P.(C) No.923 of
2021 is that they are aggrieved by the inclusion of candidates
appointed
against
the
temporary
vacancies
(deputation/leave/training reserved vacancies) in the seniority list
by treating the temporary vacancies as substantive vacancies
while giving promotion to the post of MPS Grade-II in the year
2007. According to the petitioners, when DPC was held in 2007,
there was only 22 substantive vacancies for the promotion quota,
however,
by
taking
temporary
vacancies
(deputation/leave/training reserved vacancies) altogether 40
officers were appointed as MPS Grade-II on substantive
vacancies.
Thus, the officers appointed under the 19 category
vacancies cannot in any event be considered as officers borne on
the cadre because they have been recommended by the MPS
against temporary vacancies. Hence, W.P.(C) No.923 of 2021
has been filed for setting aside the impugned DPC proceedings
held for promotion to the post of MPS Grade-II in the year 2007
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 31
and its subsequent review DPC held in 2013 and 2016
respectively along with consequential orders.
8.1.
Resisting W.P.(C) No.867 of 2017, first respondent
State filed affidavit-in-opposition stating that as per the then
existing MPS (1st Amendment) Rules, 1996, appointment to the
service shall be (a) 50% of the substantive vacancies which occur
from time to time in the authorized permanent strength of the
service shall be filled by direct recruitment in the matter specified
in part IV of the rules; and (b) the remaining 50% of such
substantive vacancies shall be filled by selection in the manner
specified in part V from amongst the officers who are substantively
borne on the cadre of Inspectors of Police, Inspectors of Police
(Legal) and Subedar/Subedar Majors of Manipur Rifles employed
under the State of Manipur.
8.2.
It
is
stated
that
50%
of
vacancies
under
deputation/leave/ training reserve was also proposed to be filled
up by promotion in the original DPC held on 12.10.2007 as well as
in the subsequent review DPCs held on 01.07.2013 and 19.8.2016
because of the then acute shortage of MPS-II officers. As against
the sanctioned strength of 125, only 37 MPS Grade-II were
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 32
available at that time. Although action to fill up MPS Grade-II
officers by direct recruitment had been taken up, the officers so
appointed would be available for duty for nearly a couple of years.
8.3.
It is further stated that as for the claim for filling up of
6 anticipated vacancies on account of promotion, 12 vacancies
were available due to promotion of 12 MPS Grade-II to MPS
Grade-I on 25.8.2006 which is the date earlier to the date of
sending of requisition to MPSC on 2.1.2007 and hence can be
treated as substantive vacancies, 50% of which can be filled up by
promotion. It is stated that the order dated 15.9.2016 issued by
the Department of P&AR based on the recommendations of the
review DPC held on 19.8.2016 was given retrospective effect from
1.3.2007 and hence the private respondents were placed above
the petitioners in the tentative seniority list of MPS notified on
15.9.2017 by using the interpretation of “recruitment year” as
“financial year” as interpreted by this Court in W.P.(C) Nos.366 of
2013 and 120 of 2014 dated 7.7.2017. Thus, prayed for dismissal
of the writ petition.
9.1.
Respondent No.4/MPSC filed affidavit-in-opposition
stating that as per the Note for DPC submitted to the MPSC by the
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 33
Department of Personnel, the total number of posts for promotion
to
MPS
Grade-II
from
Inspectors
of
Police/Subedar
Majors/Subedars of Police Department was 41 and the total
number of vacancy for the year 2005-06 was 4 and for the vacancy
year 2006-07 were 12, 27 and 37 respectively. It is stated that
50% of the vacant was to be filled up by promotion and thus, for
the vacancy year 2005-06, the vacancies were 2 and for the
vacancy year 2006-07, the vacancies were 6, 14 and 19
respectively.
9.2.
It is stated that 6 vacancies occurred due to
promotion of 12 MPS Grade-II to the post of MPS Grade-I on
25.8.2006. The 14 vacancy arose due to Amendment of MPS
Rules, 1965 from time to time. The vacancy of 19 occurred due to
20% of deputation reserve, 5% of leave reserve and another 5%
of training reserve against 125 numbers of sanctioned posts of
MPS Grade-II.
The reasons as stated in the said Note for
proposing to fill up 50% of deputation/leave/training reserve was
because of the acute shortage of MPS Grade-II officers and as
against the sanctioned strength of 125, only 37 were available. In
the said Note, it has been mentioned that although action to fill up
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 34
MPS Grade-II officers by direct recruitment had been taken up at
that time, the officers so appointed would not be available for duty
for nearly a couple of years. It is further stated that as regards,
the 6 posts for 50% of vacancies, the vacancy arose due to
promotion of 12 MPS Grade-II to the post of MPS Grade-I on
25.8.2006 and the DPC would cover such vacancies that have
arisen just before sending proposal to the MPSC for DPC or even
anticipated vacancies in that vacancy year, for which the DPC was
taken up.
Hence, there is no illegality or infirmity in the
proceedings of the DPC held in association with the MPSC.
10.1.
Respondents 7 and 8 filed affidavit-in-opposition
stating that the petitioners have no legally enforceable right
against the private respondents and have to establish the locus
standi to challenge the impugned orders. The MPSC issued an
advertisement dated 22.8.2005 for direct recruitment of various
Civil Service Combined Service, including 32 posts of MPS GradeII and clearly stated for the vacancy of 2004-2005. The petitioners
are impugning appointment of private respondents who are
promoted
to
the
post
of
MPS
Inspector/Subedar/Inspector(Legal)/Subedar
Grade-II
Majors
from
in
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
the
P a g e | 35
50%vacancies of 2006 and 2007 in promotees quota and there is
no connection in vacancy wise with direct recruit of 2005-2006
base.
10.2.
It is stated that 41 vacancies mentioned in the letter
dated 25.8.2006, the DGP mentioned the vacancy position and
shares of direct recruits and promotees quota. It is stated that the
Department of P&AR issued consolidated instruction on 29.4.1999
and as per the said instruction, if excess post was filled up by the
Government, which is alleged by the petitioners as illegal, in that
case equal number of direct recruit MPS Grade-II appointees are
also illegal, but their appointments were not challenged, yet they
also necessary party. Hence the present writ petition suffer from
lack of necessary parties and accordingly, the same is liable to be
dismissed. Further, if excess posts are filled up by promotees, in
that event some of the promotees MPS Grade-II shall be kept as
reserved, however, that has not happened simply because no
promotion was given in excess to the sanctioned post. It is further
stated that reason behind the filing of the present writ petition and
the subsequent W.P.(C) Nos.101 and 346 of 2021 was on account
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 36
of losing hope to get the seniority over the private respondents and
to disturb their seniors who had already retired long time back.
10.3.
It is stated that in compliance of the order dated
19.11.2019 passed in Civil Appeal Nos.8833-8835 of 2019 of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court, an order dated 21.12.2020 was issued by
the Department of P&AR publishing the final seniority list of MPS
officers. The petitioners after exhausting all legal remedies have
now filed the writ petition, which is not maintainable and the same
is liable to be dismissed.
11.
Respondent No.22 filed affidavit-in-opposition stating
that 50% of vacancies are to be filled up by direct recruitment and
another 50% is to be filled up by promotion. The claim of the
petitioners is that out of 41 vacancies, 19 and 6 posts cannot be
included as regular sanctioned posts, as 19 posts are temporary
and reserved for deputation/training/leave reserve and another 6
posts were not yet created at the time of DPC is twisting and
manipulating in order to fit the case. It is stated that the order
dated 15.9.2016 issued by the Department of P&AR based on the
recommendation of the review DPC held on 19.8.2016 has been
given retrospective effect from 1.3.2007 and hence the private
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 37
respondents were placed above the petitioners in the tentative
seniority list of MPS notified on 15.9.2017 by using the
interpretation of “recruitment year” as “financial year” as per the
order dated 07.07.2017 passed in W.P.(C) Nos. 366 of 2013 and
120 of 2014.
12.
Respondents 26, 27 and 30 filed affidavit-in-
opposition stating that the petitioners are misusing the process of
law to stop the promotion of the private respondents for their
personal benefits. Since the department divided the whole vacant
posts available for MPS Grade-II at the ratio of 50:50 for direct
recruits as well as for promotees as per the Manipur Police Service
Rues, 1965, there is no question of encroaching the quota for
direct recruits by the promotees. The petitioners have failed to
challenge the letter dated 25.8.2006 of the DGP which determines
the vacancy position of the promotees. Moreover, all the DPCs
were held as per the vacancies determined by the said letter. The
order dated 15.9.2016 issued by the Department of P&AR based
on the recommendations of the review DPC held on 19.8.2016
have been given retrospective effect from 1.3.2007 as per the
rules and therefore, the private respondents were placed above
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 38
the petitioners in the tentative seniority list of MPS notified on
15.9.2016 by using the interpretation of “recruitment year” as
“financial year” as stated by this Court in the order dated 7.7.2017
passed in W.P.(C) Nos.366 of 2013 120 of 2014.
13.1.
Resisting W.P.(C) No.346 of 2021, the respondent
State filed affidavit-in-opposition stating that in compliance of the
order dated 26.3.2021 passed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
Contempt Petition (C) Nos.334-335 of 2020 arising out of Civil
Appeal Nos.8836-8837 of 2019, due process for induction of
eligible MPS officers to Indian Police Service was initiated and the
writ petition suffers from non-joinder of Rajendro Singh and Mubi
Singh. It is stated that the letter dated 25.8.2006 was submitted
for filling up all the vacancies falling in promotion quota of MPS
Grade-I and MPS Grade-II stating shortage of supervisory officers
adversely affecting the efficiency and management of the force
and the number of vacancy in MPS Grade-II was stated as 47
posts and in the light of the proposal received from the DGP for
utilization of 20% deputation reserve, 5% leave reserve and 5%
training reserve on account of vacancies which had adversely
affected the efficiency and management of the work force, which
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 39
was required in the light of election to the 9th Manipur State
Assembly and the direct recruits not being available in service as
they had to undergo training during that time. The total vacancies
for the year 2005-2006 and 2006-2007 being 85 posts calculated
as 47+38=45 wherein 38=30% of 125, resulting in the vacancies
proposed with reference to promotion of MPS Grade-II officers and
direct recruits at 43 posts each, calculated at 50% of 85 as per the
provisions of Rule 5 of the MPS Rules.
13.2.
It is stated that upon receiving the letter dated
28.12.2006 from the Principal Secretary (Home) to fill up
vacancies in MPS Grade-II under promotion quota, proposal for
filling up 41 posts of MPS Grade-II was sent to MPSC on 2.1.2007
with a proposal for convening DPC for appointment by promotion
to the post of MPS Grade-II in the Police Department consisting of
Form No.6, Note for DPC and integrity certificate/vigilance
certificate. In the Note for DPC forwarded to MPSC, the total
vacancy for the year 2005-2006 is 4, wherein 2 was allotted to
promotees as 50% of vacancy to be filled up by promotion as per
Rule 5 of MPS Rules and further the total vacancy for the year
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 40
2006-2007 was counted as 12, 27, 37 wherein the vacancy meant
for promotees were 6, 14, 19 respectively.
13.3.
It is further stated that the placement of 51 MPS
Grade-I officers to MPS Junior Administrative Grade (nonfunctional) on the recommendation of Selection Committee was
done in compliance with the order dated 7.7.2017 passed by this
Court and the order dated 19.11.2019 passed by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in Civil Appeal Nos.8833-8835 of 2019 read with
Civil Appeal No.8838 of 2019 and 8836-8837 of 2019 and the
order dated 8.3.2021 passed in Contempt Petition (C) No.334-335
of 2020.
13.4.
It is stated that the promotion order of 43 promotees
to the post of MPS Grade-II notified vide DP’s order dated
12.2.2010 was made on the recommendation of DPC held on
9.2.2010 in view of vacancy arising in the year 2007-08, 2008-09
and 2009-10. Before the impugned final seniority list of MPS
officers as on 1.10.2013 was published, another final seniority list
of MPS officers as on 1.10.2013 was published vide order dated
29.6.2019 by placing the MPS direct recruits appointed on
1.3.2007 en-block senior to the MPS promote officers appointed
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 41
on 14.8.2007 basing on the principles of law laid down by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court.
The placement of 51 MPS Grade-I
officers were made under Rule 29(B)(i) and Rule 29(C)(ii) of
Manipur Public Service Rules, 1965 on the recommendation of the
Selection Committee meeting held on 20.03.2021.
14.
Respondent No.8 filed affidavit stating that the
petitioners are trying to re-open the matter already settled as per
various orders of this Court as well the Hon’ble Supreme Court.
The 19 posts are long term vacancies and the said vacancies
occurred due to 20% of deputation reserve, 5% on leave reserve
and 5% training reserve against 125 numbers of sanctioned post
of MPS Grade-II. The DPC Note clearly states that “the Post of
Commandants, Deputy Commandant, Assistant Commandants
created for IR Bns, though manned by IPS/MPS officers were not
part of the MPS Cadre post till they were encadre to the cadre post
of MPS by amending Manipur Police Service Rules vide
notification dated 14.8.2006. In lieu of the amendment of the
Manipur Police Service Rules, the zone of consideration is fixed
for general category at 86 and for SC/ST at 205.
As such,
respondent No.8 and other respondents are well within the zone
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 42
of consideration. It is stated that the petitioners are direct recruits
for the vacancy year 2005-2006 and the private respondents are
promotees of 2006-2007 vacancy years and thus, the petitioners
have no locus standing to challenge the same. The review DPC
has been conducted and order dated 15.9.2016 was issued giving
effect the promotion to the post of MPS Grade-II with effect from
1.3.2007 and, as such, the said promotion order dated 12.2.2010
has become redundant.
15.
Resisting W.P.(C) No.923 of 2021, the first
respondent State filed affidavit-in-opposition stating that as per the
provision of Rule 5 of MPS Rules as applicable on 12.1.2007, the
method of recruitment to the post of MPS Grade-II is 50% of the
substantive vacancy by direct recruitment and the remaining 50%
of the substantive vacancies by promotion and hence quota of
each direct recruit and promote in the MPS is fixed in such a
manner. The inter se seniority dispute in the MPS Grade-II officers
cadre between direct recruits and promotees were settled by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court vide judgment dated 19.11.2019 in Civil
Appeal No.8833-8835 of 2019. The consideration for promotion
of all eligible officers was on merit and the writ petition is barred
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 43
by limitation. The initiation of due process of induction of eligible
MPS officers to IPS vide Department of Personnel’s letter dated
28.5.2021 was made subsequently in compliance of the order
dated 26.3.2021 passed in Contempt Petition (C) Nos.334-335 of
2020 in Civil Appeal Nos.8833-8837 of 2019. It is stated that the
promotion order dated 12.02.2010 in respect of 43 officers to their
promotions to MPS Grade-II was issued upon recommendation of
the DPC associated with the MPSC held on 9.2.2010. Hence,
prayed for dismissal of the writ petition.
16.
Respondent No.3/MPSC filed affidavit stating that
the DPC held on 12.1.2007 was in pursuance of the proposal letter
dated 25.8.2006 submitted by the DGP, Manipur requesting the
Chief Secretary, Government of Manipur for immediate filling up
of MPS Grade-II under promotion quota in the vacancies. The
said letter clearly states that vacancies to be filled up for 41 posts
of MPS Grade-II and the DPC proceedings were held in
association with the MPSC for appointment by promotion to the
post of MPS Grade-II in accordance with the proposal given by the
Administrative Department and, as such, there is no illegality or
infirmity in the DPC proceedings.
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 44
17.1.
Respondent No.6/UPSC filed affidavit stating that the
UPSC discharging their functions and duties assigned to them
under Article 320 of the Constitution of India. By virtue of the
provisions in the All India Services Act, 1951, separate recruitment
rules have been framed for IAS/IPS/IFoS. In pursuance of these
rules, the IPS (Appointment by Promotion) Regulations, 1955
have been framed. In accordance with the provisions of the said
Regulations, the Selection Committee presided over by the
Chairman/Member of the UPSC makes selection of State Police
Service officers for promotion to the Indian Police Service. It is
stated that as per Regulation 5(1) of the Promotion Regulations,
the number of vacancies against which selection is to be made for
a particular select list for promotion to the IPS of a State cadre is
determined by the Government of India (Ministry of Home Affairs)
in consultation with the State Government concerned. Thereafter,
the State Government forwards a proposal to the Commission
along with the seniority list, eligibility list of the State Police
Officers,
integrity
certificates,
certificates
regarding
disciplinary/criminal
proceedings,
certificate
regarding
communication of adverse remarks, details of penalties imposed
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 45
on the eligible officers etc. and complete ACR desires of the
eligible officers.
17.2.
It is stated that the State Government vide letter
dated 28.5.2021 had furnished proposal for preparation of yearwise select list of 2016 onwards for promotion of MPS officers to
the IPS of Manipur cadre. In the proposal, the State Government
had intimated that the proposal is based on seniority list of MPS
officers prepared in pursuance of the order dated 19.11.2019 of
the Hon’ble Supreme Court. As the vacancies were determined
by the Government of India for the year 2016, 2017, 2018 and
2019 as 5, 1, 4, 1 respectively, a Selection Committee meeting
was held on 3.12.2021 for preparation of year-wise select list of
2016 to 2019 for promotion to IPS of Manipur Cadre and the
Minutes of the Committee dated 13.12.2021 was forwarded to the
State Government.
In view of the direction dated 20.12.201
passed by this Court for maintaining status quo as on 20.12.201
in respect of the proposal submitted by the State Government vide
letter dated 28.5.2021, further action has not been taken by the
UPSC.
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 46
18.
Respondent No.15 filed affidavit stating that the order
for promotion of 41 posts of MPS Grade-II held on 21.1.2007,
review proceedings held on 19.8.2016 and review DPC held on
19.8.2016 along with promotion order dated 1.3.2007 and order
dated 18.10.2013 have been time and again challenged and
already settled by various orders of this Court as well as the
Supreme Court and only to foster their illegal claim, the matter has
been again brought afresh only to frustrate the service condition
of the private respondents. The main ground of the writ petition is
for encroachment of quota ratio which was never pleaded in the
earlier rounds of litigation, which already attended finality and the
petitioners themselves have also admitted that “before all these
Hon’ble Courts including Apex Court, none of the party has
contended on the issue as to whether officers appointed against
substantive/temporary vacancy will be given the benefit of
substantive appointment treating them as officers borne on the
day” and as such it is clear that the petitioners are trying to reopen
the issue not pleaded in the earlier rounds of litigation while the
service position has already been settled and acted upon.
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 47
19.
Respondent Nos.10, 12, 16, 31 and 36 filed affidavit
stating that having accepted the proposition of law laid down by
this Court which has been upheld by the Supreme Court that all
the promote officers in respect of the earlier issued involved in
W.P.(C) Nos.366 of 2013 and 120 of 2014 would be en bloc above
the direct recruit officers including the petitioners after examining
and accepting the promotion orders which are being challenged in
the present writ petition, the petitioners cannot file a fresh writ
petition to do away the impact of the earlier writ petitions. In fact,
all the orders including the DPC and review DPC proceedings
have been discussed in the said writ petitions. It is stated that the
seniority list dated 21.12.2020 is the incidental outcome of the
DPC proceeding meeting held on 12.1.2007 and promotion order
dated 1.3.2007, review DPC meeting held on 19.8.2016 and
promotion order dated 15.9.2016 which has attained finality by
virtue of the Hon’ble Supreme Court’s direction.
As such,
challenge to the above mentioned proceedings and order may
contradict the directions rendered by the Hon’ble Supreme Court
thereby making the earlier directions of the Hon’ble Supreme
Court as null and void, which is not tenable in the eyes of law.
Thus, prayed for dismissal of the writ petition.
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 48
SUBMISSIONS MADE IN W.P.(C) NO.867 OF 2017:
20.
Assailing the impugned proceedings of the review
DPC dated 1.7.2013 and its promotion order dated 18.10.2013
and the review DPC dated 19.8.2016 and its promotion order
dated 15.9.2016, the learned counsel for the petitioners submitted
that in the review DPC held on 1.7.2013 and in the review DPC
held
on
19.8.2016,
the
posts
for
50%
of
deputation/training/leave reserve and 6 posts for 50% of
vacancies going to be created by promotion of 12 MPS Grade-II
officers to MPS Grade-I on the basis of the DPC held on 24.8.2006
were illegally and conveniently encroached upon and added to the
quota for the promotees in order to accommodate the private
respondents and the same cannot be treated as vacancies for the
regular promotees. The learned counsel would submit that at the
time of calculating the total vacancies for the regular promotees
the 19 posts as well as the 6 posts are to be subtracted and if
subtracted, the total vacancies for regular promotees came to only
16 posts as well as 6 posts to the total vacancies of the regular
promotees in excess and promoted the private respondents to the
post of MPS Grade-II vide order dated 18.10.2013 and
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
thus
P a g e | 49
issuance of the order dated 15.9.2016 is in violation of the
established norms and rules of service jurisprudence.
21.
The learned counsel added that those 19 posts for
the 50% of deputation/training/leave reserve and the 6 posts for
the 50% of vacancies going to be created by promotion on the
basis of the DPC held on 24.8.2006 will inevitably affect in the
preparation of the seniority list of the MPS Grade-II in the Manipur
Police Department. Hence, the above orders impugned herein are
liable to be set aside.
22.
In
reply,
submitted
that
the
50%
learned
of
the
Government
vacancies
Advocate
under
deputation/leave/training reserve were proposed to be filled up by
promotion in the original DPC held on 12.10.2007 as well in the
subsequent review DPC held on 1.7.2013 and 19.8.2016 because
of the then shortage of MPS Grade-II officers. As against the
sanctioned strength of 125, only 37 MPS Grade-II by direct
recruitment had been considered and the officers so appointed
would be available for duty for nearly a couple of years.
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 50
23.
The learned Government Advocate further submitted
that insofar as the claim of filling up of 6 anticipated vacancies on
account of promotion, 12 vacancies were available due to
promotion of 12 MPS Grade-II to MPS Grade-I on 25.8.2006 which
is the date earlier to the date of sending of requisition to MPSC on
2.1.2007 and hence, the said vacancies can be treated as
substantive vacancies, 50% of which can be filled up by
promotion. He would submit that since the order dated 15.9.2016
issued was based on the recommendation of the review DPC
dated 19.8.2016 giving retrospective effect from 1.3.2007, the
private respondents were placed above the petitioners in the
impugned tentative seniority list dated 15.9.2017. Therefore, there
is no infirmity in the impugned orders as well as the seniority list
dated 15.9.2017.
24.
The learned counsel for the respondent/MPSC
submitted that the total number of vacancy for the vacancy year
2005-06 was 4 and for the vacancy year 2006-07 were 12, 27 and
37 and that 50% of the vacant was to be filled up by promotion and
accordingly, for the vacancy year 2005-06, the vacancy was 2 and
for the vacancy year 2006-07, the vacancies were 4, 14 and 19.
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 51
He would submit that the 6 vacancy occurred was due to
promotion of 12 MPS Grade-II to the post of MPS Grade-I on
25.8.2006 and that 14 vacancy arose due to amendment of MPS
Rules from time to time.
25.
The learned counsel for the respondent/MPSC
added that the reason for proposing to fill up 50% of
deputation/leave/training reserve was because of the shortage of
MPS Grade-II officers as against the sanctioned strength of 125,
only 37 were available. Although action to fill up MPS Grade-II
officers by direct recruitment had been taken up at that time, the
officers so appointed would not be available for duty for nearly a
couple of years.
As regards the 6 posts for the 50% of the
vacancies, the vacancy arose due to promotion of 12 MPS GradeII to the post of MPS Grade-I on 25.8.2006 and the DPC would
cover such vacancies that have arisen just before sending the
proposal to the MPSC for DPC or even anticipated vacancies in
that vacancy year for which the DPC was conducted. Arguing so,
the learned counsel contended that there is no illegality or infirmity
in the impugned proceedings of the DPC held in association with
the MPSC. Thus, a prayer is made to dismiss the writ petition.
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 52
26.1.
Supporting the impugned orders, the learned counsel
for the private respondents submitted that since the Department
divided the whole vacant posts available for MPS Grade-II at the
ratio of 50:50 for the direct recruit as well as for the promotees as
per the Manipur Police Service Rules, there is no question of
encroaching the quota for direct recruits by the promotees and that
by assuming but not admitting that the plea of the petitioners is
correct in respect of 19 posts of deputation/training/leave reserved
and another 6 posts created by promotion of 12 MPS Grade-II to
MPS Grade-I i.e. total 25 vacant posts cannot be filled up by
promotees, then similarly 25 posts allocated to the direct recruits
cannot be enjoyed by the direct recruits. Thus, the petitioners
cannot have a plea to deny the promotees something when the
same benefit is claimed by them as their entitlement. The claim of
the petitioners that out of 41 vacancies 19 and 6 posts cannot be
included as regular sanction posts for the promotees, as 19 posts
are temporary and reserved for the deputation/training/leave
reserve and the 6 posts were not yet created at the time of DPC is
manipulating in order to fit their case as 50% of the similar
vacancies have been filled up by the direct recruitment.
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 53
26.2.
Further, the impugned order dated 15.9.2016 issued
by the Department of Personnel based on the recommendation of
the review DPC held on 19.8.2016 giving retrospective effect from
1.3.2007 and therefore, the private respondents were placed
above the petitioners in the tentative seniority list dated 15.9.2017
by using the interpretation of “recruitment year” as “financial year”
as observed by this Court in the order dated 7.7.2017 passed in
W.P.(C) Nos.366 of 2013 and 120 of 2014.
27.
The learned counsel for the private respondents
further submitted that the petitioners impugning appointment of
private respondents who are promoted to the post of MPS GradeII from Inspector/Subedar/Inspector(Legal)/Subedar Majors in the
50% of vacancies of 2006 and 2007 in promotees quota and that
there is no connection in vacancy wise with direct recruit of 20052006 base. In the letter dated 25.8.2006, the DGP has clearly
stated about the vacancy position and sharing of direct recruit and
promotion quota in respect of the 41 vacancies.
28.
Mr. A. Mohendro, learned counsel appearing for
some of the private respondents in W.P.(C) No.867 of 2017 and
923 of 2021 submitted that the seniority dispute of direct recruit
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 54
and the promotees MPS Grade-II of 2005-2006 base and 20062007 was already settled by the Hon’ble Apex Court and in
compliance of the order of the Hon’ble Apex Court, an order dated
21.12.2020 was issued by the Department of P&AR, thereby
publishing a final seniority list of the Manipur Police Service (MPS)
officers. After exhausting all legal remedies, the petitioners have
now filed the writ petition to reopen the settled issue and that the
settled seniority position should not be unsettled.
SUBMISSIONS MADE IN W.P.(C) NO.346 OF 2021:
29.
Assailing the impugned order dated 31.3.2021, the
learned counsel for the petitioners argued that the placement of
MPS Grade-I officers to MPS Grade-1 Junior Administrative
officers was without considering the grievance of the petitioners
and contrary to the directions issued in the earlier litigations and
also violating Rule 28 of the Manipur Public Service Rules.
30.
The learned counsel further submitted that the
private respondents who were appointed against the 19 posts of
deputation reserve/leave reserve/training reserve in the MPS
Grade-II were confirmed to their respective posts of MPS Grade-
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 55
II only in the year 2010 vide their promotion order dated 12.2.2010
and therefore, their names cannot be above the direct recruits of
2007 appointees, the seniority list in respect of the private
respondents are against the MPS (Amendment) Rules, 1965. The
private respondents cannot be considered their induction from
MPS Grade-I to Indian Police Service without the disposal of the
pending cases.
31.
On the other hand, the learned Government
Advocate appearing for the respondent State contended that a
proposal was received from the DGP for utilization of 20%
deputation reserve, 5% leave reserve and 5% training reserve on
account of vacancies which had adversely affected the efficiency
and management of the work force and that upon receipt of the
letter from the Government to fill up vacancies in MPS Grade-II
under promotion quota, proposal for filling up 41 posts of MPS
Grade-II was sent to the respondent MPSC with a proposal for
convening a DPC for appointment by promotion and thereafter
upon following the procedures, promotions were made on the
recommendation of the DPC.
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 56
32.
The learned Government Advocate added that the
impugned final seniority list of MPS officers as on 1.10.2013 was
published by placing the MPS direct recruits appointed on
1.3.2007 en-bloc senior to the MPS promote officers appointed on
14.8.2007 based on the principles of law laid down by the Hon’ble
Apex Court in the case of Union of India v. N.R.Parmar and
others, reported in (2012) 13 SCC 340 and the judgment passed
in Civil Appeal Nos.8836-8837 of 2019.
33.
The learned Government Advocate further submitted
that in compliance of the order of the Hon’ble Apex Court, 51 MPS
Grade-I officers who were found eligible for consideration for
placing MPS – Junior Administrative Grade under MPS Rules
were placed to the Manipur Police Service Administrative Grade
(non-functional) on the basis of the recommendation of the
Selection Committee vide order dated 31.3.2021 and that due
process of induction of eligible MPS officers to IPS was initiated.
The placement of 51 MPS Grade-I officers were made under Rule
29(B)(i) and Rule 29(C)(ii) of MPS Rules on the recommendation
of the Selection Committee. Arguing so, the learned Government
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 57
Advocate submitted that the relief claimed in W.P.(C) No.346 of
2021 is devoid of merits and deserves to be dismissed.
34.
The learned counsel appearing for the private
respondents submitted that the petitioners are trying to re-open
the matter already settled as per various orders of this Court as
well as the Hon’ble Apex Court and in fact the 19 posts are clear
vacancies which occurred due to 20% of deputation reserve, 5%
on leave reserve and 5% training reserve against 125 sanctioned
posts of MPS Grade-II. The petitioners are direct recruits for the
vacancy year 2005-2006 and the private respondents are
promotees of 2006-2007 vacancy years and therefore, the
petitioners have no locus standi to challenge the orders impugned
in W.P.(C) No.346 of 2021 and no ineligible officers that too who
are not within the zone of consideration were considered and that
as per rules, the incumbents including the private respondents
were considered and promotion orders were issued to them.
35.
The learned counsel for the private respondents
added that some of the private respondents filed W.P.(C) No.366
of 2013 and 120 of 2014 challenging the seniority list and some of
the petitioners have filed W.P.(C) No.235 of 2012 challenging the
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 58
seniority list dated 11.11.2008 and in the entire proceedings, there
was not even a single plea that the private respondents are
outside the zone and there was not a whisper that the private
respondents are not eligible to be promoted and that W.P.(C)
N.346 of 2021 is an attempt to do redo what has been denied by
this Court and the Hon’ble Apex Court in the earlier round of
litigations. Thus, a prayer is made to dismissed W.P.(C) No.346
of 2021.
SUBMISSIONS MADE IN W.P.(C) NO.923 OF 2021:
36.
Challenging the impugned DPC proceedings held on
21.1.2007 for promotion of 41 posts of MPS Grade-II; review
proceedings dated 19.8.2016 and the promotion order dated
1.3.2007, 18.10.2013 and 15.9.2016, the learned counsel for the
petitioners submitted that when DPC was held in 2007, there were
only 22 substantive vacancies for promotion quota. However, by
taking 19 temporary vacancies altogether 40 officers were
appointed as MPS Grade-II on substantive vacancies.
The
officers appointed under the 19 temporary vacancies cannot in any
event be considered as officers borne on the cadre as they have
recommended by the MPSC against the temporary vacancies.
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 59
37.
The learned counsel further submitted that a careful
reading of the three promotion orders, namely 1.3.2007,
18.10.2013 and 15.9.2016 arising out of the DPC Note of 2007
would reveal various changes in respect of the officers who might
have been recommended against the 19 temporary and thus last
19 names in the three orders have ex facie indicated that
candidate who might not be in the zone of consideration against
the substantive vacancies of 22 as given in the DPC note seems
to have been included as candidates in the zone of consideration
in all the aforesaid three DPCs. Therefore, for doing complete
justice and for preventing erring officers who are the author of such
misdeeds in bringing candidates within the zone of consideration
illegally to escape from accountability, it becomes utmost
important and necessary to set aside the proceedings of the all
three DPCs.
38.
The learned counsel next submitted that the State
Government in its letter dated 28.5.2021 have furnished names of
eligible officers for induction in IPS for the select list year of 2016,
2017, 2018 and 2019 wherein the names of the private
respondents are found to be included and if once the aforesaid
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 60
officers are inducted into the IPS with uncertainty of their eligibility
in the event DPC proceedings which are being questioned in
W.P.(C) No.867 of 2017 is interfered, a chaotic and never ending
complicacy in the Police Department would arise which may not
be a conducive working atmosphere in the Department.
Therefore, it would be appropriate to set aside the orders
impugned in W.P.(C) No.923 of 2021. In support, the learned
counsel for the petitioners relied upon the following decisions:
(1)
Rupa Rani Rakshit and others v.
Jarkhand Gramin Bank and others,
(2010) 1 SCC 345.
(2)
D.Ganesh Rao Patnaik and others v.
State of Jharkhand and others, (2005)
8 SCC 454.
(3)
Keshav Chandra Joshi and others v.
Union of India and others, 1992 Suppl
(1) SCC 272.
(4)
Sanjay K. Sinha-II and others v. State
of Bihar, (2004) 10 SCC 734.
(5)
Ramchandra Singh v. Savitri Devi
and others, (2003) 8 SCC 319.
(6)
Goodyear India and others v. State of
Haryana and another, (1990) 2SCC
71.
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 61
(7)
State of Punjab v. Baldev Singh,
(1996) 6 SCC 172.
39.
Per contra, the learned Government Advocate
contended that as per the provision of Rule 5 of the MPS Rules as
applicable on 12.1.2007, the method of recruitment to the post of
MPS Grade-II is 50% of the substantive vacancy by direct
recruitment and the remaining 50% of the substantive vacancy by
promotion and, therefore, the quota of each direct recruit and
promote in the MPS is fixed in such a manner and that the inter se
seniority dispute in the MPS Grade-II between direct recruits and
promotees were settled by the Hon’ble Supreme Court vide
judgment in Civil Appeal Nos.8833-8835 of 2019 decided on
19.11.2019.
40.
The
learned
counsel
appearing
for
the
respondent/MPSC submitted that the DPC was held in association
with the MPSC for appointment by promotion to the post of MPS
Grade-II in accordance with the proposal given by the
Administrative Department and, as such, there is no illegality or
infirmity in the DPC proceedings impugned in W.P.(C) No.923 of
2021.
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 62
41.
The
learned
counsel
appearing
for
the
respondent/UPSC submitted that the State Government vide letter
dated 28.5.2021 furnished the proposal for preparation of yearwise select list of 2016 onwards for promotion of MPS officers to
the IPS of Manipur cadre and in the proposal, the State
Government had intimated that the proposal is based on the
seniority list of MPS officers prepared in pursuance of the order
dated 19.11.2019 of the Hon’ble Supreme Court.
He would
submit that the as the vacancies were determined by the
Government of India, Ministry of Home Affairs for the year of 2016,
2017, 2018 an 2019 as 5, 1, 4, 1 respectively, the Selection
Committee meeting was held on 3.12.2021 for preparation of yearwise select list of 2016-2019 for promotion to IPS of Manipur
cadre.
42.
The learned counsel urged that in view of the
direction dated 20.12.2021 passed by the High Court for
maintaining status quo as on 20.12.2021 in respect of the proposal
submitted by the State Government vide letter dated 28.5.2021,
further action in terms of Regulations 7 for finalization of the select
list prepared by the Selection Committee dated 3.12.2021 for
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 63
promotion to the IPS of Manipur cadre has not been taken by the
UPSC and that the preparation and maintenance of seniority list
of State Police Service officers is the exclusive domain of the State
Government.
43.
The learned counsel for the private respondents
submitted that the petitioners have admitted that final seniority list
of MPS Grade-II were finalized on 17.5.2013, 19.2.2014 and
1.10.2014, wherein direct recruitee of 2007 MPS Grade-II were
found to be placed above promotee officers which was subject
matter of W.P.(C) Nos.366 of 2013 and 120 of 2014 filed by the
promotee officers and that the petitioners have also admitted that
in all the cases, encroachment of quota ratio as well as entitlement
of seniority by officers appointed and promoted under temporary
vacancies was not at all considered and decided. The learned
counsel submitted that such issue was not raised by any of the
party and the matter has already attained finality.
44.
The learned counsel for the private respondents next
submitted that the post of Commandants, Deputy Commandants
created for IR Bns, though manner by IPS/PMS officers were not
part of the MPS cadre post till they were encadred to the cadre
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 64
post of MPS by amending Manipur Police Service Rules. As a
result, the total sanctioned post of MPS in different grades has
been increased and that in lieu of the amendment of Manipur
Police Service Rules, the zone of consideration is fixed for general
category at 86 and for SC/ST at 205.
45.
The learned counsel urged that had the DPC had
recommended excess cadre strength and there is no defect in
quota ratio in the promotion of MPS Grade-II. The learned counsel
would submit that in the earlier round of litigations, there was no
plea that the private respondents are outside the zone or any
quota ratio has been violated. The filing of W.P.(C) No.923 of
2021 is a futile exercise for re-opening matters which have
adjudicated and effected by various orders of this Court and the
Hon’ble Supreme Court and thus, the said writ petition filed by the
petitioners is barred by the principles of res judicata and
constructive res judicata.
46.
This Court considered the rival submissions and also
perused the materials available on record.
DISCUSSION:
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 65
47.
The grievance of the petitioners, who are direct
recruits to the post of MPS Grade-II, is that out of 41 posts in which
the private respondents/promotees were promoted, 19 posts
meant for deputation/training/leave reserve and the 19 promotees
were promoted not against the vacant posts and therefore, the
promotion given them is illegal.
48.
The private respondents contested the writ petitions
by raising maintainability issue, apart from denying the averments
set out in the writ petitions. The private respondents also raised
the issue of locus standi, delay and laches, res judicata,
constructive res judicata and principle of estoppel.
49.
The writ petitions filed by the petitioners pertain to an
inter se seniority dispute in MPS Grade-II officers. The petitioners
are direct recruits and the private respondents are promotees and
prior to the induction of the private respondent on 1.3.2007 to MPS
Grade-II, they were serving as Inspector of Police and they were
granted promotion on the basis of a duly constituted DPC. The
petitioners are directly recruited into MPS Grade-II cadre vide
orders dated 14.8.2007 and 24.11.2007 respectively.
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 66
50.
Appointment and seniority in the Manipur Police
Service is governed by Manipur Police Service Rules, 1965.
Pursuant to the order passed in W.P.(C) No.235 of 2012, dated
18.2.2013, the Government of Manipur issued an order on
17.5.2013 publishing the final seniority list as on 1.4.2013 of the
MPS Grade-II officers. The promotees challenged the aforesaid
seniority by filing W.P.(C) No.366 of 2013 before this Court by
contending that they entered into the MPS Grade-II on 1.3.2007,
whereas the petitioners were appointed subsequently on
14.8.2007 and 24.11.2007 and, therefore, they should be
regarded as senior to the direct recruits.
51.
W.P.(C) No.366 of 2013 and W.P.(C) No.120 of 2014
were tried together and by the order dated 7.7.2017, while
quashing the impugned orders, the learned single Judge directed
that the batch of promotees appointed on 1.3.2007 must be given
seniority above the direct recruits appointed on 14.8.2017. The
operative portion of the order dated 7.7.2017 is extracted
hereunder for ready reference:
“(14) For the reasons stated herein above, the
writ petitions being WP(C) No.366 of 2013 and
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 67
WP(C) No.120 of 2014 are allowed and
consequently, the Government orders dated 1705-2013, 20-01-2014 and 19-02-2014, impugned
herein, in respect of the petitioners and the
private respondents, are quashed and set aside
with the following directions:
(a)
The State Government shall prepare a
seniority list afresh in respect of the
MPS Officers, after taking into account
the observations made by this Court
hereinabove, within a period of three
months from the date of receipt of a
copy of this judgment and order;
(b)
While preparing the seniority list of MPS
Officers, the State Government shall
follow
the
guidelines/instructions
contained in the Office Memorandum
dated 07-02-1986 which is adopted by
the State Government vide its Office
Memorandum dated 13-11-1987 as
directed vide order dated 18-022013
passed by the Hon’ble Gauhati High
Court in WP(C) No.235 of 20212.
There shall be no order as to costs.
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 68
52.
Aggrieved by the order of the learned Single Judge,
few direct recruits have filed W.A.No.49 of 2017 and was
transferred to Gauhati High Court and numbered as W.A.No.66 of
2018. By the judgment dated 26.9.2018, a Division Bench upheld
the conclusion of the learned single Judge.
Some of the
petitioners have also filed Review Petition No.10 of 2019 and the
same was dismissed for non-prosecution by the order dated
10.4.2019. Aggrieved by the judgment passed in the writ appeal,
direct recruits filed Special Leave Petition (C) Nos.19565-67 of
2019 (Civil Appeal Nos.8833-8835 of 2019). By the judgment
dated 19.11.2019, the Hon’ble Supreme Court dismissed the
appeals. Paragraphs 47 to 50 are relevant and the same are
quoted hereunder:
“47. As earlier discussed, the Rule 28 of the
MPS Rules, 1965 shows that seniority in the
service shall be determined based on the date
of appointment to the service. In particular
Rule 28(i) of the MPS Rules, 1965 which is
applicable to both promotees and direct
recruits, provides that seniority shall be
determined by the order in which the
appointments are made to the service. If
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 69
seniority under Rule 28(i) is to be determined
based on the date of appointment, it cannot be
said that for the purpose of Rule 28(iii), the
seniority
of
direct
recruits
should
be
determined on the basis of the date of initiation
of
the
recruitment
process.
The
term
“Recruitment Year” does not and cannot mean
the year in which, the recruitment process is
initiated or the year in which vacancy arises.
The contrary declaration in N.R. Parmar, in our
considered opinion, is not a correct view.
48. In view of the foregoing, let us now
consider the Government order (29.06.2019)
produced by the Manipur Advocate General in
the
Contempt Case.
As it appears the
seniority list published on 29.06.2019 could
not be an independent exercise but its
purpose should be to give effect to the
judgments passed by the High Court. Since
the judgment of the learned single Judge was
affirmed by the Division Bench, the seniority
list must be prepared in accordance with the
High Court’s direction.
It is certainly not
permissible to prepare a fresh seniority list as
an independent exercise, without reference to
the decisions of the Court. When we test the
validity of the list (29.06.2019), there is no
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 70
escape from the conclusion that the list
ignores the decision of the single Judge as
affirmed by the Division Bench. It is declared
so accordingly.
49. In consequence, the appeals arising out of
SLP(C)No.19565-67 of 2019 filed by the direct
recruits
are
dismissed.
On
the
same
reasoning, the appeals arising out of SLP (C)
No.19568-69 of 2019 filed by the State of
Manipur are not entertained and the same
shall stand dismissed. With the above finding
on the Contempt Case No.224 of 2018 and
quashment of the 29.06.2019 proceeding
produced in that case before the High Court,
the appeals arising out of SLP (C) No.17007
of 2019 filed by Ningam Siro against the High
Court’s
order
in
the
Contempt
Case
No.224/2018 is disposed of.
50. In view of the foregoing, the orders of the
High Court in the Writ petition and the Writ
Appeal are upheld. The State of Manipur is
accordingly directed to prepare a revised interse seniority list in the MPS Group-II cadre in
light of the above discussion and the High
Court’s Orders. This shall be done within 8
weeks from today. All consequential actions
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 71
will follow from this judgment. It is ordered
accordingly.”
53.
Alleging willful disobedience of the order passed in
C.A.No.8836-37 of 2019, Contempt Pet. (C) No.334-335 of 2020
have been filed. By the order dated 26.3.2021, the contempt
petitions are closed with following observation:
“The appellant/petitioner is satisfied with the
action taken by the respondents and the
contempt stands purged. She, however,
makes additional submissions that in terms of
para 3(f), the State Government has initiated
due process of induction of eligible MPS
officers to IPS as per the fresh seniority list
notified on 21.12.2020. But her apprehension
is that the process should not become
endless.
The Chief Secretary is present before us and
assures us that he will not take more than two
months to complete his part of the job for the
State Government but will endeavor to do it
earlier, if possible. He submits that thereafter
the matter is dependent on the timely action to
be taken by the UPSC and the Central
Government. In his view, about two months
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 72
thereafter should be sufficient for the said
purpose.
We consider appropriate to record the
aforesaid statement and to issue directions to
the Central Government and the UPSC that
once the State Government forwards the
necessary papers, the needful should be done
within a maximum period of two months
thereafter in view of the prolongation of time
which has already taken place at the cost of
the appellant/petitioner.
The contempt petitions are closed with the
aforesaid
directions
and
notice
stands
discharged.
A copy of the order passed by us should
accompany
the
proposal
of
the
State
Government to the UPSC and the Central
Government so that the timelines are kept in
mind.”
54.
When W.P.(C) No.923 of 2021 was taken up on
17.12.2021, this Court passed the following order:
“Heard Shri H.S. Paonam, learned Senior
Advocate appearing for the petitioners.
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 73
[1] By the instant writ petition, the validity and
correctness of various proceedings dated 21-012007, 01-07-2013 and 19-08-2016 are under
challenge in this writ petition and in addition
thereto, a prayer has been made to direct the
respondents no to act upon the letter dated 2805-2021.
[2] The subject matter in issue relates to the
validity
and
correctness
of
the
aforesaid
proceedings, by which many of the respondents
have been considered for promotion to the post
of Deputy Superintendent of Police.
[3] From the perusal of the averments made in
the writ petition, it is seen that the petitioners and
the respondents, have been, in one way or the
other, getting involved in various litigations
because of which, the facts and circumstances
have become complicated.
[4] Shri Shyam Sharma, learned Government
Advocate submits that pursuant to the letter
dated 28-05-2021, a DPC was held sometime in
the
first
week
of
December
and
the
recommendation thereof is being awaited by the
State Government and accordingly, he prays that
he may be given some time for seeking
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 74
instruction in the matter before any interim order
is passed by this Court.
[5] Having heard the learned counsel appearing
for the petitioners and Shri Shyam Sharma,
learned Government Advocate, this Court is of
the view that the interim order staying the
operation of the said letter dated 28-05-2021
cannot be passed, at this stage, for the reason
that the DPC’s meeting has already been held
pursuant to the said letter.
[6] in view of the above, let notice be issued to
the respondents, returnable in four weeks. Shri
Shyam Sharma, learned Government Advocate
accepts notice on behalf of the respondent Nos.
1 and 2 while Shri R.S. Reisang, learned Senior
Advocate accepts notice on behalf of the
respondent No. 3, MPSC. Shri Vijayanand
Sharma, learned Advocate appearing on behalf
of Shri B.R. Sharma, learned Advocate accepts
notice on behalf of the respondent Nos. 4 and 5.
So far as the respondent No. 6 is concerned,
appropriate step shall be taken by the learned
counsel appearing for the petitioners for service
of notice upon it by speed post. As regards
respondent Nos. 7 to 46, it has been submitted
by Shri H.S. Paonam, learned Senior Advocate
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 75
appearing for the petitioners that since the
detailed addresses of all of them are not known,
he is permitted to serve upon them by substituted
service by way of publication in two local dailies
– one, in Vernacular and another, in English, for
which he shall take appropriate steps.
[7] List the matter before another bench on 2212-2021 for consideration of the interim prayer
after an approval being obtained from the
Hon’ble Chief Justice in view of the nature of the
issue involved herein.”
55.
On 20.12.2021, this Court granted an order of status
quo to be maintained by all the parties till the next date i.e.
22.12.2021. The order dated 20.12.2021 reads thus:
“This is an application filed by the applicant/
petitioner praying for rectification of the order as
regards the status-quo to be maintained by the
parties. While dictating the order, it had been
mentioned that the status quo be maintained by
all parties. But when the draft order was being
finalized, the same had been inadvertently
omitted. This being a mistake on the part of the
Court, the instant application is allowed with the
direction that the status-quo as of today shall be
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 76
maintained by all the parties till the next date i.e.,
22-12-2022.
This order shall form part of the earlier order
passed on 17-12-2021.”
56.
By the order dated 22.12.2021, this Court passed the
following order:
“[1] Heard Mr. H.S. Paonam, learned counsel for
the petitioners in WP(C) No.923 of 2021; Mr.
M.Devenanda,
learned
counsel
for
petitioners
WP(C)
No.101
of
in
the
2021,
WP(C)No.346 of 2021 and WP(C)No. 867 of
2017; Mr. S. Biswajit, learned counsel for the
respondent Nos. 10, 12, 16, 31 in WP(C) No.923
of 2021 & respondent Nos. 5,10, 14, 17, 19 in
WP(C) No. 101 of 2021; Mr. Shyam Sharma,
learned counsel for the State respondents; Mr.
BR Sharma, learned counsel for the respondent
Nos. 4 & 5 in WP(C) No.923 of 2021; Mr.
Debendra, learned GA for the State respondents
in WP(C) No.101 of 2021; WP(C)No.867 of 2017
and WP(C) No.346 of 2021; Mr. Mohendro,
learned counsel for the respondent Nos. 7 & 8 in
WP(C) No. 101 & 867 of 2017.
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 77
[2] When the matters are taken up today, Mr. M.
Devananda,
learned
counsel
for
the
writ
petitioners in WP(C) 101 of 2021, WP(C)No.346
of 2021 and WP(C)No.867 of 2017 represented
that some of the respondents have already been
filed counter affidavit in WP(C)No.101 of 2021
and none of the respondents have filed their
counter affidavits in WP(C) No.346 of 2021. He
further reported that pleadings are completed in
WP(C) No.867 of 2017.
[3] Anyhow, the respondents seeks further time
to file their counter affidavits. Therefore, the
respondents are directed to file their counter
affidavits on the next returnable date without fail.
[4] Therefore, post these matters on 17.01.2022.
Since both the parties mentioned that there is
urgency in these matters and hence, the
respondents are directed to file their counter
affidavits on that date without fail.
[5] Earlier interim order is extended till then.
[6] Registry is directed to issue copy of this order
to both the parties to their Whapsapp/e-mail.”
57.
On 17.12.2021, this Court passed the following
order:
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 78
“Heard Mr. M. Devananda, learned counsel for
the applicants in MC[W.P.(C)] No. 280 of 2021 as
well as the petitioners in W.P.(C) Nos.346 of
2021 & 867 of 2017 and Mr. H. Debendra,
learned GA for the Respondent in MC[W.P.(C)]
No. 280 of 2021 and W.P.(C) Nos. 346 of 2021;
Mr. H.S. Paonam, learned senior counsel for the
petitioners in W.P.(C) No. 923 of 2021 and Mr.
Shyam Sharma, learned GA for the Respondent
in W.P.(C) No. 923 of 2021.
[2] Mr. H. Debendra, learned GA for the
Respondent in MC[W.P.(C)] No. 280 of 2021 and
W.P.(C) Nos. 346 of 2021 and Mr.Shyam
Sharma, learned GA for the Respondent in
W.P.(C) No. 923 of 2021 seek time to file counter
affidavit.
[3] Therefore, post these matters on 14.02.2022.
[4] Interim order already granted by this Court in
W.P.(C) No. 923 of 2021 is extended till then.
[5] Registry is directed to issue copy of this order
to both the parties through their whatsapp/email.”
58.
Thereafter, the interim order was extended from time
to time and the same is in force till date. Respondent No.15 has
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 79
filed Misc. Case (WP) No.88 of 2022 seeking to vacate the interim
order dated 17.12.201 passed in W.P.(C) No.923 of 2021 read
with order dated 20.12.2021 passed in MC (W) No.317 of 2021.
Similarly respondent Nos.10, 12, 16 have filed MC (WP) No.20 of
2022 to vacate the interim order dated 17.12.2021.
59.
The petitioners have also filed MC (WP) No.280 of
2021 seeking direction on the official respondents not to hold the
Screening Committee for induction to IPS from the Manipur Police
Service in Manipur cadre from the proposal dated 28.5.2021 till
the disposal of pending Writ Petition (C) No.857 of 2017, W.P.(C)
No.101 of 2021 and W.P.(C) No.885 of 2016.
60.
As per the then existing MPS (1st Amendment) Rules,
1996, appointment to the service shall be made by the following
methods under Rule 5:
(a)
50% of the substantive vacancies
which occur from time to time in
authorized permanent strength of the
service shall be filled by direct
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 80
recruitment in the manner specified in
Part IV of the rules; and
(b)
The
remaining
50%
of
such
substantive vacancies shall be filled
by selection in the manner specified
in part V of the rules amongst the
officers who are substantively borne
on the cadre of Inspectors of Police,
Inspectors of Police (Legal) and
Subedar/Subedar Major of Manipur
Rifles employed under the State of
Manipur.
61.
It appears that 50% of vacancies under deputation/
leave/training reserve were also proposed to be filled up by
promotion in the original DPC held on 12.2.2007 as well as in the
subsequent review DPCs held on 1.7.2013 and 19.8.2016, as
there was shortage of MPS Grade-II officers. In that process, no
quota for direct recruit has been encroached by the promotees.
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 81
62.
Admittedly, the petitioners have challenged the DPC
proceeding held on 12.2.2007 and its subsequent promotion order
dated 1.3.2007; review DPC proceeding held on 1.7.2013 and its
subsequent promotion order dated 18.10.2013; review DPC
proceeding held on 19.8.2016 and its subsequent promotion order
dated 15.9.2016 after a delay of about 17 years from the first DPC;
8 years from the review DPC of the year 2013 and 6 years of the
review DPC of the year 2016.
63.
The argument of the learned counsel for the private
respondents is that delay and laches is a relevant factor for a Court
of law to determine the question as to whether the claim made by
the petitioners deserve consideration and that on the ground of
delay and latches, the writ petitions are liable to be dismissed. In
support, the learned counsel for the private respondents placed
reliance upon the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the
case of State of Uttaranchal and another v. Shiv Charan Singh
Bhandari and others, (2013) 12 SCC 179, wherein, it has been
held as under:
“23. In State of T.N. v. Seshachalam, (2007) 10
SCC 137, this Court, testing the equality clause
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 82
on the bedrock of delay and laches pertaining to
grant of service benefit, has ruled thus:
“16. …. Filing of representations alone
would not save the period of limitation.
Delay or laches is a relevant factor for a
court of law to determine the question as to
whether the claim made by an applicant
deserves consideration.
Delay and/or
laches on the part of a government servant
may deprive him of the benefit which had
been given to others. Article 14 of the
Constitution of India would not, in a situation
of that nature, be attracted as it is well
known that law leans in favour of those who
are alert and vigilant.”
24. There can be no cavil over the fact that the
claim of promotion is based on the concept of
equality and equitability, but the said relief has to
be claimed within a reasonable time. The said
principle has been stated in GhulamRasool Lone
v. State of J&K, (2009) 15 SCC 321.
25. In NDMC v. Pan Singh, (2007) 9 SCC 278,
the Court has opined that though there is no
period of limitation provided for filing a writ
petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India, yet ordinarily a writ petition should be filed
within a reasonable time. In the said case the
respondents had filed the writ petition after
seventeen years and the court, as stated earlier,
took note of the delay and laches as relevant
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 83
factors and set aside the order passed by the
High Court which had exercised the discretionary
jurisdiction.”
By relying upon the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme
64.
Court in the case of Roshan Lal and others v. International
Airport Authority of India and others, 1980 (Supp) SCC 449,
the learned Government Advocate submitted that the writ petitions
filed several years after the appointment/promotion and that when
the prayer in the writ petition is primarily confined to seniority list
and
consequences
flowing
therefrom
legality
of
the
appointment/promotion also questioned, the same cannot be reopened.
65.
In RoshanLal, supra, the Hon’ble Supreme Court
held:
“4. ….. We do not think we will be justified in
reopening the question of the legality of the
appointment of respondents as Airport Officers
several years after their appointment. We also
notice that the prayer in the writ petitions also is
confined primarily to the seniority list and the
consequences flowing from the seniority list.”
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 84
66.
The decision in RoshanLal, supra, squarely applies
to the case on hand, as stated supra, in the case on hand, after
several years, the petitioners are now questioning the appointment
on promotion of the private respondents and their seniority and
that too when the issue has already been settled by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in the earlier round of litigations.
67.
By placing reliance upon the decision of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in the case of Union of India and another v.
S.S.Kothiyal and others, (1998) 8 SCC 682, the learned counsel
appearing for the respondent/MPSC also submitted that the writ
petitions of the petitioners are suffer from delay and latches and
therefore, the same are liable to be dismissed on the sole ground
itself.
68.
In S.S.Kothiyal, supra, the Hon’ble Supreme Court
held:
“3. In our opinion, the admitted facts of this
case alone are sufficient to reverse the
judgment fo the learned Single Judge as well
as that of the Division Bench of the High Court.
According to the version of Respondent 1
himself, his representation against non-
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 85
promotion as Deputy Commandant was
rejected on 10-6-1971, the second such
representation made on 19-8-1971 was
rejected
on
4-11-1974
and
the
third
representation made on 12-4-1977 was
rejected on 11-7-1977. It is obvious that on
rejection of his representation in June 1971,
there was no occasion for Respondent 1 to
wait any longer to challenge his non-promotion
and, therefore, the filing of the writ petition 8
years thereafter in December 1978, was highly
belated and deserved to be rejected on the
ground of laches alone in view of the settled
principles relating to interference in service
matters of this kind in exercise of the power of
judicial review. The learned Single Judge as
well as the Division Bench of the High Court
completely overlooked this aspect. The fact
that Respondent 1 waited for several years till
he
was
actually
Commandant
in
promoted
and
as
Deputy
even
as
Commandant in 1975 and more than three
years elapsed even thereafter before he had
filed the writ petition, is itself sufficient for the
rejection of the writ petition.”
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 86
69.
The decision in the case of P.S.Sadasivaswamy v.
State of Tamil Nadu, (1975) 1 SCC 152, relied upon by
Mr.Velmurugan, learned counsel appearing for some of the
respondents, it has been held as under:
“2. … A person aggrieved by an order of
promotion a junior over his head should
approach the Court at least within six months or
at the most a year of such promotion. It is not
that there is any period of limitation for the Courts
to exercise their powers under Article 226 nor is
it that there can never be a case where the
Courts cannot interfere in a matter after the
passage of a certain length of time. But it would
be a sound and wise exercise of discretion for the
Courts to refuse to exercise their extraordinary
powers under Article 226 in the case of persons
who do not approach it expeditiously for relief
and who stand by and allow things to happen and
then approach the Court to put forward stale
claims and true to unsettle settled matters. The
petitioner’s petition should, therefore, have been
dismissed in limine. Entertaining such petitions
is a waste of time of the Court. It clogs the work
of the Court and impedes the work of the Court
in considering legitimate grievances as also its
normal work. We consider that the High Court
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 87
was right in dismissing the appellant’s petition as
well as the appeal.”
70.
It is well-settled principle of law that delay defeats
equity. In S.S.Balu and another v. State of Kerala and others,
(2009) 2 SCC 479, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held as under:
“17. It is also well-settled principle of law that
“delay defeats equity”. The Government Order
was issued on 15-1-2022. The appellants did not
file any writ application questioning the legality
and validity thereof. Only after the writ petitions
filed by others were allowed and the State of
Kerala preferred an appeal there against, they
impleaded themselves as party-respondents. It
is now a trite law that where the writ petitioner
approaches the High Court after a long delay,
reliefs prayed for may be denied to them on the
ground of delay and laches irrespective of the
fact that they are similarly situated to the other
candidates who obtain the benefit of the
judgment. It is, thus, not possible for us to issue
any direction to the State of Kerala or the
Commission to appoint the appellants at this
stage. ….”
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 88
71.
The High Court does not ordinarily permit a belated
resort to the extraordinary remedy because it is likely to cause
confusion and public inconvenience and bring in its train new
injustices, and if writ jurisdiction is exercised after unreasonable
delay, it may have the effect of inflicting not only hardship and
inconvenience but also injustice on third parties.
When writ
jurisdiction is invoked, unexplained delay coupled with the creation
of third party rights in the meantime is an important factor which
also weighs with the High Court in deciding whether or not to
exercise such jurisdiction.
72.
It is trite law that a belated service related claim will
be rejected on the ground of delay and laches.
One of the
exceptions to the said rule is cases relating to a continuing wrong.
Where a service related claim is based on a continuing wrong,
relief can be granted even if there is a long delay in seeking
remedy with reference to the date on which the continuing wrong
commenced, if such continuing wrong creates a continuing source
of injury. In the case on hand, nothing has been produced to
establish that there exists continuing wrong in the case of the
petitioners. The wrong which is alleged to have been stated by the
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 89
petitioners in their pleadings cannot be treated and/or termed as
continuing wrong in the case of the petitioners.
73.
In view of above, the decisions relied upon by the
learned counsel for the petitioners in W.P.(C) No.923 of 2021 are
distinguishable and the same are not applicable to the facts and
circumstances of the case on hand. Therefore, the said decisions
are not elaborated in this order. Primarily, no material has been
produced by the petitioners to show that outside the quota
promotions were given to the private respondents.
74.
Prima facie, this Court finds that the writ petitions
suffer from delay and laches. No convincing explanation was
forthcoming from the side of the petitioners qua the delay and
laches. Since the petitioners approached the High Court after an
inordinate delay, the reliefs sought by them cannot be granted on
the ground of delay and laches in view of the settled principles
relating to interference in service matters of this kind in exercise of
the power of judicial review and also as discussed hereinabove.
75.
Now coming to the merits and demerits of the claim
made by the parties, it is pertinent to note that the petitioners were
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 90
appointed on 14.8.2007 as MPS Grade-II, whereas the private
respondents/promotes were appointed as MPS Grade-II on
1.3.2007. Thus, it is clear that when the private respondents were
appointed as MPS Grade-II, the petitioners, who are direct recruits
were not borne in the cadre. Therefore, this Court is of the view
that the petitioners have no locus to challenge the promotion given
to the private respondents, including the seniority list of the year
2017.
76.
The learned counsel appearing for the private
respondents contended that since the petitioners are direct
recruits, they have no right to challenge the promotion of the
private respondents as long as the promotes have not encroached
upon the quota of direct recruits. According to the learned counsel
for the private respondents, the direct recruits are third parties and
more over, they have not prayed for writ of quo warranto. This
Court is also find some force in the said submission raised by
learned counsel for the private respondents. Since the Department
dived the whole vacant post available for MPS Grade-II at the ratio
50:50 for direct recruits as well as for promotees as per the MPS
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 91
Rules, there is no question of encroaching the quota for direct
recruits by the promotees.
77.
By producing the following documents, Mr.S.Biswajit,
the learned counsel appearing for some of the private respondents
also submitted that the petitioners have admitted that 41 MPS
Grade-II posts meant for promotion quota, which are the newly
created posts and not temporary post:
(1)
Order
passed
by
the
Hon’ble
Supreme Court in Review Petition
No.296-298 of 2020, dated 4.3.2020.
(2)
Oder dated 18.3.2021 issued by the
Government of Manipur promoting 34
MPS officers to the post of MPS
Grade-II.
(3)
Letter dated 29.7.2005 of the Special
Secretary
(DP),
Government
of
Manipur in respect of requisition of
direct MPS officers showing 41 direct
recruit MPS Grade-II vacancy and
Government’s decision to fill up 32
vacancies only.
(4)
Relevant page of W.A.No.49 of 2017
on the file of Gauhati High Court filed
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 92
by the petitioners pleading/accepting
the 41 MPS Grade-II posts for the
promotion quota is the newly created
post not temporary posts.
(5)
Relevant portion of Review Petition
bearing
Review
Petition
Filing
No.3349 of 2019 filed by the State of
Manipur accepting that the said 41
MPS Grade-II posts in respect of
promotion quota are vacant posts.
78.
At this juncture, the learned senior counsel appearing
for the petitioners submitted that the petitioners do not have any
objection with the promotion of the private respondents, but their
grievance is only against the seniority position of the private
respondents.
79.
In reply, the learned counsel for the private
respondents submitted that the said argument is contradict to the
pleadings made in the writ petitions. The learned counsel
submitted that the main issue is regarding the 19 posts of MPS
Grade-II in respect of deputation, leave and training reserved are
50% of the total 38 posts earmarked for the promotion without
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 93
affecting 50% of the direct recruits. The said posts are under
Schedule-I as specified in Rules 4 and 7 of the Manipur Police
Service Rules, 1965 and, as such, they are not temporary post,
but authorized permanent strength of the Department. The learned
counsel further submitted that 19 posts which is the main basis of
the writ petitions are permanent posts.
80.
As could be seen from the records, the Special
Secretary (DP), Government of Manipur while communicating to
the Secretary, MPSC on 29.7.2005 regarding the Combined
Competitive Examination to be conducted by MPSC for the
process of requisition of 128 posts for different services, including
the MPS Grade-II, it has been clearly mentioned at Para V(c)(iii)
that there are 41 total number of vacancies for the direct
recruitment to MPS Grade-II, but the State Government has
decided to fill up 32 vacancies only. It also reveals that at that
point of time there were 41 vacant post of direct recruits as well as
41 vacant post of promotees in the rank of MPS Grade-II i.e.,
exactly as per 50% clause as provided in the MPS Rules, 1965.
Therefore, in the event of 19 posts of promotees are excess,
reciprocate number of post would be excess in the direct recruit
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 94
quota also. Thus, as rightly argued by the learned counsel for the
private respondents that all the 41 posts of the promotion quota
are regular and vacant posts were admitted by the petitioners and
that the State Government also accepted the said 41 posts of MPS
Grade-II are newly created and vacant posts.
81.
Litigations amongst the promotees cannot affect the
seniority of the direct recruits vis-à-vis with the promotes since if
one promotee comes instead of another promotees in the seniority
list, all the promotees who were promoted by taking the date of
promotion as 1.3.2007 would be en-bloc above the direct recruits
and hence, direct recruits have no business to interfere with the
promotion as well as seniority list qua promotees/private
respondents.
82.
The private respondents contended that the direct
recruits, including the petitioners by accepting the date of
promotion of the promoted officers as on 1.3.2007 pleaded to
apply the dove-telling method in the inter-se seniority between the
direct recruits and promotees by applying the ratio laid down in the
case of Union of India v. NR Parmer, (2012) 13 SCC 340. The
private respondents further contended that the direct recruits by
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 95
virtue of joining the service in the later recruitment year are enbloc below the promotees, who were promoted in the previous
recruitment year, have no business to interfere or challenge the
promotion, including the inter-se seniority of the promotees.
Admittedly, the said argument on the side of the private
respondents has not been suitably replied and/or controverted by
the petitioners’ side.
83.
Thus, it is clear that the willful act of the petitioners is
nothing but to delay the whole process of induction of the eligible
MPS promotees to IPS till their retirement from service on
superannuation, as they are on the verge of their retirement and
many have already retired/died without getting the entitled benefits
rendered by the Hon’ble Supreme Court as well as this Court in
the earlier round of litigations. Therefore, this Court is of the
considered view that the writ petitions at the hands of the
petitioners are barred by the principles of res judicata; constructive
res judicata and estoppel.
84.
On a perusal of the records, this Court finds that
when the issue was carried to the Hon’ble Supreme Court, the
Hon’ble Supreme Court after considering the arguments raised by
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 96
the respective counsel, decided the issue of seniority between the
direct recruits and promotees. While settling the issue, the Hon’ble
Supreme
Court
directed
the
State Government
to
give
consequential benefits to the private respondents as per the latest
seniority list dated 21.12.2020 produced by the State Government
with supporting affidavit before it.
85.
Since the Hon’ble Supreme Court accepted and
passed subsequent orders effectuating the seniority list dated
21.12.2020, the petitioners cannot now challenge the issue
already settled before the Hon’ble Supreme Court and if the
petitioners have any grievance, the only option left to them is to
approach the Hon’ble Supreme Court for appropriate relief.
86.
Once the petitioners accepted the verdict of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court, they cannot take a u-turn to stop
induction of the some promotees to IPS. The aforesaid act of the
petitioners to futile the whole exercise amounts to mala fide
intention and the same cannot be sustained in the eyes of law.
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 97
87.
It is trite law settled that a settled seniority position
should not be unsettled [Ref: Bimlesh Tanwar v. State of
Haryana and others, (2003) 5 SCC 604].
88.
The review DPC and the subsequent promotion
orders which are being challenged by the petitioners were issued
in compliance of the direction of this Court dated 12.3.2010 in
W.P.(C) No.265 of 2007 and another order dated 23.10.2015 in
W.P.(C) No.816 of 2013 which have attained finality. In fact, the
review DPC order clearly stipulates that it was done as per the
directions of this Court.
89.
Prior to the induction of the direct recruit MPS, the
private respondents were serving as Inspector in Manipur Police
Department and they were granted promotion through a duly
constituted DPCs.
At the cost of repetition, the private
respondents have entered MPS Grade-II cadre on 1.3.2007,
whereas the direct recruits were appointed later on 14.8.2007 and
24.11.2007 respectively and as such, the private respondents
should be regarded as senior to the direct recruits. The aforesaid
position has also been upheld by the Hon’ble Supreme Court.
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 98
90.
The direct recruits claimed seniority over the
promotees by contending that seniority has to be decided in
accordance with the year of vacancy and not by the fortuitous date
on which the appointment could be finalized for the direct recruits.
The said submissions cannot be accepted, as similar argument
was made before the Hon’ble Supreme Court and the Hon’ble
Supreme Court negatived the same.
91.
The claim of the petitioners that promotions of the
private respondents in 41 posts claiming the 19 posts as
temporary vacancies, which included deputation/leave/training
vacancies as illegal is unsustainable in the eyes of law, as the
DGP recommended to the MPSC for convening DPC in respect of
41 posts, which includes the 19 posts.
On a perusal of the
pleadings, it is clear that in the earlier round of litigations, the
respondent State pleaded that the said 19 posts are vacant posts
and further submitted that since the said posts are vacant and
regular posts, those officers who had been promoted in respect of
those 19 posts got their respective MGEL Number and received
full salary. Admittedly, the petitioners have failed to challenge the
letter dated 25.8.2006 of the DGP, Manipur and, as such, they
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 99
cannot challenge the subsequent actions taken as per the said
letter.
92.
At this juncture, the learned counsel for the private
respondents submitted that except few officers, who have been
promoted as per the impugned orders, all the promotees have
already retired from their service on superannuation and that some
officers have been promoted as MPS Grade-II by filling up those
vacancies including the vacancies arise owing to the promotion of
the private respondents to MPS Grade-I from MPS Grade-II as a
chain reaction.This Court finds some merits in the contention
raised by the learned counsel for the private respondents, as the
clock cannot be turned back and further it will amount to opening
of Pandora’s box, making reverse to the whole administration of
the Police Department.
93.
It is apposite to mention that the subsequent
promotion dated 18.3.2021 promoting the private respondents to
the post of MPS Grade-I admittedly was not challenged till date
and further the order dated 31.3.2021 of the respondent State
ordering placement of 51 MPS Grade-I to MPS Junior
Administrative Grade has also not been challenged till date. In
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 100
fact, the petitioners have failed to appreciate the Office
Memorandum dated 29.4.1999 issued by the Department of P&AR
and the Office Memorandum of DoPT dated 15.5.2007, which
speak about determination of regular vacancies and chain of
vacancies arising on account of retirement etc.
94.
At this juncture, the learned counsel for the
petitioners submitted that some other writ petitions are pending
and the final outcome of the said writ petitions may include the
petitioners in the seniority list of 2020, if succeeded.
The
argument aforesaid has nothing to do with the present challenges
in hand because of the fact that the petitioners in those writ
petitions are promotee officers challenging the promotion of other
promotees i.e. the issue amongst the promotee officers. Further,
the petitioners cannot take the advantage of other matters which
are not connected with the present issue, apart from the fact that
the petitioners have no locus standi to file the present writ
petitions.
95.
It is pertinent to mention that in the case of Jagdish
Ch. Pathak and others v. State of Orissa and others, (1998) 4
SCC 456, wherein the issue was whether the seniority between
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 101
the direct recruits and the promotees should be fixed by taking into
consideration the quota fixed for them and with reference to the
vacancies occurred against this quota. Rule 26 which provides
the manner as to how the seniority be determined, was relevant
and considering the scheme thereof, the Hon’ble Supreme Court
held:
“24. Rule 26 with which we are really concerned
in the present case is the rule of seniority. It
would be appropriate to extract the said Rule 26
in extensor:
“26. Seniority.- (1) When officers are
recruited by promotion and by direct
recruitment during the same year, the
promoted officers shall be considered
senior to the officers directly recruited
irrespective of their dates of joining the
appointment.
(2) Between the two groups of promoted
officers, those promoted from the rank of
Sub-Assistant Engineers shall en block be
senior to those promoted from the rank of
Junior Engineers.
(3) Subject to provision of sub-rules (1) and
(2) seniority of officers shall be determined
in accordance with the order in which their
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 102
names appear in the lists prepared by the
Commission. …”
96.
Assuming, though without admitting, that some
irregularities were committed by the Department in the process of
promotions of some private respondents, since maximum of the
promotees were already retired and only few of them are left with
very short span of service tenure, apart from the fact that many
incumbents have already occupied the vacant seats of MPS
Grade-II by virtue of the private respondents being promoted to
the higher posts i.e. MPS Grade-I, the present writ petitions filed
by the petitioners are fit cases to be dismissed by applying the
principle of equity in the interest of justice.
97.
It is reiterated that earlier, the learned Single Judge
of this Court has passed an order directing that the batch of MPS
promotees appointed on 1.3.2007 must be given seniority above
the direct recruit MPS appointed on 14.8.2007 and the learned
Single Judge justified that direct recruits can claim seniority only
from the date of their regular appointment. Aggrieved by the order
of the learned Single Judge, writ appeal was filed and a Division
Bench while upholding the ruling of the learned Single Judge
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 103
observed that seniority for direct recruits cannot be reckoned from
a date prior to their appointment. Aggrieved over the same, direct
recruits approached the Hon’ble Supreme Court. The Hon’ble
Supreme Court observed that as per Rule 28 of the MPS Rules,
1965, seniority in the service shall be determined based on the
date of appointment to the service and directed the State
Government to prepare a revised inter-se seniority list in respect
of MPS Grade-II cadres within the stipulated time. Accordingly,
the State Government under its office letter dated 28.5.2021 have
furnished the names of the eligible officers and the list of names
are prepared considering the seniority positions of the incumbents
which have attained finality after adjudication of various rounds of
litigations.
98.
As
the
vacancies
were
determined
by
the
Government of India, Ministry of Home Affairs for the year 2016,
2017 and 2018 as 5, 1, 4, 1 respectively, the Selection Committee
meeting was held on 3.12.2021 for preparation of year-wise select
list of 2016 to 2019 for promotion to IPS of Manipur cadre and the
minutes of the Committee was also forwarded vide letter dated
13.12.2021 to the State Government with a copy to the
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 104
Government of India for furnishing their observations and
recommendations of the Committee. Therefore, this Court is of
the view that the petitioners have no right to insist the
respondent/State to prepare a fresh final seniority list of MPS
officers.
99.
Any issues which have attained finality having
already decided by the Hon’ble Apex Court becomes infructuous
and moreover the same has been covered by the principles of res
judicata and constructive res judicata. While passing the judgment
dated 19.11.2019, the Hon’ble Apex Court observed that all the
consequential actions will follow from the judgment. This Court is
obliged to follow the aforesaid decision of the Hon’ble Apex Court
and following the principles laid down by the Hon’ble Apex Court,
this Court is of the view that there is no illegality in the promotion
to MPS Grade-II and the present writ petitions are futile exercise
for re-opening the matters which have adjudicated and effected by
the orders of this Court as well as the Hon’ble Apex Court.
100.
As stated supra, on the basis of the proposal
submitted by the State Government dated 28.5.2021, the
Selection Committee was held on 3.12.2021 for preparation of
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 105
year-wise selection list of 2016 to 2019 for promotion of State
Police Service officers to IPS of Manipur cadre. However, the
recommendation of the Selection Committee has not been
finalized in view of the interim order dated 20.12.2021 passed by
this Court thereby directing to maintain status quo as on
20.12.2021.
101.
When these writ petitions were taken up for hearing,
on 17.12.2021, this Court directed to list the writ petitions before
another Bench on 22.12.2021 for consideration of the interim
order. Subsequently, MC(WP) No.317 of 2021 has been filed by
the petitioners praying for rectification of the order as regards the
status quo to be maintained by the parties. The said application
was taken up on 20.12.2021 and this Court allowed the application
thereby directing that status quo as on that date shall be
maintained by all the parties till the next date of hearing. The said
order of status quo still continues.
102.
Alleging that the interim order passed by this Court is
contradictory to the judgment of the Hon’ble Apex Court dated
19.11.2019 passed in Civil Appeal No.8833-8835 of 2019,
MC(WP) Nos.88 of 2022 and 20 of 2022 have been filed by the
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 106
private respondents. Admittedly, the interim order of status quo
granted by this Court in these writ petitions is contradictory to the
judgment of the Hon’ble Apex Court passed in Civil Appeal
No.8833-8835 of 2019, dated 19.11.2019.
103.
Since the matter of seniority has been well settled
and this Court as well as the Hon’ble Supreme Court in a plethora
of cases held that the seniority/promotion granted on the strength
of DPC selection should not be unsettled after a lapse of time, this
Court finds merits in the case of the private respondents. In the
absence of any violation in the impugned orders, undertaking a
judicial review under Article 226 of the Constitution of India is
unwarranted in these cases.
104.
For the foregoing discussions, this Court is of the
view that there is no merit in the claim made by the petitioners and
also the present writ petitions at the hands of the petitioners are
hit by laches and the principles of res judicata and constructive res
judicata, apart from the principle of estoppel.
105.
In the result,
(1) The writ petitions are dismissed.
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
P a g e | 107
(2) The interim order dated 17.12.2021
passed in the writ petitions read with the
order dated 20.12.2021 passed by this
Court shall stand vacated and MC
(WP(C)) Nos.88 and 20 of 2022 are
allowed.
(3) In view of the dismissal of the writ
petitions, MC (WP(C)) No.280 of 2021 is
closed.
(4) The respondent authorities are directed to
proceed further as expeditiously as
possible.
(5) There will be no order as to costs.
JUDGE
FR/NFR
Sushil
WP(C) No. 867 of 2017, WP(C) No. 346 of 2021, WP(C) No. 923 of 2021, MC(WP(C)) No. 20 of 2022,
MC(WP(C)) No. 280 of 2022,MC(WP(C)) No. 88 of 2022
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review