Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1NC: 2026:KHC:23440
WP No. 39444 of 2025
HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
DATED THIS THE 27TH DAY OF APRIL, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE S.R.KRISHNA KUMAR
WRIT PETITION NO. 39444 OF 2025 (S-RES)
BETWEEN:
1.
SHRI.K.ANANTHAPADMANABHA RAO
S/O SHRI K. RAMEHSHA RAO
AGED ABOUT 57 YEARS
RESIDING AT-14/1, (32)
POOJA POWER COMPOUND
17A CROSS, MALLESWARAM WEST BENGALURU
560055
…PETITIONER
(BY SRI. PRANAY SHARMA Y., ADVOCATE)
AND:
Digitally
signed by
CHANDANA
BM
Location:
High Court
of Karnataka
1.
THE COMMISSIONER OF CENTRAL TAXES
NORTH WEST COMMISSIONERATE
BMTC BUILDING, SHIVAJINAGAR
BENGALURU - 560051
2.
THE CHIEF COMMISSIONER
OF CENTRAL TAX CENTRAL REVENUE BUILDING
QUEENS ROAD
BENGALURU - 560001
3.
THE ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF
CENTRAL TAX INQUIRY OFFICER, NW-DIVISION-3
NORTH WEST COMMISSIONERATE BMTC BUILDING,
SHIVAJINAGAR, BENGALURU - 560051
-2NC: 2026:KHC:23440
WP No. 39444 of 2025
HC-KAR
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. ARAVIND V CHAVAN.,ADVOCATE)
THIS WP IS FILED PRAYING TO-QUASH THE ORDER IN
ORIGINAL NO. 01/2025 PASSED BY THE R1 DATED 10.11.2025
VIDE C NO. II/10A/01/2023 VIG BNW VIDE ANNX-A DISMISSING
THE
PETITIONER
SUPERINTENDENT
FROM
OF
COMMISSIONERATE.B.
SERVICE
CENTRAL
DIRECT
OF
TAX,
THE
POST
NORTH
OF
WEST
RESPONDENTS
TO
REINSTATE THE PETITIONER AND PROVIDE SALARY TO THE
PETITIONER RETROSPECTIVELY ALONG WITH INTEREST AS
APPLICABLE.C. ALTERNATIVELY, DIRECT THE CENTRAL
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL (CAT) TO ADMIT THE APPEAL OF
THE PETITIONER AND PROVIDE FOR STAY OF THE ORDER
CHALLENGED TILL THE ADMIT OF THE APPEAL BEFORE THE
HONORABLE TRIBUNAL.D) DIRECT THE RESPONDENTS TO
PAY THE COSTS OF THIS WP.GRANT AN INTERIM ORDER TO
STAY THE OPERATION OF THE ORDER IN ORIGINAL NO.
01/2025 PASSED BY THE R1 DATED 10.11.2025 VIDE C NO.
II/10A/01/2023 VIG BNW DISMISSING THE PETITIONER FROM
SERVICE OF POST OF SUPERINTENDENT OF CENTRAL TAX
NORTH WEST COMMISSIONERATE, VIDE ANNX-A.C
THIS PETITION, COMING ON FOR FINAL HEARING, THIS
DAY, ORDER WAS MADE THEREIN AS UNDER:
-3NC: 2026:KHC:23440
WP No. 39444 of 2025
HC-KAR
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE S.R.KRISHNA KUMAR
ORAL ORDER
In this petition, the petitioner has sought for the following
reliefs:
“a) Issue a writ of the certiorari quashing the Order in
Original No.01/2025 passed by the Respondent No.1 dated
10.11.2025 vide C.No.II/10A/01/2023 Vig BNW
vide
Annexure A dismissing the petitioner from service of post of
SUPERINTENDENT
of
Central
Tax,
North
West
Commissionerate.
b) Direct the Respondents to reinstate the petitioner and
provide salary to the petitioner retrospectively along with
interest as applicable
c) Alternatively, Direct the Central Administrative Tribunal
(CAT) to admit the appeal of the petitioner and provide for
stay of the order challenged till the admit of the appeal
before the Hon'ble Tribunal.
d) And pass such other orders as this Hon'ble Court deems
fit and proper in the interest of justice and equity
e) Direct the Respondents to pay the costs of this Writ
Petition.”
-4NC: 2026:KHC:23440
WP No. 39444 of 2025
HC-KAR
2.
Heard learned counsel for the petitioner and learned
counsel for the respondent Nos.1 to 3 and perused the material on
record.
3.
disciplinary
A perusal of the material on record will indicate that the
proceedings
having
been
initiated
against
the
petitioner, by the respondents, a charge memorandum dated
10.10.2023 was issued as against the petitioner, in pursuance of
which, an enquiry report dated 27.12.2024 was submitted, to
which, a disagreement note dated 31.03.2025 was issued whereby
it was held that the charges framed against the petitioner were
proved.
4.
Subsequently, there were criminal proceedings in
Special CC No.29/2023 in which, the petitioner filed a discharge
application and the same was pending consideration. Under these
circumstances, the petitioner submitted a representation/request
for an opportunity of personal hearing on the ground that discharge
application was pending in the criminal proceedings and the same
having been posted for orders, an opportunity for personal hearing
is to be granted in favour of the petitioner.
-5NC: 2026:KHC:23440
WP No. 39444 of 2025
HC-KAR
5.
It is the grievance of the petitioner that despite the
specific request for personal hearing having been submitted by the
petitioner vide Annexure - F dated 07.11.2025, the respondent did
not exceed to the same and proceeded to pass the impugned order
at Annexure - A dated 10.11.2025 immediately thereafter without
providing sufficient and reasonable opportunity to the petitioner,
thereby violating principles of natural justice and as such, petitioner
is before this Court by way of the present petition.
6.
Learned counsel for the petitioner would also invite my
attention to the memo dated 21.04.2026 along with the documents
produced with the same in order to point out that subsequent to the
impugned order, the Sessions Court/Special Court discharged the
petitioner / accused No.2 vide Order dated 14.01.2026 which would
have a direct and substantial bearing/impact on the impugned
order of dismissal which deserves to be set aside and the matter
remitted back to the respondent for reconsideration afresh in
accordance with law.
7.
It is also pointed out that against the order passed by
the Customs Department, the petitioner had filed an appeal which
also culminated in an order dated 30.12.2025, which was
-6NC: 2026:KHC:23440
WP No. 39444 of 2025
HC-KAR
demanded for de novo adjudication, which circumstance would
also have a bearing/impact on the impugned order and against the
impugned dismissal order passed against the petitioner. It is
therefore submitted that the impugned order deserves to be set
aside and the matter remitted back to the respondent for
reconsideration afresh in accordance with law.
8.
Per contra, learned counsel for the respondent would
reiterate the various contentions urged in the statement of
objections and submits that there is no merit in the petition and the
same is liable to be dismissed especially when the petitioner has
an equally efficacious alternative remedy by way of an appeal
against the impugned order and as such, there is no merit in the
petition and the same is liable to be dismissed.
9.
A perusal of the material on record will indicate that it
is an undisputed fact and a matter of record that the impugned
order came to be passed on 10.11.2025. About 3 days prior to the
date of the impugned order, the petitioner submits a representation
vide Annexure - F dated 07.11.2025 requesting an opportunity for
personal hearing on the ground that an discharge application filed
by him in Special CC No.29/2023 in which, he was arrayed as
-7NC: 2026:KHC:23440
WP No. 39444 of 2025
HC-KAR
accused No.2 was pending before the Sessions Court/Special
Court. The said representation reads as under:
"From,
K.Ananthapadmanabha Rao
Superintendent
Northwest Commissionerate
Bengaluru
To,
The Commissioner
Disciplinary Authority
Northwest Commissionerate,
Bengaluru
Subject:
Charge memorandum issued on
10/10/2023-requesting for an additional
opportunity to present the defence in
person in the matter-Rg
In the above matter, it is submitted that, in the original
matter and root cause for the issue of the Charge
memorandum, ie., the show cause notice dated 24-1-2022
issued by the Additional Commissioner of Customs, ACC
Bengaluru, the issue has been decided by the adjudicating
authority and the gravity of charges levelled against the under
signed in the SCN has been reduced substantially, i.e., by
over 90%. Further, an appeal has been preferred. against the
same and the same is fixed for PH on 12th November 2025.
-8NC: 2026:KHC:23440
WP No. 39444 of 2025
HC-KAR
Further in respect of the action initiated by the ACB,
Bengaluru in the matter on the request of the department, the
undersigned has filed an discharge application and the
arguments on the same has completed on 5-11-2025 and the
matter is posted for orders.
Considering the above factors and more likelihood of
decisions in both above mentioned matters will be available
very shortly, I request the benign Disciplinary Authority to
provide me an opportunity to present the out come of the
parallel proceedings in person before taking any further
decision in the disciplinary proceedings, please.
The undersigned will be grateful to the Commissioner
Sir for the above act of kindness.
Place:Bengaluru
Date: 6/11/2025
Yours faithfully,
[K.Ananthapadmanabha Rao]
Superintendent"
10.
It is also a matter of record and undisputed fact that
subsequently, the Sessions Court/Special Court allowed the
discharge application vide Order dated 14.01.2026 which reads as
under:
-9NC: 2026:KHC:23440
WP No. 39444 of 2025
HC-KAR
"ORDERS ON APPLICATION U/S 239 OF CR.P.C:
The accused No.2 has filed this application under
Section 239 of Cr.P.C., seeking discharge for the allegations/
offences punishable under sections 120-B r/w section 420 of
IPC and Sections 7 and 8 of Prevention of Corruption Act
1988.
2. It is averred in the application that the alleged
omissions and commissions attributed to this accused are in
fact integral part of his duties done in discharge of duty and
any act would entail for dereliction of duty. The accused being
public servant there is need for obtaining sanction under
section 197 of CRPC and sanction under section 19 of
P.C.Act alone is not sufficient. Further under section 155 of
Customs act, accused being customs officer has immunity
from prosecution. The acts done by this accused are done in
good faith and in bonafide discharge of his official duties. It is
further averred that only Special court established under
Prevention of Corruption Act is having jurisdiction to try the
offence if specifically notified. If not notified the trial would be
rendered illegal.
3. It is further averred that there is no ingredient forth
coming to attract offence under section 120-B of IPC and
section 8 of P.C.Act. There is no conspicuous material of
meeting of minds amongst the accused persons. The matter
with regard to offence of illegal export of red sanders is
already investigated by DRI Bengaluru and show cause
notice was issued to this accused under customs act. The
- 10 NC: 2026:KHC:23440
WP No. 39444 of 2025
HC-KAR
same is pending for adjudication and Departmental enquiry is
also pending. The show cause notice issued by DRI and
charge sheet submitted by CBI arise out of same facts,
circumstances, documents. The allegation against this
accused no.2 is far from truth, not factual, and based on
assumption and presumption.
4. It is further pleaded that the charge sheet is result of
misconstruction of facts and circumstances and failure to
understand established procedure under Customs act. The
complaint
suffers
form
disjointness,
incompleteness,
misconstruction and resulting failure of justice. There is lack
of documentary evidence, the statements were recorded
under threat, coercion. There is no proof of demand and
acceptance of money. The other officers who allowed LEO for
four shipments were not charge sheeted and the accused
no.2 stands on same footing. But the same benefit is not
given to this accused. The details of these grounds
elaborately explained in the petition and sought discharge on
the above referred grounds.
5. The learned Public Prosecutor has filed statement of
objections wherein It is contended that, the petition filed by
the petitioner/accused No.2 is devoid of merits and liable to
be dismissed in limini. Based on the written complaint dated
08.09.2021 given by the Olo the Principal, Commissioner of
Customs, Airport and Air Cargo Complex, Devanahalli,
Bengaluru, a preliminary enquiry report dated 21.12.2021 was
submitted by Shri. Deviprasad, PSI, CBI, ACB, Bengaluru. On
- 11 NC: 2026:KHC:23440
WP No. 39444 of 2025
HC-KAR
the basis of the said report a case vide RC-15(A)/2021 has
been registered on 22.12.2021 against Accused No. 1Mr.C.Venkatesh, accused No.2-Mr.Anantha Padmanabha,
accused No.3-Mr.Ravinder Pawar, accused No.4-Mr.Satish
Kumar, accused No.5-Mr.Najeeb.Z and other unknown public
servant for commission of offences punishable under sections
120-B of IPC and Section 7 of Prevention of Corruption Act
alleging that they conspired for facilitating illicit export of the
Red Sandal wooden logs. The Statement of CW-79 is
relevant with regard to duties of Superintendent, Central
Excise and document no-9 is relevant document with regard
to the procedure to be followed by Inspectors and
Superintendent of Customs while clearing the ICEGATE
Portal by using shipping Bills through RMS/Assessment
Channels.
6. It is alleged that, the accused No.5-Mr.Najeeb
Zianudheen and accused No.4-Satish Kumar conspired with
accused No.1-Venkatesh.C, who is the Superintendent of
Customs and accused No.4-Sathish Kumar, office of Chief
Commissioner's
Office
Customs,
Bengaluru,
acted
as
middlemen between accused No.5 and accused No.1 and
agreed to do the documentation and other customs clearance
formalities for the illegal export of Red Sandar. In pursuance
of such conspiracy, accused No.5-Najeeb Zianudheen
procured Red Sandars vide shipping bill No.2190821 D-8 and
10). Further, on the directions of accused No.5-Najeeb
Zianudheen, accused No.4-Sathish Kumar mis-declared the
goods for customs clearance. During the process of
- 12 NC: 2026:KHC:23440
WP No. 39444 of 2025
HC-KAR
clearance, the said shipment was selected for physical
examination by Risk Management System and accused No.3Ravinder Pawar had given the examination report (D-10)
stating that the goods were Industrial Spares as declared in
the invoice even through the consignment was Red Sanders.
Further accused No.3-Ravindar Pawar demanded accused
No.4- to pay an amount of Rs.5 lakhs to clear the above
consignment which was kept aside by the screening staff as
they suspected it to contain wood. It is also revealed that
accused
-Ravinder
Pawar
told
accused
No.4-Sathish
Kumar.T that the accused No.2-Sri.Anantha Padmanabha
Rao, Superintendent had come to know about it.
7. Further, the accused No.3 immediately arranged the
amount and gave Rs.2.5 lakhs in cash to accused No.3Ravinder Pawar and transferred an amount of Rs.25,001/and
Rs.99,999/-from
No.431901500656
his
(D-13)
ICICI
Bank
account
the
bank
account
to
No.20015079351 (D-12) at SBI, PBB Branch, Malleswaram,
which is in the name of Smt.Jayalakshmi Rao, mother of
accused No.2-Sri.Anantha Padmanabha Rao on the same
day. The screen shots taken from the Indian Customs EDI
system shows that the petitioner/accused No.2 and accused
No.3/Ravinder Pawar were on duty at Import Export shed of
Air Cargo Complex on 03.06.2021 and facilitated in clearing
the shipping bill No.2190821. The fact that, shipping bill
No.2190821
was
taken
up
for
open
examination
is
established through the data available in system and the Xray image (D-8) taken in respect of the above consignment
- 13 NC: 2026:KHC:23440
WP No. 39444 of 2025
HC-KAR
looked like wood and not industrial spares. Though a false
report
filed
by
accused
No.3-Ravinder
Pawar,
the
petitioner/accused No.2 violating the procedure let Export
Order for the said consignment. Thus, the involvement of
petitioner/accused No.2 in facilitating the illegal export of RedSanders herein primafacie shows that he is particeps in
criminis of the conspiracy designed and executed by accused
No.1-Venkatesh, accused No.3-Ravindar Pawar, accused
No.4-Sathish Kumar and accused No.5-Najeeb Zianudheen
to cheat the Customs Department by mis-declaring the goods
and exported the consignments and the said accused
customs officials obtained undue advantage from accused
No.4 until it was intercepted by the DRI.
8. Issuance of the Let Export order by the accused
No.2 and crediting of amount in the account of his mother,
prima facie shows that in pursuance of such conspiracy,
petitioner /accused No.2 aided the other accused in
facilitating the illegal export of Red-Sanders. The allegations
against the accused No.2/petitioner are supported by the
statement of witnesses for oral evidence and relevant
documentary evidence. As accused No.4 and 5 are willing
parties in offering bribe and by not approached any
investigating agency to report on the corrupt practices of
accused No.1 and 3 and accused No.2. Hence, prays to
reject the discharge application.
9. Heard the arguments from both side.
- 14 NC: 2026:KHC:23440
WP No. 39444 of 2025
HC-KAR
10. The Points that would arise for my consideration
are as follows :1) Whether accused No.2 has made out
grounds to discharge and allow the
application filed under Sec. 239 of
Cr.P.C.?
2) What Order?
11. My findings on the above points are as follows:
Point No.1: In the Affirmative.
Point No.2: As per the final order
for the following::REASONS:
12.
POINT NO.1: The accused has filed the
application under section 239 of Crpc. The Section 239 of
Cr.P.C., reads as under:
S. 239: When accused shall be discharged
If, upon considering the police report and the
documents sent with it under section 173 and
making such examination, if any, of the accused as
the Magistrate thinks necessary and after giving
the prosecution and the accused an opportunity of
being heard, the Magistrate considers the charge
against the accused to be groundless, he shall
- 15 NC: 2026:KHC:23440
WP No. 39444 of 2025
HC-KAR
discharge the accused, and record his reasons for
so doing.
13. So, on understanding the provision it specifies, the
obligation to discharge the accused under Section 239
Cr.P.C. arises when the Magistrate/Special Judge considers
the charge against the accused to be groundless i.e, there is
no legal evidence or when the facts are such that no offence
is made out at all.
14. Before adverting to the factual aspects of the case,
the well settled principles of law is required to be reiterated
wherein itis held that the court at the time of considering the
application seeking for discharge need not examine the
materials in detail to ascertain whether there are grounds to
award conviction. Only aspect the court is required to
consider is to, sift and weigh the materials to ascertain
whether the materials placed before the court indicate facially
the commission of offence and if so the case has to be
proceeded, to frame charges.
15. While considering the application under section 227
of Cr.P.C., as per the dictum of Hon'ble Apex Court in the
case of State Through Deputy Superintendent Of Police
Versus R.Soundirarasu-2022 Live Law (SC) 741 has held
as under:.
53. The aforestated Section indicate that the
CrPC contemplates discharge of the accused by
- 16 NC: 2026:KHC:23440
WP No. 39444 of 2025
HC-KAR
the Court of Sessions under Section 227 in a
case triable by it, cases instituted upon a police
report are covered by Section 239 and cases
instituted otherwise than on a police report are
dealt with in Section 245. The three Sections
contain some what different provisions in regard
to discharge of the accused. As per Section 227,
the trial judge is required to discharge the
accused if "the Judge considers that there is not
sufficient ground for proceeding against the
accused".
The
obligation
to
discharge
the
accused under Section 239 arises when "the
Magistrate considers the charge against the
accused to be groundless". The power to
discharge under Section 245(1) is exercisable
when "the Magistrate considers, for reasons to be
recorded, that no case against the accused has
been made out which, if un-rebutted would
warrant his conviction". Sections 227 and 239
resply provide for discharge being made before
the recording of evidence and the consideration
as to whether the charge has to be framed or not
is required to be made on the basis of the record
of the case, including the documents and oral
hearing of the accused and the prosecution or the
police report, the documents sent along with it
and examination of the accused and after
affording an opportunity to the parties to be
heard. On the other hand, the stage for discharge
- 17 NC: 2026:KHC:23440
WP No. 39444 of 2025
HC-KAR
under Section 245 is reached only after the
evidence referred to in Section 244 has been
taken.
54. Despite the slight variation in the
provisions with regard to discharge under the
three pairs of Sections referred to above, the
settled legal position is that the stage of framing
of charge under either of these three situations, is
a preliminary one and the test of "prima facie"
case has to be applied - if the trial court is
satisfied that a prima facie case is made out,
charge has to be framed.
16. The judgment of the Hon'ble High Court of
Karnataka reported in 2022 (2) KCCR SN 135 (K.Manjunath
Vs State and another) wherein it has been held as :-
Scope of discharge under Section 239 of
Cr.P.C. is very limited. The Court cannot held a
mini trial while considering the application and
only look into the documents which have been
filed along with the charge sheet. The defence
cannot be raised in discharge application.
Scope of Section 239 of Cr.P.C. is very limited.
In a case where material is not collected, then
Court can discharge the accused, if allegation
made in the charge sheet is groundless, then
- 18 NC: 2026:KHC:23440
WP No. 39444 of 2025
HC-KAR
the Court can exercise power under Section
239 of Cr.PC. Petition dismissed.
17. In the arguments advanced by the learned counsel
for accused No.2, has more stressed upon the provision of
Section 155 of Customs Act. It is contended that, as per this
provision, the accused is having immunity from being
prosecuted directly and if has to be prosecuted, notice has to
be issued and charge sheet is to be filed within three months
of the date of offence. However, in this case, the prosecution
has not followed both and it is clear violation of this law which
benefits the accused to seek discharge of the alleged
offences.
The
learned
counsel
for
the
accused
has
emphasized on the point of following this law being special
law barring invoking General Law. It is also highlighted that,
the sanction for prosecution is only obtained under section 19
of PC Act, but, the sanction required under section 197 of
Cr.P.C., for the offence alleged under IPC is not obtained
from competent authority and this also is beneficial to the
accused to seek discharge. It goes to the roots of the case
and as such, the prosecution cannot be continued.
18. To understand better, the Section 155 of Customs
Act is reproduced as under:
155. Protection of action taken under the Act.
-(1) No suit, prosecution or other legal
proceedings
shall
lie
against
the
Central
Government or any officer of the Government or
- 19 NC: 2026:KHC:23440
WP No. 39444 of 2025
HC-KAR
a local authority for anything which is done, or
intended to be done in good faith, in pursuance
of this Act or the rules or regulations.
(2) No proceeding other than a suit shall be
commenced against the Central Government or
any officer of the Government or a local
authority for anything purporting to be done in
pursuance of this Act without giving the Central
Government or such officer a month's previous
notice in writing of the intended proceeding and
of the cause thereof, or after the expiration of
three months from the accrual of such cause.
19. The learned counsel for accused argued that, to
decide whether sanction is necessary, the judgment in the
case of D.Devaraja V/s Owais Sabeer Hussain (2020)7
SCC 695 wherein it is held that, the test whether the act is
totally unconnected with the official duty or whether there is
reasonable connection with the official duty and in case of act
of policeman or any other public servant unconnected with the
official duty their can be no question of sanction. However, if
the act alleged against the policeman is reasonably
connected with discharge of his official duty, it does not
matter if policeman has exceeded the scope of his powers
and acted beyond the four corners of law (Para-70). The
learned counsel for accused placed reliance on the judgment
of Hon'ble Apex Court in the matter of Jayalalitha V/s Union
of India and others (1999)5 SCC 138 on the point of
sanction required for prosecution. Another judgment in the
- 20 NC: 2026:KHC:23440
WP No. 39444 of 2025
HC-KAR
case of G.C.Manjunath and others V/s Seetharam, (2025) 5
SCC 390 wherein Hon'ble Apex Court has clarified the
essential
conditions
required
to
obtain
sanction
for
prosecution. More particularly, the learned counsel for the
accused relied upon the judgment of Hon'ble High Court of
Punjab and Hariyana in the case of Sunilkumar and others
V/s CBI and others 2016 SCC Online P and H 613. The
learned counsel for accused has pressed upon the fact that,
this judgment is aptly applicable to the facts of the case as the
Hon'ble High Court of Punjab and Hariyana has discussed
about the provision of Section 155 of Customs Act and based
on that, has quashed the proceedings. Even, the judgment of
Hon'ble High Court of Calcutta in the case of Ashok Kumar
Singh V/s State of West Bengal and another 2016 SCC
Online Calcutta 1516, wherein the Hon'ble High Court has
also discussed the said provision and in the facts of the case,
wherein he was examining officer of customs omitted to
perform duty in order to assist the principal accused, to export
goods improperly from India, applying section 155(2) of
Customs Act, 1962 has given the benefit of immunity of
prosecution.
20. Further, he has placed reliance on the orders
passed by the learned Special Judge sitting in the 32nd
Additional City Civil and Sessions Judge for CBI cases dated
03.03.2022 while dealing petition under section 239 read with
section 227 of Cr.P.C., for the provisions under Passport Act
specifically Section 15 is invoked and has given benefit of the
- 21 NC: 2026:KHC:23440
WP No. 39444 of 2025
HC-KAR
said provision and for non production of sanction order
discharged the accused.
21. The counter argument canvassed by the learned
Public Prosecutor is on the point that, it is only they are
protected if they act in good faith and taking bribe and doing
illegal acts is not termed as good faith and hence, this
immunity is not attracted to the case on hand. Even the
learned public prosecutor who has filed synopsis of
arguments, in that has also urged that the sanction as
required under section 197 of Crpc is required when there is
reasonable connection between act alleged and the duty of
officer. But in this case it is totally unconnected and taking
bribe for doing illegal act is not covered under good faith or in
discharge of duty. Hence the judgment relied by other side is
not applicable to case on hand.
22. Considering the rival submissions and after going
through the judgment relied upon by the learned counsel for
the accused, I am of the opinion that, the section 155 of
Customs Act has not been followed by the CBI before
prosecuting this accused. As it is admitted that, they have not
given notice of one month in writing and the prosecution is
launched after three months from accrual of such cause.
Thereby it is only left to decide whether it is attracting the
facts of the case to invoke provision under section 155 of
Customs Act. As per the contents of the provision, it is
protecting the Customs officers by any suit, prosecution or
other legal proceedings to be initiated against them, if it is
- 22 NC: 2026:KHC:23440
WP No. 39444 of 2025
HC-KAR
done or intended to be done in good faith in pursuance of this
act or the rules or regulations. The second sub section
speaks about if prosecution is to be launched, one month
prior notice to be given to the officer.
23. In this case, it is admitted fact that this accused
No.2 is Customs officer and the allegations leveled against
him are punishable under section 120-B read with 420 of IPC
and Sections 7 and 8 of PC Act. It is the allegation that, this
accused No.2 being Superintendent of Customs let export
order for the consignment and to be more specific a
consignment which was containing load of Red sanders was
allowed to pass through for export by suppressing the fact
that it is containing such goods and mentioning it as Industrial
Spares. Even though it has been brought to the knowledge of
this accused No.2, he has aided them to pass through by
accepting bribe to the account of his mother. Considering
these facts, it is clear on the face of it that the act alleged is
not to be said as distinctive, not connected to the the
discharge of his official duty. The duty of the accused No.2
was to properly check the goods and if he has omitted to do
so either intentionally or not, it is connected with discharge of
his duty. In this regard the judgment of Hon'ble Supreme
Court in Case of Rizwan Ahmed Javed Shaikh and Ors. V/s
Jammal Patel and Ors. 2001 INSC 281_it is held as under:
"The real test to be applied to attract the act which
is done by a public office and is alleged to constitute
an offence was done by the public officer whilst
- 23 NC: 2026:KHC:23440
WP No. 39444 of 2025
HC-KAR
acting in his official capacity though what he did was
neither his duty not his right to do as such public
officer. The act complained of may be in exercise of
the duty or in the absence of such duty or in
dereliction of the duty, if the act complained of is
done while acting as a public officer and in the course
of the same transaction in which the official duty was
performed or purported to be performed the public
officer would be protected.".
Thereby, in my opinion in this case as well the accused
no.2 is protected under the umbrella of section 155 of
Customs Act from being prosecuted. Hon'ble Apex Court in
the case of Costao Fernandes v. State at the instance of
D.S.P., CBI, Bombay has held:
"wherein a Customs Officer had a scuffle with a
person alleged of smuggling gold and caused
his death and when the CBI sought to
prosecute the Customs Officer, came down
heavily and held that the protection under
Section 155 of the Customs Act was available
to the Customs Officer as the killing cannot be
divorced from the performance of duty enjoined
by Section 106 of the Customs Act, 1962
though the act might be in excess. In the
present
case
also,
the
petitioners
were
searching the premises and seizing documents
under Section 105 of the Customs Act, 1962
- 24 NC: 2026:KHC:23440
WP No. 39444 of 2025
HC-KAR
and the said official duty is inseparably linked
to the allegation of interpolating two invoices
and tampering with records seized under the
cover of Panchanama. The allegations relate to
the performance of official duties by the
petitioners, hence, they were protected against
the prosecution under Section 155(1) of the
Customs Act, 1962".
24. The Hon'ble Telangana High Court in the case of
State Rep By Cbi vs Sri Rajnish Aggarwal And Another,
in CRIMINAL REVISION CASE Nos.28 of 2009, 1942, 1947,
1948, 1949 and 1681,1701,1702,1703 and 1704 of 2008,
decided on on 25 January, 2024 dealt with more or similar
situation. The brief facts of the case are explained that during
the period 2000-2001, the accused A1 to A8 entered into
criminal conspiracy among themselves to cheat the Customs
Department
at
Inland
Container
Deport,
Sanathnagar,
Hyderabad, in the matter if export of cheat and very small
garments of uneven size and shape, which are unfit for use
by any age group and have negligible value, in the guise of
"Dyed/printed
night-wears
(maxies)
in
various
style/size/design/colours made from P/L, Woven Fab valued
at Rs.300 per piece under Duty Entitlement Pass Book
(DEPB) scheme and attempted to export two consignments to
Dubai from ICD, Sanathnagar, Hyderabad on 06.01.2001 in
the name of M/s.Ganesh Yarntex Exports Pvt Ltd and M/s
Aadee Exports and Imports by way of bogus documents.
- 25 NC: 2026:KHC:23440
WP No. 39444 of 2025
HC-KAR
25. Applying the case law referred supra, the
contention of learned PP that acting in good faith does not
hold good. As the Hon'ble Apex Court has given the benefit of
Section 155 of Customs Act in case of Murder committed by
Officer of Customs which is in excess to his duty, in this case
as well the act of accused in allowing export of goods
suppressing the fact that it contains red sanders, is not
dislinked to his discharge of duty. The allegations relate to the
performance of official duties by the petitioner, hence, he is
protected under Section 155 of the Customs Act, 1962.
26. In the present case, the allegations were made
against
the
petitioner
about
cheating
the
Customs
department, committing the offence of criminal conspiracy,
and allowing illegal export of red sanders, attracting offences
under section 120-B r/w section 420 of IPC. No doubt the
Prosecution has obtained sanction order under section 19 of
PC act from competent authority but there is no specific order
showing sanction accorded under section 197 of CR. P.C to
prosecute the accused for the offfences under IPC. The
offences were alleged to have been committed by the
petitioner while performing the official duties. Section 197 of
the Code of Criminal Procedure if construed too narrowly, it
can never be applied, as it is no part of an official's duty to
commit an offence and never can be, as observed by the
Hon'ble Apex Court in Shreekantiah Ramayya Munipalli
and Anr. v. State of Bombay AIR 1955 SC 287.
- 26 NC: 2026:KHC:23440
WP No. 39444 of 2025
HC-KAR
27. No narrow interpretation can be given to Section
197 Cr.P.C., as the acts alleged against the petitioner is
reasonably connected in discharge of official duties. As such,
cognizance cannot be taken by the Court without the requisite
sanction of the appropriate Government. As such, taking
cognizance of the offences by the Court without prior sanction
is considered as illegal and void ab initio. The use of the
words 'no' and 'shall' under Section 197 Cr.P.C. would make it
abundantly clear that the bar on the exercise of power of the
court to take cognizance of any offence is absolute and
complete and taking of the cognizance is barred under law.
Further the judgments relied by accused no.2 are helpful in
holding that he is protected under section 155 of Customs Act
as well. In the case of G C Manjunath vs Seetharam,
Hon'ble Apex Court has held as under:
Para 34: The language of both Section 197 of
the CrPC and Section 170 of the Police Act is clear
that sanction is required not only for acts done in the
discharge of official duty as well as for the acts
purported to be done in the discharge of official duty
and/or acts done "under colour of or in excess of
such
duty
or
authority".
Sanction
becomes
mandatory if there is a reasonable connection
between the act and the officer's official duties, even
if the officer acted improperly or exceeded his
authority.
- 27 NC: 2026:KHC:23440
WP No. 39444 of 2025
HC-KAR
28. Hence, considering the principle explained, in this
case as well the act of accused if held as improper, even then
he is protected under section 197 of Cr.P.C. Thereby on
considering all these points this court is of the opinion that the
CBI has not followed the mandate of section 155 of Customs
Act and section. 197 of Cr.P.C and entitling the accused
discharge. Hence I answer point No.1 in the Affirmative..
29. POINT NO.2 In view of my discussions on point
No.1, I, proceed to pass the following::ORDER:
The application filed by the accused No.2
under section 239 of Cr.P.C., for discharge is
hereby allowed.
The accused No.2 is discharged of the
alleged offences under section 120-B IPC R/w
Section 420 IPC and under section 7 and 8 of PC
act."
11.
So also the Appellate Authority of the Customs
Department set aside the order passed by the original authority and
remitted the matter back to the original authority for reconsideration
afresh at the instance of the petitioner as hereunder:
- 28 NC: 2026:KHC:23440
WP No. 39444 of 2025
HC-KAR
OFFICE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF
CUSTOMS (APPEALS)
BMTC Building, Above BMTC Bus Stand, Domlur,
Bengaluru - 560071
email-id-customs-appeals0037@gov.in
Phone: 080-25301983
A.No.415,423,424&445/2025 Cus (B-Air) and 504/2025 Cus
(B-Air) (Dept)
Date: 30.12.2025
DIN-20251272MR000000E621
Order-in-Appeal No. 939-943/2025
Passed by Dr.Chetan R.C,
Commissioner of Customs (Appeals)
IRS
(C
&
IT)
PREAMBLE
1.
This copy is granted free of charge for the private use
of the person to whom it is issued.
2. Under Section 129 A (1) of the Customs Act, 1962 (as
amended), any person aggrieved by this order can appeal to
the South Regional Bench of the Tribunal having its Registry
at 1st Floor, WTC Building, FKCCI Complex, K. G. Road,
Bangalore 560 009. In case of Draw Back and Baggage
related matters the appeal lies with the Principal
Commissioner & Ex-Officio Additional Secretary to the
Government of India, 14, "B" Wing, HUDCO Vishal Building,
6th Floor, Bhikaji Cama Place, New Delhi-110 066.
3. Appeal must be filed in the prescribed C.A. 3 as
required vide Rule 6(1) of Chapter III of the Customs
(Appeals) Rules, 1982 within 3 months from the date of
communication of this order. In case of Draw Back and
Baggage related matters Application must be filed in the
prescribed C.A. 8 as required vide Rule 8A & 8B of Chapter
- 29 NC: 2026:KHC:23440
WP No. 39444 of 2025
HC-KAR
III of the Customs (Appeals) Rules, 1982 within 3 months
from the date of communication of this order.
4. Appeal must be filed in quadruplicate and must be
accompanied by:
a) Copy of the order and Order-in-Original, both in
quadruplicate (one of which at least should be certified
copy).
b) i) A Crossed Bank Draft for a sum of Rs.200/(Rupees Two Hundred only) where the amount of duty
demanded and penalty levied by the Customs Officer in the
case to which the appeal relates is One Lakh Rupees or
less,
ii) for a sum of Rs.1000/- (Rupees One Thousand
only) where the amount of duty demanded and penalty
levied by any Customs Officer in the case to which the
appeal relates is more than One Lakh Rupees, to be
obtained from a Nationalized Bank drawn in favour of the
Assistant Registrar of the Bench of the Tribunal concerned
and should be on the Bench of the Bank of the place where
Registry of the Bench is situated.
5. An appeal against this order shall lie before the Tribunal
on payment of 10% of the duty demanded where duty or
duty and penalty are in dispute, or penalty, where penalty
alone is in dispute".
6. The documents authorizing the representative to sign and
appear on behalf of the appellant, if the appeal by as
authorized representative, specified under Rule 9 of Chapter
IV of the Customs (Appeals) Rules, 1982 should accompany
the appeal.
Appellant/Exporter
A.No.
Shri K Ananthapadmanabha Rao,
415/2025 Superintendent of GST, 14/1,[32], Pooja
Power Compound, 17-A Cross, Malleswaram
West, Bengaluru-560055
423/2025 M/s UDL Logistics Pvt Ltd., Sy.No. 136/9,
Site No. 04% 05 Sneha Nagar, Kashi Nagar
Main Road, Opp. SBI Bank, Amruthahalli,
Sahakarnagar Post, Bangalore-560092
424/2025 Shri K V Dushyanth, Director, M/s UDL
- 30 NC: 2026:KHC:23440
WP No. 39444 of 2025
HC-KAR
Logistics Pvt Ltd., Sy.No. 136/9, Site No.
04& 05 Sneha Nagar, Kashi ashi Nagar Main
Road, Opp. Post, Bangalore-560092 SBI
Bank. Amruthahalli, Sahakarnagar Post,
bangalore-560092
445/2025 Shri C. Venkatesh, Superintendent of
Customs and GST (Retd.), Flat No. B-503,
Cauvery Serenity, No 10/1-1-46,
Raghavendra Extension, Yeshwantpur,
Tumkur, Bengaluru – 560022
Respondent
The Additional Commissioner of Customs,
Airport & Air Cargo Complex
Commissionerate, Bengaluru-560300
Authorized Representative for
1. Shri K Ananthapadmanabha Rao,
Appellant
Appellant for Sl. No. 1
2. Shri T Sundarnathan, Advocate, AR for Sl.
No. 2 & 3
3. Shri C Venkatesh, Appellant for Sl. No. 4
Order in Original No./ Assessment
Order
ΟΙΟ No. 03/2025-26 dated 15.04.2025
AND
Appellant
Respondents
A.No.
The Assistant Commissioner of Customs,
504/2025 Export Assessment, Airport & Air Cargo
Complex Commissionerate, Bengaluru560300
M/s UDL Logistics Pvt. Ltd. and its Managing
Director Shri KV Dushyanth; Bangalore No.
411/2, 2nd Floor, 3rd Cross, Thalacauvery
Layout, Bytrayanapura, Amruthahalli,
Sahakarnagar Post, Bangalore-560092
Shri Anantha Padmanabha Rao K, then
Superintendent of GST and Customs,
14/1,[32], Pooja Power Compound, 17-A
Cross, Malleswaram West, Bengaluru-560055
Shri Ravinder Pawar, Superintendent of GST
and Customs (the then Inspector), No. 104,
- 31 NC: 2026:KHC:23440
WP No. 39444 of 2025
HC-KAR
D-Block, Prasanahalli Village, House of
Hiranandini, Chancery Building, Devanahalli,
Bangalore-562110
(pawarpriya90958@gmail.com
priya.khatkar@gmail.com)
Authoriized
Representative for
Appellant/
Respondents
1. Shri T Sundarnathan, Advocate, AR for Respondents
Sl. No. 1
2. Shri K Ananthapadmanabha Rao, Respondent for Sl.
No. 2
3. Shri K.V. Srinivasa Prasad, AR for Respondent Sl. No.
Order-in-Original No./
Assessment Order
ΟΙΟ No. 03/2025-26 dated 15.04.2025
1. BRIEF FACTS OF THE CASE
1.1 The instant appeals are filed against OIO No. 03/2025-26
dated 15.04.2025 (hereinafter referred to as 'impugned
Order'/'OIO) passed by the Additional Commissioner of
Customs, Airport & Air Cargo Complex Commissionerate,
Bengaluru-560300 (hereinafter referred to as the lower
adjudicating authority/LAA1. Appeals have been filed by the
parties as well as by the Department.
1.2 Appeals have been filed by Shri K Anandapadmanabha
Rao, Superintendent of GST (hereinafter referred to as
'Appellant No.11, M/s UDL Logistics Pvt Ltd. (hereinafter
referred to as 'Appellant No. 2), Shri K.V.Dushyanth,
Director, M/s UDL Logistics Pvt Ltd (hereinafter referred to
as 'Appellant No. 3) and Shri C. Venkatesh, Superintendent
of Customs & GST (Retd) (hereinafter referred to as
'Appellant No. 4').
1.3 Appeal has also been filed by the Assistant
Commissioner of Customs, Export Assessment, Airport & Air
Cargo Complex Commissionerate, Bengaluru (hereinafter
referred to as 'Appellant Department) being duly authorized
by the Commissioner of Customs, Airport & Air Cargo
Complex Commissionerate, Bengaluru against the decision
in the impugned Order in respect of three noticees namely
- 32 NC: 2026:KHC:23440
WP No. 39444 of 2025
HC-KAR
M/s UDL Logistics Pvt. Ltd. and its Managing Director Shri K
V Dushyanth (hereinafter referred to as Respondent No. 1),
Shri K Ananthapadmanabha Rao, Superintendent of GST
(hereinafter referred to as 'Respondent No. 2) and Shri
Ravindra Pawar, Superintendent of GST and Customs the
then Inspector) (hereinafter referred to as 'Respondent No.
3)
1.4 The issue in brief is that based on specific intelligence,
the Directorate of Revenue Intelligence (DRI) intercepted two
export consignments at ACC, Bangalore, booked in the
name of M/s TEAC Engineers UT2, under Shipping Bill Nos.
3378541 and 3378546, both dated 26.07.2021. The
consignments were declared as "Industrial Ductile Pipes",
but, upon examination were found to conceal 106 logs of
Red Sanders Wood (Pterocarpus Santalinus) a prohibited
item for export under CITES and the Foreign Trade Policy
weighing 3.293 MT and valued at approximately Rs. 62.655
lakh. These goods were seized under Mahazar dated
29.07.2021.
1.5 Subsequent investigation revealed that the exporter had
earlier fraudulently exported five other consignments, also
concealing Red Sanders Wood. These five consignments
booked under Shipping Bill Nos. 2577229, 2569607 both
dated 21.06.2021, 2878013 dated 03.07.2021, 3158069
dated 15.07.2021 and 2190821 dated 03.06.2021 in the
name of M/s TEAC Engineers UT2 or M/s. Gurmehar Impex
covered a total of 6.821 MT of Red Sanders wood, valued at
about Rs.129.77 lakh, which had already been exported by
mis-declaring them an permissible goods.
1.6 Investigation further identified around 15 individuals and
entities including drivers, logistics operators, and
intermediaries, as part of a collusive network facilitating this
smuggling activity. Accordingly, SCN No. 155/2021-22 dated
24.01.2022 was issued to the appellant. The LAA after
having gone through the facts of the case, the reply received
during PH and relevant legal provisions ordered fori. Absolute confiscation of 106 logs of "Red Sanders'
wood totally weighing 3.293 MT valued at Rs.62.655 lakh
attempted to be exported vide the Shipping Bill Nos.
3378541 and 3378546 both dated 26.07.2021 which were
- 33 NC: 2026:KHC:23440
WP No. 39444 of 2025
HC-KAR
seized vide Mahazar dated 29.07.2021 in terms of the
provisions contained under Section 113(d), 113(e), Section
113(h) and Section 113(i) of the Customs Act, 1962
(hereinafter referred to as 'the Act)
ii. Red sanders wood (Pterocarpus Santalinus) totally
weighing 6.821 MT (not available physically) valued at Rs.
129.77 lakh which were fraudulently exported vide the
Shipping Bill Nos. 2577229 and 2569607 both dated
21.06.2021; No.2878013 dated 03.07.2021; No.3158069
dated 15.07.2021 and No.2190821 dated 03.06.2021
through ACC, Bangalore, was liable for confiscation under
Section 113(d), 113(e), Section 113(h) and Section 113(1) of
the Act along with imposition of fine in lieu of confiscation in
absence of appropriate proposal.
iii. Absolute Confiscation of the packing materials
seized vide Mahazar dated 29.07.2021 at ACC, Bangalore in
terms of provisions contained under Section 118 of the Act.
iv. Confiscation of the conveyance bearing number
TN-23-CC-8516 seized vide Mahazar dated 29.07.2021 at
ACC, Bangalore under Section 115 of the Customs Act,
1962 and in terms of Section 125 of the Act and ordered for
payment of Ra 5,00,000 in lieu of said confiscation;
Further, penalties were imposed on the individuals and
entities involved, the penalties imposed on the
appellants/respondent in the present appeals are as under.
i) Appellant No.1/Respondent No.2: Imposed a
penalty of Rs.8,81,461/- on Shri K.Anantha Padmanabha
Rao (Noticee No. 13) under Section 114AA of the Act.
ii) Appellant No. 2&3/Respondent No.1: Imposed a
penalty of Rs. 61,05/900/each on M/s UDL Logistics Private
Limited and Shri K. V. Dushyanth, Managing Director
(Noticee No.9), under Section 114AA of the Act.
iii) Appellant No. 4: Imposed a penalty of Rs.
2,86,214/- under Section 114(i) of the Act and Rs.
14,31,070/- under Section 114AA of the Act on Shri
C.Venkatesh (Noticee No. 12).
- 34 NC: 2026:KHC:23440
WP No. 39444 of 2025
HC-KAR
iv) Respondent No. 3: Imposed a penalty of Rs.
8,81,461/ on Shri Ravinder Pawar (Noticee No. 14) under
Section 114AA of the Act.
Aggrieved by the impugned OIO, the appellants have
filed the present appeals on the following grounds.
2. GROUNDS OF APPEAL: In view of the extensive
submissions advanced by the appellants, it is neither
practicable nor necessary to reproduce in extenso the
repetitive or inconsequential grounds urged. Accordingly,
only the material and relevant grounds have been succinctly
set out herein, without prejudice to the appellants'
contentions. For the sake of brevity, the entire grounds of
appeal are not being reproduced verbatim.
2.1 Appellant No. 1: Shri K Ananthapadmanabha
Rao:
2.1.1 The Respondent's logic, inferences, and findings
for imposing penalty under Section 114AA of the Customs
Act, 1962, are fundamentally flawed and unsupported by
credible evidence. The order relies heavily on surmises,
presumptions, and depositions from individuals such as
Satish Kumar, Suresh, and others who lack statutory license,
authority, or locus standi to act on behalf of exporters or
customs brokers. Such reliance violates the fundamental
principles of natural justice and established legal precedents.
The appellant expressly draws on the rulings in Union of
India v. Raj Grow Impex, 2021 (377 ELT 145) SC, and
Collector of Customs v. Sanjay Chandi Ram, 1995 (77
ELT 162) SC, which hold that penalties for misdeclaration or
fraud under Customs Act require concrete and corroborative
evidence, not mere suspicion or unauthorized witness
statements. The material facts and oral testimony relied
upon lack credibility and contradict documentary evidence,
making the penalty order arbitrary, unjust, and unsustainable
under law.
2.1.2 Despite filing comprehensive and bona fide
documentary evidence-which includes shipping bills, air way
bills, export invoices, packing lists, air freight receipts,
custodial expense receipts, scanned images, CCTV footage,
cargo-entry registers, and more the Respondent failed to
- 35 NC: 2026:KHC:23440
WP No. 39444 of 2025
HC-KAR
take these into due consideration Instead, the adjudication
rested solely on incomplete investigation and depositions
that were not tested through proper cross-examination or
supported by documentary proof. This constitutes a gross
miscarriage of justice and a fundamental breach of principles
laid down in Commissioner of Customs v. Phoenix
International Ltd., 2007 (217 ELT 513) SC, which requires
that every charge of misdeclaration or fraud must stand on
cogent, unimpeachable evidence rather than baseless
surmises. The absence of a speaking order addressing each
defense point and material evidence deprives the appellant
of a fair adjudication.
2.1.3 The Respondent ignored authenticated custodial
records provided by the operator AISATS Bengaluru,
including expert testimonies affirming that the consignment
under shipping bill no. 2190821 dated 03.06.2021 consisted
of lawful industrial pump spares, not prohibited red sanders
as alleged. These records included scanned images of
consignments, security scanning registers, physical
examination reports, and other official documentation
demonstrating adherence to customs protocols. Reliance
placed instead on the testimonies of unauthorized witnesseswho themselves retracted or contradicted their statements
betrays a flawed investigative process. In support, the
appellant cites MS Exim Services u. Commissioner of
Customs, Ludhiana, 2021 SCC OnLine CESTAT 14,
reinforcing that penalties cannot be imposed where bona fide
exercised due diligence and verifiable documentation exist,
negating allegations of false declaration.
2.1.4 The Respondent overlooked the multi-layered
and structured customs examination and assessment
process mandated by the RMS/ICES system, including
oversight by authorized officials like export assessment
Superintendents and shed inspectors. The goods were
scrutinized thoroughly via physical examination and
electronic verification before the issuance of the Let Export
Order (LEO). No evidence contradicts the documented
procedures, and no basis is shown for allegations of
misdeclaration. This is in line with the principle established in
UOI v. Ganesh Das Bhoj Raj, 2000 (122 ELT 522) (SC),
which affirms the requirement of corroborated evidence
directly linking the accused to fraud or misdeclaration. The
- 36 NC: 2026:KHC:23440
WP No. 39444 of 2025
HC-KAR
Respondent's failure to appreciate or challenge this
procedural adherence points to an arbitrary and legally
unsupportable conclusion.
2.1.5 The depositions relied upon by the Respondent
emanate from persons lacking statutory authorization or
contractual agency to represent either exporters or customs
brokers. This includes individuals associated with unrelated
entities or merely private individuals with no lawful role in
customs documentation or cargo handling. Public Notice No.
14/2011 Customs ACC and the ruling in K Sugumar v.
Commissioner of Customs, Madras-HC (2021), clearly
establish that unauthorized presence and actions in the
customs examination area are impermissible, negating the
evidential value of their statements. The Respondent's
acceptance and use of such inadmissible evidence violate
binding regulations, further undermining the fairness and
legality of the penalty proceedings against the appellant.
2.1.6 The material irregularities and defects permeate
the
investigation,
particularly
regarding
mahazar
proceedings, which were conducted without the presence of
required statutory witnesses such as the exporter, customs
house agent, vehicle driver, or the customs shed officer.
Moreover, the mahazar fails to record identifying marks and
seals on the alleged seized goods, resulting in a vital gap in
the evidentiary chain. The absence of concrete
documentation associating seized goods with the appellant's
actions contravenes principles upheld in Sea Queen
Shipping Services Pvt. Ltd. v. Commissioner of
Customs, Chennai, 2019 (366 ELT 1011) (CESTAT). This
infirmity alone undermines the legitimacy of penalty
imposition and demonstrates the lack of procedural fairness
owed to the appellant.*
2.1.7 The appellant contends that the Respondent
erroneously imposed penalty without establishing mens reathe necessary criminal intent or willful knowledge under
Section 114AA of the Customs Act. The appellant acted
strictly within the framework of RMS protocols, and there is
no material evidence pointing to knowingly issuing false or
incorrect documentation while granting the LEO for shipping
bill no. 2190821. The importance of mens rea as a condition
precedent to penalty imposition is emphasized in Hera
Shipping Solutions Pvt. Ltd. v. Commissioner of Customs,
- 37 NC: 2026:KHC:23440
WP No. 39444 of 2025
HC-KAR
Chennai, 2022-VIL-603-CESTAT-MAD, which holds that the
intentional element must be proven beyond reasonable
doubt. The Respondent's failure to establish this essential
element renders the penalty order unsustainable.
2.1.8 The mistrust or resemblance of modus operandi
with other shipments cannot replace the need for legally
admissible, compelling evidence. As established in UOI v.
Raj Grow Impex, 2014 (306 ELT 433) SC. and Collector of
Cus Sanjay Chandiram, 1995 (77 ELT 162) SC, suspicion
or inferred misconduct from unrelated cases cannot
substantiate penal consequences. The Respondent's
assumption that the shipment was red sanders based solely
on the modus operandi found in an unrelated consignment
intercepted later lacks any evidentiary foundation, rendering
the penalty imposition speculative and unlawful.
2.1.9 The penalties must be directly attributable to
proven illegal acts concerning specific goods and
transactions involving the appellant. Misattribution or pooling
of unrelated consignments to implicate the appellant violates
the principle of individual responsibility grounded in UOI v.
Ganesh Das Bhoj Raj (2000), Commissioner of Customs
v.
Phonics
International
Ltd.
(CESTAT),
and
Commissioner of Customs v. Sanjay Chandiram (2000).
The Respondent's failure to segregate facts and hold the
appellant accountable exclusively for actual conduct and
consignments breaches fair trial norms and the customs
legal framework.
2.1.10 Section 155 of the Customs Act provides
protection to officers acting in good faith and within their
official duties, shielding them from punitive action absent
malafide conduct. The appellant discharged functionary
duties as assigned, following due RMS procedures diligently
and with no mal-intent. Case law including Sea Queen
Shipping Services Pvt. Ltd. (supra) and Pushpak Lakhani v.
Principal Commissioner of Customs, 2022-VIL-528CESTAT-AHM underscores that penalties under Section
114AA cannot be levied except where intent to evade or
defraud is proven. The appellant also stresses the
fundamental right to cross-examine witnesses relied upon by
the department, a critical principle of natural justice violated
here, undermining the entire penalty process.
- 38 NC: 2026:KHC:23440
WP No. 39444 of 2025
HC-KAR
2.2 Appellant No.2: M/s UDL Logistics Pvt Ltd and
2.2.1 The Show Cause Notice is not maintainable
both in law and also on facts, as there was no specific
allegations against the Noticee No. 9/Appellant and whatever
made, were solely based on guesses and surmises. The
SCN alleging lack of due diligence and failure to verify the
documents, is vague, sweepy and arbitrary as no specific
allegations were made as against the Noticee
No.9/Appellant, more so when penal measures were
proposed under multiple provisions of law The impugned
Order was passed levying penalty against each of them
and/thús, both a nullity in law.
2.2.2 The SCN was also issued in respect of the
improper exports to as many as 15 persons including 3
Customs officers. As against the Noticee No.9/Appellant, the
said SCN merely alleged that the appellant failed to fulfill
Regulations 10(e) and 10(n) of CBLR, 2018. The SCN has
not alleged any malafide motive or act as against the
appellant which are punishable or liable in any manner under
the provisions the Customs Act.
2.2.3 A bare perusal of the Show Cause Notice and
the impugned Order would reveal that vague and false
allegations are made against the Noticee No.9 by alluding to
two different persons KV Dushyanth and UDL Logistics Pvt
Ltd- by mentioning and referring them as one person Noticee
No.9. As such, no such Noticee No.9 exists or could ever
exist. The issue of such a Show Cause Notice is arbitrary
and unlawful. Even assuming the issuing of SCN to Noticee
No.9 is valid for any reason whatsoever and without
admitting to the same, the levy of penalty on each of them
separately is arbitrary, without application of mind and
unlawful.
2.2.4 The SCN dated 24-01-2022 was issued in
respect of the exports for which the shipping bills were filed
by the Noticee No.9/Appellant on 21-6-2021 and 3-7-2021,
which were also duly cleared by the Customs Authorities,
without any adverse observation or objection in respect of
any role, act or conduct of the Noticee No.9/Appellant. Thus,
- 39 NC: 2026:KHC:23440
WP No. 39444 of 2025
HC-KAR
the SCN dt 24-01-2022 issued to the Noticee No.9/Appellant
was belated and barred by limitation.
2.2.5 The SCN was said to have been issued on the
basis of the Investigation conducted by the DRI and it was
not stated in the SCN as to any conclusion thereof. From a
bare perusal of the SCN or the impugned order, it was also
clear that the departmental authorities have examined nor
conducted any enquiry on any document or person. The
Noticee No.9/Appellant was also denied opportunity of cross
examination of the relevant persons. Thus, the entire
proceedings as against the Noticee No.9/Appellant, including
the issue of SCN and the impugned order were all in
violation of principles of natural justice and also contrary to
law and for this reason alone, both the SCN and the
impugned Order deserve to be set aside as being illegal and
arbitrary.
2.2.6 The said SCN was also issued after detailed
investigation including the collusion and unlawful conduct of
the Customs Officials. It is further submitted that there was
no allegation on the appellant as to confiscation of export
goods or contravention of any specific provision under the
Customs Act, in respect of which the appellant filed Shipping
Bills. The above clearly show that the Noticee No.9/Appellant
was bonafide in respect of their role and activities in the
exports done through them.
2.2.7 A bare reading of the Regulation 10(e) CBLR,
2018 provision show that the authorization from the exporter
was not made mandatory. In any case, the KYC documents
were duly authenticated and attested by the exporter which
were bonafidely relied on by the Noticee No.9/Appellant. The
KYC documents were the requirement and the same were
duly provided along with the cargo. It is also stated in the
impugned Order in para 79.7... ... "Out of the 03 CBs only,
M/s UDL Logistics Private Limited (Noticee No.8) is seen to
have collected KYC Documents and verified the same to
some extent from information available in public domain...."
Being so, the invocation of Reg 10(e) is not legal and not
proper.
2.2.8 Also, a bare reading of the Regulation 10(n)
CBLR, 2018 provision shows that the IEC and GSTIN and
- 40 NC: 2026:KHC:23440
WP No. 39444 of 2025
HC-KAR
the functioning of the exporter at the declared address were
to be verified as to the correctness. All KYC documents
including the IEC and GSTIN were duly authenticated and
attested by thee exporter which were bonafidely relied on by
the Noticee No.9/Appellant the correctness of which were
not denied nor disputed in any manner. It was also stated
that the KYC documents were also verified in a manner
known to law. Being so, the invocation of Reg 10(n) is not
legal and not proper.
2.2.9 The impugned Order has not made any finding
as against the Noticee No.9/Appellant nor dealt with Sec
114AA with respect to any act or any document or statement
pertaining to Noticee No.9/appellant. Hence, the section is
not applicable.
2.2.10 A bare perusal of the SCN dt 24-01-2022 show
that merely alleging lack of diligence on the Noticee
No.8/Appellant in respect of CBLR, 2018, the penalty is
sought to be leviable under Sections 114 and 114AA. A
perusal of the impugned Order reveal that while holding
correctly that Section 114(i) penalty is not legable however,
without discussing and without giving any finding against the
Noticee No.9/Appellant in any specific manner in terms of
Section 114AA, the impugned Order levied penalty under
Section 114AA and the same is not legal and not proper.
2.2.11 The Noticee No.9/Appellant was bonafide
throughout and the Noticee No.9/Appellant promptly filed its
objections and also participated in the proceedings. There
was no allegation nor any findings in respect of any undue
financial gain to the Noticee No.9/Appellant or knowledge or
intention and thus both the SCN and the impugned Order are
not sustainable both in law and on facts as against the
Noticee No.9/Appellant.
2.2.12 A perusal of the impugned Order and the
proceedings thereof would reveal that the alleged improper
exports have been made with active collusion, cooperation
and collaboration between the exporters and the
departmental officers. No act or conduct has been alleged
against or can be said to be done knowingly or with the
knowledge of any such illegal act by the Noticee
No.9/Appellant. The Noticee No.9/Appellant have only filed
- 41 NC: 2026:KHC:23440
WP No. 39444 of 2025
HC-KAR
the Shipping Bills and performed the consequential activities
thereof, all in accordance with law and their role and conduct
is bonafide and lawful both in intent and content. In the
above facts and circumstances, the impugned proceedings
and the Order thereof, as against the Noticee No.9/Appellant
are both unlawful, unjust and harsh in all, any and every
manner both in law and on facts.
2.2.13 In view of the above submissions and also due
to the fact that the obligations of the Noticee No.8/Appellant
as a Customs Broker is having been duly fulfilled, the
impugned order is liable to be set aside in every and all
manner.
2.3 Appellant No.3: Shri K V Dushyanth, Director,
M/s UDL Logistics Pvt Ltd
2.3.1 The Appellant No. 3 also submitted identical
grounds of Appellant No. 2: M/s UDL Logistics Pvt Ltd, and
therefore not repeated again. On the basis of the
submissions, the appellant requested to set aside the
impugned order.
2.4 Appellant No. 4: Shri C. Venkatesh,
Superintendent of Customs and GST (Retd.)
2.4.1 The findings against him regarding Shipping Bill
No. 3378541 dated 26.07.2021 are without basis, arbitrary,
and imposed despite bona fide facts and absence of material
evidence. The penalties under Section 114(i) and Section
114AA of the Customs Act, 1962, have been imposed
without proper examination of the appellant's defenses or the
evidences on record. The Risk Management System (RMS)
is a system-driven process configured to prevent arbitrary
actions. The appellant acted on the authority of the Duty
Roster and at the statutory workplace, following established
RMS procedures. Any issuance of Let Export Order (LEO)
was post-inspection by a pre-functionary officer, whose
report uploaded in the system was devoid of adverse
remarks. The appellant refers to CBIC Standing Order No.
22/2015 and CBIC Circular No. 23/2013 that mandate strict
adherence to RMS instructions and disallow personal
discretion beyond these instructions. The appellant relies on
Supreme Court rulings, notably M.V. Bijlani vs Union of
- 42 NC: 2026:KHC:23440
WP No. 39444 of 2025
HC-KAR
India, 2006 (5) SCC 88, and State of Punjab vs V.K.
Khanna, 2001 (2) SCC 330, affirming that adherence to
prescribed procedures precludes misconduct allegations.
The impugned order fails to identify specific deviations by the
appellant in issuing the LEO, rendering its inferences
arbitrary and unsustainable.
2.4.2 The credibility of the Mahazar dated 29.07.2021
and related Supratnama submissions, relied upon by the
Respondent, is deeply questionable. The witnesses to the
Mahazar, as revealed during cross-examination, admitted
they were not present during the proceedings and did not
witness the alleged seized goods. The investigation's
reliance on these unreliable testimonies lacking authorization
is improper. Notably, the Mahazar was carried out without
critical stakeholders present-exporter, authorized customs
broker, vehicle driver, and the appellant who issued the LEO.
The Mahazar itself fails to reference relevant custodian
records correlating the goods with the implicated Shipping
Bill No. 3378541. The examination by the Range Forest
Officer was conducted without correlating goods with the
shipping documents, further weakening evidentiary value.
Additionally, seizure under Section 110 of the Customs Act
was never effected in the legal sense as goods were handed
directly to the custodian's representative. Various annexures,
including invoices and E-way bills, have not been legally
seized and are inadmissible. The Respondent has not
addressed these critical defenses or passed speaking orders
on the Mahazar's credibility, rendering reliance on these
proceedings unlawful and unsupportable.
2.4.3 The testimonies of witnesses relied upon in the
Show Cause Notice (SGN) lack credibility and legal basis.
For instance, Sri Sridharan, partner of Ms. Sai 18 Lakshmi
Logistics (customs broker for the shipping bill), did not attest
presence at the Mahazar proceedings, negating the reliability
of statements implicating the appellant. The SCN evidence
ignores the absence of statements from authorized
representatives of the exporter, Ms. Teac Engineers UT2,
who have explicitly disavowed involvement or misuse of their
credentials. Cross-examination of Mr. Rajat Kumar Mittal of
Ms. Teac Engineers affirmed the misuse of IEC by unknown
entities, further distancing the appellant from wrongdoing.
The Respondent's impugned order selectively disregards
- 43 NC: 2026:KHC:23440
WP No. 39444 of 2025
HC-KAR
these defenses. Depositions of Sri Suresh and Sri Satish
Kumar, key witnesses, were recorded under pressure,
contradicted by Public Notice No. 14/2011, which restricts
unauthorized individuals inside customs examination areas.
Employees of unrelated customs brokers had no locus standi
over the shipping bills concerned. Despite retractions during
inquiry and parallel conduct proceedings, the Respondent
ignored cross-examination revelations and relied on the
initial, uncorroborated allegations against the appellant. This
biased approach vitiates the proceedings.
2.4.4 The Respondent erred in concluding the
appellant's culpability based on conflicted and incomplete
evidentiary records regarding financial transactions and
documentary trails. Para 81.8 of the impugned order
paradoxically claims financial transactions are not core to
adjudication yet insinuates that bank statements imply guilt.
In reality, financial transactions cited predate the issuance of
the impugned Shipping Bill No. 3378541 and bear no nexus.
The apparent selective application of facts violates principles
of neutrality and fairness. The Respondent also failed to
consider favorable evidence indicating that transactions were
unrelated personal loans, as admitted by key witnesses. The
lack of relevant invoicing, shipment registration, or transport
documentation further weakens allegations. The appellant
also challenges procedural missteps in investigation such as
lack of contemporaneous export/import activity, failure to
disclose material relied upon, and ignoring exculpatory
testimonies. These factors cumulatively negate the
foundation for penalty imposition.
2.4.5 The appellant contends that denial of natural
justice severely prejudiced the defense, specifically
regarding the refusal to allow cross-examination of
investigating officers and witnesses whose testimonies
underpin the SCN. The cross-examination right is vital,
especially given the investigation's procedural gaps,
contradictory material, and incomplete records. The
Respondent acknowledged multiple defense submissions
but unjustifiably ignored revelations from parallel inquiries
where witnesses turned hostile, and prior depositions were
retracted. The exclusion of these cross-examination
outcomes contravenes judgments such as Andaman
Timber Industries vs CCE Kolkata fl. 2015 (324 ELT 641)
- 44 NC: 2026:KHC:23440
WP No. 39444 of 2025
HC-KAR
SC, underscoring the necessity of testing witness credibility.
The appellant also highlights concealment of statements
from equally positioned officers who were similarly situated
but discharged, reflecting inconsistent application of justice.
Repeated failure to produce legible, certified Relied Upon
Documents impaired preparation of defense. The oversight
points to a manifest bias and miscarriage of justice in
sustaining penalties without proper evidential scrutiny.
2.4.6 Significant irregularities taint the investigation
process and evidentiary material. The Mahazar was
conducted in absence of key parties, with no linkage
established between seized goods and the appellant's
shipping bill. The Range Forest Officer's inability to correlate
goods to export documents and the absence of seizure
under Section 110 of the Customs Act by the seizing officer
further invalidate the evidence chain. Unauthorized handling
of shipping documents and goods is a material defect,
contravening Public Notice No. 14/2011 and the Handling of
Cargo in Customs Areas Regulations, 2009. The
Respondent's confiscation order lacks clarity about
possession of goods and wrongly clubs distinct
consignments, introducing confusion in valuation and penal
calculations. Email correspondences highlighting transport
delays introduce factual contradictions challenging the SCN
narrative. These procedural and substantive lapses
cumulatively undermine the Respondent's findings and are
legally unsustainable.
2.4.7 The issuance of the Let Export Order in respect
of Shipping Bill No. 3378541 was fully compliant with RMS
and procedural mandates. The appellant followed duty roster
assignments and acted based on standard processing flow
after inspection with no adverse remarks. Precedents like
M.V. Bijlani (supra) and State of Punjab vs V.K. Khanna
(supra) establish that compliance with prescribed procedures
precludes allegations of misconduct. The impugned order
omits to specify any deviation or illegal act by the appellant,
suggesting opportunistic targeting. Investigation findings
clearing the appellant with respect to six of seven shipping
bills-bearing identical procedural and documentary patternsindicate selective enforcement. The appellant submits that
the absence of any derogatory material on the focal shipping
- 45 NC: 2026:KHC:23440
WP No. 39444 of 2025
HC-KAR
bill, despite consistent application of RMS safeguards,
exonerates him.
2.4.8 The absence of mens rea is critical, as penalties
under Section 114(i) and Section 114AA demand deliberate
knowledge or intention. The appellant's role was limited to
processing within an automated RMS environment, lacking
discretion to override system decisions. The appellant's
issuance of LEO was subsequent to inspection findings by
an independent officer, Sri Suraj Kumar, who did not find
falsehood in documents or goods presented. The appellant
observes that no specific investigation targeted the shipping
bill at issue beyond swept-in association with parallel
consignments without corroboration. The impugned order's
conclusion of abetment is inconsistent with exoneration on
similarly situated shipping bills, revealing arbitrariness. The
appellant's defense includes testimony from various
stakeholders denying knowledge or complicity, which the
Respondent failed to address adequately. This absence of
mens rea warrants dismissal of penalty charges.
2.4.9 The valuation and assessment for penalty
imposition are flawed, arising from mixing consignments
under two distinct shipping bills. The joint grading dated
21.09.2021 obscures individual linkage to the appellant's
shipping bill, as confirmed by the Range Forest Officer's
admitted inability to correlate goods with relevant
documents. No speaking order explains reliance on such
amalgamated valuations. The appellant points to
inconsistent application of customs valuation rules, lacking
meaningful opportunity for inspection of the goods or crossexamination of valuation witnesses. This failure to attribute
value on a shipping bill basis undermines the statutory
framework for penalty and confiscation under the Customs
Act. The appellant reiterates that documents and procedures
followed in clearance matched those in other cleared bills,
further buttressing a presumption of bona fide action.
2.4.10 The protection under Section 155 of the
Customs Act shields officers acting in good faith from
punitive action absent malafide or improper motive. The
appellant discharged official duties diligently and similarly
situated officers received immunity without penalty.
Selectively directing penalty only at the appellant, without
- 46 NC: 2026:KHC:23440
WP No. 39444 of 2025
HC-KAR
distinction in facts or standards, embodies bias. The
Appellant draws on decisions including CCE v. M.I. Khan,
2000 (120 ELT 542) Tribunal, and analogous authorities
recognizing the statutory protection for officers while
performing authorized functions. The impugned order
sustaining penalty against the appellant while exonerating
others reflects an administrative agenda rather than
equitable adjudication. Furthermore, parallel disciplinary
proceedings overlap with adjudicatory findings, rendering the
continuance of penalty/proceedings oppressive and legally
questionable. The appellant thus prays for discharge and
setting aside of the penalty order in light of these protections.
2.5 Department Appeal No. 504/2025:
2.5.1 The LAA has in his Order-in-Original discussed
and found that the subject goods ie. Red Sanders Wood
(Pterocarpus Santalinus) was prohibited for export. The LAA
also held that two consignments intercepted (Shipping Bill
Nos. 3378541 and 3378546 both dated 26.07.2021) and five
consignments already exported (Shipping Bill Nos. 2190821
dated 03.06.2021, 2577229 & 2569607 both dated
21.06.2021, 2878013 dated 03.07.2021 and 3158069 dated
15.07.2021) were Red Sanders. The LAA held that all these
seven consignments were liable for confiscation under
Section 113(d), 113(e), 113(h) and 113(i) of the Customs
Act, 1962.
2.5.2 Issue of penalty under Section 114 on Noticee
No.9 ie. M/s UDL Logistics Pvt. Ltd. and its Managing
Director Shri KV Dushyanth:The LAA has discussed the role of Noticee No. 9 ie.
M/s UDL Logistics Pvt. Ltd. and its Managing Director Shri K
V Dushyanth, who have contravened provisions of
Regulation 10 of the Customs Brokers Licensing
Regulations, 2018. The LAA has held that Noticee No. 9i. failed to act prudently and was manipulated by Shri
Satish Kumar T and Shri Munikrishna C for performance of
their part in unauthorised processing of export documents;
- 47 NC: 2026:KHC:23440
WP No. 39444 of 2025
HC-KAR
ii. also failed to (1) obtain due authorization from the
exporter and (2) ascertain correctness of information
declared under 03 shipping bills handled by them;
iii. aided to the conspiracy and resulted in illegal
exports made vide Shipping Bill Nos. 2577229 and 2569607
both dated 21.06.2021 and Shipping Bill No. 2878013 dated
03.07.2021;
iv. was found liable to penal actions in terms of
Section 114AA of the Customs Act, 1962 and imposed a
penalty on both Shri K. V. Dushyanth, Managing Director
and M/s UDL Logistics Private Limited, both. The
Adjudicating Authority imposed penalty of Rs. 61,05,900/each in terms of Section 114AA of the Customs Act, 1962.
However, the LAA did not impose penalty under Section 114
by cite that the provisions of Section 114 is not applicable on
exported goods. It is submitted that the LAA has erred in the
interpretation of the Section 114. Section 114 is applicable
on exported goods as well.
2.5.3 Issue of penalty under Section 114 on Noticee
No. 13 Ananthapadmanabha Rao K, Superintendent and
Noticee no. 14 Shri Ravinder Pawar, the then Inspector:The LAA held:i.
examination of Shipping Bill No. 2190821 dated
03-06-2021 was carried out by Shri Ravinder Pawar, the
then Inspector;
ii. let export order of Shipping Bill No. 2190821 dated
03-06-2021 was granted by Shri Ananthapadmanabha Rao
K;
iii.
Shri Ravinder Pawar had regular unofficial
interactions with Shri Najeeb Zainudeen (Noticee No.4) and
Shri Satish Kumar T (Noticee No.7), the preparators of the
illegal export / attempted improper export and undue favours
/ financial transactions between them cast serious concern
regarding their active involvement in said offence;
- 48 NC: 2026:KHC:23440
WP No. 39444 of 2025
HC-KAR
iv. Shri Ananthapadmanabha Rao K was found having
financial dealings with Shri Ravinder Pawar,
v. Shri Ravinder Pawar and Shri Ananthapadmanabha
Rao K were involved in illegal export of red sanders wood
made vide Shipping Bill No. 2190821 dated 03-06-2021;
vi. imposed penalty under Section 114AA of Rs.
8,81,461/- on the both of them.
However, the LAA did not impose penalty under Section 114
by citing that the provisions of Section 114 is not applicable
on exported goods. The LAA has erred in the interpretation
of the Section 114, Section 114 is applicable on exported
goods as well.
2.5.4 While the LAA has correctly recorded the role
played and involvement of
i. Noticee No. 9 i.e. M/S UDL Logistics Pvt. Ltd. and
its Managing Director Shri KV Dushyanth;
ii. Noticee No. 13, 1.c. Shri Anantha Padmanabha
Rao K, the then Superintendent; and
iii. Noticee No. 14 ie. Shri Ravinder Pawar, the then
Inspector
In the chain of events facilitating the export of
prohibited goods, the LAA has erred in the interpretation of
Section 114. The provisions of Section 114 states that any
person who, in relation to any goods, does or omits to do any
act which would render such goods liable to confiscation
under Section 113 shall be liable to a penalty. The LAA has
found all the seven consignments were liable for confiscation
under Section 113. Further, as stated above, roles of all the
three above mentioned noticees have been found by the
LAA. Further, penalty have been imposed on these three
noticees for their acts in the illegal export under Section
114AA. The LAA should have imposed penalty under
Section 114(i) on these three, but, has failed to do so in the
Order in Original. Hence, for their acts which made goods
liable for confiscation under Section 113, these three
- 49 NC: 2026:KHC:23440
WP No. 39444 of 2025
HC-KAR
noticees are also penalizable under Section 114(i) as
proposed in the Show Cause Notice.
2.6 Cross Objections by Respondent No. 1: M/s
UDL Logistics and it's Managing Director Shri. K.V.
Dushyanth
2.6.1 The above Respondents have also filed appeals
against the Order-in-Original No.3/2025-26 dated 15-042025 and the same were taken on record as Appeal Nos.423
& 424/2025Cus (B-Air) as communicated vide Lr.
No.475/2025 dt 25-7-2025 in A. No.423/2025 Cus (B- Air)
and Lr. No.474/2025 dt 25-7-2025 in A. No.424/2025 Cus (BAir).
2.6.2 The averments and grounds as pleaded in the
above appeals filed by the above respondents are reiterated
and also warranted to be considered as Reply to the Dept
Appeals herein. Without Prejudice, the above Respondents
may be permitted to plead additional grounds and averments
as may be warranted.
2.6.3 In view of the above, the respondent requested
to dismiss the above appeals filed by the Department as not
maintainable or alternatively may be heard and decided
together along with the above said appeals filed by these
respondents and thus render justice.
2.7 Cross Objections by Respondent No. 2: Shri.
K. Ananthapadmanabha Rao
2.7.1 The respondent contends that the entire appeal
is not maintainable on facts and law, suffering from incurable
defects and procedural deficiencies in the original
investigation, adjudication, and review. The impugned Show
Cause Notice (BGR) dated 24-01-2022 alleges fraudulent
export related to seven shipping blis, including SB No.
2190821 dated 03.06.2021 for which the respondent issued
the Let Export Order (LEO). However, the goods under this
SB were thoroughly scrutinized, registered, and cleared
following prescribed customs procedures, with no credible
nexus between the respondent and the alleged violations.
Distinct exporters Ms. Gurmehar Impex (SB 2190821) and
Ms. TEAC Engineers (other SBs) were wrongly clubbed,
though they have separate IECS, GST registrations, and
- 50 NC: 2026:KHC:23440
WP No. 39444 of 2025
HC-KAR
premises. Critical documents such as shipping bills, Air Way
Bills, invoices, e-way bills, custodial and transporter records
are missing from investigation files, raising serious doubt
about the correctness of allegations. The respondent relies
on principles of natural justice as enshrined in the Customs
Act and case law emphasizing that penalties cannot arise
from assumptions or surmise but require cogent evidence.
Non-supply of vital records obstructed defense, causing
miscarriage of justice and rendering the entire appeal filed by
the department as an attempt to cover investigation
deficiencies.
2.7.2 The investigation and adjudication authorities
failed to prove seizure of goods under Section 110 of the
Customs Act, which is a sine qua non for confiscation or
penalty. The allegedly seized goods were instead handed
over to the custodian without formal seizure, as evidenced
by the Mahazar (RUD-1) conducted in the absence of
legitimate witnesses representing the exporter, customs
broker or appellant. The Mahazar thus lacks documentary
strength and credibility. Further. the adjudicating authority
ignored that SB No. 3378546, which figures prominently in
the allegations, was never registered or cleared for export,
absolving the appellant entirely of connection in this regard.
The appellant highlights this fundamental investigational
lacuna and challenges the review order for disregarding
these critical points. The respondent also objects to the
arbitrary blending of consignments under separate SBs to
derive average valuations for penalty computation,
inconsistent with customs valuation principles laid down by
courts. The SCN is time-barred, served well beyond the
permissible six-month period after investigation, undermining
its validity. These procedural anomalies entitle dismissal of
the appeal and set aside of all adverse orders.
2.7.3 The that depositions relied upon in the SCN,
sourced from unauthorized personnel including key
witnesses like Satish, Najeeb, Suresh, and Munikrishna,
were recorded under coercion and later disowned in crossexamination. The appellant further refers to Public Notice
No. 14/2011, which restricts entry and agency inside
customs examination sheds, ruling out the legitimacy of
these testimonies. The adjudicating authority refused to
allow the appelant the fundamental right of cross-
- 51 NC: 2026:KHC:23440
WP No. 39444 of 2025
HC-KAR
examination on these witnesses, causing a serious breach of
natural justice. The appellant emphasizes that there is no
documentary or testimonial evidence linking the appellant or
his actions to any fraudulent export or misdeclaration.
Specifically, there was no investigation of the alleged
exporter Ms. Gurmehar Impex or its authorized Customs
Broker M/s. Concorde Zoom. In six of seven SBs, he was
exonerated from charges, signalling selective and unjustified
targeting in the remaining case. The overall investigation and
adjudication manifest bias and lack transparency, resulting in
arbitrary penalties without sustainable proof.
2.7.4 The issuance of the Let Export Order (LEO) was
strictly compliant with the procedural framework under the
RMS during the assigned duty hours. The appellant acted on
authenticated reports of pre-functionary officers, Sri Lakshmi
Narayan (assessment) and Sri Suraj Kumar (examination),
both of whom recorded no adversarial remarks or suspicion
in documents or consignments relating to SB 2190821 dated
03.06.2021. The resspondent's professed role was limited to
issuing LEO based on system-generated scrutiny and
reports. The investigation's failure to engage these officers or
verify the completeness of their assessments deprives the
penalty proceedings of credibility. Multiple orders and notices
from the CBIC mandate that where procedures with RMS are
followed scrupulously, penalties cannot be justified. The
appellant prays that, in absence of proving any willful or
intentional neglect or manipulation, the penalties under
Sections 114(i) and 114AA must be quashed in keeping with
legal precedents.
2.7.5 The investigation failed to examine critical
stakeholders in the export chain, including the custodian
AISATS, the air carrier, the customs brokers, and the alleged
exporter, Ms. Gurmehar Impex. All consignments were
subjected to scanning and digital entry logging at the Air
Cargo Complex, with images and scanning records
maintained but withheld from the appellant and the
investigation report submitted to the adjudicating authority.
This selective use and concealment of evidence violates
principles of fairness and transparency essential in
adjudicatory processes. The appellant has consistently
requested access to these records to establish the
genuineness and correctness of exports, but such requests
- 52 NC: 2026:KHC:23440
WP No. 39444 of 2025
HC-KAR
were ignored. Further, the appellant stresses that the
investigation dehberat amalgamated consignments of
different importers/exporters and brokers in the hope of
attributing guilt without proper basis. The investigation's
approach violates statutory mandates and case laws,
including those emphasizing the requirement of specific and
attributable evidence for penalty imposition.
2.7.6 There exists no credible documentary or oral
evidence tying the appellant to any fraudulent activity or
misdeclaration. No bank statements, transport invoices,
invoices from exporters, or equivalent material has been
tendered as evidence. The allegations rely primarily on a
presumed modus operandi drawn from unrelated
consignments and coercive depositions from unauthorized
third parties. Several documented procedural protections,
including Circular No. 30/2020 (Paperless Customs) have
been ignored to attribute wrongdoing to the appellant. The
respondent points to cross-examination disclosures where
many witnesses recanted earlier statements or admitted to
making coercive claims. The adjudicating authority's silence
on these facts and failure to pass speaking orders on crucial
defenses undermines the legality of the entire penalty order
and review.
2.7.7. The principles of natural justice were violated
due to denial of the right to cross-examine investigating
officers and witnesses whose statements form the SCN
basis. The respondent's right to mount an effective defense
was severely curtailed by investigators' failure to produce
relevant documents and witnesses for testing in crossexamination. Key statements were recorded under pressure
and without confrontation or corroboration, making them
inadmissible under law. Without the possibility of crossexamination, the adjudicatory process was tilted, prejudicing
the appellant unfairly. The appellant cites precedents
emphasizing the necessity of cross-examination to ensure
reliability and fairness in quasi-judicial proceedings like
customs adjudications. The failure to consider these
established principles calls for setting aside the impugned
penalty.
2.7.8. The scope of investigation was restricted and
incomplete, omitting inquiry into critical players such as the
- 53 NC: 2026:KHC:23440
WP No. 39444 of 2025
HC-KAR
exporter, customs broker, custodian, transporter, and air
carrier for SB 2190821. No records have been produced to
establish what credentials were used to file the shipping bill,
who physically filed it, or responsibility for any alleged
irregularities. Similarly, records indicate the RMS and EDI
systems were properly employed with no discrepancy in
digital logs or registered access parameters. The DHS duty
roster corroborates that the appellant acted during assigned
export facilitation duty only in line with policy, and personal
or illegitimate intervention occurred. The incomplete
investigation results in deficiency of proof required for
penalty imposition and invalidates the proceedings.
2.7.9. The valuation and penalty computation based
on alleged confiscated goods are legally unsustainable due
to absence of seizure under Section 110 of the Customs Act,
1962, and flawed investigation blending consignments from
different sources. No speaking order accompanies the
assumptions of auction-related or market value offered in the
impugned order. Legal precedents such as UOI v. Ganesh
Das Bhojraj (2000) 9 SCC 133 and Commissioner of
Customs v. Phoenix International Ltd have mandated that
valuation for penalty must be linked to the specific goods
involved and the responsible parties. The arbitrary reliance
on unconnected consignments and generic valuations
violates these guiding principles. The appellant asserts the
goods under SB 2190821 cleared properly with no adverse
findings, warranting dismissal of penalty demands.
2.7.10 In the absence of credible and verifiable
evidence implicating the respondent in misdeclaration or
fraudulent export, the penalty order based on a presumption
of guilt violates settled legal standards. The respondent's
evidence, including photos of scanned goods, duty rosters,
RMS logs, and absence of adverse remarks at examination,
remains unchallenged. The appellant prays that the appeal
filed by the department to sustain penalty be rejected for
want of maintainability, lack of merits, and failure of
investigation and adjudication to meet the requirements of
law and principles of natural justice. The appellant further
requests an opportunity for oral hearing and for considering
additional submissions on the record, emphasizing the
considerable mental and professional prejudice suffered over
four years and nearing retirement from service.
- 54 NC: 2026:KHC:23440
WP No. 39444 of 2025
HC-KAR
2.8 Respondent No. 3: Shri Ravindra Pawar has
not filed any cross objections.
3. Personal Hearing (PH):
3.1 Shri K.Ananthapadmanabha Rao, Appellant No. 1
who is also Respondent No. 2 in Department Appeal,
appeared for the personal hearing held on 12.11.2025. He
reiterated the written submissions with grounds of appeal
made in the Appeal Memorandum and Cross Objections and
the same are taken on record. He requested to submit a
copy of Enquiry Officers Report by the end of the day and
the same also was taken on record.
3.2 Shri T. Sundarnathan, the authorised
representative of the appellant No. 2 & 3 who are also
Respondent No. 1 in Department Appeal, appeared for the
personal hearing held on 23.12.2025. The AR reiterated the
written submissions with grounds of appeal made in the
Appeal Memorandum and the same are taken on record. He
has stated that additional submissions will be made by
29.12.2025 and the same was taken on record.
3.3 Shri C Venkatesh, Appellant No. 4 appeared for
the personal hearing held on 12.11.2025. He reiterated the
written submissions with grounds of appeal made in the
Appeal Memorandum and also submitted additional
submissions during PH, the same are taken on record.
3.4.1 Shri Srinivasa Prasad, the authorised
representative (AR) of Shri Ravindra Pawar, Respondent No.
3 in Department Appeal, appeared for personal hearing on
23.12.2025. Shri Ravindra Pawar through the AR made the
submissions that the O1O No. 03/2025-26 dated 15.04.2025
passed by the LAA is not served on him despite sending email to them to serve the copy of the same, that he has not
been served with the copy of O10 even in the first appellate
stage and only the grounds of appeal was supplied which
severely hampered his ability to properly submit counter
grounds. The respondent further submitted that he sought
the cross examination of all the persons whose statements
are relied upon in the SCN and also Mahazar witness, but
- 55 NC: 2026:KHC:23440
WP No. 39444 of 2025
HC-KAR
the same was not accorded and OIO was passed violating
the principles of natural justice.
3.4.2 The respondent further submitted that he has
attended only one consignment out of many consignments
mentioned in the SCN, under which spares of pumps was
cleared and not red sanders, the scanning image clearly
indicates that the goods cleared were of pumps and not red
sanders, that the register maintained for scanning also
indicates that the same SB was scanned at the time shown
in the image, that Shri Manoj Kumar, Senior Duty Manager,
Air India Sats admitted during his examination and cross
examination before inquiry officer that the goods cleared
were pumps based on scanning image. Further, Shri Paveen
Kumar Kanigval, SIO, DRI in his deposition before the
inquiry officer admitted that the goods exported under SB
was in fact industrial pump; that there is no evidence of any
kind of payment to him by any of the person accused in the
case. Shri Satish Kumar T admitted before the inquiry officer
that he dropped at the railwa station for a consideration, that
even if he has dropped the spondent free of cost, it does not
depict that he was involved in the smuggling, that he always
admitted that he knew Satish Kumar as he was coming to
ACC for clearance of goods; that Shri Satish Kumar admitted
that the respondent has no relation to smuggling of goods;
that there is no communication between the respondent and
any of the accused in any form. The respondent further
submitted that the DRI failed to conduct investigation at the
receiving port to the extent that what material was received
and what material was declared, and also failed to establish
the procurement of red sanders and money trail for the
consignment which the respondent has cleared and it is
proved beyond doubt that it is industrial pumps. So the
decision of LAA to implicate the respondent and impose
penalty is not sustainable.
3.4.3 Further, the respondent submitted that it is
proved that the materials exported was industrial pumps as it
is evident from the scanning image and the same was
admitted by SIO, DRI, the Order of LAA is not sustainable
and requested to reject the appeal. The respondent made an
alternative prayer to keep the appeal pending as he is
intended to file appeal as and when the copy of O10 is
served to him through email to koerum291@gmail.com.
- 56 NC: 2026:KHC:23440
WP No. 39444 of 2025
HC-KAR
4. Discussions and findings:
4.1
I have gone through the appeal memorandum,
facts of the case, written submissions of the appellants and
respondents,
submissions
made
by
the
appellants/respondents/ARs during PH in respect of the
appeals filed by the appellants and the Department.
4.2.1 The issue in brief is that, based on specific
intelligence, the Directorate of Revenue Intelligence (DRI)
intercepted two export consignments at Air Cargo Complex
(ACC), Bangalore, booked in the name of M/s TEAC
Engineers UT2 under Shipping Bill Nos. 3378541 and
3378546, both dated 26.07.2021. The consignments were
declared as "Industrial Ductile Pipes, however, detailed
examination revealed concealment of 106 logs of Red
Sanders Wood (Ptero carpus Santalinus) a species
prohibited for export under CITES and the Foreign Trade
Policy. The seized quantity weighed 3.293 MT, with an
estimated value of Rs. 62.655 lakh, and was taken into
custody under Mahazar dated 29.07.2021. Subsequent
investigation established that the exporter had earlier
fraudulently exported five consignments, also concealing
Red Sanders Wodd. These consignments, booked under
Shipping Bill Nos. 2190521 (dated 03.06.2021) in the name
of M/s Gurmehar Impex, No. 2577229 and 2569607 (both
dated 21.06.2021), 2878013 (dated 03.07.2021), 3158069
(dated 15:07:2021), in the name of M/s TEAC Engineers
UT2, covered a total of 6.821 MT of Red Sanders Wood,
valued at approximately Rs. 129.77 lakh, which had already
been illicitly exported by mis-declaring them as permissible
goods.
4.2.2 The Department's investigation narrated that
Shri Najeeb Zainudheen, with the facilitation of Shri Munees
Anadakandy, procured quantities of Red Sanders wood. He
entrusted the task of mis-declaring the goods, handling
Customs formalities, and arranging other incidental
facilitation to Shri Satish Kumar T., who is a partner in M/s
Maneesh Logistic Services and concurrently employed as
Manager in M/s Marsh Shipping Agency. Shri Satish Kumar
T., in concert with his co-accused associates, managed to
file seven shipping bills by misusing the credentials of two
- 57 NC: 2026:KHC:23440
WP No. 39444 of 2025
HC-KAR
companies that were in their possession, without obtaining
any letter of authorization from the said firms. These
shipping bills were further filed through three different
Customs House Agents (CHAs). The Lower Adjudicating
Authority (LAA), in the impugned order, has confirmed the
involvement of multiple stakeholders in the fraudulent
activity, including transporters, Customs Brokers, logistics
operators, and even departmental officers. The details of the
seven shipping bills involved are set out below.
Sl.
No.
SB No.
SB Date
Exporter
Name
SB filed by
CB Name
2190821
03.06.2021
2577229
21.06.2021
Concorde
Zoom
UDL
Logistics
2569607
21.06.2021
Gurmehar
Impex
TEAC
Engineers
UT2
TEAC Engineers
UT2
2878013
03.07.2021
TEAC Engineers UDL Logistics
UT2
3158069
15.07.2021
TEAC Engineers Sri.
Lakshmi
UT2
Logistics
3378541
26.07.2021
TEAC Engineers Sri.
Lakshmi
UT2
Logistics
3378546
26.07.2021
TEAC Engineers Sri.
Lakshmi
UT2
Logistics
UDL Logistics
4.2.3. Of the seven SBs under reference, the
consignments covered under Sl. Nos. 1 to 5 were
successfully exported. The consignments pertaining to Sl.
Nos. 6 and 7 were, however, intercepted by the Directorate
of Revenue Intelligence (DRI), which triggered subsequent
investigation, adjudication proceedings, and culminated in
the issuance of the impugned order.
4.3 A total of five appeals have been filed against the
impugned order. Of these, four appeals have been preferred
by the parties concerned, while one appeal involving three
- 58 NC: 2026:KHC:23440
WP No. 39444 of 2025
HC-KAR
respondents, has been filed by the Department. For
purposes, of brevity, specificity, and clarity, the role of each
party/appellant/respondent, together with the respective
grounds of appeal and any cross-objections, is addressed
separately in the subsequent sections.
4.4 Appellant No. 1: Shri K Ananthapadmanabha
Rao, who is also Respondent No. 2 in Department
Appeal (hereinafter in the sub-paras of para 4.4 referred to
as 'appellant' / 'respondent')
4.4.1 The appellant was the shed Superintendent who
gave Let Export Order (LEO) to one of the SBs involved, ie,
SB No. 2190821 dated 03.06.2021. The Department
observed that, Shri Ravinder Pawar, the Inspector who
examined the said SB asked Shri Satish Kumar T to transfer
money to an account maintained with SBI in the name of one
Ms. Jayalakshmi Rao. K. On examination of bank statement
of Shri Satish Kumar T, there are transactions from his
account of amounts Rs. 25,001/-and Rs. 99,999/- to the
account of Ms. Jayalakshmi Rao K, who is mother of the
appellant. On this basis, the SCN alleged that the appellant
abetted in the illicit export of red sanders, and the LAA
imposed penalty of Rs. 8,81,461/- under Section 114AA of
the Act.
4.4.2 The appellant, as elaborated in paragraph 2.1
above, advanced detailed submissions. The principal
contentions are that the LAA, despite the availability of bona
fide facts, circumstances, and supporting documents, failed
to consider the defence of the appellant in its entirety. The
order is silent on several specific defences raised, including
the defects and deficiencies in the investigation, and does
not qualify as a speaking order with reference to the material
and evidence available on record. Instead, the conclusion
has been drawn purely on surmises and presumptions. It is
further contended that the LAA restricted its findings by
relying solely on the deposition of Shri Satish Kumar, who
alleged that all consignments covered by the Show Cause
Notice comprised red sanders, without any corroborative
basis, record, or evidence. The appellant emphasized that
multiple layers of checks and scrutiny exist in the export
process, from registration of goods up to their loading onto
the aircraft, which were disregarded in the adjudication.
- 59 NC: 2026:KHC:23440
WP No. 39444 of 2025
HC-KAR
Additionally, while imposing penalty under Section 114AA of
the Act, the LAA failed to establish mens rea on the part of
the appellant. No findings were drawn to demonstrate that
the appellant had knowingly or intentionally engagezt is the
act of making, signing, or using false or incorrect
documentation in relation to the Let Export Order issued for
Shipping Bill No. 2190821 dated 03:06.2021. The appellant
also highlighted various procedural lapses, including nonsupply of relevant records, and placed reliance on several
judicial precedents in support of its defence.
4.4.3 The Department has preferred an appeal
against this appellant, arraying him along with two others as
respondents. The grounds urged by the Department in
respect of these three respondents are set out in paragraph
2.5 above. In essence, the LAA has held that all seven
consignments were liable to confiscation under Section 113
of the Act. The LAA has also recorded findings regarding the
roles played by each of the three noticees and imposed
penalties upon them under Section 114AA for their
involvement in the attempted illegal export. However, the
LAA ought to have additionally imposed penalty under
Section 114(i) of the Act upon these noticees, but failed to do
so in the O10. Since their acts rendered the goods liable to
confiscation under Section 113, the three noticees are
equally liable to penalty under Section 114, as was
specifically proposed in the Show Cause Notice. The
respondent filed cross objections against the Department
appeal as detailed in para 2.7 above.
4.4.4 I have carefully examined the role of the
appellant/respondent in the present case. The appellant
issued the LEO in respect of SB No. 2190821 dated
03.06.2021. The LAA has recorded a finding that the
appellant facilitated the illegal export of red sanders through
this shipping bill, allegedly for a monetary consideration of
Rs.1,25,000/- received through banking transactions in the
account of his mother. It is noted that SB No. 2190821 dated
03.06.2021 was selected for open examination. Based on
the examination report submitted by the Inspector, the
appellant, in his capacity as Shed Officer, issued the LEO. In
such circumstances, where there is no specific intelligence
or adverse examination report under RMS instructions, the
Shed Officer is duty bound to issue the LEO. I do not find
- 60 NC: 2026:KHC:23440
WP No. 39444 of 2025
HC-KAR
any allegation of procedural lapse by the LAA against the
appellant in this regard. The sole allegation is that the money
credited to the appellant's mother's account was towards
facilitation of the illegal export, a finding drawn exclusively
from the statement of Shri Satish Kumar. On perusal of the
statements of the alleged kingpins, Shri Satish Kumar and
Shri Najeeb Zainudeen, as reproduced in the impugned
order, it is evident that the LAA himself recorded that the
appellant had no interaction with any of the alleged
perpetrators of the illegal export of red sanders under the
said shipping bill. Further, Shri Ravinder Pawar, Inspecter
wh examined the consignment, categorically denied having
shared the bank account details of the appellant's mother
with Shri Satish Kumar. No other evidence exists on record
to establish that the appellant provided such account details
to any of the accused. The goods covered under the said
shipping bill were exported and were not available for
investigation. The only basis for the LAA's conclusion that
the exported items were red sanders, and not the goods
declared in the shipping bill, is the statement of Shri Satish
Kumar, From the Show Cause Notice and the impugned
order, it is clear that the investigation failed to establish, even
through overseas enquiry, whether the goods exported were
red sanders or otherwise. In the absence of such proof, the
pro rata valuation of the goods also cannot be sustained.
Accordingly. I find that the imposition of penalty under
Section 114AA of the Customs Act, 1962 is not supported by
evidence. The LAA has himself recorded that the financial
transactions are not the core subject of adjudication and
were examined only to indicate a nexus between the
appellant and the alleged perpetrators. However, as
discussed above, such nexus has not been established. In
view of these findings, the facts weigh more in favour of the
appellant, entitling him to protection under Section 155 of the
Act. Consequently, the Department's appeal seeking
imposition of penalty under Section 114 of the Act also does
not prima facie arise. Nevertheless, considering the various
factual aspects involved, I am of the considered view that the
matter requires re-examination by the LAA, who shall pass a
reasoned and speaking order in light of the above
observations.
4.5 Appellant No. 2 & 3: M/s UDL Logistics Pvt Ltd
& Shri K V Dushyanth, Director, M/s UDL Logistics Pvt
- 61 NC: 2026:KHC:23440
WP No. 39444 of 2025
HC-KAR
Ltd who are also Respondent No. 1 in Department
Appeal (hereinafter in the sub-paras of para 4.5 referred to
as 'appellants/ respondents)
4.5.1 The appellants, being the Customs Broker and
its Managing Director, filed three shipping bills in the present
case, namely SB No. 2577229 dated 21.06.2021, SB No.
2569607 dated 21.06.2021, and SB No. 2878013 dated
03.07.2021, all in the name of M/s TEAC Engineers UT2. In
his statement, Appellant No. 3 admitted that all documents
including the invoice-cum-packing list, Air Waybill copy, IEC
copy, GSTIN copy, AD code, and LUT copy were provided
solely by Shri Satish Kumar T. He further accepted that no
letter of authorization had been obtained from M/s TEAC
Engineers UT2 for filing the aforesaid shipping bills and
conceded violation of the provisions of the Customs Brokers
Licensing Regulations BL 2018. On this basis, the SCN
alleged that the appellants failed to exeroise due diligence in
verifying the KYC particulars of the exporter and the
correctness of the goods to be exported, as mandated under
Regulations 10(c) and 10(n) of the CBLR,2018 read with
Section 146 of the Act. The LAA, after considering the
matter, imposed a penalty of Rs. 61,05,900/- each on
Appellant No. 1 and Appellant No. 2 under Section 114AA of
the Act.
4.5.2 The appellants, as elaborated in paragraphs 2.2
and 2.3 above, advanced detailed submissions. Their
principal contentions are that the SCN is not maintainable
either in law or on facts, as no specific allegations have been
made against them and the assertions therein rest solely on
conjecture and surmise. It is urged that the SCN, which
alleges lack of due diligence and failure to verify documents,
is vague, sweeping, and arbitrary, without setting out any
concrete charge against the appellants. The appellants
further contend that the SCN does not allege any malafide
motive or act attributable to them that would render them
punishable or liable under the provisions of the Customs Act,
1962. They point out that the shipping bilis dated 21.06.2021
and 03.07.2021 were duly filed and cleared by the Customs
authorities without any adverse observation or objection
regarding their role, conduct, or actions. Consequently, the
proceedings initiated are belated and barred by limitation. It
is also submitted that there is no contravention warranting
- 62 NC: 2026:KHC:23440
WP No. 39444 of 2025
HC-KAR
invocation of the provisions of the CBLR, 2018. Without
discussing or recording any specific finding against the
appellants, the impugned order has imposed penalty under
Section 114AA of the Act, which, according to them, is
neither legal nor proper. The appellants have additionally
raised certain technical grounds and emphasized that the
shipping bills were filed and all consequential activities
performed strictly in accordance with law. Their role and
conduct, they assert, were bona fide and lawful both in intent
and in content, and no act or omission has been alleged or
can be said to have been committed knowingly or with
knowledge of any illegality.
4.5.3 The Department has also filed an appeal,
arraying these appellants as respondents, as detailed in
paragraph 4.4.3 above. In the said appeal, the Department
has sought imposition of penalty under Section 114(i) of the
Act upon the appellants, who are respondent No. 1 therein.
The respondents, however, reiterated the submissions made
in their own appeal and prayed for dismissal of the
Department's appeal.
4.5.4 I find that the appellants, acting as Customs
Broker, filed three Shipping Bills in the present case. All
consignments covered under these Shipping Bills were
cleared for export, and the goods were not available for
subsequent investigation. It is noted that the Shipping Bills
were filed on the basis of export documents and KYC papers
handed over by Shri Satish Kumar, one of the accused. The
failure to verify the genuineness of Shri Satish Kumar and
the filing of Shipping Bills without obtaining proper
authorization from the exporter constitute acts of negligence
and clear violations of the provisions of the CBLR, 2018. I
further note that the Hon'ble CESTAT, vide Final Order No.
20036/2024 dated 09.01.2024 in Appeal No. 20295/2023
against OIO No. 5/2023 dated 21.03.2023 of the
Commissioner of Customs, BCC, observed that the
negligence attributable to the appellant was limited to not
verifying the authenticity of the documents and whether the
orders had been duly passed by the exporter. The Tribunal
held that, since the KYC documents were verified online and
the Shipping Bills were filed in good faith, the appellants
could not be penalised for the attempted illegal export of
prohibited goods. Accordingly, the Hon'ble CESTAT set
- 63 NC: 2026:KHC:23440
WP No. 39444 of 2025
HC-KAR
aside the revocation of the Customs Broker licence and
forfeiture of the security deposit. However, in view of the
failure to verify the genuineness of Shri Satish Kumar, who
claimed to be the authorised representative of the exporter,
the Tribunal upheld the imposition of penalty under the
CBLR, 2018 to the extent of Rs. 50,000/-, Although the SCN
alleged that the appellants abetted the illicit export of red
sanders by registering the goods and facilitating issuance of
LEO for the three Shipping Bills, I find that the LAA could not
establish any nexus between the appellants and the
perpetrators of the illegal export. Since the goods exported
were not available for investigation, and the valuation of such
unavailable goods rests only on assumptions, I hold that the
penalty imposed on the appellants under Section 114AA of
the Act is unduly harsh and requires reconsideration. For this
conclusion, reliance is placed on the Hon'ble CESTAT Final
Order No. 20036/2024 dated 09.01.2024. In view of the
foregoing, I am of the considered opinion that the matter
warrants re-examination. The grounds raised in the
Department's appeal seeking imposition of penalty under
Section 114(i) of the Customs Act, 1962 upon the appellants
may also be reviewed during the remand proceedings, in
light of the above findings and the binding observations of
the Hon'ble CESTAT.
4.6 Appellant No. 4: Shri C. Venkatesh (hereinafter
in the sub-paras of para 4.6 referred to as 'appellant')
4.6.1 The appellant, serving as Shed Superintendent,
issued the LEO in respect of Shipping Bill No. 378541 dated
26.07.2021, which was one of the two consignments
subsequently intercepted by the DRI and found to contain
red sanders. The SCN further alleged that multiple bank
transactions were made from Shri Satish Kumar T to the
appellant's bank account. Based on the statement of Shri
Satish Kumar T and digital evidence in the form of WhatsApp
calls and conversations, it was alleged that the appellant
facilitated the perpetrators in the illegal export of red sanders
in respect of six consignments and received financial
consideration for such facilitation. On this basis, the SCN
charged the appellant with abetting the illicit export of red
sanders. The LAA, after considering the allegations, imposed
penalties of Rs. 2,86,214/ under Section 114(1) and Rs.
14,31,070/- under Section 114AA of the Act.
- 64 NC: 2026:KHC:23440
WP No. 39444 of 2025
HC-KAR
4.6.2 The appellant, as elaborated in paragraph 2.4
above, advanced detailed grounds of appeal. The principal
contentions are that Shipping Bill No. 3378541 dated
26.07.2021 was an RMS-assessed Bill without any
instructions for open examination, with industrial ductile
pipes declared as the consignment; that the LEO was issued
on the basis of the inspection report uploaded by the
Inspector, which contained no adverse remarks; and that the
LAA has remained silent on the nature of any deviations or
incorrect actions attributable to the appellant. It is further
contended that the appellant was denied the opportunity to
cross-examine the witness and to inspect the alleged goods.
The pro rata average value determined in the Show Cause
Notice (SCN) for purposes of confiscation and penalty is
based on mixed consignments covering two Shipping Bills,
each having distinct statutory positions, which renders the
valuation unsustainable. The appellant also pointed to
several procedural lapses, including non-supply of legible
copies of RUDs, and placed reliance on various judicial
precedents. Moreover, it is submitted that there are no
specific findings by the LAA establishing the allegations of
abetment or of knowingly accepting the documents relating
to Shipping Bill No. 3378541 dated 26.07.2021. On these
grounds, the appellant has pleaded for setting aside the
penalties imposed under the impugned order.
4.6.3 I find that the allegations in the SCN are not
confined merely to the LEO issued in respect of Shipping Bill
No. 3378541 dated 26.07.2021, but extend to the alleged
facilitation of the perpetrators in the illegal export of six
consignments of red sanders. The investigation revealed
multiple transactions from the bank account of Shri Satish
Kumar T to the account of the appellant, for instance, on
15.06.2021 an amount of Rs. 30,000/-, on 15.07.2021
amounts of Rs. 1,00,000/-Rs. 75,000/- and 16.07.2021 Rs.
25,000/-. From the appellant's statement recorded on
13.08.2021, it is noted that he initially claimed only a passing
acquaintance with Shri Satish Kumar T. However, upon
being confronted with the account statement and transaction
details, the appellant admitted to having received these
amounts due to severe financial difficulties in his personal
life, asserting that they were taken as hand loans to be
repaid shortly. It is significant that these transactions
occurred within two months prior to the interception of the
- 65 NC: 2026:KHC:23440
WP No. 39444 of 2025
HC-KAR
consignments and during the intervening period when SBs
were filed in the name of the same exporter, M/s TEAC
Engineers UT2. The inconsistencies in the appellant's
statements and the explanation of "hand loan" are not
convincing. Further, the appellant has not provided any valid
explanation in his grounds of appeal for these financial
transactions with one of the principal accused. The records
therefore do not support the appellant's claim of innocence
regarding the activities of the perpetrators. In addition, the
recovery of numerous WhatsApp conversations and call logs
evidences the appellant's constant contact with Shri Satish
Kumar T. This prima facie deprives the appellant of immunity
under Section 155 of the Customs Act, 1962. At the same
time, the appellant has raised issues relating to denial of
natural justice, specifically the non-supply of clear copies of
RUDs and the methodology adopted for valuation of
consignments for the purpose of imposing penalties. I find
that these aspects require re-examination. Copies of all
relied-upon documents must be furnished to the appellant in
order to uphold the principles of natural justice, and the
criteria adopted for determining the quantum of penalties
must be revisited. However, I concur with the LAA that the
Customs Act does not confer an absolute right to crossexamination, and that there is no violation of natural justice
where no specific reasons have been advanced for seeking
such cross-examination. In view of the above findings, I
direct that the appellant be provided with the copies of RUDs
sought and that the matter be re-examined afresh by the
LAA in accordance with the principles of natural justice. The
appellant shall be at liberty to make additional submissions
during the remand proceedings.
4.7 Respondent No. 3 in Department appeal: Shri
Ravinder Pawar
4.7.1 The respondent, serving as Shed Inspector, had
examined the goods covered under Shipping Bill No.
2190821 dated 03.06.2021. The Department noted that Shri
Satish Kumar T, in his statement, admitted to having earlier
exported red sanders under the said shipping bill, which was
selected for examination He further stated that he had made
monetary payments to secure clearance of the consignment
and had continued to pay the respondent for facilitating
subsequent illicit exports of red sanders. In his statement,
- 66 NC: 2026:KHC:23440
WP No. 39444 of 2025
HC-KAR
the respondent denied the allegations but acknowledged that
he used to meet Shri Satish Kumar T and had requested him
to arrange taxi services, for which no payment was made. In
a subsequent statement, however, Shri Satish Kumar
asserted that the respondent was concealing the true facts.
He clarified that his assistant, Shri Sureah T, was deputed to
collect documents relating to shipping bills filed for red
sanders exports. Shri Suresh T, in his statement, confirmed
that as directed by Shri Satish Kumar T, he attended the
examination of Shipping Bill No. 2190821 dated 03.06.2021.
He deposed that the respondent partially opened the lid of
the consignment, pointed out that some wood was visible,
and cautioned that if the consignment was fully opened, it
would be captured on camera. The respondent then closed
the consignment and informed him about the money to be
collected. Based on these statements, along with evidence
recorded from other persons involved, the Show Cause
Notice alleged that the appellant had abetted the illicit export
of red sanders. Consequently, the Adjudicating Authority
imposed a penalty of Rs.8,81,461/-under Section 114AA of
the Act.
4.7.2 The Department has preferred an appeal
against this appellant, arraying him along with two others as
respondents. The grounds urged by the Department in
respect of these three respondents are set out in paragraph
2.5 above. In essence, the LAA has held that all seven
consignments were liable to confiscation under Section 113
of the Act. The LAA has also recorded findings regarding the
roles played by each of the three noticees and imposed
penalties upon them under Section 114AA for their
involvement in the attempted illegal export. However, the
LAA ought to have additionally imposed penalty under
Section 114(i) of the Act upon these noticees, but failed to do
so in the O1O, Since their acts rendered the goods liable to
confiscation under Section 113, the three noticees are
equally liable to penalty under Section 114, as was
specifically proposed in the Show Cause Notice.
4.7.3 1 note that the respondent had opened and
examined the goods covered under Shipping Bill No.
2190821 dated 03.06.2021, one of the disputed
consignments. On the basis of the statements of Shri Satish
Kumar Tand others, athers, the SCN alleged that the goods
- 67 NC: 2026:KHC:23440
WP No. 39444 of 2025
HC-KAR
under the said shipping bill comprised red sanders, and that
the respondent abetted the illicit export by furnishing a false
examination report for monetary consideration. From the
statement dated 01.08.2021 of Shri Satish Kumar T, it
emerges that the respondent was aware of the presence of
red sanders in the consignment and failed to conduct a
proper examination, instead demanding Rs. 8 lakhs to permit
the export. It was further stated that the examination report
was issued without actual verification of the goods, and that
the respondent advised modification of the pallet/package
width so as to evade detection by the scanner. Shri Satish
Kumar T also deposed that Rs 5 lakhs was paid to the
respondent, who was thereafter dropped at Guntakal
Railway Station in Andhra Pradesh, and that an additional
Rs. 6 lakhs was transferred through hawala channels at the
respondent's insistence. The respondent's own statement
confirms his continuous acquaintance with Shri Satish
Kumar T during June-July 2021. I further note that the
Authorized Representative of the respondent appeared for
personal hearing before the LAA. Being a departmental
officer conversant with adjudication procedures, it is not
convincing that the respondent was unaware of service of
the OIO. When the OIO was duly served on several other
persons involved in the case, it is difficult to accept that the
respondent made no effort to ascertain the outcome of
adjudication, or that the Department deliberately withheld the
impugned order. In the submissions on the appeal also, the
respondent has not disclosed his present communication
address. Nevertheless, these aspects require re-examination
by the Adjudicating Authority, with confirmation from the
records, to ensure that the principles of natural justice have
not been violated. It is further noted that the respondent has
not filed any appeal against the impugned order imposing
penalty under Section 114AA of the Customs Act. At this
stage, I reiterate the finding in para 4.6.3 that crossexamination is not a matter of right. In the circumstances, I
consider it appropriate to remand the matter to the LAA to reexamine the Department's contention in the present appeal
and to determine whether penalty is liable to be imposed on
the respondent under Section 114(i) of the Act.
4.8 In light of the foregoing discussion, 1 consider it
appropriate to remand the matter to the LAA for fresh
examination, covering the four appeals filed by the parties as
- 68 NC: 2026:KHC:23440
WP No. 39444 of 2025
HC-KAR
well as the appeal preferred by the Department against the
same impugned order.
5. Considering the aforesaid
observations, I pass the following order:
discussions
and
ORDER
The instant appeals, namely: Appeal No 415/2025
Cus (B-Air) dated 03.06.2025 filed by Shri K
Ananthapadmanabha Rao, Bengaluru; Appeal No. 423/2025
Cus (B-Air) dated 11.06.2025 filed by M/s UDL Logistics Pvt.
Ltd., Bengaluru; Appeal No. 424/2025 Cus (B-Air) dated
11.06.2025 filed by Shri K.V. Dushyanth, Bengaluru; Appeal
No. 445/2025 Cus (B-Air) dated 12.06.2025 filed by Shri C.
Venkatesh, Bengaluru; and Appeal No. 504/2025 Cus (B-Air)
(Dept) dated 15.07.2025 filed by the Assistant Commissioner
of Customs, Airport & Air Cargo Commissionerate,
Bengaluru, all arising out of Order-in-Original No. 03/2025-26
dated 15.04.2025 passed by the Additional Commissioner of
Customs, Airport & Air Cargo Commissionerate, Bengaluru,
are allowed by way of remand in terms of Section 128A(3) of
the Customs Act, 1962. The matter is remitted to the
Adjudicating Authority for fresh consideration in accordance
with law, ensuring adherence to the principles of natural
justice.
Dr. Chetan R.C)
Commissioner of Customs (Appeals)"
12.
The aforesaid facts and circumstances including the
orders passed by the Sessions/Special Court and the Appellate
Authority of Customs will clearly indicate that the respondent was
not justified in declining the request of the petitioner for grant of
personal hearing despite bringing it to his notice that the petitioner
- 69 NC: 2026:KHC:23440
WP No. 39444 of 2025
HC-KAR
had filed a discharge application and the same was pending
consideration before the Special/Sessions Court.
13.
In addition there to, the petitioner having sought for an
opportunity of personal hearing as late as on 07.11.2025, the
respondent did not even advert to the said request nor refer to the
same nor provide an opportunity of personal hearing to the
petitioner as can be seen from the impugned order which is clearly
violative of principles of natural justice warranting interference by
this Court in the present petition which deserves to be allowed and
the matter remitted back to the respondent for reconsideration
afresh and in accordance with law.
14.
Insofar as the contention urged by the learned counsel
for the respondent that in view of availability of equally efficacious
and alternative remedy, the petitioner is not entitled to any relief in
the present petition is concerned, in view of the findings recorded
by me herein before that the impugned order is violative of
principles of natural justice, mere availability of an appeal remedy
would not come in the way of this Court exercising its jurisdiction
under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India and as such,
- 70 NC: 2026:KHC:23440
WP No. 39444 of 2025
HC-KAR
the said contention urged by the learned counsel for the
respondent cannot be accepted.
15.
In the result, I pass the following:ORDER
(i)
Petition is hereby allowed.
(ii)
The copy of order in original No.01/2025 dated
10.11.2025 passed by respondent No.1 vide Annexure
A is hereby set aside.
(iii)
The matter is remitted back to respondent No.1 for
reconsideration afresh in accordance with law.
(iv)
Petitioner shall appear before respondent No.1 on
18.05.2026
without
awaiting
further
notice
from
respondent No.1.
(v)
Liberty is reserved in favour of the petitioner to submit
additional
pleadings
documents
etc.,
before
respondent No.1, who shall consider the same and
provide sufficient and reasonable opportunity to the
- 71 NC: 2026:KHC:23440
WP No. 39444 of 2025
HC-KAR
petitioner and pass appropriate orders in accordance
with law.
Sd/(S.R.KRISHNA KUMAR)
JUDGE
BH
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 3
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review